Guest guest Posted December 28, 2010 Report Posted December 28, 2010 I recently ended a 10 month gig teaching the prenatal breastfeeding class at one of the local hospitals (they're newly certified LCs recently took over teaching the class). In the past 2+ years, I've completely changed my helping approach to starting with laid back breastfeeding, and have seen it do wonders for my clients. When this opportunity came my way, I didn't feel right teaching " positions " . So I didn't. In fact, in my class, I went over how moms might read or see videos about particular breastfeeding positions with lots of rules, and made a point of giving them background about why a more relaxed approach might be better. By the time I was informed that the hospital didn't need my services anymore, I truly *was* ready to stop teaching the class. It had become a moral dilemma for me to prepare those parents in the best way I knew how, knowing that, in the same hospital I was teaching in (and sort of representing, even though I made it clear I was a contracted vendor and not a hospital employee), this approach was not going to be supported. I struggled a lot with doubt about how I should teach the truth as I know it: laid back seems to be the best approach for learning to breastfeed, but don't expect anybody here (meaning the hospital) to know much about it or assist you with it. The hospital LCs know about LB, and they will try it, if the mom asks, or if there's time for it. But, according to them, they get called in by desperate moms who have no clue and want them to " get the baby on the breast NOW! or I'm giving formula " , so they go for a (perceived?) quicker (more familiar) approach--upright, pillow, cross-cradle, shape breast, wait for gape, mom (or LC) latches baby. These LCs don't have a lot of experience, nor have they had good training, because the hospital was without an LC for about a year before they took their exam. I know for me, it was a very conscious decision to step out of my comfort zone and change my approach. It is only after doing it over and over again that I have built the confidence to really believe in it and the experience to know that it helps in any number of circumstances. Long reply...short answer: Go with your gut. If it is telling you that teaching positions is not the way to go, then change the class. I am finding it hard to find supporting materials, especially videos, for this approach. Thankfully, there is more out there, but I wish there was even more. I am waiting with baited breath for Colson's new DVD for mothers! Good luck! Ana Ana Estorino Uribasterra, IBCLC www.lovingstartlactationservices.com > > I teach a breastfeeding basics class for a local parenting business. We use > a powerpoint > format punctuated by lots of " instructor " ad libs etc. It is pretty > comprehensive but not > overwhelming although the length of the class is long. There is a break to > shop (and pee) > in the middle and a little time for questions at the end. But I'm > conflicted recently. I've taken > to heart the info that Colson and Smilie articles/studies bring to light. > I'm not sure we should > be teaching " positioning " as such. Maybe the class should lean more toward > instinctual responses to feeding? That is > what I do when I see a mom privately. Is there a justification in class > work at all? What all > are you including in your class formats? > > -- > Ilene Fabisch, IBCLC/RLC > Brockton, MA > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 28, 2010 Report Posted December 28, 2010 I train CBE, and Lactation Educators, for me I say teach both. I'm not convinced that any 'one' technique is right for every pair. They will all have to identify what works best for them. If you are teaching prenatally, my honest perspective is it is very unlikely that mothers will be able to identify a clear preference. It's very different teaching a class with newborn models, and trying to breastfeed after they have gone 3 days with a lack of sleep, have a sore perineum, and a lovely, wriggly, little new person who also has preferences to consider! The laid back approach certainly has some value. I would hardly dismiss other techniques however. I don't see the laid back approach as very practical when mom and baby are out and about, and that's one of the most common reactions I get from mothers. When I have spoken to mothers re: the various approaches some have loved the laid back approaches, others have not found it beneficial at all. For those who find the laid back techniques work well for them, the 'formal' holding methods are less beneficial, however for mothers who are not finding the laid back techniques beneficial, they prefer the traditional holds. Particularly if there are other factors affecting effective latching. I feel the same way about pillows. No pair 'has' to use a pillow to breastfeed, but if a mother finds that using a pillow is helpful to her I will find a way to help incorporate its use. I always ask, do you prefer support with a pillow, or do you prefer to not use a pillow, what do you feel works best for the 2 of you? I would survey your classes too. Ask them what they are interested in learning about. Would they like to review some of the instinctual infant feeding responses, would they like to learn some suggestions for holds, etc.? > > I teach a breastfeeding basics class for a local parenting business. We use > a powerpoint > format punctuated by lots of " instructor " ad libs etc. It is pretty > comprehensive but not > overwhelming although the length of the class is long. There is a break to > shop (and pee) > in the middle and a little time for questions at the end. But I'm > conflicted recently. I've taken > to heart the info that Colson and Smilie articles/studies bring to light. > I'm not sure we should > be teaching " positioning " as such. Maybe the class should lean more toward > instinctual responses to feeding? That is > what I do when I see a mom privately. Is there a justification in class > work at all? What all > are you including in your class formats? > > -- > Ilene Fabisch, IBCLC/RLC > Brockton, MA > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 IN terms of Ilene's questions about teaching " positioning " --- all I can say is that I saw a dramatic reduction in women calling about nipple pain from the course I taught aat Realbirth after implementing the Glover DVD. And that did not cease with my understanding of leaning back in the support groups I facilitated at Realbirth, nor watching Suzanne Colson's descriptive research on laid back nursing. Essentially, the women in the Glover DVD are just a few degrees away from " laid back " nursing since they are in futons that don't have pillows. The are leaning back a bit and if I were to implement a redo, I'd have they " lay back " a bit more. Something about Glover's DVD seems to click in many parents minds and lead to them adopting whatever portion of it that works for them. I have never seen any other topic or DVD result in such a dramatic reductio in phone calls about pain. Best, sburgernutr@... Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 One more comment. By the time Realbirth had closed, I had mastered the art of teaching every parent the feel of holding the baby comfortably applying the Glover + laid back technique in four different positions. Essentially it was the same basic principals in each position. The point of this was that parents could feel and I could feel their body positions. In each instance, the hand or body position might differ from mother to mother, but they had a feel of what felt good to them before trying it out on a real live baby. The more I work at the Pilates studio (the owner is excellent on body work) the more I appreciate " touch " . Best, sburgernutr@... Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.