Guest guest Posted September 12, 2006 Report Posted September 12, 2006 Sylvia, After reading your mention of immune related illnesses in the dedication, I didn't read the first part but jumped ahead to your autoimmune and immune system section because the subject interests me as I've reversed autoimmune disorders in the past. Without thinking about it you made a good point for undenatured whey on page 70. It is designed to be easily assimilated by the highly permeable intestinal mucosa of baby mammals because they do not have a well-enough developed intestinal wall or immune system to tolerate adult foods. Whey is awesome for the immune system. I think you could have made it more clear that 70% of the immune system is in the tissues immediately adjacent to the digestive tract, rather than saying 70% of the immune system is " in the digestive tract " . On page 75 you mention you have lactose intolerance; it can be eliminated by culturing a better bowel ecology with inulin and other prebiotics, according to this British Medical Journal study http://pmj.bmjjournals.com/cgi/content/full/80/946/447 which also points out that " probiotics have been shown clearly to boost immunity in the elderly. " Lots of similar work, some of it on my website, refutes the concept of keeping microflora in the intestine to a minimum, a concept championed by Elaine Gottchall and Michio Kushi, both of whom you mention. These works are now long in the tooth even though Kusi's book was revised in 1994, and we are leagues ahead of where we were 12 years ago in terms of understanding how bowel bacteria and prebiotics work. An important part of what we know is that the probiotic bacteria mut be active, not simply added as an already worked-out culture, to outcompete on the bowel lining; competition requires active fermentation of prebiotics, which is against the advice of both works. Also, on page 78, although you did specify acidophilus I think you meant to include other acid-producing lactobacilli in your definition of probiotic. But lactobacilli are already naturally higher numerically in the elderly gut, and get this -- so are pathogenic organisms, so obviously lactobacilli are not stellar performers as probiotics compared to bifidobacteria, small fluctuations of which result in large numeric changes to pathogens as well as lactobacilli. See Tungland's Comprehensive Scientific Review on my website for more aong those lines, including references. Further, you recommend on page 78 against milk proteins, based on your personal experience and your exposure to the NotMilk agenda, even quoting some of it elsewhere; I'd suggest that you should revise the language a bit for your second edition and perhaps note for your readers that milk proteins are an issue only to a fairly small minority. For the record, NotMilk prints what satisfies their platform; note if you go there www.notmilk.com you'll see that the articles are liberally sprinkled with innuendo and speculation, arguably a hallmark of the agenda sites but not of objective health reporting. A good rule of thumb is to beware the taint of the agenda sites generally if you use them at all, and be careful if you don't want to be tarred by the same brush when you do quote such a site. Moving on, according to this study in Blood Journal, platelet- derived microparticles generated during thrombus formation associate with local fibrin (the coagulating protein): http://www.bloodjournal.org/cgi/content/abstract/87/11/4651 With this in mind, the platelet activation and clotting you describe on page 75, is aggravated by the presence of higher than normal amounts of the clotting protein fibrin in the elderly because production of plasmin, the body's only natural enzyme to break it down, falls off with age. The result is reduced circulation and spontaneous clotting as blood coagulates more easily. This suggests increasing the dissolution of the fibrin to youthful values will support biological function, and it does; Taking fibrinolytic enzymes reduces clotting risk including heart attack and stroke, without warfarin, and also reduces the clot- forming effect of platelet activation by mast cells, i.e. with little free fibrin to bind to you won't get the degree of clotting that we would call excessive. Blockbuster All Clear is an enzyme blend chosen by many professionals: http://www.goodhealth.nu/us/1400 because it contains nattokinase, serapeptase and Seaprose-S, all good fibrinolytics with slightly different properties of dissolving excess clotting. It also contains protease and lipase to help scar tissue, fibrosis, adhesion and plaque dissolution. On page 81 you state that the immune system must top the replication rate of the infecting virus. Actually, because the white blood cells operate many times before they die, they don't actually have to match in numbers, and maintaining their robustness and activity are much more important. This is an important point I was going to get into on the candida list anyway; nothing beats systemic candida like a robust and aggressive immune response, and nothing makes the immune response more robust and aggresive than using undenatured whey with Transfer Factor Plus Advanced Formula. Imagine having more than four times the immune response afforded by natural killer cells, PLUS direct conferred immunity to a wide range of specific organisms, PLUS natural immunomodulators in both products to control an autoimmune or hyperensitive immune condition, PLUS all the glutathione the white blood cells need to work, and they need lots. On page 83, your comment " high cholesterol or peri-vascular disease can be caused by intestinal mucosal erosion " indicates an acceptance of one or more of the cholesterol myths. High cholesterol is not a disease and there has been no evidence to show it causes disease, although if one is under oxidative stress low-density cholesterol can certainly oxidize if it's present, which is why we take antioxidants like vitamin E and C, and the trace metal selenium. For more information, see the well referenced and aptly titled " The Cholesterol Myths " by the world's foremost cholesterol researcher, Uffe Ravnskov: http://www.ravnskov.nu/cholesterol.htm I don't want to make the posts very long so I'll sign off for now. We can dicuss a few points out of the first half your ebook later if you like, but frankly, given the errors and omissions on the 20 pages or so I have commented on so far, I think you should have made clear at the outset that it is an opinion piece, and represent it only as what you prefer for yourself. Duncan Crow Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.