Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Marcus,

Yes, of course people will know what you are signing with your left hand.

They will just think you are left handed. Just use your right hand as a place

to sign off of for your left hand.

My grandmother (my dad's mom) passed away Friday morning so we'll be off to

Peoria, Il. about a three hour drive from here, for the wake and funeral

where her friends are.

I'll be back tomorrow.

Love, Sally

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Marcus,

Yes, of course people will know what you are signing with your left hand.

They will just think you are left handed. Just use your right hand as a place

to sign off of for your left hand.

My grandmother (my dad's mom) passed away Friday morning so we'll be off to

Peoria, Il. about a three hour drive from here, for the wake and funeral

where her friends are.

I'll be back tomorrow.

Love, Sally

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm learning ASL alphabet for USA trip next year, and I have DUD right hand so if I use left, will anybody know what Im signing ???

Australians use AUSLAN and SIGNED ENGLISH ! neither are remotely similar to ASL !

Marcus !!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Marcus,

Using ASL, it doesn't matter which hand you use for your dominant hand, when you're signing or fingerspelling. People should be able to understand you. I've seen AUSLAN sign language before. Doesn't that use both hands for fingerspelling?

Greg

I'm learning ASL alphabet for USA trip next year, and I have DUD right hand so if I use left, will anybody know what Im signing ???

Australians use AUSLAN and SIGNED ENGLISH ! neither are remotely similar to ASL !

Marcus !!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Marcus,

Using ASL, it doesn't matter which hand you use for your dominant hand, when you're signing or fingerspelling. People should be able to understand you. I've seen AUSLAN sign language before. Doesn't that use both hands for fingerspelling?

Greg

I'm learning ASL alphabet for USA trip next year, and I have DUD right hand so if I use left, will anybody know what Im signing ???

Australians use AUSLAN and SIGNED ENGLISH ! neither are remotely similar to ASL !

Marcus !!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Marcus,

Using ASL, it doesn't matter which hand you use for your dominant hand, when you're signing or fingerspelling. People should be able to understand you. I've seen AUSLAN sign language before. Doesn't that use both hands for fingerspelling?

Greg

I'm learning ASL alphabet for USA trip next year, and I have DUD right hand so if I use left, will anybody know what Im signing ???

Australians use AUSLAN and SIGNED ENGLISH ! neither are remotely similar to ASL !

Marcus !!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Marcus, you can try contacting Barb Wolfe; Barb is familiar with Australian sign and I think American sign also; she might be able to answer your question; her address is:

Barbara WolffE-mail Address(es): barblulu@...

I Think she is planning to visit the USA next year also! Marie

Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

I'm learning ASL alphabet for USA trip next year, and I have DUD right hand so if I use left, will anybody know what Im signing ???

Australians use AUSLAN and SIGNED ENGLISH ! neither are remotely similar to ASL !

Marcus !!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Marcus, you can try contacting Barb Wolfe; Barb is familiar with Australian sign and I think American sign also; she might be able to answer your question; her address is:

Barbara WolffE-mail Address(es): barblulu@...

I Think she is planning to visit the USA next year also! Marie

Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

I'm learning ASL alphabet for USA trip next year, and I have DUD right hand so if I use left, will anybody know what Im signing ???

Australians use AUSLAN and SIGNED ENGLISH ! neither are remotely similar to ASL !

Marcus !!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Marcus, you can try contacting Barb Wolfe; Barb is familiar with Australian sign and I think American sign also; she might be able to answer your question; her address is:

Barbara WolffE-mail Address(es): barblulu@...

I Think she is planning to visit the USA next year also! Marie

Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

I'm learning ASL alphabet for USA trip next year, and I have DUD right hand so if I use left, will anybody know what Im signing ???

Australians use AUSLAN and SIGNED ENGLISH ! neither are remotely similar to ASL !

Marcus !!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Greg... when you go into your ASL, I see you using two hands, and whenever I "try" ASL with my left hand only, straying from preferred English, your blank.:)) In ASL you are basically, you said to me, creating a picture, then filling it in. How can we "draw" with one hand to be understood? And also with, as in my case, not very strong facial expressions?

Jennette

Re: Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

Marcus,

Using ASL, it doesn't matter which hand you use for your dominant hand, when you're signing or fingerspelling. People should be able to understand you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Marcus,

I doubt it. If you coud really fingerspell well with your left hand, think

could be understood.

ASL, unlike Aslan, uses only one hand to fingerspell so you're good to go.

Mark

----Original Messagows----

Reply-To: NF2_Crewegroups

To: <NF2_Crewegroups>

Subject: Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

Date: Mon, 4 Sep 2000 23:01:21 +1000

I'm learning ASL alphabet for USA trip next year, and I have DUD right hand

so if I use left, will anybody know what Im signing ???

Australians use AUSLAN and SIGNED ENGLISH ! neither are remotely similar to

ASL !

Marcus !!

_________________________________________________________________________

Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com.

Share information about yourself, create your own public profile at

http://profiles.msn.com.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Jeanette, Greg,

I've seen Deaf as well as deaf and hard of hearing people use one hand to

sign. Espcially if their " dominant " is holding something. You just have to

understand the context that they are talking about if their using only one

hand.

Mark

----Original Message Follows----

Reply-To: NF2_Crewegroups

To: <NF2_Crewegroups>

Subject: Re: Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

Date: Mon, 4 Sep 2000 12:57:14 -0400

Greg... when you go into your ASL, I see you using two hands, and whenever I

" try " ASL with my left hand only, straying from preferred English, your

blank.:)) In ASL you are basically, you said to me, creating a picture,

then filling it in. How can we " draw " with one hand to be understood? And

also with, as in my case, not very strong facial expressions?

Jennette

Re: Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

Marcus,

Using ASL, it doesn't matter which hand you use for your dominant hand, when

you're signing or fingerspelling. People should be able to understand you.

_________________________________________________________________________

Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com.

Share information about yourself, create your own public profile at

http://profiles.msn.com.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorry to read of your loss Sally !

Marcus

Re: Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

> Marcus,

>

> Yes, of course people will know what you are signing with your left hand.

> They will just think you are left handed. Just use your right hand as a

place

> to sign off of for your left hand.

>

> My grandmother (my dad's mom) passed away Friday morning so we'll be off

to

> Peoria, Il. about a three hour drive from here, for the wake and funeral

> where her friends are.

>

> I'll be back tomorrow.

>

> Love, Sally

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorry to read of your loss Sally !

Marcus

Re: Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

> Marcus,

>

> Yes, of course people will know what you are signing with your left hand.

> They will just think you are left handed. Just use your right hand as a

place

> to sign off of for your left hand.

>

> My grandmother (my dad's mom) passed away Friday morning so we'll be off

to

> Peoria, Il. about a three hour drive from here, for the wake and funeral

> where her friends are.

>

> I'll be back tomorrow.

>

> Love, Sally

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well in fact us Aussies are used to having to use two hands to get the job

done anyhow ! So a bit of one handed ASL should be a pushover !

( MY WIFE JOYANNE TOLD ME TO POST THIS ONE !! hahahaha )

Marcus

Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

> Date: Mon, 4 Sep 2000 23:01:21 +1000

>

> I'm learning ASL alphabet for USA trip next year, and I have DUD right

hand

> so if I use left, will anybody know what Im signing ???

>

> Australians use AUSLAN and SIGNED ENGLISH ! neither are remotely similar

to

> ASL !

>

> Marcus !!

>

> _________________________________________________________________________

> Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com.

>

> Share information about yourself, create your own public profile at

> http://profiles.msn.com.

>

>

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jennette,

I agree, half of ASL is interpreted through facial and body expressions. Also, perhaps another 25 percent of ASL is communicated using signs that represent words, the vocab. part, and perhaps the last quarter is where you actually "create a picture." It's the blend of actual sign and expression. I see ASL as being fluid and there is either the extreme ASL users (which I am not) or the extreme SEE users (which I am not). Everywhere in between that is no mans lands or Pidgin (which I am). Pidgin, is the mixed bag and from what I've seen, you have people of various sign ability, even those of Deaf Culture have their own ways of signing. Each person has their own style and for me, it's tough to read someone who I've just met for the first time, unless their signs are picture perfect at first. For me, it takes a bit of getting used to and I do pick up a lot clues off facial expression and spearheading. Eventually, I get better at interpreting their "style" and soon, I can read them even if they sign using one hand. It's just how it is with me. My receptive skills are that way. The biggest thing to learning ASL, SEE, or any kind of sign, is practice. The bottom line is, are you able to get your message across and can you understand the message the other person is trying to convey to you. That's the heart of it, I think.

Greg

Greg... when you go into your ASL, I see you using two hands, and whenever I "try" ASL with my left hand only, straying from preferred English, your blank.:)) In ASL you are basically, you said to me, creating a picture, then filling it in. How can we "draw" with one hand to be understood? And also with, as in my case, not very strong facial expressions?

Jennette

Re: Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

Marcus,

Using ASL, it doesn't matter which hand you use for your dominant hand, when you're signing or fingerspelling. People should be able to understand you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jennette,

I agree, half of ASL is interpreted through facial and body expressions. Also, perhaps another 25 percent of ASL is communicated using signs that represent words, the vocab. part, and perhaps the last quarter is where you actually "create a picture." It's the blend of actual sign and expression. I see ASL as being fluid and there is either the extreme ASL users (which I am not) or the extreme SEE users (which I am not). Everywhere in between that is no mans lands or Pidgin (which I am). Pidgin, is the mixed bag and from what I've seen, you have people of various sign ability, even those of Deaf Culture have their own ways of signing. Each person has their own style and for me, it's tough to read someone who I've just met for the first time, unless their signs are picture perfect at first. For me, it takes a bit of getting used to and I do pick up a lot clues off facial expression and spearheading. Eventually, I get better at interpreting their "style" and soon, I can read them even if they sign using one hand. It's just how it is with me. My receptive skills are that way. The biggest thing to learning ASL, SEE, or any kind of sign, is practice. The bottom line is, are you able to get your message across and can you understand the message the other person is trying to convey to you. That's the heart of it, I think.

Greg

Greg... when you go into your ASL, I see you using two hands, and whenever I "try" ASL with my left hand only, straying from preferred English, your blank.:)) In ASL you are basically, you said to me, creating a picture, then filling it in. How can we "draw" with one hand to be understood? And also with, as in my case, not very strong facial expressions?

Jennette

Re: Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

Marcus,

Using ASL, it doesn't matter which hand you use for your dominant hand, when you're signing or fingerspelling. People should be able to understand you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Marcus,

The only time I have had trouble understanding fingerspelling is when the

signer is standing at the wrong angle. As long as I can see the inside of

the hand, I can understand. That would be the only reason I could see for

there to be a problem. A lot of times, Lee or will start to sign

something to me and I have to tell them to turn their hand around. I guess

you could say that was the equivalent of mumbling? :)

Donna

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Marcus,

The only time I have had trouble understanding fingerspelling is when the

signer is standing at the wrong angle. As long as I can see the inside of

the hand, I can understand. That would be the only reason I could see for

there to be a problem. A lot of times, Lee or will start to sign

something to me and I have to tell them to turn their hand around. I guess

you could say that was the equivalent of mumbling? :)

Donna

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Marcus,

The only time I have had trouble understanding fingerspelling is when the

signer is standing at the wrong angle. As long as I can see the inside of

the hand, I can understand. That would be the only reason I could see for

there to be a problem. A lot of times, Lee or will start to sign

something to me and I have to tell them to turn their hand around. I guess

you could say that was the equivalent of mumbling? :)

Donna

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh my family is like this Donna. Sometimes I need tricky word spelt out and

they have all sorts of variations to the alphabet, DRIVES ME MAD !

MUMBLING for sure !

Thanks DONNA !

MArcus

Re: Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

> Marcus,

>

> The only time I have had trouble understanding fingerspelling is when the

> signer is standing at the wrong angle. As long as I can see the inside of

> the hand, I can understand. That would be the only reason I could see for

> there to be a problem. A lot of times, Lee or will start to sign

> something to me and I have to tell them to turn their hand around. I

guess

> you could say that was the equivalent of mumbling? :)

>

> Donna

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh my family is like this Donna. Sometimes I need tricky word spelt out and

they have all sorts of variations to the alphabet, DRIVES ME MAD !

MUMBLING for sure !

Thanks DONNA !

MArcus

Re: Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

> Marcus,

>

> The only time I have had trouble understanding fingerspelling is when the

> signer is standing at the wrong angle. As long as I can see the inside of

> the hand, I can understand. That would be the only reason I could see for

> there to be a problem. A lot of times, Lee or will start to sign

> something to me and I have to tell them to turn their hand around. I

guess

> you could say that was the equivalent of mumbling? :)

>

> Donna

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Greg

YEs AUSLAN is two handed and also Signed English. Auslan is in fact ' slang ' its not taught in schools here, but used by the deaf comunity. ( Of which I don't seem to belong )

Deaf children of deaf parents are the meat in the sandwich with this ! The yuse AUSLAN at home and SIGNED ENGLISH at school. Very confusing for them

Re: Serious Question !!! ( just this once ! )

Marcus,

Using ASL, it doesn't matter which hand you use for your dominant hand, when you're signing or fingerspelling. People should be able to understand you. I've seen AUSLAN sign language before. Doesn't that use both hands for fingerspelling?

Greg

I'm learning ASL alphabet for USA trip next year, and I have DUD right hand so if I use left, will anybody know what Im signing ???

Australians use AUSLAN and SIGNED ENGLISH ! neither are remotely similar to ASL !

Marcus !!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...