Guest guest Posted July 13, 2010 Report Posted July 13, 2010 From http://www.drmirkin.com/morehealth/G171.htm " The dominant theory today is that depression is caused by low brain levels of the neurotransmitters, serotonin and norepinephrine. The drugs such as Paxil, Prozac and Zoloft that treat depression are supposed to raise brain levels of these neurotransmitters. Doctors can also raise brain levels of serotonin by prescribing pills containing T3, a hormone produced by peripheral tissue from T4, which is produced by the thyroid gland. (1) They also prescribe T3 by itself or together with antidepressants. Depression is common among people who have too much or too little thyroid hormone. Doctors usually treat low thyroid function with T4 also known as Levothroid and many people become even more depressed. They treat this depression by prescribing T3 as well as T4. " I think the main problem of being on drugs and taking HC and thyroid is that the brain then gets conflicting biochemical messages. One may even counteract the other. That said, I know you can NOT quit ADs cold turkey. http://theroadback.org/ has been highly recommended on many groups. Check it out. Barb > > This one is for the forum members especially. > > Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > about your experience on the subject. > > > When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would > help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation > of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a > person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They > never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly > unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I > learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you > guys are: > > a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? > Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > helped your healing? > c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to > tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not > psychiatric, to stop taking AD? > > > And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can > taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? > > This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a > medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the > serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled > simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while > he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. > > > Please your opinions on the subject! > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 13, 2010 Report Posted July 13, 2010 From http://www.drmirkin.com/morehealth/G171.htm " The dominant theory today is that depression is caused by low brain levels of the neurotransmitters, serotonin and norepinephrine. The drugs such as Paxil, Prozac and Zoloft that treat depression are supposed to raise brain levels of these neurotransmitters. Doctors can also raise brain levels of serotonin by prescribing pills containing T3, a hormone produced by peripheral tissue from T4, which is produced by the thyroid gland. (1) They also prescribe T3 by itself or together with antidepressants. Depression is common among people who have too much or too little thyroid hormone. Doctors usually treat low thyroid function with T4 also known as Levothroid and many people become even more depressed. They treat this depression by prescribing T3 as well as T4. " I think the main problem of being on drugs and taking HC and thyroid is that the brain then gets conflicting biochemical messages. One may even counteract the other. That said, I know you can NOT quit ADs cold turkey. http://theroadback.org/ has been highly recommended on many groups. Check it out. Barb > > This one is for the forum members especially. > > Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > about your experience on the subject. > > > When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would > help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation > of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a > person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They > never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly > unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I > learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you > guys are: > > a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? > Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > helped your healing? > c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to > tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not > psychiatric, to stop taking AD? > > > And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can > taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? > > This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a > medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the > serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled > simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while > he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. > > > Please your opinions on the subject! > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 13, 2010 Report Posted July 13, 2010 From http://www.drmirkin.com/morehealth/G171.htm " The dominant theory today is that depression is caused by low brain levels of the neurotransmitters, serotonin and norepinephrine. The drugs such as Paxil, Prozac and Zoloft that treat depression are supposed to raise brain levels of these neurotransmitters. Doctors can also raise brain levels of serotonin by prescribing pills containing T3, a hormone produced by peripheral tissue from T4, which is produced by the thyroid gland. (1) They also prescribe T3 by itself or together with antidepressants. Depression is common among people who have too much or too little thyroid hormone. Doctors usually treat low thyroid function with T4 also known as Levothroid and many people become even more depressed. They treat this depression by prescribing T3 as well as T4. " I think the main problem of being on drugs and taking HC and thyroid is that the brain then gets conflicting biochemical messages. One may even counteract the other. That said, I know you can NOT quit ADs cold turkey. http://theroadback.org/ has been highly recommended on many groups. Check it out. Barb > > This one is for the forum members especially. > > Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > about your experience on the subject. > > > When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would > help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation > of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a > person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They > never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly > unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I > learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you > guys are: > > a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? > Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > helped your healing? > c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to > tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not > psychiatric, to stop taking AD? > > > And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can > taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? > > This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a > medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the > serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled > simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while > he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. > > > Please your opinions on the subject! > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 13, 2010 Report Posted July 13, 2010 If one decides to wean themselves of their AD and if they are taking T3, and if they want an alternative to help replace the AD on their way to healing, SAM-E, particularly in the 400mg dose taken on an empty stomach twice a day (first AM and mid afternoon) is a very potent and natural mood elevator/stabilizer. There are lots of levels of seriousness for why someone is on AD in the first place. Some people were prescribed this by well-meaning but uniformed docs who prescribed AD instead of getting to the real cause of issues/symptoms with a patient. other people are on AD because of suicidal thoughts/feelings and profound feelings of hopelessness. I think many of us know which catagory we fall in. I have been prescribed AD repeatedly in the past by docs who failed to diagnose my hypothyroid. In the beginning (15 to 20 years ago) I took the prescriptions. Later I just never filled them since I knew it was not the problem! if you didn't feel suicidal and like life wasn't worth going on then it would indeed be dangerous to stop your AD on your own without being under a doctor's care in changing your medical route. But I was one of those who knew darn well that I was getting a placebo kind of treatment when my TSH was "normal" over and over and the docs didn't know what else to do with me. I heard all the bogus nonsense about me kidding myself of how much i was really eating, about stress, about me just over-stating the issues, etc. I counted every calorie and still gained weight, i had no energy and my hair was falling out, that was enough to make anyone a tad on the down side i would say....so presto...here's a prescription for AD ....now go home. There are a lot of us who had this senario for years and years of not being properly diagnosed or given any real remedy for our very real hypo symptoms....so for those in that category who have now found real answers and are embarking on real treatment options then the AD is just going to get in the way of that treatment. But if you have other issues (none of us are black and white medically....we all have a mix of various health issues) and you are on your AD because of serious depression issues then, yes it would be foolish to just stop your AD meds without a doctors guidance and supervision. All of that said, for those who are confident that the AD was not correctly prescribed in the first place, or who suffer from the lethargy-type depression that goes hand in hand with hypo the SAM-E is one option that can bridge the gap until the thyroid meds can catch up. I can absolutely tell when I don't take the SAM-E. Hopefully I will be able to get my RT3 problem reversed and clear the RT3 out and then i can reevaluate whether I still need to take the SAM-E or not, but for now it is making a big difference. definitely a tough subject, Sharon Remember! Dolls are people, too....have you hugged your dolls today? Visit my website! http://ohyoubeautifuldoll.webs.com--- Subject: Re: To all forum members: a question about ADTo: RT3_T3 Date: Tuesday, July 13, 2010, 11:27 AM From http://www.drmirkin.com/morehealth/G171.htm"The dominant theory today is that depression is caused by low brain levels of the neurotransmitters, serotonin and norepinephrine. The drugs such as Paxil, Prozac and Zoloft that treat depression are supposed to raise brain levels of these neurotransmitters. Doctors can also raise brain levels of serotonin by prescribing pills containing T3, a hormone produced by peripheral tissue from T4, which is produced by the thyroid gland. (1) They also prescribe T3 by itself or together with antidepressants. Depression is common among people who have too much or too little thyroid hormone. Doctors usually treat low thyroid function with T4 also known as Levothroid and many people become even more depressed. They treat this depression by prescribing T3 as well as T4."I think the main problem of being on drugs and taking HC and thyroid is that the brain then gets conflicting biochemical messages. One may even counteract the other. That said, I know you can NOT quit ADs cold turkey.http://theroadback.org/ has been highly recommended on many groups. Check it out.Barb>> This one is for the forum members especially.> > Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > about your experience on the subject. > > > When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would > help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation > of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a > person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They > never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly > unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I > learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you > guys are:> > a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment?> Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > helped your healing?> c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to > tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not > psychiatric, to stop taking AD? > > > And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can > taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here?> > This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a > medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the > serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled > simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while > he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. > > > Please your opinions on the subject!> Quote
Guest guest Posted July 13, 2010 Report Posted July 13, 2010 > >And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can >taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? I have no experience on the interaction between AD and thyroid. I agree that AD's are doled out too often rather than sorting out the source of the issue, it's an easy way of getting patients to go away, they become numb emotionally and cease caring about getting well again Some of these ADs are very addictive in terms of giving severe depression as you try and get off them as a withdrawal symptom from the drug, this makes people think the drug is helping them! Paxil is particularly bad for this due to a short half life and there is interesting information out there on swapping to a different SSRi with a longer half life to make the weaning process easier, most Drs won't tell you this. Nick -- for more information on RT3 and Thyroid Resistance go to www.thyroid-rt3.com Quote
Guest guest Posted July 13, 2010 Report Posted July 13, 2010 I don't know if may input will be of any use but my case seems quite different from others I have read in the thyroid groups. I have had lots of " psychiatric " problems, mostly panic attacks, agoraphobia, panic disorder and OCD. I was given Anafranil and it actually helped a lot (although it had unpleasant side effects, like always being sleepy). But strangely enough helped also with things which don't seem " psychological " really, like it made my hair loss stop and made my hair look beautiful (before I took it my hair was dry and used to fall). My particular theory is that it helped my adrenals, among other things because I slept most of the time (I used to spent every weekend in bed sleeping, only waking up to eat a bit and go to the bathroom). I have the feeling it allowed my body to rest... When all this happened neither me nor anyone had a clue I could have thyroid or adrenal problems. With time I was able to reduce the dose of Anafranil (much before even suspecting thyroid/adrenal problems) and keep some of the benefits. For quite a while I have been on the ridiculous dose of 10 mg Anafranil and I find very difficult to wean of it. I have tried several times and I always have the same dizzy feelings and I get panicky I won't make it without it. So I have done all the T3-only treatment on these 10 mg Anafranil and I am still on it. I am actually hoping to find myself a bit more stable to try to wean again. I just wanted to add that I have very strong and fast " mental " reactions to T3, to me it feels like it goes directly to me head and removes all the anxiety making me happy... I mostly felt it at the beginning (I felt it also with Armour, but I think it was the T3 on it), now my system seems to have gone used to it (still feel it sometimes though). Despite these positive feelings I am finding difficult to reach stability (my mood and my general well-being are going up and down), so I am hanging on to my old friend Anafranil. Hope I can wean soon! Quote
Guest guest Posted July 13, 2010 Report Posted July 13, 2010 > Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > about your experience on the subject. I never heard this, but I was already in process of coming off of Effexor. I know that benzos lower cortisol so you can see how that would be counter-effective to taking HC if one already has low cortisol. It is not that the patients are addicted to ADs, it is that they become habituated (addiction would imply that more is needed to feel good). The body actually adjusts to function with the AD (poison) in it, so there is a backlash as one reduces the amount of AD (poison) she is taking. In addition, dose reductions have a cumulative effect. If I reduce my dose by 10 mg and hold it for a week, and then reduce by another 10 mg, my body reacts to a 20 mg reduction ... and I end up with severe anxiety, light-headedness, and brain-zaps. > a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? I did not stop, I could not stop - cold turkey off of Effexor could have been deadly. I am not willing to make myself fragile - I am working this protocol in parallel with reducing my AD. When I have successfully gotten off of that I will turn my attention to either the Gabapentin or the Xanax ... and I am leading my doctors who really don't know. > Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > helped your healing? I continue to taper-down my Effexor 9 mg versus an overall 150 mg current dosage and I hold it for a good month or so until I " feel " like I can take another reduction. In the meantime I'm resolving an RT3 issue and getting my tanked sex hormones balanced. Off and on I have felt fabulous and even when I don't feel fabulous I usually feel pretty good. But right now I feel kind of hypo because my RT3 is blocking my receptors. But I think you can feel good, if not optimized, with this protocol and as you feel better, stronger, you can taper off the ADs and benzos. Getting your diet and nutrition in order is a huge factor in being able to get off the meds. Highly recommended for getting off of AD's - The Antidepressant Solution by ph Glenmullen, M.D. Peaches_ii Quote
Guest guest Posted July 13, 2010 Report Posted July 13, 2010 > Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > about your experience on the subject. I never heard this, but I was already in process of coming off of Effexor. I know that benzos lower cortisol so you can see how that would be counter-effective to taking HC if one already has low cortisol. It is not that the patients are addicted to ADs, it is that they become habituated (addiction would imply that more is needed to feel good). The body actually adjusts to function with the AD (poison) in it, so there is a backlash as one reduces the amount of AD (poison) she is taking. In addition, dose reductions have a cumulative effect. If I reduce my dose by 10 mg and hold it for a week, and then reduce by another 10 mg, my body reacts to a 20 mg reduction ... and I end up with severe anxiety, light-headedness, and brain-zaps. > a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? I did not stop, I could not stop - cold turkey off of Effexor could have been deadly. I am not willing to make myself fragile - I am working this protocol in parallel with reducing my AD. When I have successfully gotten off of that I will turn my attention to either the Gabapentin or the Xanax ... and I am leading my doctors who really don't know. > Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > helped your healing? I continue to taper-down my Effexor 9 mg versus an overall 150 mg current dosage and I hold it for a good month or so until I " feel " like I can take another reduction. In the meantime I'm resolving an RT3 issue and getting my tanked sex hormones balanced. Off and on I have felt fabulous and even when I don't feel fabulous I usually feel pretty good. But right now I feel kind of hypo because my RT3 is blocking my receptors. But I think you can feel good, if not optimized, with this protocol and as you feel better, stronger, you can taper off the ADs and benzos. Getting your diet and nutrition in order is a huge factor in being able to get off the meds. Highly recommended for getting off of AD's - The Antidepressant Solution by ph Glenmullen, M.D. Peaches_ii Quote
Guest guest Posted July 13, 2010 Report Posted July 13, 2010 > Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > about your experience on the subject. I never heard this, but I was already in process of coming off of Effexor. I know that benzos lower cortisol so you can see how that would be counter-effective to taking HC if one already has low cortisol. It is not that the patients are addicted to ADs, it is that they become habituated (addiction would imply that more is needed to feel good). The body actually adjusts to function with the AD (poison) in it, so there is a backlash as one reduces the amount of AD (poison) she is taking. In addition, dose reductions have a cumulative effect. If I reduce my dose by 10 mg and hold it for a week, and then reduce by another 10 mg, my body reacts to a 20 mg reduction ... and I end up with severe anxiety, light-headedness, and brain-zaps. > a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? I did not stop, I could not stop - cold turkey off of Effexor could have been deadly. I am not willing to make myself fragile - I am working this protocol in parallel with reducing my AD. When I have successfully gotten off of that I will turn my attention to either the Gabapentin or the Xanax ... and I am leading my doctors who really don't know. > Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > helped your healing? I continue to taper-down my Effexor 9 mg versus an overall 150 mg current dosage and I hold it for a good month or so until I " feel " like I can take another reduction. In the meantime I'm resolving an RT3 issue and getting my tanked sex hormones balanced. Off and on I have felt fabulous and even when I don't feel fabulous I usually feel pretty good. But right now I feel kind of hypo because my RT3 is blocking my receptors. But I think you can feel good, if not optimized, with this protocol and as you feel better, stronger, you can taper off the ADs and benzos. Getting your diet and nutrition in order is a huge factor in being able to get off the meds. Highly recommended for getting off of AD's - The Antidepressant Solution by ph Glenmullen, M.D. Peaches_ii Quote
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2010 Report Posted July 14, 2010 " It is not that the patients are addicted to ADs, it is that they become habituated (addiction would imply that more is needed to feel good). The body actually adjusts to function with the AD (poison) in it, so there is a backlash as one reduces the amount of AD (poison) she is taking. In addition, dose reductions have a cumulative effect. If I reduce my dose by 10 mg and hold it for a week, and then reduce by another 10 mg, my body reacts to a 20 mg reduction ... and I end up with severe anxiety, light-headedness, and brain-zaps. " Sorry but this is not corre3ct. There are two forms of addiction, mental and physical. Benzo's are addictive in BOTH respoects as are more drugs. Most street drug addicts no longer get HIGH or even feel good from the drugs after a certain point. Then it becomes a physical addiciton. I am somewhat of a well educated person on this subject as I have been addicted to alcohol, cocaine, Heroin, and methamphetamine. Of these Heroin is the MOST physically addictive. I almost died fom stoppign heroin but NO ONE would ever tell me I should nto stop it. And do nto tell me because these Benzo;s are prescriptions they are ANY differnt as they are not. ALL my addictions were to try to feel NORMAL when I was so hypo and suicidal. Isn;t that why we take benzo's? HMM see a problem here? My addictions were NO differnt and until I got the HORMONES right I was always an addictive personality. I no longer have that issue.. imagine that a TRULY cured addict and alcoholic. One that can actually take a drink and nto drink to excess. ALL because I fixed th ehormone issues. NO it si not easy especially whne oyu have as many hormones off as I had, but it CAN be done. And step ONE is getting your mind clear of the DRUGS so you cna feel what the hromones are doing. T3 is HUGE in optimizing neurotransmitters. It cannto work right if ther eis a drug controlling these things. http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/NaturalThyroidHormonesADRENALS/ http://faqhelp.webs.com/ http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/RT3_T3/ http://www.thyroid-rt3.com/ http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HypoPets/ http://artisticgrooming.net/ > It is not that the patients are addicted to ADs, it is that they become habituated (addiction would imply that more is needed to feel good). The body actually adjusts to function with the AD (poison) in it, so there is a backlash as one reduces the amount of AD (poison) she is taking. In addition, dose reductions have a cumulative effect. If I reduce my dose by 10 mg and hold it for a week, and then reduce by another 10 mg, my body reacts to a 20 mg reduction ... and I end up with severe anxiety, light-headedness, and brain-zaps. > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2010 Report Posted July 14, 2010 " It is not that the patients are addicted to ADs, it is that they become habituated (addiction would imply that more is needed to feel good). The body actually adjusts to function with the AD (poison) in it, so there is a backlash as one reduces the amount of AD (poison) she is taking. In addition, dose reductions have a cumulative effect. If I reduce my dose by 10 mg and hold it for a week, and then reduce by another 10 mg, my body reacts to a 20 mg reduction ... and I end up with severe anxiety, light-headedness, and brain-zaps. " Sorry but this is not corre3ct. There are two forms of addiction, mental and physical. Benzo's are addictive in BOTH respoects as are more drugs. Most street drug addicts no longer get HIGH or even feel good from the drugs after a certain point. Then it becomes a physical addiciton. I am somewhat of a well educated person on this subject as I have been addicted to alcohol, cocaine, Heroin, and methamphetamine. Of these Heroin is the MOST physically addictive. I almost died fom stoppign heroin but NO ONE would ever tell me I should nto stop it. And do nto tell me because these Benzo;s are prescriptions they are ANY differnt as they are not. ALL my addictions were to try to feel NORMAL when I was so hypo and suicidal. Isn;t that why we take benzo's? HMM see a problem here? My addictions were NO differnt and until I got the HORMONES right I was always an addictive personality. I no longer have that issue.. imagine that a TRULY cured addict and alcoholic. One that can actually take a drink and nto drink to excess. ALL because I fixed th ehormone issues. NO it si not easy especially whne oyu have as many hormones off as I had, but it CAN be done. And step ONE is getting your mind clear of the DRUGS so you cna feel what the hromones are doing. T3 is HUGE in optimizing neurotransmitters. It cannto work right if ther eis a drug controlling these things. http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/NaturalThyroidHormonesADRENALS/ http://faqhelp.webs.com/ http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/RT3_T3/ http://www.thyroid-rt3.com/ http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HypoPets/ http://artisticgrooming.net/ > It is not that the patients are addicted to ADs, it is that they become habituated (addiction would imply that more is needed to feel good). The body actually adjusts to function with the AD (poison) in it, so there is a backlash as one reduces the amount of AD (poison) she is taking. In addition, dose reductions have a cumulative effect. If I reduce my dose by 10 mg and hold it for a week, and then reduce by another 10 mg, my body reacts to a 20 mg reduction ... and I end up with severe anxiety, light-headedness, and brain-zaps. > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2010 Report Posted July 14, 2010 " It is not that the patients are addicted to ADs, it is that they become habituated (addiction would imply that more is needed to feel good). The body actually adjusts to function with the AD (poison) in it, so there is a backlash as one reduces the amount of AD (poison) she is taking. In addition, dose reductions have a cumulative effect. If I reduce my dose by 10 mg and hold it for a week, and then reduce by another 10 mg, my body reacts to a 20 mg reduction ... and I end up with severe anxiety, light-headedness, and brain-zaps. " Sorry but this is not corre3ct. There are two forms of addiction, mental and physical. Benzo's are addictive in BOTH respoects as are more drugs. Most street drug addicts no longer get HIGH or even feel good from the drugs after a certain point. Then it becomes a physical addiciton. I am somewhat of a well educated person on this subject as I have been addicted to alcohol, cocaine, Heroin, and methamphetamine. Of these Heroin is the MOST physically addictive. I almost died fom stoppign heroin but NO ONE would ever tell me I should nto stop it. And do nto tell me because these Benzo;s are prescriptions they are ANY differnt as they are not. ALL my addictions were to try to feel NORMAL when I was so hypo and suicidal. Isn;t that why we take benzo's? HMM see a problem here? My addictions were NO differnt and until I got the HORMONES right I was always an addictive personality. I no longer have that issue.. imagine that a TRULY cured addict and alcoholic. One that can actually take a drink and nto drink to excess. ALL because I fixed th ehormone issues. NO it si not easy especially whne oyu have as many hormones off as I had, but it CAN be done. And step ONE is getting your mind clear of the DRUGS so you cna feel what the hromones are doing. T3 is HUGE in optimizing neurotransmitters. It cannto work right if ther eis a drug controlling these things. http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/NaturalThyroidHormonesADRENALS/ http://faqhelp.webs.com/ http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/RT3_T3/ http://www.thyroid-rt3.com/ http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HypoPets/ http://artisticgrooming.net/ > It is not that the patients are addicted to ADs, it is that they become habituated (addiction would imply that more is needed to feel good). The body actually adjusts to function with the AD (poison) in it, so there is a backlash as one reduces the amount of AD (poison) she is taking. In addition, dose reductions have a cumulative effect. If I reduce my dose by 10 mg and hold it for a week, and then reduce by another 10 mg, my body reacts to a 20 mg reduction ... and I end up with severe anxiety, light-headedness, and brain-zaps. > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2010 Report Posted July 14, 2010 Prior to starting thyroid meds I was always depressed. I had no problem getting off Prozac but I did have a hard time weaning off Cymbalta and Zoloft. I got a lot of brain buzzes, strange feeling for sure and there were a few times I thought I was stuck and would always have to take them. It does take a while to wean off some of the AD's but I couldn't stand the side effects they were having on my sex life. Finally I came across Stop the thyroid madness and started seeing one of the symptoms of hypo was depression and told my doc to test my thyroid. Of course it was in range but after reading these forums and Janie's book I insisted on getting started on natural thyroid meds. I was off the AD's for about a month, feeling like poo but I had my sex drive back;-) When I started taking thyroid meds I felt better almost overnight, no depression, more energy. After taking the thyroid meds with T3/T4 for over a year though I found I kept having to raise the dose and then found out about rt3 issues. I had that tested and sure enough there was an issue with the T4 clogging my receptors. Now on T3, into my 8th week towards clearance and though I've had a bump or two along the way I'm feeling a lot better. Kem in Eugene > > This one is for the forum members especially. > > Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > about your experience on the subject. > > > When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would > help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation > of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a > person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They > never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly > unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I > learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you > guys are: > > a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? > Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > helped your healing? > c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to > tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not > psychiatric, to stop taking AD? > > > And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can > taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? > > This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a > medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the > serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled > simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while > he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. > > > Please your opinions on the subject! > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2010 Report Posted July 14, 2010 Well, I think the mods tell you what is BEST to do. But if you're suicidal, probably just trying to stop them would be not be a good idea as it can take a while to optimize your t3 meds. The problem I think is you can't HEAL your adrenals (if you have adrenal problems) or get totally optimized while on AD. But t3 WILL increase your serotonin and other neurotransmitters, so you may have to pay close attention and wean off AD as you get onto t3 so you don't actually get too much serotonin/dopamine, etc. Personally, if possible, I would try to switch over to something like 5htp or St 's Wort, both of which are proven to help with depression/anxiety or whatever else you're taking AD for and then when you're off the AD, start the t3. I've tapered off ADs before, too. It was Prozac and a long time ago, like 10 years ago, but it did take me a little while. It wasn't horrid, though, like getting off of benzos. And I didn't even know about 5htp or St 's Wort. If I'd tried subbing those for the AD, I may have had no problems at all! Kathleen > Kem in Eugene > > > > > > This one is for the forum members especially. > > > > Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > > before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > > about your experience on the subject. > > > > > > When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would > > help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation > > of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a > > person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They > > never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly > > unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I > > learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you > > guys are: > > > > a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? > > Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > > helped your healing? > > c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to > > tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not > > psychiatric, to stop taking AD? > > > > > > And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can > > taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? > > > > This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a > > medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the > > serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled > > simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while > > he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. > > > > > > Please your opinions on the subject! > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 18, 2010 Report Posted July 18, 2010 Why are ADs bad for healing adrenals? Liz > > > > > > This one is for the forum members especially. > > > > > > Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > > > before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > > > about your experience on the subject. > > > > > > > > > When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would > > > help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation > > > of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a > > > person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They > > > never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly > > > unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I > > > learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you > > > guys are: > > > > > > a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? > > > Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > > > helped your healing? > > > c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to > > > tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not > > > psychiatric, to stop taking AD? > > > > > > > > > And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can > > > taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? > > > > > > This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a > > > medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the > > > serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled > > > simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while > > > he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. > > > > > > > > > Please your opinions on the subject! > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 18, 2010 Report Posted July 18, 2010 Because they change the neurotransmitters in your brain. They muddle the symptoms, and many of them LOWER or raise cortiosl. The ones that raise cortils will continue to beat your adrneals no matter how much HC you take. The ones that lower it wil supress adrenal funciton. http:www.nthadrenalsweb.com http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/NaturalThyroidHormonesADRENALS/ http://faqhelp.webs.com/ http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/RT3_T3/ http://www.thyroid-rt3.com/ http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HypoPets/ http://artisticgrooming.net/ > Why are ADs bad for healing adrenals? > Liz > > >>> >>>> This one is for the forum members especially. >>>> >>>> Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills >>>> before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you >>>> about your experience on the subject. >>>> >>>> >>>> When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would >>>> help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation >>>> of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a >>>> person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They >>>> never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly >>>> unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I >>>> learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you >>>> guys are: >>>> >>>> a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? >>>> Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually >>>> helped your healing? >>>> c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to >>>> tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not >>>> psychiatric, to stop taking AD? >>>> >>>> >>>> And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can >>>> taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? >>>> >>>> This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a >>>> medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the >>>> serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled >>>> simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while >>>> he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. >>>> >>>> >>>> Please your opinions on the subject! >>>> >>>> >>> >> > > > > ------------------------------------ > > We are not medical professionals here, just patients sharing our experiences. Please use this information with the help of a competent doctor. Yahoo! Groups Links > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 18, 2010 Report Posted July 18, 2010 Thanks, Val. How do they raise cortisol? Is it that they stimulate ACTH? I am currently going down on strattera (Norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor) because I suspected this, but I cannot find any info on it. Liz > >>> > >>>> This one is for the forum members especially. > >>>> > >>>> Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > >>>> before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > >>>> about your experience on the subject. > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would > >>>> help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation > >>>> of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a > >>>> person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They > >>>> never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly > >>>> unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I > >>>> learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you > >>>> guys are: > >>>> > >>>> a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? > >>>> Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > >>>> helped your healing? > >>>> c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to > >>>> tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not > >>>> psychiatric, to stop taking AD? > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can > >>>> taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? > >>>> > >>>> This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a > >>>> medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the > >>>> serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled > >>>> simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while > >>>> he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> Please your opinions on the subject! > >>>> > >>>> > >>> > >> > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > We are not medical professionals here, just patients sharing our experiences. Please use this information with the help of a competent doctor. Quote
Guest guest Posted July 18, 2010 Report Posted July 18, 2010 http://www-bmu.psychiatry.cam.ac.uk/publications/chamberlain07ato.pdf http:www.nthadrenalsweb.com http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/NaturalThyroidHormonesADRENALS/ http://faqhelp.webs.com/ http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/RT3_T3/ http://www.thyroid-rt3.com/ http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HypoPets/ http://artisticgrooming.net/ > Thanks, Val. > How do they raise cortisol? Is it that they stimulate ACTH? I am currently going down on strattera (Norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor) because I suspected this, but I cannot find any info on it. > Liz > > >>>>> >>>>> >>>>>> This one is for the forum members especially. >>>>>> >>>>>> Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills >>>>>> before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you >>>>>> about your experience on the subject. >>>>>> >>>>>> >>>>>> When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would >>>>>> help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation >>>>>> of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a >>>>>> person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They >>>>>> never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly >>>>>> unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I >>>>>> learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you >>>>>> guys are: >>>>>> >>>>>> a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? >>>>>> Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually >>>>>> helped your healing? >>>>>> c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to >>>>>> tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not >>>>>> psychiatric, to stop taking AD? >>>>>> >>>>>> >>>>>> And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can >>>>>> taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? >>>>>> >>>>>> This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a >>>>>> medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the >>>>>> serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled >>>>>> simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while >>>>>> he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. >>>>>> >>>>>> >>>>>> Please your opinions on the subject! >>>>>> >>>>>> >>>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>> >>>> >>> >>> >>> ------------------------------------ >>> >>> We are not medical professionals here, just patients sharing our experiences. Please use this information with the help of a competent doctor. Quote
Guest guest Posted July 18, 2010 Report Posted July 18, 2010 Thanks and congrats on the adrenal board. It looks amazing!!! > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>>> This one is for the forum members especially. > >>>>>> > >>>>>> Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > >>>>>> before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > >>>>>> about your experience on the subject. > >>>>>> > >>>>>> > >>>>>> When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would > >>>>>> help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation > >>>>>> of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a > >>>>>> person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They > >>>>>> never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly > >>>>>> unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I > >>>>>> learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you > >>>>>> guys are: > >>>>>> > >>>>>> a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? > >>>>>> Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > >>>>>> helped your healing? > >>>>>> c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to > >>>>>> tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not > >>>>>> psychiatric, to stop taking AD? > >>>>>> > >>>>>> > >>>>>> And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can > >>>>>> taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? > >>>>>> > >>>>>> This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a > >>>>>> medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the > >>>>>> serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled > >>>>>> simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while > >>>>>> he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. > >>>>>> > >>>>>> > >>>>>> Please your opinions on the subject! > >>>>>> > >>>>>> > >>>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>> > >>> > >>> ------------------------------------ > >>> > >>> We are not medical professionals here, just patients sharing our experiences. Please use this information with the help of a competent doctor. Quote
Guest guest Posted July 18, 2010 Report Posted July 18, 2010 Hi Sharon, how long did you take the SaM-e until you felt an effect. My ND started me on this one week ago and I am desperate for a positive response. How does it make you feel, do you feel really good (not depressed at all) or does it just make you feel able to cope a bit better? The 400mg dose that you are on is that 400mg elemental or 200mg? I am on 200mg elemental 3 times a day before meals. Thanks Kat > > > > This one is for the forum members especially. > > > > Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > > before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > > about your experience on the subject. > > > > > > When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would > > help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation > > of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a > > person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They > > never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly > > unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I > > learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you > > guys are: > > > > a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? > > Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > > helped your healing? > > c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to > > tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not > > psychiatric, to stop taking AD? > > > > > > And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can > > taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? > > > > This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a > > medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the > > serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled > > simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while > > he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. > > > > > > Please your opinions on the subject! > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 18, 2010 Report Posted July 18, 2010 Hi Kat The original thread was a dew days ago so it might take her a while to see this. I resurrected it. But, I took Sam-e and I have to say I didn't notice much difference in mood. I have heard that others had a big response from it though. You could try tyrosine. It raises Dopamine and NE levels in the brain, or at least it is supposed to if your body uses it right. Were you on ADs? Liz > > > > > > This one is for the forum members especially. > > > > > > Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > > > before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > > > about your experience on the subject. > > > > > > > > > When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would > > > help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation > > > of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a > > > person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They > > > never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly > > > unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I > > > learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you > > > guys are: > > > > > > a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? > > > Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > > > helped your healing? > > > c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to > > > tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not > > > psychiatric, to stop taking AD? > > > > > > > > > And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can > > > taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? > > > > > > This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a > > > medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the > > > serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled > > > simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while > > > he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. > > > > > > > > > Please your opinions on the subject! > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 18, 2010 Report Posted July 18, 2010 How about benzos - how do they interfere with t3/cortef/etc? I started taking them (2.5mg valium) per day to help control the panic attacks that started when my adrenals were giving out. While things are getting more balanced - rt3 is cleared out(it was a 12), now on 75mg cytomel and 30mg cortef, 1 tab florinef, ferritin up to 45(not there yet I know, but working on it - it was 10 when I started all of this) - I still get panic :-( It is MUCH better than it was - when I was on no cortisol/thyroid/etc and falling apart, I would wake in the middle of the night with a full panic attacks - I guess that was when cortisol was falling the lowest. I would dread going to sleep at night. Not that the days back then were that great either. :-p So now I am steadily improving, but still don't have panic issue solved and it is really limiting. Doc has suggested trying an ssri, but as I am reading all of these posts that does not sound like the right answer. I was also freaked that in the course of finding the " right one " it could trigger more panic - yeah, no thanks. The panic started with the hormone derailing. Any thoughts on what might still need adjusting or things to try? Anyone else have horrible panic that came with the hormone problems? Did it get better eventually? Thanks! > >>> > >>>> This one is for the forum members especially. > >>>> > >>>> Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > >>>> before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > >>>> about your experience on the subject. > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would > >>>> help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation > >>>> of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a > >>>> person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They > >>>> never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly > >>>> unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I > >>>> learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you > >>>> guys are: > >>>> > >>>> a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? > >>>> Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > >>>> helped your healing? > >>>> c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to > >>>> tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not > >>>> psychiatric, to stop taking AD? > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can > >>>> taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? > >>>> > >>>> This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a > >>>> medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the > >>>> serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled > >>>> simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while > >>>> he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> Please your opinions on the subject! > >>>> > >>>> > >>> > >> > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > We are not medical professionals here, just patients sharing our experiences. Please use this information with the help of a competent doctor. Quote
Guest guest Posted July 18, 2010 Report Posted July 18, 2010 Hello! I am not sure about the benzo question. I wonder that, too, but my guess is that it probably would not stress the adrenals as much as a norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor does, because NRIs constantly activate the adrenal gland. I don't think benzos do that. But, I am also not sure if the suppress the cortisol, either. If you are not sure about taking an ssri for anxiety, you could try taking LDN (Low dose naltrexone). I take it for autoimmune issues, but it has the subtle effect of calming me down. It supposedly elevates the body's natural endorphins. I know that ADs aren't good for the adrenals, but in my opinion, if you are really depressed, sometimes you just have to do ADs (that is just me, though). However, you sound more anxious, rather than depressed, so maybe you could try something else first? Liz > > >>> > > >>>> This one is for the forum members especially. > > >>>> > > >>>> Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > > >>>> before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > > >>>> about your experience on the subject. > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>>> When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would > > >>>> help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation > > >>>> of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a > > >>>> person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They > > >>>> never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly > > >>>> unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I > > >>>> learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you > > >>>> guys are: > > >>>> > > >>>> a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? > > >>>> Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > > >>>> helped your healing? > > >>>> c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to > > >>>> tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not > > >>>> psychiatric, to stop taking AD? > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>>> And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can > > >>>> taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? > > >>>> > > >>>> This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a > > >>>> medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the > > >>>> serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled > > >>>> simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while > > >>>> he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>>> Please your opinions on the subject! > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>> > > >> > > > > > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > > > We are not medical professionals here, just patients sharing our experiences. Please use this information with the help of a competent doctor. Quote
Guest guest Posted July 19, 2010 Report Posted July 19, 2010 Val said that the benzos have a negative effect as they as they both lower cortisol and are physically and psychologically addicting. Kerry > > >>> > > >>>> This one is for the forum members especially. > > >>>> > > >>>> Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > > >>>> before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > > >>>> about your experience on the subject. > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>>> When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would > > >>>> help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation > > >>>> of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a > > >>>> person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They > > >>>> never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly > > >>>> unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I > > >>>> learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you > > >>>> guys are: > > >>>> > > >>>> a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? > > >>>> Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > > >>>> helped your healing? > > >>>> c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to > > >>>> tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not > > >>>> psychiatric, to stop taking AD? > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>>> And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can > > >>>> taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? > > >>>> > > >>>> This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a > > >>>> medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the > > >>>> serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled > > >>>> simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while > > >>>> he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>>> Please your opinions on the subject! > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>> > > >> > > > > > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > > > We are not medical professionals here, just patients sharing our experiences. Please use this information with the help of a competent doctor. Quote
Guest guest Posted July 19, 2010 Report Posted July 19, 2010 Val said that the benzos have a negative effect as they as they both lower cortisol and are physically and psychologically addicting. Kerry > > >>> > > >>>> This one is for the forum members especially. > > >>>> > > >>>> Val an diane wrote in a thread before that you should stop anti-depressant pills > > >>>> before starting HC and t3 treatment. This one is new to me. I wanted to ask you > > >>>> about your experience on the subject. > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>>> When I was first diagnosed with CFS they offcourse told me that taking AD would > > >>>> help to cure the exhastion. Obviously it didn't help. But because the situation > > >>>> of being bedridden for months without forseeable cure was SO terrible for a > > >>>> person like me who used to be completly healthy until then, I took the AD. They > > >>>> never actually helped with the depression but getting off them in my emotionaly > > >>>> unstable situation seemed too risky. So, I am still taking them. But now I > > >>>> learned they can damage the hormonal healing process. So, my questions to you > > >>>> guys are: > > >>>> > > >>>> a) Did you stop taking AD before starting treatment? > > >>>> Do you have any clue from your experience how stopping taking them actually > > >>>> helped your healing? > > >>>> c) Don't you think it is too risky and even maybe a little bit irresponsible to > > >>>> tell a person suffering fron depression, even if the reason is hormonal and not > > >>>> psychiatric, to stop taking AD? > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>>> And for the mods: can you please explain to me specifically as possible how can > > >>>> taking AD damage the protocol recommanded here? > > >>>> > > >>>> This is the first time since joining this forum that I actually question a > > >>>> medical advice giving here by the mods. I know that the hormonal system and the > > >>>> serotonin system are related, but not that they can't be handeled > > >>>> simultaniously! How much courage you need to tell a person to get off AD while > > >>>> he clearly suffers from depression, I just don't get it. > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>>> Please your opinions on the subject! > > >>>> > > >>>> > > >>> > > >> > > > > > > > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > > > We are not medical professionals here, just patients sharing our experiences. Please use this information with the help of a competent doctor. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.