Guest guest Posted April 29, 2006 Report Posted April 29, 2006 Hi all you Idol fans! Anyone have any comments about last weeks show? I wasn’t surprised to see Kelli voted off. I think she does fairly well in her style of singing, country, but she hasn’t been able to expand her voice very well into the other genre`s. Except the Queen week, she was awesome I thought. I wondered how she was going to do last week, and was surprised she chose the song she did. With so many other love songs to choose, she picked one that I think only the original artist does it justice. I’m still not quite sure what Boccelli had to do with the songs they chose? I thought they might have to do opera songs? That would really have stretched them! was awesome, and I think the final 3 will include him, and he will more than likely win. The judges were too hard on Kat, and later apologized to her and gave her a more favorable review. I was a little concerned about her dress slit as it was a little too revealing, and it distracted a little from her singing. IMHO! J I was really happy to see Elliot dressing up, and he looked great, and sang good too. Poor , he was all mixed up with his song. Couldn’t stay on key, and was out of his element. He’s another one that is great in his style, but struggles outside it. Paris was good as usual, but I’ve heard better from her. I don’t think the song was right for her this time. No WOW factor. In fact the only one who moved me was and it may have been the song choice, but he did a suberb job. Well fans that’s my review this week, it will be interesting how it all plays out, and what they have in store for them next. Jackie J Quote
Guest guest Posted April 29, 2006 Report Posted April 29, 2006 Jackie- I wasn't surprised to see Kelli go. I was expecting that. My problem with the whole thing was that I missed the show Tuesday night! So I can't really rate the contestants performances. I am going to make sure I get to see the show this coming Tuesday. I wonder what they'll sing next? God bless... http://mscopgirl.blogspot.com http://360.yahoo.com/vallee45 -- AMERICAN IDOL COMMENTS? Hi all you Idol fans! Anyone have any comments about last weeks show? I wasn’t surprised to see Kelli voted off. I think she does fairly well in her style of singing, country, but she hasn’t been able to expand her voice very well into the other genre`s. Except the Queen week, she was awesome I thought. I wondered how she was going to do last week, and was surprised she chose the song she did. With so many other love songs to choose, she picked one that I think only the original artist does it justice. I’m still not quite sure what Boccelli had to do with the songs they chose? I thought they might have to do opera songs? That would really have stretched them! was awesome, and I think the final 3 will include him, and he will more than likely win. The judges were too hard on Kat, and later apologized to her and gave her a more favorable review. I was a little concerned about her dress slit as it was a little too revealing, and it distracted a little from her singing. IMHO! J I was really happy to see Elliot dressing up, and he looked great, and sang good too. Poor , he was all mixed up with his song. Couldn’t stay on key, and was out of his element. He’s another one that is great in his style, but struggles outside it. Paris was good as usual, but I’ve heard better from her. I don’t think the song was right for her this time. No WOW factor. In fact the only one who moved me was and it may have been the song choice, but he did a suberb job. Well fans that’s my review this week, it will be interesting how it all plays out, and what they have in store for them next. Jackie J Font Chinacat At by Engelbreit Tube by Milena Quote
Guest guest Posted April 29, 2006 Report Posted April 29, 2006 Hi Jackie, I like Kellie Pickler. Even though she is no longer on AI. I don't think this means we've heard the last of her. As far as her song choice, I think she could have made a more appropriate choice for her voice. Leann Rimes is the best with Unchained Melody. I can't really comment on any earlier versions. I think Kellie may have been trying to emulate Leann but she just doesn't have the voice range. Leann has been singing professionally since she was 13 or so. Kellie Pickler has talent, there's no doubt about that. Otherwise, she probably wouldn't have made it to the top 6. I don't necessarily agree with judges' opinions. I think Kat, Paris, and did pretty good with their songs. is very entertaining. He has a lot of energy on stage and I think he's the type that would want to get the audience involved. I've always liked Elliott, even when he was wearing jeans with his suit jacket. He's a great singer. has a good voice. He's primarily interested in rock and he does well with his song choices. If he should become this year's American Idol, I think that will be great for him. I probably will never hear of him again. The last time I voted in American Idol season was when Reuben Stoddard and Clay Aiken were the final two. I think Reuben was the winner, but I hear a lot of Clay Aiken jokes. Whatever happened to these two guys? Donna in WA It does not require many words to speak the truth. --Chief ph __________________________________________________ Quote
Guest guest Posted April 29, 2006 Report Posted April 29, 2006 Hi Val,……I wondered if you got to see it or not? How is the BP today? Did you call or see a Dr. yet? Its pretty important to get it checked out, I’ve read that consistently high BP makes you at risk for a stroke. Please call as soon as you can, okay! J They didn’t announce what this weeks show will be about. I was surprised. I read that all the judges signed a 3 year contract, so we have the show for another 3 years. This is the first year I’ve watched it, and now I can hardly wait to see it next year. My daughter has watched it from the beginning. Take care Val,……. Hugs, Jackie J From: MSersLife [mailto:MSersLife ] On Behalf Of Valene Sent: Saturday, April 29, 2006 8:06 AM To: MSersLife Subject: Re: AMERICAN IDOL COMMENTS? Jackie- I wasn't surprised to see Kelli go. I was expecting that. My problem with the whole thing was that I missed the show Tuesday night! So I can't really rate the contestants performances. I am going to make sure I get to see the show this coming Tuesday. I wonder what they'll sing next? God bless... http://mscopgirl.blogspot.com http://360.yahoo.com/vallee45 -- AMERICAN IDOL COMMENTS? Hi all you Idol fans! Anyone have any comments about last weeks show? I wasn’t surprised to see Kelli voted off. I think she does fairly well in her style of singing, country, but she hasn’t been able to expand her voice very well into the other genre`s. Except the Queen week, she was awesome I thought. I wondered how she was going to do last week, and was surprised she chose the song she did. With so many other love songs to choose, she picked one that I think only the original artist does it justice. I’m still not quite sure what Boccelli had to do with the songs they chose? I thought they might have to do opera songs? That would really have stretched them! was awesome, and I think the final 3 will include him, and he will more than likely win. The judges were too hard on Kat, and later apologized to her and gave her a more favorable review. I was a little concerned about her dress slit as it was a little too revealing, and it distracted a little from her singing. IMHO! J I was really happy to see Elliot dressing up, and he looked great, and sang good too. Poor , he was all mixed up with his song. Couldn’t stay on key, and was out of his element. He’s another one that is great in his style, but struggles outside it. Paris was good as usual, but I’ve heard better from her. I don’t think the song was right for her this time. No WOW factor. In fact the only one who moved me was and it may have been the song choice, but he did a suberb job. Well fans that’s my review this week, it will be interesting how it all plays out, and what they have in store for them next. Jackie J Font Chinacat At by Engelbreit Tube by Milena Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.