Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 Thank you for the response Chuck. I am hypothyroid for years now - in fact- even on 1 & l/4 grain compounded dessicated pig thyroid my T4 is only .6 w/norms of .8 to 1.8 and my T3 is 241 w/norms of 230 to 420. Oddly my TSH is .64 which seems rather low (meaning given my Frees it seems my TSH should be higher). My body temp ranges from 96.6 to 97.4 on a good day and I'm always freezing, so I was wondering if a small supplement amount would help out someone like me. Duffy On Fri, Jan 15, 2010 at 5:48 PM, Chuck B <gumboyaya@...> wrote: > Duffy wrote: > > > > > > Is there any amount of iodine which is safe to take.... > > Depends on what you mean by " safe. " Studies have shown that any > significant supplementation, on the order of the RDA or 0.15 mg, will > increase the incidence of Hashimoto's thyroiditis. The threshold for the > haptan anaphylactoid reactions is about 3 mg per day. > > Chuck > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 You might want to get tested for RT3. It blocks the T4 from convering to T3. I'm on T3 only now and I feel better. Roni <>Just because something isn't seen doesn't mean it's not there<> > > > > > > Is there any amount of iodine which is safe to take.... > > Depends on what you mean by " safe. " Studies have shown that any > significant supplementation, on the order of the RDA or 0.15 mg, will > increase the incidence of Hashimoto's thyroiditis. The threshold for the > haptan anaphylactoid reactions is about 3 mg per day. > > Chuck > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 I don't know if any credible studies have been done but there's considerable anecdotal evidence that at least for some people a TSH reading near zero may be desirable where they're taking T3 and T4 instead of T4 alone. I believe Chuck has commented on this a few times. .. .. > > Posted by: " Duffy " knockneed@... > <mailto:knockneed@...?Subject=%20Re%3A%20Iodine%20safety> > mslatrobe <mslatrobe> > > > Fri Jan 15, 2010 7:15 pm (PST) > > > > Thank you for the response Chuck. I am hypothyroid for years now - in > fact- > even on 1 & l/4 grain compounded dessicated pig thyroid my T4 is only .6 > w/norms of .8 to 1.8 and my T3 is 241 w/norms of 230 to 420. Oddly my TSH > is .64 which seems rather low (meaning given my Frees it seems my TSH > should be higher). My body temp ranges from 96.6 to 97.4 on a good day and > I'm always freezing, so I was wondering if a small supplement amount would > help out someone like me. > > Duffy > > On Fri, Jan 15, 2010 at 5:48 PM, Chuck B <gumboyaya@... > <mailto:gumboyaya%40cox.net>> wrote: > > > Duffy wrote: > > > > > > > > > Is there any amount of iodine which is safe to take.... > > > > Depends on what you mean by " safe. " Studies have shown that any > > significant supplementation, on the order of the RDA or 0.15 mg, will > > increase the incidence of Hashimoto's thyroiditis. The threshold for the > > haptan anaphylactoid reactions is about 3 mg per day. > > > > Chuck > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 Duffy, You wrote: > > Thank you for the response Chuck. I am hypothyroid for years now - in fact- > even on 1 & l/4 grain compounded dessicated pig thyroid my T4 is only .6 > w/norms of .8 to 1.8 and my T3 is 241 w/norms of 230 to 420. Oddly my TSH > is .64 which seems rather low (meaning given my Frees it seems my TSH > should be higher). My body temp ranges from 96.6 to 97.4 on a good day and > I'm always freezing, so I was wondering if a small supplement amount would > help out someone like me. > Having the T4 below range is common for dessicated thyroid, since much of the benefit is from the T3 component. However, your T3 could be higher, as well. Low TSH is also typical for dessicated. You might want to take slightly more. Are you following all the usual rules for thyroid meds, 1 hour before, 2 hours after food, etc., including coffee; 4 hours away from calcium or iron supplements? If your low thyroid production is really due to an iodine deficiency, then a supplement at the RDA level ought to be sufficient. Much larger doses will initially cause thyroid production to go down, then it could come back. However, it is not at all clear that the alleged benefits of massive iodine doses have anything to do with the thyroid. Chuck Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 Thanks for the post. Yes, I follow religiously the guidelines on how to take the meds. I set an alarm for 6 a.m. - take the thyroid meds (on my nightstand) and go back to sleep - and get up about 8:30 to live my day. I'm not a breakfast eater, so I have my coffee when I get up and around 11 a.m. or noonish I'm hungry and I eat. Its after that meal that I take my other meds. After the evening meal I take my vitamin supplements. So, basically, I'm pretty sure I'm doing that right. So probably this terrible freezing, chill I'm experiencing is because I need to get those numbers up a bit, right? I'm going to increase the dessicated med and see how that works, but I do have an entire bottle of 5mg Cytomel from last year when I was taking Synthroid and Cytomel together. Maybe I should simply take a 5mg of that every day instead. I will do more reading on the iodine issue. I do consume large amounts of salt unfortunately (hence the " other meds " mentioned above for high blood pressure}. I even salt my Corn chips! Tks again Duffy On Sat, Jan 16, 2010 at 11:39 AM, Chuck B <gumboyaya@...> wrote: > Duffy, > > You wrote: > > > > Thank you for the response Chuck. I am hypothyroid for years now - in > fact- > > even on 1 & l/4 grain compounded dessicated pig thyroid my T4 is only .6 > > w/norms of .8 to 1.8 and my T3 is 241 w/norms of 230 to 420. Oddly my TSH > > is .64 which seems rather low (meaning given my Frees it seems my TSH > > should be higher). My body temp ranges from 96.6 to 97.4 on a good day > and > > I'm always freezing, so I was wondering if a small supplement amount > would > > help out someone like me. > > > > Having the T4 below range is common for dessicated thyroid, since much > of the benefit is from the T3 component. However, your T3 could be > higher, as well. Low TSH is also typical for dessicated. You might want > to take slightly more. > > Are you following all the usual rules for thyroid meds, 1 hour before, 2 > hours after food, etc., including coffee; 4 hours away from calcium or > iron supplements? > > If your low thyroid production is really due to an iodine deficiency, > then a supplement at the RDA level ought to be sufficient. Much larger > doses will initially cause thyroid production to go down, then it could > come back. However, it is not at all clear that the alleged benefits of > massive iodine doses have anything to do with the thyroid. > > Chuck > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 Duffy, You wrote: > > ... So probably this terrible freezing, chill I'm experiencing is because I need > to get those numbers up a bit, right?... That would be my guess. However, there are some other ways the system can malfunction. You might have excess binding, which can be related to adrenal insufficiency. Most other things can be ruled out with a TSH in the normal range, except for RT3. If it is the latter, you might need to get even more T3. Chuck Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 Roni - is this a blood test? I will indeed ask my doc about this and see if I can get it added to my lab work. Thanks for the advice. Duffy On Sat, Jan 16, 2010 at 1:20 AM, Roni Molin <matchermaam@...> wrote: > You might want to get tested for RT3. It blocks the T4 from convering to > T3. I'm on T3 only now and I feel better. > > > Roni > <>Just because something > isn't seen doesn't mean it's > not there<> > > > > > > > > > > > Is there any amount of iodine which is safe to take.... > > > > Depends on what you mean by " safe. " Studies have shown that any > > significant supplementation, on the order of the RDA or 0.15 mg, will > > increase the incidence of Hashimoto's thyroiditis. The threshold for the > > haptan anaphylactoid reactions is about 3 mg per day. > > > > Chuck > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 If you are eating way too much salt, even in your own estimation, you could try eliminating regular processed salt and use sea salt instead. I found that my salt cravings definitely diminished since using it. Also, when I cook, I leave out the salt till the food is on my plate and then add a bit. I seem to need much less this way. My blood pressure has gone down. I just saw on television the other day that they have determined that excess salt is bad for your body whether or not you have high blood pressure. Roni <>Just because something isn't seen doesn't mean it's not there<> > > > > Thank you for the response Chuck. I am hypothyroid for years now - in > fact- > > even on 1 & l/4 grain compounded dessicated pig thyroid my T4 is only .6 > > w/norms of .8 to 1.8 and my T3 is 241 w/norms of 230 to 420. Oddly my TSH > > is .64 which seems rather low (meaning given my Frees it seems my TSH > > should be higher). My body temp ranges from 96.6 to 97.4 on a good day > and > > I'm always freezing, so I was wondering if a small supplement amount > would > > help out someone like me. > > > > Having the T4 below range is common for dessicated thyroid, since much > of the benefit is from the T3 component. However, your T3 could be > higher, as well. Low TSH is also typical for dessicated. You might want > to take slightly more. > > Are you following all the usual rules for thyroid meds, 1 hour before, 2 > hours after food, etc., including coffee; 4 hours away from calcium or > iron supplements? > > If your low thyroid production is really due to an iodine deficiency, > then a supplement at the RDA level ought to be sufficient. Much larger > doses will initially cause thyroid production to go down, then it could > come back. However, it is not at all clear that the alleged benefits of > massive iodine doses have anything to do with the thyroid. > > Chuck > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 Yes, it is a blood test. Roni <>Just because something isn't seen doesn't mean it's not there<> > > > > > > > > > Is there any amount of iodine which is safe to take.... > > > > Depends on what you mean by " safe. " Studies have shown that any > > significant supplementation, on the order of the RDA or 0.15 mg, will > > increase the incidence of Hashimoto's thyroiditis. The threshold for the > > haptan anaphylactoid reactions is about 3 mg per day. > > > > Chuck > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 16, 2010 Report Posted January 16, 2010 but u say salt load whilst on iodine and also what if sodium is low how much salt shld u have From: Roni Molin Sent: Saturday, January 16, 2010 7:38 PM hypothyroidism Subject: Re: Iodine safety If you are eating way too much salt, even in your own estimation, you could try eliminating regular processed salt and use sea salt instead. I found that my salt cravings definitely diminished since using it. Also, when I cook, I leave out the salt till the food is on my plate and then add a bit. I seem to need much less this way. My blood pressure has gone down. I just saw on television the other day that they have determined that excess salt is bad for your body whether or not you have high blood pressure. Roni <>Just because something isn't seen doesn't mean it's not there<> > > > > Thank you for the response Chuck. I am hypothyroid for years now - in > fact- > > even on 1 & l/4 grain compounded dessicated pig thyroid my T4 is only .6 > > w/norms of .8 to 1.8 and my T3 is 241 w/norms of 230 to 420. Oddly my TSH > > is .64 which seems rather low (meaning given my Frees it seems my TSH > > should be higher). My body temp ranges from 96.6 to 97.4 on a good day > and > > I'm always freezing, so I was wondering if a small supplement amount > would > > help out someone like me. > > > > Having the T4 below range is common for dessicated thyroid, since much > of the benefit is from the T3 component. However, your T3 could be > higher, as well. Low TSH is also typical for dessicated. You might want > to take slightly more. > > Are you following all the usual rules for thyroid meds, 1 hour before, 2 > hours after food, etc., including coffee; 4 hours away from calcium or > iron supplements? > > If your low thyroid production is really due to an iodine deficiency, > then a supplement at the RDA level ought to be sufficient. Much larger > doses will initially cause thyroid production to go down, then it could > come back. However, it is not at all clear that the alleged benefits of > massive iodine doses have anything to do with the thyroid. > > Chuck > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 17, 2010 Report Posted January 17, 2010 I, personally am not an advocate of taking iodine. I believe we get enough of it from our food. If you have been eating tons of salt you are probably already getting way more than enough iodine in your system. The freezing cold that I had experienced went away as my dose of T3 increased. I think that before you increase anything or take anything new you need an RT3 blood test. It was what showed that my RT3 was too high, thereby keeping the active hormone T3 from getting into my cells. I was then taken off combo med and put on T3 (cytomel, and now they have a generic too, liothyronine). As my dose has increased, and I've been doing it VERY slowly because I have atrial fibrillation, the freezing cold has stopped.  Once you find out if your body is actually letting the T3 into your cells or not the course of action for you will be much more accurate. Roni <>Just because something isn't seen doesn't mean it's not there<> > > > > Thank you for the response Chuck. I am hypothyroid for years now - in > fact- > > even on 1 & l/4 grain compounded dessicated pig thyroid my T4 is only .6 > > w/norms of .8 to 1.8 and my T3 is 241 w/norms of 230 to 420. Oddly my TSH > > is .64 which seems rather low (meaning given my Frees it seems my TSH > > should be higher). My body temp ranges from 96.6 to 97.4 on a good day > and > > I'm always freezing, so I was wondering if a small supplement amount > would > > help out someone like me. > > > > Having the T4 below range is common for dessicated thyroid, since much > of the benefit is from the T3 component. However, your T3 could be > higher, as well. Low TSH is also typical for dessicated. You might want > to take slightly more. > > Are you following all the usual rules for thyroid meds, 1 hour before, 2 > hours after food, etc., including coffee; 4 hours away from calcium or > iron supplements? > > If your low thyroid production is really due to an iodine deficiency, > then a supplement at the RDA level ought to be sufficient. Much larger > doses will initially cause thyroid production to go down, then it could > come back. However, it is not at all clear that the alleged benefits of > massive iodine doses have anything to do with the thyroid. > > Chuck > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 17, 2010 Report Posted January 17, 2010 You are asking folks with no experience taking iodine. Read this article: https://www.drbrownstein.com/blog_main.html On Jan 16, 2010, at 4:00 PM, Roni Molin wrote: > I, personally am not an advocate of taking iodine. I believe we get > enough of it from our food. If you have been eating tons of salt you > are probably already getting way more than enough iodine in your > system. The freezing cold that I had experienced went away as my > dose of T3 increased. > I think that before you increase anything or take anything new you > need an RT3 blood test. It was what showed that my RT3 was too high, > thereby keeping the active hormone T3 from getting into my cells. I > was then taken off combo med and put on T3 (cytomel, and now they > have a generic too, liothyronine). As my dose has increased, and > I've been doing it VERY slowly because I have atrial fibrillation, > the freezing cold has stopped. > > Once you find out if your body is actually letting the T3 into your > cells or not the course of action for you will be much more accurate. > > Roni > <>Just because something > isn't seen doesn't mean it's > not there<> > > > > > > > > Thank you for the response Chuck. I am hypothyroid for years now > - in > > fact- > > > even on 1 & l/4 grain compounded dessicated pig thyroid my T4 is > only .6 > > > w/norms of .8 to 1.8 and my T3 is 241 w/norms of 230 to 420. > Oddly my TSH > > > is .64 which seems rather low (meaning given my Frees it seems > my TSH > > > should be higher). My body temp ranges from 96.6 to 97.4 on a > good day > > and > > > I'm always freezing, so I was wondering if a small supplement > amount > > would > > > help out someone like me. > > > > > > > Having the T4 below range is common for dessicated thyroid, since > much > > of the benefit is from the T3 component. However, your T3 could be > > higher, as well. Low TSH is also typical for dessicated. You might > want > > to take slightly more. > > > > Are you following all the usual rules for thyroid meds, 1 hour > before, 2 > > hours after food, etc., including coffee; 4 hours away from > calcium or > > iron supplements? > > > > If your low thyroid production is really due to an iodine > deficiency, > > then a supplement at the RDA level ought to be sufficient. Much > larger > > doses will initially cause thyroid production to go down, then it > could > > come back. However, it is not at all clear that the alleged > benefits of > > massive iodine doses have anything to do with the thyroid. > > > > Chuck > > > > > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 17, 2010 Report Posted January 17, 2010 If you would reread my post, I didn't ask her to take anything. I suggested a test, and specifically suggested she does Not take anything new right now before she knows what is happening. Roni <>Just because something isn't seen doesn't mean it's not there<> > > > > > > Thank you for the response Chuck. I am hypothyroid for years now > - in > > fact- > > > even on 1 & l/4 grain compounded dessicated pig thyroid my T4 is > only .6 > > > w/norms of .8 to 1.8 and my T3 is 241 w/norms of 230 to 420. > Oddly my TSH > > > is .64 which seems rather low (meaning given my Frees it seems > my TSH > > > should be higher). My body temp ranges from 96.6 to 97.4 on a > good day > > and > > > I'm always freezing, so I was wondering if a small supplement > amount > > would > > > help out someone like me. > > > > > > > Having the T4 below range is common for dessicated thyroid, since > much > > of the benefit is from the T3 component. However, your T3 could be > > higher, as well. Low TSH is also typical for dessicated. You might > want > > to take slightly more. > > > > Are you following all the usual rules for thyroid meds, 1 hour > before, 2 > > hours after food, etc., including coffee; 4 hours away from > calcium or > > iron supplements? > > > > If your low thyroid production is really due to an iodine > deficiency, > > then a supplement at the RDA level ought to be sufficient. Much > larger > > doses will initially cause thyroid production to go down, then it > could > > come back. However, it is not at all clear that the alleged > benefits of > > massive iodine doses have anything to do with the thyroid. > > > > Chuck > > > > > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 17, 2010 Report Posted January 17, 2010 That's not a completely true statement. Nancie [who is a doctor] took a large dose of iodine as recommended by the iodine quacks [and Brownstein] and went into anaphylatic shock. She probably would have died if she had not been in her doctor's office and there was a crash cart available. She has posted her experience here multiple times. No matter how you slice it: Many will be harmed by massive doses of iodine, and a very small percentage will die if they go into anaphylatic shock and do not get immediate emergency care. .. .. Posted by: " Alison Trotta-Marshall " rubyrain11@... gypsy1jig Sat Jan 16, 2010 9:06 pm (PST) You are asking folks with no experience taking iodine. Read this article: https://www.drbrownstein.com/blog_main.html On Jan 16, 2010, at 4:00 PM, Roni Molin wrote: > I, personally am not an advocate of taking iodine. I believe we get > enough of it from our food. If you have been eating tons of salt you > are probably already getting way more than enough iodine in your > system. The freezing cold that I had experienced went away as my > dose of T3 increased. > I think that before you increase anything or take anything new you > need an RT3 blood test. It was what showed that my RT3 was too high, > thereby keeping the active hormone T3 from getting into my cells. I > was then taken off combo med and put on T3 (cytomel, and now they > have a generic too, liothyronine). As my dose has increased, and > I've been doing it VERY slowly because I have atrial fibrillation, > the freezing cold has stopped. > > Once you find out if your body is actually letting the T3 into your > cells or not the course of action for you will be much more accurate. > > Roni > <>Just because something > isn't seen doesn't mean it's > not there<> > > > > From: angela pittaway <angela.pittaway@...> > Subject: Re: Iodine safety > hypothyroidism > Date: Saturday, January 16, 2010, 12:04 PM > > but u say salt load whilst on iodine and also what if sodium is low > how much salt shld u have Quote
Guest guest Posted January 18, 2010 Report Posted January 18, 2010 The best thing you could do for your blood pressure is to cut your sodium down to 1,000 - 1,500 mg/day. I stay at about 800 mg/d. HTN is deadly and will shorten your life. Val Posted by: " Duffy " Thanks for your post . I do indeed use a great deal of iodized salt, interspersed with sea salt.too. I like them both. I am extremely heavy handed with the salt shaker and having to take 3 kinds of blood pressure meds no doubt proves it. Quote
Guest guest Posted January 18, 2010 Report Posted January 18, 2010 > That's not a completely true statement. Nancie [who is a doctor] Are you sure??????? > > That's not a completely true statement. Nancie [who is a doctor] took a > large dose of iodine as recommended by the iodine quacks [and > Brownstein] and went into anaphylatic shock. She probably would Quote
Guest guest Posted January 18, 2010 Report Posted January 18, 2010 I believe Nancie is a Nurse Practitioner. Roni <>Just because something isn't seen doesn't mean it's not there<> From: Trish <fielddot@...> Subject: Re: Iodine safety hypothyroidism Date: Monday, January 18, 2010, 2:30 AM > That's not a completely true statement. Nancie [who is a doctor] Are you sure??????? > > That's not a completely true statement. Nancie [who is a doctor] took a > large dose of iodine as recommended by the iodine quacks [and > Brownstein] and went into anaphylatic shock. She probably would ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted January 18, 2010 Report Posted January 18, 2010 Iodine has helped me with my temps. I don't do the iodine loading test because it scares me but I do believe we are deficient. I have had exposure to bromine from drinking Dansani bottled water, lived in an area where the water was fluoridated, have cooked and bathed in chlorinated water. Not to mention the fireworks I have observed from a short distance. Someone on the iodine forum who does autism research just posted that iodine thickens the mucosal linings in the intestines alleviating allergies. At first I didn't take iodine because I believed it was dangerous but I clearly feel better with it. I take it once a week and apply Lugol's topically to my moles and skin tags. I think it is reasonable to say 'Proceed with caution' but it could be more harmful to not take iodine. It gave me a headache so I backed off and did more salt loading. I haven't read anything or heard of a personal story where iodine harmed the thyroid, only doctors saying it could. There is plenty out there about the health benefits. I would be happy to read it if it is out there. Does anyone have this kind of information? Regards, Joan > Thank you for the response Chuck. I am hypothyroid for years now - in fact- > even on 1 & l/4 grain compounded dessicated pig thyroid my T4 is only .6 > w/norms of .8 to 1.8 and my T3 is 241 w/norms of 230 to 420. Oddly my TSH > is .64 which seems rather low (meaning given my Frees it seems my TSH > should be higher). My body temp ranges from 96.6 to 97.4 on a good day and > I'm always freezing, so I was wondering if a small supplement amount would > help out someone like me. > > Duffy Quote
Guest guest Posted January 18, 2010 Report Posted January 18, 2010 I'm new to this group but I think I won't be staying long. There is a lack of nutritional knowledge here. The tv program could be edited to that regular table salt causes high blood pressure because we know that is what they were referring to. Anyone who is hypothyroid doesn't retain salt. They should be consuming around 1 tsp per day. There are many different opinions on how to treat the thyroid but the salt thing is basic. The beginning to thyroid health is a healthful diet, one free of additives, bad oils and chemicals. Regards, Joan > > If you are eating way too much salt, even in your own estimation, you could try eliminating regular processed salt and use sea salt instead. I found that my salt cravings definitely diminished since using it. Also, when I cook, I leave out the salt till the food is on my plate and then add a bit. I seem to need much less this way. My blood pressure has gone down. I just saw on television the other day that they have determined that excess salt is bad for your body whether or not you have high blood pressure. > > > Roni Quote
Guest guest Posted January 19, 2010 Report Posted January 19, 2010 Hey Val, thanks for the advice, but I don't know what HTN is???? I don't know how to cut down my sodium, I crave it so badly, I sometimes will shake into my hand and lick it up. Its almost like a drug for me Duffy On Sun, Jan 17, 2010 at 10:57 PM, Valarie <val@...> wrote: > The best thing you could do for your blood pressure is to cut your sodium > down to 1,000 - 1,500 mg/day. I stay at about 800 mg/d. HTN is deadly and > will shorten your life. > > Val > > Posted by: " Duffy " > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 20, 2010 Report Posted January 20, 2010 that doesn't make her a doctor ...I don't believe she's ever claimed to be a doctor. Trish > > She's spoken multiple times about diagnosing and writing prescriptions IIRC. > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 20, 2010 Report Posted January 20, 2010 Some interesting facts about sodium chloride (salt) from different perspectives.  http://legacy.signonsandiego.com/uniontrib/20070717/news_lz1c17qanda.html  http://www.bellaonline.com/articles/art2440.asp  http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/sea-salt/AN01142  http://curezone.com/foods/saltcure.asp  http://www.saltworks.us/salt_info/si_gourmet_reference.asp Roni <>Just because something isn't seen doesn't mean it's not there<> From: jmlulich74 <jmlulich74@...> Subject: Re: Iodine Safety hypothyroidism Date: Wednesday, January 20, 2010, 8:46 AM Just because someone was harmed by iodine is not a reason to disregard its uses. I choose not to load up like Brownstein suggests but we clearly need iodine for our bodies to function properly. We need Vitamin A but very large amounts are toxic, that doesn't mean we don't take any. It is all a balancing act and one must know their bodies. At one time, it was safe to eat seafood but those days are over. Kelp has arsenic and aluminum in it, so we are left with Lugol's or Iodoral. I hope people do their own research, pro and con. When I hear of a report where someone had detrimental affects, I put that in my personal chart that I must proceed with caution.   But I still proceed. This thyroid business is touchy and is complicated. I am glad I tried the Iodoral. It helps me but I doubt that I will be loading up anytime soon but I certainly would it I had goiter or nodules or cancer. You bet I would. Every nursing mother needs make sure she replenishes her iodine supply, especially by the second child. Nursing takes all of the iodine from the mother. I don't have time to post the study but I would be glad to later. Everything is a balancing act and it is foolish to ignore something that just needs to be treated with respect. Joan ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted January 20, 2010 Report Posted January 20, 2010 Hi Joan, Do we know the source of the iodine in Lugols and Iodoral? After I see my doc about possible RT3 issues, I'm considering trying a llittle bit of it, but if its source is kelp - I can live without it and any contaminants it may contain. Thanks in advance for any info. Duffy On Wed, Jan 20, 2010 at 11:46 AM, jmlulich74 <jmlulich74@...> wrote: > Just because someone was harmed by iodine is not a reason to disregard its > uses. I choose not to load up like Brownstein suggests but we clearly need > iodine for our bodies to function properly. We need Vitamin A but very > large amounts are toxic, that doesn't mean we don't take any. It is all a > balancing act and one must know their bodies. At one time, it was safe to > eat seafood but those days are over. Kelp has arsenic and aluminum in it, > so we are left with Lugol's or Iodoral. > > I hope people do their own research, pro and con. When I hear of a report > where someone had detrimental affects, I put that in my personal chart that > I must proceed with caution. But I still proceed. This thyroid business > is touchy and is complicated. > > > -- SNIP Quote
Guest guest Posted January 21, 2010 Report Posted January 21, 2010 Natalaie, I have no idea why your post was so over reactive to my question. I asked because I didn't know - that's how we learn; that's what these lists are for - not because I'm paranoid. I think you need to temper your responses so that people aren't attacked for asking questions. Duffy On Thu, Jan 21, 2010 at 12:13 AM, ND <blessedark2009@...> wrote: > That is why we take it. It isn't from kelp. Do you think would > have us take something that she know could be toxic? Is anyone reading her > web site? I have been here for a month and have it all figured out by > reading what I was told to read when I signed up the day I did. > Iodoral and Lugol's is not contaminated. I can't believe that you would > think we are all taking something that is contaminated. > I can understand you are a bit paranoid but there are hundreds of us on > this site taking it. > > from Illinois > > > > > > ________________________________ > From: Duffy <knockneed@...> > hypothyroidism > Sent: Wed, January 20, 2010 3:55:52 PM > Subject: Re: Re: Iodine Safety > > > Hi Joan, Do we know the source of the iodine in Lugols and Iodoral? > After I see my doc about possible RT3 issues, I'm considering trying a > llittle bit of it, but if its source is kelp - I can live without it and > any > contaminants it may contain. > Thanks in advance for any info. > Duffy > > On Wed, Jan 20, 2010 at 11:46 AM, jmlulich74 <jmlulich74 (DOT) com> > wrote: > > > Just because someone was harmed by iodine is not a reason to disregard > its > > uses. I choose not to load up like Brownstein suggests but we clearly > need > > iodine for our bodies to function properly. We need Vitamin A but very > > large amounts are toxic, that doesn't mean we don't take any. It is all > a > > balancing act and one must know their bodies. At one time, it was safe > to > > eat seafood but those days are over. Kelp has arsenic and aluminum in > it, > > so we are left with Lugol's or Iodoral. > > > > I hope people do their own research, pro and con. When I hear of a > report > > where someone had detrimental affects, I put that in my personal chart > that > > I must proceed with caution. But I still proceed. This thyroid > business > > is touchy and is complicated. > > > > > > > > -- > SNIP > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 21, 2010 Report Posted January 21, 2010 I apologize if I hurt your feelings. Didn't mean to. from Illinois ________________________________ From: Duffy <knockneed@...> hypothyroidism Sent: Thu, January 21, 2010 9:48:22 AM Subject: Re: Re: Iodine Safety Natalaie, I have no idea why your post was so over reactive to my question. I asked because I didn't know - that's how we learn; that's what these lists are for - not because I'm paranoid. I think you need to temper your responses so that people aren't attacked for asking questions. Duffy On Thu, Jan 21, 2010 at 12:13 AM, ND <blessedark2009@ att.net> wrote: > That is why we take it. It isn't from kelp. Do you think would > have us take something that she know could be toxic? Is anyone reading her > web site? I have been here for a month and have it all figured out by > reading what I was told to read when I signed up the day I did. > Iodoral and Lugol's is not contaminated. I can't believe that you would > think we are all taking something that is contaminated. > I can understand you are a bit paranoid but there are hundreds of us on > this site taking it. > > from Illinois > > > > > > ____________ _________ _________ __ > From: Duffy <knockneedgmail (DOT) com> > hypothyroidism > Sent: Wed, January 20, 2010 3:55:52 PM > Subject: Re: Re: Iodine Safety > > > Hi Joan, Do we know the source of the iodine in Lugols and Iodoral? > After I see my doc about possible RT3 issues, I'm considering trying a > llittle bit of it, but if its source is kelp - I can live without it and > any > contaminants it may contain. > Thanks in advance for any info. > Duffy > > On Wed, Jan 20, 2010 at 11:46 AM, jmlulich74 <jmlulich74@ . com> > wrote: > > > Just because someone was harmed by iodine is not a reason to disregard > its > > uses. I choose not to load up like Brownstein suggests but we clearly > need > > iodine for our bodies to function properly. We need Vitamin A but very > > large amounts are toxic, that doesn't mean we don't take any. It is all > a > > balancing act and one must know their bodies. At one time, it was safe > to > > eat seafood but those days are over. Kelp has arsenic and aluminum in > it, > > so we are left with Lugol's or Iodoral. > > > > I hope people do their own research, pro and con. When I hear of a > report > > where someone had detrimental affects, I put that in my personal chart > that > > I must proceed with caution. But I still proceed.. This thyroid > business > > is touchy and is complicated. > > > > > > > > -- > SNIP > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.