Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Highly toxic rat poisons killing owls, other wildlife

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

Highly toxic rat poisons killing owls, other wildlife

Canadian study indicates potent rodenticide is working its way up the food chain

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/40721227/ns/us_news-environment/

VANCOUVER, British Columbia — With the spooky glow of his headlamp illuminating

an antenna in his hand, Levesque stalks one of Canada's few remaining barn

owls.

" Are you getting anything? " research team leader Sofi Hindmarch asks over a

walkie-talkie.

" I got it! " Levesque responds. Then a few seconds later, dejected, he radios

back: " No. I lost the signal. "

Working in darkness, with the quarter-moon obscured by clouds, these two

scientists are trying to figure out what an elusive, radio-collared owl is

eating along this country road just beyond the suburbs that ring Vancouver.

Their mission is to determine whether the decline of Canada's barn owl is tied,

in part, to super-toxic rat poisons.

Scientists know that at least some owls are dying under gruesome circumstances,

bleeding to death from stomach hemorrhages in an agonizing and days-long

decline. The culprit: An extra-potent class of rat poisons that has flooded the

market in recent decades, designed to more effectively kill rats, a food source

for the owls.

More threatened wildlife Hybrid polar-grizzly bear a sign of Arctic's future?

Poachers kill rare black rhino

PhotoBlog: Saving rare black rhinos in Kenya

Two seal species could get U.S. protection

Scientists aim to map, save endangered habitats

U.S. wants to lift protections for grizzly, wolf

...Six of 164 dead barn owls, barred owls and great horned owls examined in a

2009 western Canada study funded by Environment Canada had rodenticide levels

high enough to kill them outright, causing fatal stomach hemorrhages. Pesticide

readings in 15 percent to 30 percent of the others appeared toxic and seem

likely to handicap owls in a variety of ways, scientists say.

The study is the latest evidence that poses an unsettling question: Are we

willing to poison owls and a variety of other wild animals in order to fight

rats?

advertisement | ad info

Advertisement | ad info

Advertisement | ad info

.. " We're finding this stuff all over the place, " said Elliott, an

Environment Canada scientist who co-authored the owl study published last year.

" There's a lot more rodenticide in the food chain than we would have ever

thought. We're surprised that there's that much of the stuff kicking around. "

Only on msnbc.com South gains eight House seats in Census tally

'Open' Internet just a pipe dream

Fees, fares and the future of air travel

Barbour walks back comments on civil rights era

Report: U.K. greased Lockerbie bomber's release

The seedy reality behind those sexy tweets

Holiday calendar: Celebrate the longest night

...Studies in Canada, the United States and Europe show that this newer

generation of rat poisons is killing a variety of wild animals, including

mountain lions, bobcats, coyotes, foxes, skunks, deer, squirrels, possums and

raccoons, along with bald eagles, golden eagles, owls, hawks and vultures.

Hundreds of wildlife poisoning deaths have been documented. In the United

States, the pesticides have been found in hundreds of animals, according to a

2006 memo by U.S. Environmental Protection Agency biologist Bill kson. Two

years earlier, he documented more than 300 incidents of wild animals suspected

to have been killed by the chemicals.

" Clearly, more information is urgently needed on the potential impacts such

exposure may be having on populations " of raptors and other wild animals,

kson wrote.

Related: How nonprofit journalism is changing the `news ecosystem'

kson's memo was part of a years-long process at EPA that resulted in 2008 in

new rules to better control the rat poisons. Those rules, scheduled to take

effect in June 2011, did not go as far as desired by some wildlife advocates,

including the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.

The chemicals in question are known as anti-coagulants because they prevent an

animal's blood from clotting or coagulating. The first of these, synthesized in

the 1940s, is known as warfarin – the same chemical sold in miniscule

concentrations to people as Coumadin, a prescription blood thinner.

The new strain of rat poisons came along in the 1970s. The reason: Warfarin and

its cousins required the rats to return to feed on the pesticide over the course

of several days. With the newer versions, only a single dose is needed, although

it might take five days or more to do the job. Brand names include Havoc, Talon,

Contrac, Maki, Ratimus and d-CON Mouse Pruf II.

Some animals are ingesting the pesticides by eating poisoned rats as the rats

stagger about, dazed but not yet dead. This goes on for days before the rats

succumb, in the meantime making them easy targets for owls and other predators.

But there's a mysterious wrinkle in this picture. How are plant eaters like deer

and sheep ingesting rat poison? Grain eaters like squirrels? What about hawks

that subsist almost exclusively on songbirds – songbirds that probably aren't

eating rats?

Scientists wonder: Just how far into the food web have these poisons penetrated?

Canada's vanishing barn owls

On a balmy but cloudy night, Hindmarch is trying to capture a barn owl, one of

three owl species that ingested the rat poisons in the 2009 study. The hunt this

night is in a gritty industrial outpost in Vancouver, where rats scamper boldly

between the defunct lumber yard where they live and the bustling grain terminal

where they sneak their dinner.

advertisement | ad info

Advertisement | ad info

Advertisement | ad info

..Between the wail of trains on tracks perhaps 30 yards away, Hindmarch and

Levesque fiddle with their owl traps, preparing for their 9-5 shift – 9 p.m.

until 5 a.m., that is.

" Can you grab one of the girls? " Hindmarch asks Levesque, referring to the mice

that they hope will lure an owl to their traps.

The scientists carefully put the mice inside cages that will protect the mice

when an owl swoops down, attracted by the rodents noisily munching on the

crackers that Hindmarch is unwrapping. Hindmarch, of Simon Fraser University,

doesn't want the mice to be hurt.

" It's working time, " Hindmarch says as she grabs the first mouse in its

transport cage and scoots it through the open door of a small cage that's part

of the owl trap. " You'll get crackers soon. "

Get updates Follow us on Twitter

Get the latest updates on this story and others from @breakingnews.

...Levesque, a free-lance contract scientist, takes the cage and searches for

just the right spot to put it down in tall grass beside a nearby drainage ditch.

He slips in some crackers and steals back to wait inside his truck.

Hindmarch's objective is twofold: to collect the owl's blood so it can be tested

for rat poisons; and to fit the owls with radio transmitters so she can track

them and figure out where they are feeding. She wants to know whether urban owls

are eating more poisoned rats than their country cousins.

Her work is a follow up to the study analyzing owls found dead in British

Columbia and the Yukon Territory, which showed that nearly three-quarters of the

birds had rodenticides in their livers. The Canadian findings follow earlier

studies in Europe, New Zealand, New York and elsewhere that documented the

poisons spreading to wild animals.

Barn owl population dwindles

The barn owls in and around Vancouver make up the last remaining population of

barn owls in western Canada, where only 125 to 500 pairs are believed to live.

The situation is even worse in eastern Canada, where only 5 to 10 pairs are

thought to remain. Late last month the Committee on Endangered Wildlife in

Canada recommended the western population be labeled " threatened " and the

overall population labeled " endangered " under Canada's Species At Risk Act.

The findings of the Canadian scientists also will have implications in the

United States, where barn owls are legally protected in more than a dozen states

and are much more prevalent.

Hindmarch and her colleagues are eager to find out what role rat poisons may be

having in the Canadian owls' decline. So far, the research suggests that these

improved rat-killers are imposing a toxic load on the environment that no one

bargained for. It seems clear that some rats are being eaten by owls and other

wild animals after they have ingested extraordinarily high doses of poison,

researchers say.

Most popular Recession surprise: U.S. teen births hit all-time low

Updated 8 minutes ago 12/21/2010 11:51:09 PM +00:00 Soaked Southern Calif. set

to get hammered

Census: Population growth slowest since 1940

Dog gives birth to 17 puppies

Falling in love with another's spouse

... " The rats are really little toxic packages running around before they die, "

said Fry, a wildlife toxicologist and pesticides expert with the

American Bird Conservancy. " If the rat is carrying 10 or 15 times a lethal dose,

the animal that consumes it is at a much higher risk of consuming a lethal

dose. "

In some cases, the dose isn't lethal, but " maybe it's affecting their flying

ability and they're getting hit more by cars, " said Kirstin Webster, a colleague

of Hindmarch's at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver.

advertisement | ad info

Advertisement | ad info

Advertisement | ad info

..Owls that aren't killed outright by the poisons also can easily bleed to death

because their blood fails to clot. Wild animals get hurt on a regular basis,

scientists say; what otherwise would have been just a painful cut could spell

death.

Once an owl or other animal eats a poisoned rat, the pesticides stay around in

the predator's system for a very long time. It takes six months or longer for

just half the dose to be eliminated from some animals' bodies.

Imagine you're a barn owl like the one Hindmarch is trying to catch by the grain

depot.

" If you're just getting one dose on top of another, you get this constant

exposure, " said Golden, a U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service toxicologist.

" It's one thing to have enough to kill you outright. But what about the ones

that are just carrying this body burden? What effect does that have on their

fitness? That's what worries me. "

'Sublethal' effects hard to measure

These " sublethal " effects are difficult to gauge, but research suggests they are

real. For example, a study at McGill University in Montreal allowed a sparrow to

perch on a pesticide-laden surface. The bird absorbed pesticide through its

feet. Then researchers put the sparrow into a big cage along with three undosed

sparrows and a kestrel, a small type of falcon that eats sparrows.

Although the scientists could not see any differences in the behavior of the

pesticide-dosed sparrows, the kestrel apparently could. In 12 of the 15

instances in which the kestrel preyed on one of the sparrows, it picked the one

that had absorbed the pesticide. (That study did not involve rat poisons but it

shows that animals not visibly affected may be extremely vulnerable, Environment

Canada's Elliott said.)

The toll of six owls killed outright by rat poisons in the Canadian study almost

certainly underestimates the actual rate at which owls are dying from rat

poison, Elliott said. Animals that feel sick are likely to hide to protect

themselves against predators.

The birds' bodies are routinely scavenged by other wild animals, further

spreading the poison into the food chain. The chemicals have the " potential to

cause additional mortality that may not be sustainable in populations already

experiencing critical limitations, " biologists from the United Kingdom's

University of Leicester reported in 2005.

California's threatened San Joaquin kit fox is an example. Scientists collected

carcasses of the big-eared, long-legged fox that died from various causes in

Bakersfield and in an area 30 miles out in the country. Nearly all the dead

foxes from Bakersfield had residues of the long-lived second-generation

rodenticides, while none from the outlying desert did.

How are these rat poisons getting into plant eaters low on the food chain? There

is no sure answer for now. Scientists wonder, though, if carcasses of poisoned

animals are being scavenged by creatures low on the food chain. Or perhaps

insects are crawling inside the bait stations. But there could be other ways,

too. Elliott, the Environment Canada researcher, notes that scientists have seen

voles and birds hopping inside the holes on the side of bait stations that

approximate the size of the openings to their burrows or homes inside trees.

And as for deer? The seven that tested positive for rat poison in New York

" apparently were exposed due to misuse and careless bait application, " kson

of the EPA reported. Elliott noted that big blue blocks of the poisoned bait are

sometimes thrown out into the wild – blue blocks that look a whole lot like the

salt licks that deer are known to frequent.

Cracking down on rat poisons

Pushed by environmentalists who successfully sued in federal court, the EPA in

2008 issued rules for these rat poisons that largely take them out of the

consumer market.

advertisement | ad info

Advertisement | ad info

Advertisement | ad info

..Pesticide manufacturers say EPA's action was overkill, but should eliminate any

doubts about the products' safety for wildlife.

" There was not strong evidence to compel (EPA) to put into place the (new

rules). However, they did so, " said Reardon, director of communications at

Responsible Industry for a Sound Environment, which represents pesticide

manufacturers. " We have now even further added protections for secondary

wildlife exposure. "

Dale Kemery, an EPA spokesman, said the agency does not track the amount of

pesticides manufactured or applied. But New York state does tote up the

applications. New York State Department of Conservation records requested by the

Natural Resources Defense Council for use in a lawsuit to limit the

rodenticides' use showed more than 20 tons a year were applied in eight New York

City Zip codes in 2002. The pesticide manufacturer Syngenta International in

2004 revealed that some 10 million pounds of first- and second-generation rat

poisons were sold annually in California. And in British Columbia, scientists

obtained records showing large increases in their use during the 1990s.

The western Canadian study documented a 100 percent increase in sales of one of

the rat poisons, brodifacoum, and a 24 percent increase in another,

bromadiolone, in British Columbia between 1991 and 2003.

Canada in 2006 changed the rodenticides' labels to require that they be used in

dog- and child-proof bait stations that allow only rats access to the poison, or

that the bait be limited to where kids and animals don't have access.

Then, in 2009, six months before release of the study of the owl poisonings,

Health Canada issued stricter regulations. Their inspiration came from a

contentious rule approved south of the border.

In U.S., pesticide industry pushes back

In the United States, the EPA knew by the early 1980s that the pesticides that

emerged the decade before were affecting non-targeted wildlife. But it was 1999

before the agency's scientists launched a comprehensive risk analysis of the

pesticides' effects on wildlife.

W. Bush was president by the time an EPA document outlining the

environmental risks of the rat poisons was ready for public comment. EPA sent a

draft of the document to the pesticide industry in September 2001 for what was

supposed to be a 30-day technical review. The stated purpose was to allow

industry officials to make technical corrections.

Instead, the agency held a series of closed-door meetings with industry

officials, environmentalists charged. " There has been excessive undue influence

from industry on the entire process, " said the group Beyond Pesticides. " There

has been little to no opportunity for any other stakeholder to provide input or

even attend any of these meetings with EPA. "

Reardon of the pesticide industry group said it's clear the pesticide industry

didn't get special treatment from EPA because the industry opposed what the

agency ended up requiring. " EPA has added additional safeguards on top of what

was already required. One must conclude that EPA's actions satisfied what they

believed was additional risk, " she said.

In January of 2003, the agency released preliminary results for public comment.

This came more than three years after the risk analysis began. It took EPA five

more years, until May of 2008, to complete a regulatory review.

And then, a quarter-century after the poisoning of wildlife became well known,

the agency decreed that rules to protect wildlife would go into effect more than

three years later, in June 2011.

advertisement | ad info

Advertisement | ad info

Advertisement | ad info

..What the new rules allow

Under the new rules, use of the second-generation rat poisons by consumers will

be curtailed. The sale of loose rat baits will be banned in " big box " stores

like Home Depot as well as other retail outlets. However, consumers can purchase

up to one pound of bait in bait " stations " that are designed to keep out kids

and dogs.

Professional exterminators as well as employees of farms, warehouses and other

commercial installations may continue to use the more-toxic rat poisons, and

loose baits. However, they are required to use above-ground bait stations if the

bait is left outdoors or in any place accessible to children, pets or wildlife.

The rules represent a significant check on unsafe use of the products by

consumers, said Rick Keigwin, director of EPA's Pesticide Re-evaluation Division

" We wanted people who are professionals in the field, who have the training, to

use these products in the appropriate way, " he said.

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and others pushed for EPA to disallow all

outdoor uses of the rodenticides, with narrow exceptions.

EPA didn't go that far, said Parsons, an EPA biologist specializing in

pesticides, because of pushback from some businesses. For example, she said,

" restaurants and food-service facilities felt very strongly that they needed

some kind of perimeter control. " The EPA's position was backed by the U.S.

Department of Housing and Urban Development and the federal Centers for Disease

Control and Prevention.

Professional pesticide applicators support the new " common-sense " rules, said

Bob Rosenberg, vice president of the National Pest Management Association, and

opposed efforts to ban outdoor use of the more-toxic products.

" Rodents are serious problem for all the reasons you know about – public health

reasons, " Rosenberg said. " It's a lot better to get them outside rather than

inside the structure. You want to get them before they get to the food. "

Meanwhile, the multinational Reckitt Benckiser, which markets d-CON rat baits,

is challenging the EPA's new rules in court in an effort to prevent them from

going into effect.

The least-toxic answer, said Golden, the Fish and Wildlife Service toxicologist,

is a system known as " integrated pest management. " It emphasizes use of

non-toxic pest-control methods, which in the case of rats translates to trapping

the rats inside the house and finding ways to keep any more from getting in.

Absent that, Golden predicted that poisoning of wild animals will continue.

" I wouldn't use anticoagulants in my back yard, " said Golden. " These things are

pervasive and are turning up in places we did not expect. . . . They're

certainly not contained where we think they are. "

TOMORROW: Decades on, EPA on verge of curbing use of rat poisons

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...