Guest guest Posted August 23, 2007 Report Posted August 23, 2007 Search the archives here using onibasu.com and the keywords andrewhallcutler and NCD or zeolite. There are some very good posts from Andy on the topic. There is an exceptionally good one in the archives of the adult-metal-chelation group, but you would have to join the group to search the archives there. NCD doesn't pass the blood brain barrier. It doesn't even leave the gut. There is no evidence that it will chelate metals, if we are using the work chelate to mean remove metals from the body. Some people report some improvement, which must be from some other unknown mechanism. Some people report adverse effects. But, I'm just a biologist. Search for Andy's posts, he's a PhD chemist. J > > > As a desperate mother, I also wonder if there had been any commentary > or data-driven opinions on a hotly discussed " miracle " chelation > cure, Natural Cellular Defense – a form of zeolite. > > > > The company claims that this (patented) form of zeolite tightly binds > heavy metals in its specially charged lattice, without having an > affinity for " good " minerals. I am unable to find any outside > " technical " assessment of this item, only rebuttals to general > skeptics, by the providers' designated champions (doctors). > > I would very much be interest in a chemist's assessment of the > efficacy of this item to bind mercury. I can not find any claims of > whether it crosses the blood brain barrier. > > Thanks! > > Deb > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 24, 2007 Report Posted August 24, 2007 Andy who is a chemist gave his assesment of this product in old posts. He said it was not a chelator for metals. While it might do " something " in the body, removing metals is not one of them. It does not have the chemistry components of a metal chelator. It is not a sulpher thiol compound. There is a reason you cannot find any outside technical assessment, because it is not the miracle they proclaim. That is not to say it has not helped some people, but we think that is due to the fact that it is volcanic ash, and ash would absorb gut bacteria. Someone tested NCD through DDI and the results did not impress me. It actually contained heavy metals. I think the results are in the files section. Some poeple did report their children getting worse using this product also. For the price...dmsa is a safer bet. > > > As a desperate mother, I also wonder if there had been any commentary > or data-driven opinions on a hotly discussed " miracle " chelation > cure, Natural Cellular Defense – a form of zeolite. > > > > The company claims that this (patented) form of zeolite tightly binds > heavy metals in its specially charged lattice, without having an > affinity for " good " minerals. I am unable to find any outside > " technical " assessment of this item, only rebuttals to general > skeptics, by the providers' designated champions (doctors). > > I would very much be interest in a chemist's assessment of the > efficacy of this item to bind mercury. I can not find any claims of > whether it crosses the blood brain barrier. > > Thanks! > > Deb > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 25, 2007 Report Posted August 25, 2007 There are hundreds of papers in the chemical literature that show that zeolites trap metals. I remember one of the guys in my lab doing research on this back when I was studying for my PhD. Industrially, it's an accpeted way to filter metals from solution in the cleaning of waste effluent. However, I don't think it's a suitable chelator to use in place of DMSA becuase: (a) It's not at all selective for mercury or lead ( I don't see how it gets into and out of the body © I'm not convinced that the product has enough zeolite in it to make a difference. Having said that, several parents see a change so it may do something. If it does anythign at all, my money is on it working in the gut and not in the body. I certainly don't see it as an alternative to DMSA/DMPS. Liam > > > > > > As a desperate mother, I also wonder if there had been any > commentary > > or data-driven opinions on a hotly discussed " miracle " chelation > > cure, Natural Cellular Defense – a form of zeolite. > > > > > > > > The company claims that this (patented) form of zeolite tightly > binds > > heavy metals in its specially charged lattice, without having an > > affinity for " good " minerals. I am unable to find any outside > > " technical " assessment of this item, only rebuttals to general > > skeptics, by the providers' designated champions (doctors). > > > > I would very much be interest in a chemist's assessment of the > > efficacy of this item to bind mercury. I can not find any claims > of > > whether it crosses the blood brain barrier. > > > > Thanks! > > > > Deb > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 25, 2007 Report Posted August 25, 2007 Those of us capable of reading and understanding the chemical literature, and of figuring out how it applies to what happens inside human beings realize that NCD can not either be absorbed or clear any heavy metals systemically. Basically it filters the wastewater inside the intestines, which is excreted in the stool anyway - this really doesn't do any good as far as heavy metal clearance goes. The positive reports sound more like it modulates intestinal microorganisms than that it is a chelator anyway. Andy > > > > > > > > > As a desperate mother, I also wonder if there had been any > > commentary > > > or data-driven opinions on a hotly discussed " miracle " chelation > > > cure, Natural Cellular Defense – a form of zeolite. > > > > > > > > > > > > The company claims that this (patented) form of zeolite tightly > > binds > > > heavy metals in its specially charged lattice, without having an > > > affinity for " good " minerals. I am unable to find any outside > > > " technical " assessment of this item, only rebuttals to general > > > skeptics, by the providers' designated champions (doctors). > > > > > > I would very much be interest in a chemist's assessment of the > > > efficacy of this item to bind mercury. I can not find any claims > > of > > > whether it crosses the blood brain barrier. > > > > > > Thanks! > > > > > > Deb > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 2, 2007 Report Posted September 2, 2007 > > > As a desperate mother, I also wonder if there had been any commentary > or data-driven opinions on a hotly discussed " miracle " chelation > cure, Natural Cellular Defense – a form of zeolite. Yes. In my scientific opinion it does not remove any heavy metals. I am familiar with zeolites and first used them in 1980. > The company claims that this (patented) form of zeolite The patent I saw appeared to cover a specific use, not the zeolite itself. The use was not heavy metal detoxification. > tightly binds > heavy metals in its specially charged lattice, without having an > affinity for " good " minerals. I am unable to find any outside > " technical " assessment of this item, only rebuttals to general > skeptics, by the providers' designated champions (doctors). > > I would very much be interest in a chemist's assessment See my resume at www.noamalgam.com/vita.html for qualifications. > of the efficacy of this item to bind mercury. it has no special affinity for this. > I can not find any claims of > whether it crosses the blood brain barrier. It neither does this nor is it absorbed into the systemic ciruclation from the gastrointestinal tract. If it were injected intraveously it would not cross the BBB. > Thanks! > > Deb Please note that part of the confusion is due to the fact that many people report a positive experience on using the stuff (which disapears promptly on discontinuing it). Their reports sound a lot like it is modulating dysbiosis. It has been used in animal feed for decades. Zeolites are dirt. They are a mined product. They are geologically common enough there is no reason for them to be particularly expensive. Hopefully other products will be available soon so as to reduce the financial damage trying them causes. As long as you realize they don't detox anything and actually do chelate properly there is no reason (other than cost) not to use the stuff if you want to. Andy Quote
Guest guest Posted September 2, 2007 Report Posted September 2, 2007 > > > As long as you realize they [zeolites] don't detox anything and actually do chelate properly there is no reason (other than cost) not to use the stuff if you want to. You don't find it problematic that it is an aluminum based product? Anne Quote
Guest guest Posted September 2, 2007 Report Posted September 2, 2007 I know someone using Liquid Zeolite and their metals test shows metals comming out. It didn't infact take them all out because they had to also ALA. > > > > > > As long as you realize they [zeolites] don't detox anything and > actually do chelate properly there is no reason (other than cost) not > to use the stuff if you want to. > > You don't find it problematic that it is an aluminum based product? > > Anne > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 3, 2007 Report Posted September 3, 2007 The aluminium should be bound into a tight metal-oxide ceramic matrix. This is pretty stable. IMHO, it shouldn't release much aluminium when in the gut. > > > > > > As long as you realize they [zeolites] don't detox anything and > actually do chelate properly there is no reason (other than cost) not > to use the stuff if you want to. > > You don't find it problematic that it is an aluminum based product? > > Anne > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 3, 2007 Report Posted September 3, 2007 Thanks for that. Next question: If one uses NCD and runs a UTM, should aluminum show up? Anne > > > > > > > > > As long as you realize they [zeolites] don't detox anything and > > actually do chelate properly there is no reason (other than cost) > not > > to use the stuff if you want to. > > > > You don't find it problematic that it is an aluminum based product? > > > > Anne > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 3, 2007 Report Posted September 3, 2007 Also note that the DDI results of NCD indicate more than just alumninum in this product. I think the results are still in the files section. Also people could still dump metals on a urine test taking this or any other supplement. People dump metals daily no matter what they take or do. So it's hard to say that the NCD alone is responsible for it. Just my opinion. People I am sure will use it, and that's ok. > > > > > > > > > > > > As long as you realize they [zeolites] don't detox anything and > > > actually do chelate properly there is no reason (other than cost) > > not > > > to use the stuff if you want to. > > > > > > You don't find it problematic that it is an aluminum based > product? > > > > > > Anne > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 3, 2007 Report Posted September 3, 2007 Is the Lead and manganese also tightly bound? > > > > > > > > > As long as you realize they [zeolites] don't detox anything and > > actually do chelate properly there is no reason (other than cost) > not > > to use the stuff if you want to. > > > > You don't find it problematic that it is an aluminum based product? > > > > Anne > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 3, 2007 Report Posted September 3, 2007 I looked at them over on the NCD list. Still not sure what to make of this stuff.... There really do have to be answers. Sadly, those that try to provide them for us are usually part of the marketing hoopla. We have been off of them for quite some time, and I plan to keep it that way. But, I am glad to hear Andy say that they are generally safe.... Anne > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > As long as you realize they [zeolites] don't detox anything > and > > > > actually do chelate properly there is no reason (other than > cost) > > > not > > > > to use the stuff if you want to. > > > > > > > > You don't find it problematic that it is an aluminum based > > product? > > > > > > > > Anne > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 3, 2007 Report Posted September 3, 2007 > > > > > > > > > As long as you realize they [zeolites] don't detox anything and > > actually do chelate properly there is no reason (other than cost) > not > > to use the stuff if you want to. > > > > You don't find it problematic that it is an aluminum based product? > > > > Anne > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 3, 2007 Report Posted September 3, 2007 Thanks, Andy. Would you expect aluminum to show up on an 8 hour UTM test if you used NCD just before and during this 8 hour period? Or would the fact that it had not be released from the metal-oxide ceramic matrix mean that none would appear? Thanks. Anne > > > > > > > > > > > > As long as you realize they [zeolites] don't detox anything and > > > actually do chelate properly there is no reason (other than cost) > > not > > > to use the stuff if you want to. > > > > > > You don't find it problematic that it is an aluminum based product? > > > > > > Anne > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 4, 2007 Report Posted September 4, 2007 > > Is the Lead and manganese also tightly bound? I've only ever worked with pure synththetic zeolites. These are Al - Si - O networks that don't contain lead or manganese. The AL-Si-O network is incredibly stable. Natural zeolites may contain other elements and I'm not sure that these would be as well bound into the network. Large lead and manganese cations would strain the crystal structure and might be removed, though this is not very likely. There are cations assoicated with many zeolites and these are readily ion exchanged. If that's what you're referring to, then these would be released readily in the body. I don't know if the NCD product contains lead or manganese or not, so I can't comment on the dangers. I would have presumed that these elements would have been removed through ion exchange prior to the zeolite being sold? Quote
Guest guest Posted April 5, 2008 Report Posted April 5, 2008 [ ] Re: zeolite, Natural Cellular Defense (NCD) and heavy metal chelation Those of us capable of reading and understanding the chemical literature, and of figuring out how it applies to what happens inside human beings realize that NCD can not either be absorbed or clear any heavy metals systemically. Basically it filters the wastewater inside the intestines, which is excreted in the stool anyway - this really doesn't do any good as far as heavy metal clearance goes. The positive reports sound more like it modulates intestinal microorganisms than that it is a chelator anyway. Andy > > > > > > > > > As a desperate mother, I also wonder if there had been any > > commentary > > > or data-driven opinions on a hotly discussed " miracle " chelation > > > cure, Natural Cellular Defense - a form of zeolite. > > > > > > > > > > > > The company claims that this (patented) form of zeolite tightly > > binds > > > heavy metals in its specially charged lattice, without having an > > > affinity for " good " minerals. I am unable to find any outside > > > " technical " assessment of this item, only rebuttals to general > > > skeptics, by the providers' designated champions (doctors). > > > > > > I would very much be interest in a chemist's assessment of the > > > efficacy of this item to bind mercury. I can not find any claims > > of > > > whether it crosses the blood brain barrier. > > > > > > Thanks! > > > > > > Deb > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 5, 2008 Report Posted April 5, 2008 [ ] Re: zeolite, Natural Cellular Defense (NCD) and heavy metal chelation > > > As a desperate mother, I also wonder if there had been any commentary > or data-driven opinions on a hotly discussed " miracle " chelation > cure, Natural Cellular Defense - a form of zeolite. Yes. In my scientific opinion it does not remove any heavy metals. I am familiar with zeolites and first used them in 1980. > The company claims that this (patented) form of zeolite The patent I saw appeared to cover a specific use, not the zeolite itself. The use was not heavy metal detoxification. > tightly binds > heavy metals in its specially charged lattice, without having an > affinity for " good " minerals. I am unable to find any outside > " technical " assessment of this item, only rebuttals to general > skeptics, by the providers' designated champions (doctors). > > I would very much be interest in a chemist's assessment See my resume at www.noamalgam.com/vita.html for qualifications. > of the efficacy of this item to bind mercury. it has no special affinity for this. > I can not find any claims of > whether it crosses the blood brain barrier. It neither does this nor is it absorbed into the systemic ciruclation from the gastrointestinal tract. If it were injected intraveously it would not cross the BBB. > Thanks! > > Deb Please note that part of the confusion is due to the fact that many people report a positive experience on using the stuff (which disapears promptly on discontinuing it). Their reports sound a lot like it is modulating dysbiosis. It has been used in animal feed for decades. Zeolites are dirt. They are a mined product. They are geologically common enough there is no reason for them to be particularly expensive. Hopefully other products will be available soon so as to reduce the financial damage trying them causes. As long as you realize they don't detox anything and actually do chelate properly there is no reason (other than cost) not to use the stuff if you want to. Andy Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.