Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 Libraries aren't exactly in the creative fields, but the whole spirit of the freedom of information feels great after growing up being told how we should/shouldn't feel. Also, books were my escape world..I loved escape novels like Harry Potter or " On the Run " type series, where the kids would forge a new world for themselves, solve problems, etc. I would also have a ton of dreams where I'm running away from my family or from some bad guy, but my fada keeps chasing me down. Once in a while, though, I managed to. I couldn't stand realistic fiction about families, for some reason. I'm also a writer (though time keeps me from doing so all the time) and I've written many short stories, poems, and I've been attempting to write this one escape book since I was 15. I was trying to portray a happy family, but oddly enough, I couldn't. I stopped and restarted. It fell by the wayside when I was disowned by fada and enabling nada. But now that I have all this perspective, though, I'm thinking about returning to my story, using my family dynamics as the framework for a more workable, writable family that I actually understand. I always wanted to keep a journal, especially after I saw Harriet the Spy, but then my parents told me that's a horrible thing to do, and discouraged it. But I've tried on occasion keeping clandestine journals, hiding it in my room, but I was always afraid that my parents would stumble across it. So periodically I'd rip out all the pages and throw it out on trash day so they wouldn't find the incriminating frustration and anger I was putting down on the pages--if they had I would have been in hot water for a LONG time. So, now, when I want to go back and see what I was writing, I can't. I even took it out on a blog, but then I deleted all the pages. I also liked drawing, and I still do. Nothing like a box of crayons or colored pencils to channel your emotions into something therapeutic, to center your mind before doing some other task (like homework). > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 I am actually the opposite. I am so dang analytical it's scary. I don't know if nada made me this way of if it's genetic or both. I'm in the medical field, so my Type A-ness works out well for that. But the over analyzation of everything causes some problems in my personal life. Oh wait! I just remembered this- I kept a journal from 2nd grade until the end of high school, a little in to college. I only wrote when I was upset- so pretty much every day. It was really cathartic. Nada has read my journal twice that I know of. I felt SO violated. Maybe that's why I don't keep one anymore. Or maybe it's because now that I am out of nada's house I don't need it so much. I tried to start it up again a few years ago but it felt like more of a chore than anything else. > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 I'm not in a creative field, but I can remember keeping a journal from an early age, and nada constantly trying to get hold of it. She would also rearrange my room and go through all of my things every time I went away for a weekend, on a church trip or to a camp, or to spend the night at a friends house. I'm 29 years old now, and have not lived at home since I was 18. A couple of years ago nada was cleaning out my old room and gleefully told me how she and my younger male coousin who she hired to help clean found all my old letters to past boyfriends and read them all. There was no privacy allowed in nada's house. > > > I work as a freelance writer and a photographer. Oddly, for all her > faults, my mother has always encouraged this. Possible because she has > NPD too and finds this brag worthy. > > Sent from my blueberry. > > On Mar 26, 2010, at 8:27 AM, Fiona <hermitsdaughter@...<hermitsdaughter%40yahoo.com>> > > wrote: > > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self- > > expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, > > music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I > > would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was > > writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 Oh me too! Reading is one of the only ways I can find to relax. It's so great to be swept up into another world. When I am depressed that's all I want to do. I used to draw when I was little but have no interest anymore. Did nada kill all of my creativity or maybe I just changed? I noticed recently that instead of making things " extra " special, like when decorating for parties, I keep things pretty simple. I think I crave basic and simple since nada was OVER THE TOP with all things and stressed herself and me to the maximum over every detail. And always there was some thing that didn't turn out the way she expected so she was disappointed. Also, she expected a large amount of praise for all her work. > > > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 photography is so cool. I wish I had that talent! > > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self- > > expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, > > music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I > > would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was > > writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 Yup! I'm an artist - I've been painting since I was a kid. This has always been a safe way for me to express myself, and " to feel heard " . My nada always complained that she didn't like the tone of my voice. Painting gave me a voice that she couldn't criticize :-) I went through periods of writing in journals as well, but that was always scary because as a kid, nada would sneak into my room and read my diaries. - > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 When I was in 2nd grade I ripped out a few pages of my diary and threw them in the trash. It was about a boy I thought was cute. Nada found them and kept them. I think that's alright, because now when I read them it's cute. What's NOT alright, was that she teased me about them at the time. I was mortified. It's like my feelings didn't matter because I was a kid. Wait, they don't matter now either. How silly of me. > > > > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > > > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self- > > > expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, > > > music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > > > > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I > > > would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was > > > writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 That's an interesting question. I absolutely love creative arts of ALL kinds. It's something that my parents could not take from me. My imagination is something that I can share with people I choose. I write creatively (as does my brother). I cherish photography (especially of nature - the absence of human pain/emotions). I paint. I draw. I crotchet. I do all that I can creatively to release the child within me. I teach and do what I can to share my enthusiasm for life with others. Writing in a journal was sketchy for me as a child because nada would find the information and use it against me. Writing about fiction was much safer and less painful. As an adult I find much catharsis/healing from writing. Has anyone read books by Augusten Burroughs? Wow! He's got a gift of writing and he's got quite a story to tell. Eh? > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 I started writing abstract poetry and painting abstract art for this reason. My mother wasn't horribly bright. She'd read the poems and have no idea what they meant or that they were about her. ________________________________ To: WTOAdultChildren1 Sent: Fri, March 26, 2010 2:37:51 PM Subject: Re: Writers, artists?  That's an interesting question. I absolutely love creative arts of ALL kinds. It's something that my parents could not take from me. My imagination is something that I can share with people I choose. I write creatively (as does my brother). I cherish photography (especially of nature - the absence of human pain/emotions) . I paint. I draw. I crotchet. I do all that I can creatively to release the child within me. I teach and do what I can to share my enthusiasm for life with others. Writing in a journal was sketchy for me as a child because nada would find the information and use it against me. Writing about fiction was much safer and less painful. As an adult I find much catharsis/healing from writing. Has anyone read books by Augusten Burroughs? Wow! He's got a gift of writing and he's got quite a story to tell. Eh? > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 " I only wrote when I was upset- so pretty much every day. " Oh Mozz I loved this statement. Just speaks of so much understanding and healing. I never wrote when I was little because there was no privacy in my house. What I did do was read. Alot. My sister was 5 years older than me so the books that were around were quite a bit along. I remember reading The Fountain Head and Atlas Shrugged when I was in 4th and 5th grade. lol I would escape into the reading and still to this day I love a good book. I still find it too troubling to read or watch anything about disfunctional families or abused children........ I am very analytical so I use that in the running of my business but my business itself is very crafty. Receiving validation for designs is very healing for me. What I find the most healing is letting the young people that work for me create things and than bragging about them. This way I get to help them with self esteem and in turn it gives me a sense of doing something worthwhile and giving something I never got as a young woman. > > > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 26, 2010 Report Posted March 26, 2010 I am a writer. It took me years and years of growth to even admit that secretly, much less type these words. And I was a writer when I was young, but tucked it away " forever " when my mother attacked it as a teenager. It came back. And I am thrilled. And now, I am throwing all logic to the wind and following my true calling. I am a writer. Thanks for this post. > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 27, 2010 Report Posted March 27, 2010 Growing up, I wrote every single day. A lot. Poems, stories, journaling, you name it. I was known for always, ALWAYS, having my nose in a book. I hung out at libraries. On Friday nights. Until nada found my journal and made it clear she didn't like what she'd read. She accused me of doing all sorts of bizarre things based on what she found, when in truth I was a pretty normal kid. Suddenly, writing wasn't safe anymore. I literally didn't write recreationally again for twenty years. In the meantime, I became more drawn to math and science, largely I think because there was always a right answer that no one could argue. In other words, two plus two always equalled four no matter what your religion was or whether you had a bad day. My equations couldn't be misinterpreted or used against me. They were either right or they weren't. I found some solace there. I'm now a doctor and I'm finding myself drawn back to writing. It's like a zit I've ignored for far too long and now it really, really needs to be popped. Every time I write I am terrified. I expect ridicule, scorn. I expect to be shunned or fired because of it. I know these fears are probably irrational but to me they are extremely real. So in short, although in practice I'm a doctor, in my heart I'm a writer. > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 27, 2010 Report Posted March 27, 2010 Wow you guys have all mirrored my own experiences...this is so encouraging because you understand me too. The npd in my nada made her a stage mother, and I began piano lessons at 7. I've played all my life...but in the past several years have not touched my piano. Just since I began researching bpd have I had the urge to play again...to self-express. Playing the piano around nada's house everyday was one way I could drown out her yelling, slamming, and raging. It soothed the savage beast. A lifetime girlfriend told me recently I used to carry notebook paper and a pencil around everywhere we went as kids. I've always written. Writing has been the best friend because when I had to be 'overly protected' by nada, when my younger brothers were still icky to me, and my fada was always gone on the road, I could write. Mostly it was poetry, short stories, or just journaling. I still love to write. I like to do research papers believe it or not...because they're based on FACTS and they are ORGANIZED. My high school boyfriend and I wrote love letters to each other and I kept his in a notebook in my room. Nada was reading it all the time and I didn't realize it. Of course it was 'dirty' and 'shameful' to her...but it was actually normal. I had a box of letters in my room, and one weekend, my nada and fada had their friends come to get me and take me to spend the weekend with them. While I was gone, my parents scourged my room for anything they could find to incriminate me... All they found was a simple box of letters, in which one girl had writtem to me about my sexual feelings toward a boyfriend. When I came home, they raised hell about it, they banished her when she came to visit, and forbade me from ever seeing Fred again. This is how most all of my relationships ended... with their interference. To this day I don't know how to end a relationship. So yes to writing, piano, loved math, loved science, and reading. > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 27, 2010 Report Posted March 27, 2010 Hi Fi In my professional life I m an electronics and computer geek. Yea, picture the slide rule and multi colored pens, the spaced out 1000 yard stare, the geeky guy at the console at a NASA launch. My avocations, and loves, are artsy. I m a musician, I play the trombone, I draw and paint in pastels, I ve been dabbling in digital photography, mostly to provide subjects to draw, but coming to appreciate it as an art in its own right, and I write, prose, poetry, and as I noted in an earlier post, have a book in the concept phase. Reading was a major escape as a kid, from the madness that was nada. Ditto music. Anything I think, that lets us create a world that is not the private hell we lived in was good. Doug > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 27, 2010 Report Posted March 27, 2010 thanks for this post, i can really relate.. i remember spending a lot of time reading many books and writing in my journal every day too.. escaping into a book often more mature than i could fully understand.. and pouring my heart out in my diary, which nada snooped into until i locked it up and told everyone she was the reason behind my needing a lock..  today i have no business of my own to do, but i really enjoy your encouraging others' work who are a part of your business.. and i find myself doing that with my friends and acquaintances a lot of the time too.. trying to find as many ways i can sincerely compliment them and build them up as i can.. it was something i never had growing up, encouragement to do well and i get a lot of satisfaction doing that now.  we orphans have a lot in common i think. Subject: Re: Writers, artists? To: WTOAdultChildren1 Date: Saturday, March 27, 2010, 12:48 AM  " I only wrote when I was upset- so pretty much every day. " Oh Mozz I loved this statement. Just speaks of so much understanding and healing. I never wrote when I was little because there was no privacy in my house. What I did do was read. Alot. My sister was 5 years older than me so the books that were around were quite a bit along. I remember reading The Fountain Head and Atlas Shrugged when I was in 4th and 5th grade. lol I would escape into the reading and still to this day I love a good book. I still find it too troubling to read or watch anything about disfunctional families or abused children.... .... I am very analytical so I use that in the running of my business but my business itself is very crafty. Receiving validation for designs is very healing for me. What I find the most healing is letting the young people that work for me create things and than bragging about them. This way I get to help them with self esteem and in turn it gives me a sense of doing something worthwhile and giving something I never got as a young woman. > > > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 27, 2010 Report Posted March 27, 2010 Can I ever so relate to all of this!! When I was a kid, all I could think of to write was what is commonly known as " fan fiction " --stories featuring characters and plots from TV shows and movies. I could never make up my own characters and plots, because I was so in love with the characters and shows on TV. I always wanted to be somebody else...me, only somebody else. Wonder why *that* might have been. *rolleyes.gif* I finally figured out why a girl at age 8 or so might really feel like she needed to be Isis: She'd have to be a superhero before her parent was ever satisfied with her! My mother used to go on and on about how she encouraged my writing. And that was true, to a point. Yeah, there were times she could be encouraging, but I remember being made fun of MUCH more often, and stuff I was writing taken out and denigrated and laughed at. She'd complain to my father, who took me out and bought me " The Diary of Anne , " because they thought a child ought to be reading something important. When I was a kid, I was the only child I knew who never got to see any of the Star Wars movies, because my parents though they were " stupid. " I was expected to as well, and also expected to defend this view to the neighborhood kids. You can expect that that didn't endear me to them at all, especially since they had seen them and I hadn't! I also completely get it about the parent stage managing all your relationships. My nada had to be *completely* in the middle of any childhood friendship I had. Every time I saw or talked to anybody, there was an endless round of, " What did you say? " and then, " What did she say? " and, " What did you say? " and, " What did she say? " until I had painfully dredged up every single little cotton-picking little syllable. When I finally thought she was done, she would forget it for an hour or so and then it would be, " So what else did say? " and she'd continue until I felt like screaming and crying and tearing my hair and running from the room. Any problem I experienced with these childhood friends HAD to be handled exactly the way she thought it should be handled and I had to report the conversation and the results. Of course, since she didn't know how to manage relationships at all, this was not at all any way to learn how. When we moved out of town, I kept in touch with my first girlhood friend from my old neighborhood as much as possible and when we were in grade school, she'd come and spend weeks with us in the summer. But as high school started and life got busier and we moved again, we didn't have much in common anymore and life got busier. Nada really missed this childhood friend, because she would come over and help with housework without being asked. (Now, if you were being hit and screamed and raged at constantly, would YOU want to help with housework?) This was the kid nada once said she wished was her daughter instead of me. When high school graduation time came around, this friend sent us a graduation announcement. Nada was so enraged that this person hadn't kept in touch, it didn't matter that *I* wasn't or that *I* understood life had moved on and we had grown apart. She took it upon herself to write a blistering letter to this friend, without my knowledge, thus ending my relationship with the friend. I thought of contacting the friend, maybe mailing her a secret letter or something, and explaining, but then I might have to face what would happen if we patched things up and my friend later told nada what I had done. At seventeen, I wasn't ready to face that, so I lost contact with the person. I never did get to explain. I guess she thought nada was writing that poison pen letter from both of us. I, however, digress. After writing a fan fic that *almost* won an Omni Peace Writing Award (but didn't because it was a fan fic), I at last got an idea for something original to write. I'm working on a novel about KO's struggling with life and BPD parents... --. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 27, 2010 Report Posted March 27, 2010 I always loved writing. I will never forget nada coming into my bedroom, finding the key to my diary where I had written that I loved Chamberlain who played Dr. Kildare back then of course to which she wrote back in her writing of course IN my diary " you are not to like Dr. Kildare anymore. You are to like Ben Casey " . I felt betrayed when I found that written in my diary and very violated. Of course I became a very timid child very early in life thanks to being very afraid of nada and displeasing her along with her 'children should be seen and not heard'. I was judged as bad even though I did nothing wrong or bad because I knew how I would be beaten whenever I did do the slightest thing or nothing to displease her so I was afraid to test my boundaries and of course challenge the Queen. She years later when I got one of my first boyfriends as a young adult kept his letter to me for a month knowing that he was moving back to Wisconsin to go to law school and in it had asked me to please forgive him. If he didn't hear from me in a month, he would be back in Wisconsin but in it he admitted how much he loved me and wanted me to go back with him where we would marry! I never forgot him but of course since nada did NOT want him with me she steamed open that letter, kept it from me just long enough for him to leave and THEN told me the landlady had 'just given it to her' (I got home from work an hour and a half later than nada) and she handed it to me steamed open but the postmark on it gave her away. She made no secret of the fact she didn't like him when we were going out. Although he did betray me by cheating on me with another woman who wasn't a virgin (I was) and she had gotten pregnant with his child which is why I broke it off with him, he had finally convinced her to have an abortion the letter stated. It altered the course of my life. I would have married him! She had no right to do what she did, but nada as all BPD'sfrom reading about other nada's here, have no rules except their own set of rules to live by. I still think about him occasionally, but of course I will never find him now and if I did, I'm sure he's married to someone else and happy. Yes I did become a writer anyway despite nada who has no idea I am writing the story of coping and living with a BPD nada which will not be sent for publication until she has passed on. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 27, 2010 Report Posted March 27, 2010 OMG, Marilyn. That just floored me. My nada did something similar to my brother. He had met someone online and she told her he had financial problems and a bankruptcy. Now, this relationship probably was not going to go anywhere anyway, but you don't disclose private financial information like that to a perfect stranger on the internet whom you've never even met, about a child of yours who's trying to start a career in law enforcement! How appalling it is that our nadas don't think twice about doing this kind of thing. And look how many people have written in here that their nada snooped in their room, their diaries, etc. This appears to be a very common thing! --. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 27, 2010 Report Posted March 27, 2010 Ann, And talking about giving others credit and kudos helps to remind me to do it more often! I never had children so I get to Mother others in healthy ways! > > > > > > > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > > > > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > > > > > > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 27, 2010 Report Posted March 27, 2010 My mother played piano growing up, and she took me and my siblings to lessons. When my brother stopped playing, she quit taking me. I drove myself across town and paid for lessons out of my part time, minimum wage, HS paycheck. I was average (or so I thought) and nada told me a few times how much she hated it and how much it cut her apart when I played a song better than her. Funny, I quit playing at 19 or so. After all, I was just average after all. Last month, I went to hear some kids from an art school play piano. These kids rehearse at least 3 hours each day, with lessons on the side. I was struck with the fact that I was 90% as good as them when I was in high school. Apparently, I was very talented and was doing some very difficult pieces. It was ignored. Never mentioned in my house. They never once reflected that to me or spoke about the fact that I was good. They treated me like I was barely adequate. I don't really play anymore. And here's another fun one: I wrote a really good song about 10 years ago. I performed it in front of my church, and it was VERY well received. My mother told everyone my sister wrote it. Never wrote another thing again. Sheesh. > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 29, 2010 Report Posted March 29, 2010 Hi Holly, I **love**libraries. My fantasy would be to have my own fully furnished luxury suite in a library, with cable tv and a Wii, of course. I could spend a full day at a library and not know the time has gone. The funny part is that my mother works at my local library, so I try to go when I know she's not there. Even my 12 year old will say, " why does grandma have to give us such a hard time when we come to visit at the library?? " My mother will get all " don't talk to me, I'm working!! " self-righteous, and then sidle up to me to talk trash about her coworkers. I hear you when you were saying, " I've tried on occasion keeping clandestine journals, hiding it in my room, but I was always afraid that my parents would stumble across it. So periodically I'd rip out all the pages and throw it out... " Me, too, totally. I start to keep a journal and find myself not being completely as honest or genuine as I want b/c I'm afraid it'll be found. My mother read through my stuff all the time and one time it was really, really bad. After that time, she treated me like I was complete trash; didn't like what she'd read. > > > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 29, 2010 Report Posted March 29, 2010 " Also, she expected a large amount of praise for all her work. " Mozz, that's how my brother is. Ugh, I hate it when he gives me a gift or does something. I deliberately just say, " oh, thank you very much. " And that's IT. Otherwise, if I keep gushing or saying thank you (b/c he keeps going on and on about how much trouble it was and how rude the cashier was but he held his tongue... " Yada yada!!! > > > > > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > > > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > > > > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 29, 2010 Report Posted March 29, 2010 " When I was in 2nd grade I ripped out a few pages of my diary and threw them in the trash. It was about a boy I thought was cute. Nada found them and kept them. I think that's alright, because now when I read them it's cute. What's NOT alright, was that she teased me about them at the time. I was mortified. It's like my feelings didn't matter because I was a kid. Wait, they don't matter now either. How silly of me. " Mozzarella, that's terrible. You must've felt pretty helpless. My mother does that to my 5 year old. Of course, I don't put up with it. Nada's such a meathead. Honestly, my 5 year old--being FIVE--behaved kind of mischievously and my mother mildly scolded her. Fine. THEN, she (nada) said, " I'M going to go sit with my OTHER granddaughter. SHE'S much better behaved. " I just told my little one, " don't worry, sweetie. Nanny's just being silly. " Later when we got home, I asked her how it felt when nada did that. She just said, 'it hurt. " I'm going to have to scale back these visits as well. > > > > > > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > > > > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self- > > > > expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, > > > > music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > > > > > > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I > > > > would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was > > > > writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 29, 2010 Report Posted March 29, 2010 I'm so happy for you that you can " come out " as a writer! To someone not from this kind of background, it might sound like it doesn't make sense. But it makes perfect sense, esp when you live and are raised by people who need to know everything about you, even almost your thoughts. Someone else had said they wrote only fiction in their home, to avoid getting found out. I wish I'd done that. > > > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 29, 2010 Report Posted March 29, 2010 " Every time I write I am terrified. I expect ridicule, scorn. I expect to be shunned or fired because of it. I know these fears are probably irrational but to me they are extremely real. " Writermanque, I know how you feel. I think that might be why I asked others how they felt about this; every time I try to write creatively...I can't. Not to lay yet another thing at my mother's feet (oh what the heck!), but when I was in my late teens, she found a journal I'd kept about 3 years previously. I had changed in so many ways, for the better, since I'd written that journal. She went ballistic. And, worse for me at this age, she utterly shunned me. I can imagine what an Amish shunning must feel like. She refused to speak to me, she would not touch me, nothing. She would look at me with contempt and say things like, " slut " or would mutter under her breath. I don't know, I must have ptsd associated with this! B/c it's really affected my ability to just write. If I write creatively, I expect all the things you said. I need to just do it! > > > > I was wondering yesterday how many of us are in the creative fields. > > With our backgrounds, many with parents not exactly encouraging self-expression, I was curious if any of you turned to writing, art, music, etc. to feel " heard. " > > > > I've always written -- even that was threatening to my mother. I would be writing in my journal and she would want to know what I was writing. " I'm dying to know what you're writing about... " Yeesh. > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.