Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Interesting article on the placebo effect - implications for use all?

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

I have always thought of PT as the " art " and " science " of Physical Therapy.

When I worked in a hospital I always loved to perform a show to patient and

family of a new stroke and get a body part to move with facilitation. see

there is hope. . Satisfied my showman side while giving hope to the patient

to work hard at therapy. Part of being a master clinician is the ability to

sell your healing attitude to the patient. I am all for evidenced based

treatment but keeping a little snake oil salesman going can only enhance the

total product.

Steve Passmore PT, MS

Healthy Recruiting Tools

spass@...

Phone:

Fax:

" What We Did For You Yesterday Is History. What Can We Do For You Today "

Recruiting Tools: Cold Calls ~ List Enhancement ~ Direct Mailers ~ Card

Design ~ Recruiting Software

From: PTManager [mailto:PTManager ] On Behalf

Of M. Howell, PT, MPT

Sent: Tuesday, December 28, 2010 12:57 AM

To: PTManager

Subject: Interesting article on the placebo effect -

implications for use all?

Hi everyone,

This is interesting research on the placebo-effect (see link below) from

Time health. Made me think about our discussions on use of modalities that

cannot be supported by research yet but have plenty of anecdotal reports of

positive effects. Before we throw all the devices away, be aware that they

may work, but just not how they are researched to work. It won't be until

we can be reimbursed using a system that rewards positive outcomes, not just

procedures, that we can fully take advantage of the mind-body connection in

treatment including the selected use of modalities that may work purely via

the placebo effect. If you take into account a clinician's experience (as

part of the evidence-based triangle) and their ability to understand when

the placebo effect may work when other treatments won't and you achieve the

outcomes desired and goals are reached, then is there anything wrong with

using it (the placebo effect) in treatment?

To look at it another way, is the growing body of research on the placebo

effect enough evidence-based to warrant reimbursement for the appropriate

use of it???

" Placebos Work Even if You Know They're Fake: But How? "

http://healthland.time.com/2010/12/27/placebos-work-even-if-you-know-theyre-

fake-but-how/?artId=20546?contType=article?chn=us

Tom Howell, P.T., M.P.T.

Howell Physical Therapy

Eagle, ID

thowell@... <mailto:thowell%40fiberpipe.net>

This email and any files transmitted with it may contain PRIVILEGED or

CONFIDENTIAL information and may be read or used only by the intended

recipient. If you are not the intended recipient of the email or any of its

attachments, please be advised that you have received this email in error

and that any use, dissemination, distribution, forwarding, printing or

copying of this email or any attached files is strictly prohibited. If you

have received this email in error, please immediately purge it and all

attachments and notify the sender by reply email.

Posted

I agree with you, Steve. I have been told by more than one patient or

group I'm giving a presentation to " we don't know if what you're telling

us is true or not, but we can tell that you believe it so much that

we'll go along with you " . Once we have the confidence of the patient, I

find that compliance can go up to and even exceed both of our

expectations. Attitude and belief does play a large part in getting

compliance with our patients. Compliance does give better results in

most situations.

Tom Kaluzny PT

Rehabilitation Services Manager

Providence Mount Carmel Hospital

982 E. Columbia

Colville, WA 99114

Work:

Fax:

Co-Manager Rehabilitation Services

Providence Saint ph Hospital

500 E. Webster

P.O. Box 197

Chewelah, WA 99109

email: thomas.kaluzny@...

Therapy is about the power of possibility. So is Providence.

www.providenceiscalling.jobs/therapy

<http://www.providenceiscalling.jobs/therapy>

________________________________

From: PTManager [mailto:PTManager ] On

Behalf Of Steve Passmore

Sent: Tuesday, December 28, 2010 8:13 AM

To: PTManager

Subject: RE: Interesting article on the placebo effect -

implications for use all?

I have always thought of PT as the " art " and " science " of Physical

Therapy.

When I worked in a hospital I always loved to perform a show to patient

and

family of a new stroke and get a body part to move with facilitation.

see

there is hope. . Satisfied my showman side while giving hope to the

patient

to work hard at therapy. Part of being a master clinician is the ability

to

sell your healing attitude to the patient. I am all for evidenced based

treatment but keeping a little snake oil salesman going can only enhance

the

total product.

Steve Passmore PT, MS

Healthy Recruiting Tools

<mailto:spass@...

<mailto:spass%40healthyrecruiting.com> > spass@...

<mailto:spass%40healthyrecruiting.com>

Phone:

Fax:

" What We Did For You Yesterday Is History. What Can We Do For You Today "

Recruiting Tools: Cold Calls ~ List Enhancement ~ Direct Mailers ~ Card

Design ~ Recruiting Software

From: PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

[mailto:PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com> ]

On Behalf

Of M. Howell, PT, MPT

Sent: Tuesday, December 28, 2010 12:57 AM

To: PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

Subject: Interesting article on the placebo effect -

implications for use all?

Hi everyone,

This is interesting research on the placebo-effect (see link below) from

Time health. Made me think about our discussions on use of modalities

that

cannot be supported by research yet but have plenty of anecdotal reports

of

positive effects. Before we throw all the devices away, be aware that

they

may work, but just not how they are researched to work. It won't be

until

we can be reimbursed using a system that rewards positive outcomes, not

just

procedures, that we can fully take advantage of the mind-body connection

in

treatment including the selected use of modalities that may work purely

via

the placebo effect. If you take into account a clinician's experience

(as

part of the evidence-based triangle) and their ability to understand

when

the placebo effect may work when other treatments won't and you achieve

the

outcomes desired and goals are reached, then is there anything wrong

with

using it (the placebo effect) in treatment?

To look at it another way, is the growing body of research on the

placebo

effect enough evidence-based to warrant reimbursement for the

appropriate

use of it???

" Placebos Work Even if You Know They're Fake: But How? "

http://healthland.time.com/2010/12/27/placebos-work-even-if-you-know-the

yre-

fake-but-how/?artId=20546?contType=article?chn=us

Tom Howell, P.T., M.P.T.

Howell Physical Therapy

Eagle, ID

thowell@... <mailto:thowell%40fiberpipe.net>

<mailto:thowell%40fiberpipe.net>

This email and any files transmitted with it may contain PRIVILEGED or

CONFIDENTIAL information and may be read or used only by the intended

recipient. If you are not the intended recipient of the email or any of

its

attachments, please be advised that you have received this email in

error

and that any use, dissemination, distribution, forwarding, printing or

copying of this email or any attached files is strictly prohibited. If

you

have received this email in error, please immediately purge it and all

attachments and notify the sender by reply email.

Posted

I was reminded of a radiolab program I heard a few years ago:

PLACEBO http://www.radiolab.org/2007/may/17/

All of their programs are worth listening to, I download and re listen

to the mp3's all the time.

Wade , PT

OR

>

> I agree with you, Steve. I have been told by more than one patient or

> group I'm giving a presentation to " we don't know if what you're telling

> us is true or not, but we can tell that you believe it so much that

> we'll go along with you " . Once we have the confidence of the patient, I

> find that compliance can go up to and even exceed both of our

> expectations. Attitude and belief does play a large part in getting

> compliance with our patients. Compliance does give better results in

> most situations.

>

> Tom Kaluzny PT

> Rehabilitation Services Manager

> Providence Mount Carmel Hospital

> 982 E. Columbia

> Colville, WA 99114

> Work:

> Fax:

>

> Co-Manager Rehabilitation Services

> Providence Saint ph Hospital

> 500 E. Webster

> P.O. Box 197

> Chewelah, WA 99109

> email: thomas.kaluzny@...

> <mailto:thomas.kaluzny%40providence.org>

>

> Therapy is about the power of possibility. So is Providence.

> www.providenceiscalling.jobs/therapy

> <http://www.providenceiscalling.jobs/therapy>

>

> ________________________________

>

> From: PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> [mailto:PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>] On

> Behalf Of Steve Passmore

> Sent: Tuesday, December 28, 2010 8:13 AM

> To: PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> Subject: RE: Interesting article on the placebo effect -

> implications for use all?

>

> I have always thought of PT as the " art " and " science " of Physical

> Therapy.

> When I worked in a hospital I always loved to perform a show to patient

> and

> family of a new stroke and get a body part to move with facilitation.

> see

> there is hope. . Satisfied my showman side while giving hope to the

> patient

> to work hard at therapy. Part of being a master clinician is the ability

> to

> sell your healing attitude to the patient. I am all for evidenced based

> treatment but keeping a little snake oil salesman going can only enhance

> the

> total product.

>

> Steve Passmore PT, MS

>

> Healthy Recruiting Tools

>

> <mailto:spass@... <mailto:spass%40healthyrecruiting.com>

> <mailto:spass%40healthyrecruiting.com> > spass@...

> <mailto:spass%40healthyrecruiting.com>

> <mailto:spass%40healthyrecruiting.com>

>

> Phone:

>

> Fax:

>

> " What We Did For You Yesterday Is History. What Can We Do For You Today "

>

> Recruiting Tools: Cold Calls ~ List Enhancement ~ Direct Mailers ~ Card

> Design ~ Recruiting Software

>

> From: PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> [mailto:PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com> ]

> On Behalf

> Of M. Howell, PT, MPT

> Sent: Tuesday, December 28, 2010 12:57 AM

> To: PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> Subject: Interesting article on the placebo effect -

> implications for use all?

>

> Hi everyone,

>

> This is interesting research on the placebo-effect (see link below) from

> Time health. Made me think about our discussions on use of modalities

> that

> cannot be supported by research yet but have plenty of anecdotal reports

> of

> positive effects. Before we throw all the devices away, be aware that

> they

> may work, but just not how they are researched to work. It won't be

> until

> we can be reimbursed using a system that rewards positive outcomes, not

> just

> procedures, that we can fully take advantage of the mind-body connection

> in

> treatment including the selected use of modalities that may work purely

> via

> the placebo effect. If you take into account a clinician's experience

> (as

> part of the evidence-based triangle) and their ability to understand

> when

> the placebo effect may work when other treatments won't and you achieve

> the

> outcomes desired and goals are reached, then is there anything wrong

> with

> using it (the placebo effect) in treatment?

>

> To look at it another way, is the growing body of research on the

> placebo

> effect enough evidence-based to warrant reimbursement for the

> appropriate

> use of it???

>

> " Placebos Work Even if You Know They're Fake: But How? "

>

> http://healthland.time.com/2010/12/27/placebos-work-even-if-you-know-the

> yre-

> fake-but-how/?artId=20546?contType=article?chn=us

>

> Tom Howell, P.T., M.P.T.

>

> Howell Physical Therapy

>

> Eagle, ID

>

> thowell@... <mailto:thowell%40fiberpipe.net>

> <mailto:thowell%40fiberpipe.net>

> <mailto:thowell%40fiberpipe.net>

>

> This email and any files transmitted with it may contain PRIVILEGED or

> CONFIDENTIAL information and may be read or used only by the intended

> recipient. If you are not the intended recipient of the email or any of

> its

> attachments, please be advised that you have received this email in

> error

> and that any use, dissemination, distribution, forwarding, printing or

> copying of this email or any attached files is strictly prohibited. If

> you

> have received this email in error, please immediately purge it and all

> attachments and notify the sender by reply email.

>

>

Posted

Flynn describes the treatment effect of lumbar manipulation as a " reset " of the

movement of the spine - sort of like the " Control-Alt-Delete " command for your

computer.

You can see his presentation here...

http://www.viddler.com/explore/Evidenceinmotio/videos/7/

Lumbar manipulation probably works through non-mechanical effects that has a

large impact on behavior, like movement.

If I can twist and thrust my patient they figure out that movement is probably

safe for them to perform on their own, as well.

Is this placebo? Or, is is just a treatment effect that doesn't yet fit our

mechanistic worldview?

Tim , PT

www.PhysicalTherapyDiagnosis.com

> >

> > I agree with you, Steve. I have been told by more than one patient or

> > group I'm giving a presentation to " we don't know if what you're telling

> > us is true or not, but we can tell that you believe it so much that

> > we'll go along with you " . Once we have the confidence of the patient, I

> > find that compliance can go up to and even exceed both of our

> > expectations. Attitude and belief does play a large part in getting

> > compliance with our patients. Compliance does give better results in

> > most situations.

> >

> > Tom Kaluzny PT

> > Rehabilitation Services Manager

> > Providence Mount Carmel Hospital

> > 982 E. Columbia

> > Colville, WA 99114

> > Work:

> > Fax:

> >

> > Co-Manager Rehabilitation Services

> > Providence Saint ph Hospital

> > 500 E. Webster

> > P.O. Box 197

> > Chewelah, WA 99109

> > email: thomas.kaluzny@...

> > <mailto:thomas.kaluzny%40providence.org>

> >

> > Therapy is about the power of possibility. So is Providence.

> > www.providenceiscalling.jobs/therapy

> > <http://www.providenceiscalling.jobs/therapy>

> >

> > ________________________________

> >

> > From: PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> > [mailto:PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>] On

> > Behalf Of Steve Passmore

> > Sent: Tuesday, December 28, 2010 8:13 AM

> > To: PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> > Subject: RE: Interesting article on the placebo effect -

> > implications for use all?

> >

> > I have always thought of PT as the " art " and " science " of Physical

> > Therapy.

> > When I worked in a hospital I always loved to perform a show to patient

> > and

> > family of a new stroke and get a body part to move with facilitation.

> > see

> > there is hope. . Satisfied my showman side while giving hope to the

> > patient

> > to work hard at therapy. Part of being a master clinician is the ability

> > to

> > sell your healing attitude to the patient. I am all for evidenced based

> > treatment but keeping a little snake oil salesman going can only enhance

> > the

> > total product.

> >

> > Steve Passmore PT, MS

> >

> > Healthy Recruiting Tools

> >

> > <mailto:spass@... <mailto:spass%40healthyrecruiting.com>

> > <mailto:spass%40healthyrecruiting.com> > spass@...

> > <mailto:spass%40healthyrecruiting.com>

> > <mailto:spass%40healthyrecruiting.com>

> >

> > Phone:

> >

> > Fax:

> >

> > " What We Did For You Yesterday Is History. What Can We Do For You Today "

> >

> > Recruiting Tools: Cold Calls ~ List Enhancement ~ Direct Mailers ~ Card

> > Design ~ Recruiting Software

> >

> > From: PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> > <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> > [mailto:PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> > <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com> ]

> > On Behalf

> > Of M. Howell, PT, MPT

> > Sent: Tuesday, December 28, 2010 12:57 AM

> > To: PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> > <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> > Subject: Interesting article on the placebo effect -

> > implications for use all?

> >

> > Hi everyone,

> >

> > This is interesting research on the placebo-effect (see link below) from

> > Time health. Made me think about our discussions on use of modalities

> > that

> > cannot be supported by research yet but have plenty of anecdotal reports

> > of

> > positive effects. Before we throw all the devices away, be aware that

> > they

> > may work, but just not how they are researched to work. It won't be

> > until

> > we can be reimbursed using a system that rewards positive outcomes, not

> > just

> > procedures, that we can fully take advantage of the mind-body connection

> > in

> > treatment including the selected use of modalities that may work purely

> > via

> > the placebo effect. If you take into account a clinician's experience

> > (as

> > part of the evidence-based triangle) and their ability to understand

> > when

> > the placebo effect may work when other treatments won't and you achieve

> > the

> > outcomes desired and goals are reached, then is there anything wrong

> > with

> > using it (the placebo effect) in treatment?

> >

> > To look at it another way, is the growing body of research on the

> > placebo

> > effect enough evidence-based to warrant reimbursement for the

> > appropriate

> > use of it???

> >

> > " Placebos Work Even if You Know They're Fake: But How? "

> >

> > http://healthland.time.com/2010/12/27/placebos-work-even-if-you-know-the

> > yre-

> > fake-but-how/?artId=20546?contType=article?chn=us

> >

> > Tom Howell, P.T., M.P.T.

> >

> > Howell Physical Therapy

> >

> > Eagle, ID

> >

> > thowell@... <mailto:thowell%40fiberpipe.net>

> > <mailto:thowell%40fiberpipe.net>

> > <mailto:thowell%40fiberpipe.net>

> >

> > This email and any files transmitted with it may contain PRIVILEGED or

> > CONFIDENTIAL information and may be read or used only by the intended

> > recipient. If you are not the intended recipient of the email or any of

> > its

> > attachments, please be advised that you have received this email in

> > error

> > and that any use, dissemination, distribution, forwarding, printing or

> > copying of this email or any attached files is strictly prohibited. If

> > you

> > have received this email in error, please immediately purge it and all

> > attachments and notify the sender by reply email.

> >

> >

Posted

Excellent talk!

From: medicalartsrehab

Sent: Wednesday, December 29, 2010 10:03 AM

To: PTManager

Subject: Re: Interesting article on the placebo effect -

implications for use all?

Flynn describes the treatment effect of lumbar manipulation as a " reset " of the

movement of the spine - sort of like the " Control-Alt-Delete " command for your

computer.

You can see his presentation here...

http://www.viddler.com/explore/Evidenceinmotio/videos/7/

Lumbar manipulation probably works through non-mechanical effects that has a

large impact on behavior, like movement.

If I can twist and thrust my patient they figure out that movement is probably

safe for them to perform on their own, as well.

Is this placebo? Or, is is just a treatment effect that doesn't yet fit our

mechanistic worldview?

Tim , PT

www.PhysicalTherapyDiagnosis.com

> >

> > I agree with you, Steve. I have been told by more than one patient or

> > group I'm giving a presentation to " we don't know if what you're telling

> > us is true or not, but we can tell that you believe it so much that

> > we'll go along with you " . Once we have the confidence of the patient, I

> > find that compliance can go up to and even exceed both of our

> > expectations. Attitude and belief does play a large part in getting

> > compliance with our patients. Compliance does give better results in

> > most situations.

> >

> > Tom Kaluzny PT

> > Rehabilitation Services Manager

> > Providence Mount Carmel Hospital

> > 982 E. Columbia

> > Colville, WA 99114

> > Work:

> > Fax:

> >

> > Co-Manager Rehabilitation Services

> > Providence Saint ph Hospital

> > 500 E. Webster

> > P.O. Box 197

> > Chewelah, WA 99109

> > email: thomas.kaluzny@...

> > <mailto:thomas.kaluzny%40providence.org>

> >

> > Therapy is about the power of possibility. So is Providence.

> > www.providenceiscalling.jobs/therapy

> > <http://www.providenceiscalling.jobs/therapy>

> >

> > ________________________________

> >

> > From: mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com

<mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> > [mailto:mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com

<mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>] On

> > Behalf Of Steve Passmore

> > Sent: Tuesday, December 28, 2010 8:13 AM

> > To: mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> > Subject: RE: Interesting article on the placebo effect -

> > implications for use all?

> >

> > I have always thought of PT as the " art " and " science " of Physical

> > Therapy.

> > When I worked in a hospital I always loved to perform a show to patient

> > and

> > family of a new stroke and get a body part to move with facilitation.

> > see

> > there is hope. . Satisfied my showman side while giving hope to the

> > patient

> > to work hard at therapy. Part of being a master clinician is the ability

> > to

> > sell your healing attitude to the patient. I am all for evidenced based

> > treatment but keeping a little snake oil salesman going can only enhance

> > the

> > total product.

> >

> > Steve Passmore PT, MS

> >

> > Healthy Recruiting Tools

> >

> > <mailto:spass@... <mailto:spass%40healthyrecruiting.com>

> > <mailto:spass%40healthyrecruiting.com> > spass@...

> > <mailto:spass%40healthyrecruiting.com>

> > <mailto:spass%40healthyrecruiting.com>

> >

> > Phone:

> >

> > Fax:

> >

> > " What We Did For You Yesterday Is History. What Can We Do For You Today "

> >

> > Recruiting Tools: Cold Calls ~ List Enhancement ~ Direct Mailers ~ Card

> > Design ~ Recruiting Software

> >

> > From: mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com

<mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> > <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> > [mailto:mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com

<mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> > <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com> ]

> > On Behalf

> > Of M. Howell, PT, MPT

> > Sent: Tuesday, December 28, 2010 12:57 AM

> > To: mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> > <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com>

> > Subject: Interesting article on the placebo effect -

> > implications for use all?

> >

> > Hi everyone,

> >

> > This is interesting research on the placebo-effect (see link below) from

> > Time health. Made me think about our discussions on use of modalities

> > that

> > cannot be supported by research yet but have plenty of anecdotal reports

> > of

> > positive effects. Before we throw all the devices away, be aware that

> > they

> > may work, but just not how they are researched to work. It won't be

> > until

> > we can be reimbursed using a system that rewards positive outcomes, not

> > just

> > procedures, that we can fully take advantage of the mind-body connection

> > in

> > treatment including the selected use of modalities that may work purely

> > via

> > the placebo effect. If you take into account a clinician's experience

> > (as

> > part of the evidence-based triangle) and their ability to understand

> > when

> > the placebo effect may work when other treatments won't and you achieve

> > the

> > outcomes desired and goals are reached, then is there anything wrong

> > with

> > using it (the placebo effect) in treatment?

> >

> > To look at it another way, is the growing body of research on the

> > placebo

> > effect enough evidence-based to warrant reimbursement for the

> > appropriate

> > use of it???

> >

> > " Placebos Work Even if You Know They're Fake: But How? "

> >

> > http://healthland.time.com/2010/12/27/placebos-work-even-if-you-know-the

> > yre-

> > fake-but-how/?artId=20546?contType=article?chn=us

> >

> > Tom Howell, P.T., M.P.T.

> >

> > Howell Physical Therapy

> >

> > Eagle, ID

> >

> > thowell@... <mailto:thowell%40fiberpipe.net>

> > <mailto:thowell%40fiberpipe.net>

> > <mailto:thowell%40fiberpipe.net>

> >

> > This email and any files transmitted with it may contain PRIVILEGED or

> > CONFIDENTIAL information and may be read or used only by the intended

> > recipient. If you are not the intended recipient of the email or any of

> > its

> > attachments, please be advised that you have received this email in

> > error

> > and that any use, dissemination, distribution, forwarding, printing or

> > copying of this email or any attached files is strictly prohibited. If

> > you

> > have received this email in error, please immediately purge it and all

> > attachments and notify the sender by reply email.

> >

> >

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...