Guest guest Posted February 28, 2010 Report Posted February 28, 2010 I mean MEDDLING- I am losing it! Apparently I lost the ability to spell correctly. > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > C, > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing well. > > Then she wrote back: > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish people would leave me alone! > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 28, 2010 Report Posted February 28, 2010 Hi Mozz, me again...first awesome letter you wrote the neighbor and really she responded more maturely than I would have expected. Still that sentence you quoted is a problem. Really it is likely true that your mother really does need extra help to stay independent. Likely this neighbor has a kind heart and a hard time saying no - sees the needs and meets them. Better in the long term for a paid service to do things like shopping, house cleaning and the like. For your sake and to keep neighbors from being unhealthily involved. Is there any way your mother would accept hired help to help with her needs? Is there any way that she can pay for it - or *would* pay for it? I have mine on a list in her city and every six months a social worker from the city comes to evaluate her functioning and set up free help if she's eligible. First time started to work out but then budget cuts screwed it up. Second time my nada lied to the social worker about how much help my aunt actually was to her so she wouldn't qualify. Still pissed about that. And yes you are right about the STUCK problem, there's no pain free way out. I guess it's just an individual question of which pain we can live with. Maybe others on the group will see a different angle that'll be more helpful. > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > C, > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing well. > > Then she wrote back: > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish people would leave me alone! > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 28, 2010 Report Posted February 28, 2010 Mozz, The line you mention sounds like typical non-bpd enmeshment. The bpd needs help, somenone *has* to help, no one else is helping, therefore I *have* to. The sense of compulsion your neighbor feels I don't think has anything to do with you. You have not asked her to help, but probably your mom has. I might just say, " My mom is very lucky to have you there. " In other words, pull yourself out of the equation a little bit in your language. It isn't the two of you together in this trying to help her in tandem. It's each of you separately trying to work out what to do. If the neighbor is enmeshed with your mother, at least it doesn't have to a be a 3-way co-dependent dance. It sounds to me like she's trying to sort out her own feelings about your mom. I think there could be a sign that's getting it when she says, " I keep thinking if you see her more often her sadness would go away, but maybe it wouldn't matter anyway. " Best of luck, Ashana Your Mail works best with the New Yahoo Optimized IE8. Get it NOW! http://downloads.yahoo.com/in/internetexplorer/ Quote
Guest guest Posted February 28, 2010 Report Posted February 28, 2010 The same situation happened to me, so I understand your frustration. After my dad died, my nada latched onto her next door neighbors, a couple, who had been friends with both mom and dad. Nada wasn't ill but she'd lost her husband of 40 years and was alone for the first time in her life, and she became very emotionally dependent on them. Nada demanded a lot of their time and energy and since they were both retired and because they lived right next door they were very handy. My nada became so emotionally needy and demanding that the husband started complaining to me when I would visit nada, he would tell me that I needed to be more involved with my nada, that it wasn't their job and " somebody had to do it. " These next-door-neighbors ended up moving away from my nada after a couple of years. My nada has been very resistant to the idea of a hired care-giver/driver to come in two or three times a week to help her with housekeeping and take her to the stores and to appointments, but that is going to be her only choice, as my Sister will no longer be serving in that capacity and I live on the other side of the country. My nada has been relying on various members of our extended family and on neighbors to drive her around, but as she needs more care I don't think that's going to continue to be an option. But perhaps your nada will be open to the idea of a part-time hired care-giver with a car, who can take her places, which will also give your nada's neighbor a break. -Annie > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > C, > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing well. > > Then she wrote back: > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish people would leave me alone! > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 28, 2010 Report Posted February 28, 2010 Hey, Mozz - I think and Annie have it right. Same thing has happened with my mom. The neighbors/friends are called upon to " help " her (because she acts like she needs a LOT more help than she really requires), then she complains about " having no one in the family to help, sob, sob " so they complain to me and tell me I need to " step up to the plate. " Funny, after a few months, Nada starts painting them black, and they start to disconnect, and I don't hear anything further from them. She has now killed relationships with all of her extended family, her childhood friends, her banker, etc. She's down to this one neighbor who has an agenda of her own, I believe - it's hard to tell who is the bigger player in the scenario. So again, the script has come in handy. " Please take a few minutes to look up BPD and then I will be happy to discuss my relationship with my mother. Until you are briefed on this mental illness and what it does to close relationships, there is no point in our discussing this further. " I am telling you - every single person who has gone to the trouble to look it up has called me back and said, " wow, she does that stuff to me, too. " Then I can suggest ways to deal with her. I am not trying to deprive my mom of friends - God knows, she needs some. But I'm not going to waste my breath trying to defend my NC/LC stance when talking to somebody who's been brainwashed by my mother's -caliber performances. > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > C, > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing well. > > Then she wrote back: > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish people would leave me alone! > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 28, 2010 Report Posted February 28, 2010 , I LOVE the script you've made! " Please take a few minutes to look up BPD and then I will be happy to discuss my relationship with my mother. Until you are briefed on this mental illness and what it does to close relationships, there is no point in our discussing this further. " I'm still kinda clueless with interpersonal communication and need coaching and scripts to get back to normal communication. And also, when trying to explain BPD with uninformed family members, and have been caught in some sort of guilting trip on occasion by my two aunts (mom's sister, and mom's sister in law) who think it's normal parents/children thing, and want me to stop hurting my mom (she grew up in an abusive home, and I'm thinking more and more likely her mother was BPD). As bad as I feel about that, she did make a choice to side with fada. But this script will be VERY important when I talk about it with relatives in a few weeks (visiting them in CO for spring break). So...thank you thank you thank you! > > > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > > C, > > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing well. > > > > Then she wrote back: > > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish people would leave me alone! > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 28, 2010 Report Posted February 28, 2010 Thanks . Can you pls tell me more about that list- how did you find out about that? I wonder if there is something like that in nada's city... I asked nada last night about hiring help and she did excalty what I expected her to do- gave 1,000 reasons why she couldn't do it and when I debunked her reasons one by one she just changed the subject. I am going to look into it and then present her with a few options. > > > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > > C, > > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing well. > > > > Then she wrote back: > > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish people would leave me alone! > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 28, 2010 Report Posted February 28, 2010 I ended up writing back, " My mother is lucky to have you for a friend. I am looking into hiring someone to take her to her appts and run errands. " I think that was good b/c I acknowledged she's a good friend, but let her know I don't expect her to do anything. I don't know. I was really close with this woman and her family growing up, but now I think once nada dies I don't want to have anything to do with her ever again. Sad. > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > C, > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing well. > > Then she wrote back: > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish people would leave me alone! > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 28, 2010 Report Posted February 28, 2010 -- LOVE the script!! Thank you for sharing that!!! I feel a lot more protected having that in my arsenal. Mozz-- Unfortunately, I'm not sure you are going to be able to protect yourself AND protect the neighbor's good opinion of you. I'm sorry. Its not fair. You may have to let her think of you as a jerk--as horribly unfair as it is--to keep your sanity. The more you try to convince the neighbor of the truth, the more you get sucked in to having to justify yourself. And, frankly, you shouldn't have to justify any actions w/ nada to anyone. Your friends here get it. We know. You don't have to convince anyone else for it to be correct and right. Sorry you are having to fight your way through this one--it is a tough one, for sure. Blessings, Karla > > > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > > C, > > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing well. > > > > Then she wrote back: > > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish people would leave me alone! > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 28, 2010 Report Posted February 28, 2010 Mozz, most cities unless they are very tiny have something called a " Elderly Services " or some such thing. It's the arm of the state social services funded by taxes that's in charge of Meals on Wheels eligibility and the like. If you start making calls they'll probably eventually direct you to the organization that has the social workers who can arrange free services and evaluate functioning. I don't doubt your nada will do her best to evade this - mine is slippery as an eel conversationally. The only way I got her to consider it the first time was I emphasized that it was free and she really was in bad shape physically. The great thing is though if you can get someone in there even once then she's on their radar and they call to followup ever so often too. In the case of my nada, unfortunately her health will have to decline severely again before there'll be success getting people in there again but...having the option at the ready eases my mind. Also they usually have a website with all sorts of useful eldercare material gathered - like paid services, low cost housing, various levels of care facilities, etc. I sure wish you luck! Quote
Guest guest Posted February 28, 2010 Report Posted February 28, 2010 Thanks so much for this awesome info- I had no idea. > > Mozz, most cities unless they are very tiny have something called a " Elderly Services " or some such thing. It's the arm of the state social services funded by taxes that's in charge of Meals on Wheels eligibility and the like. If you start making calls they'll probably eventually direct you to the organization that has the social workers who can arrange free services and evaluate functioning. I don't doubt your nada will do her best to evade this - mine is slippery as an eel conversationally. The only way I got her to consider it the first time was I emphasized that it was free and she really was in bad shape physically. The great thing is though if you can get someone in there even once then she's on their radar and they call to followup ever so often too. > > In the case of my nada, unfortunately her health will have to decline severely again before there'll be success getting people in there again but...having the option at the ready eases my mind. Also they usually have a website with all sorts of useful eldercare material gathered - like paid services, low cost housing, various levels of care facilities, etc. > > I sure wish you luck! > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 1, 2010 Report Posted March 1, 2010 I agree--thanks for the great script and great role model, !! - > > > > > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > > > C, > > > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing well. > > > > > > Then she wrote back: > > > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > > > > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish people would leave me alone! > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 1, 2010 Report Posted March 1, 2010 Thanks Karla. I know I have to get over worrying about what others think. My T has told me this time and time again. I wonder- why is that so hard? Why should I care when I know I am not in the wrong? I wish I could be one of those people who doesn't care what others think. > > > > > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > > > C, > > > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing well. > > > > > > Then she wrote back: > > > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > > > > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish people would leave me alone! > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 2, 2010 Report Posted March 2, 2010 Here's my take: " What others think " isn't just a silly vanity to us. If you think about it, our safety and survival depended, at every moment, on what our nadas thought about us. If she thinks we are trash in the moment? We were abused, neglected, violated, etc. If she thinks we were perfect? We may get through that moment, even as it came with a lot of pressure. I guess what I'm saying is that others' opinion of us is linked to our survival and core sense of safety. Its not that easy to just let that go. You're not an idiot. Nor are you vain or petty or shallow. You're just a child of BPD. And you are doing very well. Just keep doing what you're doing--protecting yourself as best you can, releasing what is not yours to hold, and processing/venting as much as you need to. Its a bit like wrestling a porcupine to help them, no? Blessings, Karla > > > > > > > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > > > > C, > > > > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing well. > > > > > > > > Then she wrote back: > > > > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > > > > > > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish people would leave me alone! > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 2, 2010 Report Posted March 2, 2010 Very insightful- never thought about it that way. This post has helped me a lot and I am going to have my husband read it. He can't understand why I can't just *stop* caring. > > > > > > > > > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > > > > > C, > > > > > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing well. > > > > > > > > > > Then she wrote back: > > > > > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > > > > > > > > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish people would leave me alone! > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 3, 2010 Report Posted March 3, 2010 Mozz I ran into this sort of thing so much when nada was alive. It was hard, and it hurt. But the reality of it was and is, BP s manipulate so much, so readily, so easily, that after a time it comes on automatically. Mom ( interesting, now she s dead, sometimes I can call her that) would give these left handed compliments about me to other people, I know he s so busy, thats why he doesnt come around more. Then of course, friends and neighbors thought, as she intended, she is such an understanding mother, and he is such a putz for not visiting his mother. What she did not , of course, tell them, was we lived 5 blocks apart, and she would not come to my house more than 3 times in her last 2 years of life. She would say, He does what he can to help me, but he has that wife to support and his money is really tight. But omit, that she made more from her pension than her sister who was and is still working with SS and work besides, at 75, nor would she mention that she assumed an obligation on my part to support her from the time I was 14 and she was 33 and newly divorced from my dad. She would for all her life spend without regard, was a horrid spendthrift, hoarder, and had awful money management, then expected me ( and of course, anyone she knew or met, and AMAZINGLY, managed to get near strangers to give or send her money for years!) She would not mention the times she would " borrow " money from me, never , ever to be repaid. She would not mention the car I was about to sell to downsize, which she said she would like to buy, or how much of the price of it she stiffed me for. How I ended up losing my Pontiac to her, still paying for it due to her, and driving a little Chevette. How she then gave the car away to her second ex husband as part of the divorce. She would not mention her 500 and 600 dollar a MONTH long distance bills for accepting long distance calls from prisoners across the country. And of course, when I set bounderies, that said Mom , I can t make you do right and sensible things about money, but I can decide never to hand you money unless you do, that was lost. It was meanness. She would push my buttons, until I learned about bounderies, by talking about hers and my dads sex lives, even when I was begging her to shut up about it, saying I didnt want to hear about it, that it was inappropriate, until I was yelling and nearly frothing at the mouth. Then she would " confidentially tell " friends, neighbors, preachers, that she was scared of her son s temper. She had a way , when I was a teenager, of ininuating herself into the relationship with any of my friends that she knew, to the point that they were HER buddies, a car load of teen age boys would go grab burgers, with me, and ..................her. Once, she apparently had a discussion about the lack of cleanliness in our house. Now she was a hoarder, and had a pathological aversion to cleaning. My homes when I lived with her were unspeakably filthy. Once, she ironed a dirty pair of jeans for me to wear to school. The week before, I had experienced a bladder infection, and lost bladder control while wearing them. So they stunk of urine, and infection, and were freshly ironed and steaming when she handed them to me to put on for school. Nada s cleaning habits in a nutshell for you there. So , this discussion with an 18 year old boy buddy, while I was 16, resulted in him coming to the house while I was there alone to tell me to help her clean more, it was to hard on her. Another friend lost. He overlooked 2 things. I outweighed him by 40 lbs, and KO teenagers are filled with rage. I let him live though. So yea, I understand how the opinion of the fringe people works. It was and is hard to set the healthy bounderies. It was hard not to tell people to kiss where the sun wont shine and get out of my life, and sometimes that is what it took. But I learned to try saying, you just don t know the whole story, and in some cases share the story, in some say its really none of your business. And for everyone who talked about it, there were many more who just whispered about it. I could not change what they thought. I knew if they stayed around her long enough, they would end up out of the relationship because well, she was a BP. My friends, who cared for me, and cared to know, I would share the secret with. The others, I had to place them with nada, prepared to just cut them loose as a safe boundery. People who didnt live with it just have no idea. They have a mental image of what it ought to be like, and what you ought to do, and what they think they would do if it were them. They are typically wrong on all counts. It was hard, as was all of life because of being a KO. It hurt. It still does. I m healing, but OH, so slowly. We want others to think well of us. What we all must keep in mind, is that if others talk to nada, her words will always and forever only make her look good, or the victim. She will never this side of death say, our relationship is strained because I was sick and really hurt my kid and screwed it up. I hope we can heal it. The words we dream of, arent they? Most of us will never hear them. So, if she must look good or the victim, then we must look bad or the schmuck. That, friends, is our reality. Doug > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > C, > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing well. > > Then she wrote back: > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish people would leave me alone! > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 3, 2010 Report Posted March 3, 2010 Doug, you always hit the nail on the head. Time and time again your explanations have described my nada perfectly. I am so sick of the compliments that are really digs. > > > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a > really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada > has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about > what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I > treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD > is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 > months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and > I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this > crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > > C, > > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the > jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, > etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she > refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you > once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am > asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up > to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You > ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood > by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses > me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, > but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to > courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about > this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. > Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing > well. > > > > Then she wrote back: > > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she > doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you > both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit > next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to > visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. > Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people > that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat > people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my > neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to > help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she > sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't > matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll > back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do > to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help > and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never > asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, > mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known > me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish > people would leave me alone! > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 3, 2010 Report Posted March 3, 2010 I agree. Doug, and so many others hit the nail on the head and it is amazing how easy some of you guys can put into words what I feel and what I cannot express. the best is what he wrote: She would push my buttons, until I learned about bounderies, by talking > about hers and my dads sex lives, even when I was begging her to shut up > about it, saying I didnt want to hear about it, that it was > inappropriate, until I was yelling and nearly frothing at the mouth. > Then she would " confidentially tell " friends, neighbors, preachers, > that she was scared of her son s temper. Granted, my nada didn't go much into the sex thing...except to announce loudly in front of me, ti the neighbors, when I was a private/conservative teenager that *I* " needed to get laid " nice. All of the people saw my rage and agreed with her and they shook their heads " yes, yes, your daughter has SOME temper " I was teased/tormented/abused so yeah, I had a temper. I hated her back then but didn't know it. Now I know I hate her and can control my anger when she isn't around to abuse me. Hence, why NC works for me! > > > > > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a > > really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada > > has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about > > what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I > > treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD > > is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 > > months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and > > I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this > > crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > > > C, > > > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the > > jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, > > etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she > > refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you > > once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am > > asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up > > to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You > > ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood > > by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses > > me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, > > but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to > > courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about > > this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. > > Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing > > well. > > > > > > Then she wrote back: > > > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she > > doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you > > both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit > > next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to > > visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. > > Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people > > that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat > > people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my > > neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to > > help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she > > sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't > > matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll > > back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > > > > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do > > to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help > > and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never > > asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, > > mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known > > me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish > > people would leave me alone! > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 3, 2010 Report Posted March 3, 2010 Doug, what you wrote really spoke to me especially the part about the hoarding and your friends telling you that you should help her clean. I started cleaning early not because I had " chores " but because there was such filth in the house I couldn't stand it. In hindsight the house was clean to the degree it was because of what I did in those days. My nada's line to me was that we lived like that because we were poor, so when I saw other houses that looked like nice I believed it was because they were rich. I was so angry when I finally understood the lie in that. And of course various strangers over the years have believed it was my job to help her live normally - completely not comprehending the rage I'd encounter when pointing out that having a roach colony next to the stove was unhealthy. I don't know if you've spent any time looking at the children of hoarders web pages and groups that have sprung up in the last few years but it sure is on point. There seems to be a strong link between hoarding and BPD/NPD behavior. It's very rare someone hoards and does not dominate their family into living in it and shutting up about it without BPD type behaviors. I often wonder if the same area of the brain is affected. > > > > Nada has a neighbor that has always been a good family friend. She's a > really good person and has been almost like family to us. But since nada > has gotten sick she has sent me a few really infuriating emails about > what I should be doing. One email basically slammed me for the way I > treat nada. Basically she is misinformed and doesn't even know what BPD > is. I asked her politely to butt out and she apologized. Now, about 2 > months later I got another email telling me that nada is really sick and > I should visit more often and put our differences aside and all this > crap. I was just livid when I got the email and wrote this: > > C, > > I talk to my mom every day- I know how she feels, I know about the > jury duty, I know about her mouth, that she needs to get her taxes done, > etc. On all accounts I have tried to help and on all accounts she > refuses. I know your heart is in the right place, but I have asked you > once to stop sending me these emails telling me what I should do. I am > asking you again to please stop. You are misinformed. You chalk this up > to every day mother- daughter issues, which I assure you it is not. You > ask me to imagine this or that. Imagine being constantly misunderstood > by a neighbor who assumes without asking. It hurts my feelings, stresses > me out and frankly makes me mad. I appreciate all you do for my mother, > but I do not expect anything from you. I wish you would extend me to > courtesy of knowing I am doing the best I can. If you want to talk about > this in person let me know and I will come over next time I am in town. > Otherwise please know I care very much about you and hope you are doing > well. > > > > Then she wrote back: > > Okey dokey. Yes I continue to see one side possibly because she > doesn't explain (and she doesn't have to) what's going on between you > both and so therefore for example if I ask her about when you will visit > next she sometimes cries and tells me you can't make it up here to > visit. I then make an assumption you don't want to visit more often. > Other than your mother I have always looked for friendships with people > that are more or less happy, cheerful, positive thinking and upbeat > people doing worthwhile things we have in common. But your mom is my > neighbor and became my friend anyway and someone has to do what I do to > help her and she doesn't want P to come back. I keep thinking if she > sees you more often her sadness will go away, but maybe it wouldn't > matter anyway and I am truly not seeing the situation correctly. So I'll > back out of making suggestions to you about your mother. > > > > What really bothers me now is this line: " someone has to do what I do > to help her " . What should I say to this? It's true- she does need help > and I feel bad it's falling on the neighbor. But guess what- I never > asked for her help. I don't know what to say back. I am so annoyed, sad, > mad, etc. Who does she think she is, juding me like this? She has known > me since 7th grade- I thought she knew me better than this. I wish > people would leave me alone! > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 3, 2010 Report Posted March 3, 2010 At another group I belong to for those with bpd relatives or bpd SOs, the topic of hoarding behaviors came up. There appeared to be a lot of posters mentioning that their bpd mother was a hoarder and lived in a filthy, unsanitary home because the nada refused to get rid of the hoarded junk or clean up the place even though she was not physically disabled. Some mentioned that their bpd mom didn't hoard stuff, yet allowed filth to accumulate unabated (decomposing garbage, layers of accumulated food on counters, fungus and mold-encrusted plates in the sink, animal feces and urine soaking the carpets, layers of animal hair and dander coating every surface, etc.) You'd think the neighbors would complain about the stench and the rats and roaches such filth would attract. My nada was/is a clean freak and a hoarder; the piles of excess items she collected were/still are all neatly boxed in plastic containers and labeled, though. She loves to shop for clothes, but how many pairs of pink slacks can one woman possibly use, I ask you? Last time I looked, I swear she had 18 different pair of pink slacks. Her closets are stuffed with clothes and shoes, but neatly. It does make me wonder if perhaps the same parts of the brain (if not functioning properly) result in both bpd and hoarding behavior? -Annie > > Doug, what you wrote really spoke to me especially the part about the hoarding and your friends telling you that you should help her clean. I started cleaning early not because I had " chores " but because there was such filth in the house I couldn't stand it. In hindsight the house was clean to the degree it was because of what I did in those days. My nada's line to me was that we lived like that because we were poor, so when I saw other houses that looked like nice I believed it was because they were rich. I was so angry when I finally understood the lie in that. And of course various strangers over the years have believed it was my job to help her live normally - completely not comprehending the rage I'd encounter when pointing out that having a roach colony next to the stove was unhealthy. > > I don't know if you've spent any time looking at the children of hoarders web pages and groups that have sprung up in the last few years but it sure is on point. There seems to be a strong link between hoarding and BPD/NPD behavior. It's very rare someone hoards and does not dominate their family into living in it and shutting up about it without BPD type behaviors. I often wonder if the same area of the brain is affected. > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 3, 2010 Report Posted March 3, 2010 Annie - once again I think you and I have the same nada! My nada doesn't live in filth, but in tremendous amounts of clutter and chaos. She lives in a 5BR house and every single closet is packed neatly with her clothes and junk. She can't seem to get rid of anything! One time I was standing in her kitchen and counted 60 flower vases scattered around the kitchen and dining room. Every wall is covered in pictures. I get dizzy walking into her house. Fortunately, she has a cleaning person who cleans 2x/wk because she is incapable of cleaning, yet goes crazy when there is any sand or dust on the floor. She lives near the beach and goes absolutely ballistic over sand getting into the house! Growing up I always had to clean her house when she was between cleaning people (which was often). It was one way I learned to pacify her. I loved it when she and my dad would go out for an evening and I could make the kitchen " spotless " (including polishing all the copper pots) and she would come home and not scream at me. She also seems to be incapable of closing drawers and cabinets! Drives me nuts. (How many times my poor dad banged his head on cabinets that she left open). Ugh! - > > At another group I belong to for those with bpd relatives or bpd SOs, the topic of hoarding behaviors came up. There appeared to be a lot of posters mentioning that their bpd mother was a hoarder and lived in a filthy, unsanitary home because the nada refused to get rid of the hoarded junk or clean up the place even though she was not physically disabled. > > Some mentioned that their bpd mom didn't hoard stuff, yet allowed filth to accumulate unabated (decomposing garbage, layers of accumulated food on counters, fungus and mold-encrusted plates in the sink, animal feces and urine soaking the carpets, layers of animal hair and dander coating every surface, etc.) You'd think the neighbors would complain about the stench and the rats and roaches such filth would attract. > > My nada was/is a clean freak and a hoarder; the piles of excess items she collected were/still are all neatly boxed in plastic containers and labeled, though. She loves to shop for clothes, but how many pairs of pink slacks can one woman possibly use, I ask you? Last time I looked, I swear she had 18 different pair of pink slacks. Her closets are stuffed with clothes and shoes, but neatly. > > It does make me wonder if perhaps the same parts of the brain (if not functioning properly) result in both bpd and hoarding behavior? > > -Annie > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 3, 2010 Report Posted March 3, 2010 I personally think one pair of pink slacks is quite enough. =) > > > > Doug, what you wrote really spoke to me especially the part about the hoarding and your friends telling you that you should help her clean. I started cleaning early not because I had " chores " but because there was such filth in the house I couldn't stand it. In hindsight the house was clean to the degree it was because of what I did in those days. My nada's line to me was that we lived like that because we were poor, so when I saw other houses that looked like nice I believed it was because they were rich. I was so angry when I finally understood the lie in that. And of course various strangers over the years have believed it was my job to help her live normally - completely not comprehending the rage I'd encounter when pointing out that having a roach colony next to the stove was unhealthy. > > > > I don't know if you've spent any time looking at the children of hoarders web pages and groups that have sprung up in the last few years but it sure is on point. There seems to be a strong link between hoarding and BPD/NPD behavior. It's very rare someone hoards and does not dominate their family into living in it and shutting up about it without BPD type behaviors. I often wonder if the same area of the brain is affected. > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2010 Report Posted March 4, 2010 my nada is a hoarder as well. her house is not filthy, but very cluttered and dusty...many things must be moved to get to things along the walls..it's rare to find a place to sit without having to move things out of the way. The closets are overflowing..there are boxes stacked everywhere..she cant throw anything of hers away, but didn't have any trouble throwing/giving MY stuff away... Jackie Annie - once again I think you and I have the same nada! My nada doesn't live in filth, but in tremendous amounts of clutter and chaos. She lives in a 5BR house and every single closet is packed neatly with her clothes and junk. She can't seem to get rid of anything! One time I was standing in her kitchen and counted 60 flower vases scattered around the kitchen and dining room. Every wall is covered in pictures. I get dizzy walking into her house. Fortunately, she has a cleaning person who cleans 2x/wk because she is incapable of cleaning, yet goes crazy when there is any sand or dust on the floor. She lives near the beach and goes absolutely ballistic over sand getting into the house! Growing up I always had to clean her house when she was between cleaning people (which was often). It was one way I learned to pacify her. I loved it when she and my dad would go out for an evening and I could make the kitchen " spotless " (including polishing all the copper pots) and she would come home and not scream at me. She also seems to be incapable of closing drawers and cabinets! Drives me nuts. (How many times my poor dad banged his head on cabinets that she left open). Ugh! - Quote
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2010 Report Posted March 4, 2010 I think one pair is one too many LOL Jackie I personally think one pair of pink slacks is quite enough. =) Quote
Guest guest Posted March 4, 2010 Report Posted March 4, 2010 LOL!!! > > I think one pair is one too many LOL > > Jackie > > > > I personally think one pair of pink slacks is quite enough. =) > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.