Guest guest Posted March 1, 2008 Report Posted March 1, 2008 Hi Cam, Thank you so very much!!!! I am so excited to hear about the others in Oklahoma City, I also had my surgery done by Dr. Fulton S. Tompkins, 1967. In fact, my Mom wrote the home care book that he publicized initially. I can't say enough good things about him. I found a wonderful neurosurgeon here, that actually studied in Chicago with the Doctors there doing revisions. He has told me to go to either Chicago or St. Louis for help. At this point, he is checking my progression once a year and stated last year that if it got any worse, I would have to do something. This year the progression was minimal, thank goodness!! So, in the meantime, I am trying to educate myself as to the possibilities that lay ahead. You all seem to be such a great group and so well educated. Thank you for sharing. I will keep reading! Thanks, Debbie ________________________________ From: on behalf of cammaltby Sent: Sat 3/1/2008 4:29 PM Subject: [ ] How to search for a revision specialist Debra, My own methods of searching included a multi-pronged approach. First of all I really did my best to become educated as to what my diagnosis was and what it means in terms of surgical correction. I know this sounds like a lot of work...and it was...but I believe it is necessary in order to make the kind of life altering decisions that this will lead you too. I thought it was too important to let someone else make the decisions as to what kind of surgery I should have, and when/where I should have it when I really couldn't evaluate the choices unless I understood it all. Make sense? So the places I learned the most from were messages boards of like- situated patients. I read literally humdreds of medical abstracts and I used several websites a lot, particularly Spine Universe. You can read research at PubMed (www.pubmed.gov) fairly quickly and after you get the hang of typing in key words you will be amazed at what you can read. Start off with words like " fixed sagittal imbalance " and take it from there. I also read most of the abstracts at the Scoliosis Research Societys site (www.srs.org). If you go through our F_R group site, I believe you will find most of the " ground " I covered in the menu on the left. Racine's " scoliosis links " is a treasure trove of reading for easy access to flatback research. While you are doing all this reading you should be making notes and you will begin to see a pattern develop of specialists that are going to be on your " short list " . For me, I decided there was no way I was going to have surgery with a doctor that did not have a number of these surgeries under his/her belt. I also decided that the critical " you have one chance to get it right " kind of surgery that this is meant that I should consider any surgeon in the USA as a candidate. I honestly don't feel that any patient is doing themselves a service by pre-determining that they will only stay in their home town. Some folks get lucky and find a great doctor close...others have found that travel was the only way to insure they got the skill set they wanted in a doctor. So be sure to do some research on " surgical outcomes " as it realates to the number of times a surgeon does any given procedure and you will see what I am talkng about. Proximity is just a challenge to be overcome...I don't see it as a qualifying characteristic of a surgeon. The other source which I strongly suggest you look at is the " physician locator " at the Scoliosis Research Society's website (www.srs.org). Members of the society MUST devote at least 20% of their practice to scoliosis....all the names you hear on this site and read research from on our particular malady are members. I personally wanted a surgeon who " eats, breathes, and sleeps " adult deformity. After I narrowed my list I also checked their records with their state medical licensing to make sure they were not involved in litigation. Both states I was looking at had easy, open access for this. It may vary by state. I also asked each surgeon if they could connect me with patients who had had the surgery suggested for me. I figured this would get me to the " good stories " ...but I used message boards for finding patients on my own and I contacted them by email and later by phone. I also did some reading on hospitals, ther national rankings, their status as a special center for ortho care or spine care. I looked at mortatlity rates and infection rates....the kind of stuff you hope you don't have to think about, but should. I hope this helps. I wish it was easy and there was a list of doctors that I could send you to, but there isn't one that I am aware of....and honestly the policy of our board is only to recommend a surgeon for an opinion, not for surgery. It may seem like a small distinction but I don't think it is. I am aware of another message board that permits members to recommend their doctor in a format that is not verified by anyone. I know of a patient who wrote gushing/glowing recommendations for her doctor (who did not look good on paper to most of us) before surgery. Her surgery was not a success...and last time I looked the glowing recommendation was still up there. I frankly don't want anyone here at this group to have that kind of responsibilty for another persons health or well being. I think the best that any of us can do is point each other in the direction of information and help them sort through it and find what is best for them. I do believe we are all individuals and that there is no one doctor for everyone. It is as personal a decision as you will make in your entire life. In fact, it will be one of the most important, so I hope that you make it with extreme care. That was along answer wasn't it? Well, SB does make the point right off the bat that the Oklahoma gals have found no one that " checks all the boxes " nearby and they have luckily found StLouis/Bridwell or Lenke to be a good option so that should help you start your search for names right there! (Use the seach feature on this site and search : SB or Kam or Oklahoma City and I think you will be reading for awhile). Hope this helps! Take Care, Cam Quote
Guest guest Posted March 2, 2008 Report Posted March 2, 2008 Kam, Kathy and I had a wonderful lunch date with Dr Tompkins a few months ago. Kathy doesn't live in the OKC area any longer and I actually met her in Dr Bridwell's office the day before my surgery. Kam and I met through the message board and discovered we had some classes at OU together. There is also another lady in the OKC area that wasn't able to attend our lunch with Dr Tompkins. She has had surgery in Chicago and she does not seem to be doing as well as the three of us that had Dr Bridwell. I think we are due for another lunch date soon, so if you would like to email me privately, we can include you in the next one and make it soon! We could even invite Dr Tompkins again. He did my surgery in 1973 and Kam's sometime in the 80s. I think Kathy was also in the 60s. > > Hi Cam, > > Thank you so very much!!!! I am so excited to hear about the others in Oklahoma City, I also had my surgery done by Dr. Fulton S. Tompkins, 1967. In fact, my Mom wrote the home care book that he publicized initially. I can't say enough good things about him. I found a wonderful neurosurgeon here, that actually studied in Chicago with the Doctors there doing revisions. He has told me to go to either Chicago or St. Louis for help. At this point, he is checking my progression once a year and stated last year that if it got any worse, I would have to do something. This year the progression was minimal, thank goodness!! So, in the meantime, I am trying to educate myself as to the possibilities that lay ahead. > > You all seem to be such a great group and so well educated. Thank you for sharing. I will keep reading! > > Thanks, > Debbie > > > > ________________________________ > > From: on behalf of cammaltby > Sent: Sat 3/1/2008 4:29 PM > > Subject: [ ] How to search for a revision specialist > > > > Debra, > > My own methods of searching included a multi-pronged approach. > > First of all I really did my best to become educated as to what my > diagnosis was and what it means in terms of surgical correction. I > know this sounds like a lot of work...and it was...but I believe it > is necessary in order to make the kind of life altering decisions > that this will lead you too. I thought it was too important to let > someone else make the decisions as to what kind of surgery I should > have, and when/where I should have it when I really couldn't evaluate > the choices unless I understood it all. Make sense? > > So the places I learned the most from were messages boards of like- > situated patients. I read literally humdreds of medical abstracts and > I used several websites a lot, particularly Spine Universe. You can > read research at PubMed (www.pubmed.gov) fairly quickly and after you > get the hang of typing in key words you will be amazed at what you > can read. Start off with words like " fixed sagittal imbalance " and > take it from there. I also read most of the abstracts at the > Scoliosis Research Societys site (www.srs.org). > > If you go through our F_R group site, I believe you will find most of > the " ground " I covered in the menu on the left. > Racine's " scoliosis links " is a treasure trove of reading for easy > access to flatback research. > > While you are doing all this reading you should be making notes and > you will begin to see a pattern develop of specialists that are going > to be on your " short list " . For me, I decided there was no way I was > going to have surgery with a doctor that did not have a number of > these surgeries under his/her belt. I also decided that the > critical " you have one chance to get it right " kind of surgery that > this is meant that I should consider any surgeon in the USA as a > candidate. I honestly don't feel that any patient is doing themselves > a service by pre-determining that they will only stay in their home > town. Some folks get lucky and find a great doctor close...others > have found that travel was the only way to insure they got the skill > set they wanted in a doctor. So be sure to do some research > on " surgical outcomes " as it realates to the number of times a > surgeon does any given procedure and you will see what I am talkng > about. Proximity is just a challenge to be overcome...I don't see it > as a qualifying characteristic of a surgeon. > > The other source which I strongly suggest you look at is > the " physician locator " at the Scoliosis Research Society's website > (www.srs.org). Members of the society MUST devote at least 20% of > their practice to scoliosis....all the names you hear on this site > and read research from on our particular malady are members. I > personally wanted a surgeon who " eats, breathes, and sleeps " adult > deformity. After I narrowed my list I also checked their records > with their state medical licensing to make sure they were not > involved in litigation. Both states I was looking at had easy, open > access for this. It may vary by state. > > I also asked each surgeon if they could connect me with patients who > had had the surgery suggested for me. I figured this would get me to > the " good stories " ...but I used message boards for finding patients > on my own and I contacted them by email and later by phone. > > I also did some reading on hospitals, ther national rankings, their > status as a special center for ortho care or spine care. I looked at > mortatlity rates and infection rates....the kind of stuff you hope > you don't have to think about, but should. > > I hope this helps. I wish it was easy and there was a list of doctors > that I could send you to, but there isn't one that I am aware > of....and honestly the policy of our board is only to recommend a > surgeon for an opinion, not for surgery. It may seem like a small > distinction but I don't think it is. > > I am aware of another message board that permits members to recommend > their doctor in a format that is not verified by anyone. I know of a > patient who wrote gushing/glowing recommendations for her doctor (who > did not look good on paper to most of us) before surgery. Her surgery > was not a success...and last time I looked the glowing recommendation > was still up there. I frankly don't want anyone here at this group to > have that kind of responsibilty for another persons health or well > being. I think the best that any of us can do is point each other in > the direction of information and help them sort through it and find > what is best for them. I do believe we are all individuals and that > there is no one doctor for everyone. It is as personal a decision as > you will make in your entire life. In fact, it will be one of the > most important, so I hope that you make it with extreme care. > > That was along answer wasn't it? Well, SB does make the point right > off the bat that the Oklahoma gals have found no one that " checks all > the boxes " nearby and they have luckily found StLouis/Bridwell or > Lenke to be a good option so that should help you start your search > for names right there! (Use the seach feature on this site and > search : SB or Kam or Oklahoma City and I think you will be reading > for awhile). > > Hope this helps! > > Take Care, Cam > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.