Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Woman arrested for refusing patdown

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

The thing is, car crashes easily kill more people than terrorism, but there is not a national "car terror scale. "So why do we obsess over things that carry a very minute chance of killing us over things that have a greater chance of killing us?

The attitude of these people is truly remarkable. Obviously they consider the typical American citizen as guilty until proven innocent and are behaving like bullies. I've also read that they are stepping up restrictions on thermoses because of some chatter or something. All the terrorists have to do is increase the number of items they could even remotely possibly use as weapons to totally overwhelm our tech based system. It is entirely possible the terrorists haven't made a serious attempt on another plane simply by those things that have happened and the chatter causes us to spend billions of dollars for no result and to cause increasing consternation for travelers. Why bother blowing up a plane when these actions cost so much more?

http://www.kvue.com/news/local/Woman-arrested-at-ABIA-after-refusing-enhanced-pat-down-112354199.html

Early Wednesday morning, a computer glitch shut down a security checkpoint for a couple of hours at Austin-Bergstrom International Airport. The line snaked out the door as many travelers waited for more than an hour and some missed their flights. One of the first people in line after that shutdown never made it through. She was arrested and banned from the airport.

Hirschkind, 56, who says she is a rape victim and who has a pacemaker-type device implanted in her chest, says her constitutional rights were violated. She says she never broke any laws. But the Transportation Security Administration disagrees.

Hirschkind was hoping to spend Christmas with friends in California, but she never made it past the security checkpoint.

"I can't go through because I have the equivalent of a pacemaker in me," she said.

Hirschkind said because of the device in her body, she was led to a female TSA employee and three Austin police officers. She says she was told she was going to be patted down.

"I turned to the police officer and said, 'I have given no due cause to give up my constitutional rights. You can wand me,'" and they said, 'No, you have to do this,'" she said.

Hirschkind agreed to the pat down, but on one condition.

"I told them, 'No, I'm not going to have my breasts felt,' and she said, 'Yes, you are,'" said Hirschkind.

When Hirschkind refused, she says that "the police actually pushed me to the floor, (and) handcuffed me. I was crying by then. They drug me 25 yards across the floor in front of the whole security."

An ABIA spokesman says it is TSA policy that anyone activating a security alarm has two options. One is to opt out and not fly, and the other option is to subject themselves to an enhanced pat down. Hirschkind refused both and was arrested.

Other travelers KVUE talked to say they empathize with Hirschkind, but the law is the law.

"I understand her side of it, and their side as well, but it is for our protection so I have no problems with it," said Gwen Washington, who lives in Killeen.

"It's unfortunate that that happened and she didn't get to fly home, but it makes me feel a little safer," said Protine.

The TSA did release a statement Wednesday that said in part, "Our officers are trained to treat all passengers with dignity and respect. Security is not optional."

The TSA says less than three percent of travelers get a pat-down

Posted

Because humans are exceptionally bad at sane risk evaluation when low risk high consequence events are involved. -=Russ=-

The thing is, car crashes easily kill more people than terrorism, but there is not a national "car terror scale. "So why do we obsess over things that carry a very minute chance of killing us over things that have a greater chance of killing us?

The attitude of these people is truly remarkable. Obviously they consider the typical American citizen as guilty until proven innocent and are behaving like bullies. I've also read that they are stepping up restrictions on thermoses because of some chatter or something. All the terrorists have to do is increase the number of items they could even remotely possibly use as weapons to totally overwhelm our tech based system. It is entirely possible the terrorists haven't made a serious attempt on another plane simply by those things that have happened and the chatter causes us to spend billions of dollars for no result and to cause increasing consternation for travelers. Why bother blowing up a plane when these actions cost so much more?

http://www.kvue.com/news/local/Woman-arrested-at-ABIA-after-refusing-enhanced-pat-down-112354199.html

Early Wednesday morning, a computer glitch shut down a security checkpoint for a couple of hours at Austin-Bergstrom International Airport. The line snaked out the door as many travelers waited for more than an hour and some missed their flights. One of the first people in line after that shutdown never made it through. She was arrested and banned from the airport.

Hirschkind, 56, who says she is a rape victim and who has a pacemaker-type device implanted in her chest, says her constitutional rights were violated. She says she never broke any laws. But the Transportation Security Administration disagrees.

Hirschkind was hoping to spend Christmas with friends in California, but she never made it past the security checkpoint.

"I can't go through because I have the equivalent of a pacemaker in me," she said.

Hirschkind said because of the device in her body, she was led to a female TSA employee and three Austin police officers. She says she was told she was going to be patted down.

"I turned to the police officer and said, 'I have given no due cause to give up my constitutional rights. You can wand me,'" and they said, 'No, you have to do this,'" she said.

Hirschkind agreed to the pat down, but on one condition.

"I told them, 'No, I'm not going to have my breasts felt,' and she said, 'Yes, you are,'" said Hirschkind.

When Hirschkind refused, she says that "the police actually pushed me to the floor, (and) handcuffed me. I was crying by then. They drug me 25 yards across the floor in front of the whole security."

An ABIA spokesman says it is TSA policy that anyone activating a security alarm has two options. One is to opt out and not fly, and the other option is to subject themselves to an enhanced pat down. Hirschkind refused both and was arrested.

Other travelers KVUE talked to say they empathize with Hirschkind, but the law is the law.

"I understand her side of it, and their side as well, but it is for our protection so I have no problems with it," said Gwen Washington, who lives in Killeen.

"It's unfortunate that that happened and she didn't get to fly home, but it makes me feel a little safer," said Protine.

The TSA did release a statement Wednesday that said in part, "Our officers are trained to treat all passengers with dignity and respect. Security is not optional."

The TSA says less than three percent of travelers get a pat-down

Posted

THAT is a very good point, Zoe!

maybe because an air crash involves so many people, and car crashes are mostly a

handful, or because cars are more a part of teh average person's lives that air

travel.

It seems more socially acceptable to be afrraid to fly than afraid to travel by

car!!

rl

'My cat Rusty is a servant of the Living God....'adapted from a poem by

Smart

 

The attitude of these people is truly remarkable. Obviously they consider

the typical American citizen as guilty until proven innocent and are behaving

like bullies. I've also read that they are stepping up restrictions on thermoses

because of some chatter or something. All the terrorists have to do is increase

the number of items they could even remotely possibly use as weapons to totally

overwhelm our tech based system. It is entirely possible the terrorists haven't

made a serious attempt on another plane simply by those things that have

happened and the chatter causes us to spend billions of dollars for no result

and to cause increasing consternation for travelers. Why bother blowing up a

plane when these actions cost so much more?

 

 

http://www.kvue.com/news/local/Woman-arrested-at-ABIA-after-refusing-enhanced-pa\

t-down-112354199.html

Early Wednesday morning, a computer glitch shut down a security

checkpoint for a couple of hours at Austin-Bergstrom International

Airport.  The line snaked out the door as many travelers waited for more

than an hour and some missed their flights.  One of the first people in

line after that shutdown never made it through. She was arrested and banned from

the airport.

Hirschkind, 56, who says she is a rape victim and

who has a pacemaker-type device implanted in her chest, says her

constitutional rights were violated.  She says she never broke any

laws.  But the Transportation Security Administration disagrees. 

Hirschkind was hoping to spend Christmas with friends in California, but she

never made it past the security checkpoint.

" I can't go through because I have the equivalent of a pacemaker in me, " she

said.

Hirschkind said because of the device in her body, she was led to a female

TSA employee and three Austin police officers.  She says she was told she

was going to be patted down.

" I turned to the police officer and said, 'I have given no due cause to give

up my constitutional rights.  You can wand me,' " and they said, 'No, you

have to do this,' " she said.

Hirschkind agreed to the pat down, but on one condition.

" I told them, 'No, I'm not going to have my breasts felt,' and she

said, 'Yes, you are,' " said Hirschkind.

When Hirschkind refused, she says that  " the police actually pushed me to

the floor, (and) handcuffed me.  I was crying by then.  They drug

me 25 yards across the floor in front of the whole security. "

An ABIA spokesman says it is TSA policy that anyone activating a security

alarm has two options.  One is to opt out and not fly, and the other

option is to subject themselves to an enhanced pat down.  Hirschkind

refused both and was arrested.

Other travelers KVUE talked to say they empathize with Hirschkind, but

the law is the law.

" I understand her side of it, and their side as well, but it is for our

protection so I have no problems with it, " said Gwen Washington, who lives in

Killeen.

" It's unfortunate that that happened and she didn't get to fly home, but it

makes me feel a little safer, " said Protine.  

The TSA did release a statement Wednesday that said in part, " Our

officers are trained to treat all passengers with dignity and respect. Security

is not optional. "  

The TSA says less than three percent of travelers get a

pat-down

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...