Guest guest Posted April 24, 2008 Report Posted April 24, 2008 Fuller, Did you go to the link? You can post comments there and I encourage you to do that. The comments on this website were made based on two articles in a discussion of proton treatment The articles asked if protons are justified by cost for prostate cancer? Can we as a society afford protons was the main topic of the articles. They did not doubt that it is the best for some cancers but the doubt came about for prostate cancer which is where they have their aggressive marketing. Read the articles and respond in the comment section. They are asking if trials should be done on protons for prostate cancer patients not on protons in general. Both sides of the issues were represented. I did not write the words. I just gave you enough information to know what is at the link. I know you and others on this list have an interest in protons and felt you should be aware of this article. If what they say is misleading you need to go there and correct it. As comparative effectiveness expands we will be hearing more about cost vs. benefit. That is the reality of what our medical system is going through right now. Kathy From: ProstateCancerSupport [mailto:ProstateCancerSupport ] On Behalf Of Fuller Sent: Thursday, April 24, 2008 4:54 PM To: ProstateCancerSupport Subject: Re: Proton beam radiation and prostate cancer management « THE “New†PROSTATE CANCER INFOLINK Part of Kathy's post says: " The problem is that there has never been a randomized clinical trial of PBRT as compared to standard forms of external beam radiotherapy, and building new PBRT facilities is expensive. Why would we be doing this unless there was a clear and proven clinical benefit for patients? " --------------------------------------- My reply: There are " clear and proven " clinical benefits for PBRT, and these explain why that there is a list of new and more to come proton hospitals and facilities, most associated with the finest medical facilities in the United States. It is the ONLY external beam radiation that can be used to treat non- operable brainstem, and certain brain cancers, and the ONLT external radiation treatment PREFERRED by most radiolgists for the treatment of CHILDREN's cancers. The reason? Because it is precise and does not harm nearby critical tissue and structures and the rapidly growing normal cells of children. Also, the new proton facilities will contribute greatly to cancer research, not just prostate cancer, but all cancers. And, there are greatly reduced side effects generally and especially when used to treat prostate cancer. Lastly, there has been such a trial: Ulrick Mock et al. Department of Radiotherapy and Radiobiology, Medical University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria. Abstract: Comparative treatment planning…photon- versus proton-based radiotherapy. PMID: 15995838. If any of the readers of this wonderful group ever have a family member, child, or friend with a head or brain tumor, I strongly urge them to consult with one of the five " Centers of Excellence " hospitals that have proton beam therapy before using surgery or some other type of radiation. It may mean a greatly improved outlook for the rest of their life. Fuller > > > > For many years, the facility at Loma in California was the only commercially functional proton beam radiation facility in the USA. Now there are five such facilities (at Loma , CA; Bloomington, IN; Boston, MA; Houston, TX; and ville, FL), with three more under construction and 10 more in the planning stage. About 8,000 men have undergone proton beam radiotherapy for prostate cancer since the Loma facility first opened in 1990. > > There seems no doubt that proton beam radiotherapy (PBRT) is a valuable and effective method for the treatment of prostate cancer and certain other forms of cancer, but prostate cancer is the “clinical business model†on which proton beam radiotherapy has been primarily dependent. The problem is that there has never been a randomized clinical trial of PBRT as compared to standard forms of external beam radiotherapy, and building new PBRT facilities is expensive. Why would we be doing this unless there was a clear and proven clinical benefit for patients? > > > > For the entire article: > > > > http://prostatecancerinfolink.net/2008/04/24/proton-beam-radiation- and-prostate-cancer-mangement/ > > or > > http://tinyurl.com/3kdege > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.