Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Re: New Michigan PT Administrative Rules (11/29/10)

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

I appreciate everyone's input on this, as well as the efforts and aim of

the MI BOPT's (and Mr. 's) actions. I am not in any way trying to

" beat up " on the BOPT or Mr. , as Don put it, but I am looking for

a legal loop-hole. Not for myself, however, but to prepare for others

attempts to horde in on the practice of PT.

I don't believe ATC's can serve as PT's nor PTA's, nor did I see anyone

in this discussion try to promote that they were equal in any way to

PT's or PTA's.

The fact that the AG's office is now involved, as well as the fact that

this discussion exists, seems proof enough to me that there is in fact

some grey area in the administrative rules. I have no doubt on what the

intention's of the BOPT and MPTA are. However going strictly by the

administrative rules, it doesn't seem that this has been achieved.

I don't pretend to understand the difficulty in drafting these rules,

nor do I wish to take away from the efforts of Mr. and everyone

else involved. I am just looking at areas that may leave us open to

other professions taking away from our field of practice. My hope is

that the AG comes back with a definitive answer and we can put this to

rest. (probably wishful thinking)

D. Nanzer, DPT, MBA, CSCS

Lansing, MI

>>> Gobble Gobble 12/23/2010 11:47 AM >>>

Hello Selena and Group,

I really do not understand why you wish to beat up the Michigan BOPT

and

in particular. It appears that they are only giving you information to

assist

you in understanding the " Rules " and the " Context " in which the " Rules "

are

written.

Please, remember that it not within the Michigan BOPT to endorse others

opinions

(as has been stated in several posts).

I appreciate that these facts do not seem to refect your opinion.

Personally, I do not find them very difficult to understand. Also,

personally,

I do not believe that ATC's delivering PT interventions should be done

so

without Direct Supervision (just as cited in the " Rules " ) as they are

" unlicensed " under the Michigan BOPT.

You see, " hair dressers " are licensed as well, but cannot perform PT

intervention either. I have friends that are " hair dressers " and I

respect them

and they are nice people, but they are not equivalent to a Physical

Therapist.

ATC's are not equivalent to PT's or PTA's either. If they were, they

would be

called PT's. Again, it seems fairly simple to me. It not to say that

ATC's

done have skills, but it is not the same skills and knowledge base of

the

Physical Therapist.

Well, I suppose there are many others with other opinions, but to me to

think of

an ATC as a PT is greatly depreciating the profession of Physical

Therapy.

Just my thoughts and opinions.

I wish everyone (including you, Selena) a great holiday season!

Don, PT

Michigan

----Original Message----

To: PTManager

Sent: Thu, December 23, 2010 6:52:26 AM

Subject: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules

(11/29/10)

,

Of course the MI Board was highly involved and did the leg work... but

the MPTA

was also involved - there were meetings and discussions. The Michigan

Athletic

Training Society was also involved in some way.

Obviously, there is gray. If there wasn't gray, there wouldn't be so

many

questions and the Michigan Board would stick out its neck, support the

MPTA

interpretation and make a public statement OR the Michigan Public

Health

Department would. Here's the latest update:

The following comment was recently received from Rae Ramsdell,

Regulatory

Division Director at the MDCH:

" Neither the MDCH nor the Board of Physical Therapy has issued an

opinion,

interpretation or comment regarding the statement issued by the

Michigan

Physical Therapy Association's statement regarding the PTA rules and

the

delegation of interventions to unlicensed individuals. Th

e MDCH has

received

numerous calls from both Athletic Trainers and Physical Therapists with

regard

to this issue. We have asked our legal representative from the Attorney

General's office to look into this issue and are awaiting that

response. The

MDCH has not expressed either agreement or disagreement with the MPTA

statement,

which at this time is solely its own opinion and does not represent an

interpretation of the rule by the MDCH. "

When someone's heart and passion are involved, it is difficult to take

a step

back and take a look at what is really written. I didn't write the

thing and I'm

not word-smithing it. I shared exactly where the problem originates and

where

the " gray " exists. I also haven't seen a single poster looking for a

loop-hole.

Questioning what is written to understand is not creating a loop-hole.

Sharing

an interpretation of what is written, isn't creating a loop-hole

either.

If athletic trainers were not licensed in the state of MI, your below

interpretation would be most accurate. But... things changed in 2010

and

athletic trainers became licensed (well, they will need to be licensed

by 2011

and thereafter).

It'll be interesting to learn the Michigan Attorney General's

interpretation.

The poor guy is going to have to wordsmith it, you know - that's what

attorneys

do... ;)

Selena Horner, PT

ton, MI

----Original Message----

In PTManager , DAVID PERRY <dperrypt@...wrote:

Selena,

The Michigan Board of Physical Therapy and the Michigan Physical

Therapy

Association are separate entities. The Board of Physical Therapy

developed the

Administrative Rules, which went through an exhausive public approval

process.

The language used is consistent with FSBPT and APTA positions/policies,

and it

also satisfies the regulatory components within Michigan state

government. I

participated in the writing of the Rules, which was completed fully

independent

of MPTA. MPTA's interpretation of the adopted Rules was developed to

serve as a

guide for it's membership. While I personally feel it's a good start, I

still

encourage all licensed PTs and PTAs in Michigan to read the rules and

law

themselves, and not be reliant on others interpretations. You may see

more gray

in the rules than do I, as I see it clearly stated that only PTs and

PTAs

perform physical therapy interventions. An ATC, working in a physical

therapy

setting, serves as an unlicensed aide, and would be delegated by me to

provide

support functions with a patient and not skilled physical therapy

interventions.

Along with anyone else who is not a licensed PT or PTA. And my

supervison of

them would need to be direct on-site. Pretty black and white to me.

To date the only ones I know that are complaining are a few Athletic

Trainers or

those PTs who have inappropriately used them as PTA substitutes in

years past

due to the lack of PTA regulation in Michigan. Much traffic has been

on this

listserve the past few days regarding the WSJ article about the abuse

by

physicians billing for physical therapy when no physical therapists are

involved. Are we PTs any different when we bill for skilled physical

therapy

provided by other than a PT or PTA? The use of " aides " to provide

physical

therapy interventions has been a slippery slope for years. At least in

Michigan,

the new Administrative Rules were developed by the Board of Physical

Therapy to

end that element of potential abuse, and to raise the practice bar to

be

consistent with professional standards.

I don't see the gray, sorry you do. I'm constantly amazed by our

society's

penchant for trying to find a loop-hole in word-smithing. IÂ recommend

all to

read the Public Health Code and PT Administrative Rules leaving their

color

pallet aside, for what it says, and not what they wished it said. And

focus on

promoting physical therapy in it's purest professional form, the

treatment of

patients by physical therapists and physical therapist as

sistants.

Happy Holidays to All

W. , PT, MS

Grosse Pointe Woods, MI

PTA Program Chair, Baker College of Park

Therapeutics

Chair, Michigan Board of Physical Therapy

begin_of_the_skype_highlighting

end_of_the_skype_highlighting

david.perry@...

" And in the end it's not the years in your life that count. It's the

life in

your years. " Abraham Lincoln

" A person who never made a mistake never tried anything new. " Albert

Einstein

----Original Message----

To: PTManager

Sent: Tue, December 21, 2010 8:39:19 PM

Subject: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules

(11/29/10)

, your interpretation is really skewed toward the interpretation

the MPTA

rolled out. If you read the language in the actual rule and not what

MPTA would

like you to believe, you'll see the gray.

Let's start with the definitions:

R 338.7121 Definitions.

(d) " Intervention " means the purposeful and skillful interaction of the

physical

therapist or physical therapist assistant with the patient or client

and, if

appropriate, with other individuals involved in the care of the patient

or

client, using various physical therapy methods and techniques to

produce changes

that are consistent with the diagnosis and prognosis.

Via the definition of " intervention " the door is opened for interaction

of

" other individuals " in the care of the patient or client besides

physical

therapists and physical therapist assistants. Because of the

long-winded

description and the use of prepositions, the language creates two

situations. 1)

The PT or PTA interacts with the patient/client AND with caregivers of

the

patient/client or 2) The PT or PTA interacts with the patient/client

AND with

other staff members within the organization providing services.

This administrative rule definitely defines the roles of physical

therapists and

physical therapist assistants. The rule doesn't define or describe all

the

" other individuals " involved in the care of the patient or client. We

know there

are " other individuals " because the rule does discuss delegation to

" unlicensed "

individuals. The issue lies in the simple fact that " other individuals "

involved

in the care of the patient or client could potentially be licensed

athletic

trainers.

The intent of what MPTA probably wanted written and the language of

what was

actually written are two different things.

I'll be interested in the Michigan Attorney General's interpretation.

Selena Horner, PT

ton, MI

----Original Message----

In PTManager , DAVID PERRY <dperrypt@wrote:

I encourage every Michigan physical therapist and physical therapist

assistant

to read for themselves the PT Administrative Rules that went into

effect

November 29, 2010, and not rely on interpretation by others.

http://www.state.mi.us/orr/emi/admincode.asp?AdminCode=Single & Admin_Num=33807101\

& Dpt=CH & RngHigh=>=

Keep in mind these Administrative Rules describe the practice of

physical

therapy. The rules are specific that, within physical therapy practice,

that

only PTs and PTAs are considered licensed. All others utilized in a

physical

therapy setting in Michigan fall under the unlicensed category

(including ATC,

Exercise Physiologists, Massage Therapists, Aide, Tech, etc). Those

other

entities may be considered licensed under their own discipline if

so

licensed. But these Rules only define what is physical therapy.

The Rules are also specific that only PTs and PTAs perform physical

therapy

interventions, a term which is defined in the Rules. Acts, tasks and

functions

is a term used in the general provisions of the Michigan Public Health

Code,

which while not specifically defined in the PT Administrative Rules,

should be

considered to mean all other activities except Interventions as

defined.

Please though, read the original document and not rely on others

interpretation

of

it. For it is the Public Health Code and accompanying Administrative

Rules

for your specific license for which a licensed individual is held

accountable.

W. , PT, MS

Grosse Pointe Woods, MI

PTA Program Chair, Baker College of Park

Therapeutics

Chair, Michigan Board of Physical Therapy

begin_of_the_skype_highlighting             Â

Â

   Â

 end_of_the_skype_highlighting

david.perry@

" And in the end it's not the years in your life that count. It's the

life in

your years. " Abraham Lincoln

" A person who never made a mistake never tried anything new. " Albert

Einstein

----Original Message----

From: Nanzer <michael.nanzer@>

To: PTManager

Sent: Mon, December 20, 2010 6:38:51 AM

Subject: Re: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules

(11/29/10)

I agree with Terry and Selena, the rule would be much less ambiguous if

they had

delineated licensed vs unlicensed better. Explaining it on the members

only

section of the MPTA seems to do little since the part that will be

legally

enforced (the administrative rule I initially linked to, and the one

available

to the public) does not define it. The rule is also ambiguous on what

constitutes an " act, task, or function " which it does state unlicensed

persons

can do.

As I see it, we are all waiting for the Michigan Attorney General's

interpretation. After which, I am sure there will be much more room for

debate.

D. Nanzer, DPT, MBA, CSCS

Supervisor

Athletic Training Department & SportsMed Physical Therapy Center

Ingham Regional Medical Center

Direct

----Original Message----

Rick Gawenda <rick0905@12/11/2010 9:10 PM >>>

That interpretation can be found on the members only Section of the

MPTA website

as that is what MPTA is stating.

Rick Gawenda, PT

President/CEO

Gawenda Seminars & Consulting

www.gawendaseminars.com

----Original Message----

On Sat, 12/11/10, TSTEGMAN2 <tstegster@wrote:

From: TSTEGMAN2 <tstegster@>

Subject: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules

(11/29/10)

To: PTManager

Date: Saturday, December 11, 2010, 9:12 AM

Where did Don, PT get the following phrase from that rule: " Also note:

Licensed

persons designated in this section are persons holding either Physical

Therapist

or Physical Therapist Assistant licenses. This assumes the all other

individuals

are unlicensed individuals " ? I searched that whole rule and could not

find the

definition of a " licensed person " in that rule. It is assumed that one

is

talking about a PT/PTA being licensed because that is what the

paragraph is

talking about. But if ATCs are licensed, then I would think that

different

lawyers would/could interpret this rule in many different ways. I would

recommend getting the definition of a " licensed person " as put forth by

Don

added to the definition paragraph so one knows what a " licensed person "

is.

Terry Stegman, PT, MS, Eng-Phy

----Original Message----

In PTManager , " selenahorner " <BassHorner2@wrote:

Of course the Michigan Athletic Trainer's Society (MATS) is in

disagreement with

how the MPTA is interpreting the regulations rolled out in November.

MATS has been in communication with the Michigan Department of

Community Health

(MDCH) prior to and now after the implementation of the administrative

rules.

The current status: MATS has repeatedly asked the MDCH for their formal

interpretation of the Rules as the MDCH has regulatory authority over

the PT

Board. Currently, the MDCH has advised that they have submitted an

inquiry to

the Michigan Attorney General on this subject. In my opinion, Michigan

physical

therapists need to continue to stay tuned to the evolving story. An

attorney

general's interpretation may be different than MPTA's interpretation.

Physical

therapists are licensed... physical therapist assistants are

licensed... and at

the end of 2010, athletic train

ers were licensed. It seems the language

of the

administrative rules is legally vague. I did not see where the

administrative

rules specifically stated that only physical therapists and physical

therapist

assistants were considered the only licensed individuals and all other

individuals would be considered not licensed.

http://tinyurl.com/y7wycr

Selena Horner, PT ton, MI

----Original Message----

In PTManager , Rick Gawenda <rick0905@wrote:

Mr. Nanzer, ATC's would not be allowed to provide physical therapy

interventions. They would be able to perform tasks and acts delegated

to them by

a PT or PTA.

Rick Gawenda, PT President Section on Health Policy & Administration

APTA

Supervisor

Ingham Regional Medical Center

SportsMed & Physical Therapy Center

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...