Guest guest Posted October 4, 2010 Report Posted October 4, 2010 There has been much hype in the British media in the past few months about mental disorders and pharma-friendly "solutions". Much of this was presenting industry propaganda as settled science.This just in from Barry . is our resident expert on UK law and ethics. He lectures at Leeds Law School and Medical Ethics at the University of Lincolnshire in the UK. Dr Jay ph, our lists expert on genetics is mentioned in this article. writes: Today, Thursday, the media, particularly the BBC carried a lot of exposure for an online study in the Lancet from Cardiff allegedly showing "clear" evidence that ADHD is a genetic disorder. Ian Kendall was available for the BBC in the morning to suggest the picture was a more complicated one of gene-environment interaction. In spite of clear evidence to the contrary the BBC News 24 service continually ran headlines suggesting 'ADHD genetic link found', 'ADHD definitely a brain disorder' 'ADHD a neurodevelopmental disorder' emphasising only one element of the story (the pro disorder lobby) and avoided examining in any detail the alleged data and 'scientific' methodology used in this so called study. Oliver denounced the study, or its presentation, as an "intellectual scam". He emphasised that the control group showed 7% of normals with abnormal copy number variants while the sample had 14% cnv - in other words it showed that in only 10% of children with ADHD are genes implicated. Lefanu, and Kinderman suggested caution, the latter suggesting that he was not sure either that the study helped with stigma. 7.1% of the population has this copy number variant as opposed to the alleged 2% incidence of ADHD in the population. A 7% copy number variant in the population cannot be described as a 'disorder' by any epidemiological standard except in an outbreak of a pathogenic infection and even the most outrageous ADHD lobbyists don't suggest a pathogen as the 'cause'. It leaves the vast majority of those presenting with the cnv as normal, i.e possessing the gene variant but not presenting with any of the so called ADHD 'symptoms' It was heavily promoted as beneficial to families to reduce stigma by giving them a diagnosis. This evening NHS Choices came out with a carefully weighed article entitled "ADHD Genes are only part of the story". It is not clear how much this study is part of an illness-awareness promotion. Some of the participants are eminent. But one of them, deCODE genetics, according to Wikipedia is based in Iceland and filed for bankruptcy in the USA in 2009. The BBC have once again engaged in poor quality reporting on ADHD and have failed to consider that this study has nothing to do with removing stigma and everything to do with promoting the use of powerful and toxic medications to control behaviour simply to enrich the drug companies. If anyone wants to remove the stigma of ADHD then they should stop 'diagnosing' it Vincehttp://www.guardian.co.uk/lifeandstyle/2005/dec/04/healthandwellbeing On the couch Blame games If our genes aren't responsible for the onset of many mental illnesses, what is? Oliver weighs up the evidence - and fingers the culprit Oliver The Observer, Sunday 4 December 2005 Proponents of the genetic view of what makes us different from our siblings had high hopes for the Human Genome Project - it was going to identify the schizophrenia gene, the gay gene and so on. The first disappointment was when the project found far fewer genes than was expected (around 25,000). This led Craig Venter, the leader of much of the research, to conclude that 'the wonderful diversity of the human species is not hard-wired in our genetic code. Our environments are critical'. Undeterred by Venter, the genes were further sifted only to find that single ones for mental illnesses simply do not seem to exist. The fall-back position is that there must be dozens, or even hundreds, of combinations of genes responsible. So far this has not been demonstrated and the basis for claims that mental illness has a genetic cause are studies of identical twins. These have been shown to be highly unreliable (see Jay ph, The Gene Illusion) and indeed, when the molecular geneticists have explored every pathway, it may well turn out twin-study estimates of heritability have been wildly exaggerated. In the case of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) for example, with hindsight, the over-statements may seem unjustified. A recent British Journal of Psychiatrypaper began with the claim that ADHD is a 'highly heritable' disorder. However, it went on to reveal that molecular genetics has signally failed to identify genes which explain it, so their claim that it is '60-90 per cent' heritable relies wholly on twin studies. Indeed, America's prestigious National Institute of Health finds no evidence ADHD is a biological brain disorder. Environmental explanation is to be found in child psychiatrist Sam Timimi's book, Naughty Boys. There are clear links to parental maltreatment (abuse, neglect) but, in addition, environmental biological factors can come into play, like diet or stress. Sons of mothers who are anxious during the third trimester of pregnancy are significantly more likely to have ADHD when followed up at three, five, seven and nine. The anxiety seems to be passed chemically through the placenta to the foetus. Timimi asserts that there is a myth of genetic-neurological causes of ADHD and that the increased tendency to diagnose it in the past decade coincides with the drug companies' desire to promote lucrative amphetamine-based treatments. The geneticneurological argument became common currency when the pharmaceutical companies sought support for physical treatments. While there is no conspiracy, the doctors and researchers are mostly sided with the view of the companies. Readers with sons on ADHD medication may dislike hearing all this. But there is now abundant evidence that the drugs have massive side effects and in many cases are just not needed. Timimi describes how using psychological treatments has meant he hardly ever has to employ them and the scientific case for chemical-free treatment grows stronger by the day. The mental block The excessive boozing of your undergraduate offspring is not associated with low self-esteem (Psychology of Addictive Behaviours). However, it is predicted if your little soak is a narcissist (me, me, me, I have to be the centre of attention, aren't I wonderful). Protectors against gargantuan ingestion of alcohol were doing well academically and believing in God's love - religious students did not get pissed nearly as much. Implication: Have a God-squadding, self-effacing, swot for a student offspring ... Similarity in personality has often been claimed as a good predictor of whether couples will stay together. A new study shows that what matters more is whether your partner's personality fits your ideal of what one should be like, rather than whether they actually resemble you (Journal of Personality and Social Psychology). Forty-nine couples were followed for nine months. At the end, the most harmonious both fitted each other's ideal, more than being really similar types of people. Implication: Meeting your dream man is cool, but being his dream girl as well is coolest. Exposure to male pheromones makes men more likely to feel positively about a product and to regard it as having masculine characteristics (Psychology & Marketing). The same hormones had no effect on women's perceptions. Implication: If you are male and find yourself in a shop with an unaccountable urge to buy a bra for yourself, insist that they switch off the (hormone-packed) air-con. guardian.co.uk © Guardian News and Media Limited 2010 List members noted in Green text. FAIR USE NOTICE: This may contain copyrighted (© ) material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Such material is made available for educational purposes, to advance understanding of human rights, democracy, scientific, moral, ethical, and social justice issues, etc. It is believed that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Title 17 U.S.C. section 107 of the US Copyright Law. This material is distributed without profit. The information herein shall not be considered an endorsement of anyone discontinuing psychiatric drugs. If you are stopping taking medication IT IS ADVISABLE TO REDUCE DOSES GRADUALLY WITH EXTREME CAUTION, as it is difficult to predict who will have problems withdrawing. It is worth getting as much information and support as you can, and involving your doctor wherever possible. You will find withdrawal information here. http://theicarusproject.net/alternative-treatments/harm-reduction-guide-to-coming-off-psychiatric-drugs FOR MORE INFORMATION ON WITHDRAWAL:: Get Lehmann's book, Coming off Psychiatric Drugs: Successful Withdrawal from Neuroleptics, Antidepressants, Lithium, Carbamazepine and Tranquilizers. This valuable resource comes in US, UK, Greek. and German editions. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.