Guest guest Posted April 13, 2010 Report Posted April 13, 2010 I understand this very well. I think it's also some of the frustrating part about this disorder. Some of them have an ability to turn their charm on (or off) at times that are convenient for them. Would you think in your mother's case that 'high functioning' could be interpreted as 'faker, liar, sociopath?' My mother wasn't quite as able to control herself as yours was, but I could see her playing the pretend part of sanity many times. Eventually, people would catch on and she'd run them off for one reason or another after she showed her true colors. Even family members flew the other direction where she was concerned. I don't think my family members were in disbelief, but now that it's all over and my mother is gone, they sure are eager to tell me to 'get over it.' It makes me want to slap the crap out of them too. In a message dated 4/14/2010 1:48:29 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time, anuria-67854@... writes: You have described exactly what my younger Sister and I are up against, because our bpd/npd nada behaves in a very charming and appealing way to most of our relatives, and to her friends, neighbors, strangers, etc. Nada only targets me and Sister (and dad when he was alive) and her own older sister for verbal abuse. My nada is what is referred to as " high-functioning " My nada is what is referred to as " high-functioning " <WBR She saves up her rage and frustration to spew at Sister and me in private, and she'll attack her much-loathed older sister too when they are alone (or with me or Sister as witnesses). I have seen my nada lose her temper at *other* people and have a weepy public breakdown only a very few times in my lifetime; most of the time she is very in-control of herself. Nada's self-control makes it difficult for our other relatives to understand that Sister and I endured horrible emotional and physical abuse as kids and young people, and it makes it very difficult for them to understand the emotional abuse that Sister still has to put up with from nada. At least Sister and I can corroborate and validate each other's memories (for the most part) about our mother and how she treated us and still treats us. -Annie > > What do you do when your other close family members, such as aunts and grandparents just " know " that your parents are the most wonderful people and the most fantastic parents on the planet and that you are just a crazy, lazy, insensitive piece of work? > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 13, 2010 Report Posted April 13, 2010 You have described exactly what my younger Sister and I are up against, because our bpd/npd nada behaves in a very charming and appealing way to most of our relatives, and to her friends, neighbors, strangers, etc. Nada only targets me and Sister (and dad when he was alive) and her own older sister for verbal abuse. My nada is what is referred to as " high-functioning " , meaning she has a lot of control over how she behaves. She saves up her rage and frustration to spew at Sister and me in private, and she'll attack her much-loathed older sister too when they are alone (or with me or Sister as witnesses). I have seen my nada lose her temper at *other* people and have a weepy public breakdown only a very few times in my lifetime; most of the time she is very in-control of herself. Nada's self-control makes it difficult for our other relatives to understand that Sister and I endured horrible emotional and physical abuse as kids and young people, and it makes it very difficult for them to understand the emotional abuse that Sister still has to put up with from nada. At least Sister and I can corroborate and validate each other's memories (for the most part) about our mother and how she treated us and still treats us. -Annie > > What do you do when your other close family members, such as aunts and grandparents just " know " that your parents are the most wonderful people and the most fantastic parents on the planet and that you are just a crazy, lazy, insensitive piece of work? > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 All you can do is hold on to your truth - know that no one on this planet is in a position to tell you that your experiences aren't real. Also that other close family members have a huge stake in you getting back in your box so the current equilibrium can continue. One problem that happened for me that might happen for you or others I would mention. When I was NC with my nada, I ended up becoming closer with her sister, my aunt who at first appeared sympathetic. I ended up becoming far closer to her than was healthy for me - I guess in a way trying to get her to be a mother substitute. All that happened was I kind of ended up with two nadas instead of one because it turned out that my aunt was also emotionally unhealthy and supported my nada more than I realized. Be careful of who you let into your life to occupy the " mother space " if you are NC because it can be a very vulnerable time. > > What do you do when your other close family members, such as aunts and grandparents just " know " that your parents are the most wonderful people and the most fantastic parents on the planet and that you are just a crazy, lazy, insensitive piece of work? > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 It has helped me to remind myself that the close family members who just know for sure that my parents are wonderful people have a stake--*for themselves*--in believing this.Since this knowing is actually a fiction,their insistence is in their best interests,not in mine.My best interest lies in knowing the truth and acting/reacting accordingly. My paternal grandmother helped me when I was a child by being kind to me most of the time; by actually treating me like a kid.But she also betrayed me many times by not sticking up for me or going along with nada's version of me or of events.This is mainly because her son,my father,was becoming something of a ne'er do well and a hood at the time when he met nada and their relationship got him back on track.So in my grandmother's mind,nada was the " lovely girl " who had reformed her son.For her to accept the reality--that my nada was abusive-- would have hurt *her* too much.I think that stuff like this is about the family member's needs and we get sacrificed to them.It's not like they're going to be super honest and clear with themselves and say to themselves: Hey,wait,I think I have a blind spot here! Let me honestly examine it so I don't make so-and-so's kid responsible,so I don't engage in scapegoating.... Instead,they don't examine their bias.They don't examine themselves.They don't think it out clearly and consciously.They simply decide: so-and-so's kid is crazy...lazy...insensitive...Because it's easier and alot more comfortable for *me* to know that so-and-so is the most fantastic parent on the planet and *my* family is ok,it's just that one rotten kid... Call me cynical,but that's how it is in my FOO.One of my cousins got banished and condemned for daring to speak the truth about her father and I saw how it's not only me: it's the FOO dynamic.How could my cousin be such a horrible liar when we all know what a wonderful father X is? Not,of course,that she spoke her truth at great risk to herself and with absolutely nothing to gain by doing so but much to lose.She was a nasty liar and he was just wonderful.They needed to believe that because supporting my cousin as a truth teller would have upset the entire dynamic of denial that had allowed her abuse in the first place. My cousin was NOT lying nor horrible.They were lying to themselves. Hope that helps. > > What do you do when your other close family members, such as aunts and grandparents just " know " that your parents are the most wonderful people and the most fantastic parents on the planet and that you are just a crazy, lazy, insensitive piece of work? > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 I repeat " What other people think of me is none of my business " The Four Agreements: Do not take anything personally helps also May we all heal, C > > What do you do when your other close family members, such as aunts and grandparents just " know " that your parents are the most wonderful people and the most fantastic parents on the planet and that you are just a crazy, lazy, insensitive piece of work? > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 I just tell them they have no idea what went/goes on behind our closed doors Jackie What do you do when your other close family members, such as aunts and grandparents just " know " that your parents are the most wonderful people and the most fantastic parents on the planet and that you are just a crazy, lazy, insensitive piece of work? Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 my nada is the same way...in public, and in front of others she can control herself...but she waits until we're home, behind closed doors, and rages and attacks her children and husband. Outsiders haven't a clue, and would never believe what a horrible person nada is.. Jackie You have described exactly what my younger Sister and I are up against, because our bpd/npd nada behaves in a very charming and appealing way to most of our relatives, and to her friends, neighbors, strangers, etc. Nada only targets me and Sister (and dad when he was alive) and her own older sister for verbal abuse. My nada is what is referred to as " high-functioning " , meaning she has a lot of control over how she behaves. She saves up her rage and frustration to spew at Sister and me in private, and she'll attack her much-loathed older sister too when they are alone (or with me or Sister as witnesses). I have seen my nada lose her temper at *other* people and have a weepy public breakdown only a very few times in my lifetime; most of the time she is very in-control of herself. Nada's self-control makes it difficult for our other relatives to understand that Sister and I endured horrible emotional and physical abuse as kids and young people, and it makes it very difficult for them to understand the emotional abuse that Sister still has to put up with from nada. At least Sister and I can corroborate and validate each other's memories (for the most part) about our mother and how she treated us and still treats us. -Annie Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 Dear forinqsetc, I can't say what you should do specifically, obviously, and I'm pretty new around here and I don't know your whole story. My mom is very high-functioning, so the only people in the world who have first-handedly experienced her behavior to the best of my knowledge are my dad, mom, and sister. If you've tried to tell your family, your aunts and your grandparents, for example, about what your parents are like, and they are calling you crazy, insensitive, and lazy, then like other people said already, it's important to remember that they need to enforce the status quo for their own happiness- and that happiness is dearly bought for them to ignore the problem, or support it, because it's only going to hurt the people- your parents, and themselves, in the long run. If you haven't tried to tell your family about your parents, and they already have come to these conclusions, then it's either that your parents have established a reputation for you already, or they are so oblivious to what's going on that they don't see your parents behavior. For example, I recently told one of my mom's best friends, the same lady she volunteers with, teaches Sunday school with, and has been friends with for twenty some years, about my mom's behavior. She believed me- I'm lucky- but she said she never would have guessed this was happening. Twenty years, and for most of it my mom was coming home every day from work to act out horribly to us. Either way, if they've formed an opinion like this, you may not be able to convince them otherwise. I cried everytime over the course of a month whenever I thought about the fact that slowly alienating my mom from my life was the same as cutting off the family on her side that I grew up with. You are fighting for healthiness, and getting to that place where you rely first on yourself, and not on the opinions even of those that are close to you, is the best sanctuary I know of. What you do as far as I know, is trust yourself. If your family believes what you've said to be true, then know that they are also unhealthy, or totally ignorant. I used to not believe this but I know now that it -is- possible to be the only sane/healthy one in a room of family (or even friends). It can feel like the whole world and all the unjust things that are happening to you because of family are a lie, or made up in your head, and you are the confused one. I know the feeling- I felt like maybe I really was crazy. But then I got back in contact with my mom again and I remembered that I wasn't. Trust yourself (I know I keep saying it!)! Because what happened to you is all true, and it's wrong. Trying to escape it or trying to tell others is not hurtful, crazy, or insensitive. If no one believes you, then leave. I'm moving across the country, to build a life that's free of the (physically present) influences that I've chosen to be in my life. I don't even have a job yet, or anywhere else but a couch to sleep on. I know it might sound crazy (or not) but for a while I thought of myself as the vessel that needed to transport that small 'clear space-sanctuary' I talked about earlier in my head away from the situation. That sanctuary feels still in my head like the healthy seed that I can plant in a safe place to create a healthy life for myself. Trust yourself and validate yourself, you are right about what is happening to you, even when all these people you may have looked up to don't know or are willfully wrong. That's what I've got. Hope it helps somehow. -Spring (Who is going to be late for an exam if she does not hurry herself up. ) Oh, P.S. I know nobody here knows me yet, I've posted twice. But reading what others have posted makes me feel like I am already acquainted with a lot of people and their situations. I hope to get to know a lot of people around here. It's nice to know I'm not crazy. > > What do you do when your other close family members, such as aunts and grandparents just " know " that your parents are the most wonderful people and the most fantastic parents on the planet and that you are just a crazy, lazy, insensitive piece of work? > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 Yep, in addition to the " script " ( " look up BPD and then let's have a conversation " )- you can certainly tell them that you understand that their experience with Nada and Fada is quite different than what you experienced growing up as their child. In addition - You know that your grandparents, aunts and uncles have an experience with your parents that is much older than yours. They saw Nada and Fada as children, and there may be dysfunction in those memories as well. You can't know everything that went on before you were born, and family " stories " can be - umm, shall we say - " re-edited " - to put the family in the best light, or to reinforce family members' roles. So whatever your experience was, you can't necessarily overcome what these older relatives remember, or what their image of your parents is. It might take a lot of re-thinking for them to change their minds - or, as in the case of a lot of posters here, they might say, " yeah, we always knew there was something off kilter with your mom... " SO - you might have to accept that by going NC or LC, or just making a commitment to your own self-preservation, you are pretty much writing off members of your extended family. They might re-establish the relationship with you in future years, or maybe not. It might be part of the price you pay for getting free of BPD dysfunction. However, there are a million other people out there who can become your " family of choice. " You can start building your community, always insisting that your friends and acquaintances treat you with civility and respect. Once you have built another support system, maybe you won't feel the loss of the FOO so much. I don't know - my " real " relatives are just about all dead and my extended family wasn't close to my nuclear family (gee, what did they know???). My husband's extended family is great, but we see them rarely. His closest family members are hideous in their own warped way, so I refuse to become embroiled with them. Therefore, I depend heavily on my best friend and a community of other parents who have kids involved in my son's activities - school, etc. It serves the purpose. > > I just tell them they have no idea what went/goes on behind our closed doors > > Jackie > > > > What do you do when your other close family members, such as aunts and > grandparents just " know " that your parents are the most wonderful people and > the most fantastic parents on the planet and that you are just a crazy, > lazy, insensitive piece of work? > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 I think that you have a couple of choices in that situation, and which one is best depends on how enmeshed they are with your parents. If your relatives are enmeshed and insist on actively supporting your parents' bad behavior, then I don't think there's any option other then controlling your interactions with them just as you should be controlling your interactions with your parents. Having boundaries that you enforce and limiting or eliminating contact with them may be necessary. Nadas and fadas can and will turn other relatives into extensions of themselves with the aim of getting whatever they want. When that happens, you pretty much have to treat their minions as extensions of them. It is sad to have to lose other relationships, but you may have to do it to protect yourself. If your relatives aren't particularly enmeshed but rather are ignorant of your parents' bad behavior, you have more choices. (If they already " know " that you're crazy and lazy, then I fear they are enmeshed unfortunately.) You can attempt to educate them about BPD and what has happened and is still happening. Trying to do so carries a certain amount of risk that they'll simply turn against you and call you a liar. You can also agree to disagree with them and pretty much drop the subject. Some people are more willing to do that than others. If they're not willing to hear the truth and they're not willing to drop the subject, then you have to decide how much your relationships with them are worth to you. It is usually hard for people, even decent, caring people, to believe that those they care for are mentally ill and abusive to others. Most people just don't want to believe that kind of thing about people they care about. Believing it can disrupt their happy world and/or require them to take actions that they aren't comfortable with taking. The fact that my nada has no other family anywhere near here helps limit such problems for me. My uncles and cousins don't have enough contact with her to be enmeshed and caught up in her craziness, although one of my uncles probably has fada-like characteristics of his own. (He's always treated me well. The stories I've heard from a couple of my cousins tell a different story.) I deal with my brother by not talking about our mother much. He knows that our sister doesn't have contact with her and he knows that I have a lot of problems with how she's behaved over the years, but he appears to get along with her (Living on the other side of the country makes that easier for him.) I have no urge to rock the boat and harm my relationship with him, so I don't talk about it when I visit him. At 11:54 AM 04/12/2010 forinqsetc wrote: >What do you do when your other close family members, such as >aunts and grandparents just " know " that your parents are the >most wonderful people and the most fantastic parents on the >planet and that you are just a crazy, lazy, insensitive piece >of work? -- Katrina Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 You hit on one of the most crazy making parts of it. They can pull it together enough to put on apprearances. And apprearances, and perceptions, are everything to the BPs. When my folks divorced, it was as if my dad s FOO divorced me as well. I had my favorite uncle tell me I should go beat up my dads girl friend so he would come back to my mom. They play the victim so very well. Eventually, everyone they have a relationship with will vanish. They will drive away anyone who gets close and caught up in their web. But it is a sad reality of the KO, that we are often percieved by the FOO and friends for years as a Piece of Work. I have yet to hear of them coming back decades later and saying, OMG I m so sorry, how did you survive her. Doug > > What do you do when your other close family members, such as aunts and grandparents just " know " that your parents are the most wonderful people and the most fantastic parents on the planet and that you are just a crazy, lazy, insensitive piece of work? > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 This keyed in for me too. I had to be very careful about who got my information, and I kept to a largely underground mentality about the whole thing. I couldn't trust anyone. Nada told me I was dead to her and then kept using spies to find out how I was. When I got it all tied up, the one person left talking to me ... who I trusted most...ended up being the person she used to e-mail me after 13 years of silence. I was heartbroken. I agreed to contact, but I have never trusted her and right at the moment I am looking at going NC permanently. The irony of this? The person who gave me up and let her e-mail me...just told me not too long ago that he finally gets it. And now he's heartbroken, because he knows what he put me through and how bad it was. It's just hard. > > > > What do you do when your other close family members, such as aunts and grandparents just " know " that your parents are the most wonderful people and the most fantastic parents on the planet and that you are just a crazy, lazy, insensitive piece of work? > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 Agreed > > > > What do you do when your other close family members, such as aunts and grandparents just " know " that your parents are the most wonderful people and the most fantastic parents on the planet and that you are just a crazy, lazy, insensitive piece of work? > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 I've seen as close to an apology as I ever will...from ONE person. Who found himself subjected to the situation and it nearly destroyed his marriage and his family because he was so blind to it. When he told me, he was as ashamed as he was hurt by what he had allowed to happen as much as what he had endured. There is no sense of victory in this...it's just this devastating hurt that these people inflict on everyone around them. It makes me more and more convinced that the only way to deal with it is to get out. You may never get an apology or validation from anyone close...but I am thankful for this group...and my kids who have seen it. I tell you what...it's a huge relief. > > > > What do you do when your other close family members, such as aunts and > grandparents just " know " that your parents are the most wonderful people > and the most fantastic parents on the planet and that you are just a > crazy, lazy, insensitive piece of work? > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 Something that you wrote here , reminds me of how it would feel to take care of my mother in my house. I would have to pretend that my mother didn't have a problem and the we all should walk on egg shells so as not to upset my mother. We would have to alter ourselves to " pretend " that mother was " perfect " so that mother wouldn't turn into a whiny sulking bitch...or a self righteous person that makes everyone feel like they are doing it wrong. She loves to use the Bible to manipulate people to act right...while she is cleaver to conceal her own self under a mask. So what you wrote (I included the part below) reminded me of what I would have to do in order to have a relationship with my mother. I would have to lie to myself, because my mother " can't handle " the truth. I would have to make myself into a scapegoat, so that my mother might be " rescued " . I would have to distort my kids perception in order to remain in denial that this lady being in my home " can work " , just because of some one trying to tell me that God wants me to do this or expects me to. Just because of Guilt. Since telling my mother that I didn't want to take care of her and her response was " Well, Becky we never know what God's will is and so we can't tell what might happen. " just made it more clear that they were not listening to me. I have never hinted that I was going to take care of them. I also never took any money or support from my parent that I didn't pay back in two months time. Banks don't expect you to take care of them so I don't feel guilty here either. (Well I do or I wouldn't mention it. But I don't because when I borrowed the money my father told me that he thought I had no intention of paying it back. I later learned he had borrowed twice as much from my grandmother and never paid it back. The hypocrite.) These are my arguements that run around and around in my head so that I remain true to myself and my family to have NC with my nada. Becky >They needed to believe that because supporting my cousin as a >truth teller would have upset the entire dynamic of denial that had >allowed her abuse in the first place. > > My cousin was NOT lying nor horrible.They were lying to themselves. > > Hope that helps. > > > > > > > What do you do when your other close family members, such as aunts and grandparents just " know " that your parents are the most wonderful people and the most fantastic parents on the planet and that you are just a crazy, lazy, insensitive piece of work? > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 There was nothing I could do until she turned on them. While I was a teen, I BEGGED various family members to take me in. I tried to tell them what she was doing, and they were all taken in by her. EVERYONE thought that my mother was basically a saint for putting up with such a " troubled " kid. When I was a young woman, and I was in therapy, everyone was happy because I obviously had issues. When I cut off contact with my NADA, I was a horrible person. When SHE cut them all off, they came crying to me for explanations. When they reached out to her, and wanted to go visit, she was receptive....then she sent them all a batsh*t crazy letter accusing THEM of everything that she used to accuse me of. All of a sudden they turn to me for answers. My answer to them? " Welcome to my world " . I've cut myself off from my family. I'm 36 years old, and have my own healthy, very happy family. I plan on keeping it that way. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2010 Report Posted April 14, 2010 said... >>Eventually, people would catch on and she'd run them off for one reason or another after she showed her true colors. Even family members flew the other direction where she was concerned.<< I found this to be true, as well, in my own situation. (forgive me, I haven't read ahead yet and still have several dozen posts to get to!) I think that for many BPD's their illness manifests differently with their children and/or the people they live with or have a lot of close contact with. I know I grew up thinking nobody else saw the crazy, and this led me to think I was crazy. Even as a young adult, I found it so frustrating. Then two years ago, in my mid 30's, I went NC. That made a world of difference. It wasn't enough to just go NC, I had to learn to draw boundaries with my brother, father, and other relatives regarding nada. Nada is a champ at triangulating...using others to communicate with me. Even after NC started (which I kind of just DID, without announcing it to her or anyone else), this triangulating happened. My therapist helped me learn to say (and to believe!!) in various pieces and ways " Our relationship is about US, not about her and I. I don't want the situation with her to complicate OUR relationship, so let's leave her out of it. " And, when they were trying to pass along " your mother wants you to... " or whatever, I had to learn to say " She needs to be the one to communicate her needs/thoughts/opinions/information to me. That is not your job and it is unfair to your relationship with me. " They'd inevitably say " But she says you blocked her email! " and I say back " Yes, but that is her problem to solve, not yours, there are many other ways she can contact me. " Some of them push a few times, but I really worked hard to never ever respond to what nada was trying to say...that way, there was nothing for them to take back to her " Ninera said this or that to what you said " . Game over. I win. I also decided to just not complain about her to my relatives. I need to express that stuff, need to share it, need to get it out...so I use my therapist, this group, and specific trusted friends who are willing to hear that stuff and be supporting and nonjudging with me. I made a conscious effort to engage my other relatives in a relationship that was NOT based on nada, her behaviours, her lies, her distortions. And you know what? Most of them have come around! I've been able to get to know them FREE OF HER...without her meddling or controlling or intervening. And they have been able to get to know ME. It helps that one of my uncles has made a point of telling that side of the family " You need to get to know Ninera, she's not who you've been told she is. " And, without me as her target, nada has had to vent her crazy on others...so gradually other family members are distancing themselves from her as they start to feel more and more of the crazy directed at them. And that only helps. They hate it, and they see that while she is trashing me to them frequently, I'm not participating in that drama. I love it. And I totally admit that there's a small part of me happy dancing inside singing " Take that, nada. Eff you! " Ninera > > Subject: Re: Re: Other family members' disbelief > To: WTOAdultChildren1 > Date: Wednesday, April 14, 2010, 6:01 AM > I understand this very well. I think > it's also some of the frustrating > part about this disorder. Some of them have an ability to > turn their charm on > (or off) at times that are convenient for them. Would you > think in your > mother's case that 'high functioning' could be > interpreted as 'faker, liar, > sociopath?' > > My mother wasn't quite as able to control herself as yours > was, but I could > see her playing the pretend part of sanity many times. > Eventually, people > would catch on and she'd run them off for one reason > or another after she > showed her true colors. Even family members flew the > other direction where > she was concerned. I don't think my family members > were in disbelief, but > now that it's all over and my mother is gone, they > sure are eager to tell me > to 'get over it.' It makes me want to slap the crap > out of them too. > > > > > > > In a message dated 4/14/2010 1:48:29 A.M. Eastern Daylight > Time, > anuria-67854@... > writes: > > > > > You have described exactly what my younger Sister and I are > up against, > because our bpd/npd nada behaves in a very charming and > appealing way to most > of our relatives, and to her friends, neighbors, strangers, > etc. Nada only > targets me and Sister (and dad when he was alive) and her > own older sister > for verbal abuse. > > My nada is what is referred to as > " high-functioning " My nada is what is > referred to as " high-functioning " <WBR > > She saves up her rage and frustration to spew at Sister and > me in private, > and she'll attack her much-loathed older sister too when > they are alone > (or with me or Sister as witnesses). I have seen my nada > lose her temper at > *other* people and have a weepy public breakdown only a > very few times in my > lifetime; most of the time she is very in-control of > herself. > > Nada's self-control makes it difficult for our other > relatives to > understand that Sister and I endured horrible > emotional and physical abuse as kids > and young people, and it makes it very difficult for > them to understand the > emotional abuse that Sister still has to put up with > from nada. At least > Sister and I can corroborate and validate each > other's memories (for the > most part) about our mother and how she treated us > and still treats us. > > -Annie > > > > > > What do you do when your other close family > members, such as aunts and > grandparents just " know " that your parents are the > most wonderful people and > the most fantastic parents on the planet and that you > are just a crazy, > lazy, insensitive piece of work? > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 15, 2010 Report Posted April 15, 2010 I tried not to blame my family but I got to a point where I just did. I'd rather not but my brain just goes there for some reason. In a message dated 4/15/2010 11:17:38 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time, nasta444@... writes: Some family memebers don't want to get involve. They know that something is wrong with the Nada but for the sake of their own sanity they keep away. I never blamed them. ________________________________ From: " _Hummingbird1298@Humming_ (mailto:Hummingbird1298@...) " <_Hummingbird1298@Humming_ (mailto:Hummingbird1298@...) > To: _WTOAdultChildren1@WTOAdultChilWTO_ (mailto:WTOAdultChildren1 ) Sent: Thu, April 15, 2010 5:55:49 AM Subject: Re: Re: Other family members' disbelief I understand how other family members want to deny it all. I often wondered, in my family, if it was guilt for their lack of action when I was little. I'll never know for sure. My family has this 'get over it' attitude. My aunt told me, " you mother was sick...we all know that...its why we didn't come around. you need to move on. " I let her know that I didn't have the luxary of not coming around my mother when I was a child like she did and not to ever tell me to get over it again. I wanted to cuss her out, but I refrained. [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around _http://mail.http://ma_ (http://mail.yahoo.com/) [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] Quote
Guest guest Posted April 15, 2010 Report Posted April 15, 2010 Doesn't that drive you nuts? That people saw the crazy and didn't say anything? I have a cousin who is the same age as I am (literally...our bdays are a week apart). Her older sister and my nada get along like sick gangbusters. THis older sister, M, actually lived with my family for a year or so when I was 12 and it was pure hell. She was as nasty to me as nada, and violated boundaries all over the place. A couple of months ago my cousin and I were really talking about her sister M and my nada and she was opening up about how M was cruel to her and our other female cousin growing up. Then we talked about M's enmeshment with nada and my cousin says " Yeah, my mom and I talk about that a lot and how M is doing the same shit to her kids that your mom did to you and your brother. " Wait...what??!!! You all KNEW and you lived 2000 miles away and you still KNEW?? " Well, yeah. My mom always talked about how eventually you'd rebel and not want anything to do with your mother. " Good Lord. Why couldn't they have said something when I was 15? It sure would have helped back then to know that the crazy wasn't ME!! Ninera > > Subject: Re: Re: Other family members' disbelief > To: WTOAdultChildren1 > Date: Thursday, April 15, 2010, 12:52 PM > You know, though, you all might be > surprised when your nada dies how people > will tell you that they knew something wasn't right. I > really was > surprised. People would tell me, " oh, we knew your > mother had problems. " In that > nice, feeling me out kind of way. > > There was a friend of my mom's who had 2 daughters who were > the same ages > as me and my sister. The friend was divorced, my mom was > separated, so they > had a lot in common. One of the girl's recently found > me on Facebook and > has said all kinds of things she 'knew' about my > mother that I never realized > others noticed. > > Most people just wont say anything. Sadly. > > > In a message dated 4/14/2010 8:18:18 A.M. Eastern Daylight > Time, > sleddog@... > writes: > > > > > my nada is the same way...in public, and in front of others > she can control > > herself...but she waits until we're home, behind closed > doors, and rages > and > attacks her children and husband. Outsiders haven't a clue, > and would > never > believe what a horrible person nada is.. > > Jackie > > You have described exactly what my younger Sister and > I are up against, > because our bpd/npd nada behaves in a very charming and > appealing way to > most of our relatives, and to her friends, neighbors, > strangers, etc. Nada > only targets me and Sister (and dad when he was alive) and > her own older > sister for verbal abuse. > > My nada is what is referred to as > " high-functioning " My nada is what is > refer > of control over how she behaves. > > She saves up her rage and frustration to spew at Sister and > me in private, > and she'll attack her much-loathed older sister too when > they are alone > (or > with me or Sister as witnesses). I have seen my nada > lose her temper at > *other* people and have a weepy public breakdown only a > very few times in > my > lifetime; most of the time she is very in-control of > herself. > > Nada's self-control makes it difficult for our other > relatives to > understand > that Sister and I endured horrible emotional and > physical abuse as kids > and > young people, and it makes it very difficult for them > to understand the > emotional abuse that Sister still has to put up with > from nada. At least > Sister and I can corroborate and validate each > other's memories (for the > most part) about our mother and how she treated us > and still treats us. > > -Annie > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 15, 2010 Report Posted April 15, 2010 Some family memebers don't want to get involve. They know that something is wrong with the Nada but for the sake of their own sanity they keep away. I never blamed them. ________________________________ To: WTOAdultChildren1 Sent: Thu, April 15, 2010 5:55:49 AM Subject: Re: Re: Other family members' disbelief  I understand how other family members want to deny it all. I often wondered, in my family, if it was guilt for their lack of action when I was little. I'll never know for sure. My family has this 'get over it' attitude. My aunt told me, " you mother was sick...we all know that...its why we didn't come around. you need to move on. " I let her know that I didn't have the luxary of not coming around my mother when I was a child like she did and not to ever tell me to get over it again. I wanted to cuss her out, but I refrained. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 15, 2010 Report Posted April 15, 2010 I dont blame you, I would probably be NC with them since they didnt care enough to protect us.. I dont need or want people in my life who dont care about me. And thanks tyo nada, I dont have strong family ties...we never lived near family, I only saw them once in a great while...The pictures of my brother ( the golden child) showed we went back there 3 times between 1955-1972 and I remember the rest... Jackie Yep. I am angry too. Especially at the adults who knew. ESPECIALLY at my family. Their " move on " comments piss me off even more! Quote
Guest guest Posted April 15, 2010 Report Posted April 15, 2010 same with me..I keep telling myself back then , people didn't get involved, not even when it was family, and they had their own families and things to do/take care of...but still, it hurts that others knew and saw and still did nothing...I KNOW our neighbors had to have heard...our windows were open in summer, and the houses were real close together.. Jackie I tried not to blame my family but I got to a point where I just did. I'd rather not but my brain just goes there for some reason. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 15, 2010 Report Posted April 15, 2010 Yea, , you GO girl! My nada was in a psychotic break for the last 3 days of her life, having auditory halluciations. People were agreeing with her that they heard it too just to avoid arguments. And many said, when I alluded to her emotional problems , yea, we knew she struggled with something. It is SO easy for them to say, wow, the old gal was a little screwy but we nodded and went along. But they were not children who were trapped inside it 24/7/365 for their entire lives. In fairness, I hope to think that if any of them had to spend a few days in our world, they would have kidnapped us and run for it. But the fact is, they were ready to say, wow she s sort of off, but nice enough in the right circumstances. And leave us to deal with it. For the rest of our freaking lives. Thanks a lot everyone. We ll see you in 40 years or so, after we finish therapy. Doug > > Yep. I am angry too. Especially at the adults who knew. ESPECIALLY at my > family. Their " move on " comments piss me off even more! > > > > > In a message dated 4/15/2010 9:19:01 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time, > sleddog@... writes: > > > > > if the family or long time friends say anything like that to me...I may > have to say something like, then why didn't you try and help us abused > kids > ?? or something...?? or something...<WBR>.I think I'd really be angry , > knowing > nothing > > Jackie > > You know, though, you all might be surprised when your nada dies how people > will tell you that they knew something wasn't right. I really was > surprised. People would tell me, " oh, we knew your mother had problems. " > In > that > nice, feeling me out kind of way. > > There was a friend of my mom's who had 2 daughters who were the same ages > as me and my sister. The friend was divorced, my mom was separated, so they > had a lot in common. One of the girl's recently found me on Facebook and > has said all kinds of things she 'knew' about my mother that I never > realized > others noticed. > > Most people just wont say anything. Sadly. > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted April 15, 2010 Report Posted April 15, 2010 I found this on youtube and it's about how to deal with difficult people. He's not talking about people with BPD ofcourse, but it's just nice to get some insight as of how to deal with the challenging personalities. He's a funny munk ________________________________ To: WTOAdultChildren1 Sent: Thu, April 15, 2010 10:12:19 AM Subject: Re: Re: Other family members' disbelief  I tried not to blame my family but I got to a point where I just did. I'd rather not but my brain just goes there for some reason. In a message dated 4/15/2010 11:17:38 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time, nasta444yahoo (DOT) ca writes: Some family memebers don't want to get involve. They know that something is wrong with the Nada but for the sake of their own sanity they keep away. I never blamed them. ____________ _________ _________ __ From: " _Hummingbird1298@ Humming_ (mailto:Hummingbird1298@ aol.com) " <_Hummingbird1298@ Humming_ (mailto:Hummingbird1298@ aol.com) > To: _WTOAdultChildren1@ WTOAdultChilWTO_ (mailto:WTOAdultChildren1@ yahoogroups. com) Sent: Thu, April 15, 2010 5:55:49 AM Subject: Re: Re: Other family members' disbelief I understand how other family members want to deny it all. I often wondered, in my family, if it was guilt for their lack of action when I was little. I'll never know for sure. My family has this 'get over it' attitude. My aunt told me, " you mother was sick...we all know that...its why we didn't come around. you need to move on. " I let her know that I didn't have the luxary of not coming around my mother when I was a child like she did and not to ever tell me to get over it again. I wanted to cuss her out, but I refrained. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 16, 2010 Report Posted April 16, 2010 " For the rest of our freaking lives. Thanks a lot everyone. We ll see you in 40 years or so, after we finish therapy. " @ Doug...LMAO!! Dude...you're a trip. --LL. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.