Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: OT: Opinion time!!!! Gastric bypass Vs the lap band

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

If it were me I would pick the one that is the least invasive. I think there is

a new procedure that is more like the band that is less surgery than the other

with excellent results. Cannot remember what it is called.

Good luck to you. My sis in law is about to have the lap band done and I know

two other people this year who had it done with great success.

Carolyn Eddy

" Sweet Goat Mama "

Posted

Carolyn:

I am leaning towards having the lap band procedure.

My sister had the gastric bypass surgery when it was first invented

many years ago. At first it was a success. Now she has regained every ounce that

she lost AND MORE!!!!

All of her family keeps harping on me to have the gastric bypass. When

they do this, I bring up my sister and say, " no way, !! "

I have heard that the gastric bypass procedure is also very risky!!

Chris

>

>

> If it were me I would pick the one that is the least invasive. I think

> there is a new procedure that is more like the band that is less surgery

> than the other with excellent results. Cannot remember what it is called.

>

> Good luck to you. My sis in law is about to have the lap band done and I

> know two other people this year who had it done with great success.

>

> Carolyn Eddy

> " Sweet Goat Mama "

>

>

Posted

have you done any research on the procedures? Have you talked about with

your doctor? Your doctor may feel one procedure would be better if you have

other medical conditions.

I know people who have had both procedures and have done well. the by pass

surgery is much less invasive than years ago. The lap band is adjustable from

what I hear.

Hopefully some of this group will be able to give you feed back of their

experiences.

Have a good holiday season.

--- Halladay wrote:

>

>> If you were in my spot, which surgery would you have? Would you have

> gastric bypass or the lap band? Why have you made that one your choice?

>

Posted

Hi

Just some information from my experience. I had The gastric bypass surgery done

in 2002 was on a respirator & hospitalized for a month afterward. The weight

came off easy but After a year and a half it started to come back on.

I lost 400lbs And gained back 150lbs.Before surgery I had little pain, but since

the surgery I've had chronic pain from lower leg lymphedema and Fibromyalgia and

can do less now than at my highest weight.

I'm on an online support group for others who have had gastric bypass and it

unfortunately didn't help their pain.

The band has issues as well, as long as something is liquid a person

can consume it so sugar, and other high cal stuff, some people in my

support group would even put lasagna in a blender.

And others have had to have emergency surgery because of bleeding

ulcers near the band, or lodged food. There are many sucessful people as

well.But for them it's a life long battle of measuring, planning, supplements,

and exercise. Wishing you the best in whatever you decide.

Peace,

> --- Halladay wrote:

> >

> >> If you were in my spot, which surgery would you have? Would you

> have

> > gastric bypass or the lap band? Why have you made that one your

> choice?

> >

>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...