Guest guest Posted December 21, 2010 Report Posted December 21, 2010 Mr. , I am very appreciative for your input. I agree that everyone should review the rules for themselves. I was just trying to make the point that if the Att. Gen. interprets the rules differently than us, it would seem likely that it would have some impact on how they are enforced. Thanks for helping to clear up the issue of " acts, tasks, and functions " , I am now clear on that point. You also stated: " The rules are specific that, within physical therapy practice, that only PTs and PTAs are considered licensed. All others utilized in a physical therapy setting in Michigan fall under the unlicensed category (including ATC, Exercise Physiologists, Massage Therapists, Aide, Tech, etc). " In what area is the rule specific on this matter? Part 3 and Part 4 of the act give the requirements for licensure for PT's and PTA's. So do we take from this that since other professions are not delineated in the same manner they fall in the unlicensed category? Or is there an area that I have just missed in the rule that more clearly explains what constitutes a licensed vs unlicensed professional? Any guidance would be much appreciated. D. Nanzer, DPT, MBA, CSCS Supervisor Athletic Training Department & SportsMed Physical Therapy Center Ingham Regional Medical Center Direct >>> DAVID PERRY 12/20/2010 4:49 PM >>> I encourage every Michigan physical therapist and physical therapist assistant to read for themselves the PT Administrative Rules that went into effect November 29, 2010, and not rely on interpretation by others. http://www.state.mi.us/orr/emi/admincode.asp?AdminCode=Single & Admin_Num=33807101\ & Dpt=CH & RngHigh= Keep in mind these Administrative Rules describe the practice of physical therapy. The rules are specific that, within physical therapy practice, that only PTs and PTAs are considered licensed. All others utilized in a physical therapy setting in Michigan fall under the unlicensed category (including ATC, Exercise Physiologists, Massage Therapists, Aide, Tech, etc). Those other entities may be considered licensed under their own discipline if so licensed. But these Rules only define what is physical therapy. The Rules are also specific that only PTs and PTAs perform physical therapy interventions, a term which is defined in the Rules. Acts, tasks and functions is a term used in the general provisions of the Michigan Public Health Code, which while not specifically defined in the PT Administrative Rules, should be considered to mean all other activities except Interventions as defined. Please though, read the original document and not rely on others interpretation of it. For it is the Public Health Code and accompanying Administrative Rules for your specific license for which a licensed individual is held accountable. W. , PT, MS Grosse Pointe Woods, MI PTA Program Chair, Baker College of Park Therapeutics Chair, Michigan Board of Physical Therapy david.perry@... " And in the end it's not the years in your life that count. It's the life in your years. " Abraham Lincoln " A person who never made a mistake never tried anything new. " Albert Einstein ________________________________ To: PTManager Sent: Mon, December 20, 2010 6:38:51 AM Subject: Re: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules (11/29/10) I agree with Terry and Selena, the rule would be much less ambiguous if they had delineated licensed vs unlicensed better. Explaining it on the members only section of the MPTA seems to do little since the part that will be legally enforced (the administrative rule I initially linked to, and the one available to the public) does not define it. The rule is also ambiguous on what constitutes an " act, task, or function " which it does state unlicensed persons can do. As I see it, we are all waiting for the Michigan Attorney General's interpretation. After which, I am sure there will be much more room for debate. D. Nanzer, DPT, MBA, CSCS Supervisor Athletic Training Department & SportsMed Physical Therapy Center Ingham Regional Medical Center Direct >>> Rick Gawenda 12/11/2010 9:10 PM >>> That interpretation can be found on the members only Section of the MPTA website as that is what MPTA is stating. Rick Gawenda, PT President/CEO Gawenda Seminars & Consulting www.gawendaseminars.com Subject: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules (11/29/10) To: PTManager Date: Saturday, December 11, 2010, 9:12 AM Where did Don, PT get the following phrase from that rule: " Also note: Licensed persons designated in this section are persons holding either Physical Therapist or Physical Therapist Assistant licenses. This assumes the all other individuals are unlicensed individuals " ? I searched that whole rule and could not find the definition of a " licensed person " in that rule. It is assumed that one is talking about a PT/PTA being licensed because that is what the paragraph is talking about. But if ATCs are licensed, then I would think that different lawyers would/could interpret this rule in many different ways. I would recommend getting the definition of a " licensed person " as put forth by Don added to the definition paragraph so one knows what a " licensed person " is. Terry Stegman, PT, MS, Eng-Phy Mr. Nanzer, ATC's would not be allowed to provide physical therapy interventions. They would be able to perform tasks and acts delegated to them by a PT or PTA. Rick Gawenda, PT President Section on Health Policy & Administration APTA Supervisor Ingham Regional Medical Center SportsMed & Physical Therapy Center Quote
Guest guest Posted December 21, 2010 Report Posted December 21, 2010 Hi Dave, As always, appreciate your input and perspective. Another question---I thought we were to expect verbiage about CEU's. Is this forthcoming in the near future? Lori Be kinder than necessary because everyone you meet is fighting some kind of battle From: PTManager [mailto:PTManager ] On Behalf Of DAVID PERRY Sent: Monday, December 20, 2010 4:50 PM To: PTManager Subject: Re: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules (11/29/10) I encourage every Michigan physical therapist and physical therapist assistant to read for themselves the PT Administrative Rules that went into effect November 29, 2010, and not rely on interpretation by others. http://www.state.mi.us/orr/emi/admincode.asp?AdminCode=Single & Admin_Num=33807101\ & Dpt=CH & RngHigh= Keep in mind these Administrative Rules describe the practice of physical therapy. The rules are specific that, within physical therapy practice, that only PTs and PTAs are considered licensed. All others utilized in a physical therapy setting in Michigan fall under the unlicensed category (including ATC, Exercise Physiologists, Massage Therapists, Aide, Tech, etc). Those other entities may be considered licensed under their own discipline if so licensed. But these Rules only define what is physical therapy. The Rules are also specific that only PTs and PTAs perform physical therapy interventions, a term which is defined in the Rules. Acts, tasks and functions is a term used in the general provisions of the Michigan Public Health Code, which while not specifically defined in the PT Administrative Rules, should be considered to mean all other activities except Interventions as defined. Please though, read the original document and not rely on others interpretation of it. For it is the Public Health Code and accompanying Administrative Rules for your specific license for which a licensed individual is held accountable. W. , PT, MS Grosse Pointe Woods, MI PTA Program Chair, Baker College of Park Therapeutics Chair, Michigan Board of Physical Therapy david.perry@...<mailto:david.perry%40baker.edu> " And in the end it's not the years in your life that count. It's the life in your years. " Abraham Lincoln " A person who never made a mistake never tried anything new. " Albert Einstein ________________________________ From: Nanzer <michael.nanzer@...<mailto:michael.nanzer%40irmc.org>> To: PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com> Sent: Mon, December 20, 2010 6:38:51 AM Subject: Re: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules (11/29/10) I agree with Terry and Selena, the rule would be much less ambiguous if they had delineated licensed vs unlicensed better. Explaining it on the members only section of the MPTA seems to do little since the part that will be legally enforced (the administrative rule I initially linked to, and the one available to the public) does not define it. The rule is also ambiguous on what constitutes an " act, task, or function " which it does state unlicensed persons can do. As I see it, we are all waiting for the Michigan Attorney General's interpretation. After which, I am sure there will be much more room for debate. D. Nanzer, DPT, MBA, CSCS Supervisor Athletic Training Department & SportsMed Physical Therapy Center Ingham Regional Medical Center Direct >>> Rick Gawenda <rick0905@...<mailto:rick0905%40yahoo.com>> 12/11/2010 9:10 PM >>> That interpretation can be found on the members only Section of the MPTA website as that is what MPTA is stating. Rick Gawenda, PT President/CEO Gawenda Seminars & Consulting www.gawendaseminars.com From: TSTEGMAN2 <tstegster@...<mailto:tstegster%40gmail.com>> Subject: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules (11/29/10) To: PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com> Date: Saturday, December 11, 2010, 9:12 AM Where did Don, PT get the following phrase from that rule: " Also note: Licensed persons designated in this section are persons holding either Physical Therapist or Physical Therapist Assistant licenses. This assumes the all other individuals are unlicensed individuals " ? I searched that whole rule and could not find the definition of a " licensed person " in that rule. It is assumed that one is talking about a PT/PTA being licensed because that is what the paragraph is talking about. But if ATCs are licensed, then I would think that different lawyers would/could interpret this rule in many different ways. I would recommend getting the definition of a " licensed person " as put forth by Don added to the definition paragraph so one knows what a " licensed person " is. Terry Stegman, PT, MS, Eng-Phy Mr. Nanzer, ATC's would not be allowed to provide physical therapy interventions. They would be able to perform tasks and acts delegated to them by a PT or PTA. Rick Gawenda, PT President Section on Health Policy & Administration APTA Supervisor Ingham Regional Medical Center SportsMed & Physical Therapy Center Quote
Guest guest Posted December 21, 2010 Report Posted December 21, 2010 Lori, The Administrative Rules that went into effect Nov 29 only addressed the licensure of PTAs, in order to expedite the rule promogation process and get that set of rules in place quickest after the passage of PTA licensure in June 2009. Yes, quick in government terms. The MI Board of Physical Therapy is currently working on a new set of rules revision which will implement the Continuing Competency for Relicensure. Stay tuned in mid-2011 for those.  W. , PT, MS Grosse Pointe Woods, MI PTA Program Chair, Baker College of Park Therapeutics Chair, Michigan Board of Physical Therapy david.perry@... " And in the end it's not the years in your life that count. It's the life in your years. " Abraham Lincoln " A person who never made a mistake never tried anything new. " Albert Einstein ________________________________ To: " PTManager " <PTManager > Sent: Tue, December 21, 2010 8:58:24 AM Subject: RE: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules (11/29/10)  Hi Dave, As always, appreciate your input and perspective. Another question---I thought we were to expect verbiage about CEU's. Is this forthcoming in the near future? Lori Be kinder than necessary because everyone you meet is fighting some kind of battle From: PTManager [mailto:PTManager ] On Behalf Of DAVID PERRY Sent: Monday, December 20, 2010 4:50 PM To: PTManager Subject: Re: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules (11/29/10) I encourage every Michigan physical therapist and physical therapist assistant to read for themselves the PT Administrative Rules that went into effect November 29, 2010, and not rely on interpretation by others. http://www.state.mi.us/orr/emi/admincode.asp?AdminCode=Single & Admin_Num=33807101\ & Dpt=CH & RngHigh= Keep in mind these Administrative Rules describe the practice of physical therapy. The rules are specific that, within physical therapy practice, that only PTs and PTAs are considered licensed. All others utilized in a physical therapy setting in Michigan fall under the unlicensed category (including ATC, Exercise Physiologists, Massage Therapists, Aide, Tech, etc). Those other entities may be considered licensed under their own discipline if so licensed. But these Rules only define what is physical therapy. The Rules are also specific that only PTs and PTAs perform physical therapy interventions, a term which is defined in the Rules. Acts, tasks and functions is a term used in the general provisions of the Michigan Public Health Code, which while not specifically defined in the PT Administrative Rules, should be considered to mean all other activities except Interventions as defined. Please though, read the original document and not rely on others interpretation of it. For it is the Public Health Code and accompanying Administrative Rules for your specific license for which a licensed individual is held accountable. W. , PT, MS Grosse Pointe Woods, MI PTA Program Chair, Baker College of Park Therapeutics Chair, Michigan Board of Physical Therapy david.perry@...<mailto:david.perry%40baker.edu> " And in the end it's not the years in your life that count. It's the life in your years. " Abraham Lincoln " A person who never made a mistake never tried anything new. " Albert Einstein ________________________________ From: Nanzer <michael.nanzer@...<mailto:michael.nanzer%40irmc.org>> To: PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com> Sent: Mon, December 20, 2010 6:38:51 AM Subject: Re: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules (11/29/10) I agree with Terry and Selena, the rule would be much less ambiguous if they had delineated licensed vs unlicensed better. Explaining it on the members only section of the MPTA seems to do little since the part that will be legally enforced (the administrative rule I initially linked to, and the one available to the public) does not define it. The rule is also ambiguous on what constitutes an " act, task, or function " which it does state unlicensed persons can do. As I see it, we are all waiting for the Michigan Attorney General's interpretation. After which, I am sure there will be much more room for debate. D. Nanzer, DPT, MBA, CSCS Supervisor Athletic Training Department & SportsMed Physical Therapy Center Ingham Regional Medical Center Direct >>> Rick Gawenda <rick0905@...<mailto:rick0905%40yahoo.com>> 12/11/2010 9:10 >>>PM >>> That interpretation can be found on the members only Section of the MPTA website as that is what MPTA is stating. Rick Gawenda, PT President/CEO Gawenda Seminars & Consulting www.gawendaseminars.com From: TSTEGMAN2 <tstegster@...<mailto:tstegster%40gmail.com>> Subject: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules (11/29/10) To: PTManager <mailto:PTManager%40yahoogroups.com> Date: Saturday, December 11, 2010, 9:12 AM Where did Don, PT get the following phrase from that rule: " Also note: Licensed persons designated in this section are persons holding either Physical Therapist or Physical Therapist Assistant licenses. This assumes the all other individuals are unlicensed individuals " ? I searched that whole rule and could not find the definition of a " licensed person " in that rule. It is assumed that one is talking about a PT/PTA being licensed because that is what the paragraph is talking about. But if ATCs are licensed, then I would think that different lawyers would/could interpret this rule in many different ways. I would recommend getting the definition of a " licensed person " as put forth by Don added to the definition paragraph so one knows what a " licensed person " is. Terry Stegman, PT, MS, Eng-Phy Mr. Nanzer, ATC's would not be allowed to provide physical therapy interventions. They would be able to perform tasks and acts delegated to them by a PT or PTA. Rick Gawenda, PT President Section on Health Policy & Administration APTA Supervisor Ingham Regional Medical Center SportsMed & Physical Therapy Center Quote
Guest guest Posted December 21, 2010 Report Posted December 21, 2010 As stated previously, both the law (Public Health Code) and operant definitions (Administrative Rules) need to be referenced, as neither is truly a stand-alone document. In the Public Health Code, 333.17801 Definitions; principles of construction. Sec. 17801. (1) As used in this part: (a) " Physical therapist " means an individual licensed under this article to engage in the practice of physical therapy. ( " Physical therapist assistant " means an individual with a health profession subfield license under this part who assists a physical therapist in physical therapy intervention.  The Administrative Rules for each discipline address only that discipline, thus the Physical Therapy Rules only address the provision of physical therapy, and the PHC only defines 2 licensed entities, PT & PTA. All others, within the Physical Therapy law and administrative rules, would constitute " unlicensed " .  As for the Attorney Generals opinion, we all need to wait and see how they answer the request for clarification. When I spoke with a representative from their office, I clearly addressed that this rules revision is intended to define physical therapy practice only, not other professions (as they are addressed in their own set of laws and administrative rules). As stated in the law above, licensed PTs engage in the practice of physical therapy, and licensed PTAs assist in providing physical therapy interventions. W. , PT, MS Grosse Pointe Woods, MI PTA Program Chair, Baker College of Park Therapeutics Chair, Michigan Board of Physical Therapy david.perry@... " And in the end it's not the years in your life that count. It's the life in your years. " Abraham Lincoln " A person who never made a mistake never tried anything new. " Albert Einstein ________________________________ To: PTManager Sent: Tue, December 21, 2010 6:58:55 AM Subject: Re: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules (11/29/10)  Mr. , I am very appreciative for your input. I agree that everyone should review the rules for themselves. I was just trying to make the point that if the Att. Gen. interprets the rules differently than us, it would seem likely that it would have some impact on how they are enforced. Thanks for helping to clear up the issue of " acts, tasks, and functions " , I am now clear on that point. You also stated: " The rules are specific that, within physical therapy practice, that only PTs and PTAs are considered licensed. All others utilized in a physical therapy setting in Michigan fall under the unlicensed category (including ATC, Exercise Physiologists, Massage Therapists, Aide, Tech, etc). " In what area is the rule specific on this matter? Part 3 and Part 4 of the act give the requirements for licensure for PT's and PTA's. So do we take from this that since other professions are not delineated in the same manner they fall in the unlicensed category? Or is there an area that I have just missed in the rule that more clearly explains what constitutes a licensed vs unlicensed professional? Any guidance would be much appreciated. D. Nanzer, DPT, MBA, CSCS Supervisor Athletic Training Department & SportsMed Physical Therapy Center Ingham Regional Medical Center Direct >>> DAVID PERRY 12/20/2010 4:49 PM >>> I encourage every Michigan physical therapist and physical therapist assistant to read for themselves the PT Administrative Rules that went into effect November 29, 2010, and not rely on interpretation by others. http://www.state.mi.us/orr/emi/admincode.asp?AdminCode=Single & Admin_Num=33807101\ & Dpt=CH & RngHigh= Keep in mind these Administrative Rules describe the practice of physical therapy. The rules are specific that, within physical therapy practice, that only PTs and PTAs are considered licensed. All others utilized in a physical therapy setting in Michigan fall under the unlicensed category (including ATC, Exercise Physiologists, Massage Therapists, Aide, Tech, etc). Those other entities may be considered licensed under their own discipline if so licensed. But these Rules only define what is physical therapy. The Rules are also specific that only PTs and PTAs perform physical therapy interventions, a term which is defined in the Rules. Acts, tasks and functions is a term used in the general provisions of the Michigan Public Health Code, which while not specifically defined in the PT Administrative Rules, should be considered to mean all other activities except Interventions as defined. Please though, read the original document and not rely on others interpretation of it. For it is the Public Health Code and accompanying Administrative Rules for your specific license for which a licensed individual is held accountable. W. , PT, MS Grosse Pointe Woods, MI PTA Program Chair, Baker College of Park Therapeutics Chair, Michigan Board of Physical Therapy david.perry@... " And in the end it's not the years in your life that count. It's the life in your years. " Abraham Lincoln " A person who never made a mistake never tried anything new. " Albert Einstein ________________________________ To: PTManager Sent: Mon, December 20, 2010 6:38:51 AM Subject: Re: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules (11/29/10) I agree with Terry and Selena, the rule would be much less ambiguous if they had delineated licensed vs unlicensed better. Explaining it on the members only section of the MPTA seems to do little since the part that will be legally enforced (the administrative rule I initially linked to, and the one available to the public) does not define it. The rule is also ambiguous on what constitutes an " act, task, or function " which it does state unlicensed persons can do. As I see it, we are all waiting for the Michigan Attorney General's interpretation. After which, I am sure there will be much more room for debate. D. Nanzer, DPT, MBA, CSCS Supervisor Athletic Training Department & SportsMed Physical Therapy Center Ingham Regional Medical Center Direct >>> Rick Gawenda 12/11/2010 9:10 PM >>> That interpretation can be found on the members only Section of the MPTA website as that is what MPTA is stating. Rick Gawenda, PT President/CEO Gawenda Seminars & Consulting www.gawendaseminars.com Subject: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules (11/29/10) To: PTManager Date: Saturday, December 11, 2010, 9:12 AM Where did Don, PT get the following phrase from that rule: " Also note: Licensed persons designated in this section are persons holding either Physical Therapist or Physical Therapist Assistant licenses. This assumes the all other individuals are unlicensed individuals " ? I searched that whole rule and could not find the definition of a " licensed person " in that rule. It is assumed that one is talking about a PT/PTA being licensed because that is what the paragraph is talking about. But if ATCs are licensed, then I would think that different lawyers would/could interpret this rule in many different ways. I would recommend getting the definition of a " licensed person " as put forth by Don added to the definition paragraph so one knows what a " licensed person " is. Terry Stegman, PT, MS, Eng-Phy Mr. Nanzer, ATC's would not be allowed to provide physical therapy interventions. They would be able to perform tasks and acts delegated to them by a PT or PTA. Rick Gawenda, PT President Section on Health Policy & Administration APTA Supervisor Ingham Regional Medical Center SportsMed & Physical Therapy Center Quote
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 Let me preface my comments with the understanding of how difficult it is to develop rules that are clear-cut and not open for interpretation. With that said, I must agree with Selena regarding the statement " and, if appropriate, with other individuals involved in the care of the patient or client " , is open for interpretation. My opinion is the MI Board of PT meant this statement to apply to the family members of the patient or other designated individuals in the care of the patient, but I can see how others could interpret it to mean other providers such as ATC's. This was one question I had for ; however, he and I have been unable to touch base with each other. I think has done as best as one can do via email and list serves to provide the MI Boards interpretation/meaning of the Administrative Rules. I would also say MPTA's example of what constitutes an act, task, or function was vague with one of the examples being " some modalities " . My question wold be " What are some modalities " ? My hope is once the AG provides their opinion, the MI Board of PT and/or MPTA may be able to provide further clarification to its members and non-members as we all ( well, maybe most) strive to do the right thing. Rick Gawenda, PT President Section on Health Policy & Administration APTA Subject: Re: New Michigan PT Administartive Rules (11/29/10) To: PTManager Date: Tuesday, December 21, 2010, 8:39 PM Â , your interpretation is really skewed toward the interpretation the MPTA rolled out. If you read the language in the actual rule and not what MPTA would like you to believe, you'll see the gray. Let's start with the definitions: R 338.7121 Definitions. (d) " Intervention " means the purposeful and skillful interaction of the physical therapist or physical therapist assistant with the patient or client and, if appropriate, with other individuals involved in the care of the patient or client, using various physical therapy methods and techniques to produce changes that are consistent with the diagnosis and prognosis. Via the definition of " intervention " the door is opened for interaction of " other individuals " in the care of the patient or client besides physical therapists and physical therapist assistants. Because of the long-winded description and the use of prepositions, the language creates two situations. 1) The PT or PTA interacts with the patient/client AND with caregivers of the patient/client or 2) The PT or PTA interacts with the patient/client AND with other staff members within the organization providing services. This administrative rule definitely defines the roles of physical therapists and physical therapist assistants. The rule doesn't define or describe all the " other individuals " involved in the care of the patient or client. We know there are " other individuals " because the rule does discuss delegation to " unlicensed " individuals. The issue lies in the simple fact that " other individuals " involved in the care of the patient or client could potentially be licensed athletic trainers. The intent of what MPTA probably wanted written and the language of what was actually written are two different things. I'll be interested in the Michigan Attorney General's interpretation. Selena Horner, PT ton, MI > > Mr. Nanzer, > > ATC's would not be allowed to provide physical therapy interventions. They would > be able to perform tasks and acts delegated to them by a PT or PTA. > > > Rick Gawenda, PT President Section on Health Policy & Administration APTA > > Supervisor > > Ingham Regional Medical Center > > SportsMed & Physical Therapy Center > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.