Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 If you're referring to milkmakers brand, I actually did a little research with about 15 women who were back at work and pumping. They all noticed an increase in their supply within 5 days--eating 1-2 cookes/day. placebo effect? maybe. or maybe they finally got enough calories during their day. Whatever the reason, the moms didn't care! they saw results. My 2 cents! I haven't tried any of the other brands to comment about them. Beebe, M.Ed., IBCLC Lactation Consultant/Postpartum Doula www.second9months.comBreastfeeding Between the Lines: http://second9months.wordpress.com/--- Subject: lactation cookiesTo: Date: Sunday, December 26, 2010, 4:13 PM I have posted that I have no concern with the general idea of promotion of foods to support lactation. I wonder actually if there are any cultures anywhere that do not have some nutritional accommodation to support milk production. But, I finally read the ingredients on the packages of cookies on the market. Basically, it seems that brewer's yeast, oats and flax are the ingredients credited with increased milk production. Several things trouble me. First--at one cookie per day--I cannot imagine any real results. So, how many are women really eating? Because these cookies are just junk food with a few decent ingredients added in. And they are not even the best sources of these nutrients. Like EFAs--hemp and chia are better sources than flax. And, IMO, real supply issues are often linked to inflammation which is most often linked in the diet to cow milk and gluten. Oats are contaminated with gluten, unless you use gluten-free oats. And of course the cookies use wheat flour anyway. And a lot of sugar. I guess I am really trying to understand how, in a culture where the avg American is already overfed and undernourished, there is a benefit to teaching women that they can eat junk food for "good health". Only the YummmyMummy brand contained ingredients that I think are beneficial. And many of the recipes on the web contain harmful ingredients like agave. I mean if you really thought these foods were beneficial--then why not eat a bowl of oatmeal with freshly ground flax seeds and throw some brewers yeast info a smoothie? Tow, IBCLC, Toulouse, FR Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 That wasn't my point. I don't think most American women are calorie deprived! We do not need extra calories to breastfeed. My point was that these nutrients might be helpful, but why consume them in the context of junk food? Tow, IBCLC, Toulouse, FR > > > Subject: lactation cookies > To: > Date: Sunday, December 26, 2010, 4:13 PM > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Â > > > > > > > > > > I have posted that I have no concern with the general idea of promotion of foods to support lactation. I wonder actually if there are any cultures anywhere that do not have some nutritional accommodation to support milk production. > > > > But, I finally read the ingredients on the packages of cookies on the market. Basically, it seems that brewer's yeast, oats and flax are the ingredients credited with increased milk production. Several things trouble me. First--at one cookie per day--I cannot imagine any real results. So, how many are women really eating? Because these cookies are just junk food with a few decent ingredients added in. And they are not even the best sources of these nutrients. Like EFAs--hemp and chia are better sources than flax. And, IMO, real supply issues are often linked to inflammation which is most often linked in the diet to cow milk and gluten. Oats are contaminated with gluten, unless you use gluten-free oats. And of course the cookies use wheat flour anyway. And a lot of sugar. > > > > I guess I am really trying to understand how, in a culture where the avg American is already overfed and undernourished, there is a benefit to teaching women that they can eat junk food for " good health " . > > > > Only the YummmyMummy brand contained ingredients that I think are beneficial. And many of the recipes on the web contain harmful ingredients like agave. > > > > I mean if you really thought these foods were beneficial--then why not eat a bowl of oatmeal with freshly ground flax seeds and throw some brewers yeast info a smoothie? > > > > Tow, IBCLC, Toulouse, FR > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 I don't consider the ingredients in some cookies to necessarily be junk. just because it's in the form of a cookie. All cookies are not created equally, for sure. I see lots of moms who just plain aren't getting enough to eat. yes, there are plenty of overweight people in this country, but there are also tons of women who are afraid to eat anything. I see them every day. I'm sure it's a regional thing...I certainly agree that moms should focus on eating food that is supporting their bodies but I also think that eating should be fun. Beebe, M.Ed., IBCLC Lactation Consultant/Postpartum Doula www.second9months.comBreastfeeding Between the Lines: http://second9months.wordpress.com/--- Subject: Re: lactation cookiesTo: Date: Monday, December 27, 2010, 8:59 AM That wasn't my point. I don't think most American women are calorie deprived! We do not need extra calories to breastfeed. My point was that these nutrients might be helpful, but why consume them in the context of junk food? Tow, IBCLC, Toulouse, FR > > > Subject: lactation cookies > To: > Date: Sunday, December 26, 2010, 4:13 PM > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Â > > > > > > > > > > I have posted that I have no concern with the general idea of promotion of foods to support lactation. I wonder actually if there are any cultures anywhere that do not have some nutritional accommodation to support milk production. > > > > But, I finally read the ingredients on the packages of cookies on the market. Basically, it seems that brewer's yeast, oats and flax are the ingredients credited with increased milk production. Several things trouble me. First--at one cookie per day--I cannot imagine any real results. So, how many are women really eating? Because these cookies are just junk food with a few decent ingredients added in. And they are not even the best sources of these nutrients. Like EFAs--hemp and chia are better sources than flax. And, IMO, real supply issues are often linked to inflammation which is most often linked in the diet to cow milk and gluten. Oats are contaminated with gluten, unless you use gluten-free oats. And of course the cookies use wheat flour anyway. And a lot of sugar. > > > > I guess I am really trying to understand how, in a culture where the avg American is already overfed and undernourished, there is a benefit to teaching women that they can eat junk food for "good health". > > > > Only the YummmyMummy brand contained ingredients that I think are beneficial. And many of the recipes on the web contain harmful ingredients like agave. > > > > I mean if you really thought these foods were beneficial--then why not eat a bowl of oatmeal with freshly ground flax seeds and throw some brewers yeast info a smoothie? > > > > Tow, IBCLC, Toulouse, FR > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 28, 2010 Report Posted December 28, 2010 I absolutely agree with you--all cookies are not created equal. As I said--one brand looked very nourishing. Milk Makers do not. And of course eating should be fun--healthy food is not boring and un-fun! I am not a fan of this whole trend at all. Maybe you are right about the regional issues--but I counsel women all over the country and I don't think not eating is their biggest problem--being poorly nourished, however, is a huge problem. Tow, IBCLC, Toulouse, FR > > > > > > From: <IParentLLC@> > > > Subject: lactation cookies > > > To: > > > Date: Sunday, December 26, 2010, 4:13 PM > I mean if you really thought these foods were beneficial--then why not eat a bowl of oatmeal with freshly ground flax seeds and throw some brewers yeast info a smoothie? > > > Tow, IBCLC, Toulouse, FR > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 28, 2010 Report Posted December 28, 2010 I agree about the nourishment thing, for sure. But I find when moms are back at work and/or when their babies get a little older and all the help is gone, they have a tough time just getting enough calories. They're too busy trying to "get things done". I would encourage you to ask milkmakers for a sample and to see the nutritional profile. I think you'd be surprised. They taste more like a bowl of oatmeal than a typical store bought cookie.Thanks for your input! Beebe, M.Ed., IBCLC Lactation Consultant/Postpartum Doula www.second9months.comBreastfeeding Between the Lines: http://second9months.wordpress.com/--- Subject: Re: lactation cookiesTo: Date: Monday, December 27, 2010, 4:42 PM I absolutely agree with you--all cookies are not created equal. As I said--one brand looked very nourishing. Milk Makers do not. And of course eating should be fun--healthy food is not boring and un-fun! I am not a fan of this whole trend at all. Maybe you are right about the regional issues--but I counsel women all over the country and I don't think not eating is their biggest problem--being poorly nourished, however, is a huge problem. Tow, IBCLC, Toulouse, FR > > > > > > From: <IParentLLC@> > > > Subject: lactation cookies > > > To: > > > Date: Sunday, December 26, 2010, 4:13 PM > I mean if you really thought these foods were beneficial--then why not eat a bowl of oatmeal with freshly ground flax seeds and throw some brewers yeast info a smoothie? > > > Tow, IBCLC, Toulouse, FR > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 28, 2010 Report Posted December 28, 2010 Dear Colleagues: Anyone can be both overweight AND malnourished. Putting good ingredients along with junky ones in a cooky is better than a cooky that is 100% crap. For some people, the road to good nutrition is gradual and means changing a lifetime of habits and learning to be comfortable with good food. It is not an easy task. There are pitfalls along the way. I started changing my diet in the 1970s. The New York Times Natural Foods Cookbook was my bible. My first step was to make whole wheat bread using lots of different recipes. My grandfather pooh-poohed the concept of 'organic' food, because it was a relatively new phrase and many foods contain carbon, which makes them organic in the chemical sense. I didn't feel better either; nearly 20 years later a homeopath identified my wheat allergy. The road to good nutrition in this country is NOT easy. In Europe, Hershey makes and sells chocolate without genetically modified ingredients. They don't do that in the US. Corporations suck profits out of our health. Good food is more expensive than crap. Eating well is difficult, and worth it, and should be the easiest way to eat. If you are interested in more, read Pollan's Food Rules or The Omnivore's Dilemma. Should be required reading in high school! warmly, Nikki Lee Quote
Guest guest Posted December 28, 2010 Report Posted December 28, 2010 Thank-you for the suggestion, but I looked at the nutritional info on-line and given that I do not eat gluten, I will not be trying a sample! And I don't encourage anyone else to eat gluten, bc I have yet to meet anyone who is not sensitive to it, once they actually pay attention to their bodies. I would love to see them made with almond and coconut flour! Tow, IBCLC, Toulouse, FR > > I agree about the nourishment thing, for sure. Â But I find when moms are back at work and/or when their babies get a little older and all the help is gone, they have a tough time just getting enough calories. Â They're too busy trying to " get things done " . Â > Â I would encourage you to ask milkmakers for a sample and to see the nutritional profile. Â I think you'd be surprised. Â They taste more like a bowl of oatmeal than a typical store bought cookie. > Thanks for your input! > > > > Beebe, M.Ed., IBCLC > Lactation Consultant/Postpartum Doula > > www.second9months.comBreastfeeding Between the Lines: Â http://second9months.wordpress.com/ > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 28, 2010 Report Posted December 28, 2010 Hmmmm. I'll pass that on to . I've been thinking of experimenting with gluten free, but I am such a grain girl. can't imagine. Beebe, M.Ed., IBCLC Lactation Consultant/Postpartum Doula www.second9months.comBreastfeeding Between the Lines: http://second9months.wordpress.com/--- Subject: Re: lactation cookiesTo: Date: Tuesday, December 28, 2010, 1:25 PM Thank-you for the suggestion, but I looked at the nutritional info on-line and given that I do not eat gluten, I will not be trying a sample! And I don't encourage anyone else to eat gluten, bc I have yet to meet anyone who is not sensitive to it, once they actually pay attention to their bodies. I would love to see them made with almond and coconut flour! Tow, IBCLC, Toulouse, FR > > I agree about the nourishment thing, for sure. Â But I find when moms are back at work and/or when their babies get a little older and all the help is gone, they have a tough time just getting enough calories. Â They're too busy trying to "get things done". Â > Â I would encourage you to ask milkmakers for a sample and to see the nutritional profile. Â I think you'd be surprised. Â They taste more like a bowl of oatmeal than a typical store bought cookie. > Thanks for your input! > > > > Beebe, M.Ed., IBCLC > Lactation Consultant/Postpartum Doula > > www.second9months.comBreastfeeding Between the Lines: Â http://second9months.wordpress.com/ > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 29, 2010 Report Posted December 29, 2010 > > Thank-you for the suggestion, but I looked at the nutritional info on-line and given that I do not eat gluten, I will not be trying a sample! And I don't encourage anyone else to eat gluten, bc I have yet to meet anyone who is not sensitive to it, once they actually pay attention to their bodies. I would love to see them made with almond and coconut flour! > > Tow, IBCLC, Toulouse, FR > But for me, because 2 of my 3 children have life threatening nut allergies, I would avoid a cookie made with almond flour while lactating. There is a recipe floating around the Internet called " Queenie's lactation cookies " which is similar to the milk makers cookies. If a mother really wanted a treat, I would recommend this recipe. I really want American mothers to move away from the idea that they need so much stuff to be a good mother. The recommended baby registry lists are several pages long and include all these must have items that are not really must haves. I want to moms to use what they have at home already or make it themselves for a fraction of the ready-made sale price. Buying a cookie falls into this category for me, especially since there are many non-cookies options that we know aid milk production. Carroll, MA, IBCLC Quote
Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 , You speak of the biggest problem of being poorly nourished... I agree with that, but when you are trying to introduce healthy foods to people who have lived on less than healthy foods all their life, it may be too much for them to think of going to a healthfood store to purchase flax seed let alone purchase a grinder to grind fresh flax seed. I enjoyed son's book on Mother Food, and could see the support and health benefits of different foods that she discusses. So, why shouldn't we tell mom's what foods may support nutrition? Sometimes offering them better choices of more nourishing foods and even premade/easy foods will be better than nothing wouldn't they? Dalton Louisiana > > I absolutely agree with you--all cookies are not created equal. As I said--one brand looked very nourishing. Milk Makers do not. And of course eating should be fun--healthy food is not boring and un-fun! I am not a fan of this whole trend at all. Maybe you are right about the regional issues--but I counsel women all over the country and I don't think not eating is their biggest problem--being poorly nourished, however, is a huge problem. > > Tow, IBCLC, Toulouse, FR > > > I mean if you really thought these foods were beneficial--then why not eat a bowl of oatmeal with freshly ground flax seeds and throw some brewers yeast info a smoothie? > > > > > > Tow, IBCLC, Toulouse, FR > > > > > > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.