Guest guest Posted December 22, 2007 Report Posted December 22, 2007 Interesting article on fluoride and aluminum in tea. " Tea is very high in fluoride content. Fluoride in tea is much higher than the Maximum Contaminant Level (MCL) set for fluoride in drinking water. " http://www.bruha.com/pfpc/html/green_tea___.html Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2007 Report Posted December 24, 2007 --- <oz4caster@...> wrote: > Interesting article on fluoride and aluminum in tea. > http://www.bruha.com/pfpc/html/green_tea___.html I found another article by the same author, posted at the WAPF web site: " Fluoride: Worse than We Thought " By s Schuld http://www.westonaprice.org/envtoxins/fluoride.html This article is referenced by the one above: " Why EPA's Headquarters Professionals' Union Opposes Fluoridation " http://www.fluoridealert.org/hp-epa.htm I also checked to see how much fluoride was listed in the USDA nutrient data base. It shows about 0.8 mg per 8oz cup of tea brewed with tap water based on an average of 63 samples with a standard error of about 2%. They didn't list the fluoride in tea prepared with distilled water and they didn't have a listing for green tea, so I assume that they were measuring black tea. The USDA listing of fluoride in prepared tea is similar to the amounts reported at PFPC: http://bruha.com/pfpc/html/f-_in_food.html Note: to convert mg/l to mg/cup, divide by 4.2 cups/liter If you drink fluoridated water, it typically has about 1 mg/l of fluoride. That means if you drink a liter per day, about one quart per day, you get 1 mg of fluoride per day just from your water alone. Absurdly, the US Institute of Medicine, Food and Nutrition Board, has set the " Adequate Intake (AI) per day " for fluoride at 4 mg for men and 3 mg for women (ages 14 and over). They list the " Tolerable Upper Intake Levels (UL) " at 10 mg per day. Sadly, it appears that this recommendation was heavily influenced by pro-fluoridation proponents and is way too high. From the information I have seen, it looks like the UL should be more like 2 to 4 mg per day and that ideally we should try to keep total fluoride intake to less than 1 mg per day. As far as kombucha, here is the e-mail response that I got from GT with GT's Kombucha about fluoride in their product: " It is true that green and black teas contain some amount of fluoride. However, Kombucha is very unique because it is actually no longer a green or black tea after the fermentation. Most of the chemical make-up of the tea has been converted or consumed by the Kombucha culture. The last time we tested our product for fluoride, the results were that it contained a 'negligible' amount. In laboratory language that means 'lower than the smallest measurement for that testing method'. I apologize that I do not have an exact measurement to give you. " I typically drink a couple of 16oz bottles of GT's Kombucha each week. I'd like to brew my own kombucha, but I'd like to find a tea that has measured low fluoride levels and so far, I haven't found one. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 19, 2008 Report Posted February 19, 2008 Dear , Thank you for posting this article link about tea and the thyroid. I am searching the archives for any info on thyroid and found your post on tea. I drink loose leaf tea daily. I still have to digest this article, it is printing as I type this, but from the looks of it, I may have to mend my ways. Perhaps an herbal thyroid friendly tisane could be my substitute. I have recently switched to organic teas, but I'm not sure if they're ok for someone with thyroid issues, which I very strongly suspect I have. And where does kombucha fit into all this? Just today, I asked my farmer for his next available kombucha mushroom so I could try my hand at making my own. Thanks again for the link, Ann -- Green Tea, Fluoride & the Thyroid Interesting article on fluoride and aluminum in tea. " Tea is very high in fluoride content. Fluoride in tea is much higher than the Maximum Contaminant Level (MCL) set for fluoride in drinking water. " http://www.bruha.com/pfpc/html/green_tea___.html Quote
Guest guest Posted February 19, 2008 Report Posted February 19, 2008 I did read an article a couple years ago, and no I did not keep it, but supposedly organic teas do not have this problem. Don't know why, maybe they use a different water. I really wish I could find the article again as this has come up many times. Maybe the Happy Herbalist can help on this. Allyn From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Ann Sent: Tuesday, February 19, 2008 5:04 PM Subject: Re: Green Tea, Fluoride & the Thyroid Dear , Thank you for posting this article link about tea and the thyroid. I am searching the archives for any info on thyroid and found your post on tea. I drink loose leaf tea daily. I still have to digest this article, it is printing as I type this, but from the looks of it, I may have to mend my ways. Perhaps an herbal thyroid friendly tisane could be my substitute. I have recently switched to organic teas, but I'm not sure if they're ok for someone with thyroid issues, which I very strongly suspect I have. And where does kombucha fit into all this? Just today, I asked my farmer for his next available kombucha mushroom so I could try my hand at making my own. Thanks again for the link, Ann -- Green Tea, Fluoride & the Thyroid Interesting article on fluoride and aluminum in tea. " Tea is very high in fluoride content. Fluoride in tea is much higher than the Maximum Contaminant Level (MCL) set for fluoride in drinking water. " http://www.bruha.com/pfpc/html/green_tea___.html Quote
Guest guest Posted February 19, 2008 Report Posted February 19, 2008 --- Ann <patriciak4him@...> wrote: > I have recently switched to organic teas, but I'm not sure if > they're ok for someone with thyroid issues, which I very strongly > suspect I have. And where does kombucha fit into all this? Ann, be sure to read the other messages in the thread, as they have more info. I still have not found any measurements of fluoride in organic teas, but I suspect it is still substantial. If your tap water is fluoridated, that adds to the exposure. You can reduce your exposure by removing the fluoride from the water you drink and use for tea or kombucha. The amount of fluoride in tea is somewhat variable, and I suspect that is true for organic teas as well, depending on the soil it is grown in, water used on the plants, and whether the tea leaves are young or old. Older leaves have more fluoride and tend to be used more in cheaper teas. The youngest leaves have the least fluoride. But short of getting measurements from your tea vendor, I'd be reluctant to take a chance where hypothyroid issues are a concern. That doesn't mean eliminating tea, but get good quality organic tea and brew it with fluoride-free water. I'd be reluctant to drink more than a cup daily (seven cups a week), even with good health. I don't drink tea, but I drink a couple of bottles of GT's kombucha each week (32 oz). I don't know much about hypothyroid. Hopefully others on this list who have had deal with it will chip in, but from what I recall reading it's a good idea to make sure you're getting enough iodine in your diet, eliminate all soy, avoid other goitrogenic foods like broccoli and cabbage, take a good quality high vitamin cod liver oil, get plenty of good quality grass-fed animal fats from dairy and/or meat and avoid or eliminate sugar and sweets. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2008 Report Posted February 20, 2008 Dear , Thank you for your tips and info on thyroid, fluoride, tea & kombucha. Your comments were very helpful. I'm trying to find a good physician that knows the right tests to order and can also diagnose and interpret the tests to help me gain my strength back. Then, I want to treat it nutritionally through diet as much as possible. The water it's grown in has me thinking about gardening in my backyard.. would local outside water that is not filtered have too much fluoride for growing veggies and herbs? Thanks again for your help. And blessings to you, Ann -- Re: Green Tea, Fluoride & the Thyroid --- Ann <patriciak4him@...> wrote: > I have recently switched to organic teas, but I'm not sure if > they're ok for someone with thyroid issues, which I very strongly > suspect I have. And where does kombucha fit into all this? Ann, be sure to read the other messages in the thread, as they have more info. I still have not found any measurements of fluoride in organic teas, but I suspect it is still substantial. If your tap water is fluoridated, that adds to the exposure. You can reduce your exposure by removing the fluoride from the water you drink and use for tea or kombucha. The amount of fluoride in tea is somewhat variable, and I suspect that is true for organic teas as well, depending on the soil it is grown in, water used on the plants, and whether the tea leaves are young or old. Older leaves have more fluoride and tend to be used more in cheaper teas. The youngest leaves have the least fluoride. But short of getting measurements from your tea vendor, I'd be reluctant to take a chance where hypothyroid issues are a concern. That doesn't mean eliminating tea, but get good quality organic tea and brew it with fluoride-free water. I'd be reluctant to drink more than a cup daily (seven cups a week), even with good health. I don't drink tea, but I drink a couple of bottles of GT's kombucha each week (32 oz). I don't know much about hypothyroid. Hopefully others on this list who have had deal with it will chip in, but from what I recall reading it's a good idea to make sure you're getting enough iodine in your diet, eliminate all soy, avoid other goitrogenic foods like broccoli and cabbage, take a good quality high vitamin cod liver oil, get plenty of good quality grass-fed animal fats from dairy and/or meat and avoid or eliminate sugar and sweets. .. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2008 Report Posted February 20, 2008 --- Ann <patriciak4him@...> wrote: > would local outside water that is not filtered have too much > fluoride for growing veggies and herbs? Ann, watering garden plants with fluoridated water would probably add a little fluoride to the plants. I suspect that some plants, like tea are much more likely to pull fluoride from soil and water than others, but I don't know much about this. To be safe, you might look into collecting rain water to use for watering. It won't have chlorine either, which is probably better for the plants as well. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2008 Report Posted February 20, 2008 > > would local outside water that is not filtered have too much > > fluoride for growing veggies and herbs? > > Ann, watering garden plants with fluoridated water would > probably add a little fluoride to the plants. I suspect that some > plants, like tea are much more likely to pull fluoride from soil and > water than others, but I don't know much about this. To be safe, you > might look into collecting rain water to use for watering. It won't > have chlorine either, which is probably better for the plants as well. > > > I did some research into this, and most fluoride found naturally is calcium fluoride, which has very little uptake in plants and animals. Most plants, even when watered with 10ppm fluoride irrigation water (10x the average) didn't seem to have significant amounts in the final plant. Roots will have the most, fruits the least...but after looking at the numbers from some studies I wasn't afraid of using fluoridated water to water my plants...and I can get pretty paranoid when it comes to fluoride. Organically grown foods (plants and animals) can be watered with fluoridated water. I'm pretty sure I read the fluoride in tea is from a certain pesticide they use on tea, and its also why organic teas seem to be fine. - Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2008 Report Posted February 20, 2008 Hi , Your post gives me hope that I may be able to enjoy a nice cup of organic tea. Just this week I got two large orders of tea and tisanes. They were rather pricy and so I am relieved to hear that I may still be able to use them. With regards to fluoride and back yard garden plants, what are your thoughts on ginger root, lettuce, and sweet potatoes? Thanks for your great info. Blessings to you, Ann -- Re: Green Tea, Fluoride & the Thyroid I did some research into this, and most fluoride found naturally is calcium fluoride, which has very little uptake in plants and animals. Most plants, even when watered with 10ppm fluoride irrigation water (10x the average) didn't seem to have significant amounts in the final plant. Roots will have the most, fruits the least...but after looking at the numbers from some studies I wasn't afraid of using fluoridated water to water my plants...and I can get pretty paranoid when it comes to fluoride. Organically grown foods (plants and animals) can be watered with fluoridated water. I'm pretty sure I read the fluoride in tea is from a certain pesticide they use on tea, and its also why organic teas seem to be fine. - .. Quote
Guest guest Posted February 20, 2008 Report Posted February 20, 2008 From the tables I looked at the only produce I was concerned with was amaranth which was grown with fluoridated water. Everything else I wouldn't worry about, even roots. I should have saved the studies so I could share them but it was just from google research and I found some PDF files of some studies. Cabbage, and similar vegetables had the lowest amounts. As long as you avoid fluoridated from drinking water, don't take hot long baths/showers in fluoridated water, and avoid conventional teas you should be fine...at least in regards to fluoride. I really think long hot baths/showers are one of the biggest things that get people. Many are unwilling to give them up too. - > > Hi , > Your post gives me hope that I may be able to enjoy a nice cup of organic > tea. Just this week I got two large orders of tea and tisanes. They were > rather pricy and so I am relieved to hear that I may still be able to use > them. > > With regards to fluoride and back yard garden plants, what are your thoughts > on ginger root, lettuce, and sweet potatoes? > Thanks for your great info. > Blessings to you, > Ann > > -- Re: Green Tea, Fluoride & the Thyroid > > > I did some research into this, and most fluoride found naturally is > calcium fluoride, which has very little uptake in plants and animals. > Most plants, even when watered with 10ppm fluoride irrigation water > (10x the average) didn't seem to have significant amounts in the final > plant. Roots will have the most, fruits the least...but after looking > at the numbers from some studies I wasn't afraid of using fluoridated > water to water my plants...and I can get pretty paranoid when it comes > to fluoride. > > Organically grown foods (plants and animals) can be watered with > fluoridated water. > > I'm pretty sure I read the fluoride in tea is from a certain pesticide > they use on tea, and its also why organic teas seem to be fine. > > - > > > . > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2008 Report Posted February 21, 2008 , short of getting a whole house filter system which is financially impossible, what the heck are you supposed to do for bathing? I'm being serious here, a wet washcloth just doesn't hack it routinely and how about hair washing? Just how much fluoride is absorbed by the skin in say a 10 min shower? Patty --- In , " gdawson6 " <gdawson6@...> wrote: I really think long hot baths/showers are one of the biggest things > that get people. Many are unwilling to give them up too. > > - Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2008 Report Posted February 21, 2008 I found some discussion on this... http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=37038 There isn't conclusive evidence how much fluoride is absorbed, but the factors are what type of it is in water, which changes from bad to worse, and how hot the shower, how long, etc... My only shower right now is actually outdoors and its been pretty cold in SoCal, so I take quick showers and only when I need them...hot for of comfort but not too hot. Don't get too paranoid or worried...it won't help anything. Just do what you can and make sure you eat a nutritious diet. - > I really think long hot baths/showers are one of the biggest things > > that get people. Many are unwilling to give them up too. > > > > - > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 21, 2008 Report Posted February 21, 2008 how about getting a fluoride shower filter? there's one on this page. http://www.energelproducts.com/fluoride-water-filters.html > I really think long hot baths/showers are one of the biggest things > > that get people. Many are unwilling to give them up too. > > > > - > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2008 Report Posted February 22, 2008 Carolyn, Thank you so much for that link. I had no idea there was a shower filter that removed fluoride and that's feasible in the next few months, but I have some questions you may know the answer to although I will email the company too. The filters I've seen for drinking water that aren't RO use aluminum to remove Fluoride. I wrote to a few of these companies and they all admitted aluminum getting in your drinking water was a possiblity. One company did say that if you used a solid carbon filter BENEATH, not next to the Fluoride filter, it would catch the aluminum. So, until I know differently, let's say this filter uses aluminum. Would there be enough in the shower water to be a concern? Are you simply exchanging one poison for another. Thanks. Patty --- In , " carolyn_graff " <zgraff@...> wrote: > > how about getting a fluoride shower filter? there's one on this page. > http://www.energelproducts.com/fluoride-water-filters.html > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2008 Report Posted February 22, 2008 I'm considering the fluoride filter as well...but it says it only removes fluoride down to .5ppm. If your water is fluoridated properly thats only removing 1/2 the fluoride (should be at 1 ppm)...but some places have tested for higher and it varies. I'm going to look around and see if any other filter does better...though reducing it would still be good. - > > > > how about getting a fluoride shower filter? there's one on this > page. > > http://www.energelproducts.com/fluoride-water-filters.html > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2008 Report Posted February 22, 2008 I have seen 50 buck shower head filters, but never researched their claims. desh Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2008 Report Posted February 22, 2008 As a get by, you could try one quart of distilled water...heated and add a 1/2 cup or so of vinager. You won't need to add soap or rinse, the vinegar smell will go away in a few minutes. Re: Green Tea, Fluoride & the Thyroid , short of getting a whole house filter system which is financially impossible, what the heck are you supposed to do for bathing? I'm being serious here, a wet washcloth just doesn't hack it routinely and how about hair washing? Just how much fluoride is absorbed by the skin in say a 10 min shower? Patty I really think long hot baths/showers are one of the biggest things > that get people. Many are unwilling to give them up too. > > - Quote
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2008 Report Posted February 22, 2008 If you find anything else , please let me know or post it here. I asked them if they used aluminum and here is there response: Hi Patty - it is the activated alumina and that is the reason for the 2nd stage filter in our shower filter. The second filter gets rid the leftover alumina. Ara --- In , " gdawson6 " <gdawson6@...> wrote: > > I'm considering the fluoride filter as well...but it says it only > removes fluoride down to .5ppm. If your water is fluoridated properly > thats only removing 1/2 the fluoride (should be at 1 ppm)...but some > places have tested for higher and it varies. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2008 Report Posted March 5, 2008 In regards to Kombucha Tea and Tea and fluoride. In the typical recipe for making kombucha, the amount of tea used is typically only 1/4 that as one would use to make a cup of tea. Additionally one does not have to steep the tea for more than a few minutes. Peace Ed Kasper LAc. & family www.HappyHerbalist.com .................................................... Dear , Thank you for posting this article link about tea and the thyroid. I am searching the archives for any info on thyroid and found your post on tea. I drink loose leaf tea daily. I still have to digest this article, it is printing as I type this, but from the looks of it, I may have to mend my ways. Perhaps an herbal thyroid friendly tisane could be my substitute. I have recently switched to organic teas, but I'm not sure if they're ok for someone with thyroid issues, which I very strongly suspect I have. And where does kombucha fit into all this? Just today, I asked my farmer for his next available kombucha mushroom so I could try my hand at making my own. Thanks again for the link, Ann -- Green Tea, Fluoride & the Thyroid Interesting article on fluoride and aluminum in tea. " Tea is very high in fluoride content. Fluoride in tea is much higher than the Maximum Contaminant Level (MCL) set for fluoride in drinking water. " http://www.bruha.com/pfpc/html/green_tea___.html Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.