Guest guest Posted January 22, 2010 Report Posted January 22, 2010 Hi, Joan. I appreciate that you do not follow the stereotype of the iodine sites in recommending massive doses of iodine to all and sundry. More comments below. Please be aware that my world view is from an appreciation of allopathic medicine [despite it's limitations] and for the scientific method. .. .. > Posted by: " jmlulich74 " jmlulich74@... > <mailto:jmlulich74@...?Subject=%20Re%3A%20Iodine%20Safety> > jmlulich74 <jmlulich74> > > > Wed Jan 20, 2010 8:48 am (PST) > > > > Just because someone was harmed by iodine is not a reason to disregard > its uses. ; ; That is correct. First of all there are well established uses borne our by credible studies. Where it becomes more of a problem is when uses for which there are no well established studies or even credible theories are propagated. .. .. > I choose not to load up like Brownstein suggests but we clearly need > iodine for our bodies to function properly. .. .. Yes, we need about half the iodine that we get in the US [150 mcg/day] as demonstrated by peer reviewed research. Brownstein, incidentally, is not one of the " researchers " who has ever contributed anything credible in that field. .. .. > We need Vitamin A but very large amounts are toxic, that doesn't mean > we don't take any. It is all a balancing act and one must know their > bodies. At one time, it was safe to eat seafood but those days are > over. Kelp has arsenic and aluminum in it, so we are left with Lugol's > or Iodoral. .. .. You can die from drinking too much water. And no one suggests not taking any iodine, given that every medical person on earth and a vast number of others know of the research that lists it as an essential substance. .. .. > > I hope people do their own research, pro and con. When I hear of a > report where someone had detrimental affects, I put that in my > personal chart that I must proceed with caution. But I still proceed. > This thyroid business is touchy and is complicated. .. .. It can be. But apparently for about 95% of patients they take one simple pill each day and live a completely full and normal life. That does not negate the fact that for some small percentage of patients some apparent effects of hypothyroidism [or other ailment with somewhat similar symptoms] suffer continuing problems that range from mild to a living hell. .. .. > > I am glad I tried the Iodoral. It helps me but I doubt that I will be > loading up anytime soon but I certainly would it I had goiter or > nodules or cancer. You bet I would. .. .. When we are desperate we will often try desperate remedies; that's true. Some benefits would normally be expected to show up in credible studies to using somewhat more than the RDA of iodine; typically about chance or placebo. .. .. > > Every nursing mother needs make sure she replenishes her iodine > supply, especially by the second child. Nursing takes all of the > iodine from the mother. I don't have time to post the study but I > would be glad to later. .. .. That would be interesting to see. I'm under the impression that if we removed all of the iodine from someone they would very shortly be very dead but maybe that's wrong. In any event it appears that a pregnant mom should take perhaps another 100 mcg/day of iodine if she's not getting more than the usual RDA of 150 mcg/day. While breastfeeding the same should be sufficient [for a total of about 250 mcg/day]. .. .. > > Everything is a balancing act and it is foolish to ignore something > that just needs to be treated with respect. > > Joan .. .. What perhaps causes more problems is not having the the capability to distinguish between unreliable sources such as anecdotal evidence and properly conducted research; and an inability to recognize the modus operandi of con artists and quacks. Quote
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2010 Report Posted January 22, 2010 Here is an e-mail from another happy iodine customer from the iodine group, (she says to the groups moderator who is training to be a Naturopathic doctor) : I credit you with my lack of thyroid cancer 2 years out from surgery! I finally broke down and saw an endo last month. Told her flat out that I would not entertain the idea of radiation...to not even discuss it with me as I would not have it. She was shocked that I was doing so well on Armour for the past 5 years...she asked if I would agree to an ultrasound of the area and blood tests. I said yes. I think she was freaked by the outcome of the tests. I'm cancer free so far...no thryoid tissue was even detectable with the ultrasound. I hope to encourage her to think outside of the " endo box " that big pharma has kept her in so that she will do her patients some good! I credit YOU, Steph, with teaching me about iodine and opening my eyes to the options that are out there.... I'm doing well and you are to blame! haha Thank you from the bottom of my heart! You touch so many lives each day! You touched mine and continue to do so with your research and help. I hope you will write a book one day so that it will become a best seller and open more eyes to our world of thyroid issues! On Jan 21, 2010, at 6:46 PM, wrote: > Hi, Joan. I appreciate that you do not follow the stereotype of the > iodine sites in recommending massive doses of iodine to all and > sundry. > More comments below. Please be aware that my world view is from an > appreciation of allopathic medicine [despite it's limitations] and for > the scientific method. > . > . > > > Posted by: " jmlulich74 " jmlulich74@... > > <mailto:jmlulich74@...?Subject=%20Re%3A%20Iodine%20Safety> > > jmlulich74 <jmlulich74> > > > > > > Wed Jan 20, 2010 8:48 am (PST) > > > > > > > > Just because someone was harmed by iodine is not a reason to > disregard > > its uses. > ; > ; > That is correct. First of all there are well established uses borne > our > by credible studies. Where it becomes more of a problem is when uses > for which there are no well established studies or even credible > theories are propagated. > . > . > > I choose not to load up like Brownstein suggests but we clearly need > > iodine for our bodies to function properly. > . > . > Yes, we need about half the iodine that we get in the US [150 mcg/day] > as demonstrated by peer reviewed research. Brownstein, incidentally, > is > not one of the " researchers " who has ever contributed anything > credible > in that field. > . > . > > > We need Vitamin A but very large amounts are toxic, that doesn't > mean > > we don't take any. It is all a balancing act and one must know their > > bodies. At one time, it was safe to eat seafood but those days are > > over. Kelp has arsenic and aluminum in it, so we are left with > Lugol's > > or Iodoral. > . > . > You can die from drinking too much water. And no one suggests not > taking any iodine, given that every medical person on earth and a vast > number of others know of the research that lists it as an essential > substance. > . > . > > > > I hope people do their own research, pro and con. When I hear of a > > report where someone had detrimental affects, I put that in my > > personal chart that I must proceed with caution. But I still > proceed. > > This thyroid business is touchy and is complicated. > . > . > It can be. But apparently for about 95% of patients they take one > simple pill each day and live a completely full and normal life. That > does not negate the fact that for some small percentage of patients > some > apparent effects of hypothyroidism [or other ailment with somewhat > similar symptoms] suffer continuing problems that range from mild to a > living hell. > . > . > > > > I am glad I tried the Iodoral. It helps me but I doubt that I will > be > > loading up anytime soon but I certainly would it I had goiter or > > nodules or cancer. You bet I would. > . > . > When we are desperate we will often try desperate remedies; that's > true. Some benefits would normally be expected to show up in credible > studies to using somewhat more than the RDA of iodine; typically about > chance or placebo. > . > . > > > > > Every nursing mother needs make sure she replenishes her iodine > > supply, especially by the second child. Nursing takes all of the > > iodine from the mother. I don't have time to post the study but I > > would be glad to later. > . > . > That would be interesting to see. I'm under the impression that if we > removed all of the iodine from someone they would very shortly be very > dead but maybe that's wrong. In any event it appears that a pregnant > mom should take perhaps another 100 mcg/day of iodine if she's not > getting more than the usual RDA of 150 mcg/day. While breastfeeding > the > same should be sufficient [for a total of about 250 mcg/day]. > . > . > > > > Everything is a balancing act and it is foolish to ignore something > > that just needs to be treated with respect. > > > > Joan > . > . > What perhaps causes more problems is not having the the capability to > distinguish between unreliable sources such as anecdotal evidence and > properly conducted research; and an inability to recognize the modus > operandi of con artists and quacks. > > > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.