Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: War rhetoric rises between North and South Korea

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

I've been reading some things about the South Korean military that give cause for concern.

The SK army relies on conscription to fill the ranks. Conscript armies usually don't fare very well and typically have low morale. This is probably the case here because the incidence of people avoiding the draft through various means, including bribery, is on the rise. Also, for some time a common belief amongst the young was that it was the US that divided the Koreas and that the North was the victim. That has been changing but slowly.

Much of the current political leadership has never served in the military. Because of that they aren't aware of conditions in the military nor what it is or isn't capable of. In essence they are probably overestimating their army's capability.

The SK army isn't that technologically advanced. As it stands, they are under US command still and it is the US forces that have most of the high tech gear. Several times, including 2007, command of SK forces was supposed to have been handed back to SK commanders. They seemed to have realized that their military wasn't ready and so it was pushed back to at least 2012. SK forces recently did get a high tech command and control center for about $30 million but it isn't as powerful as US versions, but then it doesn't need to be since it is only concerned about the local area and not the world.

So, the US have the tech while the SK troops are perhaps as our forces were in the 1980's (just a guess but I mean they don't have as much fancy stuff as the US does). They are a conscript force of which many don't want to be there. Its an open question how they will react when shelled for the first time and NK human waves pour into them.

In a message dated 12/24/2010 12:21:09 A.M. Eastern Standard Time, no_reply writes:

War rhetoric rises between North and South Korea

Posted

I've been reading some things about the South Korean military that give cause for concern.

The SK army relies on conscription to fill the ranks. Conscript armies usually don't fare very well and typically have low morale. This is probably the case here because the incidence of people avoiding the draft through various means, including bribery, is on the rise. Also, for some time a common belief amongst the young was that it was the US that divided the Koreas and that the North was the victim. That has been changing but slowly.

Much of the current political leadership has never served in the military. Because of that they aren't aware of conditions in the military nor what it is or isn't capable of. In essence they are probably overestimating their army's capability.

The SK army isn't that technologically advanced. As it stands, they are under US command still and it is the US forces that have most of the high tech gear. Several times, including 2007, command of SK forces was supposed to have been handed back to SK commanders. They seemed to have realized that their military wasn't ready and so it was pushed back to at least 2012. SK forces recently did get a high tech command and control center for about $30 million but it isn't as powerful as US versions, but then it doesn't need to be since it is only concerned about the local area and not the world.

So, the US have the tech while the SK troops are perhaps as our forces were in the 1980's (just a guess but I mean they don't have as much fancy stuff as the US does). They are a conscript force of which many don't want to be there. Its an open question how they will react when shelled for the first time and NK human waves pour into them.

In a message dated 12/24/2010 12:21:09 A.M. Eastern Standard Time, no_reply writes:

War rhetoric rises between North and South Korea

Posted

Nothing is stopping the South Koreans from trying to update their own technology

and revamp their military. I am sure we have treaties which try to prevent that

from happening, but when you have such a potentially deadly enemy nearby, a

little self-determination can come in handy.

Administrator

" So, the US have the tech while the SK troops are perhaps as our forces were in

the 1980's (just a guess but I mean they don't have as much fancy stuff as the

US does). They are a conscript force of which many don't want to be there. Its

an open question how they will react when shelled for the first time and NK

human waves pour into them. "

Posted

Mostly what's stopping them is a lack of political will and the typical politicians' desire to spend money on vote buying projects instead of the military. Then there is the issue of the conscript military. Given the attitudes toward the military in South Korea it is not likely they could get the troops they need to protect the country. Hard to believe it but even with an enemy that wants to kill them right across the border, few young men want to serve to protect their country. Still, conscripts are generally poor quality troops with low morale so they probably wouldn't perform very well in the first place.

In a message dated 12/26/2010 12:29:47 A.M. Eastern Standard Time, no_reply writes:

Nothing is stopping the South Koreans from trying to update their own technology and revamp their military. I am sure we have treaties which try to prevent that from happening, but when you have such a potentially deadly enemy nearby, a little self-determination can come in handy.Administrator

Posted

" Hard to believe it but even with an enemy that wants to kill them right across

the border, few young men want to serve to protect their country. Still,

conscripts are generally poor quality troops with low morale so they probably

wouldn't perform very well in the first place. "

Most people who do not volunteer tend to have a degree of cynicism because they

see and hear so much about mismanagement of affairs in the military. I think if

I were a South korean, I would be wondering why my government doesn't just scrap

any treaty they may have with us and anyone else and work toward developing

their own nuculear weapons as a deterrent to North Korean hostilities.

Administrator

Posted

Some of the cynicism is because of propaganda and such aimed at the students to keep them from joining up and lowering their morale if they do. There is also a lot of corruption in the SK government down to local levels and the regular brawls in their parliament can't encourage much faith in government.

Aside from that, there has been pressure in South Korea and also Japan to scrap old treaties and develop nukes and conventional weapons to better defend themselves against China, etc., because the US is seen as less and less likely to actually come to their aid.

In a message dated 12/27/2010 12:34:32 A.M. Eastern Standard Time, no_reply writes:

Most people who do not volunteer tend to have a degree of cynicism because they see and hear so much about mismanagement of affairs in the military. I think if I were a South korean, I would be wondering why my government doesn't just scrap any treaty they may have with us and anyone else and work toward developing their own nuculear weapons as a deterrent to North Korean hostilities. Administrator

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...