Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 Hi Merav and others, Sorry if I was caught off guard, BUT, if the photos didn't come thru, sorry. But, the photos in the email I sent were NOT the ones that Merav linked to on snopes. The photos in the email I sent were of a dark haired, dark eyed woman, not the blonde that I found when I googled the subject line and checked snopes. Were they also exaggerated and or photo-shopped? Maybe. But, the point is, that a woman can easily weigh 320 pounds and be large and not overweight. Maybe I didn't have accurate photos. . .I'll never know, since I couldn't find the photos I sent on any site to confirm accuracy. Sorry. . . Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT Consultant, Writer, Speaker Director of Medical Nutrition Signet Diagnostic Corporation (Mountain Time) Fax: DineRight4@... In a message dated 3/22/2010 6:57:40 P.M. Mountain Daylight Time, meravls@... writes: For those who missed the pic like I did... _http://www.snopes.http://www.http://www.snopehttp_ (http://www.snopes.com/photos/people/tallwoman.asp) Merav Levi, RD, MS, _CDNhttp://www.CDNhttp:/CDNhttp://www.<W_ (cdnhttp://www.linkedin.com/in/meravlevi) To: _rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa ) From: _Dineright4@..._ (mailto:Dineright4@...) Date: Mon, 22 Mar 2010 13:35:58 -0400 Subject: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) Subject: 320 pound woman]  What does a 320 pound woman look like? Now, before you scroll down to look at her pictures, get a mental image of what you think a woman who weighs 320 looks like!! Not exactly what you were expecting is it? The tallest woman in the world lives in Holland . She is 7'4 " and weighs 320 What a relief! Now we ALL know we aren't overweight; we're just too short! I knew it!;-) Have A Great Day _________________________________________ (_http://www.incredimhttp://wwhttp://ww & <WBR>rui=393_ (http://www.incredimail.com/?id=606432 & rui=39314327) ) _________________________________________ Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 Hi Merav and others, Sorry if I was caught off guard, BUT, if the photos didn't come thru, sorry. But, the photos in the email I sent were NOT the ones that Merav linked to on snopes. The photos in the email I sent were of a dark haired, dark eyed woman, not the blonde that I found when I googled the subject line and checked snopes. Were they also exaggerated and or photo-shopped? Maybe. But, the point is, that a woman can easily weigh 320 pounds and be large and not overweight. Maybe I didn't have accurate photos. . .I'll never know, since I couldn't find the photos I sent on any site to confirm accuracy. Sorry. . . Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT Consultant, Writer, Speaker Director of Medical Nutrition Signet Diagnostic Corporation (Mountain Time) Fax: DineRight4@... In a message dated 3/22/2010 6:57:40 P.M. Mountain Daylight Time, meravls@... writes: For those who missed the pic like I did... _http://www.snopes.http://www.http://www.snopehttp_ (http://www.snopes.com/photos/people/tallwoman.asp) Merav Levi, RD, MS, _CDNhttp://www.CDNhttp:/CDNhttp://www.<W_ (cdnhttp://www.linkedin.com/in/meravlevi) To: _rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa ) From: _Dineright4@..._ (mailto:Dineright4@...) Date: Mon, 22 Mar 2010 13:35:58 -0400 Subject: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) Subject: 320 pound woman]  What does a 320 pound woman look like? Now, before you scroll down to look at her pictures, get a mental image of what you think a woman who weighs 320 looks like!! Not exactly what you were expecting is it? The tallest woman in the world lives in Holland . She is 7'4 " and weighs 320 What a relief! Now we ALL know we aren't overweight; we're just too short! I knew it!;-) Have A Great Day _________________________________________ (_http://www.incredimhttp://wwhttp://ww & <WBR>rui=393_ (http://www.incredimail.com/?id=606432 & rui=39314327) ) _________________________________________ Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 I'm just saying that IF the photo's I sent originally (nobody received apparantly and they weren't the ones on snopes) were accurate and and IF this woman (the woman in the original photos) weighed that much, then she's not overweight or overfat. But, as I said, maybe it's completely inaccurate or photoshopped and it's all a mute point. . . A muscular, larged boned man at 6'6 " can easily be 260# and not be overweight. But, if 13 inches shorter and small framed we'd expect his IBW to be around 140 pounds, but could easily be at a healthy weight much heavier. So, I don't know how heavy a 7'7 " tall woman could be and still not be overweight/overfat, but 320 doesn't sound like such a stretch if large boned and fit. Jan In a message dated 3/23/2010 9:40:23 A.M. Mountain Daylight Time, melissa.nodvin@... writes: Did you mean to say this: the point is, that a woman can easily weigh 320 pounds and be large and not overweight. I totally disagree. Women can be large but weighing 320 pounds is excessive and very much considered overweight. _________________________________ From: _rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa ) [mailto:_rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa ) ] On Behalf Of _Dineright4@..._ (mailto:Dineright4@...) Sent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 11:21 AM To: _rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa ) Subject: Re: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) -different pictures Hi Merav and others, Sorry if I was caught off guard, BUT, if the photos didn't come thru, sorry. But, the photos in the email I sent were NOT the ones that Merav linked to on snopes. The photos in the email I sent were of a dark haired, dark eyed woman, not the blonde that I found when I googled the subject line and checked snopes. Were they also exaggerated and or photo-shopped? Maybe. But, the point is, that a woman can easily weigh 320 pounds and be large and not overweight. Maybe I didn't have accurate photos. . .I'll never know, since I couldn't find the photos I sent on any site to confirm accuracy. Sorry. . . Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT Consultant, Writer, Speaker Director of Medical Nutrition Signet Diagnostic Corporation (Mountain Time) Fax: _DineRight4@..._ (mailto:DineRight4@...) <mailto:DineRight4%mailto:Di> Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 I'm just saying that IF the photo's I sent originally (nobody received apparantly and they weren't the ones on snopes) were accurate and and IF this woman (the woman in the original photos) weighed that much, then she's not overweight or overfat. But, as I said, maybe it's completely inaccurate or photoshopped and it's all a mute point. . . A muscular, larged boned man at 6'6 " can easily be 260# and not be overweight. But, if 13 inches shorter and small framed we'd expect his IBW to be around 140 pounds, but could easily be at a healthy weight much heavier. So, I don't know how heavy a 7'7 " tall woman could be and still not be overweight/overfat, but 320 doesn't sound like such a stretch if large boned and fit. Jan In a message dated 3/23/2010 9:40:23 A.M. Mountain Daylight Time, melissa.nodvin@... writes: Did you mean to say this: the point is, that a woman can easily weigh 320 pounds and be large and not overweight. I totally disagree. Women can be large but weighing 320 pounds is excessive and very much considered overweight. _________________________________ From: _rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa ) [mailto:_rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa ) ] On Behalf Of _Dineright4@..._ (mailto:Dineright4@...) Sent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 11:21 AM To: _rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa ) Subject: Re: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) -different pictures Hi Merav and others, Sorry if I was caught off guard, BUT, if the photos didn't come thru, sorry. But, the photos in the email I sent were NOT the ones that Merav linked to on snopes. The photos in the email I sent were of a dark haired, dark eyed woman, not the blonde that I found when I googled the subject line and checked snopes. Were they also exaggerated and or photo-shopped? Maybe. But, the point is, that a woman can easily weigh 320 pounds and be large and not overweight. Maybe I didn't have accurate photos. . .I'll never know, since I couldn't find the photos I sent on any site to confirm accuracy. Sorry. . . Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT Consultant, Writer, Speaker Director of Medical Nutrition Signet Diagnostic Corporation (Mountain Time) Fax: _DineRight4@..._ (mailto:DineRight4@...) <mailto:DineRight4%mailto:Di> Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 Did you mean to say this: the point is, that a woman can easily weigh 320 pounds and be large and not overweight. I totally disagree. Women can be large but weighing 320 pounds is excessive and very much considered overweight. ________________________________ From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On Behalf Of Dineright4@... Sent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 11:21 AM To: rd-usa Subject: Re: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) -different pictures Hi Merav and others, Sorry if I was caught off guard, BUT, if the photos didn't come thru, sorry. But, the photos in the email I sent were NOT the ones that Merav linked to on snopes. The photos in the email I sent were of a dark haired, dark eyed woman, not the blonde that I found when I googled the subject line and checked snopes. Were they also exaggerated and or photo-shopped? Maybe. But, the point is, that a woman can easily weigh 320 pounds and be large and not overweight. Maybe I didn't have accurate photos. . .I'll never know, since I couldn't find the photos I sent on any site to confirm accuracy. Sorry. . . Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT Consultant, Writer, Speaker Director of Medical Nutrition Signet Diagnostic Corporation (Mountain Time) Fax: DineRight4@... <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com> In a message dated 3/22/2010 6:57:40 P.M. Mountain Daylight Time, meravls@... <mailto:meravls%40msn.com> writes: For those who missed the pic like I did... _http://www.snopes.http://www.http://www.snopehttp_ <http://www.snopes.http:/www.http:/www.snopehttp_> (http://www.snopes.com/photos/people/tallwoman.asp <http://www.snopes.com/photos/people/tallwoman.asp> ) Merav Levi, RD, MS, _CDNhttp://www.CDNhttp:/CDNhttp://www. <CDNhttp://www.CDNhttp:/CDNhttp:/www.> <W_ (cdnhttp://www.linkedin.com/in/meravlevi <cdnhttp://www.linkedin.com/in/meravlevi> ) To: _rd-usa@... <mailto:_rd-usa%40yahoogroups.rd> -_ (mailto:rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> ) From: _Dineright4@... <mailto:_Dineright4%40aol.Din> _ (mailto:Dineright4@... <mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com> ) Date: Mon, 22 Mar 2010 13:35:58 -0400 Subject: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) Subject: 320 pound woman]  What does a 320 pound woman look like? Now, before you scroll down to look at her pictures, get a mental image of what you think a woman who weighs 320 looks like!! Not exactly what you were expecting is it? The tallest woman in the world lives in Holland . She is 7'4 " and weighs 320 What a relief! Now we ALL know we aren't overweight; we're just too short! I knew it!;-) Have A Great Day _________________________________________ (_http://www.incredimhttp://wwhttp://ww & <http://www.incredimhttp:/wwhttp:/ww & > <WBR>rui=393_ (http://www.incredimail.com/?id=606432 & rui=39314327 <http://www.incredimail.com/?id=606432 & rui=39314327> ) ) _________________________________________ Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 Did you mean to say this: the point is, that a woman can easily weigh 320 pounds and be large and not overweight. I totally disagree. Women can be large but weighing 320 pounds is excessive and very much considered overweight. ________________________________ From: rd-usa [mailto:rd-usa ] On Behalf Of Dineright4@... Sent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 11:21 AM To: rd-usa Subject: Re: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) -different pictures Hi Merav and others, Sorry if I was caught off guard, BUT, if the photos didn't come thru, sorry. But, the photos in the email I sent were NOT the ones that Merav linked to on snopes. The photos in the email I sent were of a dark haired, dark eyed woman, not the blonde that I found when I googled the subject line and checked snopes. Were they also exaggerated and or photo-shopped? Maybe. But, the point is, that a woman can easily weigh 320 pounds and be large and not overweight. Maybe I didn't have accurate photos. . .I'll never know, since I couldn't find the photos I sent on any site to confirm accuracy. Sorry. . . Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT Consultant, Writer, Speaker Director of Medical Nutrition Signet Diagnostic Corporation (Mountain Time) Fax: DineRight4@... <mailto:DineRight4%40aol.com> In a message dated 3/22/2010 6:57:40 P.M. Mountain Daylight Time, meravls@... <mailto:meravls%40msn.com> writes: For those who missed the pic like I did... _http://www.snopes.http://www.http://www.snopehttp_ <http://www.snopes.http:/www.http:/www.snopehttp_> (http://www.snopes.com/photos/people/tallwoman.asp <http://www.snopes.com/photos/people/tallwoman.asp> ) Merav Levi, RD, MS, _CDNhttp://www.CDNhttp:/CDNhttp://www. <CDNhttp://www.CDNhttp:/CDNhttp:/www.> <W_ (cdnhttp://www.linkedin.com/in/meravlevi <cdnhttp://www.linkedin.com/in/meravlevi> ) To: _rd-usa@... <mailto:_rd-usa%40yahoogroups.rd> -_ (mailto:rd-usa <mailto:rd-usa%40yahoogroups.com> ) From: _Dineright4@... <mailto:_Dineright4%40aol.Din> _ (mailto:Dineright4@... <mailto:Dineright4%40aol.com> ) Date: Mon, 22 Mar 2010 13:35:58 -0400 Subject: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) Subject: 320 pound woman]  What does a 320 pound woman look like? Now, before you scroll down to look at her pictures, get a mental image of what you think a woman who weighs 320 looks like!! Not exactly what you were expecting is it? The tallest woman in the world lives in Holland . She is 7'4 " and weighs 320 What a relief! Now we ALL know we aren't overweight; we're just too short! I knew it!;-) Have A Great Day _________________________________________ (_http://www.incredimhttp://wwhttp://ww & <http://www.incredimhttp:/wwhttp:/ww & > <WBR>rui=393_ (http://www.incredimail.com/?id=606432 & rui=39314327 <http://www.incredimail.com/?id=606432 & rui=39314327> ) ) _________________________________________ Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 I am sorry if I made you feel you needed to be on the defense. It was not my intention. Since I didn't get the pics with your e-mail, I googled it. And I agree - not all 320lbs people, man or woman, are " automatically " obese. I am sure Arnold Schwartzeneger, in his younger days and career, was " obese " by numbers, but we all know he had very little fat tissue. Merav Levi, RD, MS, CDN http://www.linkedin.com/in/meravlevi To: rd-usa From: Dineright4@... Date: Tue, 23 Mar 2010 11:20:15 -0400 Subject: Re: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) -different pictures Hi Merav and others, Sorry if I was caught off guard, BUT, if the photos didn't come thru, sorry. But, the photos in the email I sent were NOT the ones that Merav linked to on snopes. The photos in the email I sent were of a dark haired, dark eyed woman, not the blonde that I found when I googled the subject line and checked snopes. Were they also exaggerated and or photo-shopped? Maybe. But, the point is, that a woman can easily weigh 320 pounds and be large and not overweight. Maybe I didn't have accurate photos. . .I'll never know, since I couldn't find the photos I sent on any site to confirm accuracy. Sorry. . . Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT Consultant, Writer, Speaker Director of Medical Nutrition Signet Diagnostic Corporation (Mountain Time) Fax: DineRight4@... In a message dated 3/22/2010 6:57:40 P.M. Mountain Daylight Time, meravls@... writes: For those who missed the pic like I did... _http://www.snopes.http://www.http://www.snopehttp_ (http://www.snopes.com/photos/people/tallwoman.asp) Merav Levi, RD, MS, _CDNhttp://www.CDNhttp:/CDNhttp://www.<W_ (cdnhttp://www.linkedin.com/in/meravlevi) To: _rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa ) From: _Dineright4@..._ (mailto:Dineright4@...) Date: Mon, 22 Mar 2010 13:35:58 -0400 Subject: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) Subject: 320 pound woman]  What does a 320 pound woman look like? Now, before you scroll down to look at her pictures, get a mental image of what you think a woman who weighs 320 looks like!! Not exactly what you were expecting is it? The tallest woman in the world lives in Holland . She is 7'4 " and weighs 320 What a relief! Now we ALL know we aren't overweight; we're just too short! I knew it!;-) Have A Great Day _________________________________________ (_http://www.incredimhttp://wwhttp://ww & <WBR>rui=393_ (http://www.incredimail.com/?id=606432 & rui=39314327) ) _________________________________________ Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 I am sorry if I made you feel you needed to be on the defense. It was not my intention. Since I didn't get the pics with your e-mail, I googled it. And I agree - not all 320lbs people, man or woman, are " automatically " obese. I am sure Arnold Schwartzeneger, in his younger days and career, was " obese " by numbers, but we all know he had very little fat tissue. Merav Levi, RD, MS, CDN http://www.linkedin.com/in/meravlevi To: rd-usa From: Dineright4@... Date: Tue, 23 Mar 2010 11:20:15 -0400 Subject: Re: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) -different pictures Hi Merav and others, Sorry if I was caught off guard, BUT, if the photos didn't come thru, sorry. But, the photos in the email I sent were NOT the ones that Merav linked to on snopes. The photos in the email I sent were of a dark haired, dark eyed woman, not the blonde that I found when I googled the subject line and checked snopes. Were they also exaggerated and or photo-shopped? Maybe. But, the point is, that a woman can easily weigh 320 pounds and be large and not overweight. Maybe I didn't have accurate photos. . .I'll never know, since I couldn't find the photos I sent on any site to confirm accuracy. Sorry. . . Jan Patenaude, RD, CLT Consultant, Writer, Speaker Director of Medical Nutrition Signet Diagnostic Corporation (Mountain Time) Fax: DineRight4@... In a message dated 3/22/2010 6:57:40 P.M. Mountain Daylight Time, meravls@... writes: For those who missed the pic like I did... _http://www.snopes.http://www.http://www.snopehttp_ (http://www.snopes.com/photos/people/tallwoman.asp) Merav Levi, RD, MS, _CDNhttp://www.CDNhttp:/CDNhttp://www.<W_ (cdnhttp://www.linkedin.com/in/meravlevi) To: _rd-usa@...-_ (mailto:rd-usa ) From: _Dineright4@..._ (mailto:Dineright4@...) Date: Mon, 22 Mar 2010 13:35:58 -0400 Subject: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) Subject: 320 pound woman]  What does a 320 pound woman look like? Now, before you scroll down to look at her pictures, get a mental image of what you think a woman who weighs 320 looks like!! Not exactly what you were expecting is it? The tallest woman in the world lives in Holland . She is 7'4 " and weighs 320 What a relief! Now we ALL know we aren't overweight; we're just too short! I knew it!;-) Have A Great Day _________________________________________ (_http://www.incredimhttp://wwhttp://ww & <WBR>rui=393_ (http://www.incredimail.com/?id=606432 & rui=39314327) ) _________________________________________ Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 Look at Shaq O'Neil. He's 7+ ft and 320+lbs. Proportional, muscular. Sure, he could lean out a bit. But when you hear that someone weighs 320#, your brain defaults to a picture of someone very overweight. Macdonald, R.D. Nutrition, Fitness, and Wellness Coach Complete Wellness, NOW! (818)458-1487 320 pound woman]  What does a 320 pound woman look like? Now, before you scroll down to look at her pictures, get a mental image of what you think a woman who weighs 320 looks like!! Not exactly what you were expecting is it? The tallest woman in the world lives in Holland . She is 7'4 " and weighs 320 What a relief! Now we ALL know we aren't overweight; we're just too short! I knew it!;-) Have A Great Day _________________________________________ (_http://www.incredimhttp://wwhttp://ww & <WBR>rui=393_ (http://www.incredimail.com/?id=606432 & rui=39314327) ) _________________________________________ Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 Look at Shaq O'Neil. He's 7+ ft and 320+lbs. Proportional, muscular. Sure, he could lean out a bit. But when you hear that someone weighs 320#, your brain defaults to a picture of someone very overweight. Macdonald, R.D. Nutrition, Fitness, and Wellness Coach Complete Wellness, NOW! (818)458-1487 320 pound woman]  What does a 320 pound woman look like? Now, before you scroll down to look at her pictures, get a mental image of what you think a woman who weighs 320 looks like!! Not exactly what you were expecting is it? The tallest woman in the world lives in Holland . She is 7'4 " and weighs 320 What a relief! Now we ALL know we aren't overweight; we're just too short! I knew it!;-) Have A Great Day _________________________________________ (_http://www.incredimhttp://wwhttp://ww & <WBR>rui=393_ (http://www.incredimail.com/?id=606432 & rui=39314327) ) _________________________________________ Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 Look at Shaq O'Neil. He's 7+ ft and 320+lbs. Proportional, muscular. Sure, he could lean out a bit. But when you hear that someone weighs 320#, your brain defaults to a picture of someone very overweight. Macdonald, R.D. Nutrition, Fitness, and Wellness Coach Complete Wellness, NOW! (818)458-1487 320 pound woman]  What does a 320 pound woman look like? Now, before you scroll down to look at her pictures, get a mental image of what you think a woman who weighs 320 looks like!! Not exactly what you were expecting is it? The tallest woman in the world lives in Holland . She is 7'4 " and weighs 320 What a relief! Now we ALL know we aren't overweight; we're just too short! I knew it!;-) Have A Great Day _________________________________________ (_http://www.incredimhttp://wwhttp://ww & <WBR>rui=393_ (http://www.incredimail.com/?id=606432 & rui=39314327) ) _________________________________________ Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 If she is the stated 7'4 " at 320 lbs her BMI would be 29 which puts her at over weight. That said, BMI does not take in to factor frame size, and believe me at 7'4 " she will not be small boned. Her DBW would be 245-269 lbs so an extra 80 lbs depending on her bone structure may not be as earth shattering as it appears. Believe me at 269 she would most likely look thin at 245 she may start looking wasted. Remember BMI is based on a study on men in the VA system extrapolated to everyone else and does not take into account ethnic variances or bone structure. Also be aware that the best survival rates are in BMIs of 25-30. among the classic white middle class American population again no variances are accounted for. I may be white middle class American BUT I am not a small man! Jackie Chase RD Dillingham AK Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 If she is the stated 7'4 " at 320 lbs her BMI would be 29 which puts her at over weight. That said, BMI does not take in to factor frame size, and believe me at 7'4 " she will not be small boned. Her DBW would be 245-269 lbs so an extra 80 lbs depending on her bone structure may not be as earth shattering as it appears. Believe me at 269 she would most likely look thin at 245 she may start looking wasted. Remember BMI is based on a study on men in the VA system extrapolated to everyone else and does not take into account ethnic variances or bone structure. Also be aware that the best survival rates are in BMIs of 25-30. among the classic white middle class American population again no variances are accounted for. I may be white middle class American BUT I am not a small man! Jackie Chase RD Dillingham AK Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 If she is the stated 7'4 " at 320 lbs her BMI would be 29 which puts her at over weight. That said, BMI does not take in to factor frame size, and believe me at 7'4 " she will not be small boned. Her DBW would be 245-269 lbs so an extra 80 lbs depending on her bone structure may not be as earth shattering as it appears. Believe me at 269 she would most likely look thin at 245 she may start looking wasted. Remember BMI is based on a study on men in the VA system extrapolated to everyone else and does not take into account ethnic variances or bone structure. Also be aware that the best survival rates are in BMIs of 25-30. among the classic white middle class American population again no variances are accounted for. I may be white middle class American BUT I am not a small man! Jackie Chase RD Dillingham AK Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 When this topic came up, I automatically deleted it and hoped it would just go away. Why? Well, I am not a skinny person. I even had a picture on facebook and someone - a dietitian - made a comment about it. In my defensiveness I took offense to it. I am now finding this discussion interesting. My take on the pictures? Well I am choosing to not make a public comment. All I am saying is we all must continue to strive on keeping an open non-judgemental mind in our profession. Respectfully, Carol Casey On Tue, Mar 23, 2010 at 12:34 PM, Chase wrote: > > > If she is the stated 7'4 " at 320 lbs her BMI would be 29 which puts her at > over weight. That said, BMI does not take in to factor frame size, and > believe me at 7'4 " she will not be small boned. Her DBW would be 245-269 lbs > so an extra 80 lbs depending on her bone structure may not be as earth > shattering as it appears. Believe me at 269 she would most likely look thin > at 245 she may start looking wasted. Remember BMI is based on a study on men > in the VA system extrapolated to everyone else and does not take into > account ethnic variances or bone structure. Also be aware that the best > survival rates are in BMIs of 25-30. > among the classic white middle class American population again no variances > are accounted for. I may be white middle class American BUT I am not a small > man! > > Jackie Chase RD > Dillingham AK > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 When this topic came up, I automatically deleted it and hoped it would just go away. Why? Well, I am not a skinny person. I even had a picture on facebook and someone - a dietitian - made a comment about it. In my defensiveness I took offense to it. I am now finding this discussion interesting. My take on the pictures? Well I am choosing to not make a public comment. All I am saying is we all must continue to strive on keeping an open non-judgemental mind in our profession. Respectfully, Carol Casey On Tue, Mar 23, 2010 at 12:34 PM, Chase wrote: > > > If she is the stated 7'4 " at 320 lbs her BMI would be 29 which puts her at > over weight. That said, BMI does not take in to factor frame size, and > believe me at 7'4 " she will not be small boned. Her DBW would be 245-269 lbs > so an extra 80 lbs depending on her bone structure may not be as earth > shattering as it appears. Believe me at 269 she would most likely look thin > at 245 she may start looking wasted. Remember BMI is based on a study on men > in the VA system extrapolated to everyone else and does not take into > account ethnic variances or bone structure. Also be aware that the best > survival rates are in BMIs of 25-30. > among the classic white middle class American population again no variances > are accounted for. I may be white middle class American BUT I am not a small > man! > > Jackie Chase RD > Dillingham AK > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 I think we really need to look at the whole picture and remember where some of these THINGS we base good health, good weight, good eating come from. Some of it can be pretty eye opening and in the future may look as strange then, as encouraging smoking for weight loss looks to us now. OK, here are some more oldie but not so goodies, cream and milk diet for stomach ulcers, chicken soup enemas for nutrition (1900 Doctor's Medical Book), the 'Rice Diet', my grandma's personal favorite 2 tablespoons of olive oil before meals for high cholesterol. Remember Fiddler On the Roof and a proper double chin, being fat use to be a sign of health, fat people did not get TB. That is one of the nice thing about our profession, is it is constantly changing and it only took a stroke of a pen to make hundred of thousands of Americans overweight and obese over night. Even after more years then I want to admit I have yet to be bored or unable to find some new aspect of our profession to explore, life is so exciting at times. Jackie Chase RD Dillingham AK Subject: Re: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) -different pictures To: rd-usa Date: Tuesday, March 23, 2010, 8:04 PM When this topic came up, I automatically deleted it and hoped it would just go away. Why? Well, I am not a skinny person. I even had a picture on facebook and someone - a dietitian - made a comment about it. In my defensiveness I took offense to it. I am now finding this discussion interesting. My take on the pictures? Well I am choosing to not make a public comment. All I am saying is we all must continue to strive on keeping an open non-judgemental mind in our profession. Respectfully, Carol Casey Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 I think we really need to look at the whole picture and remember where some of these THINGS we base good health, good weight, good eating come from. Some of it can be pretty eye opening and in the future may look as strange then, as encouraging smoking for weight loss looks to us now. OK, here are some more oldie but not so goodies, cream and milk diet for stomach ulcers, chicken soup enemas for nutrition (1900 Doctor's Medical Book), the 'Rice Diet', my grandma's personal favorite 2 tablespoons of olive oil before meals for high cholesterol. Remember Fiddler On the Roof and a proper double chin, being fat use to be a sign of health, fat people did not get TB. That is one of the nice thing about our profession, is it is constantly changing and it only took a stroke of a pen to make hundred of thousands of Americans overweight and obese over night. Even after more years then I want to admit I have yet to be bored or unable to find some new aspect of our profession to explore, life is so exciting at times. Jackie Chase RD Dillingham AK Subject: Re: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) -different pictures To: rd-usa Date: Tuesday, March 23, 2010, 8:04 PM When this topic came up, I automatically deleted it and hoped it would just go away. Why? Well, I am not a skinny person. I even had a picture on facebook and someone - a dietitian - made a comment about it. In my defensiveness I took offense to it. I am now finding this discussion interesting. My take on the pictures? Well I am choosing to not make a public comment. All I am saying is we all must continue to strive on keeping an open non-judgemental mind in our profession. Respectfully, Carol Casey Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 My daughter, a 10th grader, doing a research, for a social study research class about fashion and social behavior. SO, of course she touches the issue of weight.here is an interesting link she cites on her study:http://ohioline.osu.edu/hyg-fact/5000/5238.html I think, that in our struggle, as professionals and individuals, to teach the audience (AKA public) healthy eating habits, we lost the focus. We focus on the thin, on appearance on size # (which shrinks every year) and therefore we judge overwt and obese ppl to levels of abuse and discrimination.We, as a society, lost our way, and I blame, at least in part, our profession.As women, its even harder - we have to look even skinnier after the 2nd-3rd-4th child baring. I am not an heavy person. never been. I am lucky, in a way, and I am well aware of it. However, I am not a skinny, size-2 either. I dated a 5'4 " tall 250-ish lbs guy who was horrified to walk down the street at day light bc he felt all the eyes and judgement staring at him. So I know quit well how it feel " on the other side of the scale " And I tell you - as a society and professionals, we are doing so much harm to the next generation it is scary. (and that's even before going into the " big brother is watching " like NYC new suggestion to ban salt in restaurants, and list calories on all menus and Mrs. Obama statement to put her very young girls on a diet...my ears are still aching from it. Don't get me started. I just don't believe this is the way.)When will we go back to value people for people - I know - I am naive, but I am just hoping that we stop look at people as size #. Maybe, just maybe, if we stop being so judgmental about wt, we will help people shade lbs as a " side effect " ... Merav Levi, RD, MS, CDNhttp://www.linkedin.com/in/meravlevi To: rd-usa From: jackiechase66@... Date: Tue, 23 Mar 2010 16:50:04 -0700 Subject: Re: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) -different pictures I think we really need to look at the whole picture and remember where some of these THINGS we base good health, good weight, good eating come from. Some of it can be pretty eye opening and in the future may look as strange then, as encouraging smoking for weight loss looks to us now. OK, here are some more oldie but not so goodies, cream and milk diet for stomach ulcers, chicken soup enemas for nutrition (1900 Doctor's Medical Book), the 'Rice Diet', my grandma's personal favorite 2 tablespoons of olive oil before meals for high cholesterol. Remember Fiddler On the Roof and a proper double chin, being fat use to be a sign of health, fat people did not get TB. That is one of the nice thing about our profession, is it is constantly changing and it only took a stroke of a pen to make hundred of thousands of Americans overweight and obese over night. Even after more years then I want to admit I have yet to be bored or unable to find some new aspect of our profession to explore, life is so exciting at times. Jackie Chase RD Dillingham AK Subject: Re: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) -different pictures To: rd-usa Date: Tuesday, March 23, 2010, 8:04 PM When this topic came up, I automatically deleted it and hoped it would just go away. Why? Well, I am not a skinny person. I even had a picture on facebook and someone - a dietitian - made a comment about it. In my defensiveness I took offense to it. I am now finding this discussion interesting. My take on the pictures? Well I am choosing to not make a public comment. All I am saying is we all must continue to strive on keeping an open non-judgemental mind in our profession. Respectfully, Carol Casey Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 My daughter, a 10th grader, doing a research, for a social study research class about fashion and social behavior. SO, of course she touches the issue of weight.here is an interesting link she cites on her study:http://ohioline.osu.edu/hyg-fact/5000/5238.html I think, that in our struggle, as professionals and individuals, to teach the audience (AKA public) healthy eating habits, we lost the focus. We focus on the thin, on appearance on size # (which shrinks every year) and therefore we judge overwt and obese ppl to levels of abuse and discrimination.We, as a society, lost our way, and I blame, at least in part, our profession.As women, its even harder - we have to look even skinnier after the 2nd-3rd-4th child baring. I am not an heavy person. never been. I am lucky, in a way, and I am well aware of it. However, I am not a skinny, size-2 either. I dated a 5'4 " tall 250-ish lbs guy who was horrified to walk down the street at day light bc he felt all the eyes and judgement staring at him. So I know quit well how it feel " on the other side of the scale " And I tell you - as a society and professionals, we are doing so much harm to the next generation it is scary. (and that's even before going into the " big brother is watching " like NYC new suggestion to ban salt in restaurants, and list calories on all menus and Mrs. Obama statement to put her very young girls on a diet...my ears are still aching from it. Don't get me started. I just don't believe this is the way.)When will we go back to value people for people - I know - I am naive, but I am just hoping that we stop look at people as size #. Maybe, just maybe, if we stop being so judgmental about wt, we will help people shade lbs as a " side effect " ... Merav Levi, RD, MS, CDNhttp://www.linkedin.com/in/meravlevi To: rd-usa From: jackiechase66@... Date: Tue, 23 Mar 2010 16:50:04 -0700 Subject: Re: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) -different pictures I think we really need to look at the whole picture and remember where some of these THINGS we base good health, good weight, good eating come from. Some of it can be pretty eye opening and in the future may look as strange then, as encouraging smoking for weight loss looks to us now. OK, here are some more oldie but not so goodies, cream and milk diet for stomach ulcers, chicken soup enemas for nutrition (1900 Doctor's Medical Book), the 'Rice Diet', my grandma's personal favorite 2 tablespoons of olive oil before meals for high cholesterol. Remember Fiddler On the Roof and a proper double chin, being fat use to be a sign of health, fat people did not get TB. That is one of the nice thing about our profession, is it is constantly changing and it only took a stroke of a pen to make hundred of thousands of Americans overweight and obese over night. Even after more years then I want to admit I have yet to be bored or unable to find some new aspect of our profession to explore, life is so exciting at times. Jackie Chase RD Dillingham AK Subject: Re: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) -different pictures To: rd-usa Date: Tuesday, March 23, 2010, 8:04 PM When this topic came up, I automatically deleted it and hoped it would just go away. Why? Well, I am not a skinny person. I even had a picture on facebook and someone - a dietitian - made a comment about it. In my defensiveness I took offense to it. I am now finding this discussion interesting. My take on the pictures? Well I am choosing to not make a public comment. All I am saying is we all must continue to strive on keeping an open non-judgemental mind in our profession. Respectfully, Carol Casey Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 So tired of hearing about size and lbs .. instead of embracing a healthy active lifestyle and clean eating. although there is tons out there .. this is well worth a read: http://www.lindabacon.org/ best regards RE: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) -different pictures > > My daughter, a 10th grader, doing a research, for a social study research > class about fashion and social behavior. SO, of course she touches the > issue of weight.here is an interesting link she cites on her > study:http://ohioline.osu.edu/hyg-fact/5000/5238.html snipp Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 So tired of hearing about size and lbs .. instead of embracing a healthy active lifestyle and clean eating. although there is tons out there .. this is well worth a read: http://www.lindabacon.org/ best regards RE: 320 pound woman (paradigm shift) -different pictures > > My daughter, a 10th grader, doing a research, for a social study research > class about fashion and social behavior. SO, of course she touches the > issue of weight.here is an interesting link she cites on her > study:http://ohioline.osu.edu/hyg-fact/5000/5238.html snipp Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 I just read on the Med Page Today how a NORMAL weight woman has to do 20.1 hours of moderately vigorous exercise every week in order to maintain her normal weight. Something is very wrong when normal women have to spend half a work week in vigorous exercise to maintain their weight. Where did we go wrong as a society that so much time needs to be spent on weight control just to remain at your normal weight. I don't remember anyone exercising for hours a week in order to maintain her weight in the 50's & 60's. I remember Jack Alane promoting exercise to keep you in shape but that was it. As I stated before something is very wrong with what we are doing if it takes so much work to maintain a normal weight. Jackie Chase RD Dillingham AK > > My daughter, a 10th grader, doing a research, for a social study research class about fashion and social behavior. SO, of course she touches the issue of weight.here is an interesting link she cites on her study:http://ohioline.osu.edu/hyg-fact/5000/5238.html > I think, that in our struggle, as professionals and individuals, to teach the audience (AKA public) healthy eating habits, we lost the focus. We focus on the thin, on appearance on size # (which shrinks every year) and therefore we judge overwt and obese ppl to levels of abuse and discrimination.We, as a society, lost our way, and I blame, at least in part, our profession.As women, its even harder - we have to look even skinnier after the 2nd-3rd-4th child baring. > I am not an heavy person. never been. I am lucky, in a way, and I am well aware of it. However, I am not a skinny, size-2 either. > I dated a 5'4 " tall 250-ish lbs guy who was horrified to walk down the street at day light bc he felt all the eyes and judgement staring at him. So I know quit well how it feel " on the other side of the scale " And I tell you - as a society and professionals, we are doing so much harm to the next generation it is scary. (and that's even before going into the " big brother is watching " like NYC new suggestion to ban salt in restaurants, and list calories on all menus and Mrs. Obama statement to put her very young girls on a diet...my ears are still aching from it. Don't get me started. I just don't believe this is the way.)When will we go back to value people for people - I know - I am naive, but I am just hoping that we stop look at people as size #. Maybe, just maybe, if we stop being so judgmental about wt, we will help people shade lbs as a " side effect " ... > > Merav Levi, RD, MS, CDNhttp://www.linkedin.com/in/meravlevi > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 Maybe if our daily activity was more 'active' (like before modern conveniences) we wouldn't need 20 hrs/wk in a gym.  Do you all remember life when we had to get up off the couch to change the TV channel? How about manually washing, wringing and hanging clothes to dry? We walked to the store daily? We walked our children to school?  We have less activity of daily lifestyle and more calories than 50 or 100 years ago. Gyms are a relatively new phenomenon - 100 years ago the gym was where men went to box or wrestle. These days our jobs take less manual labor. And so many of us in Western Society are using fewer calories than we eat so that is why purposeful exercise has to be part of our lives.  Holly ---------- Holly Lee Brewer, MS RD CDE Pediatric Dietitian, Diabetes Educator Medical Nutrition Therapist, Las Vegas, NV Maj Holly Brewer, USAFR BSC http://hollyinbalad.blogspot.com Malcom Grow Medical Center, s AFB, MD (Oct-Dec 2009) Joint Base Balad, Iraq (Jan-Jul 2009) > > My daughter, a 10th grader, doing a research, for a social study research class about fashion and social behavior. SO, of course she touches the issue of weight.here is an interesting link she cites on her study:http://ohioline. osu.edu/hyg- fact/5000/ 5238.html > I think, that in our struggle, as professionals and individuals, to teach the audience (AKA public) healthy eating habits, we lost the focus. We focus on the thin, on appearance on size # (which shrinks every year) and therefore we judge overwt and obese ppl to levels of abuse and discrimination. We, as a society, lost our way, and I blame, at least in part, our profession.As women, its even harder - we have to look even skinnier after the 2nd-3rd-4th child baring. > I am not an heavy person. never been. I am lucky, in a way, and I am well aware of it. However, I am not a skinny, size-2 either. > I dated a 5'4 " tall 250-ish lbs guy who was horrified to walk down the street at day light bc he felt all the eyes and judgement staring at him. So I know quit well how it feel " on the other side of the scale " And I tell you - as a society and professionals, we are doing so much harm to the next generation it is scary. (and that's even before going into the " big brother is watching " like NYC new suggestion to ban salt in restaurants, and list calories on all menus and Mrs. Obama statement to put her very young girls on a diet...my ears are still aching from it. Don't get me started. I just don't believe this is the way.)When will we go back to value people for people - I know - I am naive, but I am just hoping that we stop look at people as size #. Maybe, just maybe, if we stop being so judgmental about wt, we will help people shade lbs as a " side effect " ... > > Merav Levi, RD, MS, CDNhttp://www. linkedin. com/in/meravlevi > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 Maybe if our daily activity was more 'active' (like before modern conveniences) we wouldn't need 20 hrs/wk in a gym.  Do you all remember life when we had to get up off the couch to change the TV channel? How about manually washing, wringing and hanging clothes to dry? We walked to the store daily? We walked our children to school?  We have less activity of daily lifestyle and more calories than 50 or 100 years ago. Gyms are a relatively new phenomenon - 100 years ago the gym was where men went to box or wrestle. These days our jobs take less manual labor. And so many of us in Western Society are using fewer calories than we eat so that is why purposeful exercise has to be part of our lives.  Holly ---------- Holly Lee Brewer, MS RD CDE Pediatric Dietitian, Diabetes Educator Medical Nutrition Therapist, Las Vegas, NV Maj Holly Brewer, USAFR BSC http://hollyinbalad.blogspot.com Malcom Grow Medical Center, s AFB, MD (Oct-Dec 2009) Joint Base Balad, Iraq (Jan-Jul 2009) > > My daughter, a 10th grader, doing a research, for a social study research class about fashion and social behavior. SO, of course she touches the issue of weight.here is an interesting link she cites on her study:http://ohioline. osu.edu/hyg- fact/5000/ 5238.html > I think, that in our struggle, as professionals and individuals, to teach the audience (AKA public) healthy eating habits, we lost the focus. We focus on the thin, on appearance on size # (which shrinks every year) and therefore we judge overwt and obese ppl to levels of abuse and discrimination. We, as a society, lost our way, and I blame, at least in part, our profession.As women, its even harder - we have to look even skinnier after the 2nd-3rd-4th child baring. > I am not an heavy person. never been. I am lucky, in a way, and I am well aware of it. However, I am not a skinny, size-2 either. > I dated a 5'4 " tall 250-ish lbs guy who was horrified to walk down the street at day light bc he felt all the eyes and judgement staring at him. So I know quit well how it feel " on the other side of the scale " And I tell you - as a society and professionals, we are doing so much harm to the next generation it is scary. (and that's even before going into the " big brother is watching " like NYC new suggestion to ban salt in restaurants, and list calories on all menus and Mrs. Obama statement to put her very young girls on a diet...my ears are still aching from it. Don't get me started. I just don't believe this is the way.)When will we go back to value people for people - I know - I am naive, but I am just hoping that we stop look at people as size #. Maybe, just maybe, if we stop being so judgmental about wt, we will help people shade lbs as a " side effect " ... > > Merav Levi, RD, MS, CDNhttp://www. linkedin. com/in/meravlevi > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.