Guest guest Posted August 3, 2010 Report Posted August 3, 2010 Does Dr. Goldberg have a website? What is the difference between him and other docs?To: shiriw@...; mb12 valtrex Sent: Tue, August 3, 2010 10:52:52 PMSubject: Chelation Shiri, I’m so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz’s son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son’s story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally. My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don’t know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn’t until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn’t want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn’t have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours. Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don’t waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. ’s first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . Hope this helps, Marcia Hinds Quote
Guest guest Posted August 3, 2010 Report Posted August 3, 2010 Marcia, I don't understand why you would come here and say this. I don't care about you talking about Dr. G, I think everyone has a right to information about doctors and can make their own choices. But this list is called "MB12Valtrex". Which pretty much means it's a DAN type of list, which we both know Dr. G absolutely hates. Yes, I was on the list when my son was a patient of his but I didn't come here to tell everyone how Dr. G hates this or that to a list of people that are doing DAN/homeopathy/naturopathy/whatever. Do you honestly think that people don't know that chelation is controversial to the greater medical community? We're *all* here doing things that are controversial. NIDS isn't any less controversial. The topics discussed on this list are mostly all things Dr. G doesn't agree with. Dr. G doesn't even like Stan and you know this, you've been around a long time with Dr. G so I don't think for a second that you missed that conversation with Dr. G.But my problem is with you coming on here and talking about how dangerous Dr. G thinks chelation is (or HBOT, or supplements or anything else, for that matter). I don't understand why you're here, then. You don't do MB12, either. Not that I think you need to, I'm just confused as to why you are on here. If it's to only provide a sales pitch for Dr. G, and make everyone feel guilty/horrible/scared about the choices they are making or considering then I have a problem with it. It's one thing to discuss the pros and cons of chelation, but I don't hear that from you. Instead I hear Dr. G's rhetoric. I left his office to get away from his DAN ranting.I get very wary when I see dr. G's patients on here because as crazy as it sounds, people report back to Dr. G about other patients. And it worries me that privacy is being violated. And before you get defensive, *IT HAPPENED TO ME*. Someone decided to tell Dr. G when I was still with him that we were doing MB12. It was a nightmare, his *wife* decided to get involved, etc. So forgive me if I sound a little conspiracy theorist here but I've been around the block on this.If you want to discuss treatment, discuss treatments. If you want to discuss your experience, by all means do so. And honestly, I don't care if you talk about Dr. G. But parents have enough people and doctors trying to tell them that everyone that *is* finding success is wrong and hurting their children and doing everything they can to scare them away from any kind of biomed treatment. They don't need it here, too. They need information. Good bad and indifferent. Things to research. How to make sensible choices. Things like that. They need support. If you have anything negative to offer about chelation, then offer it. If you have any experience with it, then offer it. But "Dr. G says it's dangerous" isn't helpful considering how he feels about DAN and how DAN feels about him. Cheryl~http://www.gryffins-tail.blogspot.com~@midian42~ Shiri,I’m so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz’s son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son’s story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally. My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don’t know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn’t until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn’t want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn’t have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours.Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don’t waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. ’s first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . Hope this helps,Marcia Hinds Quote
Guest guest Posted August 3, 2010 Report Posted August 3, 2010 Hello, dear. Andy Cutler's protocol is the safest, most effective way of chelating. period. Many, many people have been harmed by IV, high dose and infrequent dosing. Please check up autism mercury and frequent dose chelation groups before going down your proposed path. You won't regret it. Best wishes, F. > > A Naturopath I am considering using has an article on chelation on his > site and he uses intravenous EDTA to chelate. It is very expensive! > ($100/visit including all the kidney function tests, minimum 30 visits) > > I thought I read somewhere that some of you were administering topicals > on the inside of the arm to chelate heavy metals in your children. Is > that DSMA or someething? > > What tests are necessary when one is chelating? > > How much does that cost for a course of treatment, including all the > kidney function tests, etc.? > > How long does it take to normalize from heavy metals with chelation? > Any experiences you've had would be welcome. > > Laurie > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 3, 2010 Report Posted August 3, 2010 , Reading the story of your sons recovery made me cry from hope and happiness. Hope from hearing others recoveries is what keeps me going when I just want to crawl under the covers and stay there. I don't know if DS's current progress will stick, we've been through many ups and downs in our journey to recovery, and we still have such a far ways to go. As far as doing chelation, I think every child's issues are different, and I can't ignore so many parents testimonies of its effectiveness. I'm also afraid of the damage chelation might cause, but I'm more fearful of the damage being done if I don't get those metals out. Ds has high metals, and has classic symptoms of mercury damage: little feeling in hands and feet, night sweats etc... I just want it out! If anyone has a better alternative, I will consider anything. I will definitely look into Dr. Goldberg, although I must say that I am wary of anyone who completely rejects other Biomedical Dr.s and treatments. No treatment approach or Doctor has all the answers on what will work 100% for every kid. If they did, we wouldn't all be on this list searching and trying new things! I don't know a lot about the science of how these things work, but I do know that absolutism, especially when it comes to science that is yet to be explained, is something I am wary of. My son's pediatrician who gave him 8 vaccines all at once adamantly argued with me about what nonesense it was to break up vaccines - and since DS regression I will never trust a Dr who claims to have all the answers. My current Dan admits he doesn't have all the answers and that we just have to try and test and try and test. Thats all we can do. Thanks so much for sharing your story, you must be so proud of your son! I hope one day I can tell the same story... > > Shiri, > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and > recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same > doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated > with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were > also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are > considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. > Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know > about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We > treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally. > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us > would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. > The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends > on an academic scholarship. > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. > He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At > school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. > joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student > Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for > three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, > is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, > I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid > who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the > house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third > percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical > treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in > his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in > the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received > any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted > pretty weird socially. > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the > local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that > all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to > recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face > another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech > therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The > worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what > choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or > drag him kicking and screaming into ours. > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children > are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune > problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, > educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that > for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive > supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I > found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New > York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with > . > > Hope this helps, > > Marcia Hinds > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 I agree! We never chelated. But if we had, or if we ever decide to, Andy Cutler's protocol is the only one I'd choose!!I'd much prefer following a protocol by a PhD in chemistry from Princeton vs. a DAN who had one semester of Chemistry in all of his years at medical school! Andy has books that you can read, as well, if you'd like to learn more. Or like Fiona said, sign up for one of his message boards. Sent from my iPhone Hello, dear. Andy Cutler's protocol is the safest, most effective way of chelating. period. Many, many people have been harmed by IV, high dose and infrequent dosing. Please check up autism mercury and frequent dose chelation groups before going down your proposed path. You won't regret it. Best wishes, F. > > A Naturopath I am considering using has an article on chelation on his > site and he uses intravenous EDTA to chelate. It is very expensive! > ($100/visit including all the kidney function tests, minimum 30 visits) > > I thought I read somewhere that some of you were administering topicals > on the inside of the arm to chelate heavy metals in your children. Is > that DSMA or someething? > > What tests are necessary when one is chelating? > > How much does that cost for a course of treatment, including all the > kidney function tests, etc.? > > How long does it take to normalize from heavy metals with chelation? > Any experiences you've had would be welcome. > > Laurie > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 Agree with your sentiment on doctors claiming to know everything. The DAN doctors in general are more open as I have seen but I have heard from Dr G's patients (we are not currently) that he monitors each patient very closely & is definitely knowledgeable on the Immune system dysfunction aspect. - which is a common issue with kids (again probably not all the kids).We all want to be able to tell the story like Marcia soon & hope by that time there will not be so much confusion on Diagnosis & treatment options. I hope Marcia & others story influence mainstream medical institutions like AA of Pediatrics etc to recognize the gravity of the situation & not continue to do what they have been doing for the last so many years. To: mb12 valtrex Sent: Tue, August 3, 2010 10:37:21 PMSubject: Re: Chelation , Reading the story of your sons recovery made me cry from hope and happiness. Hope from hearing others recoveries is what keeps me going when I just want to crawl under the covers and stay there. I don't know if DS's current progress will stick, we've been through many ups and downs in our journey to recovery, and we still have such a far ways to go. As far as doing chelation, I think every child's issues are different, and I can't ignore so many parents testimonies of its effectiveness. I'm also afraid of the damage chelation might cause, but I'm more fearful of the damage being done if I don't get those metals out. Ds has high metals, and has classic symptoms of mercury damage: little feeling in hands and feet, night sweats etc... I just want it out! If anyone has a better alternative, I will consider anything. I will definitely look into Dr. Goldberg, although I must say that I am wary of anyone who completely rejects other Biomedical Dr.s and treatments. No treatment approach or Doctor has all the answers on what will work 100% for every kid. If they did, we wouldn't all be on this list searching and trying new things! I don't know a lot about the science of how these things work, but I do know that absolutism, especially when it comes to science that is yet to be explained, is something I am wary of. My son's pediatrician who gave him 8 vaccines all at once adamantly argued with me about what nonesense it was to break up vaccines - and since DS regression I will never trust a Dr who claims to have all the answers. My current Dan admits he doesn't have all the answers and that we just have to try and test and try and test. Thats all we can do. Thanks so much for sharing your story, you must be so proud of your son! I hope one day I can tell the same story... > > Shiri, > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and > recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same > doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated > with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were > also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are > considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. > Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know > about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We > treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally. > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us > would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. > The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends > on an academic scholarship. > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. > He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At > school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. > joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student > Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for > three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, > is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, > I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid > who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the > house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third > percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical > treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in > his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in > the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received > any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted > pretty weird socially. > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the > local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that > all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to > recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face > another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech > therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The > worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what > choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or > drag him kicking and screaming into ours. > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children > are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune > problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, > educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that > for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive > supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I > found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New > York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with > . > > Hope this helps, > > Marcia Hinds > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 > > > > A Naturopath I am considering using has an article on chelation on his > > site and he uses intravenous EDTA to chelate. It is very expensive! > > ($100/visit including all the kidney function tests, minimum 30 visits) > > > > I thought I read somewhere that some of you were administering topicals > > on the inside of the arm to chelate heavy metals in your children. Is > > that DSMA or someething? > > > > What tests are necessary when one is chelating? > > > > How much does that cost for a course of treatment, including all the > > kidney function tests, etc.? > > > > How long does it take to normalize from heavy metals with chelation? > > Any experiences you've had would be welcome. > > > > Laurie > > > Reading these post i also get worried about all these treatments for our kids. We did DAN for 5-6 yrs. my grandson got only worse. I am saying this because I only want parents to be careful with all. We did mild HBOT actually purchased one) almost 200 dives chealation (transdermal) this I depleted him of vitamins he was so sick he could not get up off couch & move arround like other children. He had hidden strep didn`t know (DAN Dr.)didn`t mention oxygen feeds strep this caused him more problems. We were afraid at this point we were loosing him. Think God we found Dr. Goldberg We stopped all supp. except multivitamin he started his protocol he got better. Started getting color back eating better put his weight back on he lost.We have pictures to prove what he looked like during this time. He is not recovered but he is more aware more healthy than before. We feel we are on the right track with Dr. G.`s protocol with our little boy. Parents just be careful I don`t want this to happen to any other child I know how we all desperately want our children to get better. Each child is different I`ve read success stories from DAN but for ours it was a nightmare. Marcia just wants to help these children I understand what she is saying she cares. We need to help each other & listen with and open mind. Carole Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 Cheryl, I am a mother just like you who has been taken advantage of because of my desperation to help my child. I have read your posts for years and know what an intelligent, concerned and informed mom you are. Any of us would do anything if we thought it would change the outcome for our kids. That makes us very vulnerable and sometimes not the best judge of the treatments we should be using. Yes, Dr. Goldberg can be difficult, sometimes even more than difficult. But that doesn’t change the fact that he is brilliant, correct medically, and saved my kid. I like you have had many problems with Dr. Goldberg. I’m not saying anything here that I haven’t told him to his face. We have had many arguments over the years and I especially get angry when he thinks his way is the only way and he yells at parents when he thinks they are doing things that will not help their kids. As parents we have enough guilt and insecurity about our kids without his antics on top of the problems we have to face daily. Sometimes just getting out of bed to face another day full with autism seems like an impossible task. I am not a Goldberg groupie. We even stopped seeing him for almost two years when he became too difficult to work with and got our meds from our family practice doctor. But that was a scary time, since our family doctor didn’t really understand the medical reasons or how to do the blood tests to ensure there was no damage to my kid from the meds. All of this discussion doesn’t change the fact that Goldberg helped my child recover. But even his methods wouldn’t have been effective if I hadn’t done the ABA and educational interventions. In my opinion, Dr G knows the medical but not the behavioral or educational. He hates ABA. But those are the techniques we used to help learn what he missed. If you can't get a kid to do anything or attend, you can't teach them anything. I don’t care which doctor you go to for help. Dr. in Texas is much easier to deal with than Dr. G but go to someone who will use sound scientific methods to help your child and not just throw hundreds of supplements at the same time so you don’t know which thing is actually working. I haven’t been to all the DAN doctors (some may be doing the right things) but I did go to Sidney Baker who started DAN with Dr. Rimland and he wasn’t. Even if you do everything right, some kids have immune systems so messed up even the correct treatment can’t help them. I’m glad you found what is working for your child. That is all that matters, but I question is your child and Stan’s kid doing so well because you started correcting their immune systems with Dr. Goldberg or because of what you are doing now? For our kind of kids the response to treatment may be years behind what you actually did because it takes years to gain language and develop after doing the initial treatment has helped your child. And what about the kids who just get better from spontaneous remission? Kathy who runs the Northern NY clinic for autism said on another list: “The problem with these recovery stories is that they are very misleading. Was this child in a subgroup that went into a spontaneous remission as at least 10% of the kids do? If so, then parents watching this may think the therapy made a difference, which it does in the sense that it MAY help the child " catch up " but if their child is not in that same sub-group it won't work the same way.” She went on to say since you don’t see the result of treatment immediately it is difficult to pinpoint what was done to help a child. Kathy on I don’t know about the MB12 lollipops but Stan Kurtz started to help his son by going to Dr. Goldberg and still refers to him on his website. Unfortunately, sometimes the initial reason, good intentions and mission for people’s actions change. I have been told by a friend of mine that Stan Kurtz charged her $200 for an hour of consultation to help her son. I question how another parent without an MD behind their name (who has been through this hell with their child) would try to benefit financially from helping another parent? What’s wrong with this picture? As of yet there is not magic pill or cure, just years of work with skilled in immunology (like Dr. Goldberg or Dr. ) to help correct the problems with your child’s immune system. We started with Dr. G when my son was five. We did DAN before that. is now twenty-one and recovered. My son, , was diagnosed when he was four years old. The leading authority on autism said he would never be okay. He was going to end up in a group home. Today does all the things the professionals said could never happen. He studies mechanical engineering at a university on a merit scholarship. excels academically but more importantly has friends and even a girlfriend for a while. He is a member of Sigma Chi Fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. is a typical college student who drinks an occasional beer, goes on dates, stays out too late with friends and then sleeps through eight o’clock classes. I couldn’t be more proud. When was little, I never thought these things were possible. Unbelievable as it seems, this is the same child who wanted to spend every day all day long plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house. ’s long road to recovery was the hardest thing I have ever lived through but this is the reason I am on this list. I would love to spend my time doing other things, but there are too many kids not getting better. Recovery is a long process, not for sissies, and not all kids can fully recover. But they can all improve. Marcia Hinds Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 Cheryl I did not tell Dr Goldberg about your son, it was one of your friends on this list she simply said " Cheryl does it why can't I " I barely look at this list any more but a mom not a patient of my husband thought I should know you referenced me. There is no privacy issue and I work there so no HIPPA violation but sorry it was not me. Dr Goldberg has a book coming out in the Winter when you see the Spect scans of the brains of your children and the damage caused by HBOT, Chelation, and Mega supplements perhaps you will change your opinion. I only got involved with you because I thought you were a good person and that was by private email. I felt sorry for your son, I don't care who his doc is but what you were about to do to him and the resulting damage to his brain. When you and others see the thining and scalloping of the brain that leads to seizures that these therapies cause I hope you will wake up and re-think your position. This is not to scare anyone but reality! My husband would not be as adament as he is about these approaches if his training and time did not support how harmful they are to children and the general lack of failure of any " real success " . Elyse Goldberg > > > > > Shiri, > > > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally. > > > > > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. > > > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. > > > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours. > > > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . > > > > Hope this helps, > > > > Marcia Hinds > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 I've known you were on this list for a long time now, Elyse. And I know there are lots of people reporting back to you and Dr. G. (even if it is simply by accident). How it happened really doesn't matter. If there were anything I didn't want getting back to you, I wouldn't have said it. No need to feel like you have anything to explain to me.I know why you contacted me then. I know you did it because you care. I happen to know first hand how passionate you and Dr. G are about our kids. But having met so many "real successes", I think a blanket disregard for other methods is only harmful to the goal *for everyone*. My son is doing very well. He's starting general ed 1st grade after a very successful gen ed Kinder year, playing soccer and has friends. I can't complain at the moment. I know about the Spect Scans. I also know the same arguments used in other studies, both for and against various things, used by both Dr. G and DAN can be applied here, too. But I certainly don't object to seeing the information out there or on this list. Cheryl~http://www.gryffins-tail.blogspot.com~@midian42~ Cheryl I did not tell Dr Goldberg about your son, it was one of your friends on this list she simply said "Cheryl does it why can't I" I barely look at this list any more but a mom not a patient of my husband thought I should know you referenced me. There is no privacy issue and I work there so no HIPPA violation but sorry it was not me. Dr Goldberg has a book coming out in the Winter when you see the Spect scans of the brains of your children and the damage caused by HBOT, Chelation, and Mega supplements perhaps you will change your opinion. I only got involved with you because I thought you were a good person and that was by private email. I felt sorry for your son, I don't care who his doc is but what you were about to do to him and the resulting damage to his brain. When you and others see the thining and scalloping of the brain that leads to seizures that these therapies cause I hope you will wake up and re-think your position. This is not to scare anyone but reality! My husband would not be as adament as he is about these approaches if his training and time did not support how harmful they are to children and the general lack of failure of any "real success". Elyse Goldberg > > > > > Shiri, > > > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally. > > > > > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. > > > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. > > > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours. > > > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . > > > > Hope this helps, > > > > Marcia Hinds > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 I have uploaded some Spect scans of kids doing what you believe to be correct, sorry this isn't science fiction but very real. As they say one picture worth one thousand words...The deterioration of these children's brains is nothing short of criminal, they have no say in the matter. I know of several attorneys looking into class action suits in this matter. Everyone's definition of well is different mine is a functioning brain not one fried out by chelating, HBOT, and supplements. And for the record Dr Goldberg's approach was approved by the FDA for future trials and accepted by The Medical Board as " do no harm " so regardless of what you chosen to believe it is safe. I'm sorry that you don't have an open enough mind to see the effects your son had coming off a SSRI was because he needed it! Would love to see a scan of him by 4th grade. Elyse Goldberg > > > > > > > > > > > Shiri, > > > > > > > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. > > > > > > > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > > > > > > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. > > > > > > > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours. > > > > > > > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . > > > > > > > > Hope this helps, > > > > > > > > Marcia Hinds > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 And I'm sorry you didn't get to see him acting like a psychopath/sociopath while he was on it. It's too bad you didn't see what he looked like because you might have had the same creepy feelings as my husband and I did when we were worried he might decide to get into the knife drawer and stab us all in our sleep. Maybe you think that's "needing" and "helping" but turning my son into a psychopath, to me, isn't helping at all. So please, don't tell me I don't have an open mind. I went to see Dr. G to begin with, I'd say that certainly counts as open since I knew of the other protocols then, too, and chose him despite his reputation among the DAN community. Using withdrawal as an excuse to say he "needed" it is unconscionable when there is more than enough evidence and widely accepted that these drugs have withdrawal symptoms. As a psychiatrist (if I remember correctly), you know this. My son's behavior/cognition improved dramatically after his withdrawal symptoms were over and he is a different kid without them than with them.I've chosen to believe what I've seen with my own eyes in my son. SSRIs were not right for him. I'm sorry *you* aren't open enough to realize that. You're more than welcome to pay for a scan of him in the 4th grade.And now, with those scans, how many of them were given under controlled settings? How many of them were given before doing anything? And then, how many were given wherein treatments were controlled and documented? How many of them were of kids that had nothing before and then did HBOT and HBOT *only*? Sure, it's easy to say that what everyone is doing is wrong when you say you have the spect scans to prove it but the spect scans, while I don't disagree that they are helpful and clearly something is going on, but it doesn't show causation. Can you pinpoint causation or is it just a bunch of kids that have done these things that you are getting scans of and then saying, yes, it's HBOT, chelation, supplements, etc because none of my kids are doing it and their scans don't look like that. There are so many reasons why these scans can come out that way. And yes, I do believe it's possible it very well could be HBOT or chelation or supplements. But again, where's the causation in the pictures? Does this argument sound familiar? Because when you break it down to bare bones, it's the same argument used for all the other studies that get "discredited" by the so-called experts telling me my son has a genetic defect that causes autism. Or the argument that says diet doesn't work. Or that my son's progress is due to time, not medicine. Or that vaccines just happen to be timed at the same time as autism is generally diagnosed. The list goes on.You seem to think that I completely think you're wrong. I've never said you are wrong. I've never even hinted that you're wrong. But you keep getting defensive and telling me I'm not open when I've been nothing but open. I think Dr. G has some good stuff happening and I would actually *love* to see someone take his spect scans, see his correlations, and decide to do a full scale controlled study on it to really get some answers. But we're still pointing fingers in the dark here. Cheryl~http://www.gryffins-tail.blogspot.com~@midian42~ I have uploaded some Spect scans of kids doing what you believe to be correct, sorry this isn't science fiction but very real. As they say one picture worth one thousand words...The deterioration of these children's brains is nothing short of criminal, they have no say in the matter. I know of several attorneys looking into class action suits in this matter. Everyone's definition of well is different mine is a functioning brain not one fried out by chelating, HBOT, and supplements. And for the record Dr Goldberg's approach was approved by the FDA for future trials and accepted by The Medical Board as "do no harm" so regardless of what you chosen to believe it is safe. I'm sorry that you don't have an open enough mind to see the effects your son had coming off a SSRI was because he needed it! Would love to see a scan of him by 4th grade. Elyse Goldberg > > > > > > > > > > > Shiri, > > > > > > > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. > > > > > > > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > > > > > > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. > > > > > > > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours. > > > > > > > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . > > > > > > > > Hope this helps, > > > > > > > > Marcia Hinds > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 This conversation has absolutely nothing to do with me, but I don't feel you have a place on this board. Coming on here and essentially saying that the treatments us parents are doing is 'nothing short of criminal' is just plain rude. What is criminal is the fact that we were all put in the position of having to repair the damages incurred to our children from those whom we trusted. I'm not a doctor or a scientist, but I can't imagine that a brain that is filled with mercury is all that pretty on a spect scan either....it has to look better once all that garbage is removed, no matter the method of removal. And as lovely as it is that your husband's methodology is being adopted by the FDA, that doesn't mean that others' methods aren't recovering children. And to be honest, my faith in the FDA is sort of on rocky grounds these days, anyway. Please stop coming on here and trying to scare parents with these sort of tactics. To: mb12 valtrex Sent: Wed, August 4, 2010 6:15:30 PMSubject: Re: Chelation I have uploaded some Spect scans of kids doing what you believe to be correct, sorry this isn't science fiction but very real. As they say one picture worth one thousand words...The deterioration of these children's brains is nothing short of criminal, they have no say in the matter. I know of several attorneys looking into class action suits in this matter. Everyone's definition of well is different mine is a functioning brain not one fried out by chelating, HBOT, and supplements. And for the record Dr Goldberg's approach was approved by the FDA for future trials and accepted by The Medical Board as "do no harm" so regardless of what you chosen to believe it is safe. I'm sorry that you don't have an open enough mind to see the effects your son had coming off a SSRI was because he needed it! Would love to see a scan of him by 4th grade.Elyse Goldberg> > > > > > > > > > > Shiri,> > > > > > > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally.> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. > > > > > > > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > > > > > > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. > > > > > > > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours.> > > > > > > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . > > > > > > > > Hope this helps,> > > > > > > > Marcia Hinds> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >> > >> > > >> Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 I agree.So, let me get this straight.... if you want to use Dr. G to help your kids, you need to consent to SSRIs no matter whatand you need to consent to being spied on by his wife? Now *that's* creepy.--- ToniTo: mb12 valtrex Sent: Wed, August 4, 2010 7:27:36 PMSubject: Re: Re: Chelation This conversation has absolutely nothing to do with me, but I don't feel you have a place on this board. Coming on here and essentially saying that the treatments us parents are doing is 'nothing short of criminal' is just plain rude. What is criminal is the fact that we were all put in the position of having to repair the damages incurred to our children from those whom we trusted. I'm not a doctor or a scientist, but I can't imagine that a brain that is filled with mercury is all that pretty on a spect scan either....it has to look better once all that garbage is removed, no matter the method of removal. And as lovely as it is that your husband's methodology is being adopted by the FDA, that doesn't mean that others' methods aren't recovering children. And to be honest, my faith in the FDA is sort of on rocky grounds these days, anyway. Please stop coming on here and trying to scare parents with these sort of tactics. From: ElyseG <elyse-g@.... com>To: mb12 valtrex@ yahoogroups. comSent: Wed, August 4, 2010 6:15:30 PMSubject: Re: Chelation I have uploaded some Spect scans of kids doing what you believe to be correct, sorry this isn't science fiction but very real. As they say one picture worth one thousand words...The deterioration of these children's brains is nothing short of criminal, they have no say in the matter. I know of several attorneys looking into class action suits in this matter. Everyone's definition of well is different mine is a functioning brain not one fried out by chelating, HBOT, and supplements. And for the record Dr Goldberg's approach was approved by the FDA for future trials and accepted by The Medical Board as "do no harm" so regardless of what you chosen to believe it is safe. I'm sorry that you don't have an open enough mind to see the effects your son had coming off a SSRI was because he needed it! Would love to see a scan of him by 4th grade.Elyse Goldberg> > > > > > > > > > > Shiri,> > > > > > > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally.> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. > > > > > > > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > > > > > > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. > > > > > > > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours.> > > > > > > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . > > > > > > > > Hope this helps,> > > > > > > > Marcia Hinds> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >> > >> > > >> Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 Not sure why you are atacking her, I appreciate the info > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Shiri, > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. > > > > > > > > > > > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > > > > > > > > > > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. > > > > > > > > > > > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours. > > > > > > > > > > > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . > > > > > > > > > > > > Hope this helps, > > > > > > > > > > > > Marcia Hinds > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 Please, keep it civil, guys. Cheryl~http://www.gryffins-tail.blogspot.com~@midian42~ Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 What info ? That we are hurting our kids? I would appreciate it if it wasn't given to prove a point of an argument...I think Marcia was trying to be helpful... But it seems like since someone's name was mentioned in a previous email, " It's on !" And we all have to hear and see what damage we have been doing to the kids we love. Callous disregard if you will. Sent from my iPhone Not sure why you are atacking her, I appreciate the info > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Shiri, > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. > > > > > > > > > > > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > > > > > > > > > > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. > > > > > > > > > > > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours. > > > > > > > > > > > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . > > > > > > > > > > > > Hope this helps, > > > > > > > > > > > > Marcia Hinds > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 Ditto!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!To: mb12 valtrex Sent: Wed, August 4, 2010 7:33:11 PMSubject: Re: Re: Chelation I agree.So, let me get this straight.... if you want to use Dr. G to help your kids, you need to consent to SSRIs no matter whatand you need to consent to being spied on by his wife? Now *that's* creepy.--- ToniFrom: ez <martis0425@sbcgloba l.net>To: mb12 valtrex@ yahoogroups. comSent: Wed, August 4, 2010 7:27:36 PMSubject: Re: Re: Chelation This conversation has absolutely nothing to do with me, but I don't feel you have a place on this board. Coming on here and essentially saying that the treatments us parents are doing is 'nothing short of criminal' is just plain rude. What is criminal is the fact that we were all put in the position of having to repair the damages incurred to our children from those whom we trusted. I'm not a doctor or a scientist, but I can't imagine that a brain that is filled with mercury is all that pretty on a spect scan either....it has to look better once all that garbage is removed, no matter the method of removal. And as lovely as it is that your husband's methodology is being adopted by the FDA, that doesn't mean that others' methods aren't recovering children. And to be honest, my faith in the FDA is sort of on rocky grounds these days, anyway. Please stop coming on here and trying to scare parents with these sort of tactics. From: ElyseG <elyse-g@.... com>To: mb12 valtrex@ yahoogroups. comSent: Wed, August 4, 2010 6:15:30 PMSubject: Re: Chelation I have uploaded some Spect scans of kids doing what you believe to be correct, sorry this isn't science fiction but very real. As they say one picture worth one thousand words...The deterioration of these children's brains is nothing short of criminal, they have no say in the matter. I know of several attorneys looking into class action suits in this matter. Everyone's definition of well is different mine is a functioning brain not one fried out by chelating, HBOT, and supplements. And for the record Dr Goldberg's approach was approved by the FDA for future trials and accepted by The Medical Board as "do no harm" so regardless of what you chosen to believe it is safe. I'm sorry that you don't have an open enough mind to see the effects your son had coming off a SSRI was because he needed it! Would love to see a scan of him by 4th grade.Elyse Goldberg> > > > > > > > > > > Shiri,> > > > > > > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally.> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. > > > > > > > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > > > > > > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. > > > > > > > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours.> > > > > > > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . > > > > > > > > Hope this helps,> > > > > > > > Marcia Hinds> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >> > >> > > >> Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 I second that.The FDA means s*** to me. To: mb12 valtrex Sent: Wed, August 4, 2010 7:27:36 PMSubject: Re: Re: Chelation This conversation has absolutely nothing to do with me, but I don't feel you have a place on this board. Coming on here and essentially saying that the treatments us parents are doing is 'nothing short of criminal' is just plain rude. What is criminal is the fact that we were all put in the position of having to repair the damages incurred to our children from those whom we trusted. I'm not a doctor or a scientist, but I can't imagine that a brain that is filled with mercury is all that pretty on a spect scan either....it has to look better once all that garbage is removed, no matter the method of removal. And as lovely as it is that your husband's methodology is being adopted by the FDA, that doesn't mean that others' methods aren't recovering children. And to be honest, my faith in the FDA is sort of on rocky grounds these days, anyway. Please stop coming on here and trying to scare parents with these sort of tactics. From: ElyseG <elyse-g@.... com>To: mb12 valtrex@ yahoogroups. comSent: Wed, August 4, 2010 6:15:30 PMSubject: Re: Chelation I have uploaded some Spect scans of kids doing what you believe to be correct, sorry this isn't science fiction but very real. As they say one picture worth one thousand words...The deterioration of these children's brains is nothing short of criminal, they have no say in the matter. I know of several attorneys looking into class action suits in this matter. Everyone's definition of well is different mine is a functioning brain not one fried out by chelating, HBOT, and supplements. And for the record Dr Goldberg's approach was approved by the FDA for future trials and accepted by The Medical Board as "do no harm" so regardless of what you chosen to believe it is safe. I'm sorry that you don't have an open enough mind to see the effects your son had coming off a SSRI was because he needed it! Would love to see a scan of him by 4th grade.Elyse Goldberg> > > > > > > > > > > Shiri,> > > > > > > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally.> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. > > > > > > > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > > > > > > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. > > > > > > > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours.> > > > > > > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . > > > > > > > > Hope this helps,> > > > > > > > Marcia Hinds> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >> > >> > > >> Quote
Guest guest Posted August 4, 2010 Report Posted August 4, 2010 I need to jump in. I'm Kathy I've been on the boards for 4 years. My son is a non responder! Meaning he stays the same whatever I try. I need to tell you I am doing NIDS now with Dr Goldberg. I am not at all a Goldberg groupie but I do wish I had known about him years ago. My son has been doing his antiviral/antifungal/SSRI protocol now for almost 6 months and there is still no change for the better or worse. I don't think he has autism anymore - something else is going on! I can't seem to find where the damage has been done! He is non verbal and has done proper ABA/VB/Natural Environment Teaching for those same 4 years. He is a true non responder. But I will tell you at 2-2.5 years old I had a very different kid. He called out to me in the morning when he woke up and smiled when I came to his room and asked for more cookies/juice/etc. He is now non verbal with interest in nothing; so all I do every night for the last 4 years is go online and learn and learn from parents. I do think that I made the mistake of chelating way too strong. I do believe that chelation made things worse not better. Although before I did that I made the effort to meet other local families who had done chelation and had success! Major success so I started with IV-DMPS from a pretty famous West Coast DAN. I live in Canada where there is no DAN just a naturapath who has taken DAN training and now is a part of Great Plains Labs. There is no one here so my husband and I would pick who we would visit every year. We've been to Oregon/New York and Florida chasing DANS and came away with nothing. So I just want to say that I think it is totally fair for everyone to give their opinion. Good and Bad the list that I was on is not running anymore and I learned so much there. But now I am glad there are other lists where I am finding both Marcia and Cheryl. Whether you agree with each other or not. BOTH of you have helped me tremendously! All of the asd boards help. I don't post often but just reading them gives me a sense of not being alone in this. I still believe my kid will recover even though I am exhausted trying to figure out how!!! Kathy in BC > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Shiri, > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Hope this helps, > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Marcia Hinds > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 Elyse, Do you have an autistic or recovered child? Caryn > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Shiri, > > > > > > > > > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. > > > > > > > > > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > > > > > > > > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. > > > > > > > > > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours. > > > > > > > > > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . > > > > > > > > > > Hope this helps, > > > > > > > > > > Marcia Hinds > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 This is just my opinion. And I will be civil. The scans that were uploaded were done so to prove a point to an argument. Elyse clearly states that she barely looks at this email list anymore. Don't be surprised if your questions about the scans go unanswered. I for 1 am extremely upset by this scare tactic. I hate that I am questioning every decision I've made based on scans I do not understand. This should never have taken place. It was truly irresponsible .Margo Sent from my iPhone Elyse, Do you have an autistic or recovered child? Caryn > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Shiri, > > > > > > > > > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. > > > > > > > > > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > > > > > > > > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. > > > > > > > > > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours. > > > > > > > > > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . > > > > > > > > > > Hope this helps, > > > > > > > > > > Marcia Hinds > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 ly I'm just sick of the public bickering among the professionals who are suppose to have our kids best interest at heart. I suppose if one truly believes his or her way is the only way he/she may get frustrated with what others are doing. But lately the public studies contradicting former comrades are annoying and to me discredit all the studies. Obviously there are politics involved. Look at the doctors who have autistic kids themselves. They are not only doctors but parents--they also do what they think is best for their kids. Also what works for one kid doesn't work for another so there is room in this arena for lots of ideas. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Shiri, > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. > > > > > > > > > > > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > > > > > > > > > > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. > > > > > > > > > > > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours. > > > > > > > > > > > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . > > > > > > > > > > > > Hope this helps, > > > > > > > > > > > > Marcia Hinds > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 I should reply to the group more -- sorry for that. I have two children that were severely autistic. I thought that they would never drink out of an open cup or know their names. My daughter regressed to the point that she was mute. My son now attends a mainstream school and received an average of 85% this last year -- and he is still improving. My daughter is no longer mute -- far from it. Over about the last 9 years, we have tried just about everything. They were in one of the first studies using MB12. I have learned that the heavy metals and viruses that damaged their chemistry hit them in more than one spot. Taking the approach that a variety of things have to be done has been most productive. There are no silver bullets, where a couple of supplements did the trick. Of all the things I wish I could have done differently was getting the mercury, lead, antimony, etc out of their systems as quick as possible. I regret that I listened to the mainstream to the point that I proceeded so slowly at first. I know that each child is different, but I now realize that one of the most important pieces to this has been getting the heavy metals out. They do nothing but harm while they remain in our childre. There is a lot of talk about chelation that is just not based in much fact. As long as you are working with a trained DAN doctor, it is safe. He will monitor liver functions, minerals, etc, as per the protocol. A valuable piece of the puzzle should not be thrown out, because of hearsay. Tim > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Shiri, > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm so glad the antivirals worked for your child. My son is 21 and recovered. He sees Dr. Goldberg of Tarzana, Ca. who is the same doctor who first saw Stan Kurtz's son and helped him. My son was treated with antivirals also. The rest of the issues with his immune system were also treated. When I read about how you and some others on the list are considering Chelation I had to write to let you know how dangerous Dr. Goldberg believes that is for our kids. I also wanted to let you know about my son's story in hopes of helping you and others on the list. We treated his Autism medically, behaviorally and educationally. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > My son was diagnosed with autism when he was four. The psychiatrist told us would probably end up in a group home or institution. She was wrong. The only institution is in today is the university he currently attends on an academic scholarship. > > > > > > > > > > > > does all the things the doctors told me he would never be able to do. He lives in a dorm with three guys who don't know he ever had autism. At school, he studies mechanical engineering and is number two in his class. joined Sigma Chi fraternity and was president of the Jewish Student Association. He drives, has tons of friends, and even had a girlfriend for three months (who would have seen that one coming?) But more importantly, is happy. If anyone had told me this was possible when he was little, I never would have believed them. How could this possibly be the same kid who spent his days plugging in a portable radio into every outlet in the house, made weird noises, and hurt his sister? > > > > > > > > > > > > When my son entered kindergarten at almost six, he was in the third percentile for speech. By that time had been receiving medical treatment from Dr. Goldberg for about a year. He had a full-time aide in his classroom to help him in school. By the third grade, my son tested in the 85th percentile for speech and by sixth grade no longer received any special education services or assistance at school. However, he acted pretty weird socially. > > > > > > > > > > > > In high school, joined the track team, lots of clubs and worked at the local movie theater. However, it wasn't until he was away at college that all the holes in his social development filled in. It was a long road to recovery. There were mornings I didn't want to get out of bed just to face another day filled with autism. The revolving door filled with speech therapists, social skills groups, and ABA therapy was overwhelming. The worst times were when I didn't have a direction or a plan. But, what choice did I really have: let drift off forever into his own world, or drag him kicking and screaming into ours. > > > > > > > > > > > > Today, autism is a catch-all term for a set of symptoms. What our children are facing is not a psychiatric disorder, but a treatable medical immune problem. My kid was kicked out of the autism club because of the medical, educational and behavioral things we did to help him recover. I want that for all your kids so please don't waste time on the millions of expensive supplements. I did that too. 's first doctor was a DAN doctor until I found Dr. Goldberg. Dr. of Port Arkansas, TX and the Northern New York Autism Clinic all use medical treatment similar to what we did with . > > > > > > > > > > > > Hope this helps, > > > > > > > > > > > > Marcia Hinds > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted August 5, 2010 Report Posted August 5, 2010 Sorry if you do not want to see the truth. With Dr. Mena and Dr. we accumulated over 133+ scans in the mid 90s, BEFORE DAN and other protocols were in effect These were essentially CLEAN kids reflecting just this disease (NIDS) process. Consistent with ADHD variants and CFS/CFIDS ALL the pathology was primarily in the temporal lobes (with some issues with the frontal lobes). THIS illness affects those areas. We now have (to Dr. Mena's dismay) NeuroSPECTs with significant abnormalities in what were always previously normal areas of the brain (Parietal lobes, occipital), THIS IS IATROGENIC (therapy induced harm). ANY short term gain, will be more than lost with the harm being done. This is NO longer theoretical, it is being seen on the scans. Dr Mena will soon be publishishing an article showing this. I'm wasn't trying to do any more then give you information that you clearly do not want. The files I uploaded are scans on children before being seen by Dr. Goldberg. There are plenty of scans not of Goldbergs patients showing the same problem. This is a really serious issue as these issues did not exist before these protocols. However seeing the scans scar me. All of the chelation protocols had similar results it would not be fair to name people. Interestingly the scans on SSRI's show healthier brains. In the literature they appear to be neuro-protective. My dad died from a brain disease , he drove to my house on Thanksgiving, was urinating and defecating in the garage by Dec 16 and died on Jan 6th. When the docs at UCLA showed me his Spect scan and said Elyse you can read this, what do you expect us to do? So much tissue was gone that by Jan 6 he stopped breathing as the part of the autonomic system that controls breathing disappeared. I've watched Neurologist read scans and tell me the exact function of the child without ever seeing them. This is not witchcraft but real pictures science! As a parent you have the right to do what you want with your child My Mom had a favorite saying " Time will tell " it certainly will. I thought you as parents would want to see the information, you know like what the brain was doing. My Bad, I guess you can't handle the truth. The number of children now needing group homes is enlarging not shrinking it breaks my heart. I will not post here but Cherly accused me of I'm not sure what, and her docterate will surely recover all your children God willing Anybody wanting real info can contact me by email Elyse Goldberg > > > You know something that really bothers me... Is when somebody like > Elyse gives such a strong statement with nothing to support their point > of view. What tells me that those SPECT scans you uploaded are not from > kids in the NIDS protocol by using SSRIs? Where are your studies that > supports your statement? Where has been Dr. Goldberg all this time and > how come we don't see him at autism conferences as often as many other > doctors? > > Talking about criminal. What about the SSRI side effects? There are > many more severe side effects with the SSRIs than with many other > medications. Why don't you talk about those? > > http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/LongTermSSRI.htm > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/LongTermSSRI.htm> > > > > MEDICAL REPORTS OF SSRI ANTIDEPRESSANT INDUCED (IATROGENIC) SEVERE > SYMPTOMS: > > > > Go to: Newborn Babies (Neonatal) Neurological Damage & Withdrawal > Side-Effects > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants-ADF.htm#neonatal> > Go to: General Physical & Mental Side-Effects > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants-ADF.htm#general> > Go to: Body Movement Disorders (Dystonia) & Parkinsonism (future > Parkinson's disease) > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants-ADF.htm#movement> > Go to: Akathisia, Mania, Restlessness & Restless Legs Syndrome > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants-ADF.htm#akathisia> > Go to: Serotonin Syndrome, Neuroleptic Malignant Syndrome > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants-ADF.htm#serotonin> > Go to: Blood/Organ Diseases, Stroke, Hemorrhage, TIA, Tumours & > Bleedings > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants-ADF.htm#stroke> > Go to: Hepato Toxicity (Liver Damage) > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants-ADF.htm#liver> > Go to: Cardiovascular Toxicity (Heart Damage) & Neurological Toxicity > (Brain Damage) > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants-ADF.htm#heart> > Go to: Epileptiform Activity, Epilepsy, Seizures, REM Sleep/Memory/EEG > Problems, Sleepwalking > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants-ADF.htm#epilepsy> > > Go to: Hypoglycemia (low blood sugar), Hyperglycemia (high blood sugar, > Diabetes) > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants.htm#blood-sugar> > Go to: Urinary Incontinence, Dermatologic (Skin) Problems, Ocular (Eyes) > Disturbances > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants.htm#urinary> > Go to: Pain & Numbness, Swellings, Sexual (Organ) Problems, Hormonal > Imbalances > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants.htm#pain> > Go to: Hyponatremia & Syndrome of Inappropriate Secretion of > Antidiuretic Hormone (SIADH) > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants.htm#hyponatremia> > Go to: (Suicide Overdose)-Toxicity & Death > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants.htm#overdose-toxici\ > ty> > Go to: Suicide, Suicidality, Suicide Attempts & Self-Harm > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants.htm#suicide> > Go to: Mental State, Perceptual, Emotional & Psychological Changes > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants.htm#mental> > Go to: Mental & Physical Side-Effects of Withdrawal/Discontinuation > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants.htm#withdrawal> > Go to: Other Observations & Complications: Case Reports, Reviews & > Studies <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidepressants.htm#other> > > SSRI's: NEWBORN BABIES (NEONATAL) NEUROLOGICAL DAMAGE & WITHDRAWAL SIDE > EFFECTS 2004 > 09/00 > Case/Study Neonatal toxicity: Fluoxetine concentrations in cord & > maternal serum > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidep-concentrations-in-cord-seru\ > m.htm> > 2004 > 08/09 > WARNING Health Canada: Potential Neurological Adverse Effects of SSRI's > on Newborns > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/2004-08-09-HealthCan-SSRIs-newborns\ > .htm> > 2004 > 08/00 > Case/Study Using an SSRI during pregnancy has Damaging Teratogenic > Effects on the Fetus > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/SSRI-teratogenic-effects-on-the-fet\ > us.htm> > 2004 > 06/00 > Case/Review Baby SSRI (withdrawal) side-effects: agitation, breathing & > suction problems > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antideps-neonatal-complications.htm\ > > > 2004 > 02/00 > Case/Study SSRI's during pregnancy: Foetal Brain Damage > (Neurobehavioral Disruptions) > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/SSRI-disrupt-neurological-systems-n\ > ewborns.htm> > 2003 > 11/00 > Case/Review Neonatal (baby) Large Intraventricular Haemorrhage with > maternal use of Paxil > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/paxil-baby-intraventricular-haemorr\ > hage.htm> > 2003 > 08/00 > Case/Review Baby SSRI (withdrawal) effects: hypoglycaemia, bradycardia, > tachycardia, jaundice > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/2003-08-ADRAC-SSRI-neonatal-effects\ > .htm#1> > 2003 > 07/00 > Case/Review Increased risk for neonatal problems after exposure to > SSRI's in late pregnancy > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/SSRIs-serot-symptoms-newborns-infan\ > ts.htm> > 2003 > 07/14 > Case/Review SSRI's During Pregnancy May Cause Neurologic Symptoms in > Newborns > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/2003-07-14-SSRIs-Pregnancy-Newborns\ > .htm> > 2003 > 07/12 > Case/Review Withdrawal symptoms in New Born Baby after exposure to > Effexor during pregnancy > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/effexor-withdrawal-neonate.htm> > 2003 > 04/16 > Case/Review Neonatal (baby) Convulsions & Subarachnoid Hemorrhage after > exposure to Paxil > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/paxil-neonatal-convulsions-hemorrha\ > ge.htm> > 2001 > 09/00 > Case/Review Neonatal Paxil withdrawal syndrome or actually serotonin > syndrome? > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/paxil-serotonin-toxicity.htm> > 2001 > 03/00 > Case/Review New Born BABY SSRI withdrawal syndrome lasting up to one > month after birth > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidep-SSRI-Baby-withdrawal.htm> > 2001 > 03/00 > Case/Review New Born BABY Withdrawal Syndrome after exposure to SSRI's > Celexa, Paxil, Prozac > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/celexa-neonatal-withdrawal-syndrome\ > .htm> > 2000 > 10/11 > Case/Review Prozac Toxicity in preterm infant: marked motor automatism > & skin manifestations > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/prozac-toxicity-baby.htm> > 1999 > 11/00 > Case/Study Breastfeeding while taking Prozac associated with reduced > growth infants > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/prozac-infants-breastfed-growth-def\ > icit.htm> > 1997 > 11/00 > Case/Review SSRI's, Breast Milk and Withdrawal Symptoms in Newborn > Babies > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/SSRI-Baby-withdrawal-breast-milk.ht\ > m#ssri> > > SSRI Antidepressants: GENERAL PHYSICAL & MENTAL SIDE-EFFECTS 2004 > 09/14 > FDA US Antidepressant " BLACK BOX WARNING " On Suicidality Risk > Recommended > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/2004-09-14-FDA-US-Black-Box-Warning\ > .htm> > 2004 > 06/03 > Health Canada Stronger warnings for SSRI's & other anti-depressants > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/2004-06-03-Health-Canada-SSRI-warni\ > ng.htm> > 2004 > 03/00 > Case/Review Severe adverse drug reactions of (SSRI) antidepressants > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidep-severe-adverse-reactions.ht\ > m> > 2004 > 02/00 > Case/Review Serotonin Syndrome and the use of SSRI's > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/SSRIs-serotonin-syndrome.htm> > 2004 > 01/26 > Case/Review Antidepressant Drugs and Suicidal/Aggressive Behaviors > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/sui_behav_antidep.pdf> > 2003 > 06/15 > Case/Review Hyponatraemia with SSRI's > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/2003-06-Australian-Adverse-Drug-Rea\ > ctions-Bulletin.htm#1> > 2003 > 05/00 > Case/Review Antidepressant withdrawal-induced Mania in patients with > mood disorders > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/SSRIs-withdrawal-mania.htm> > 2003 > 04/04 > Case/Review Clinical Study Dr Healy: Lines of evidence on risks > of suicide with SSRI's > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/2003-04-Healy-SSRIs-suicide.htm> > 2003 > 03/31 > Case/Review SSRI-induced Epileptic Seizures > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/SSRIs-epileptic-seizures.htm> > 2002 > 00/00 > Case/Review Effects of antidepressant drugs on seizure threshold > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/SSRIs-seizure-treshold.htm> > 2002 > 05/08 > Case/Review Amotivational Syndrome (Frontal Lobe Syndrome) Link with > SSRI Use in Youth > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/frontal-lobe-syndrome.htm> > 2002 > 03/15 > Case/Review Rare Neurologic Syndrome (Call Fleming Syndrome) Linked to > AntiDepressants > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/call-fleming-syndrome.htm> > 2002 > 03/07 > Case/Review Antidepressants associated with increased risk of falling > in elderly persons > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/antidep-falls-elederly.htm> > 2002 > 03/05 > Case/Review Male Breast Neoplasia (cancer) in association with SSRI > therapy: report of 3 cases > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/SSRIs-male-breast-cancer.htm> > 2002 > 02/00 > Case/Review Hepatotoxicity (liver damage) associated with the new > antidepressants > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/02-2002-Hepatotoxicity-With-New-Ant\ > idepressants.htm> > 2002 > 01/00 > Case/Review Cerebral Vasoconstriction and Stroke after use of > Serotonergic Drugs > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/stroke-vasoconstriction.htm> > 2001 > 06/00 > Case/Review Amotivational (Frontal Lobe) Syndrome with SSRI's in > children & adolescents > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/SSRIs-frontal-lobe-syndrome.htm> > 2001 > 01/20 > Case/Review Selective serotonin uptake inhibitors and Pancreatitis > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/SSRIs-pancreatitis.htm> > 2000 > 12/00 > Case/Review Serotonergic antidepressants and Urinary Incontinence > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/SSRIs-urinary%20-ncontinence.htm> > 2000 > 10/24 > Case/Review Post-SSRI LSD Flashbacks in Teenagers > <http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/case.htm> Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.