Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 Hi! I said yesterday that the psychiatrist prescribed Celexa for Liam. I must say that I am so very uneasy with this. I just have something inside me that's screaming no. I am a Christian and have prayed about this, so I'm not sure if God is screaming no. If so, I don't want to push against what I'm supposed to do. Liam's counselor, I believe, does CBT, but the OCD is new. He hasn't seen her since the diagnosis, so I don't think she's worked with him on OCD, AND he always says they just play games. He's been seeing her for 1 1/2 years with no improvement in his behavior, mainly at school. The true OCD presented over this past summer, and the psych said it's between a mild to moderate case. My dilemma is this, do I switch him to a counselor who does ERP and see if that can help him before I give the Celexa? This is what my gut is telling me to do, but then I'm afraid I'll tick off the psychiatrist. I don't want to burn that bridge. One of my deficits from brain surgery is indecision. I know what I WANT to do, but I don't know if it's right, so I really struggle with it. I had to take a Xanax last night to go to sleep because I was so upset about giving him Celexa this morning. I have emailed my counselor to see what she thinks, and I think holding off on the Celexa until I talk to her is what I'm going to do. What do you all think? Also, I gave Liam Trazodone to help with sleep last night. I gave him a very small dose as the dose prescribed is the same dose my mom takes! It didn't seem to help, so maybe he needs a bit more. BUT, he was compulsing with the questions and apologies. I answered for awhile, but then I remembered what someone said about it being hard for us, but we have to not entertain their compulsions. I stopped answering him, he kept asking until he cried while asking. I let it go on for a bit and then said, " Liam, I am no longer talking to you. " He stopped and went to sleep!! So I think this interaction has made me think more about finding a therapist to do ERP with him before starting the new medication. The psychiatrist hasn't even mentioned ERP. I just don't know! Steffanie Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 Hi Steffanie, The ERP is very powerful, when they can do it. It is considered the front line treatment for OCD. So, if your son's OCD is mild/moderate it might very well be best to try it first and see. Can you not keep the prescription as a back up? The psychiatrist may very well know that ERP is what is needed too. The medication is intended to assist in doing the ERP, by lowering the intensity of the OCD, and the anxiety, and any depression. The medication alone rarely stops the OCD. So, I would just have this conversation with the psychiatrist and see their thoughts on it all. You can refer to the ocfoundation website to verify treatment, as back up. It's good to be open with the doctors you need to work with. Warmly, BArb > > > Hi! I said yesterday that the psychiatrist prescribed Celexa for Liam. I must say that I am so very uneasy with this. I just have something inside me that's screaming no. I am a Christian and have prayed about this, so I'm not sure if God is screaming no. If so, I don't want to push against what I'm supposed to do. Liam's counselor, I believe, does CBT, but the OCD is new. He hasn't seen her since the diagnosis, so I don't think she's worked with him on OCD, AND he always says they just play games. He's been seeing her for 1 1/2 years with no improvement in his behavior, mainly at school. The true OCD presented over this past summer, and the psych said it's between a mild to moderate case. My dilemma is this, do I switch him to a counselor who does ERP and see if that can help him before I give the Celexa? This is what my gut is telling me to do, but then I'm afraid I'll tick off the psychiatrist. I don't want to burn that bridge. One of my deficits from brain surgery is indecision. I know what I WANT to do, but I don't know if it's right, so I really struggle with it. I had to take a Xanax last night to go to sleep because I was so upset about giving him Celexa this morning. I have emailed my counselor to see what she thinks, and I think holding off on the Celexa until I talk to her is what I'm going to do. What do you all think? > > Also, I gave Liam Trazodone to help with sleep last night. I gave him a very small dose as the dose prescribed is the same dose my mom takes! It didn't seem to help, so maybe he needs a bit more. BUT, he was compulsing with the questions and apologies. I answered for awhile, but then I remembered what someone said about it being hard for us, but we have to not entertain their compulsions. I stopped answering him, he kept asking until he cried while asking. I let it go on for a bit and then said, " Liam, I am no longer talking to you. " He stopped and went to sleep!! So I think this interaction has made me think more about finding a therapist to do ERP with him before starting the new medication. The psychiatrist hasn't even mentioned ERP. I just don't know! > > Steffanie > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 Thank you, Barb. I needed to hear that. This is what I know in my heart. I was just so discouraged that the therapy so far hasn't helped. I like his therapist, and he said he'd miss her if he left, but I really think getting him in the right type of therapy might be a benefit. He sees his counselor tomorrow. My husband is going to take him, and I'm going to have him ask her if she does ERP, and if so if she'll start using it. I'm also taking him to my counselor on Monday for additional assessment. Seeing how my ignoring his talking last night eventually stopped it has given me hope. I do have the prescription, and I want to talk to my counselor. If she thinks this is an option, I will call and talk to the psychiatrist's nurse. I have had such a horrible experience with a psychiatrist and with doctors in my brain cancer journey, that I sort of fear speaking up to a doctor. I have done it for my own health, so I need to do what I think is right for my son. It's just so hard! Steffanie To: From: barbnesrallah@... Date: Wed, 8 Sep 2010 13:13:52 +0000 Subject: Re: Confused and unsure Hi Steffanie, The ERP is very powerful, when they can do it. It is considered the front line treatment for OCD. So, if your son's OCD is mild/moderate it might very well be best to try it first and see. Can you not keep the prescription as a back up? The psychiatrist may very well know that ERP is what is needed too. The medication is intended to assist in doing the ERP, by lowering the intensity of the OCD, and the anxiety, and any depression. The medication alone rarely stops the OCD. So, I would just have this conversation with the psychiatrist and see their thoughts on it all. You can refer to the ocfoundation website to verify treatment, as back up. It's good to be open with the doctors you need to work with. Warmly, BArb > > > Hi! I said yesterday that the psychiatrist prescribed Celexa for Liam. I must say that I am so very uneasy with this. I just have something inside me that's screaming no. I am a Christian and have prayed about this, so I'm not sure if God is screaming no. If so, I don't want to push against what I'm supposed to do. Liam's counselor, I believe, does CBT, but the OCD is new. He hasn't seen her since the diagnosis, so I don't think she's worked with him on OCD, AND he always says they just play games. He's been seeing her for 1 1/2 years with no improvement in his behavior, mainly at school. The true OCD presented over this past summer, and the psych said it's between a mild to moderate case. My dilemma is this, do I switch him to a counselor who does ERP and see if that can help him before I give the Celexa? This is what my gut is telling me to do, but then I'm afraid I'll tick off the psychiatrist. I don't want to burn that bridge. One of my deficits from brain surgery is indecision. I know what I WANT to do, but I don't know if it's right, so I really struggle with it. I had to take a Xanax last night to go to sleep because I was so upset about giving him Celexa this morning. I have emailed my counselor to see what she thinks, and I think holding off on the Celexa until I talk to her is what I'm going to do. What do you all think? > > Also, I gave Liam Trazodone to help with sleep last night. I gave him a very small dose as the dose prescribed is the same dose my mom takes! It didn't seem to help, so maybe he needs a bit more. BUT, he was compulsing with the questions and apologies. I answered for awhile, but then I remembered what someone said about it being hard for us, but we have to not entertain their compulsions. I stopped answering him, he kept asking until he cried while asking. I let it go on for a bit and then said, " Liam, I am no longer talking to you. " He stopped and went to sleep!! So I think this interaction has made me think more about finding a therapist to do ERP with him before starting the new medication. The psychiatrist hasn't even mentioned ERP. I just don't know! > > Steffanie > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 Okay, I'm going to have my husband do some investigating tomorrow night when he takes Liam to his appt. I am working with my counselor on this too. She is going to teach me, and if Liam's counselor doesn't do this, I will switch him. He got through my not answering him last night. When I took him to school today, I did the dropoff lane instead of walking him up. He normally comes after me 3-5 times. I told him he could not when I dropped him off as other cars are waiting behind me. He came back once. There was a day last week where he forgot a book at home. He cannot use the book at school, but he felt he HAD to have it. He called my cell from the office crying. I did not call back or take the book to him. My counselor said that though as parents we feel we need to fix these things, I did the right thing for his OCD. I felt good about that! She said that his coming back to the car once today is improvement and will continue to get better. Feeling like maybe we can get through to him. Hoping the Celexa helps with school. On a really positive note, we got a note in the mail today from the school, signed by the teachers saying they're praying for our family. What a pleasant change from the public school. Steffanie To: From: BJClosner@... Date: Wed, 8 Sep 2010 18:29:48 +0000 Subject: Re: Confused and unsure Hi, Steffanie. You mentioned the therapist does CBT, but you didn't mention if she does ERP. Many therapists use CBT, but it can be used for different things, so they must know how to use it specifically for OCD, using ERP (exposure and response prevention). When they do ERP, the one with OCD has to be mentally ready to take it on. If you force it on them, you can expect meltdowns. So, if he is not ready to take on the " questioning " he is doing, it could cause the crying and meltdowns you saw. That might be too much for him to cope with right now. Trazadone is an older antidepressant. I would ask the doctor if is takes time to work when used as sleep aid. Have you tried Children's Benadryl (for some can have the opposite affect though), or Melatonin? Many in here have used them, and they work immediately. Has the diagnosing doctor mentioned if Liam's OCD is mild, moderate, or severe? I agree with Barb, if it is mild or moderate you could try the therapy first, alone. But, if it's severe, like our son's was, you probably will need the medication to bring down the anxiety to help assist with the therapy. Because exposure therapy has them confronting the OCD, which can cause the anxiety to flare at first. The short explanation of what ERP is, . . .They don't do what OCD wants. BUT, they have to be willing to take it on, or it can cause trauma. They typically make what is called a hierarchy list, listing their Obsessions and Compulsions, then rating them from least bothersome, to worst. They take on the least bothersome ones, working their way up to the hardest ones, gaining confidence needed to take on the tougher stuff. For our son, his easiest to conquer was the " just right " OCD, hardest was contamination stuff. An example of how it works. . .One OC our son had was shutting drawers all over the house, then running his hands down them to double check them to make sure they were shut. He was constantly doing it. His homework, with his agreement, was to leave drawers ajar, all over the house, and not shut them. At first, it really bothered him. Heck, I was shutting the drawers without thinking and would have to open them back up. lol When that didn't desensitize him enough, he was instructed to open one drawer on his dresser, leaving the rest shut, and watch it for 15 minutes. He did that every day. Eventually, his OCD over it, lessened, and the OC went away. To this day, it doesn't bother him anymore. But, he does sometimes catch himself straightening something up, or lining it up the way OCD wants. When he worked on that particular OCD, he had to purposely put thing in an angle OCD did NOT want. So, if he catches himself doing it now, he immediately messes it back up and walks away. It causes him some uncomfortable feelings, but when doing ERP, they diminish with time and the OCD loses it's power. He also worked on asking questions. For him, he had agreed to try to stop, which is very important. His OCD had him asking questions nonstop through movies. . Having to know what certain words meant, or EXACTLY what was going on. He couldn't wait to try to figure it out. So, he agreed to stop asking, and we agreed to answer him (if he did ask) with, " I can't say " . He groaned out loud at times because of the way it made him feel, but eventually he acclimated, the OCD diminished, and it stopped. I'm not suggesting you do this to Liam, because he's not on board with that happening, and it will cause him a lot of distress. But, getting him into someone who does ERP is VERY important to his getting better. A therapist who understands OCD and uses ERP can be hard to find, but worth the effort. Many doctors don't know about ERP. That might be why your psychiatrist didn't mention it. Unfortunately, most do not understand OCD well, so typically prescribe pills. And in many cases they are needed, but most don't know about the correct therapy. They just tell you to go to a therapist, and expect the therapist to understand the treatment. But, there are also many therapists who don't know about, or understand ERP either. If it were me, Steffanie, and I felt that strongly about the medication (and believe me I did when our son first started it, but we didn't know about ERP back then either), AND depending on how severe you think Liam's OCD is. . . .I would talk to the psychiatrist and explain you want to try therapy without the medication first, but explain you will try it if the therapy is too hard without it. I would think they would respect that. Keep in mind that most psychiatrists prescribe meds. They can also diagnose, but then usually prescribe meds. So, if you go to one, they will most likely give you medication. There are a few who actually do therapy too, but that is not typical. If you haven't had a chance to read anything about ERP works, I would recommend a book called Talking Back to OCD, by March. It is actually a workbook that walks you through ERP, but does a really good job of explaining how it works too. Hugs, BJ PS~ Also a Christian here. ) Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 BJ, you asked how the doc classified Liam's OCD. He said it was between a mild to moderate case. Steffanie To: From: BJClosner@... Date: Wed, 8 Sep 2010 18:29:48 +0000 Subject: Re: Confused and unsure Hi, Steffanie. You mentioned the therapist does CBT, but you didn't mention if she does ERP. Many therapists use CBT, but it can be used for different things, so they must know how to use it specifically for OCD, using ERP (exposure and response prevention). When they do ERP, the one with OCD has to be mentally ready to take it on. If you force it on them, you can expect meltdowns. So, if he is not ready to take on the " questioning " he is doing, it could cause the crying and meltdowns you saw. That might be too much for him to cope with right now. Trazadone is an older antidepressant. I would ask the doctor if is takes time to work when used as sleep aid. Have you tried Children's Benadryl (for some can have the opposite affect though), or Melatonin? Many in here have used them, and they work immediately. Has the diagnosing doctor mentioned if Liam's OCD is mild, moderate, or severe? I agree with Barb, if it is mild or moderate you could try the therapy first, alone. But, if it's severe, like our son's was, you probably will need the medication to bring down the anxiety to help assist with the therapy. Because exposure therapy has them confronting the OCD, which can cause the anxiety to flare at first. The short explanation of what ERP is, . . .They don't do what OCD wants. BUT, they have to be willing to take it on, or it can cause trauma. They typically make what is called a hierarchy list, listing their Obsessions and Compulsions, then rating them from least bothersome, to worst. They take on the least bothersome ones, working their way up to the hardest ones, gaining confidence needed to take on the tougher stuff. For our son, his easiest to conquer was the " just right " OCD, hardest was contamination stuff. An example of how it works. . .One OC our son had was shutting drawers all over the house, then running his hands down them to double check them to make sure they were shut. He was constantly doing it. His homework, with his agreement, was to leave drawers ajar, all over the house, and not shut them. At first, it really bothered him. Heck, I was shutting the drawers without thinking and would have to open them back up. lol When that didn't desensitize him enough, he was instructed to open one drawer on his dresser, leaving the rest shut, and watch it for 15 minutes. He did that every day. Eventually, his OCD over it, lessened, and the OC went away. To this day, it doesn't bother him anymore. But, he does sometimes catch himself straightening something up, or lining it up the way OCD wants. When he worked on that particular OCD, he had to purposely put thing in an angle OCD did NOT want. So, if he catches himself doing it now, he immediately messes it back up and walks away. It causes him some uncomfortable feelings, but when doing ERP, they diminish with time and the OCD loses it's power. He also worked on asking questions. For him, he had agreed to try to stop, which is very important. His OCD had him asking questions nonstop through movies. . Having to know what certain words meant, or EXACTLY what was going on. He couldn't wait to try to figure it out. So, he agreed to stop asking, and we agreed to answer him (if he did ask) with, " I can't say " . He groaned out loud at times because of the way it made him feel, but eventually he acclimated, the OCD diminished, and it stopped. I'm not suggesting you do this to Liam, because he's not on board with that happening, and it will cause him a lot of distress. But, getting him into someone who does ERP is VERY important to his getting better. A therapist who understands OCD and uses ERP can be hard to find, but worth the effort. Many doctors don't know about ERP. That might be why your psychiatrist didn't mention it. Unfortunately, most do not understand OCD well, so typically prescribe pills. And in many cases they are needed, but most don't know about the correct therapy. They just tell you to go to a therapist, and expect the therapist to understand the treatment. But, there are also many therapists who don't know about, or understand ERP either. If it were me, Steffanie, and I felt that strongly about the medication (and believe me I did when our son first started it, but we didn't know about ERP back then either), AND depending on how severe you think Liam's OCD is. . . .I would talk to the psychiatrist and explain you want to try therapy without the medication first, but explain you will try it if the therapy is too hard without it. I would think they would respect that. Keep in mind that most psychiatrists prescribe meds. They can also diagnose, but then usually prescribe meds. So, if you go to one, they will most likely give you medication. There are a few who actually do therapy too, but that is not typical. If you haven't had a chance to read anything about ERP works, I would recommend a book called Talking Back to OCD, by March. It is actually a workbook that walks you through ERP, but does a really good job of explaining how it works too. Hugs, BJ PS~ Also a Christian here. ) Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 Steffanie, The part about coming back to you at drop-off reminds me SO much of Sam in the morning. I drop him off at my mom's house because she brings him to school for me as his school is twenty minutes the opposite direction from mine. When we get to her house he says, " Mom, will you wait to make sure the door is unlocked? " And I am supposed to say, " Yes Sam, I will wait to make sure the door is unlocked " in exactly this specific tone of voice. If I don't he will repeat the question again and begin to get agitated, because of course I am often rushing and say, " yup " or " sure " or try nodding my head. The door is ALWAYS unlocked because my mom is ALWAYS up and expecting us. He has never been locked out of her house. The key to her house is in her mailbox, and HALF THE TOWN knows it! But he will come back to me repeatedly for reassurance if I don't say it " just right " ... Since school had been out until last week I had totally forgotten about this ritual, but it sure came back FULL FORCE last week! My teaching partner had written a " social script " for Sam to read in the car to try to ease his anxiety (before we knew he had OCD) last spring. He would read it to know what to expect, with examples of all the possible things I might say if I didn't say it " just right " so he would know that it would still be OK. It helped a bit, but boy has it been BAD lately... AND he knows I ALWAYS get out of the car, to come around and give him a kiss, and then as I get back in I watch to make sure he has gotten into the mud room okay. He KNOWS I will wait! BUT HE STILL HAS TO ASK!!!!!!!!!!!!! Heidi > > > Okay, I'm going to have my husband do some investigating tomorrow night when he takes Liam to his appt. I am working with my counselor on this too. She is going to teach me, and if Liam's counselor doesn't do this, I will switch him. He got through my not answering him last night. When I took him to school today, I did the dropoff lane instead of walking him up. He normally comes after me 3-5 times. I told him he could not when I dropped him off as other cars are waiting behind me. He came back once. There was a day last week where he forgot a book at home. He cannot use the book at school, but he felt he HAD to have it. He called my cell from the office crying. I did not call back or take the book to him. My counselor said that though as parents we feel we need to fix these things, I did the right thing for his OCD. I felt good about that! She said that his coming back to the car once today is improvement and will continue to get better. Feeling like maybe we can get through to him. Hoping the Celexa helps with school. > > On a really positive note, we got a note in the mail today from the school, signed by the teachers saying they're praying for our family. What a pleasant change from the public school. > > Steffanie > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 8, 2010 Report Posted September 8, 2010 Oh dear, these poor kids all operate alike! I told Liam that I am going to drop him off from now on instead of walking him up. I told him it might be harder but it's better for him. Steffanie To: From: hdvoigt@... Date: Thu, 9 Sep 2010 00:38:01 +0000 Subject: Re: Confused and unsure Steffanie, The part about coming back to you at drop-off reminds me SO much of Sam in the morning. I drop him off at my mom's house because she brings him to school for me as his school is twenty minutes the opposite direction from mine. When we get to her house he says, " Mom, will you wait to make sure the door is unlocked? " And I am supposed to say, " Yes Sam, I will wait to make sure the door is unlocked " in exactly this specific tone of voice. If I don't he will repeat the question again and begin to get agitated, because of course I am often rushing and say, " yup " or " sure " or try nodding my head. The door is ALWAYS unlocked because my mom is ALWAYS up and expecting us. He has never been locked out of her house. The key to her house is in her mailbox, and HALF THE TOWN knows it! But he will come back to me repeatedly for reassurance if I don't say it " just right " ... Since school had been out until last week I had totally forgotten about this ritual, but it sure came back FULL FORCE last week! My teaching partner had written a " social script " for Sam to read in the car to try to ease his anxiety (before we knew he had OCD) last spring. He would read it to know what to expect, with examples of all the possible things I might say if I didn't say it " just right " so he would know that it would still be OK. It helped a bit, but boy has it been BAD lately... AND he knows I ALWAYS get out of the car, to come around and give him a kiss, and then as I get back in I watch to make sure he has gotten into the mud room okay. He KNOWS I will wait! BUT HE STILL HAS TO ASK!!!!!!!!!!!!! Heidi Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.