Guest guest Posted October 4, 2006 Report Posted October 4, 2006 The drs say there is no difference in reoccurance but I know a lot of ladies that would totally disagree with that. I have known several that have had lumpectomies only for the cancer to reoccur and then they have to have a mastectomy. Hugs nne Breast Cancer Patients Soul Mates for Life http://www.geocities.com/chucky5741/breastcancerpatients.html BreastCancerStories.com http://www.breastcancerstories.com/content/view/433/161/ Angel Feather Loomer www.angelfeatherloomer.blogspot.com Check out my other ornaments at www.geocities.com/chucky5741/bcornament.html Lots of info and gifts at: www.cancerclub.com Re: Hello...new and decisions Hi lyn, Glad to hear the chemo is working to shrink that tumor! Lumpectomy & radiation vs. mastectomy is a big decision. There are alot of factors to weigh. There is no difference in recurrence rates regardless which you choose. For some women, they have more peace of mind with a mastectomy. I had a lumpectomy first, but margins weren't clean. Because of where the tumor was (under my nipple) the doctor couldn't guarantee clean margins if I did a re-excision. I ended up with a mastectomy and I feel good about that decision. They found more DCIS. Also, because of where my tumor was, the radiation would have been very close to my heart. Let us know how your Nov. 1st appt goes and what your doctor recommends. I think the statistic is over 80% of women diagnosed with bc have no family history. I'm one of those 80% women. take care, ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG Free Edition. Version: 7.1.407 / Virus Database: 268.12.12/462 - Release Date: 10/3/2006 Quote
Guest guest Posted October 4, 2006 Report Posted October 4, 2006 Its a hard choice but remember even if you have a mastectomy, depending on your individual case, you could still need radiation. I had a mastectomy and in the beginning the onc was talking radiation but then changed his mind. Hugs nne Breast Cancer Patients Soul Mates for Life http://www.geocities.com/chucky5741/breastcancerpatients.html BreastCancerStories.com http://www.breastcancerstories.com/content/view/433/161/ Angel Feather Loomer www.angelfeatherloomer.blogspot.com Check out my other ornaments at www.geocities.com/chucky5741/bcornament.html Lots of info and gifts at: www.cancerclub.com Hello...new and decisions Hello, My name is lyn and I was diagnosed with IDC on July 13th 2006. I am having chemo 1st (AC+T) and have just completed my 4th of 6 treatments. By the MRI the tumor was 4.8CM and growing quickly. I am Estrogren and Progesterone Positive (+3) but Her2/neu negative. Nodes were swollen but shrank to normal a few days after the 1st chemo. The tumor is shrinking dramatically (almost undetectable by feel) so my oncologist feels I should be good for a lumpectomy. I am most concerned about radiation. I meet with the surgeon on November 1st to discuss options. If it is a lumpectomy and radiation vs a mastectomy and reconstruction but no radiation I am not sure what I will do. I am 42 with no risk factors and no family history. This has been quite a shock. Thanks lyn ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG Free Edition. Version: 7.1.407 / Virus Database: 268.12.12/462 - Release Date: 10/3/2006 Quote
Guest guest Posted October 4, 2006 Report Posted October 4, 2006 Hello, lyn, I had 11 months of chemo first, until my my oncologist said the lump was small enough for a lumpectomy (from 10cms down to 2.75cms). Then my surgeon said if the lumpectomy didn't get clean margins he'd have to go in again ... so I had a mastectomy. And radiation - we are treating this thing aggressively! And now I'm on chemo tablets and Arimidex. Compared with chemo I found that radiation was easy. It made my skin a little red, but they gave me nice aquaeous cream to put on it, and I got tired, but not as much as with the chemo. I didn't consider reconstruction was anything I wanted - I'm 63 and don't want any avoidable surgery. You'll make your own decisions, I know, but I wanted to let you know radiation can be easy. Love, Margery. ============================================ margery@... in North Herts, UK ============================================ > Hello...new and decisions > > Hello, > > My name is lyn and I was diagnosed with IDC on July 13th 2006. > I am having chemo 1st (AC+T) and have just completed my 4th of 6 > treatments. > > By the MRI the tumor was 4.8CM and growing quickly. I am Estrogren > and Progesterone Positive (+3) but Her2/neu negative. Nodes were > swollen but shrank to normal a few days after the 1st chemo. > > The tumor is shrinking dramatically (almost undetectable by feel) so > my oncologist feels I should be good for a lumpectomy. > > I am most concerned about radiation. I meet with the surgeon on > November 1st to discuss options. > > If it is a lumpectomy and radiation vs a mastectomy and > reconstruction but no radiation I am not sure what I will do. > > I am 42 with no risk factors and no family history. This has been > quite a shock. > > Thanks > > lyn > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 4, 2006 Report Posted October 4, 2006 I didn't have any family history either, and according to statistics, almost 70 percent of breast cancers don't have any family history. Radiation can make you tired, but they do provide topical creams to keep the burning to a minimum. I had bilateral mastectomy due to the fact I had lobular carcinoma in one breast and atypical ductal hyperplasia in the other. It would have been a matter of time...There are many options following a mastectomy regarding reconstruction. Check out s Hopkins website, which is where I had my surgery and reconstruction. Katharine _____ From: breastcancer2 [mailto:breastcancer2 ] On Behalf Of r18252000 Sent: Wednesday, October 04, 2006 12:19 PM To: breastcancer2 Subject: Hello...new and decisions Hello, My name is lyn and I was diagnosed with IDC on July 13th 2006. I am having chemo 1st (AC+T) and have just completed my 4th of 6 treatments. By the MRI the tumor was 4.8CM and growing quickly. I am Estrogren and Progesterone Positive (+3) but Her2/neu negative. Nodes were swollen but shrank to normal a few days after the 1st chemo. The tumor is shrinking dramatically (almost undetectable by feel) so my oncologist feels I should be good for a lumpectomy. I am most concerned about radiation. I meet with the surgeon on November 1st to discuss options. If it is a lumpectomy and radiation vs a mastectomy and reconstruction but no radiation I am not sure what I will do. I am 42 with no risk factors and no family history. This has been quite a shock. Thanks lyn Quote
Guest guest Posted October 4, 2006 Report Posted October 4, 2006 I didn't have any family history either, and according to statistics, almost 70 percent of breast cancers don't have any family history. Radiation can make you tired, but they do provide topical creams to keep the burning to a minimum. I had bilateral mastectomy due to the fact I had lobular carcinoma in one breast and atypical ductal hyperplasia in the other. It would have been a matter of time...There are many options following a mastectomy regarding reconstruction. Check out s Hopkins website, which is where I had my surgery and reconstruction. Katharine _____ From: breastcancer2 [mailto:breastcancer2 ] On Behalf Of r18252000 Sent: Wednesday, October 04, 2006 12:19 PM To: breastcancer2 Subject: Hello...new and decisions Hello, My name is lyn and I was diagnosed with IDC on July 13th 2006. I am having chemo 1st (AC+T) and have just completed my 4th of 6 treatments. By the MRI the tumor was 4.8CM and growing quickly. I am Estrogren and Progesterone Positive (+3) but Her2/neu negative. Nodes were swollen but shrank to normal a few days after the 1st chemo. The tumor is shrinking dramatically (almost undetectable by feel) so my oncologist feels I should be good for a lumpectomy. I am most concerned about radiation. I meet with the surgeon on November 1st to discuss options. If it is a lumpectomy and radiation vs a mastectomy and reconstruction but no radiation I am not sure what I will do. I am 42 with no risk factors and no family history. This has been quite a shock. Thanks lyn Quote
Guest guest Posted October 4, 2006 Report Posted October 4, 2006 Hi lyn. Great news about the tumor shrinking . I had the choice a year ago between lumpectomy or masectomy . I chose the lumpectomy,then had chemo and radiation. Radiation was a piece of cake compared to the chemo,I went back to work during the radiation. However if I had to do it all over again I would have a double masectomy because now I worry about it coming back and I don't want to have to go through everything all over again. I chose that way because I didn't think I could handle losing my breasts along with everything else I was going to have to deal with - mainly losing my hair. It was hard,but I'm a much stronger person than I thought and I could have handled it. Good luck to you with whatever decision you make. Stay strong and laugh as much as you can. Sheri --------------------------------- Yahoo! Messenger with Voice. Make PC-to-Phone Calls to the US (and 30+ countries) for 2¢/min or less. Quote
Guest guest Posted October 4, 2006 Report Posted October 4, 2006 Hi lyn, As nne said, there are other factors that determine whether you need radiation. You may need radiation on your lymph node area if you had positive nodes. After your surgery your doctors will make a recommendation. take care, Quote
Guest guest Posted October 4, 2006 Report Posted October 4, 2006 Thanks. I wish I could know ahead of time and if I could avoid radiation with a mastectomy I am seriously considering that option. Then I have to decide if I want to go thru reconstruction or not. The early decisions were pretty easy. Since the tumor was so large and growing so fast I started heavy chemo quickly. 12 days after being diagnosed was my first chemo, and it reversed the growth very quickly but now facing decisions again. Ah for a crystal ball that worked. Thanks lyn > > Hi lyn, > > As nne said, there are other factors that determine whether you > need radiation. You may need radiation on your lymph node area if you > had positive nodes. After your surgery your doctors will make a > recommendation. > > take care, > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 4, 2006 Report Posted October 4, 2006 Thanks. My hair has not been a big deal for me. I had long red hair and had a party (beer, bbq and a hair trimmer) with my buddies and we took it down to about 1/4 inch. I am not doing a wig and go without a hat or scarf everywhere but work. Losing a breast to a mastectomy is not a huge concern for me. I am not sure if my fear of radiation is completely rational but it scares me more than a mastectomy and more than chemo. Part of the equation for me is what my breast will look like after a lumpectomy since it is on the top part of my breat near the nipple and they may need to remove a section since it was spread out. If I am going to have to have plastic surgery anyway why not just take the damn thing off anyway. > > Hi lyn. Great news about the tumor shrinking . I had the choice a year ago between lumpectomy or masectomy . I chose the lumpectomy,then had chemo and radiation. Radiation was a piece of cake compared to the chemo,I went back to work during the radiation. However if I had to do it all over again I would have a double masectomy because now I worry about it coming back and I don't want to have to go through everything all over again. I chose that way because I didn't think I could handle losing my breasts along with everything else I was going to have to deal with - mainly losing my hair. It was hard,but I'm a much stronger person than I thought and I could have handled it. Good luck to you with whatever decision you make. Stay strong and laugh as much as you can. Sheri > > --------------------------------- > Yahoo! Messenger with Voice. Make PC-to-Phone Calls to the US (and 30+ countries) for 2¢/min or less. > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 4, 2006 Report Posted October 4, 2006 Thanks Margery, I am trying to work thru and understand what my fears about radiation are. I know that some comes from a friend of mine that is a two times breast cancer survivor that was recently diagnosed with lung cancer that the docs believe is due to the radiation she had in the early 80's. I know that it is better and more localized now but I can't shake the fear. We shall see... Thanks > > Hello, lyn, > > I had 11 months of chemo first, until my my oncologist said the lump was > small enough for a lumpectomy (from 10cms down to 2.75cms). Then my surgeon > said if the lumpectomy didn't get clean margins he'd have to go in again ... > so I had a mastectomy. And radiation - we are treating this thing > aggressively! And now I'm on chemo tablets and Arimidex. > > Compared with chemo I found that radiation was easy. It made my skin a > little red, but they gave me nice aquaeous cream to put on it, and I got > tired, but not as much as with the chemo. I didn't consider reconstruction > was anything I wanted - I'm 63 and don't want any avoidable surgery. > > You'll make your own decisions, I know, but I wanted to let you know > radiation can be easy. > > Love, > Margery. > ============================================ > margery@... in North Herts, UK > ============================================ > > > > > > Hello...new and decisions > > > > Hello, > > > > My name is lyn and I was diagnosed with IDC on July 13th 2006. > > I am having chemo 1st (AC+T) and have just completed my 4th of 6 > > treatments. > > > > By the MRI the tumor was 4.8CM and growing quickly. I am Estrogren > > and Progesterone Positive (+3) but Her2/neu negative. Nodes were > > swollen but shrank to normal a few days after the 1st chemo. > > > > The tumor is shrinking dramatically (almost undetectable by feel) so > > my oncologist feels I should be good for a lumpectomy. > > > > I am most concerned about radiation. I meet with the surgeon on > > November 1st to discuss options. > > > > If it is a lumpectomy and radiation vs a mastectomy and > > reconstruction but no radiation I am not sure what I will do. > > > > I am 42 with no risk factors and no family history. This has been > > quite a shock. > > > > Thanks > > > > lyn > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 5, 2006 Report Posted October 5, 2006 I will be facing radiation also( had a lumpectomy in August) and from what I have read and the things that I have heard from others is that it can be compared with a bad sunburn but that there are creams that you are given that wil help some of the burning situation. ne--- In breastcancer2 , " r18252000 " wrote: > > Hello, > > My name is lyn and I was diagnosed with IDC on July 13th 2006. > I am having chemo 1st (AC+T) and have just completed my 4th of 6 > treatments. > > By the MRI the tumor was 4.8CM and growing quickly. I am Estrogren > and Progesterone Positive (+3) but Her2/neu negative. Nodes were > swollen but shrank to normal a few days after the 1st chemo. > > The tumor is shrinking dramatically (almost undetectable by feel) so > my oncologist feels I should be good for a lumpectomy. > > I am most concerned about radiation. I meet with the surgeon on > November 1st to discuss options. > > If it is a lumpectomy and radiation vs a mastectomy and > reconstruction but no radiation I am not sure what I will do. > > I am 42 with no risk factors and no family history. This has been > quite a shock. > > Thanks > > lyn > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 5, 2006 Report Posted October 5, 2006 Hi, I had a lumpectomy followed by radiation last year. Radiation was a piece of cake. Yes, there was some " burning " of the skin, but nothing worse than exposing skin to the sun for too long. The toughest part of the radiation was the preparation. It took about an hour to set up all of the templates so that only the cancerous area would be irradiated. They were very careful to protect my heart, lungs, etc. I just hate laying on those darn, cold tables. :-) I am in Arizona and had the sweetest and best radiology center possible. Maya _____ From: breastcancer2 [mailto:breastcancer2 ] On Behalf Of adrianne222000 Sent: Thursday, October 05, 2006 9:30 AM To: breastcancer2 Subject: Re: Hello...new and decisions I will be facing radiation also( had a lumpectomy in August) and from what I have read and the things that I have heard from others is that it can be compared with a bad sunburn but that there are creams that you are given that wil help some of the burning situation. ne--- In breastcancer2@ <mailto:breastcancer2%40yahoogroups.com> yahoogroups.com, " r18252000 " wrote: > > Hello, > > My name is lyn and I was diagnosed with IDC on July 13th 2006. > I am having chemo 1st (AC+T) and have just completed my 4th of 6 > treatments. > > By the MRI the tumor was 4.8CM and growing quickly. I am Estrogren > and Progesterone Positive (+3) but Her2/neu negative. Nodes were > swollen but shrank to normal a few days after the 1st chemo. > > The tumor is shrinking dramatically (almost undetectable by feel) so > my oncologist feels I should be good for a lumpectomy. > > I am most concerned about radiation. I meet with the surgeon on > November 1st to discuss options. > > If it is a lumpectomy and radiation vs a mastectomy and > reconstruction but no radiation I am not sure what I will do. > > I am 42 with no risk factors and no family history. This has been > quite a shock. > > Thanks > > lyn > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 5, 2006 Report Posted October 5, 2006 > > > > Hello, > > > > My name is lyn and I was diagnosed with IDC on July 13th 2006. > > I am having chemo 1st (AC+T) and have just completed my 4th of 6 > > treatments. > > > > By the MRI the tumor was 4.8CM and growing quickly. I am Estrogren > > and Progesterone Positive (+3) but Her2/neu negative. Nodes were > > swollen but shrank to normal a few days after the 1st chemo. > > > > The tumor is shrinking dramatically (almost undetectable by feel) > so > > my oncologist feels I should be good for a lumpectomy. > > > > I am most concerned about radiation. I meet with the surgeon on > > November 1st to discuss options. > > > > If it is a lumpectomy and radiation vs a mastectomy and > > reconstruction but no radiation I am not sure what I will do. > > > > I am 42 with no risk factors and no family history. This has been > > quite a shock. > > > > Thanks > > > > lyn > > Hi lyn. My name is Diane. I just turned 53. I had a right radical mastectomy August 1. I am stage III-B. I had one node positive out of thirteen. I am in my next to the last week of radiation therapy. It's really not so bad. I have one spot that really has burned quite a bit, but my physician prescribed come medication to use three times a day. My only other problem with the radiation is the tiredness, but my physician assures me that after the radiation is completed that, too, will resolve. I understand totally your feelings of confusion. I went to my surgeon one Friday, had ultrasound and biopsies that same day, saw him the following Monday and had my surgery that Tuesday....talk about a whirlwind of activity. Then it was off to the oncologist, who was determined I was going to undergo chemo, no ifs, ands or buts about it.......however, I had other thoughts. I talked with my family, my minister and I prayed more than I believe I have ever prayed before. My decision was to turn down chemo and opt for the radiation. I had worked in a hematology-oncology group before and I just couldn't see me putting not only myself, but my family, especially my two young grandchildren who are in my life every day, through the effects of chemotherapy. My family backed my decision 100%. They understand that I opted for quality of life over quantity....I'm not saying that I don't want to live to be 103, but we are such as active family, we are constantly on the go and I feel if I had taken the chemo. we would not have been able to share and do all we normally do. There are so many decisions that we as breast cancer patients must face. Decisions that are very much life altering not only for us but for our family. I pray that your radiation goes as easily for you as mine has for me. I am so happy to hear that your tumor and nodes are shrinking, that is such a good sign. Just be sure to make the decision that YOU want to make, not what EVERYONE else feels you should. I do not regret one bit having my mastectomy nor opting for the radiation over the chemo. I am back to work full time. I'm still able to go and do with my family (maybe just not as much right now) and I am beginning to see the light at the end of the tunnel as far as my radiation goes. What happens next, I don't know, but GOD does and he is looking out for you just as he is for me. I wish you the best in whatever decision you make. Good luck and Good health! Best Wishes! Diane > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 5, 2006 Report Posted October 5, 2006 > > > > Hello, > > > > My name is lyn and I was diagnosed with IDC on July 13th 2006. > > I am having chemo 1st (AC+T) and have just completed my 4th of 6 > > treatments. > > > > By the MRI the tumor was 4.8CM and growing quickly. I am Estrogren > > and Progesterone Positive (+3) but Her2/neu negative. Nodes were > > swollen but shrank to normal a few days after the 1st chemo. > > > > The tumor is shrinking dramatically (almost undetectable by feel) > so > > my oncologist feels I should be good for a lumpectomy. > > > > I am most concerned about radiation. I meet with the surgeon on > > November 1st to discuss options. > > > > If it is a lumpectomy and radiation vs a mastectomy and > > reconstruction but no radiation I am not sure what I will do. > > > > I am 42 with no risk factors and no family history. This has been > > quite a shock. > > > > Thanks > > > > lyn > > Hi lyn. My name is Diane. I just turned 53. I had a right radical mastectomy August 1. I am stage III-B. I had one node positive out of thirteen. I am in my next to the last week of radiation therapy. It's really not so bad. I have one spot that really has burned quite a bit, but my physician prescribed come medication to use three times a day. My only other problem with the radiation is the tiredness, but my physician assures me that after the radiation is completed that, too, will resolve. I understand totally your feelings of confusion. I went to my surgeon one Friday, had ultrasound and biopsies that same day, saw him the following Monday and had my surgery that Tuesday....talk about a whirlwind of activity. Then it was off to the oncologist, who was determined I was going to undergo chemo, no ifs, ands or buts about it.......however, I had other thoughts. I talked with my family, my minister and I prayed more than I believe I have ever prayed before. My decision was to turn down chemo and opt for the radiation. I had worked in a hematology-oncology group before and I just couldn't see me putting not only myself, but my family, especially my two young grandchildren who are in my life every day, through the effects of chemotherapy. My family backed my decision 100%. They understand that I opted for quality of life over quantity....I'm not saying that I don't want to live to be 103, but we are such as active family, we are constantly on the go and I feel if I had taken the chemo. we would not have been able to share and do all we normally do. There are so many decisions that we as breast cancer patients must face. Decisions that are very much life altering not only for us but for our family. I pray that your radiation goes as easily for you as mine has for me. I am so happy to hear that your tumor and nodes are shrinking, that is such a good sign. Just be sure to make the decision that YOU want to make, not what EVERYONE else feels you should. I do not regret one bit having my mastectomy nor opting for the radiation over the chemo. I am back to work full time. I'm still able to go and do with my family (maybe just not as much right now) and I am beginning to see the light at the end of the tunnel as far as my radiation goes. What happens next, I don't know, but GOD does and he is looking out for you just as he is for me. I wish you the best in whatever decision you make. Good luck and Good health! Best Wishes! Diane > Quote
Guest guest Posted October 5, 2006 Report Posted October 5, 2006 > > > > Hello, > > > > My name is lyn and I was diagnosed with IDC on July 13th 2006. > > I am having chemo 1st (AC+T) and have just completed my 4th of 6 > > treatments. > > > > By the MRI the tumor was 4.8CM and growing quickly. I am Estrogren > > and Progesterone Positive (+3) but Her2/neu negative. Nodes were > > swollen but shrank to normal a few days after the 1st chemo. > > > > The tumor is shrinking dramatically (almost undetectable by feel) > so > > my oncologist feels I should be good for a lumpectomy. > > > > I am most concerned about radiation. I meet with the surgeon on > > November 1st to discuss options. > > > > If it is a lumpectomy and radiation vs a mastectomy and > > reconstruction but no radiation I am not sure what I will do. > > > > I am 42 with no risk factors and no family history. This has been > > quite a shock. > > > > Thanks > > > > lyn > > Hi lyn. My name is Diane. I just turned 53. I had a right radical mastectomy August 1. I am stage III-B. I had one node positive out of thirteen. I am in my next to the last week of radiation therapy. It's really not so bad. I have one spot that really has burned quite a bit, but my physician prescribed come medication to use three times a day. My only other problem with the radiation is the tiredness, but my physician assures me that after the radiation is completed that, too, will resolve. I understand totally your feelings of confusion. I went to my surgeon one Friday, had ultrasound and biopsies that same day, saw him the following Monday and had my surgery that Tuesday....talk about a whirlwind of activity. Then it was off to the oncologist, who was determined I was going to undergo chemo, no ifs, ands or buts about it.......however, I had other thoughts. I talked with my family, my minister and I prayed more than I believe I have ever prayed before. My decision was to turn down chemo and opt for the radiation. I had worked in a hematology-oncology group before and I just couldn't see me putting not only myself, but my family, especially my two young grandchildren who are in my life every day, through the effects of chemotherapy. My family backed my decision 100%. They understand that I opted for quality of life over quantity....I'm not saying that I don't want to live to be 103, but we are such as active family, we are constantly on the go and I feel if I had taken the chemo. we would not have been able to share and do all we normally do. There are so many decisions that we as breast cancer patients must face. Decisions that are very much life altering not only for us but for our family. I pray that your radiation goes as easily for you as mine has for me. I am so happy to hear that your tumor and nodes are shrinking, that is such a good sign. Just be sure to make the decision that YOU want to make, not what EVERYONE else feels you should. I do not regret one bit having my mastectomy nor opting for the radiation over the chemo. I am back to work full time. I'm still able to go and do with my family (maybe just not as much right now) and I am beginning to see the light at the end of the tunnel as far as my radiation goes. What happens next, I don't know, but GOD does and he is looking out for you just as he is for me. I wish you the best in whatever decision you make. Good luck and Good health! Best Wishes! Diane > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.