Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Jackie,me too...There were other times when you'd think my teachers would have " done something " but didn't and I know it wasn't just with me.Looking back on it,I remember some other kids in school who were in bad home situations and my memories of problems they had make it very obvious to the adult me now that they were being abused. And people are also just...weird and weak in ways and unless some authority has specifically commanded them to do X,they will not take the initiative on their own and act on their own steam.And they will rationalize that or engage in different forms of denial. Once when I was in my twenties and had come " home " to visit I hooked up with a friend from grade school who had just happened to have run into our old fifth grade teacher and invited her to dinner.She asked me if I wanted to come to the dinner and I did. I had had a couple of traumas with that teacher that year related to nada's demonizing of me and trying to get the teacher to help me and finding myself trumped by nada's tricks and *me* getting blamed instead.And long story short,that was one of the years when I'd think it would have been obvious to an adult that I was being abused. So anyway,I went to this dinner and when my friend said to the teacher, " And of course,you remember ... " She looked at me blankly and blinked and said, " Oh,my,no,I'm sorry...I don't remember you.Were you in my class? " Was I in her class!!!! Hell,yeah,and I had been re-traumatized by her and was *still* smarting from it.Oh my god,I was so annoyed I had to force myself to calmly say, " Yes,you were my teacher the 78/79 school year- " She giggled, " Oh,I'm just drawing a blank...Who else was in the class that year,do you remember? " I described one of my classmates,a boy who came from such an abusive home,he actually committed suicide in high school,but I didn't mention the suicide part. " Oh,yes! I remember him.Oh,that poor kid.I felt so sorry for that kid. " " Oh,really, " I asked her, " Why is that? " She said, " He was in such a bad place at home,I remember that,he had such a hard time... " I asked her if she had ever called CPS about him and suddenly she wasn't so enthusiastic and she muttered a bit defensively, " No,no,it wasn't like that " and sort of snorted. " But you say you felt so sorry for him.Didn't that make you want to do- " " I TRIED to be nice to him,to make him feel better- " " But Ms X,if you had reasons to believe he was in a bad situation at home- " She said, " You can't know.If you don't know...for sure...you don't want to...I mean,I see the police on the highway pulling Black people over all the time and you figure probably they didn't really do anything and they're just being harrassed and you do want to intervene and you feel sorry for them but then you don't know-- " " Ok,let's not use Black people to deflect from the point here " ,I said and she got angry. " I care about racism! I'm not going to have you imply that I don't care about racism because I deeply do.I see that happen when I'm driving and I was thinking about that just today! " (note: the teacher was white and lived in a mostly all white town) My friend was giving me a pleading look to back off,so I did: " Oh,well,I'm sure M didn't invite us to dinner so we could argue about racism,I know she wanted to catch up on all your news,so what else have you been up to? " My friend mouthed " thank you " to me and later told me that she had been shocked the teacher didn't even remember me and disturbed that the teacher would say how much she'd cared about my classmate,as if that was enough.She said, " You should have told her he killed himself..but uhhmm...I guess maybe not... " That kid's suicide had deeply upset all of us who had known him and years later,I mean years later,when I ran into another former classmate,who incidentally recognized me right away,one of the first things he said was, " Oh god and do you remember poor F " and we talked about how both of us still felt haunted by what happened and saddened and frustrated that it had come to that. And so F is now recalled by all who knew him as " Poor F " (who committed suicide). -- > > that makes senses...but it's still so sad ...I know when I was in school, > nothing was ever said/done about the welts on my legs...or the brusies on my > arms from where nada grabed me and draged me around... > > Jackie Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 Holy @#)%*@ !! Batman! My sister and I, too. She said wonderful things like " I wish I never had you, " " Stop you bawling or I'll give you something to bawl about " , " do that again, and I'll knock your teeth out. " She'd rip all the drawers out of my dressers and desks and dump them on the floor screaming and telling me to clean them up. " And... she made me clean every Friday from 3 until she got home after 5 then scream, yell, hit, and ground me for the weekend because it wasn't " clean enough " .... but... by george, both my sister and I had our braces and nice dresses for church. She was all smiles during church... then we'd go to the car and it would start all over. ..... it's all about appearances, nice dress and braces before the public, but abused behind it all. being l.c. for 30 years makes it easier to forget (that plus therapy and lots of college psychology courses). > > > > > > I really think you will heal from it because you want to. It may not feel > > > like it's coming fast enough, but you're on the journey. > > > > > > I understand what you mean about those experiences of being ignored teaching > > > you to be quiet. If it's been demonstrated to you again and again that no > > > one cares, why bother. I didn't tell anyone that I was urinating blood and > > > in pain. When I was in so much obvious crying pain that I had to be taken > > > for emergency kidney care, it was my fault for not mentioning it. Yet they > > > teach us not to mention it, right? I mean, I appreciate that they took me > > > for care that time, but there were plenty of other times the problem " just > > > went away " or I sustained a permanent injury that I just live with. > > > > > > What really twists my brain around in my situation was that my parents > > > neglected health issues and also bought braces for my teeth. Thank you, but, > > > um, I'm confused. > > > > > > B. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 14, 2010 Report Posted February 14, 2010 , I'm speechless. If you were in a room with all of us giving an account of that story, there wouldn't be a dry eye in the house and there would be a lot of hugs (and, possibly eating of ice cream) involved. Please count this as a big cyber-hug. , (whose was finally able to use spatula's for cooking in her early 40s after being beat with them as a child.) Quote
Guest guest Posted February 15, 2010 Report Posted February 15, 2010 Thank you,.You're very kind -- > > , > I'm speechless. > If you were in a room with all of us giving an account of that story, there wouldn't be a dry eye in the house and there would be a lot of hugs (and, possibly eating of ice cream) involved. > Please count this as a big cyber-hug. > > , > (whose was finally able to use spatula's for cooking in her early 40s after being beat with them as a child.) > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 15, 2010 Report Posted February 15, 2010 that's just awful, for a teacher to have strong suspicious and still not do a thing to help. With us, there were 3 of us in grad school at one time..and funny how all 3 would have huge red welts on their body all on the same day !! sigh..I dont blame you for being angry...she just turned her back on you ( and on poor F) Jackie Jackie,me too...There were other times when you'd think my teachers would have " done something " but didn't and I know it wasn't just with me.Looking back on it,I remember some other kids in school who were in bad home situations and my memories of problems they had make it very obvious to the adult me now that they were being abused. And people are also just...weird and weak in ways and unless some authority has specifically commanded them to do X,they will not take the initiative on their own and act on their own steam.And they will rationalize that or engage in different forms of denial. Once when I was in my twenties and had come " home " to visit I hooked up with a friend from grade school who had just happened to have run into our old fifth grade teacher and invited her to dinner.She asked me if I wanted to come to the dinner and I did. I had had a couple of traumas with that teacher that year related to nada's demonizing of me and trying to get the teacher to help me and finding myself trumped by nada's tricks and *me* getting blamed instead.And long story short,that was one of the years when I'd think it would have been obvious to an adult that I was being abused. So anyway,I went to this dinner and when my friend said to the teacher, " And of course,you remember ... " She looked at me blankly and blinked and said, " Oh,my,no,I'm sorry...I don't remember you.Were you in my class? " Was I in her class!!!! Hell,yeah,and I had been re-traumatized by her and was *still* smarting from it.Oh my god,I was so annoyed I had to force myself to calmly say, " Yes,you were my teacher the 78/79 school year- " She giggled, " Oh,I'm just drawing a blank...Who else was in the class that year,do you remember? " I described one of my classmates,a boy who came from such an abusive home,he actually committed suicide in high school,but I didn't mention the suicide part. " Oh,yes! I remember him.Oh,that poor kid.I felt so sorry for that kid. " " Oh,really, " I asked her, " Why is that? " She said, " He was in such a bad place at home,I remember that,he had such a hard time... " I asked her if she had ever called CPS about him and suddenly she wasn't so enthusiastic and she muttered a bit defensively, " No,no,it wasn't like that " and sort of snorted. " But you say you felt so sorry for him.Didn't that make you want to do- " " I TRIED to be nice to him,to make him feel better- " " But Ms X,if you had reasons to believe he was in a bad situation at home- " She said, " You can't know.If you don't know...for sure...you don't want to...I mean,I see the police on the highway pulling Black people over all the time and you figure probably they didn't really do anything and they're just being harrassed and you do want to intervene and you feel sorry for them but then you don't know-- " " Ok,let's not use Black people to deflect from the point here " ,I said and she got angry. " I care about racism! I'm not going to have you imply that I don't care about racism because I deeply do.I see that happen when I'm driving and I was thinking about that just today! " (note: the teacher was white and lived in a mostly all white town) My friend was giving me a pleading look to back off,so I did: " Oh,well,I'm sure M didn't invite us to dinner so we could argue about racism,I know she wanted to catch up on all your news,so what else have you been up to? " My friend mouthed " thank you " to me and later told me that she had been shocked the teacher didn't even remember me and disturbed that the teacher would say how much she'd cared about my classmate,as if that was enough.She said, " You should have told her he killed himself..but uhhmm...I guess maybe not... " That kid's suicide had deeply upset all of us who had known him and years later,I mean years later,when I ran into another former classmate,who incidentally recognized me right away,one of the first things he said was, " Oh god and do you remember poor F " and we talked about how both of us still felt haunted by what happened and saddened and frustrated that it had come to that. And so F is now recalled by all who knew him as " Poor F " (who committed suicide). -- Quote
Guest guest Posted February 15, 2010 Report Posted February 15, 2010 sounds just like my nada :-( Jackie Holy @#)%*@ !! Batman! My sister and I, too. She said wonderful things like " I wish I never had you, " " Stop you bawling or I'll give you something to bawl about " , " do that again, and I'll knock your teeth out. " She'd rip all the drawers out of my dressers and desks and dump them on the floor screaming and telling me to clean them up. " And... she made me clean every Friday from 3 until she got home after 5 then scream, yell, hit, and ground me for the weekend because it wasn't " clean enough " .... but... by george, both my sister and I had our braces and nice dresses for church. She was all smiles during church... then we'd go to the car and it would start all over. ..... it's all about appearances, nice dress and braces before the public, but abused behind it all. being l.c. for 30 years makes it easier to forget (that plus therapy and lots of college psychology courses). Quote
Guest guest Posted February 15, 2010 Report Posted February 15, 2010 I am convinced my mother-in-law has untreated BPD. She does the " not communicating " thing. My mother didn't do that with her kids. She did it to my dad SOME, but mostly she was the 'cut of the relationship with you the second you do something wrong' if you were a friend. She really had no friends at the end of her life. Which is sad to me. She would have a friend who was the best thing since sliced bread. Then she'd say something bad about them and they'd get mad and stop speaking and that was that -- for YEARS she would go on about what a horrible person they were. YEARS...forever, really... When she died, family came to her funeral and a handful of neighbors and maybe 15 people. Then some strange man showed up that came up to me and told me my mother loved him, lol. We never did figure out who that man was! In a message dated 2/11/2010 2:09:17 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, lisa@... writes: I think in my situation it was more like, " don't you dare show the outside world my crazy. " Here's a fairly recent example from a couple years ago where nada was playing her " I'm punishing you by not communicating " game [my transgression, you ask? Not sending her flowers/card on Easter, which prior to that year had been a non-card-worthy holiday in our scattered FOO since I've been out of college--22 years now.] I was calling her about once a week or so, just to check in on her welfare (she's single, living in a new city/state, no relatives within 600 miles). Over the span of about 3 weeks, I left a few messages, acknowledging that she was upset with me but asked her to just confirm that she was okay--send up a flare--email, phone call something. She didn't, and my sister also hadn't heard from her in several weeks, so I called one of her neighbors to confirm that she was okay. Well *that* certainly got her attention--shortly after that got a hysterical call from her: " DON'T YOU EVER DO THAT AGAIN!! IT'S NONE OF THEIR BUSINESS!! I'M FINE...... " - > > Don't you DARE show the outside world MY neglect. > > Anyone? > > Karla > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 15, 2010 Report Posted February 15, 2010 , my nada sounds A LOT like yours. She is very hot and cold with friends and family members - one minute they are the best, the next she cuts them out of her life. Usually she does something, they get pissed and let her know, then THEY are no good. She never takes responsibility for her actions - EVER. - > > > > Don't you DARE show the outside world MY neglect. > > > > Anyone? > > > > Karla > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 15, 2010 Report Posted February 15, 2010 That is my nada and it is so confusing- in the sense you never know where you stand with her. Sometimes I was the greatest daughter and other times I was a horrible human being. My nada also never takes responsbility for her actions- Thanks for sharing, Malinda > > > > > > Don't you DARE show the outside world MY neglect. > > > > > > Anyone? > > > > > > Karla > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.