Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Kirkman contamination

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

I like you got the letter from them yesterday but I knew about since last Monday. And like you I am scared of using there Zinc again, I cant believe they would let something like this happen, we are here trying to ckean out and repair our kids systems and they sell us defective supplements, I called his DAN right away to see if we could test Peanut for this or in what way would this effect him, but I made an apt to see him this 25th so I hope this doesn't cause problems cause they will be hearing from me if it does!

Subject: Re: Kirkman contaminationTo: mb12 valtrex Date: Tuesday, January 12, 2010, 1:48 PM

In regards to the Kirkman recall, our son was also taking some of their contaminated vitamins. I learned about it on other boards, and I was the original poster of the info here on this board. I spoke with Larry Newman, the COO, late last week about the whole situation and finally ended up getting the recall info (same letter as the one Lucia posted below) directly from Kirkman via email last night (Mon night)...which was well after their Dec. 30th letter originally informing certain customers/distribut ors. I thought I'd share some of the things I've learned and were disturbing to me about the whole situation:--I asked Mr. Newman why some distributors/ customers got a letter about the recall put out on Dec 30th letter and others didn't. He said, "The information is now on the website" and "emails are going out." I found it hard to believe that in this day and age, it took an entire WEEK to get it on their website (especially when I

learned about it from other parents over the internet!). He said they had to follow FDA protocols, however, what I found incredibly disturbing is why some people got the info directly and others didn't. When I first heard about it, I immediately called our local compounding pharmacy, who is a Kirkman distributor, and they had no idea about the recall at all, I had to actually tell them the items that were recalled. I told that to Mr. Newman, and he said, "Well, they're one of our smaller distributors, so the information is probably in route". Mr. Newman told me that they contacted their "biggest distributors first" (I'm not sure why everyone couldn't have been made aware about it at the same time). Interestingly I also spoke to a rep at ourkidsASD.com (who is probably a pretty darn big distributor) , and she said that they had only gotten the info from Kirkman 2 days before.--Mr. Newman also had the audacity to say something about the holidays

delaying things. ly, IMO they should have been working OVERTIME over the holidays to address this situation and get the information out, especially when they KNEW about the problem, and kids like mine were taking contaminated vitamins. --When I first called Kirkman after hearing about the recall, one customer rep told me that only certain lots were affected. But when I called back a few minutes later, another one said that ALL lots were affected. IMO, all parents should call wherever they purchased ANY of these products (all lots, it doesn't matter), and the place where you bought them from will give a refund. I personally didn't feel safe giving ANY Kirkman products with stevia, even the ones that weren't on the recall, so I threw those right out.--I also asked Mr. Newman why they were using stevia from China in the first place. He didn't have a good answer for that, he said something about how most stevia comes from China. I told

him that parents expected highest quality from Kirkman's, and with the price of their supplements, they should have gotten their stevia from other places instead, not China who is known for such contamination problems in general. --When I returned my supply of chewable Vit C tablets to the pharmacy, I noticed that labels said "Country of Origin USA". I'm not a lawyer, so I don't know all the laws governing product labeling and what determines the "Country of Origin", but based on the whole situation, I thought the labeling was very misleading, in my humble opinion as a parent who goes out of my way to try and purchase safe, effective supplements. The whole thing makes me furious when I think about the number of kids who were most likely affected and how the information was disseminated SO slowly on Kirkman's part, especially when they knew about the problem. IMO I think there should be some kind of class-action lawsuit, the way Kirkman

has handled this has been unconscionable, and, and as another parent mentioned on another board, criminal. Not sure if any of this is helpful to anyone, but I thought I'd post it since I'm sure many other parents are feeling the exact same anger about the whole mess as I am!> >> > Not sure if this has already been posted here (saw it on several other lists and didn't think I saw it here, but I apologize if it is a repeat). Just passing it on for those of you who use Kirkman.> > > > >The following Kirkman products have been contaminated with antimony:> > >- Liquid Zinc> > >- Super NT Powder w/o A & D> > >-

DMAE Chewables> > >- Super NT orange> > >- B complex pro support> > >- TMG w folinic acid> > >- chewable vit. c> > > > >The contamination is reported to come from stevia sourced in China. >Please contact Kirkman if you are using these products to verify >lot/batch numbers.> >>

Posted

That truly sucks, but I am so glad I stopped using it, now I dont know if should just stop using everything from them!!!!! I am so confused : (

From: Nanci <smiths4himyahoo (DOT) com>Subject: Re: Kirkman contaminationTo: mb12 valtrex@ yahoogroups. comDate: Thursday, January 7, 2010, 11:44 AM

What I find more disturbing about this is that there is nothing posted on their website either. I am signed up to get their emails and I did not receive anything from them about this, but they do send about specials and promos. I wouldn't have known if you hadn't posted this.Thankfully my son is not on any of the recalled products, but I am sure there are many here whose children are.>> Not sure if this has already been posted here (saw it on several other lists and didn't think I saw it here, but I apologize if it is a repeat). Just passing it on for those of you who use Kirkman.> > >The following Kirkman products have been contaminated with antimony:> >- Liquid Zinc> >- Super NT

Powder w/o A & D> >- DMAE Chewables> >- Super NT orange> >- B complex pro support> >- TMG w folinic acid> >- chewable vit. c> > >The contamination is reported to come from stevia sourced in China. >Please contact Kirkman if you are using these products to verify >lot/batch numbers.>

Posted

That truly sucks, but I am so glad I stopped using it, now I dont know if should just stop using everything from them!!!!! I am so confused : (

From: Nanci <smiths4himyahoo (DOT) com>Subject: Re: Kirkman contaminationTo: mb12 valtrex@ yahoogroups. comDate: Thursday, January 7, 2010, 11:44 AM

What I find more disturbing about this is that there is nothing posted on their website either. I am signed up to get their emails and I did not receive anything from them about this, but they do send about specials and promos. I wouldn't have known if you hadn't posted this.Thankfully my son is not on any of the recalled products, but I am sure there are many here whose children are.>> Not sure if this has already been posted here (saw it on several other lists and didn't think I saw it here, but I apologize if it is a repeat). Just passing it on for those of you who use Kirkman.> > >The following Kirkman products have been contaminated with antimony:> >- Liquid Zinc> >- Super NT

Powder w/o A & D> >- DMAE Chewables> >- Super NT orange> >- B complex pro support> >- TMG w folinic acid> >- chewable vit. c> > >The contamination is reported to come from stevia sourced in China. >Please contact Kirkman if you are using these products to verify >lot/batch numbers.>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...