Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Re: It's good to think - but not too much, scientists ...

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

I can see that. Most characters across the genres carry a good bit about the author in them, though that can also reflect their mood at the time of writing as well as themselves.

Perhaps for the majority of people however for songwriters, playwrights, novelists, et al, thinking a lot about one's own thoughts is very good. It allows the creative individual a place to replay what they've written and to improve on it. The most successful arts industry people are the ones who think a lot about their own thoughts and then present those thoughts to the world at large.

RavenCo-Administrator

Posted

I can see that. Most characters across the genres carry a good bit about the author in them, though that can also reflect their mood at the time of writing as well as themselves.

Perhaps for the majority of people however for songwriters, playwrights, novelists, et al, thinking a lot about one's own thoughts is very good. It allows the creative individual a place to replay what they've written and to improve on it. The most successful arts industry people are the ones who think a lot about their own thoughts and then present those thoughts to the world at large.

RavenCo-Administrator

Posted

I agree. When I was in high school, many times I heard people saying they were glad to be out of class and have some time off so they wouldn't have to think. Never understood that.

I do not have to think very hard to agree with you, . :P

Posted

I agree. When I was in high school, many times I heard people saying they were glad to be out of class and have some time off so they wouldn't have to think. Never understood that.

I do not have to think very hard to agree with you, . :P

Posted

When I first went to college I met nothing but the knuckleheads and left after two semesters. Later I went back and was more able to pick out the serious students and even if I didn't befriend them, I could sit near them in class and that made it easier to get through.

I really think that college should only be for the top performers from high school, say the top 10% more or less. Anyone else who wants to go to college will have to wait until they are at least 22. On the one hand this would make those serious about their educations work harder for it not only to make that top 10% but also high up in that ranking to get the better colleges and scholarships. This should make college a more serious place. Other students would have 4 years of the real world to figure out that flipping burgers or whatever isn't so great and would be more serious when they went to college.

There could be exemptions to the rule though. A college prep school could have a higher percentage or graduates allowed into college, subject to an annual review of their graduates in college: lots of drop outs or low grades could get their prep status revoked. ROTC and like programs would allow college admission, provided grades were kept up and there were no discipline problems.

Reform isn't likely to happen, however, because the colleges today are big business and get too much federal money. The more students, the more money, never mind if 50% of freshmen never graduate, they get the money and crowds in the stands at the football games that make the alumni shell out more cash.

In a message dated 9/19/2010 7:37:15 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, no_reply writes:

I also found it refreshing to leave behind the high schoolers who were only interested in goofing off. Once I made it to grad school, it was refreshing to leave behind the undergraduates who were only interested in goofing off. Administrator

Posted

Too much information and too many options can do that. This would be less of a problem if the schools taught child how to think and process information rather than just babysit them and fill them with fluff as happens all too often, especially in the US.

Hi;

yes, I DO agree that most people don't think enough....

But some times personally I get into a sort of analysis paralysis

or over think some things.

rl

Posted

Re:

....  if the schools taught child how to think and process information ...And what, exactly, would motivate the teachers/administrators to want *that*? The children might question things that the teachers/administrators (and those who pay their salaries) don't *want* questioned ...

Kate Gladstone 

Posted

Particularly because they might realize they aren't being prepared for the real world, given few if any marketable skills. That should make them VERY angry.

Of course, the new education boss has a plan. He's going to teach all the kids to be good "environmental citizens of the world" and prepare them for the green jobs "needed" to fix the world. How about training them so they could get just about any job they wanted how preparing them for life?

http://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/75711

PS: This is right on schedule according to the Treaty of Rio Bush Senior locked us into.

And what, exactly, would motivate the teachers/administrators to want *that*? The children might question things that the teachers/administrators (and those who pay their salaries) don't *want* questioned ...

Kate Gladstone

Posted

Particularly because they might realize they aren't being prepared for the real world, given few if any marketable skills. That should make them VERY angry.

Of course, the new education boss has a plan. He's going to teach all the kids to be good "environmental citizens of the world" and prepare them for the green jobs "needed" to fix the world. How about training them so they could get just about any job they wanted how preparing them for life?

http://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/75711

PS: This is right on schedule according to the Treaty of Rio Bush Senior locked us into.

And what, exactly, would motivate the teachers/administrators to want *that*? The children might question things that the teachers/administrators (and those who pay their salaries) don't *want* questioned ...

Kate Gladstone

Posted

Re:

> The question is, who is going to teach it to them? It would have to be the

>parents, I should think, since they are not under the direct influence of

>government.

A lot of parents are just as fiercely " into " controlling the children

(and preventing them from thinking) as any government you could name.

Kate Gladstone

    http://www.Handwritin

Posted

Re:

> The question is, who is going to teach it to them? It would have to be the

>parents, I should think, since they are not under the direct influence of

>government.

A lot of parents are just as fiercely " into " controlling the children

(and preventing them from thinking) as any government you could name.

Kate Gladstone

    http://www.Handwritin

Posted

A lot of parents are just as fiercely " into " controlling the children

(and preventing them from thinking) as any government you could name.

Kate Gladstone

Posted

I'll agree with that and many more can't be bothered to teach the kids anything expecting the schools to do all of that, too.

I know there are several programs out there on the market that could work, if they could be introduced to the schools and teachers willing to learn to teach them and do so. What I think would work best would be one of the programs that teaches reading at a higher level than where most schools stop. Mostly kids are taught to recognize words, maybe know what they mean and maybe make sense of simple sentences. This is about 4th grade level reading and is just sufficient for basic literacy. There is a program I took that doesn't so much teach speed reading as it teaches how to get more out of what you do read in terms of memory, comprehension, processing and analyzing what you read. Something like that would be a great help, along with books that the kids would actually be interested in reading. If they learned to like to read and to do it more effectively, they would read more and be able to understand what they are reading better because they would know how to associate it with other knowledge they possess.

Of course, it would still help if the rest of their course material was real material and not a bunch of nonsense as well.

A lot of parents are just as fiercely "into" controlling the children(and preventing them from thinking) as any government you could name.Kate Gladstone

Posted

All through school and even in college we would take aptitude tests. They seemed to be reasonably accurate. However, these were just choices, and there were many, not codified paths. That will probably come later at some point. Right now they are still shifting toward more mush and propaganda about the environment than a real education that might allow one of those kids to discover a real breakthrough one day.

It really galls me that those in power now want to de-develop the West. Development has caused some problems, but on the other hand, it has given us the economic resources to even consider "green technology." Underdeveloped countries don't have those resources and it is why the local environment is getting worse in so many places, such as burning down jungle and ploughing up savannah for crop land. Those nations haven't passed through the developmental cycle yet that causes populations to stabilize. They are stuck where the West was about 150 years ago, when technology allowed more food to be grown and between that and medicine, more people lived to adulthood. In time we moved to the next stage which was when new births declined overall to more closely match deaths and the population growth dramatically slowed. In fact, the US population growth would be near negative if not for all the immigration legal and otherwise. Also, giving those nations money, which is also part of the de-development scheme, won't help them a bit.

Anyway, my point is that destroying the economy of the west won't help the environment in the long run. It will simply strip away the surplus resources that could have been used to intelligently address the problems at hand. Make the people poor and they aren't going to give a rip about the environment because they'll be too busy just trying to stay alive. For that matter, it would probably also result in more children being born because poorer people tend to have more kids.

Its just completely backwards, unless the goal is to break everyone down and control them liked chipped cattle.

In a message dated 9/24/2010 4:11:00 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, no_reply writes:

It does seem like everyone is being made to march in line. In the Soviet era, kids where simply TOLD what they were going to be when they grew up and were given instruction throughout their childhoods to help them reach the goal set for them. I wonder how far removed we are from that.Administrator

Posted

Virginia has the "Standards of Excellence" or something like that. It is a set of standards that all schools must teach to and tests determine if a school stays accredited or not. I looked over those standards for Second Grade back when my mother was a teacher and they looked alright for that age group. Never saw what the higher grades looked like though.

Still, I don't think it would be too hard to add in advanced reading courses as well. Maybe not for all students, but certainly for the college bound ones. I also don't think it would be too bad to allow something like a GED quick course for some students which would be combined with a shop type course that would allow earlier graduation aimed at putting out qualified workers, ones who might not get the college prep degree, but they would still be taught to read above bare literacy, know some real history and have an understand of economics and personal finance.

In a message dated 9/24/2010 4:08:39 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, no_reply writes:

You're right. What is taught in elementary schools and secondary schools is largely determined by local, state, and federal governments with community input providing a percentage of the input.

Posted

Virginia has the "Standards of Excellence" or something like that. It is a set of standards that all schools must teach to and tests determine if a school stays accredited or not. I looked over those standards for Second Grade back when my mother was a teacher and they looked alright for that age group. Never saw what the higher grades looked like though.

Still, I don't think it would be too hard to add in advanced reading courses as well. Maybe not for all students, but certainly for the college bound ones. I also don't think it would be too bad to allow something like a GED quick course for some students which would be combined with a shop type course that would allow earlier graduation aimed at putting out qualified workers, ones who might not get the college prep degree, but they would still be taught to read above bare literacy, know some real history and have an understand of economics and personal finance.

In a message dated 9/24/2010 4:08:39 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, no_reply writes:

You're right. What is taught in elementary schools and secondary schools is largely determined by local, state, and federal governments with community input providing a percentage of the input.

Posted

I've read that one of the reasons many boys lose interest in reading because of the required reading selections. Most of them appeal more toward girls, stories about relationships and that kind of thing, where boys prefer stories about sports, heroes, etc. (I know that is a generalized statement about boys and girls, but in general it holds true.) Since boys aren't interested in those kinds of stories but are forced to read them anyway, they come to dislike reading. probably came to like reading again because he could choose his own kind of material.

I know that in lower schools a standardized reading list is needed to allow for testing. However, there should be a balance of material that appeals to boy and girls, not heavily slanted toward one or the other.

On a related note: loved to read through about 4th grade....Hated it through the remainder of his school career, and as many of you know repeated 12th grade. Halfway through his baccalaureate program, his love for reading miraculously returned, and now, in his graduate program (Teaching English for middle and high school students) he reads not only as required, but also for fun. What does that say about our system? Louise

Posted

Never read that one. On the other hand, I had to read some books in college that were miserable. Rarely have I been "beaten" by a book, meaning I couldn't finish it, but several assigned books I just couldn't manage.

In a message dated 9/28/2010 1:40:29 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time, no_reply writes:

In college, I think the novel I hated the most was "Wuthering Heights."By about a quarter of the way through the novel, I was hoping all the characters would get shot and the rest of the novel would be a bunch of blank pages. Didn't happen though.Administrator

Posted

Never read that one. On the other hand, I had to read some books in college that were miserable. Rarely have I been "beaten" by a book, meaning I couldn't finish it, but several assigned books I just couldn't manage.

In a message dated 9/28/2010 1:40:29 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time, no_reply writes:

In college, I think the novel I hated the most was "Wuthering Heights."By about a quarter of the way through the novel, I was hoping all the characters would get shot and the rest of the novel would be a bunch of blank pages. Didn't happen though.Administrator

Posted

Most of the ones for English classes were OK. Particularly the SciFi and Fantasy survey classes I took. The ones that were the bad were in the social sciences classes.

In a message dated 9/28/2010 5:13:24 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, no_reply writes:

Every book I was assigned, I read. But then I kind of had to, because I was an English major. The one book I have never been able to finish which I purchased outside of college is the Arabian Nights. I think the reason is because I find it useless to read a series of stories which have no end to them. Administrator

Posted

yes, I agree most genres do carry a good bit about the author in them, and would add also they may carry a reflection of the life/times and morals the author lived in; example, authors such as Helen MacInnes, who wrote during and after WW II, wrote main characters who were generally moral, believing in "God, The Queen, and Country," the 'villains' were amoral or immoral in contrast.rl 'My cat Rusty is a servant of the Living God....'adapted from a poem by SmartTo: FAMSecretSociety Sent: Sun, September 19, 2010 1:45:12 PMSubject: Re: Re: It's good to think - but not too much, scientists ...

I can see that. Most characters across the genres carry a good bit about the author in them, though that can also reflect their mood at the time of writing as well as themselves.

Perhaps for the majority of people however for songwriters, playwrights, novelists, et al, thinking a lot about one's own thoughts is very good. It allows the creative individual a place to replay what they've written and to improve on it. The most successful arts industry people are the ones who think a lot about their own thoughts and then present those thoughts to the world at large.

RavenCo-Administrator

Posted

As an adult, I realize I need time to be on my own, so I don't have to "think others thoughts" in the sense of having to listen to and maybe respond to chit chat OR even other input,.....BUT this is not my needing time to not think, I just need lots of time to "think my own thoughts" which could include reading, watching some TV, etc, or walking outside or in a mall etc where I don't have to dialogue, but can just think about what has happened or what I have read or heard.rl 'My cat Rusty is a servant of the Living God....'adapted from a poem by SmartTo: FAMSecretSociety Sent: Sun, September 19, 2010 2:11:09 PMSubject: Re: Re: It's good to think - but not too much, scientists ...

I agree. When I was in high school, many times I heard people saying they were glad to be out of class and have some time off so they wouldn't have to think. Never understood that.

I do not have to think very hard to agree with you, . :P

Posted

I think (and this was confirmed by an elementary school principle some years ago) that cognitive skills were being taught more in a certain era (when my daughter was in elementary school in the early 1990's) than when we (she and I) were in elementary school (back in th 1960's and 70's)Of course this was not factual, just her and my recollection of things.rl 'My cat Rusty is a servant of the Living God....'adapted from a poem by SmartTo: FAMSecretSociety Sent: Fri, September 24, 2010 10:21:45 AMSubject: Re: Re: It's good to think - but not too much, scientists ...

Too much information and too many options can do that. This would be less of a problem if the schools taught child how to think and process information rather than just babysit them and fill them with fluff as happens all too often, especially in the US.

Hi;

yes, I DO agree that most people don't think enough....

But some times personally I get into a sort of analysis paralysis

or over think some things.

rl

Posted

challenging points, Kate; BUT if society really wants to educate children, then the needs; of the teachers and admins are less important than the needs of the children to be taught to think!Cynically I would add: Do parents want their children to be questioning things?? (I wanted my child to question and challenge; my own mom accepted me challenging society's and her ideas, but my dad certainly did not)Is education's purpose to produce little robot children spouting rhetoric or to produce analytical children who challenge and debate and analyze?? (my daughter is a debater and really analytical, don't know if it is due to her formal education or to growing up with a mom who is very analytical, and controversial; her dad is some-what analytical, more towards physical choices that

societal ones, his personality is more conformist) 'My cat Rusty is a servant of the Living God....'adapted from a poem by SmartTo: FAMSecretSociety Sent: Fri, September 24, 2010 10:31:18 AMSubject: Re:

Re: It's good to think - but not too much, scientists ...

Re:

.... if the schools taught child how to think and process information ...And what, exactly, would motivate the teachers/administrators to want *that*? The children might question things that the teachers/administrators (and those who pay their salaries) don't *want* questioned ...

Kate Gladstone

Posted

wrote;'the only option left that I can think of would be for children to take it upon themselves to try to learn how to think for themselves. That's an incredibly difficult proposition, I suppose.'my comments;Difficult but do-able; the child would need to personally see the need to learn to think, probably be a bit different, be un-swayed by cultural 'norms', and maybe be dis-satisfied with life as they know it while growing up, so want to find a different way of dealing with life.Maybe for some people, this leads to being a criminal and or violent, maybe a sociopath, for others of us just to being an intellectual and a non-conformist.rl 'My cat Rusty is a servant of the Living God....'adapted from a poem by SmartFrom: environmental1st2003 <no_reply >To: FAMSecretSociety Sent: Fri, September 24, 2010 2:25:57 PMSubject: Re: It's good to think - but not too much, scientists ...

I said:

"The question is, who is going to teach it to them? It would have to be the parents, I should think, since they are not under the direct influence of government."

Kate replied:

"Alot of parents are just as fiercely "into" controlling the children

(and preventing them from thinking) as any government you could name."

And my answer is that you are correct, of course, in which case the only option left that I can think of would be for children to take it upon themselves to try to learn how to think for themselves. That's an incredibly difficult proposition, I suppose.

Administrator

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...