Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 An increase in blood supply and innervation to the frenum also occurs around a year so besides the greater mobility and less cooperation of an older baby, even, anesthesia could be necessary. However, in the past I've known Dr Corrylos to clip older infants and even a child once but the for the child she used injectable novacaine (or the like). The latter case was an unusual one as child was extremely patient and cooperative and just wanted to speak normally. Barbara Latterner Quote
Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 I have a 4 year old who is going to have his TT released very soon, by one of the local MDs who treats breastfeeding babies. We aren't using anesthesia, but we are using novicaine-type meds and likely tyleonol and ibuprofen.My take on it is that the 'risk' is higher for a newborn and the trauma of being held down for the novicaine and the sting of the needle is the same or worse than the actual clip. My son has a thick band that will probably take more than one snip and I am uncomfortable doing it without meds.I do feel bad for some of the babies who I have seen released. I wish there was a safe way to do it pain-free. Some parents use homeopathics, but it doesn't make it pain or trauma free. Some babies seems to be in more pain than others. HealySeattle, WAForgive my writing or typos...lost the rollerball on my blackberry yesterday and can't go back and edit.Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerrySender: Date: Thu, 30 Dec 2010 07:58:20 -0500To: < >ReplyTo: Subject: Re: Another question about TT I always assumed, in my ignorance, that the need for anesthesia was because toddlers don't like things stuck in their mouths and might BITE the person trying to do the procedure. I have no idea. Would love to know the history on use of anesthesia. My son needed anesthesia twice -- once for adenoids and tonsils the size of golfballs and once for a hernia. His friend needed open heart surgery at age 4. It is not something I would ever put a young child through without good cause.Best regards, E. Burger, MHS, PhD, IBCLC Quote
Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 my ENT uses acupuncture and homeopathics. I have a 4 year old who is going to have his TT released very soon, by one of the local MDs who treats breastfeeding babies. We aren't using anesthesia, but we are using novicaine-type meds and likely tyleonol and ibuprofen. My take on it is that the 'risk' is higher for a newborn and the trauma of being held down for the novicaine and the sting of the needle is the same or worse than the actual clip. My son has a thick band that will probably take more than one snip and I am uncomfortable doing it without meds. I do feel bad for some of the babies who I have seen released. I wish there was a safe way to do it pain-free. Some parents use homeopathics, but it doesn't make it pain or trauma free. Some babies seems to be in more pain than others. HealySeattle, WAForgive my writing or typos...lost the rollerball on my blackberry yesterday and can't go back and edit.Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry Sender: Date: Thu, 30 Dec 2010 07:58:20 -0500To: < >ReplyTo: Subject: Re: Another question about TT I always assumed, in my ignorance, that the need for anesthesia was because toddlers don't like things stuck in their mouths and might BITE the person trying to do the procedure. I have no idea. Would love to know the history on use of anesthesia. My son needed anesthesia twice -- once for adenoids and tonsils the size of golfballs and once for a hernia. His friend needed open heart surgery at age 4. It is not something I would ever put a young child through without good cause. Best regards, E. Burger, MHS, PhD, IBCLC -- ~~~~~~~~~~ Shari Silady ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ " Mothers have as powerful an influence over the welfare of future generations as all other earthly causes combined. " ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Quote
Guest guest Posted December 30, 2010 Report Posted December 30, 2010 not traumatic.. same for any age. They even do them in the NICU here. shariThe sooner the better for releasing the tongue. Just curious to know your thoughts behind the frenectomy being more risky for a newborn. Admittedly I've only watched very straight forward releases - but to my non-medical eye they were very quick, easy, and did not appear at all traumatic. Ellen Ellen J. Rubin, MA, IBCLC, LLLL > > I have a 4 year old who is going to have his TT released very soon, by one of the local MDs who treats breastfeeding babies. We aren't using anesthesia, but we are using novicaine-type meds and likely tyleonol and ibuprofen. > My take on it is that the 'risk' is higher for a newborn and the trauma of being held down for the novicaine and the sting of the needle is the same or worse than the actual clip. My son has a thick band that will probably take more than one snip and I am uncomfortable doing it without meds. > I do feel bad for some of the babies who I have seen released. I wish there was a safe way to do it pain-free. Some parents use homeopathics, but it doesn't make it pain or trauma free. Some babies seems to be in more pain than others. > > Healy > Seattle, WA > Forgive my writing or typos...lost the rollerball on my blackberry yesterday and can't go back and edit. > Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry > > Re: Another question about TT > > I always assumed, in my ignorance, that the need for anesthesia was because toddlers don't like things stuck in their mouths and might BITE the person trying to do the procedure. I have no idea. Would love to know the history on use of anesthesia. My son needed anesthesia twice -- once for adenoids and tonsils the size of golfballs and once for a hernia. His friend needed open heart surgery at age 4. It is not something I would ever put a young child through without good cause. > > Best regards, > E. Burger, MHS, PhD, IBCLC > -- ~~~~~~~~~~ Shari Silady ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ " Mothers have as powerful an influence over the welfare of future generations as all other earthly causes combined. " ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Quote
Guest guest Posted December 31, 2010 Report Posted December 31, 2010 I meant the anesthesia has slightly increased risk for newborns, not the release. Catching up on the conversation after learning to use my new phone... Healy Seattle, WA > Just curious to know your thoughts behind the frenectomy being more risky for a newborn. Admittedly I've only watched very straight forward releases - but to my non-medical eye they were very quick, easy, and did not appear at all traumatic. > > Ellen> > Ellen J. Rubin, MA, IBCLC, LLLL> > > > > >> >> I have a 4 year old who is going to have his TT released very soon, by one of the local MDs who treats breastfeeding babies. We aren't using anesthesia, but we are using novicaine-type meds and likely tyleonol and ibuprofen. >> My take on it is that the 'risk' is higher for a newborn and the trauma of being held down for the novicaine and the sting of the needle is the same or worse than the actual clip. My son has a thick band that will probably take more than one snip and I am uncomfortable doing it without meds. >> I do feel bad for some of the babies who I have seen released. I wish there was a safe way to do it pain-free. Some parents use homeopathics, but it doesn't make it pain or trauma free. Some babies seems to be in more pain than others. >> >> Healy>> Seattle, WA>> Forgive my writing or typos...lost the rollerball on my blackberry yesterday and can't go back and edit.>> Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry >> >> Re: Another question about TT >> >> I always assumed, in my ignorance, that the need for anesthesia was because toddlers don't like things stuck in their mouths and might BITE the person trying to do the procedure. I have no idea. Would love to know the history on use of anesthesia. My son needed anesthesia twice -- once for adenoids and tonsils the size of golfballs and once for a hernia. His friend needed open heart surgery at age 4. It is not something I would ever put a young child through without good cause. >> >> Best regards,>> E. Burger, MHS, PhD, IBCLC>>> > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 1, 2011 Report Posted January 1, 2011 I agree the sooner the better. I think I was unclear because of my broken phone. Bear with me as I figure out how to type on a touch screen... I do think it is *traumatic* for an infant to be taken out of mom's arms, swadled, held down, tongue lifted, and frenulum cut. If there was an effective, non-invasive way to treat, i'd be all for it. I do think the benefit outweighs the trauma, though. Some babies don't seem bothered by it nearly as much as others. Homeopathics can help, and there are other things I will do with my older child, but it's not trauma-free. Another one of my children broke his leg a few years ago. We used a therapeutic story to help him work out the trauma he experienced, as well as Verbal First Aid. I encourage parents to talk to the baby while comforting him/her, babies can feel validated by this even if they don't understand the words exactly. I am interested to hear about experiences with laser treatment. Neither of the local practitioners use the laser. Healy Seattle, WA > not traumatic.. same for any age. They even do them in the NICU here. > shari> The sooner the better for releasing the tongue.> > On Thu, Dec 30, 2010 at 3:14 PM, lllellenrubin wrote:> >>>>>> Just curious to know your thoughts behind the frenectomy being more risky>> for a newborn. Admittedly I've only watched very straight forward releases ->> but to my non-medical eye they were very quick, easy, and did not appear at >> all traumatic.>>>> Ellen>>>> Ellen J. Rubin, MA, IBCLC, LLLL>>>>>> >> >>> > I have a 4 year old who is going to have his TT released very soon, by>> one of the local MDs who treats breastfeeding babies. We aren't using>> anesthesia, but we are using novicaine-type meds and likely tyleonol and >> ibuprofen.>> > My take on it is that the 'risk' is higher for a newborn and the trauma>> of being held down for the novicaine and the sting of the needle is the same>> or worse than the actual clip. My son has a thick band that will probably >> take more than one snip and I am uncomfortable doing it without meds.>> > I do feel bad for some of the babies who I have seen released. I wish>> there was a safe way to do it pain-free. Some parents use homeopathics, but >> it doesn't make it pain or trauma free. Some babies seems to be in more pain>> than others.>> >>> > Healy>> > Seattle, WA>> > Forgive my writing or typos...lost the rollerball on my blackberry >> yesterday and can't go back and edit.>> > Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry>> >>> > Re: Another question about TT >> >>> > I always assumed, in my ignorance, that the need for anesthesia was>> because toddlers don't like things stuck in their mouths and might BITE the>> person trying to do the procedure. I have no idea. Would love to know the >> history on use of anesthesia. My son needed anesthesia twice -- once for>> adenoids and tonsils the size of golfballs and once for a hernia. His friend>> needed open heart surgery at age 4. It is not something I would ever put a >> young child through without good cause.>> >>> > Best regards,>> > E. Burger, MHS, PhD, IBCLC>> >>>>> >>> > > > -- > ~~~~~~~~~~ Shari Silady ~~~~~~~~~~~~~> " Mothers have as powerful an influence over the welfare of> future generations as all other earthly causes combined. " > ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.