Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 Yes, Marilyn, thank you so much for developing the community. We may need help in the " gut " department, but we have wonderful hearts. PJ > > Dear Marilyn, > > Thank you for developing this amazing list. > It in itself is a healing. supportive and nurturing and generous. > Many thanks for sending your speech-- I hope this will become an > annual tradition. If we all lived closer, what an SCD/BTVC > Anniversary Party e could have! Music! Food! Dogs & Cats! > With appreciation, > > Ruth > > > > > > > Speech given by Marilyn L. Alm > to the Kiwanis Club of Algiers > 9 April 2003 in New Orleans, Louisiana > > Good evening. I've been told that the topic of my > speech tonight is supposed to be " A Holistic > Approach to Treating Some Gut Disorders " . > Actually, it's " A Dietary Approach. " Gut > disorders, including constipation, diarrhea, > Crohn's Disease, and Ulcerative Colitis affect on > the order of 60 to 70 million people worldwide. > They account for almost 200,000 deaths, 10 > million hospitalizations (13 percent of all > hospitalizations), and over 50 million office > visits to physicians, but they are, despite all > the advertisements on TV for Maalox, Ex-lax, > Imodium A-D and other OTC drugs, one of the least talked about. > > Gut disorders are essentially a taboo subject in > North American and Western European cultures. How > do we know this? Profanity is usually linked to > taboo subjects, and if you think about it, most > of the profanity we see scrawled as graffiti or > which assails our ears on the street is related > to religion, sex, and bodily functions. > > What exactly are some of these gut disorders? > Crohn's disease causes inflammation in the lower > part of the small intestine, although it can > affect any part of the digestive tract. > Ulcerative colitis causes inflammation and ulcers > in the large intestine. Irritable bowel syndrome > (IBS) is characterized by recurring abdominal > discomfort or pain, bloating, and altered bowel > function – such as constipation, diarrhea, or > alternating constipation and diarrhea. > > I've perused an awful lot of web sites and books > regarding these disorders over the last 27 years. > Almost all of them, including the Crohn's and > Colitis Foundation of America state that diet has > nothing to do with these diseases. In fact, the > Times-Picayune[1] ran an article a couple of > weeks ago which stated unequivocally that diet > could do nothing to help the nearly 3000 > Louisiana children who suffer from Crohn's > Disease. To my mind, the idea that the food we > eat has no effect on the very organs intended to > digest it for our use is pretty foolish. Dr. J.O. > Hunter, in an article in Lancet, the British > medical journal, confirms this fact, as does Dr. > Hoffman of New York City. Other Lancet > articles also state that persons with gut > disorders frequently have intolerances to corn, > wheat, milk, potatoes and rye. What these > substances have in common are complex > carbohydrates, not gluten. Yet the gluten-free > diet popularized in the last 40 or so years as > the gut diet, yields variable results, > perpetuating the myth that diet has nothing to do > with the management of gut disorders. > > Dr. Sidney Valentine Haas, coauthor with his son, > Dr. Merrill P. Haas, of Management of Celiac > Disease, which was published in 1951, might not > be surprised at his successors in the field of > gastroenterology, but he would probably be > saddened by the amount of pain and suffering > caused by failure to recognize a simple fact > stated by Dr. Gee: " We must never forget > that what the patient takes beyond his ability to > digest does harm. " The Haas' book, based on many > years of clinical experience, documented the > experience of these doctors in treating and > curing hundreds of cases of celiac disease. > > The Specific Carbohydrate Diet as delineated in > Elaine Gottschall's Breaking the Vicious Cycle > came about because in 1958, the Gottschalls took > their eight year old daughter Judy to see Dr. > Haas. Judy had ulcerative colitis. Years of > medication had done nothing. Her condition was > deteriorating. Surgical removal of her colon > seemed to be the only option. Dr. Haas, then in > his 90s, asked one simple question: " What has > this child been eating? " The result was that Judy > Gottschall was placed on the Specific > Carbohydrate Diet. Two years later, she was > symptom free. Nearly forty years later, she eats > about 85-90% SCD, and remains symptom free, with no medications. > > Mrs. Gottschall, though, wanted to know why the > diet worked. Unfortunately, she could not consult > with Dr. Haas, as he had passed away. So, in her > late 40s, she decided to return to college and > get the knowledge she needed to find out why. And > she did, earning a bachelor's degree in biology, > magna cum laude from Montclair State College in > New Jersey. She also did work in graduate studies > in nutrition at Rutgers. After a move to Canada, > she obtained a Master of Science degree in from > the Department of Cell Biology at the University > of Western Ontario, where she spent four years > investigating the effects of various sugars on > the digestive tract. Not wanting to see others > suffer as her daughter had, she wrote and > published first Food and the Gut Reaction, and > then Breaking the Vicious Cycle, now in its tenth edition. > > But why does the Specific Carbohydrate Diet work? > Some gut diseases are the consequence of an > overgrowth and imbalance of intestinal microbial > flora. By altering our diet, we can bring our > system back into balance, healing our digestive > tracts and restoring proper absorption. > > The intestinal tract is an astoundingly rich > ecosystem, home to over 400 bacterial species. > Some are harmless, and others not. In a healthy > person's gut, these various communities of microbes balance each other. > > Yet this balance can easily be upset by what we > eat. Overgrowths can occur, triggered by overuse > of antacids, reduced stomach acidity due to > aging, weakening of the immune system through > malnutrition or poor diet, or antibiotic therapy. > > Carbohydrates, contrary to the gluten theory, > play an enormous role in our gut health. If > carbohydrates are not fully digested and > absorbed, they feed the bacteria we host, causing a population > explosion. > > Bacterial overgrowth inhibits absorption, which > leads to even more undigested carbs. Excessive > protective mucus is produced, which also inhibits > digestion and absorption. Eventually, though, the > mucus-making cells become exhausted, and the > intestinal surface is laid bare. It may be > ulcerated. As even more carbohydrates are left in > the gut, they cause water and nutrients to be > pulled from the body into the colon, resulting in > chronic diarrhea. Absorption is further hindered > as diarrhea increases the rate with which food > travels through the gut. Truly a vicious cycle. > > So the question then is, " How do we break the vicious cycle? " > > And the answer lies in Dr. Gee's > statement, " We must never forget that what the > patient takes beyond his ability to digest does > harm. " By changing one's diet to what one can > absorb, the gut can heal. The symptoms disappear, one by one. > > What, then, is the Specific Carbohydrate Diet? > > People with IBD can't fully break down complex > chains of carbohydrates. Thus, the Specific > Carbohydrate Diet excludes most complex > carbohydrates, such as processed sugars, grains, > potatoes and most legumes. Even the slightest bit > of these carbohydrates can cause symptoms to flare up. > > Yet grains are imbedded in our thought patterns > as food. Wheat is the staff of life. Who ever > heard of Creole or Cajun food that wasn't served > on a bed of rice? Grain even infuses our > patriotism, " O beautiful for spacious skies, for > amber waves of grain… " . It's almost un-American > not to eat grain – and if we are not eating grain > and potatoes, what are we to eat? That's easy. We eat: > * Fresh or frozen beef, lamb, poultry, pork, fish, eggs > * Vegetables-fresh or frozen, raw or cooked > (with no added sugar or starch) > * Homemade yogurt fermented at least 24 hours > * Natural cheeses with little or no lactose, > such as Cheddar, Colby, havarti, Swiss, dry curd cottage cheese > * Fruits-fresh or frozen, raw or cooked; (with no added sugar) > * Salad and cooking oils > * Honey, nuts and nut flours, spices > * Very dry wine, occasional gin, rye, Scotch, bourbon, vodka, etc. > What we DON'T eat includes: > * Grains, including bread, rice, pasta, cereal, and corn products > * Processed meats, like hot dogs, cold cuts, fast food > * Potatoes (or starchy roots) > * Milk, margarine, soy products > * Chocolate (alas!), starches, added sugar, > including corn syrup, cane sugar, molasses > * Beer, sherry, cordials, liqueurs or brandy > > SCD, though, is not a diet which you can follow > Sunday through Thursday, and then go out and eat > whatever you want on Friday and Saturday. Strict > adherence is critical since that one little bite > of pasta, a single Saltine cracker, even a little > bit of grain flour in gravy or coating a veal > cutlet is a veritable smorgasbord to the bacteria in your gut. > > I recall, for instance, a year ago Christmas Eve. > The kitchen of the restaurant where we went > messed up my order, coating the meat in flour. > New to SCD, I figured a little bit of flour > wouldn't hurt. After weeks of no trouble, I > barely made it home before the diarrhea hit, and > I spent the next four hours in the bathroom. The > next time a restaurant did not do my order > correctly, I sent it back. I'm not generally > confrontational, but nothing is worth those hours of pain. > > In addition to strict adherence, SCD also > requires label reading, because our food is > becoming more and more processed and so, more > adulterated. Years ago, vanilla extract, which > adds a lovely flavor to SCD ice cream, smoothies > and baked goods (made from finely ground nuts, > not grain flour), was just vanilla bean and > alcohol. The new McCormick's vanilla, however, > has high-fructose corn syrup in it! Packaged > grated cheese from the market often has potato > starch as an anti-caking agent. Glance at a tuna > fish label in the market, and you'll see " packed > in spring water " . What could be a problem with > fish packed in water? Read the fine print. It's > water, vegetable broth and tuna. And that > vegetable broth almost always contains both soy > and MSG. Even worse, sometimes, labels lie. > Canned foods, even if they don't say so on the > label, often contain sugar and starch, to make the food taste better, > you know! > > The Specific Carbohydrate Diet can be > challenging, requiring a significant change in > lifestyle for the patient and his or her family. > No longer can you stop at Burger Thing or Taco > Whistle on your way home from work. You have to plan ahead and cook. > > Yet it can be done. And lest you think that > taking away grains and potatoes and convenience > foods means dull, boring meals, my parents, Ross > and Marge Lessentine, have been coming over for > an SCD dinner on Monday nights. > > How about starting with a tossed salad of green > leaf lettuce, vine-ripened heirloom tomatoes, and > crimini mushrooms topped with grated cheddar > cheese and your choice of homemade ranch > dressing, homemade honey-mustard dressing, or > homemade Italian dressing? Then move on to > grilled boneless chicken breast Florentine, > topped with freshly grated parmesan cheese and > thick, home-cooked tomato sauce. And then let's > wind up with something a little light – egg nog > ice cream topped with fresh Bing cherries. > > Or maybe we'll start with nice, ripe slices of > California avocadoes, interlaced with tomato > wedges and topped with old-fashioned creamy-style > French dressing, made with oil, vinegar, and > spices. Next, a piled high platter of flat-style > beef and bean burritos, with lettuce, tomato, and > sour dressing. And afterwards, a butter-pecan satin pudding. > > For a casual night, how about a Creole style pot > roast, simmered for hours with a bit of red wine > and spices, with sides of mushrooms and baby new > carrots? For dessert, fresh strawberries. > > This week, we started with grilled Portobello > mushrooms topped with a large mound of crab claw > meat and a creamy lemon-pepper sauce. Then we > went to lightly steamed new asparagus, and > thick-cut pork chops seasoned with homemade > blackened seasoning. For dessert, we finished up > the leftover eggnog ice cream, and added some blue berries for good > measure. > > A side benefit is that because I make everything, > it's easy to customize a dish, as for my mother, who is on a salt-free > diet. > There is one problem to mentioning all this yummy > food. Thankfully, everyone here has already > eaten, or I might have the lot of you following me home! > > Still, the question which comes to mind when > someone claims that it's possible to cure these > diseases which threaten not only our lives but > the quality of them is, " If there is a diet which > can put these scourges into remission, especially > a diet which allows such fabulous food, why > aren't the doctors shouting it from the rooftops? " > > Let's take a look at some figures, provided by > the Crohn's and Colitis Foundation of America: > * It is estimated that up to 1,000,000 people > in the United States suffer from inflammatory bowel disease. > * In 1990, the total annual medical costs for > IBD patients was estimated at 1- 2 billion dollars. > Reducing this cost in both money and suffering > would seem to be a priority. Yet the CCFA and > many gastroenterologists continue to insist that > diet has nothing to with gut diseases. Why? > > The answer, sadly, may be that medicines for gut > diseases are highly profitable. So is cheap food. > * Proctor and Gamble's Asacol, one of the > primary drugs for these diseases, made $300 million in 2002. > * Also in 2002, revenue from Remicade, > another IBD drug, increased 80 percent, to $379 million. > * Many CCFA corporate donors include the > manufacturers of these and similar drugs. As a > consequence, former CCFA members who have > regained their health through SCD are inclined to > wonder if those donations are why the > organization continues to maintain that > unprofitable diet has nothing to do with gut disease. > According to Schlosser's Fast Food Nation, > Americans spent $110 billion in 2000 on fast > food, more than on higher education, personal > computers, software or new cars. America's > service economy creates 90 percent of all new > jobs, and most of those are in the fast food > realm. The golden arches are better known around > the world now than the Christian cross, according > to Schlosser. And every product made by this > industry is illegal on the Specific Carbohydrate > Diet. Is it possible that there is a link between > the rise of fast food, and the proliferation of > gut diseases? Surely not – the experts assure us > that diet has nothing to do with disease! > > Doctors also say, " But there are no studies! " and > conveniently forget Dr. Haas' Management of > Celiac Disease, based on decades of observation > and evaluation of more than 600 cases. Then > again, most medical research is funded by > pharmaceutical firms who have everything to gain > from patentable drugs and nothing to gain from > assisting people to eat a biologically appropriate diet. > > So the bottom line would seem to be money. > Physicians and surgeons, pharmaceutical firms, > the CCFA, and all the fast food companies in the > world stand to lose significant revenue if people > do something as radical as changing their diets > to healthy food which they can digest. > > There's another problem with managing gut > diseases by diet. In our modern world, we want > things now, fast, yesterday, even. We don't like > taking time. Very few people wish to acknowledge > that it has taken many years for them to become > ill, and that it may take months or years to > heal. As a consequence, entirely too many people > would rather pop a dozen pills than give up French fries and wheat > bread. > > Yet many will do anything to live a normal life. > There are over a thousand members of an Internet > community dedicated to the implementation of the > Specific Carbohydrate Diet. A thousand active > members, that is, with an average span on the > list of about a year. People come, learn how to > implement SCD, regain their health, and then go > on about their lives. Some of us stay to teach. > > True, SCD is not an easy diet. Still, > approximately 90% of the people with Crohn's > Disease who follow it regain their health. > Approximately 75% of the people with Ulcerative > Colitis also heal. That's a far better percentage > than any of the drugs currently on the market. > > How did I find SCD? Backwards, actually. My > husband Harry and I have had dachshunds and cats > for most of our married life. Most people find a > healthy diet for themselves, then look for one > for their pets. We did the reverse. In 1998, we > became mom and dad to a pair of gorgeous > long-haired red dachshunds, Shadow and Sunny. We > were determined they would get the best food > money could buy – our vet and the breeder > recommended several kinds of kibble. But despite > really small servings of this premium, and mostly > grain kibble, Shadow and Sunny both ended up very > overweight, with soft, mushy stools. I was > frustrated, because this was the same situation I > was in – eating very small amounts, continuously > hungry, and still gaining weight. > > Through research, I learned about > species-appropriate diets, that is diets made of > the kinds of foods an animal evolved to eat. > > My dachshunds lost weight on a biologically appropriate grain-free diet. > > So, I began a search for a grain-free diet for humans. > > I found it in the Specific Carbohydrate Diet. > > When I first read Breaking the Vicious Cycle, I > didn't think I had IBD, so it was a shock to > discover the urgency and soft, mushy stools I had > suffered with for 25 years was not " normal " as I > had been told by various physicians. Nor was my > overweight because I " refused to get a little > exercise by pushing myself away from the table. " > It, too, was a symptom of undiagnosed malabsorption. > > I have now been following SCD for 17 months. > Without limiting what I eat, I have, by healing > my gut, lost 120 pounds. For the first time in > many years, I'm confident that I will re-achieve > a healthy weight. I no longer have the problems > which made it necessary to carry spare > underclothes in my purse, and a plastic bag to > put the soiled ones in. I don't enter a building > and immediately look to see where the restrooms > are and I'm no longer acquainted with every rest > stop between here and wherever. > > The Specific Carbohydrate Diet has truly given me > my life back. The time I spend cooking is minimal > compared to the amount of time I used to spend in > restrooms, doing extra laundry, or generally > feeling too ill to accomplish anything. > > Will the SCD ever become the first standard > treatment of gut diseases, rather than the last > resort of desperate people whom conventional > medicine has failed? I don't know. It's a dream. > > In a write up on SCD in the Wall Street Journal > last autumn, the Journal noted, " The failure of > the IBD diet to gain widespread acceptance within > the medical community is a lesson in the grim > financial reality of medical research. Doctors > don't accept treatments that aren't validated by > controlled studies, and drug companies, which > fund most medical research, pay to study pills, not diets. " > > And yet, this method of treatment does not, as > its detractors hope, die. Dr. Sidney Valentine > Haas passed the torch to Elaine Gottschall. Now > 82, Mrs. Gottschall regularly updates Breaking > the Vicious Cycle, and participates in areas > which support treatment of gut disease by diet. > She has trained several assistants to carry the > torch into the future. And it is to be hoped that > one day, when a patient first goes to his or her > health care professional with a gut problem, that > after carefully noting symptoms and doing > whatever tests seem indicated, the physician of > the future will ask, " And what have you been eating? " > > ---------- > > BTVC-SCD is now more than 1800 strong, averaging > 2000 messages a month. You, the members, from > Australia to the US to Canada to the UK, to India > and beyond have made this group what it is: > dedicated to the support of the Specific > Carbohydrate Diet as it was written by Elaine > Gottschall, who passed on to us what she learned > from Dr. Sidney Valentine Haas. > > Thank you, to all of the people who come here for help and who end up > helping. > > Thank you to all of the longer-term and dedicated > members who spend so many hours each week > answering questions and helping others. > > Thank you for making this group a healing place. > > I like to think of both Dr. Haas and Elaine > looking down and smiling as their healing legacy moves forward into > the future. > > Happy Third Birthday to BTVC-SCD!! > > — Marilyn > New Orleans, Louisiana, USA > Undiagnosed IBS since 1976, SCD since 2001 > Darn Good SCD Cook > No Human Children > Shadow & Sunny Longhair Dachshund > Babette the Foundling Beagle > > > > > Ruth J. Hirsch, MA, LMFT > Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist > • > 44 Main Street > Kingston, NY 12401 > partner-in-healing@... > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 29, 2010 Report Posted September 29, 2010 At 07:10 AM 9/24/2010, you wrote: Yes, Marilyn, thank you so much for developing the community. We may need help in the " gut " department, but we have wonderful hearts. PJ, Amen to that! Heart is where healing begins! — Marilyn New Orleans, Louisiana, USA Undiagnosed IBS since 1976, SCD since 2001 Darn Good SCD Cook No Human Children Shadow & Sunny Longhair Dachshund Babette the Foundling Beagle Quote
Guest guest Posted September 29, 2010 Report Posted September 29, 2010 Thank you for developing this amazing list. It in itself is a healing. supportive and nurturing and generous. Many thanks for sending your speech-- I hope this will become an > annual tradition. If we all lived closer, what an SCD/BTVC Anniversary Party e could have! Music! Food! Dogs & Cats! LOL, indeed! Oh, can you imagine what it would be like to have a whole bunch of us booked on the same Rocky Mountaineer train, driving their chefs crazy? — Marilyn New Orleans, Louisiana, USA Undiagnosed IBS since 1976, SCD since 2001 Darn Good SCD Cook No Human Children Shadow & Sunny Longhair Dachshund Babette the Foundling Beagle Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.