Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Herxing

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

Theresa,

Pardon me if you have already explained this previously, but..how's your

candida issue? Looked into it?

>From: " Theresa Romani " <tromani@...>

>Reply-onelist

> " CFS FM Experimental " <onelist>

>Subject: Herxing

>Date: Wed, 19 Jan 2000 19:59:24 -0500

>

>Hi,

>

> I have been having repeated problems with healing from ingrown toenail

>surgery that was done before Thanksgiving. The Dr has put me on different

>antibiotics each time for 1 to 2 weeks. The first and third (current) time

>it was to prevent infections, the second time to actually fight an existing

>infection. My problem is that each time I take an antibiotic I seem to get

>somehow depressed and extremely lethargic - sleeping or wanting to all day

>long and still sleeping at night. Is this considered to be a herx reaction?

>I'm not in any kind of muscle pain or anything - just plain tired and

>nonfunctional til I'm off them several days. Anyone else experience this

>sort of thing? I can't remember the name of the 1st ab, but the second was

>something like levaquin, and now a generic of ciprofloxicin. Thanks!

>

> -Theresa

>

______________________________________________________

Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com

Posted

I got fibro around age 13 or 14. around this time I also had 3 ingrown

tonails and with each operation I went on antibiotics (amoxycilan maybe?)

for about a month. Ive always wondered if this contributed to my getting

fibro.

Posted

..... I have a sleeping beauty in my house how that Laurie is taking doxcycyline,

running 16+ hrs/day. I view it as a herx effect.

I would also view depression as a herx effect in CFSers -- herxing often makes

existing symptoms worst and in some cases 'brings out the symptoms that you

could have in 6 -24 months if you did nothing'

If the infection persists, try adding bromelain -- it is a demonstrated

(European and Japanese studies) antibiotic potenator... but also expect more

herxing....

Posted

Doesn't sound like any herxheimer reaction I have experienced, but I have

not been on those drugs you mentioned, here is a brief explanation of the

herx:

From Vanderhoof-Forschner's Book, [1997] " Everything You Need To Know

About Lyme Disease " :

What is a Herxheimer reaction?

Answer: The term was originally used to describe a reaction that occurred

6-10

hours after the initial treatment for syphilis. It consisted of transient

fever and a brief exacerbation of visible lesions. It is thought that this

is

caused by either an allergic response to antigens or foreign substances

released by the organism when it is killed or that these substances may have

endotoxic properties. Much the same situation occurs during the treatment

of

Lyme disease. Patients encounter a variety of symptoms which may include

fever, chills, rash and increased symptomatology. Usually this reaction is

seen with IV therapy but it can occur during oral antibiotic therapy as

well.

The point at which it happens during therapy varies from one antibiotic to

another but generally it does not occur prior to day 10. However, it is

important that you ask your doctor about this so that you will know what to

expect.

Q. How can a Lyme patient be certain that he/she is experiencing a Herx

reaction and not an allergic reaction?

A: This is very difficult. Herx reactions are very common during treatment

of

Lyme disease. It usually consists of fever, chills, sweats, joint and

muscle

pain and exacerbation of symptoms. It occurs in approximately 50% of

patients

in varying degrees of severity. However, this symptom complex is very

similar

to a type of allergic reaction that is antiboby dependent, called serum

sickness.

Originally serum sickness occured when large amounts of antiserum prepared

in

horses or rabbits were injected into patients to protect them from various

diseases particularly during the period from 1900-1940. But this reaction

is

also encountered with penicillin and other drugs. Typically it occurs 3

days

to 3 weeks after injection and the patient experiences fever, enlarged lymph

nodes and spleen, and painful joints. Since a large amount of antigen or

foreign substance is injected, there is still a considerable amount of

antigen

available once antibody production begins. This excess of free antigen is

able

to bind to newly formed antibodies and form Ag-Ab complexes. In turn these

complexes bind a substance found in the blood called complement and attract

polymorphonuclear leukocytes (white blood cells). Lysosomal (digestive)

enzymes are released which cause tissue damage with destructive inflammation

of

small blood vessels (vasculitis). Free complement in the blood is depressed

at

the height of the reaction. This can be detected by a blood test. Once the

complexes are destroyed, free antibodies appear and symptoms abate. But if

the

offending substance continues to be administered, the vasculitis will result

in

chronic inflammmation.

Since the Herxheimer reaction seen in Lyme disease also involves a reaction

to

a foreign substance (either one released by the organism once it is killed

or

an endotoxin), it is important to carefully monitor the patient once the

reaction begins. Also, since the reaction is fueled by excess antigen it

can

be controlled by decreasing the amount of antibiotic that is used. This in

turn decreases the amount of antigen or toxin. If it is determined that

this

is not a detrimental situation it is important not to stop therapy. It can

be

altered as described above but not stopped. Once the patient has safely

passed

through this period he or she often experiences a lessening of symptoms

since

reaction is often elicited in response to spirochetal demise. " >>

> From: " Theresa Romani " <tromani@...>

>

> Hi,

>

> I have been having repeated problems with healing from ingrown toenail

> surgery that was done before Thanksgiving. The Dr has put me on different

> antibiotics each time for 1 to 2 weeks. The first and third (current) time

> it was to prevent infections, the second time to actually fight an

existing

> infection. My problem is that each time I take an antibiotic I seem to get

> somehow depressed and extremely lethargic - sleeping or wanting to all day

> long and still sleeping at night. Is this considered to be a herx

reaction?

> I'm not in any kind of muscle pain or anything - just plain tired and

> nonfunctional til I'm off them several days. Anyone else experience this

> sort of thing? I can't remember the name of the 1st ab, but the second was

> something like levaquin, and now a generic of ciprofloxicin. Thanks!

>

> -Theresa

Posted

A message I recently relayed indicated that certain antibiotics can contribute

to / promote the growth of cell wall deficient (CWD) bacteria (just like other

promote yeast infections!). It may be a contributing factor -- but more

importantly, your wondering could also be a curing factor: You may wish to be

tested for CWD (most commonly known by one species: mycoplasma) OR if your MD

deems the risks acceptable, try an antibiotic effective against CWD (for example

doxcycline) for 30 days to see if any improvement happens.

----- Original Message -----

From: 2276@...

I got fibro around age 13 or 14. around this time I also had 3 ingrown

tonails and with each operation I went on antibiotics (amoxycilan maybe?)

for about a month. Ive always wondered if this contributed to my getting

fibro.

Posted

In a message dated 1/19/00 7:58:29 PM Eastern Standard Time,

tromani@... writes:

<< From: " Theresa Romani " <tromani@...>

Hi,

I have been having repeated problems with healing from ingrown toenail

surgery that was done before Thanksgiving. The Dr has put me on different

antibiotics each time for 1 to 2 weeks. The first and third (current) time

it was to prevent infections, the second time to actually fight an existing

infection. My problem is that each time I take an antibiotic I seem to get

somehow depressed and extremely lethargic - sleeping or wanting to all day

long and still sleeping at night. Is this considered to be a herx reaction?

I'm not in any kind of muscle pain or anything - just plain tired and

nonfunctional til I'm off them several days. Anyone else experience this

sort of thing? I can't remember the name of the 1st ab, but the second was

something like levaquin, and now a generic of ciprofloxicin. Thanks!

-Theresa

>>

A few persons I know have shared the same thing with me that they get very

tired when taking antibiotics...so i think it's fairly common....i wouldn't

worry about it. did you ever ask your doctor if that was a side effect?

Posted

Dear ,

I'm not experiencing any oral or vaginal yeast symptoms which are what

usually hit me. I eat a lot of yogurt so I hope I'm replenishing the

" friendlies " needed. Is there something else that can be tested easily?

- Theresa

>From: " Thorstensen " <jane_doe_press@...>

>

>Theresa,

>

>Pardon me if you have already explained this previously, but..how's your

>candida issue? Looked into it?

Posted

In a message dated 1/20/2000 2:38:26 PM Eastern Standard Time,

Luvsjurny@... writes:

> Anyone else experience this

> sort of thing? I can't remember the name of the 1st ab, but the second was

> something like levaquin, and now a generic of ciprofloxicin

Hi Theresa

Could be herxing,

Friends and i have experienced all kinds of herxing,

could be fillers in the abx that you are allergic too

did you feel better and then slightly overdue in the begining of abx

with me,

sometimes i felt it was a die off w/ your symtoms,

usually mine start from the head and works to the feet

i have never been on those abx's you were given

so many factors w/abx and us......

are those abx's in the same family? ask Dr. , maybe a clue there..... you

were put on an abx in case of infection started?

Good Luck.......

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Somish or any other willing contributor,

Sorry for beginner question. Haven't been able to get a definition from

any medical dictionaries. What is the " herxing effect?

Greatly appreicated and thanks in advance if you have time to clue me in....

S.

Posted

In a message dated 1/29/00 3:24:56 AM Eastern Standard Time,

onelist writes:

> From: Jerry <sheri.clark@...>Subject: Re: herxingSomish or any

> other willing contributor,Sorry for beginner question. Haven't been able to

> get a definition fromany medical dictionaries. What is the " herxing effect?

> Greatly appreicated and thanks in advance if you have time to clue me

in....S.

> ____________________________________________________________

Sheri, You should be careful with the responses you get to this question. Abx

herxing is a term that is thrown around on this list like mud in a pig pin.

Since

abx only KEEP bacteria from reproducing by eliminating their ability to

develop membranes (cell walls), it is hard for me to understand why people

claim that abx are 'killing off' bacteria and making them feel temporarily

worse.

Common sense tells you that in the past, when you have had strep throat, you

feel better a day or two after taking the abx. Where is the herx affect? I

will get

beat up for this message but I feel like herxing is an overused and

inappropriate

term in many cases.

Mike

Posted

Herxing is short for the Herxheimer effect, which basically says that

anytime you kill off alot of bacteria, fungus, viruses, whatever, in the

body, you will have symptoms from the toxicity of the dead nasties until

your body has a chance to clear all that stuff out of your system. The

symptoms can vary, and they can be severe or mild, and anything you do to

help with cleansing will help alleviate them, but they will pass. Other

people might have a more scientific definition, but loosely, that's all

we're talking about.

in North Carolina

>

> Sorry for beginner question. Haven't been able to get a definition from

> any medical dictionaries. What is the " herxing effect?

>

> Greatly appreicated and thanks in advance if you have time to

> clue me in....

> S.

Posted

In a message dated 1/29/00 7:02:06 PM Eastern Standard Time,

onelist writes:

> Herxing only occurs with SOME micro-organisms like parasites, fungi,

> spirochetes (syphilis, lyme) and the dreaded intra cellular bacteriae we

are

> constantly talking about (mycoplasma, chlamydiae, rickettsiae).

>

> And my personal view is that it is quite the opposite: ie the medicos are

> not aware of this effect (they only learnt it in rel to some parasites and

> syphilis), and since they don't know much at all about other chronic

> intracellulars they don't know about Herxing either, and they'll give you

> the kind of spiel you just gave us!

>

> Nelly

Nelly, if you read my message again I said " it was hard for me to understand " ,

not that everyone else was wrong. You obvioulsy know more about this subject

than I.

Mike

Posted

Thank you Mike.

You also make common sense. Hmmm...opposing information. Maybe you

stirred the pot. Usually a little stirred pot brings more to the

surface. Thanks again, S.

Posted

... as a FYI, when I talked about herxing this morning ... there were many

'excuse me but I'll pass on the antibiotics' looks, especially when yeast issues

and 18 months were mentioned!

Laurie sharing her experience -- the positive aspects made a real impact:

* you know that you REALLY have something (it's NOT AIYH)

* with bromelain being able to 'control' how good or bad a day can be (after the

initial herxing) had an empowering effect

* having family members change their attitude to " your sickness " because you are

on antibiotics prescribed by a MD

* MD's prescription to control yeast worked -- she forgot it for 4 days, and was

'painfully' reminded...

Of course, having our (and their) MD there also helped.. MD is 'new' to this

aspect of CFS -- but having two active herxers (including one willing to help

talk other CFSers through it), is helping her education greatly... :-)

---------- Original Message ----------------------------------

From: MCamp10139@...

And my personal view is that it is quite the opposite: ie the medicos are

not aware of this effect (they only learnt it in rel to some parasites and

syphilis), and since they don't know much at all about other chronic

intracellulars they don't know about Herxing either, and they'll give you

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

In a message dated 2/9/00 4:00:44 PM Eastern Standard Time,

onelist writes:

<< When I started to take fiber wit extremely potent

strains of Lactobacillus acidophilus and Bifidus ??, I had to begin with a

tea spoon of it. I felt (within two hours) nausea, headache etc. I thought

it meant " herxing " . >>

Stanislava, " herxing " is the bad effects of bacteria or viruses dying off

after

treatment with an antibiotic or whey or glutamine or whatever. I doubt that

you had real herxing after using acidophilus. Some might say you can herx

from anything, but if you want a real definition, use 'herxheimer' in a

search

engine to get a good definition. My point is this; herxing is a bad reaction

from

bugs dying off, anything else is simply a side effect from a treatment, like

an

upset or burning stomach from taking too much aspirin. It seemed like folks

were almost saying, " yeah, I took aspirin and herxed for days! " -can't happen.

Mike

  • 1 month later...
Guest guest
Posted

nope, never had herxing effect from kutapressin. I will soon add kut to the

immunopro. Take that, you hhv6ies!

Guest guest
Posted

Does anyone have a herxing or detoxing effect with kutapressin. I never have --

at least I don't think I have. anyone else?

steve

Guest guest
Posted

hi steve, i herxed when i first started Kutapressin......but after taking for

a yr, i dont feel like its doing anything anymore

Radha

  • 2 weeks later...
Guest guest
Posted

I am someone who does not seem to experience herxing for some reason as well.

I know someone else mentioned this a while back.

Also, I do not sweat anymore. Has this happened to anyone since CFIDS and if

so do you know why this happens?

Lastly, I read that some of you are on Transfer Factor. I read someplace

that cfids is very much like Lupus where we have some parts of the immune

system being in over drive because of massive antibody production. Well,

wouldn't transfer factor make this part of cfids much worse? Isn't transfer

factor pure antibodies? Thank you,

Guest guest
Posted

Time: from 3 days to 8 weeks have been what I know from personal experience or correspondance... the 8 weeks folks has a long rough wait for it (lots of doubts after 4 weeks)

No Herxing is NOT guaranteed (80-90% odds), the symptoms and more information is available at http://www.folkarts.com/idef/herxheimer.htm

HTH

Ken Lassesen 2 @ 2 ft PWC, 2 @ 4ft PWC2 ft PWC: http://www.folkarts.com/idef/4 ft PWC: http://corgi.folkarts.com/Fax: (520) 832-6836 ICQ #: 2122097 (Netmeeting too)

herxing

From: radha21@... hi all, just wanted to know how long it usually takes to start herxing after u start the doxy........and is herxing the only sign that the abx is doing anything? if u dont herx then does that mean that abx wont help? and what exactly does herxing entail? thanks for your help...Radha

This list is intended for patients to share personal experiences with each other, not to give medical advice. If you are interested in any treatment discussed here, please consult your doctor.

Guest guest
Posted

Yes. my mom's neighbour and her sister both have CFIDS and noticed the no sweat aspect.

My original theory was that sweat reduced blood volume -- and many of us (per Bell-Streeten research) have a very low blood volume... hence no water available for sweat...

Ken Lassesen 2 @ 2 ft PWC, 2 @ 4ft PWC2 ft PWC: http://www.folkarts.com/idef/4 ft PWC: http://corgi.folkarts.com/Fax: (520) 832-6836 ICQ #: 2122097 (Netmeeting too)

----- Original Message -----

From: lbinujrsy@... Also, I do not sweat anymore. Has this happened to anyone since CFIDS and if so do you know why this happens?

Guest guest
Posted

hi i used to break out into cold sweats really bad, but neurontin and

oral interferon helped....now i dont get attacks as much, and less severe.

neurontin doesnt help my pain or energy though.......

Radha

  • 4 months later...
  • 9 years later...
Guest guest
Posted

Could it be possible that herxing could be a result of normal cells being killed

and releasing toxins?

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...