Guest guest Posted August 5, 2006 Report Share Posted August 5, 2006 Hi Shane and Robin! Sensory Integration Dysfunction or DSI, is a separate unique diagnosis that can stand alone or be found co existing in other conditions -including but not limited to autism. Sensory Integration Dysfunction can go undetected when mild, or could be acquired after a head injury, or as a symptom of Transverse Myelopathy. http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/jhtmc/clinical.htm Again just because it looks, talks and walks like a duck -could be a kid trick or treating..doesn't mean it's auto-autism. (either that or you can get autism from a car accident if you hit your head and develop sensory issues!) Sounds like you are doing all the right things just in case -and that's the best way to go. As you may recall from your brother - therapy for autism itself is not the same as therapy for apraxia. There is not enough ST and OT in ABA approaches. Therapy for sensory issues however are always appropriate for anyone who is diagnosed as having sensory issues -no matter what the other diagnosis are. Find out what each diagnosis is that you are dealing with and provide appropriate therapies for each and it won't be so confusing. At 24 months your child could be diagnosed with oral apraxia -but not verbal. At 24 months typically the diagnosis would be suspected apraxia and you could start appropriate therapy for apraxia just in case. Won't hurt and could help if not apraxic...but will be invaluable if apraxic. And in the US -apraxia and dyspraxia mean the same thing. Take one step at a time -we are here for you as a group and we have tons of parents and professionals here who can lead you down the early stages of the road you are now on. And it's great you read The Late Talker...I'm one of the co authors and know we put info in there to help parents just like you! ===== Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2006 Report Share Posted August 5, 2006 Hi, My child also had multiple specialists calling her different things....her official diagnosis was high functioning PDD-NOS, moderate verbal apraxia, sensory processing disorder, severe speech delay, and hypotonia. She was very loving, had okay eye contact, and did not have meltdowns. None-the-less, she had issues...including excema and a very poor immune system. Long story short, after coming to this great list first and then branching out into the autism spectrum ones, we were able to diagnose her correctly. Beyond any reasonable doubt, unequivocally, no-mistaking it....she had mercury poisoning. Hair tests, urine tests, and stool tests all confirmed it. Chelating has reversed her conditions almost 100%. She will enter kindergarten in two weeks mainstreamed needing speech therapy once a week. I realize not everyone's child is like my daughter. I'm not saying all children with issues have to be mercury poisoned. She also had yeast issues and viral issues (making antibodies to the measles virus like crazy). But at the end of the day, mercury was her biggest problem. It's an avenue worth pursuing, even if it doesn't turn out to be your child's. It can't hurt to rule it out. If one was to line up all of the symptoms of mercury poisoning with all of the symptoms of the autism spectrum, including apraxia, ADD/ADHD, and many other of the disorders that plague our children, there are no differences. They aren't kind of similar...they are identical. Anyone interested in more info may email me off line. I'm happy to help. -------------- Original message -------------- From: " Shane H. " <robin.harmon@...> If anyone can shed some light on this for me, I would be so grateful. I have been going through evaluations with my almost 24 month old son for about 4 months now. We started with his developmental pediatrician, then moved into the EI system's three, seperate evaluators, and lastly have sought out evaluations from our Children's hospital for ST, OT and soon PT. The dev. pediatrician did not feel he was on the ASD spectrum, but had a severe commuinication delay. The 1st SLP suspected severe verbal with moderate oral apraxia. The 2nd SLP said age appropriate receptive skills, severe expressive skills, with apraxic like symptoms. The OT says he has a mild hypotonia (truncal) and sensory issues and wants him to have a PT evaluation. So where does all of this lead me? I read the book the late talker. It explained that apraxic children often have a mild hypotonia and sensory issues, which may just peg my son to a tee. He has all the classic verbal issues...drooling, adding vowel sounds " up-ah " , lots of groping. However, I am confused. I have been doing research on a lot of different disorders, and cannot seem to figure out where the line is between some of them. If a child has verbal/oral apraxia, sensory issues, and a hypotonia, what is the main difference between this and dyspraxia? And then there is autism. So far, I hear that my son is not on the spectrum...but the sensory issues make me wonder (loves to touch the ends of his hair with his thumb, loves visual stuff like colors and is even advanced with this, sensory seeking with feet and hands). By the way - I actually have a lot of sensory issues and they still are a problem for me as an adult. It seems that a lot of the issues that apraxic children have can cross over to the autistic diagnosis, except for the social part? Is this correct? My son has no social issues that can be recognized yet. Good eye contact, loves other kids, pretend play, pointing, etc. His evaluations always include that he is " extremely social " . But I still wonder if he has some form of autism? I am so confused. The reason I am still wondering about autism is because my brother is autistic. I have to say that he acted very differently from my son...no eye contact until 16, frequent and intense meltdowns over sensory things (like spinning signs), no pretend play, severe social issues...but the family history makes it more of a possibility. Even is he is not autistic now, could he suddenly regress socially? I do not know what to look for anymore. Every evaluation is filled with so many questions...my head is spinning. Do I have to wait until he is three to really know what his challenges are and how to help him? Regardless of his label, I just want to get him the right kind of help so that he can have the brightest future possible. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2006 Report Share Posted August 5, 2006 Robin, Welcome! The lines of diagnoses seem to be so blurry. Yes, many apraxic kids have sensory issues and do not get an autism diagnosis - but some do. None of the evaluations you've had have pointed to ASD, and if an expert does say someday that your son is autistic you'll have to make up your own mind whether you want to agree with that and what you want to do about it. With your family history of autism and sensory problems, I strongly urge you to avoid any vaccines that contain mercury (like the flu shot, but you can get a preservative-free version if you look around) and to do your own research into the other vaccines to make up your own mind about them. Kids can still regress after age 2 into an autism diagnosis, and I have " met " online many parents who claim that vaccines were the trigger for their kids. Regardless of whether you believe them, there really is no reason to inject mercury into a young child or anyone for that matter. Another thing you can do to help prevent regression (and keep your son healthy) is to give him vitamins and minerals to boost the immune system (I'm thinking C, E, zinc, magnesium, and fish oils to name a few but I'm not a doctor or nutritionist). And of course, you can go further and look into biomedial treatments for apraxia and autism. If your feeling adventurous and have the cash to do it, you may want to look into Dr. Amy Yasko's genetic testing and protocol at www.autismanswer.com (no need to be dx) - it could shed some light on why you and your brother have the sensory issues too. Kerri > I have to say that he acted very differently from my son...no eye contact > until 16, frequent and intense meltdowns over sensory things (like > spinning signs), no pretend play, severe social issues...but the family > history makes it more of a possibility. Even is he is not autistic > now, could he suddenly regress socially? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2006 Report Share Posted August 5, 2006 I heard a therapist once describe the differences between a child on the spectrum vs not as ASD children were primarily involved/locked within their own heads/minds whereas a non autistic child was primarily involved in the world around him/her. Your child's social strengths are a good indicator of not being on the spectrum. Many symptoms overlap diagnoses (speech delays, sensory issues, learning disabilities, auditory processing, motor planning and tone) from autism to ADD to CP to many others. It is good you are getting OT,PT, SLP, reports. I would still suggest you find a good neuropsychologist to help you understand how your child's brain works, learns so that you can translate that information into a school education and service delivery plan (IEP). It takes time to get all this information together but over time working on these areas will make a difference for your child. " Shane H. " <robin.harmon@...> wrote: If anyone can shed some light on this for me, I would be so grateful. I have been going through evaluations with my almost 24 month old son for about 4 months now. We started with his developmental pediatrician, then moved into the EI system's three, seperate evaluators, and lastly have sought out evaluations from our Children's hospital for ST, OT and soon PT. The dev. pediatrician did not feel he was on the ASD spectrum, but had a severe commuinication delay. The 1st SLP suspected severe verbal with moderate oral apraxia. The 2nd SLP said age appropriate receptive skills, severe expressive skills, with apraxic like symptoms. The OT says he has a mild hypotonia (truncal) and sensory issues and wants him to have a PT evaluation. So where does all of this lead me? I read the book the late talker. It explained that apraxic children often have a mild hypotonia and sensory issues, which may just peg my son to a tee. He has all the classic verbal issues...drooling, adding vowel sounds " up-ah " , lots of groping. However, I am confused. I have been doing research on a lot of different disorders, and cannot seem to figure out where the line is between some of them. If a child has verbal/oral apraxia, sensory issues, and a hypotonia, what is the main difference between this and dyspraxia? And then there is autism. So far, I hear that my son is not on the spectrum...but the sensory issues make me wonder (loves to touch the ends of his hair with his thumb, loves visual stuff like colors and is even advanced with this, sensory seeking with feet and hands). By the way - I actually have a lot of sensory issues and they still are a problem for me as an adult. It seems that a lot of the issues that apraxic children have can cross over to the autistic diagnosis, except for the social part? Is this correct? My son has no social issues that can be recognized yet. Good eye contact, loves other kids, pretend play, pointing, etc. His evaluations always include that he is " extremely social " . But I still wonder if he has some form of autism? I am so confused. The reason I am still wondering about autism is because my brother is autistic. I have to say that he acted very differently from my son...no eye contact until 16, frequent and intense meltdowns over sensory things (like spinning signs), no pretend play, severe social issues...but the family history makes it more of a possibility. Even is he is not autistic now, could he suddenly regress socially? I do not know what to look for anymore. Every evaluation is filled with so many questions...my head is spinning. Do I have to wait until he is three to really know what his challenges are and how to help him? Regardless of his label, I just want to get him the right kind of help so that he can have the brightest future possible. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2006 Report Share Posted August 5, 2006 , Was the test for mercury a blood test? julieobradovic@... wrote: Hi, My child also had multiple specialists calling her different things....her official diagnosis was high functioning PDD-NOS, moderate verbal apraxia, sensory processing disorder, severe speech delay, and hypotonia. She was very loving, had okay eye contact, and did not have meltdowns. None-the-less, she had issues...including excema and a very poor immune system. Long story short, after coming to this great list first and then branching out into the autism spectrum ones, we were able to diagnose her correctly. Beyond any reasonable doubt, unequivocally, no-mistaking it....she had mercury poisoning. Hair tests, urine tests, and stool tests all confirmed it. Chelating has reversed her conditions almost 100%. She will enter kindergarten in two weeks mainstreamed needing speech therapy once a week. I realize not everyone's child is like my daughter. I'm not saying all children with issues have to be mercury poisoned. She also had yeast issues and viral issues (making antibodies to the measles virus like crazy). But at the end of the day, mercury was her biggest problem. It's an avenue worth pursuing, even if it doesn't turn out to be your child's. It can't hurt to rule it out. If one was to line up all of the symptoms of mercury poisoning with all of the symptoms of the autism spectrum, including apraxia, ADD/ADHD, and many other of the disorders that plague our children, there are no differences. They aren't kind of similar...they are identical. Anyone interested in more info may email me off line. I'm happy to help. -------------- Original message -------------- From: " Shane H. " <robin.harmon@...> If anyone can shed some light on this for me, I would be so grateful. I have been going through evaluations with my almost 24 month old son for about 4 months now. We started with his developmental pediatrician, then moved into the EI system's three, seperate evaluators, and lastly have sought out evaluations from our Children's hospital for ST, OT and soon PT. The dev. pediatrician did not feel he was on the ASD spectrum, but had a severe commuinication delay. The 1st SLP suspected severe verbal with moderate oral apraxia. The 2nd SLP said age appropriate receptive skills, severe expressive skills, with apraxic like symptoms. The OT says he has a mild hypotonia (truncal) and sensory issues and wants him to have a PT evaluation. So where does all of this lead me? I read the book the late talker. It explained that apraxic children often have a mild hypotonia and sensory issues, which may just peg my son to a tee. He has all the classic verbal issues...drooling, adding vowel sounds " up-ah " , lots of groping. However, I am confused. I have been doing research on a lot of different disorders, and cannot seem to figure out where the line is between some of them. If a child has verbal/oral apraxia, sensory issues, and a hypotonia, what is the main difference between this and dyspraxia? And then there is autism. So far, I hear that my son is not on the spectrum...but the sensory issues make me wonder (loves to touch the ends of his hair with his thumb, loves visual stuff like colors and is even advanced with this, sensory seeking with feet and hands). By the way - I actually have a lot of sensory issues and they still are a problem for me as an adult. It seems that a lot of the issues that apraxic children have can cross over to the autistic diagnosis, except for the social part? Is this correct? My son has no social issues that can be recognized yet. Good eye contact, loves other kids, pretend play, pointing, etc. His evaluations always include that he is " extremely social " . But I still wonder if he has some form of autism? I am so confused. The reason I am still wondering about autism is because my brother is autistic. I have to say that he acted very differently from my son...no eye contact until 16, frequent and intense meltdowns over sensory things (like spinning signs), no pretend play, severe social issues...but the family history makes it more of a possibility. Even is he is not autistic now, could he suddenly regress socially? I do not know what to look for anymore. Every evaluation is filled with so many questions...my head is spinning. Do I have to wait until he is three to really know what his challenges are and how to help him? Regardless of his label, I just want to get him the right kind of help so that he can have the brightest future possible. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2006 Report Share Posted August 5, 2006 Hi Shane and Robin! Sensory Integration Dysfunction or DSI, is a separate unique diagnosis that can stand alone or be found co existing in other conditions -including but not limited to autism. Sensory Integration Dysfunction can go undetected when mild, or could be acquired after a head injury, or as a symptom of Transverse Myelopathy. http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/jhtmc/clinical.htm Again just because it looks, talks and walks like a duck -could be a kid trick or treating..doesn't mean it's auto-autism. (either that or you can get autism from a car accident if you hit your head and develop sensory issues!) Sounds like you are doing all the right things just in case -and that's the best way to go. As you may recall from your brother - therapy for autism itself is not the same as therapy for apraxia. There is not enough ST and OT in ABA approaches. Therapy for sensory issues however are always appropriate for anyone who is diagnosed as having sensory issues -no matter what the other diagnosis are. Find out what each diagnosis is that you are dealing with and provide appropriate therapies for each and it won't be so confusing. At 24 months your child could be diagnosed with oral apraxia -but not verbal. At 24 months typically the diagnosis would be suspected apraxia and you could start appropriate therapy for apraxia just in case. Won't hurt and could help if not apraxic...but will be invaluable if apraxic. And in the US -apraxia and dyspraxia mean the same thing. Take one step at a time -we are here for you as a group and we have tons of parents and professionals here who can lead you down the early stages of the road you are now on. And it's great you read The Late Talker...I'm one of the co authors and know we put info in there to help parents just like you! ===== Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2006 Report Share Posted August 5, 2006 Wow. Thank you all so much for the information. My son will be two next week and is schedulded to receive his next vaccinations shortly after. I will discuss the mercury issue with his doctor before he receives any vaccinations. Is mercury poisoning something that I can ask his pediatrician to test for or will I have to go to a hospital? > > Robin, > > Welcome! The lines of diagnoses seem to be so blurry. Yes, many > apraxic kids have sensory issues and do not get an autism diagnosis - > but some do. None of the evaluations you've had have pointed to ASD, > and if an expert does say someday that your son is autistic you'll > have to make up your own mind whether you want to agree with that and > what you want to do about it. > > With your family history of autism and sensory problems, I strongly > urge you to avoid any vaccines that contain mercury (like the flu > shot, but you can get a preservative-free version if you look around) > and to do your own research into the other vaccines to make up your > own mind about them. Kids can still regress after age 2 into an > autism diagnosis, and I have " met " online many parents who claim that > vaccines were the trigger for their kids. Regardless of whether you > believe them, there really is no reason to inject mercury into a young > child or anyone for that matter. Another thing you can do to help > prevent regression (and keep your son healthy) is to give him vitamins > and minerals to boost the immune system (I'm thinking C, E, zinc, > magnesium, and fish oils to name a few but I'm not a doctor or > nutritionist). And of course, you can go further and look into > biomedial treatments for apraxia and autism. > > If your feeling adventurous and have the cash to do it, you may want > to look into Dr. Amy Yasko's genetic testing and protocol at > www.autismanswer.com (no need to be dx) - it could shed some light on > why you and your brother have the sensory issues too. > > Kerri > > > I have to say that he acted very differently from my son...no eye > contact > > until 16, frequent and intense meltdowns over sensory things (like > > spinning signs), no pretend play, severe social issues...but the > family > > history makes it more of a possibility. Even is he is not autistic > > now, could he suddenly regress socially? > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2006 Report Share Posted August 5, 2006 Hi, My child also had multiple specialists calling her different things....her official diagnosis was high functioning PDD-NOS, moderate verbal apraxia, sensory processing disorder, severe speech delay, and hypotonia. She was very loving, had okay eye contact, and did not have meltdowns. None-the-less, she had issues...including excema and a very poor immune system. Long story short, after coming to this great list first and then branching out into the autism spectrum ones, we were able to diagnose her correctly. Beyond any reasonable doubt, unequivocally, no-mistaking it....she had mercury poisoning. Hair tests, urine tests, and stool tests all confirmed it. Chelating has reversed her conditions almost 100%. She will enter kindergarten in two weeks mainstreamed needing speech therapy once a week. I realize not everyone's child is like my daughter. I'm not saying all children with issues have to be mercury poisoned. She also had yeast issues and viral issues (making antibodies to the measles virus like crazy). But at the end of the day, mercury was her biggest problem. It's an avenue worth pursuing, even if it doesn't turn out to be your child's. It can't hurt to rule it out. If one was to line up all of the symptoms of mercury poisoning with all of the symptoms of the autism spectrum, including apraxia, ADD/ADHD, and many other of the disorders that plague our children, there are no differences. They aren't kind of similar...they are identical. Anyone interested in more info may email me off line. I'm happy to help. -------------- Original message -------------- From: " Shane H. " <robin.harmon@...> If anyone can shed some light on this for me, I would be so grateful. I have been going through evaluations with my almost 24 month old son for about 4 months now. We started with his developmental pediatrician, then moved into the EI system's three, seperate evaluators, and lastly have sought out evaluations from our Children's hospital for ST, OT and soon PT. The dev. pediatrician did not feel he was on the ASD spectrum, but had a severe commuinication delay. The 1st SLP suspected severe verbal with moderate oral apraxia. The 2nd SLP said age appropriate receptive skills, severe expressive skills, with apraxic like symptoms. The OT says he has a mild hypotonia (truncal) and sensory issues and wants him to have a PT evaluation. So where does all of this lead me? I read the book the late talker. It explained that apraxic children often have a mild hypotonia and sensory issues, which may just peg my son to a tee. He has all the classic verbal issues...drooling, adding vowel sounds " up-ah " , lots of groping. However, I am confused. I have been doing research on a lot of different disorders, and cannot seem to figure out where the line is between some of them. If a child has verbal/oral apraxia, sensory issues, and a hypotonia, what is the main difference between this and dyspraxia? And then there is autism. So far, I hear that my son is not on the spectrum...but the sensory issues make me wonder (loves to touch the ends of his hair with his thumb, loves visual stuff like colors and is even advanced with this, sensory seeking with feet and hands). By the way - I actually have a lot of sensory issues and they still are a problem for me as an adult. It seems that a lot of the issues that apraxic children have can cross over to the autistic diagnosis, except for the social part? Is this correct? My son has no social issues that can be recognized yet. Good eye contact, loves other kids, pretend play, pointing, etc. His evaluations always include that he is " extremely social " . But I still wonder if he has some form of autism? I am so confused. The reason I am still wondering about autism is because my brother is autistic. I have to say that he acted very differently from my son...no eye contact until 16, frequent and intense meltdowns over sensory things (like spinning signs), no pretend play, severe social issues...but the family history makes it more of a possibility. Even is he is not autistic now, could he suddenly regress socially? I do not know what to look for anymore. Every evaluation is filled with so many questions...my head is spinning. Do I have to wait until he is three to really know what his challenges are and how to help him? Regardless of his label, I just want to get him the right kind of help so that he can have the brightest future possible. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 Robin, Welcome! The lines of diagnoses seem to be so blurry. Yes, many apraxic kids have sensory issues and do not get an autism diagnosis - but some do. None of the evaluations you've had have pointed to ASD, and if an expert does say someday that your son is autistic you'll have to make up your own mind whether you want to agree with that and what you want to do about it. With your family history of autism and sensory problems, I strongly urge you to avoid any vaccines that contain mercury (like the flu shot, but you can get a preservative-free version if you look around) and to do your own research into the other vaccines to make up your own mind about them. Kids can still regress after age 2 into an autism diagnosis, and I have " met " online many parents who claim that vaccines were the trigger for their kids. Regardless of whether you believe them, there really is no reason to inject mercury into a young child or anyone for that matter. Another thing you can do to help prevent regression (and keep your son healthy) is to give him vitamins and minerals to boost the immune system (I'm thinking C, E, zinc, magnesium, and fish oils to name a few but I'm not a doctor or nutritionist). And of course, you can go further and look into biomedial treatments for apraxia and autism. If your feeling adventurous and have the cash to do it, you may want to look into Dr. Amy Yasko's genetic testing and protocol at www.autismanswer.com (no need to be dx) - it could shed some light on why you and your brother have the sensory issues too. Kerri > I have to say that he acted very differently from my son...no eye contact > until 16, frequent and intense meltdowns over sensory things (like > spinning signs), no pretend play, severe social issues...but the family > history makes it more of a possibility. Even is he is not autistic > now, could he suddenly regress socially? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 I heard a therapist once describe the differences between a child on the spectrum vs not as ASD children were primarily involved/locked within their own heads/minds whereas a non autistic child was primarily involved in the world around him/her. Your child's social strengths are a good indicator of not being on the spectrum. Many symptoms overlap diagnoses (speech delays, sensory issues, learning disabilities, auditory processing, motor planning and tone) from autism to ADD to CP to many others. It is good you are getting OT,PT, SLP, reports. I would still suggest you find a good neuropsychologist to help you understand how your child's brain works, learns so that you can translate that information into a school education and service delivery plan (IEP). It takes time to get all this information together but over time working on these areas will make a difference for your child. " Shane H. " <robin.harmon@...> wrote: If anyone can shed some light on this for me, I would be so grateful. I have been going through evaluations with my almost 24 month old son for about 4 months now. We started with his developmental pediatrician, then moved into the EI system's three, seperate evaluators, and lastly have sought out evaluations from our Children's hospital for ST, OT and soon PT. The dev. pediatrician did not feel he was on the ASD spectrum, but had a severe commuinication delay. The 1st SLP suspected severe verbal with moderate oral apraxia. The 2nd SLP said age appropriate receptive skills, severe expressive skills, with apraxic like symptoms. The OT says he has a mild hypotonia (truncal) and sensory issues and wants him to have a PT evaluation. So where does all of this lead me? I read the book the late talker. It explained that apraxic children often have a mild hypotonia and sensory issues, which may just peg my son to a tee. He has all the classic verbal issues...drooling, adding vowel sounds " up-ah " , lots of groping. However, I am confused. I have been doing research on a lot of different disorders, and cannot seem to figure out where the line is between some of them. If a child has verbal/oral apraxia, sensory issues, and a hypotonia, what is the main difference between this and dyspraxia? And then there is autism. So far, I hear that my son is not on the spectrum...but the sensory issues make me wonder (loves to touch the ends of his hair with his thumb, loves visual stuff like colors and is even advanced with this, sensory seeking with feet and hands). By the way - I actually have a lot of sensory issues and they still are a problem for me as an adult. It seems that a lot of the issues that apraxic children have can cross over to the autistic diagnosis, except for the social part? Is this correct? My son has no social issues that can be recognized yet. Good eye contact, loves other kids, pretend play, pointing, etc. His evaluations always include that he is " extremely social " . But I still wonder if he has some form of autism? I am so confused. The reason I am still wondering about autism is because my brother is autistic. I have to say that he acted very differently from my son...no eye contact until 16, frequent and intense meltdowns over sensory things (like spinning signs), no pretend play, severe social issues...but the family history makes it more of a possibility. Even is he is not autistic now, could he suddenly regress socially? I do not know what to look for anymore. Every evaluation is filled with so many questions...my head is spinning. Do I have to wait until he is three to really know what his challenges are and how to help him? Regardless of his label, I just want to get him the right kind of help so that he can have the brightest future possible. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 , Was the test for mercury a blood test? julieobradovic@... wrote: Hi, My child also had multiple specialists calling her different things....her official diagnosis was high functioning PDD-NOS, moderate verbal apraxia, sensory processing disorder, severe speech delay, and hypotonia. She was very loving, had okay eye contact, and did not have meltdowns. None-the-less, she had issues...including excema and a very poor immune system. Long story short, after coming to this great list first and then branching out into the autism spectrum ones, we were able to diagnose her correctly. Beyond any reasonable doubt, unequivocally, no-mistaking it....she had mercury poisoning. Hair tests, urine tests, and stool tests all confirmed it. Chelating has reversed her conditions almost 100%. She will enter kindergarten in two weeks mainstreamed needing speech therapy once a week. I realize not everyone's child is like my daughter. I'm not saying all children with issues have to be mercury poisoned. She also had yeast issues and viral issues (making antibodies to the measles virus like crazy). But at the end of the day, mercury was her biggest problem. It's an avenue worth pursuing, even if it doesn't turn out to be your child's. It can't hurt to rule it out. If one was to line up all of the symptoms of mercury poisoning with all of the symptoms of the autism spectrum, including apraxia, ADD/ADHD, and many other of the disorders that plague our children, there are no differences. They aren't kind of similar...they are identical. Anyone interested in more info may email me off line. I'm happy to help. -------------- Original message -------------- From: " Shane H. " <robin.harmon@...> If anyone can shed some light on this for me, I would be so grateful. I have been going through evaluations with my almost 24 month old son for about 4 months now. We started with his developmental pediatrician, then moved into the EI system's three, seperate evaluators, and lastly have sought out evaluations from our Children's hospital for ST, OT and soon PT. The dev. pediatrician did not feel he was on the ASD spectrum, but had a severe commuinication delay. The 1st SLP suspected severe verbal with moderate oral apraxia. The 2nd SLP said age appropriate receptive skills, severe expressive skills, with apraxic like symptoms. The OT says he has a mild hypotonia (truncal) and sensory issues and wants him to have a PT evaluation. So where does all of this lead me? I read the book the late talker. It explained that apraxic children often have a mild hypotonia and sensory issues, which may just peg my son to a tee. He has all the classic verbal issues...drooling, adding vowel sounds " up-ah " , lots of groping. However, I am confused. I have been doing research on a lot of different disorders, and cannot seem to figure out where the line is between some of them. If a child has verbal/oral apraxia, sensory issues, and a hypotonia, what is the main difference between this and dyspraxia? And then there is autism. So far, I hear that my son is not on the spectrum...but the sensory issues make me wonder (loves to touch the ends of his hair with his thumb, loves visual stuff like colors and is even advanced with this, sensory seeking with feet and hands). By the way - I actually have a lot of sensory issues and they still are a problem for me as an adult. It seems that a lot of the issues that apraxic children have can cross over to the autistic diagnosis, except for the social part? Is this correct? My son has no social issues that can be recognized yet. Good eye contact, loves other kids, pretend play, pointing, etc. His evaluations always include that he is " extremely social " . But I still wonder if he has some form of autism? I am so confused. The reason I am still wondering about autism is because my brother is autistic. I have to say that he acted very differently from my son...no eye contact until 16, frequent and intense meltdowns over sensory things (like spinning signs), no pretend play, severe social issues...but the family history makes it more of a possibility. Even is he is not autistic now, could he suddenly regress socially? I do not know what to look for anymore. Every evaluation is filled with so many questions...my head is spinning. Do I have to wait until he is three to really know what his challenges are and how to help him? Regardless of his label, I just want to get him the right kind of help so that he can have the brightest future possible. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 > > , > > Was the test for mercury a blood test? > You usually cannot just " do a blood test " for mercury. If there has been recent exposure (within the past six weeks) then an RBC mercury might be high. But usually mercury is sequestered into the fat and brain tissues. Sometimes hair tests are done but be warned...if other metals are high and mercury is low or near zero it may mean your child is a " non-excretor " of mercury and these children have some of the worst ASD disorders. When they receive chelation treatment a lot of mercury eventually comes out. Look for these things: are there a lot of autoimmune disease problems in your family history? Lupus, arthritis, diabetes, ITP, scleroderma in any close relatives? Have you had RhoGam injections in past pregnancies when it still had thimerosal mercury in it? Do you have a lot of dental amalgams in your teeth? And the history of autism in your brother is a warning sign. Your family may be one of those genetically vulnerable ones. Take care! And never, never vaccinate if a child is sick or feverish or even sniffly. Just say no! Spreading out the vaccines and giving extra vitamin C is an option for some. We have genetic humoral immune deficiencies in our family and my DGS had the live chickenpox vaccine on his first birthday. He had ear infections and severe receptive and expressive speech delay, oral-sensory problems, etc. and lost eye contact and joint attention right after that. Just after his fourth birthday, he had shingles. And atypical pneumonia. His pediatrician gave him acyclovir, and after two years of speech therapy, his articulation suddenly became age-appropriate. ProEFA helped him before. But I saw such an awful regression between 9 months and 13 months (coming in from out of state as a grandma) that I also blame the chickenpox vaccine as well as a whole lot of other factors. He's older than your child so he got a mercury-containing hep B vaccine at age one day. Our family is riddled with autoimmune disease and mercury " allergies. " My late husband may have had Asperger's Syndrome. There may be multiple factors, but don't risk vaccinating the " everything at once " way or too early, and look carefully at your family history. It will tell you more than a blood test. Mady Hornig did a study with different strains of mice and some of them responded with autistic-like behaviors to injections of thimerosal at exactly the same developmental stages as we give, or used to give, mercury containing vaccines to infants. Some strains, in fact most, were OK with the shots. Again, your family history will tell you more than a blood test about your child's vulnerability. Peace, Kathy E. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 Wow. Thank you all so much for the information. My son will be two next week and is schedulded to receive his next vaccinations shortly after. I will discuss the mercury issue with his doctor before he receives any vaccinations. Is mercury poisoning something that I can ask his pediatrician to test for or will I have to go to a hospital? > > Robin, > > Welcome! The lines of diagnoses seem to be so blurry. Yes, many > apraxic kids have sensory issues and do not get an autism diagnosis - > but some do. None of the evaluations you've had have pointed to ASD, > and if an expert does say someday that your son is autistic you'll > have to make up your own mind whether you want to agree with that and > what you want to do about it. > > With your family history of autism and sensory problems, I strongly > urge you to avoid any vaccines that contain mercury (like the flu > shot, but you can get a preservative-free version if you look around) > and to do your own research into the other vaccines to make up your > own mind about them. Kids can still regress after age 2 into an > autism diagnosis, and I have " met " online many parents who claim that > vaccines were the trigger for their kids. Regardless of whether you > believe them, there really is no reason to inject mercury into a young > child or anyone for that matter. Another thing you can do to help > prevent regression (and keep your son healthy) is to give him vitamins > and minerals to boost the immune system (I'm thinking C, E, zinc, > magnesium, and fish oils to name a few but I'm not a doctor or > nutritionist). And of course, you can go further and look into > biomedial treatments for apraxia and autism. > > If your feeling adventurous and have the cash to do it, you may want > to look into Dr. Amy Yasko's genetic testing and protocol at > www.autismanswer.com (no need to be dx) - it could shed some light on > why you and your brother have the sensory issues too. > > Kerri > > > I have to say that he acted very differently from my son...no eye > contact > > until 16, frequent and intense meltdowns over sensory things (like > > spinning signs), no pretend play, severe social issues...but the > family > > history makes it more of a possibility. Even is he is not autistic > > now, could he suddenly regress socially? > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 Thank you so much for this information. You have given me so much to think about. My mom actually has both lupas and arthritis. She is also from Rotterdam, Holland. She grew up in the city, which is full of industrial plants loaded with contaminants. I have always wondered if this may have had something to do with my brother's autism. > > > > , > > > > Was the test for mercury a blood test? > > > You usually cannot just " do a blood test " for mercury. If there has been recent exposure > (within the past six weeks) then an RBC mercury might be high. But usually mercury is > sequestered into the fat and brain tissues. Sometimes hair tests are done but be > warned...if other metals are high and mercury is low or near zero it may mean your child is > a " non-excretor " of mercury and these children have some of the worst ASD disorders. > When they receive chelation treatment a lot of mercury eventually comes out. > > Look for these things: are there a lot of autoimmune disease problems in your family > history? Lupus, arthritis, diabetes, ITP, scleroderma in any close relatives? Have you had > RhoGam injections in past pregnancies when it still had thimerosal mercury in it? Do you > have a lot of dental amalgams in your teeth? And the history of autism in your brother is a > warning sign. Your family may be one of those genetically vulnerable ones. Take care! > > And never, never vaccinate if a child is sick or feverish or even sniffly. Just say no! > Spreading out the vaccines and giving extra vitamin C is an option for some. We have > genetic humoral immune deficiencies in our family and my DGS had the live chickenpox > vaccine on his first birthday. He had ear infections and severe receptive and expressive > speech delay, oral-sensory problems, etc. and lost eye contact and joint attention right > after that. Just after his fourth birthday, he had shingles. And atypical pneumonia. His > pediatrician gave him acyclovir, and after two years of speech therapy, his articulation > suddenly became age-appropriate. > > ProEFA helped him before. But I saw such an awful regression between 9 months and 13 > months (coming in from out of state as a grandma) that I also blame the chickenpox > vaccine as well as a whole lot of other factors. He's older than your child so he got a > mercury-containing hep B vaccine at age one day. Our family is riddled with autoimmune > disease and mercury " allergies. " My late husband may have had Asperger's Syndrome. > > There may be multiple factors, but don't risk vaccinating the " everything at once " way or > too early, and look carefully at your family history. It will tell you more than a blood test. > Mady Hornig did a study with different strains of mice and some of them responded with > autistic-like behaviors to injections of thimerosal at exactly the same developmental > stages as we give, or used to give, mercury containing vaccines to infants. Some strains, > in fact most, were OK with the shots. Again, your family history will tell you more than a > blood test about your child's vulnerability. > > Peace, > Kathy E. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 Do you know which shots your son is scheduled to get? Has he ever had a bad reaction to any vaccines? It would be a miracle if your son's pediatrician actually took seriously your concerns about mercury poisoning. I have yet to visit an MD who does. Testing is tricky, because blood tests only test for recent exposure and urine and hair tests only pick up what is being excreted (and the problem is that some kids can't get rid of it). BUT, almost all vaccinations no longer contain the high amounts of mercury they once did - thankfully! Flu shots are a big offender still, as are the tetanus shots you'd get an older child (not the combo vaccination your son probably is getting or already got). I'd suggest doing a google search about the issue to look for a list you can compare to what your doctor is going to give him. In addition to vaccines, children can build up high levels of mercury from the air/water/polluted food sources - usually not too big of an issue, but if your son is not excreting it those levels can get dangerous quickly. MMR is a concern because it is a live virus, as is chickenpox (I think?). So let us know what shots he's to receive, and maybe someone more knowledgable can go through them with you. Kerri > > Wow. Thank you all so much for the information. My son will be two > next week and is schedulded to receive his next vaccinations shortly > after. I will discuss the mercury issue with his doctor before he > receives any vaccinations. Is mercury poisoning something that I can > ask his pediatrician to test for or will I have to go to a hospital? > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 You are right - looks like you have a family history of inflammatory and immune system problems (very typical for autism to run in these families too). Try not to worry. Start researching, find a good doctor, and I know you will be able to prevent your son from further harm and hopefully reverse the damage that's already happened! I've heard some absolutely amazing success stories with chelation. Check out the group chelatingkids2. Kerri > > > > > > , > > > > > > Was the test for mercury a blood test? > > > > > You usually cannot just " do a blood test " for mercury. If there has > been recent exposure > > (within the past six weeks) then an RBC mercury might be high. But > usually mercury is > > sequestered into the fat and brain tissues. Sometimes hair tests > are done but be > > warned...if other metals are high and mercury is low or near zero > it may mean your child is > > a " non-excretor " of mercury and these children have some of the > worst ASD disorders. > > When they receive chelation treatment a lot of mercury eventually > comes out. > > > > Look for these things: are there a lot of autoimmune disease > problems in your family > > history? Lupus, arthritis, diabetes, ITP, scleroderma in any close > relatives? Have you had > > RhoGam injections in past pregnancies when it still had thimerosal > mercury in it? Do you > > have a lot of dental amalgams in your teeth? And the history of > autism in your brother is a > > warning sign. Your family may be one of those genetically > vulnerable ones. Take care! > > > > And never, never vaccinate if a child is sick or feverish or even > sniffly. Just say no! > > Spreading out the vaccines and giving extra vitamin C is an option > for some. We have > > genetic humoral immune deficiencies in our family and my DGS had > the live chickenpox > > vaccine on his first birthday. He had ear infections and severe > receptive and expressive > > speech delay, oral-sensory problems, etc. and lost eye contact and > joint attention right > > after that. Just after his fourth birthday, he had shingles. And > atypical pneumonia. His > > pediatrician gave him acyclovir, and after two years of speech > therapy, his articulation > > suddenly became age-appropriate. > > > > ProEFA helped him before. But I saw such an awful regression > between 9 months and 13 > > months (coming in from out of state as a grandma) that I also blame > the chickenpox > > vaccine as well as a whole lot of other factors. He's older than > your child so he got a > > mercury-containing hep B vaccine at age one day. Our family is > riddled with autoimmune > > disease and mercury " allergies. " My late husband may have had > Asperger's Syndrome. > > > > There may be multiple factors, but don't risk vaccinating > the " everything at once " way or > > too early, and look carefully at your family history. It will tell > you more than a blood test. > > Mady Hornig did a study with different strains of mice and some of > them responded with > > autistic-like behaviors to injections of thimerosal at exactly the > same developmental > > stages as we give, or used to give, mercury containing vaccines to > infants. Some strains, > > in fact most, were OK with the shots. Again, your family history > will tell you more than a > > blood test about your child's vulnerability. > > > > Peace, > > Kathy E. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 > > , > > Was the test for mercury a blood test? > You usually cannot just " do a blood test " for mercury. If there has been recent exposure (within the past six weeks) then an RBC mercury might be high. But usually mercury is sequestered into the fat and brain tissues. Sometimes hair tests are done but be warned...if other metals are high and mercury is low or near zero it may mean your child is a " non-excretor " of mercury and these children have some of the worst ASD disorders. When they receive chelation treatment a lot of mercury eventually comes out. Look for these things: are there a lot of autoimmune disease problems in your family history? Lupus, arthritis, diabetes, ITP, scleroderma in any close relatives? Have you had RhoGam injections in past pregnancies when it still had thimerosal mercury in it? Do you have a lot of dental amalgams in your teeth? And the history of autism in your brother is a warning sign. Your family may be one of those genetically vulnerable ones. Take care! And never, never vaccinate if a child is sick or feverish or even sniffly. Just say no! Spreading out the vaccines and giving extra vitamin C is an option for some. We have genetic humoral immune deficiencies in our family and my DGS had the live chickenpox vaccine on his first birthday. He had ear infections and severe receptive and expressive speech delay, oral-sensory problems, etc. and lost eye contact and joint attention right after that. Just after his fourth birthday, he had shingles. And atypical pneumonia. His pediatrician gave him acyclovir, and after two years of speech therapy, his articulation suddenly became age-appropriate. ProEFA helped him before. But I saw such an awful regression between 9 months and 13 months (coming in from out of state as a grandma) that I also blame the chickenpox vaccine as well as a whole lot of other factors. He's older than your child so he got a mercury-containing hep B vaccine at age one day. Our family is riddled with autoimmune disease and mercury " allergies. " My late husband may have had Asperger's Syndrome. There may be multiple factors, but don't risk vaccinating the " everything at once " way or too early, and look carefully at your family history. It will tell you more than a blood test. Mady Hornig did a study with different strains of mice and some of them responded with autistic-like behaviors to injections of thimerosal at exactly the same developmental stages as we give, or used to give, mercury containing vaccines to infants. Some strains, in fact most, were OK with the shots. Again, your family history will tell you more than a blood test about your child's vulnerability. Peace, Kathy E. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 I think someone may have already answered this, but unless the exposure to the mercury was extremely recent, a blood test won't tell you anything. A hair test is the most non-invasive, easiest way of determining mercury poisoning. Mercury causes something called derranged mineral transport. Basically it messes up the body's ability to communicate with itself....holding on to too much zinc, not enough calcium, too much copper, or any number of things. A hair test can be read to determine the likelihood of derranged mineral transport. Other tests can be used to support the hair test, including urine and stool provocation tests, EKG's, and truly a host of options. Be aware that the most poisoned people will have very LOW levels of mercury being excreted in their hair and urine at first. Because they can't excrete it, they are poisoned. The most common mistake is reading a hair test with low mercury and thinking " oh, there's no mercury here...must be no problem " . Genetic reasons can play a role in why a person cannot excrete properly. My daughter carries the MTHFR genetic mutation that helps in the bodies abilty to detoxify. Additionally, a child on antibiotics while exposed to mercury cannot excrete it. Genetic suceptibility or not, antibiotics destroy the good flora of the intestines. The good flora excretes the mercury. Finally, antibioics cause yeast, which methylizes mercury and allows it to cross the blood brain barrier. Never believe anyone who says ethyl mercury (the kind in shots) can't get into the brain. Yes it can. Finally, consider what your child's true mercury exposure is/was. It's not just the shots, although that's the most damaging. Studies have shown autism rates to be higher in places with high mercury pollution. Also, if you have mercury (amalgam) fillings and/or have a high diet of tuna and fish while pregnant or nursing, the exposure multiplies. And the Rhogam shots (the Rh negative ones) also contain mercury to this day. Mercury is much more damaging to a fetus. 46% of mothers of autistic children surveyed had rhogam shots. If you are interested in purchasing a hair test, it's $93 from www.directlabs.com You need the hair essential elements one. From there, you can read the results with the help of a book by Dr. Hall Cutler called Hidden Hair Toxicities, available online. There are 5 counting rules that a hair test will follow if a person is poisoned. I can read the results very easily at this point if you are interested. Results from the hair test can get to you as soon as one week after you submit it. -------------- Original message -------------- From: kcventi <kcventi@...> , Was the test for mercury a blood test? julieobradovic@... wrote: Hi, My child also had multiple specialists calling her different things....her official diagnosis was high functioning PDD-NOS, moderate verbal apraxia, sensory processing disorder, severe speech delay, and hypotonia. She was very loving, had okay eye contact, and did not have meltdowns. None-the-less, she had issues...including excema and a very poor immune system. Long story short, after coming to this great list first and then branching out into the autism spectrum ones, we were able to diagnose her correctly. Beyond any reasonable doubt, unequivocally, no-mistaking it....she had mercury poisoning. Hair tests, urine tests, and stool tests all confirmed it. Chelating has reversed her conditions almost 100%. She will enter kindergarten in two weeks mainstreamed needing speech therapy once a week. I realize not everyone's child is like my daughter. I'm not saying all children with issues have to be mercury poisoned. She also had yeast issues and viral issues (making antibodies to the measles virus like crazy). But at the end of the day, mercury was her biggest problem. It's an avenue worth pursuing, even if it doesn't turn out to be your child's. It can't hurt to rule it out. If one was to line up all of the symptoms of mercury poisoning with all of the symptoms of the autism spectrum, including apraxia, ADD/ADHD, and many other of the disorders that plague our children, there are no differences. They aren't kind of similar...they are identical. Anyone interested in more info may email me off line. I'm happy to help. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 " I heard a therapist once describe the differences between a child on the spectrum vs not as ASD children were primarily involved/locked within their own heads/minds whereas a non autistic child was primarily involved in the world around him/her. Your child's social strengths are a good indicator of not being on the spectrum. " I like that phrasing - it makes it more clear. Disordered social interactions are a cornerstone of ASD, but that explanation makes it more understandable, in my humble opinion. Warm regards, ****************** (Rochester, NY) Mom to , 3.2 years, Verbal Apraxia & , 1 year ________________________________ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of kcventi Sent: Saturday, August 05, 2006 9:09 PM Subject: Re: [ ] Apraxia...Dyspraxia...Autism....I am so confused! I heard a therapist once describe the differences between a child on the spectrum vs not as ASD children were primarily involved/locked within their own heads/minds whereas a non autistic child was primarily involved in the world around him/her. Your child's social strengths are a good indicator of not being on the spectrum. Many symptoms overlap diagnoses (speech delays, sensory issues, learning disabilities, auditory processing, motor planning and tone) from autism to ADD to CP to many others. It is good you are getting OT,PT, SLP, reports. I would still suggest you find a good neuropsychologist to help you understand how your child's brain works, learns so that you can translate that information into a school education and service delivery plan (IEP). It takes time to get all this information together but over time working on these areas will make a difference for your child. " Shane H. " <robin.harmon@... <mailto:robin.harmon%40fuse.net> > wrote: If anyone can shed some light on this for me, I would be so grateful. I have been going through evaluations with my almost 24 month old son for about 4 months now. We started with his developmental pediatrician, then moved into the EI system's three, seperate evaluators, and lastly have sought out evaluations from our Children's hospital for ST, OT and soon PT. The dev. pediatrician did not feel he was on the ASD spectrum, but had a severe commuinication delay. The 1st SLP suspected severe verbal with moderate oral apraxia. The 2nd SLP said age appropriate receptive skills, severe expressive skills, with apraxic like symptoms. The OT says he has a mild hypotonia (truncal) and sensory issues and wants him to have a PT evaluation. So where does all of this lead me? I read the book the late talker. It explained that apraxic children often have a mild hypotonia and sensory issues, which may just peg my son to a tee. He has all the classic verbal issues...drooling, adding vowel sounds " up-ah " , lots of groping. However, I am confused. I have been doing research on a lot of different disorders, and cannot seem to figure out where the line is between some of them. If a child has verbal/oral apraxia, sensory issues, and a hypotonia, what is the main difference between this and dyspraxia? And then there is autism. So far, I hear that my son is not on the spectrum...but the sensory issues make me wonder (loves to touch the ends of his hair with his thumb, loves visual stuff like colors and is even advanced with this, sensory seeking with feet and hands). By the way - I actually have a lot of sensory issues and they still are a problem for me as an adult. It seems that a lot of the issues that apraxic children have can cross over to the autistic diagnosis, except for the social part? Is this correct? My son has no social issues that can be recognized yet. Good eye contact, loves other kids, pretend play, pointing, etc. His evaluations always include that he is " extremely social " . But I still wonder if he has some form of autism? I am so confused. The reason I am still wondering about autism is because my brother is autistic. I have to say that he acted very differently from my son...no eye contact until 16, frequent and intense meltdowns over sensory things (like spinning signs), no pretend play, severe social issues...but the family history makes it more of a possibility. Even is he is not autistic now, could he suddenly regress socially? I do not know what to look for anymore. Every evaluation is filled with so many questions...my head is spinning. Do I have to wait until he is three to really know what his challenges are and how to help him? Regardless of his label, I just want to get him the right kind of help so that he can have the brightest future possible. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 The only place you can get an actual accurate body burden of mercury besides the hair testing is from France. This will measure the porhyrin excretion that will indicate if you are dealing with toxicities, guarenteed to show the existence of mercury toxicity in the body.You do not need a physcian to order this for you. http://www.labbio.net/pages/index_vh_eng.htm The test is relatively cheap about $130. TOXICOLOGICAL HIGHLIGHT Porphyrinurias Induced by Mercury and Other Metals Bruce A. Fowler University of land, Toxicology Program, 1450 South Rolling Road, Baltimore, land 21227 ABSTRACT The article highlighted in this issue is " Quantitative Evaluation of Urinary Porphyrins as a Measure of Kidney Mercury Content and Mercury Body Burden during Prolonged Methylmercury Exposure in Rats " by D. Pingree, P. Lynne Simmonds, T. Rummel, and S. Woods. Biomarkers for toxic agents such as methylmercury are ideally early, chemical-specific biological responses to exposure of a target cell population which can be measured in accessible biological matrices such as blood or urine. Chemical-induced alterations in the heme biosynthetic pathway are among the those biomarkers of chemical exposure/toxic cell injury that have proven themselves both useful and reliable over a number of decades. This pathway, which is essential for life, produces heme, utilized for a host of hemoproteins including hemoglobin, the cytochrome P450 family, and mitochondrial cytochromes. There are a host of biological processes of direct toxicological interest which are dependent upon the heme biosynthetic pathway. The heme pathway is also highly sensitive to inhibition by a number of inorganic agents such as lead, mercury, and arsenicals as well as organic agents such as the chlorinated benzenes and alcohol. There is also a high degree of correlation between excretion of specific porphyrins in the urine and other ultrastructural/biochemical alterations in organelles, such as the mitochondrion, which contain a number of enzymes in the heme biosynthetic pathway (Fowler et al., 1987). This indicates the utility of porphyrinurias in detecting early stages of cell injury. As noted below, metal-induced disturbances in this pathway have also proven useful for examining the interactions between metals under mixture exposure conditions (Mahaffey et al., 1981, Conner et al., 1995). Over the years, measurement of lead-induced alterations in this pathway (e.g., blood delta-aminolevulinic acid dehydratase activity and measurement of erythrocyte zinc protoporphyrin) were used in making timely public health screening decisions for both workers and children exposed to lead-containing dust (Piomelli et al., 1987). These measurements have permitted physicians to ascertain that sufficient exposure to lead had occurred to produce a disturbance in an essential biochemical pathway and that a biological threshold had been crossed. The question of variability in individual susceptibility to alterations in the heme pathway by metals such as lead and mercury, as a function of the biologically active fraction of these metals, has remained a problem. The paper by Pingree et al. represents a major contribution towards addressing this question for a common organometal toxicant (methylmercury) which is of current public health concern. It examines the relationship between biological activity against the renal heme biosynthetic pathway and intracellular biological availability of CH3Hg+ and Hg2+ as monitored by sodium 2,3-dimercapto-1-propanesulfonic acid (DMPS) mobilization from the kidney. The import of these studies in a rodent species is not trivial for humans, since the heme pathway is highly conserved across species, and previous studies (- et al., 1995) have shown similar findings with regard to the observed porphyrinuria pattern. Methylmercury-induced porphyrinuria of renal origin was first described in rats (Woods and Fowler, 1977) at dose levels that did not produce signs of neurological dysfunction in this species. Subsequent studies in humans exposed to mercury vapor (- et al., 1995) showed similar findings. The study by Pingree and colleagues makes a substantial contribution toward a better understanding of the mechanisms underlying this unique porphyrinuria pattern. It also contributes to the field of metal toxicology in several specific areas. First, it defines a relationship between a biological effect (mercury-specific porphyrinuria pattern) and a target tissue dose of this element as measured by the relationship with the DMPS mobilizable fraction. The high degree of statistical correlation between renal mercury burden and porphyrin excretion in the urine indicates that the observed mercury-specific porphyrin excretion pattern may be reliably used as a noninvasive index of the total renal mercury burden. More specifically, the porphyrinuria pattern clarifies this relationship in terms of the biologically active fractions of CH3Hg+ and Hg2+ as evidenced by the strong statistical relationship between DMPS chelatable fractions and alterations in the observed porphyrinuria. It is also extremely valuable to be aware of the dose-related nature of the porphyrinuria pattern across a wide range of doses, both with regard to the consistency of the effects and with regard to potential applicability to a wide range of exposures, such as may be encountered in human populations. These findings are also important from the pharmacological perspective since they help to delineate the fraction of these 2 mercurial species being chelated and hence provide valuable data on the pharmacological efficacy of this chelating agent. This is also of basic scientific interest since it would suggest that DMPS is capable of chelating Hg2+ from the renal metallothionein pool normally found in rat kidney to bind zinc and copper. In addition, since the heme biosynthetic pathway is highly conserved across species, the ability to extrapolate these findings to man or other species of interest is obvious and is supported by the findings of - et al. (1995). Finally, it should be noted that a number of studies in the last 20 years have utilized specific metal porphyrinuria patterns as biomarkers of exposure to either a single metal (Woods and Fowler, 1977, 1978) or metal mixtures (Mahaffey et al., 1981; Conner et al., 1995). It will be of interest to determine if similar relationships exist between the biologically active fractions of these elements in their respective target tissues. It should be clear that the approach taken in the paper by Pingree et al. could be applied to other metal nephrotoxins which also produce relatively specific porphyrinuria patterns (e.g., for lead, using EDTA or DMSA as chelating test agents and for arsenicals, using perhaps BAL as a chelating test agent). The point here is that the approach taken in the paper by Pingree et al. could have broader applicability to a number of toxic metals, either alone or as mixture combinations. In summary, the results of this paper provide further evidence of the utility of chemical-induced alterations in the heme biosynthetic pathway as a reliable class of biomarker for delineating both the total tissue burden of a toxic substance such as methyl mercury and the intracellular bioavailability of reactive chemical species of this toxic agent. It should be noted that this approach could also be applied to evaluating the efficacy of new therapeutic agents such as chelators or perhaps agents which facilitate the excretion of toxic metals from the body. It is clear that this highly useful class of biomarker may have as yet undiscovered applications in delineating both the total tissue burden of toxic metals such as mercury and the biologically available fraction of reactive chemical species. NOTES For correspondence via fax: (410) 455-6314. E-mail: bfowler@.... REFERENCES Conner, E. A., Yamauchi, H., and Fowler, B. A. (1995). Alterations in the heme biosynthetic pathway from III-V semiconductor metal indium arsenide (InAs). Chem. Biol. Interact. 96, 273–285.[iSI][Medline] Fowler B. A., Oskarsson, A. and Woods, J. S. (1987). Metal- and metalloid-induced porphyrinurias: Relationships to cell injury. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 514, 172–182.[Medline] -, D., Maiorino, R. M., Zuniga-, M. Z., Xu, Z., Hurlbut, K. M., Junco-Munoz, P., Aposhian, M.M., Dart, R.C., Gama, J. H., Echeverria, D., Woods, J. S., and Aposhian, H. V. (1995). Sodium 2,3-dimercaptopropane-1-sulfonate challenge test for mercury in humans: II. Urinary mercury, porphyrins and neurobehavioral changes of dental workers in Monterrey, Mexico. J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther. 272, 264–274.[Abstract] Mahaffey, K. R., Capar, S. G, Gladen, B. C., and Fowler, B. A. (1981). Concurrent exposure to lead, cadmium and arsenic. Effects on toxicity and tissue metal concentrations in the rat. J. Lab. Clin. Med. 98, 463–481.[iSI][Medline] Piomelli, S., Seaman, C., and Kapoor, S. (1987). Lead-induced abnormalities in porphyrin metabolism: The relationship with iron deficiency. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 514, 278–288.[Medline] Woods, J. S., and Fowler, B. A. (1977). Renal porphyrinuria during chronic methyl mercury exposure. J. Lab. Clin. Med. 90, 266–272.[iSI] [Medline] Woods, J. S., and Fowler, B. A. (1978). Altered regulation of hepatic heme biosynthesis and urinary porphyrin excretion during prolonged exposure to sodium arsenate. Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol. 43, 361–371. [iSI][Medline] This article has been cited by other articles: K. L. Nuttall Interpreting Mercury in Blood and Urine of Individual Patients Ann. Clin. Lab. Sci., July 1, 2004; 34(3): 235 - 250. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------- This Article Abstract FREE Full Text (PDF) Alert me when this article is cited Alert me if a correction is posted Services Email this article to a friend Similar articles in this journal Similar articles in ISI Web of Science Similar articles in PubMed Alert me to new issues of the journal Add to My Personal Archive Download to citation manager Search for citing articles in: ISI Web of Science (2) Request Permissions Disclaimer Google Scholar Articles by Fowler, B. A. PubMed PubMed Citation Articles by Fowler, B. A. Online ISSN 1096-0929 - Print ISSN 1096-6080 Copyright © 2006 Society of Toxicology Oxford Journals Oxford University Press Site Map Privacy Policy Frequently Asked Questions Other Oxford University Press sites: Oxford University Press Oxford Journals Japan American National Biography Booksellers' Information Service Children's Fiction and Poetry Children's Reference Corporate & Special Sales Dictionaries Dictionary of National Biography Digital Reference English Language Teaching Higher Education Textbooks Humanities International Education Unit Law Medicine Music Online Products Oxford English Dictionary Reference Rights and Permissions Science School Books Social Sciences Very Short Introductions World's Classics > Hi, > > My child also had multiple specialists calling her different things....her official diagnosis was high functioning PDD-NOS, moderate verbal apraxia, sensory processing disorder, severe speech delay, and hypotonia. She was very loving, had okay eye contact, and did not have meltdowns. None-the-less, she had issues...including excema and a very poor immune system. > > Long story short, after coming to this great list first and then branching out into the autism spectrum ones, we were able to diagnose her correctly. Beyond any reasonable doubt, unequivocally, no- mistaking it....she had mercury poisoning. Hair tests, urine tests, and stool tests all confirmed it. Chelating has reversed her conditions almost 100%. She will enter kindergarten in two weeks mainstreamed needing speech therapy once a week. > > I realize not everyone's child is like my daughter. I'm not saying all children with issues have to be mercury poisoned. She also had yeast issues and viral issues (making antibodies to the measles virus like crazy). But at the end of the day, mercury was her biggest problem. It's an avenue worth pursuing, even if it doesn't turn out to be your child's. It can't hurt to rule it out. > > If one was to line up all of the symptoms of mercury poisoning with all of the symptoms of the autism spectrum, including apraxia, ADD/ADHD, and many other of the disorders that plague our children, there are no differences. They aren't kind of similar...they are identical. Anyone interested in more info may email me off line. I'm happy to help. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 Thank you so much for this information. You have given me so much to think about. My mom actually has both lupas and arthritis. She is also from Rotterdam, Holland. She grew up in the city, which is full of industrial plants loaded with contaminants. I have always wondered if this may have had something to do with my brother's autism. > > > > , > > > > Was the test for mercury a blood test? > > > You usually cannot just " do a blood test " for mercury. If there has been recent exposure > (within the past six weeks) then an RBC mercury might be high. But usually mercury is > sequestered into the fat and brain tissues. Sometimes hair tests are done but be > warned...if other metals are high and mercury is low or near zero it may mean your child is > a " non-excretor " of mercury and these children have some of the worst ASD disorders. > When they receive chelation treatment a lot of mercury eventually comes out. > > Look for these things: are there a lot of autoimmune disease problems in your family > history? Lupus, arthritis, diabetes, ITP, scleroderma in any close relatives? Have you had > RhoGam injections in past pregnancies when it still had thimerosal mercury in it? Do you > have a lot of dental amalgams in your teeth? And the history of autism in your brother is a > warning sign. Your family may be one of those genetically vulnerable ones. Take care! > > And never, never vaccinate if a child is sick or feverish or even sniffly. Just say no! > Spreading out the vaccines and giving extra vitamin C is an option for some. We have > genetic humoral immune deficiencies in our family and my DGS had the live chickenpox > vaccine on his first birthday. He had ear infections and severe receptive and expressive > speech delay, oral-sensory problems, etc. and lost eye contact and joint attention right > after that. Just after his fourth birthday, he had shingles. And atypical pneumonia. His > pediatrician gave him acyclovir, and after two years of speech therapy, his articulation > suddenly became age-appropriate. > > ProEFA helped him before. But I saw such an awful regression between 9 months and 13 > months (coming in from out of state as a grandma) that I also blame the chickenpox > vaccine as well as a whole lot of other factors. He's older than your child so he got a > mercury-containing hep B vaccine at age one day. Our family is riddled with autoimmune > disease and mercury " allergies. " My late husband may have had Asperger's Syndrome. > > There may be multiple factors, but don't risk vaccinating the " everything at once " way or > too early, and look carefully at your family history. It will tell you more than a blood test. > Mady Hornig did a study with different strains of mice and some of them responded with > autistic-like behaviors to injections of thimerosal at exactly the same developmental > stages as we give, or used to give, mercury containing vaccines to infants. Some strains, > in fact most, were OK with the shots. Again, your family history will tell you more than a > blood test about your child's vulnerability. > > Peace, > Kathy E. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 Do you know which shots your son is scheduled to get? Has he ever had a bad reaction to any vaccines? It would be a miracle if your son's pediatrician actually took seriously your concerns about mercury poisoning. I have yet to visit an MD who does. Testing is tricky, because blood tests only test for recent exposure and urine and hair tests only pick up what is being excreted (and the problem is that some kids can't get rid of it). BUT, almost all vaccinations no longer contain the high amounts of mercury they once did - thankfully! Flu shots are a big offender still, as are the tetanus shots you'd get an older child (not the combo vaccination your son probably is getting or already got). I'd suggest doing a google search about the issue to look for a list you can compare to what your doctor is going to give him. In addition to vaccines, children can build up high levels of mercury from the air/water/polluted food sources - usually not too big of an issue, but if your son is not excreting it those levels can get dangerous quickly. MMR is a concern because it is a live virus, as is chickenpox (I think?). So let us know what shots he's to receive, and maybe someone more knowledgable can go through them with you. Kerri > > Wow. Thank you all so much for the information. My son will be two > next week and is schedulded to receive his next vaccinations shortly > after. I will discuss the mercury issue with his doctor before he > receives any vaccinations. Is mercury poisoning something that I can > ask his pediatrician to test for or will I have to go to a hospital? > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 You are right - looks like you have a family history of inflammatory and immune system problems (very typical for autism to run in these families too). Try not to worry. Start researching, find a good doctor, and I know you will be able to prevent your son from further harm and hopefully reverse the damage that's already happened! I've heard some absolutely amazing success stories with chelation. Check out the group chelatingkids2. Kerri > > > > > > , > > > > > > Was the test for mercury a blood test? > > > > > You usually cannot just " do a blood test " for mercury. If there has > been recent exposure > > (within the past six weeks) then an RBC mercury might be high. But > usually mercury is > > sequestered into the fat and brain tissues. Sometimes hair tests > are done but be > > warned...if other metals are high and mercury is low or near zero > it may mean your child is > > a " non-excretor " of mercury and these children have some of the > worst ASD disorders. > > When they receive chelation treatment a lot of mercury eventually > comes out. > > > > Look for these things: are there a lot of autoimmune disease > problems in your family > > history? Lupus, arthritis, diabetes, ITP, scleroderma in any close > relatives? Have you had > > RhoGam injections in past pregnancies when it still had thimerosal > mercury in it? Do you > > have a lot of dental amalgams in your teeth? And the history of > autism in your brother is a > > warning sign. Your family may be one of those genetically > vulnerable ones. Take care! > > > > And never, never vaccinate if a child is sick or feverish or even > sniffly. Just say no! > > Spreading out the vaccines and giving extra vitamin C is an option > for some. We have > > genetic humoral immune deficiencies in our family and my DGS had > the live chickenpox > > vaccine on his first birthday. He had ear infections and severe > receptive and expressive > > speech delay, oral-sensory problems, etc. and lost eye contact and > joint attention right > > after that. Just after his fourth birthday, he had shingles. And > atypical pneumonia. His > > pediatrician gave him acyclovir, and after two years of speech > therapy, his articulation > > suddenly became age-appropriate. > > > > ProEFA helped him before. But I saw such an awful regression > between 9 months and 13 > > months (coming in from out of state as a grandma) that I also blame > the chickenpox > > vaccine as well as a whole lot of other factors. He's older than > your child so he got a > > mercury-containing hep B vaccine at age one day. Our family is > riddled with autoimmune > > disease and mercury " allergies. " My late husband may have had > Asperger's Syndrome. > > > > There may be multiple factors, but don't risk vaccinating > the " everything at once " way or > > too early, and look carefully at your family history. It will tell > you more than a blood test. > > Mady Hornig did a study with different strains of mice and some of > them responded with > > autistic-like behaviors to injections of thimerosal at exactly the > same developmental > > stages as we give, or used to give, mercury containing vaccines to > infants. Some strains, > > in fact most, were OK with the shots. Again, your family history > will tell you more than a > > blood test about your child's vulnerability. > > > > Peace, > > Kathy E. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 I think someone may have already answered this, but unless the exposure to the mercury was extremely recent, a blood test won't tell you anything. A hair test is the most non-invasive, easiest way of determining mercury poisoning. Mercury causes something called derranged mineral transport. Basically it messes up the body's ability to communicate with itself....holding on to too much zinc, not enough calcium, too much copper, or any number of things. A hair test can be read to determine the likelihood of derranged mineral transport. Other tests can be used to support the hair test, including urine and stool provocation tests, EKG's, and truly a host of options. Be aware that the most poisoned people will have very LOW levels of mercury being excreted in their hair and urine at first. Because they can't excrete it, they are poisoned. The most common mistake is reading a hair test with low mercury and thinking " oh, there's no mercury here...must be no problem " . Genetic reasons can play a role in why a person cannot excrete properly. My daughter carries the MTHFR genetic mutation that helps in the bodies abilty to detoxify. Additionally, a child on antibiotics while exposed to mercury cannot excrete it. Genetic suceptibility or not, antibiotics destroy the good flora of the intestines. The good flora excretes the mercury. Finally, antibioics cause yeast, which methylizes mercury and allows it to cross the blood brain barrier. Never believe anyone who says ethyl mercury (the kind in shots) can't get into the brain. Yes it can. Finally, consider what your child's true mercury exposure is/was. It's not just the shots, although that's the most damaging. Studies have shown autism rates to be higher in places with high mercury pollution. Also, if you have mercury (amalgam) fillings and/or have a high diet of tuna and fish while pregnant or nursing, the exposure multiplies. And the Rhogam shots (the Rh negative ones) also contain mercury to this day. Mercury is much more damaging to a fetus. 46% of mothers of autistic children surveyed had rhogam shots. If you are interested in purchasing a hair test, it's $93 from www.directlabs.com You need the hair essential elements one. From there, you can read the results with the help of a book by Dr. Hall Cutler called Hidden Hair Toxicities, available online. There are 5 counting rules that a hair test will follow if a person is poisoned. I can read the results very easily at this point if you are interested. Results from the hair test can get to you as soon as one week after you submit it. -------------- Original message -------------- From: kcventi <kcventi@...> , Was the test for mercury a blood test? julieobradovic@... wrote: Hi, My child also had multiple specialists calling her different things....her official diagnosis was high functioning PDD-NOS, moderate verbal apraxia, sensory processing disorder, severe speech delay, and hypotonia. She was very loving, had okay eye contact, and did not have meltdowns. None-the-less, she had issues...including excema and a very poor immune system. Long story short, after coming to this great list first and then branching out into the autism spectrum ones, we were able to diagnose her correctly. Beyond any reasonable doubt, unequivocally, no-mistaking it....she had mercury poisoning. Hair tests, urine tests, and stool tests all confirmed it. Chelating has reversed her conditions almost 100%. She will enter kindergarten in two weeks mainstreamed needing speech therapy once a week. I realize not everyone's child is like my daughter. I'm not saying all children with issues have to be mercury poisoned. She also had yeast issues and viral issues (making antibodies to the measles virus like crazy). But at the end of the day, mercury was her biggest problem. It's an avenue worth pursuing, even if it doesn't turn out to be your child's. It can't hurt to rule it out. If one was to line up all of the symptoms of mercury poisoning with all of the symptoms of the autism spectrum, including apraxia, ADD/ADHD, and many other of the disorders that plague our children, there are no differences. They aren't kind of similar...they are identical. Anyone interested in more info may email me off line. I'm happy to help. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 6, 2006 Report Share Posted August 6, 2006 " I heard a therapist once describe the differences between a child on the spectrum vs not as ASD children were primarily involved/locked within their own heads/minds whereas a non autistic child was primarily involved in the world around him/her. Your child's social strengths are a good indicator of not being on the spectrum. " I like that phrasing - it makes it more clear. Disordered social interactions are a cornerstone of ASD, but that explanation makes it more understandable, in my humble opinion. Warm regards, ****************** (Rochester, NY) Mom to , 3.2 years, Verbal Apraxia & , 1 year ________________________________ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of kcventi Sent: Saturday, August 05, 2006 9:09 PM Subject: Re: [ ] Apraxia...Dyspraxia...Autism....I am so confused! I heard a therapist once describe the differences between a child on the spectrum vs not as ASD children were primarily involved/locked within their own heads/minds whereas a non autistic child was primarily involved in the world around him/her. Your child's social strengths are a good indicator of not being on the spectrum. Many symptoms overlap diagnoses (speech delays, sensory issues, learning disabilities, auditory processing, motor planning and tone) from autism to ADD to CP to many others. It is good you are getting OT,PT, SLP, reports. I would still suggest you find a good neuropsychologist to help you understand how your child's brain works, learns so that you can translate that information into a school education and service delivery plan (IEP). It takes time to get all this information together but over time working on these areas will make a difference for your child. " Shane H. " <robin.harmon@... <mailto:robin.harmon%40fuse.net> > wrote: If anyone can shed some light on this for me, I would be so grateful. I have been going through evaluations with my almost 24 month old son for about 4 months now. We started with his developmental pediatrician, then moved into the EI system's three, seperate evaluators, and lastly have sought out evaluations from our Children's hospital for ST, OT and soon PT. The dev. pediatrician did not feel he was on the ASD spectrum, but had a severe commuinication delay. The 1st SLP suspected severe verbal with moderate oral apraxia. The 2nd SLP said age appropriate receptive skills, severe expressive skills, with apraxic like symptoms. The OT says he has a mild hypotonia (truncal) and sensory issues and wants him to have a PT evaluation. So where does all of this lead me? I read the book the late talker. It explained that apraxic children often have a mild hypotonia and sensory issues, which may just peg my son to a tee. He has all the classic verbal issues...drooling, adding vowel sounds " up-ah " , lots of groping. However, I am confused. I have been doing research on a lot of different disorders, and cannot seem to figure out where the line is between some of them. If a child has verbal/oral apraxia, sensory issues, and a hypotonia, what is the main difference between this and dyspraxia? And then there is autism. So far, I hear that my son is not on the spectrum...but the sensory issues make me wonder (loves to touch the ends of his hair with his thumb, loves visual stuff like colors and is even advanced with this, sensory seeking with feet and hands). By the way - I actually have a lot of sensory issues and they still are a problem for me as an adult. It seems that a lot of the issues that apraxic children have can cross over to the autistic diagnosis, except for the social part? Is this correct? My son has no social issues that can be recognized yet. Good eye contact, loves other kids, pretend play, pointing, etc. His evaluations always include that he is " extremely social " . But I still wonder if he has some form of autism? I am so confused. The reason I am still wondering about autism is because my brother is autistic. I have to say that he acted very differently from my son...no eye contact until 16, frequent and intense meltdowns over sensory things (like spinning signs), no pretend play, severe social issues...but the family history makes it more of a possibility. Even is he is not autistic now, could he suddenly regress socially? I do not know what to look for anymore. Every evaluation is filled with so many questions...my head is spinning. Do I have to wait until he is three to really know what his challenges are and how to help him? Regardless of his label, I just want to get him the right kind of help so that he can have the brightest future possible. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.