Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

A Cover-Up on Agent Orange?

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Guest guest
Posted

(someone said that the CDC is doing the same thing to Chronic Fatigue, MCS

and toxic mold. what do you think?)

NATION: A Cover-Up on Agent Orange?

Critics charge that the Centers for Disease Control sabotaged an

investigation of the defoliant's effects on

Vietnam veterans

Time

7-23-1990

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

----

The medical detectives at the Atlanta-based Centers for Disease

Control have a well-earned reputation for relentlessly tracking down

the causes of such mysterious ailments as Legionnaires' disease. But

the agency's record is in danger of being blemished by a bitter

controversy over Agent Orange, a defoliant containing dioxin, a

suspected carcinogen.

Critics charge that the agency and one of its senior officials,

Dr. Vernon Houk, helped scuttle a $63 million study that might have

determined once and for all whether U.S. troops exposed to Agent

Orange suffered serious damage to their health. Houk maintains he

recommended that the study be canceled on strictly scientific

grounds. Yet there is evidence that the CDC suppressed reports from

the National Academy of Sciences that directly challenged its

position, and spurned extensive help from the Pentagon, leading the

White House to kill the study.

Agent Orange was widely used in Vietnam to strip the thick jungle

canopy that helped conceal enemy forces; only later did scientists

become aware of the potentially dangerous long-term effects of

dioxin, which has produced cancers in animals. The defoliant has

been suspect ever since unknown numbers of Vietnam veterans developed

various cancers or fathered seriously handicapped children. Based on

the inability to prove a conclusive link between those ailments and

Agent Orange, the Reagan and Bush administrations refused to

compensate veterans for all but a few of these health problems. But

critics charge that no clear connections have been established

because no serious large-scale study of exposed veterans has been

done.

The most forceful complaints about the CDC have been leveled by

former Chief of Naval Operations Elmo R. Zumwalt Jr. As the Navy's

top commander in Vietnam, he ordered that Agent Orange be sprayed in

the Mekong Delta region to destroy vegetation from which the Vietcong

regularly launched ambushes against U.S. patrol boats. In 1988

Zumwalt's son Elmo III, a former lieutenant who had served in the

''brown-water Navy,'' died from a rare lymphoma. Zumwalt believes his

son's exposure to Agent Orange was responsible.

Last month Zumwalt told a House subcommittee that the CDC's work

on Agent Orange had been ''a fraud.'' He singled out Houk for having

''made it his mission to manipulate and prevent the true facts from

being determined.'' New York Congressman Ted Weiss, chairman of the

panel, charged in an interview that the CDC appeared to have

''rigged'' its investigation to support its view that a large study

of exposed veterans was not feasible.

Congress authorized the CDC study in 1982 after receiving

thousands of complaints from Vietnam vets about Agent Orange. Houk,

director of the agency's Center for Environmental Health and Injury

Control, was placed in charge. At the White House, a science panel of

the Agent Orange Working Group supervised the CDC's investigation.

The Pentagon assigned its Environmental Support Group to provide the

CDC with Agent Orange spraying records and those of the deployment of

soldiers who may have been exposed.

But the study soon bogged down in a complex dispute over

identifying which soldiers were likely to have been exposed to Agent

Orange. The CDC considered a company of 200 men potentially exposed

if it passed within 1.3 miles of a recently sprayed area. The Army

had fairly detailed records on the daily positions of its companies

during the fighting. There were gaps, but the Pentagon group

repeatedly told the CDC that other documents, such as daily journals

and situation reports, could be used to pinpoint which units had

ventured into areas sprayed with the defoliant. Houk's team

complained that the Pentagon data were too spotty to determine

whether companies had been deployed in normal formations spread over

200 to 300 yards or dispersed over distances of up to 12 miles. It

stubbornly refused to make use of the other records.

By late January 1986, Dr. Carl Keller, chairman of the White House

science panel, and several other of its members concluded that Houk

had already decided that the CDC study was not feasible and was

trying to pin the blame on the Pentagon. To break the impasse,

retired Army Major General Murray was asked by Defense Secretary

Caspar Weinberger to review the Pentagon records. After a four-month

study, Murray thought the records were useful. But as a nonscientist

he did not feel competent to rebut the objections raised by Houk and

the White House scientists. He gave up, agreed that the information

was inadequate and suggested cancellation of the project.

Unknown to Murray and the White House, the Institute of Medicine,

an arm of the National Academy of Sciences, then turned in a

contracted consultants' report to the CDC on the Agent Orange study.

It concluded that the Pentagon group was fully capable of

''determining locations and filling gaps'' in the troop movements and

criticized the CDC's study for excluding many of the veterans most

likely to have been exposed. The CDC never turned the institute's

report over to the White House.

Murray presented his conclusions at a White House meeting on May

27, 1986. The White House moved to kill the study unless other ways

could be found to identify exposed soldiers. Much later, Murray

learned of the institute's report and began to doubt his

recommendation. ''I may have been a babe in the woods,'' he said in

an interview. ''My feeling now is that this whole thing deserves

another look.''

Instead of killing the project outright, the White House panel

accepted a proposal by Houk to take blood tests of 646 Vietnam

veterans, selected on the basis of their probable exposure, to see if

they had elevated blood levels of dioxin. The tests showed that none

had abnormal blood levels -- not surprising, given that the exposure

would have taken place 20 years earlier and that none of those tested

had handled Agent Orange directly.

Though many scientists ridiculed the blood tests, Houk used them

to contend again that the Pentagon records could not be used to

pinpoint exposure to Agent Orange. He recommended canceling the

study; the White House Science Panel agreed, and the Domestic Policy

Council did so in September 1987. This was after $43 million had been

spent.

Once again the White House had acted without having all the facts.

The Institute of Medicine only weeks earlier had written a blistering

review of the CDC's work. It urged that each of the agency's major

conclusions be deleted because the evidence presented by the CDC did

not support them. The White House never received this devastating

report.

Houk insists that his opposition to continuing the project was

based solely on rigorous scientific principles. ''If we could find a

population of people who were exposed in sufficient numbers, we would

have proceeded with our study,'' he says. ''We just simply could not

find them.'' Skeptics like Congressman Weiss suspect that the CDC did

not want to antagonize the Reagan Administration, which was worried

about the huge liability costs if Agent Orange was shown to cause the

veterans' ailments. Whatever the reasons for its failure, the

decision not to complete the study leaves open a vexing problem:

whether Agent Orange will exact a toll on Vietnam vets and their

descendants for generations to come.

Copyright 1990 Time Inc.

Ed Magnuson. Reported by Jay zell/Washington, NATION: A Cover-Up on

Agent Orange? Critics charge that the Centers for Disease Control sabotaged

an investigation of the defoliant's effects on Vietnam veterans. , Time,

07-23-1990, pp 27.

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...