Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Is it legal to secretly record a teacher in class?

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

http://www.ocala.com/article/20101225/ARTICLES/101229821/-1/entertainment02?Titl\

e=Is-it-legal-to-secretly-record-a-teacher-in-class-

Is it legal to secretly record a teacher in class?

The question was raised after a parent recorded teachers mocking her autistic

child

By Joe Callahan

Staff writer

Published: Saturday, December 25, 2010 at 6:30 a.m.

Last Modified: Sunday, December 26, 2010 at 1:17 a.m.

The State Attorney's Office says it won't prosecute a teacher and an aide who

were caught on tape mocking an autistic first-grader because the tape doesn't

offer enough proof to support a charge of child abuse.

But the incident, which prompted the n County School Board to fire the aide

and put the teacher on unpaid leave pending a termination hearing, has also

raised questions about whether the audio recording made by the child's mother

violates a Florida law against secretly taping private conversations.

At issue is whether the conversation between the teachers is considered private,

even though it occurred in a public school classroom. The attorney for the

teacher says it is was private and that the recording was illegal. The school

district's attorney says the classroom is a public place, so the recording was

legal. And prosecutors say it's a gray area.

The issue began unfolding in October when the mother of the 7-year-old girl

began to suspect something was wrong with her child, who cannot speak.

The mother placed a digital recorder in her child's backpack, then listened to

it when the child returned home.

The recording reportedly revealed the child was called " a hippo, " a " hippo in a

ballerina suit " and " a beached whale sleeping, " a School District report states.

The teacher and the aide also reportedly chastised the child for wetting herself

and made her wear soiled clothes and clean her own urine, the report stated.

The mother shared the recording with School District administrators, and the

teacher and aide were placed on paid leave. It took seven weeks for the district

to verify who was speaking on the tape, officials said.

Last week, Maplewood Elementary School teacher's aide Deborah J. was fired

by the School Board for her role in the recording incident. did not

challenge Superintendent of Schools Jim Yancey's recommendation to terminate her

contract.

The board placed Maplewood teacher Rhoda on unpaid leave.

requested a hearing in hopes of convincing the School Board to change its

decision. That hearing will be held sometime after the first of the year.

At that hearing, the board can uphold its decision and fire or change

its mind and reinstate the 20-year veteran educator.

In the end, Assistant State Attorney Ric Ridgway said, there was just not enough

evidence to prosecute anyone involved in the October incident, which has sparked

much debate over the legality of the tape and an expectation of privacy.

Florida's wiretapping law requires that both parties in a conversation give

consent before a recording can be made. Florida makes it a crime to intercept,

or record, any " wire, oral, or electronic communication, " unless all parties to

the communication give consent.

However, the law allows recordings to be made in places where there is no

reasonable expectation of privacy, such as a conversation in a public where they

could be overheard. In such cases, consent is not needed for someone to make a

recording.

District's position

Shortly after the incident came to light, Yancey said he believed the recording

was probably illegally obtained by the mother. Still, he felt and

should be fired based on what they said and did to the child, which

was based solely on that recording.

But hours after Yancey's statement appeared on Ocala.com, the superintendent

received an e-mail from his attorney, Haldin, which Yancey passed along

to the Star-Banner. Haldin said the taping was legal.

" While Florida has a `wiretap' statute, the Florida courts have construed it to

not apply where a recording is made in a party's place of business, " Haldin

wrote.

The courts have said, according to Haldin, that a party has no reasonable

expectation of privacy " in a place of business and, therefore, recording without

a party's knowledge in a place of business is not prohibited by the statute.

Here, the party's place of business is the school classroom. "

Haldin further stated that the classroom is not only private, it is filled with

students and " is accessible throughout the day by administrators,

paraprofessionals, parents and other teachers and students. "

" It cannot reasonably be considered a private place for a teacher. The courts

have gone on to say that in addition to a party expecting privacy at a location,

the expectation must include a `societal recognition that the expectation is

reasonable,' & #8201; " Haldin quoted from a court decision.

Haldin said he believes that society recognizes the opposite: " That society

needs to know how teachers are treating handicapped children in its classrooms. "

Teacher's position

, the teacher, is being represented by Ocala attorney Bradshaw,

who believes that the evidence against was obtained illegally.

Bradshaw said " had a reasonable expectation of privacy. "

Though the Maplewood classroom could be deemed public, Bradshaw said only a few

select administrators can just walk inside. Almost everyone else must register

at the front office. If allowed inside, the person must hand over a driver's

license at the front office to get a badge. The teacher is then notified of the

visitor.

Based on that information, Bradshaw said the classroom should be considered

private and that and should have a reasonable expectation of

privacy when it comes to conversations among themselves.

Bradshaw said the statements, which he called improper, could have been between

two employees who were frustrated and were blowing off steam out of earshot of

the children.

Bradshaw also said his client should be presumed innocent and that he has the

right to examine the tape to determine what statements his client may have made

and whether the statements were even made in front of students.

Bradshaw included 51 letters of support from fellow teachers and parents in

's request for a hearing.

Bradshaw also asked the board to seek a ruling from the court as to the legality

of the recording before holding the termination hearing.

School District officials will not honor his request.

School District spokesman Christian said even if the recording is deemed

to be illegally obtained, the district " still has the right to fire them for any

reason. " Christian said the legality of the recording will not change Yancey's

decision.

State's investigation

Ridgway, the chief assistant State Attorney, said the issue of whether the tape

recording was illegally obtained is not clear.

" Was there a reasonable expectation that the conversation was private? " Ridgway

asked. It is very much in a gray area, he said. " There's not a lot of cases in

that area. "

Ridgway said there was no proof the child suffered any physical harm. The second

part of the child abuse statute revolves around mental abuse.

" We would have to prove that there was psychological damage done to the child,

beyond just being mean, " Ridgway said. That would be further hard to prove, he

added, because the child is non-verbal and cannot communicate about what

happened.

When it comes to prosecuting the mother for illegally recording someone, he said

that the gray area played a big role in that decision. And since the teachers

were not prosecuted, he believes it would be unfair to prosecute the mother of

the child.

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...