Guest guest Posted May 11, 2010 Report Posted May 11, 2010 He's absolutely right, there are no studies, we were the study!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Don't you love their system, put it out there and see what the results are? Ask the company, this is what they say............ When you ask why you can't give to children, their response is, "because it's never been tested on children" To: miralax Sent: Tue, May 11, 2010 6:53:31 AMSubject: pharmacist take This morning I learned a guy I swim with every Tues and Thurs morning is a pharmacist. So, between sets, I asked him why doctors and pharmacists continue to rx Miralax for children when it's not approved. I feel pharmacists are to blame, too. They're the ones that hand the physical product to us with no words of warning. He said while it's true it's not approved, there are no studies to show it's damaging and really, when docs rx meds, it's always risk vs. benefit. More kids are helped with it than harmed by it. I asked him since there ARE some kids who are harmed, why do they not warn parents. He gave 2 reasons: 1) it helps more than it hurts (so I guess for those of us whose kids have been hurt, it doesn't matter...) and 2) it's the parents job to check out all medicines before giving it to their child. I argued that if a doc is rx'ing it to us, we trust them. He just shrugged. Argh!!! The level of frustration made the rest of my swim pretty good as I pounded it out on the water. I was so sad, too, at the level of brainwashing this guy had - he never once considered getting to the root of constipation, he only talked about making kids go - band aid! When I asked him about getting to the root of the problem, he said most parents don't want or understand that, therefore just make them happy and off they go.Anyway, thought I'd share. I didn't dig too deep with him - need to stay friends, ya know.- Tracie Quote
Guest guest Posted May 11, 2010 Report Posted May 11, 2010 Also, my pharmacist asked for my research as this happened to his next door neighbor who happens to be a lawyer. Because of his high profile, he declined to go any further and sent 12 yr old to a psyc doc. Wait till I give him the FDA oversight board meeting results!!!!! To: miralax Sent: Tue, May 11, 2010 7:49:36 AMSubject: Re: pharmacist take He's absolutely right, there are no studies, we were the study!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!! !! Don't you love their system, put it out there and see what the results are? Ask the company, this is what they say......... ... When you ask why you can't give to children, their response is, "because it's never been tested on children" From: Tracie Happel <ctaj10centurylink (DOT) net>To: miralax@yahoogroups .comSent: Tue, May 11, 2010 6:53:31 AMSubject: pharmacist take This morning I learned a guy I swim with every Tues and Thurs morning is a pharmacist. So, between sets, I asked him why doctors and pharmacists continue to rx Miralax for children when it's not approved. I feel pharmacists are to blame, too. They're the ones that hand the physical product to us with no words of warning. He said while it's true it's not approved, there are no studies to show it's damaging and really, when docs rx meds, it's always risk vs. benefit. More kids are helped with it than harmed by it. I asked him since there ARE some kids who are harmed, why do they not warn parents. He gave 2 reasons: 1) it helps more than it hurts (so I guess for those of us whose kids have been hurt, it doesn't matter...) and 2) it's the parents job to check out all medicines before giving it to their child. I argued that if a doc is rx'ing it to us, we trust them. He just shrugged. Argh!!! The level of frustration made the rest of my swim pretty good as I pounded it out on the water. I was so sad, too, at the level of brainwashing this guy had - he never once considered getting to the root of constipation, he only talked about making kids go - band aid! When I asked him about getting to the root of the problem, he said most parents don't want or understand that, therefore just make them happy and off they go.Anyway, thought I'd share. I didn't dig too deep with him - need to stay friends, ya know.- Tracie Quote
Guest guest Posted May 11, 2010 Report Posted May 11, 2010 We had a discussion with our bowel and bladder specialist about "not being approved for children". Her take was that many medications that are prescribed are not approved for children. Testing on children is not a popular idea. Parents aren't going to submit their children to trials unless they have a specific need. It is difficult to get the approval for use on children. Jack From: miralax [mailto:miralax ] On Behalf Of Tracie HappelSent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 7:54 AMTo: miralax Subject: pharmacist take This morning I learned a guy I swim with every Tues and Thurs morning is a pharmacist. So, between sets, I asked him why doctors and pharmacists continue to rx Miralax for children when it's not approved. I feel pharmacists are to blame, too. They're the ones that hand the physical product to us with no words of warning. He said while it's true it's not approved, there are no studies to show it's damaging and really, when docs rx meds, it's always risk vs. benefit. More kids are helped with it than harmed by it. I asked him since there ARE some kids who are harmed, why do they not warn parents. He gave 2 reasons: 1) it helps more than it hurts (so I guess for those of us whose kids have been hurt, it doesn't matter...) and 2) it's the parents job to check out all medicines before giving it to their child. I argued that if a doc is rx'ing it to us, we trust them. He just shrugged. Argh!!! The level of frustration made the rest of my swim pretty good as I pounded it out on the water. I was so sad, too, at the level of brainwashing this guy had - he never once considered getting to the root of constipation, he only talked about making kids go - band aid! When I asked him about getting to the root of the problem, he said most parents don't want or understand that, therefore just make them happy and off they go.Anyway, thought I'd share. I didn't dig too deep with him - need to stay friends, ya know.- Tracie No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/10/10 02:26:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted May 11, 2010 Report Posted May 11, 2010 Hmmmm...that's really interesting. Then how did they know that giving it to children would not cause some kind of catastrophic result? Who was the first child guinea pig, I wonder? Who was the first PCP to Rx this to a child? Did they simply cross their fingers and hope for the best? No body even knows what the long-term effects will be. I mean, the manufacturers specifically state Not for use for longer than 7 days?? 14 days?? I forget. But no one is recommending long-term use of this product except the docs and for children. Seems odd. And wrong.To: miralax Sent: Tue, May 11, 2010 9:34:11 AMSubject: RE: pharmacist take We had a discussion with our bowel and bladder specialist about "not being approved for children". Her take was that many medications that are prescribed are not approved for children. Testing on children is not a popular idea. Parents aren't going to submit their children to trials unless they have a specific need. It is difficult to get the approval for use on children. Jack From: miralax@yahoogroups .com [mailto:miralax@ yahoogroups. com] On Behalf Of Tracie HappelSent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 7:54 AMTo: miralax@yahoogroups .comSubject: pharmacist take This morning I learned a guy I swim with every Tues and Thurs morning is a pharmacist. So, between sets, I asked him why doctors and pharmacists continue to rx Miralax for children when it's not approved. I feel pharmacists are to blame, too. They're the ones that hand the physical product to us with no words of warning. He said while it's true it's not approved, there are no studies to show it's damaging and really, when docs rx meds, it's always risk vs. benefit. More kids are helped with it than harmed by it. I asked him since there ARE some kids who are harmed, why do they not warn parents. He gave 2 reasons: 1) it helps more than it hurts (so I guess for those of us whose kids have been hurt, it doesn't matter...) and 2) it's the parents job to check out all medicines before giving it to their child. I argued that if a doc is rx'ing it to us, we trust them. He just shrugged. Argh!!! The level of frustration made the rest of my swim pretty good as I pounded it out on the water. I was so sad, too, at the level of brainwashing this guy had - he never once considered getting to the root of constipation, he only talked about making kids go - band aid! When I asked him about getting to the root of the problem, he said most parents don't want or understand that, therefore just make them happy and off they go.Anyway, thought I'd share. I didn't dig too deep with him - need to stay friends, ya know.- Tracie No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/10/10 02:26:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted May 11, 2010 Report Posted May 11, 2010 I have to say, I don't see anything odd or wrong about relieving my son's chronic constipation. We understand the source of the constipation. Spina Bifida. congenital nerve damage. We have an effective method to keep him regular. Miralax and enemeez We have observed no apparent adverse effects. He has a twin sister not on Miralax. They are developmentally and behaviorally similar. Diet isn't going to stimulate nerves that don't work. My son needs the water to stay in the bowels and not be taken out of the stool before it has a chance to move of of his bowels. In my son's case, the catastrophic results would be allowing his constipation to snowball into impaction and distended pockets. The Miralax is a blessing for him. Jack From: miralax [mailto:miralax ] On Behalf Of LilluSent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 12:13 PMTo: miralax Subject: Re: pharmacist take Hmmmm...that's really interesting. Then how did they know that giving it to children would not cause some kind of catastrophic result? Who was the first child guinea pig, I wonder? Who was the first PCP to Rx this to a child? Did they simply cross their fingers and hope for the best? No body even knows what the long-term effects will be. I mean, the manufacturers specifically state Not for use for longer than 7 days?? 14 days?? I forget. But no one is recommending long-term use of this product except the docs and for children. Seems odd. And wrong. From: Jack Gershon <jackgershon (DOT) cc>To: miralax Sent: Tue, May 11, 2010 9:34:11 AMSubject: RE: pharmacist take We had a discussion with our bowel and bladder specialist about "not being approved for children". Her take was that many medications that are prescribed are not approved for children. Testing on children is not a popular idea. Parents aren't going to submit their children to trials unless they have a specific need. It is difficult to get the approval for use on children. Jack From: miralax@yahoogroups .com [mailto:miralax@ yahoogroups. com] On Behalf Of Tracie HappelSent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 7:54 AMTo: miralax@yahoogroups .comSubject: pharmacist take This morning I learned a guy I swim with every Tues and Thurs morning is a pharmacist. So, between sets, I asked him why doctors and pharmacists continue to rx Miralax for children when it's not approved. I feel pharmacists are to blame, too. They're the ones that hand the physical product to us with no words of warning. He said while it's true it's not approved, there are no studies to show it's damaging and really, when docs rx meds, it's always risk vs. benefit. More kids are helped with it than harmed by it. I asked him since there ARE some kids who are harmed, why do they not warn parents. He gave 2 reasons: 1) it helps more than it hurts (so I guess for those of us whose kids have been hurt, it doesn't matter...) and 2) it's the parents job to check out all medicines before giving it to their child. I argued that if a doc is rx'ing it to us, we trust them. He just shrugged. Argh!!! The level of frustration made the rest of my swim pretty good as I pounded it out on the water. I was so sad, too, at the level of brainwashing this guy had - he never once considered getting to the root of constipation, he only talked about making kids go - band aid! When I asked him about getting to the root of the problem, he said most parents don't want or understand that, therefore just make them happy and off they go.Anyway, thought I'd share. I didn't dig too deep with him - need to stay friends, ya know.- Tracie No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/10/10 02:26:00 No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/11/10 02:26:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted May 11, 2010 Report Posted May 11, 2010 I’m curious, since you’ve had success with miralax and no adverse effects, have you also tried the oxypowder (? I think that’s what it’s called) that’s been mentioned on here? I was wondering how well it works compared to the miralax? From: miralax [mailto:miralax ] On Behalf Of Jack Gershon Sent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 12:06 PM To: miralax Subject: RE: pharmacist take I have to say, I don't see anything odd or wrong about relieving my son's chronic constipation. We understand the source of the constipation. Spina Bifida. congenital nerve damage. We have an effective method to keep him regular. Miralax and enemeez We have observed no apparent adverse effects. He has a twin sister not on Miralax. They are developmentally and behaviorally similar. Diet isn't going to stimulate nerves that don't work. My son needs the water to stay in the bowels and not be taken out of the stool before it has a chance to move of of his bowels. In my son's case, the catastrophic results would be allowing his constipation to snowball into impaction and distended pockets. The Miralax is a blessing for him. Jack From: miralax [mailto:miralax ] On Behalf Of Lillu Sent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 12:13 PM To: miralax Subject: Re: pharmacist take Hmmmm...that's really interesting. Then how did they know that giving it to children would not cause some kind of catastrophic result? Who was the first child guinea pig, I wonder? Who was the first PCP to Rx this to a child? Did they simply cross their fingers and hope for the best? No body even knows what the long-term effects will be. I mean, the manufacturers specifically state Not for use for longer than 7 days?? 14 days?? I forget. But no one is recommending long-term use of this product except the docs and for children. Seems odd. And wrong. From: Jack Gershon To: miralax Sent: Tue, May 11, 2010 9:34:11 AM Subject: RE: pharmacist take We had a discussion with our bowel and bladder specialist about " not being approved for children " . Her take was that many medications that are prescribed are not approved for children. Testing on children is not a popular idea. Parents aren't going to submit their children to trials unless they have a specific need. It is difficult to get the approval for use on children. Jack From: miralax@yahoogroups .com [mailto:miralax@ yahoogroups. com] On Behalf Of Tracie Happel Sent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 7:54 AM To: miralax@yahoogroups .com Subject: pharmacist take This morning I learned a guy I swim with every Tues and Thurs morning is a pharmacist. So, between sets, I asked him why doctors and pharmacists continue to rx Miralax for children when it's not approved. I feel pharmacists are to blame, too. They're the ones that hand the physical product to us with no words of warning. He said while it's true it's not approved, there are no studies to show it's damaging and really, when docs rx meds, it's always risk vs. benefit. More kids are helped with it than harmed by it. I asked him since there ARE some kids who are harmed, why do they not warn parents. He gave 2 reasons: 1) it helps more than it hurts (so I guess for those of us whose kids have been hurt, it doesn't matter...) and 2) it's the parents job to check out all medicines before giving it to their child. I argued that if a doc is rx'ing it to us, we trust them. He just shrugged. Argh!!! The level of frustration made the rest of my swim pretty good as I pounded it out on the water. I was so sad, too, at the level of brainwashing this guy had - he never once considered getting to the root of constipation, he only talked about making kids go - band aid! When I asked him about getting to the root of the problem, he said most parents don't want or understand that, therefore just make them happy and off they go. Anyway, thought I'd share. I didn't dig too deep with him - need to stay friends, ya know. - Tracie No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/10/10 02:26:00 No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/11/10 02:26:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted May 11, 2010 Report Posted May 11, 2010 My point was, Jack, that they didn't know what the results would be or what the adverse side effects may be when they first prescribed this off label to children. I was wondering "out loud" who this first child/children may have been and why/how their medical care providers felt it was safe when the manufacturer clearly stated that it was not. I am truly happy for you and your little boy (as I have stated before) that Miralax has indeed provided the solution that you so desparately need. I know that you do have misgivings about it, as well, despite the fact that you have thus far not witnessed any adverse side-effects, but so far, so good, right? But for those of us whose children only had a mild case of constipation which could have been mitigated with diet alterations, it is mystifying why PCPs would continue to prescribe this strong drug to our young children. One would not opt for brain surgery when 2 Tylenol would have worked. I feel that in my daughter's case (let me just speak for myself here) that the negative impact of the proscribed solution far outstripped its benefits. Her PCP even knew what the cause was (whole cow's milk) and still told me to keep her on the milk and continue to give her the Miralax. This resulted in my DD not growing a centimeter or gaining a single ounce (in fact she lost 1 lb) in 8 months. She now measures small for her age group, as a result, her hair growth is sparse and she has recurrent rashes. Where Miralax is the ONLY solution, then yes, it's a blessing. But most of us who found this forum and are greatful for it are here because Miralax was NOT a blessing for us. I have said this before: Miralax should not be the first course of action - at least for children under 17 years of age (i.e., still growing). It should be a treatment of last resort, when everything else has failed. Even then, these children who were put on Miralax as a treatment of last resort should be closely monitored for ANY adverse reaction as they are being prescribed medicaiton not initialy intended for use with their age group and any adverse reaction should be reported to the FDA. I find the way that Miralax is now being prescribed, like children's aspirin, wholly irresponsible and it should be stopped. I don't necessarily want to see it taken off the shelves because it obviously does help children like your son, but it should come with a warning for the rest of us whose children ended up suffering needlessly because of this drug. To: miralax Sent: Tue, May 11, 2010 2:06:16 PMSubject: RE: pharmacist take I have to say, I don't see anything odd or wrong about relieving my son's chronic constipation. We understand the source of the constipation. Spina Bifida. congenital nerve damage. We have an effective method to keep him regular. Miralax and enemeez We have observed no apparent adverse effects. He has a twin sister not on Miralax. They are developmentally and behaviorally similar. Diet isn't going to stimulate nerves that don't work. My son needs the water to stay in the bowels and not be taken out of the stool before it has a chance to move of of his bowels. In my son's case, the catastrophic results would be allowing his constipation to snowball into impaction and distended pockets. The Miralax is a blessing for him. Jack From: miralax@yahoogroups .com [mailto:miralax@ yahoogroups. com] On Behalf Of LilluSent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 12:13 PMTo: miralax@yahoogroups .comSubject: Re: pharmacist take Hmmmm...that' s really interesting. Then how did they know that giving it to children would not cause some kind of catastrophic result? Who was the first child guinea pig, I wonder? Who was the first PCP to Rx this to a child? Did they simply cross their fingers and hope for the best? No body even knows what the long-term effects will be. I mean, the manufacturers specifically state Not for use for longer than 7 days?? 14 days?? I forget. But no one is recommending long-term use of this product except the docs and for children. Seems odd. And wrong. From: Jack Gershon <jackgershon (DOT) cc>To: miralax@yahoogroups .comSent: Tue, May 11, 2010 9:34:11 AMSubject: RE: pharmacist take We had a discussion with our bowel and bladder specialist about "not being approved for children". Her take was that many medications that are prescribed are not approved for children. Testing on children is not a popular idea. Parents aren't going to submit their children to trials unless they have a specific need. It is difficult to get the approval for use on children. Jack From: miralax@yahoogroups .com [mailto:miralax@ yahoogroups. com] On Behalf Of Tracie HappelSent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 7:54 AMTo: miralax@yahoogroups .comSubject: pharmacist take This morning I learned a guy I swim with every Tues and Thurs morning is a pharmacist. So, between sets, I asked him why doctors and pharmacists continue to rx Miralax for children when it's not approved. I feel pharmacists are to blame, too. They're the ones that hand the physical product to us with no words of warning. He said while it's true it's not approved, there are no studies to show it's damaging and really, when docs rx meds, it's always risk vs. benefit. More kids are helped with it than harmed by it. I asked him since there ARE some kids who are harmed, why do they not warn parents. He gave 2 reasons: 1) it helps more than it hurts (so I guess for those of us whose kids have been hurt, it doesn't matter...) and 2) it's the parents job to check out all medicines before giving it to their child. I argued that if a doc is rx'ing it to us, we trust them. He just shrugged. Argh!!! The level of frustration made the rest of my swim pretty good as I pounded it out on the water. I was so sad, too, at the level of brainwashing this guy had - he never once considered getting to the root of constipation, he only talked about making kids go - band aid! When I asked him about getting to the root of the problem, he said most parents don't want or understand that, therefore just make them happy and off they go.Anyway, thought I'd share. I didn't dig too deep with him - need to stay friends, ya know.- Tracie No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/10/10 02:26:00 No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/11/10 02:26:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted May 11, 2010 Report Posted May 11, 2010 No, we haven't tried OxyPowder. The key to Miralax's success (for us) is that it is an osmotic. It holds water in the bowels, allowing the stool to stay soft longer. From what I have read of oxypowder, it is more of a cleanser/de-toxifier. My son doesn't suffer from anything like this. His problem is poor bowel motility due to nerve damge of the spinal cord. From: miralax [mailto:miralax ] On Behalf Of Renae SchleySent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 2:49 PMTo: miralax Subject: RE: pharmacist take I’m curious, since you’ve had success with miralax and no adverse effects, have you also tried the oxypowder (? I think that’s what it’s called) that’s been mentioned on here? I was wondering how well it works compared to the miralax? From: miralax [mailto:miralax ] On Behalf Of Jack GershonSent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 12:06 PMTo: miralax Subject: RE: pharmacist take I have to say, I don't see anything odd or wrong about relieving my son's chronic constipation. We understand the source of the constipation. Spina Bifida. congenital nerve damage. We have an effective method to keep him regular. Miralax and enemeez We have observed no apparent adverse effects. He has a twin sister not on Miralax. They are developmentally and behaviorally similar. Diet isn't going to stimulate nerves that don't work. My son needs the water to stay in the bowels and not be taken out of the stool before it has a chance to move of of his bowels. In my son's case, the catastrophic results would be allowing his constipation to snowball into impaction and distended pockets. The Miralax is a blessing for him. Jack From: miralax [mailto:miralax ] On Behalf Of LilluSent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 12:13 PMTo: miralax Subject: Re: pharmacist take Hmmmm...that's really interesting. Then how did they know that giving it to children would not cause some kind of catastrophic result? Who was the first child guinea pig, I wonder? Who was the first PCP to Rx this to a child? Did they simply cross their fingers and hope for the best? No body even knows what the long-term effects will be. I mean, the manufacturers specifically state Not for use for longer than 7 days?? 14 days?? I forget. But no one is recommending long-term use of this product except the docs and for children. Seems odd. And wrong. From: Jack Gershon <jackgershon (DOT) cc>To: miralax Sent: Tue, May 11, 2010 9:34:11 AMSubject: RE: pharmacist take We had a discussion with our bowel and bladder specialist about "not being approved for children". Her take was that many medications that are prescribed are not approved for children. Testing on children is not a popular idea. Parents aren't going to submit their children to trials unless they have a specific need. It is difficult to get the approval for use on children. Jack From: miralax@yahoogroups .com [mailto:miralax@ yahoogroups. com] On Behalf Of Tracie HappelSent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 7:54 AMTo: miralax@yahoogroups .comSubject: pharmacist take This morning I learned a guy I swim with every Tues and Thurs morning is a pharmacist. So, between sets, I asked him why doctors and pharmacists continue to rx Miralax for children when it's not approved. I feel pharmacists are to blame, too. They're the ones that hand the physical product to us with no words of warning. He said while it's true it's not approved, there are no studies to show it's damaging and really, when docs rx meds, it's always risk vs. benefit. More kids are helped with it than harmed by it. I asked him since there ARE some kids who are harmed, why do they not warn parents. He gave 2 reasons: 1) it helps more than it hurts (so I guess for those of us whose kids have been hurt, it doesn't matter...) and 2) it's the parents job to check out all medicines before giving it to their child. I argued that if a doc is rx'ing it to us, we trust them. He just shrugged. Argh!!! The level of frustration made the rest of my swim pretty good as I pounded it out on the water. I was so sad, too, at the level of brainwashing this guy had - he never once considered getting to the root of constipation, he only talked about making kids go - band aid! When I asked him about getting to the root of the problem, he said most parents don't want or understand that, therefore just make them happy and off they go.Anyway, thought I'd share. I didn't dig too deep with him - need to stay friends, ya know.- Tracie No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/10/10 02:26:00 No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/11/10 02:26:00 No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2867 - Release Date: 05/11/10 02:26:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted May 11, 2010 Report Posted May 11, 2010 I would probably be of the same mindset as you if I were in your shoes. Respectfully Jack From: miralax [mailto:miralax ] On Behalf Of LilluSent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 3:47 PMTo: miralax Subject: Re: pharmacist take My point was, Jack, that they didn't know what the results would be or what the adverse side effects may be when they first prescribed this off label to children. I was wondering "out loud" who this first child/children may have been and why/how their medical care providers felt it was safe when the manufacturer clearly stated that it was not. I am truly happy for you and your little boy (as I have stated before) that Miralax has indeed provided the solution that you so desparately need. I know that you do have misgivings about it, as well, despite the fact that you have thus far not witnessed any adverse side-effects, but so far, so good, right? But for those of us whose children only had a mild case of constipation which could have been mitigated with diet alterations, it is mystifying why PCPs would continue to prescribe this strong drug to our young children. One would not opt for brain surgery when 2 Tylenol would have worked. I feel that in my daughter's case (let me just speak for myself here) that the negative impact of the proscribed solution far outstripped its benefits. Her PCP even knew what the cause was (whole cow's milk) and still told me to keep her on the milk and continue to give her the Miralax. This resulted in my DD not growing a centimeter or gaining a single ounce (in fact she lost 1 lb) in 8 months. She now measures small for her age group, as a result, her hair growth is sparse and she has recurrent rashes. Where Miralax is the ONLY solution, then yes, it's a blessing. But most of us who found this forum and are greatful for it are here because Miralax was NOT a blessing for us. I have said this before: Miralax should not be the first course of action - at least for children under 17 years of age (i.e., still growing). It should be a treatment of last resort, when everything else has failed. Even then, these children who were put on Miralax as a treatment of last resort should be closely monitored for ANY adverse reaction as they are being prescribed medicaiton not initialy intended for use with their age group and any adverse reaction should be reported to the FDA. I find the way that Miralax is now being prescribed, like children's aspirin, wholly irresponsible and it should be stopped. I don't necessarily want to see it taken off the shelves because it obviously does help children like your son, but it should come with a warning for the rest of us whose children ended up suffering needlessly because of this drug. From: Jack Gershon <jackgershon (DOT) cc>To: miralax Sent: Tue, May 11, 2010 2:06:16 PMSubject: RE: pharmacist take I have to say, I don't see anything odd or wrong about relieving my son's chronic constipation. We understand the source of the constipation. Spina Bifida. congenital nerve damage. We have an effective method to keep him regular. Miralax and enemeez We have observed no apparent adverse effects. He has a twin sister not on Miralax. They are developmentally and behaviorally similar. Diet isn't going to stimulate nerves that don't work. My son needs the water to stay in the bowels and not be taken out of the stool before it has a chance to move of of his bowels. In my son's case, the catastrophic results would be allowing his constipation to snowball into impaction and distended pockets. The Miralax is a blessing for him. Jack From: miralax@yahoogroups .com [mailto:miralax@ yahoogroups. com] On Behalf Of LilluSent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 12:13 PMTo: miralax@yahoogroups .comSubject: Re: pharmacist take Hmmmm...that' s really interesting. Then how did they know that giving it to children would not cause some kind of catastrophic result? Who was the first child guinea pig, I wonder? Who was the first PCP to Rx this to a child? Did they simply cross their fingers and hope for the best? No body even knows what the long-term effects will be. I mean, the manufacturers specifically state Not for use for longer than 7 days?? 14 days?? I forget. But no one is recommending long-term use of this product except the docs and for children. Seems odd. And wrong. From: Jack Gershon <jackgershon (DOT) cc>To: miralax@yahoogroups .comSent: Tue, May 11, 2010 9:34:11 AMSubject: RE: pharmacist take We had a discussion with our bowel and bladder specialist about "not being approved for children". Her take was that many medications that are prescribed are not approved for children. Testing on children is not a popular idea. Parents aren't going to submit their children to trials unless they have a specific need. It is difficult to get the approval for use on children. Jack From: miralax@yahoogroups .com [mailto:miralax@ yahoogroups. com] On Behalf Of Tracie HappelSent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 7:54 AMTo: miralax@yahoogroups .comSubject: pharmacist take This morning I learned a guy I swim with every Tues and Thurs morning is a pharmacist. So, between sets, I asked him why doctors and pharmacists continue to rx Miralax for children when it's not approved. I feel pharmacists are to blame, too. They're the ones that hand the physical product to us with no words of warning. He said while it's true it's not approved, there are no studies to show it's damaging and really, when docs rx meds, it's always risk vs. benefit. More kids are helped with it than harmed by it. I asked him since there ARE some kids who are harmed, why do they not warn parents. He gave 2 reasons: 1) it helps more than it hurts (so I guess for those of us whose kids have been hurt, it doesn't matter...) and 2) it's the parents job to check out all medicines before giving it to their child. I argued that if a doc is rx'ing it to us, we trust them. He just shrugged. Argh!!! The level of frustration made the rest of my swim pretty good as I pounded it out on the water. I was so sad, too, at the level of brainwashing this guy had - he never once considered getting to the root of constipation, he only talked about making kids go - band aid! When I asked him about getting to the root of the problem, he said most parents don't want or understand that, therefore just make them happy and off they go.Anyway, thought I'd share. I didn't dig too deep with him - need to stay friends, ya know.- Tracie No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/10/10 02:26:00 No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/11/10 02:26:00 No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2867 - Release Date: 05/11/10 02:26:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted May 11, 2010 Report Posted May 11, 2010 I personally think Miralax is s joke. They had my son on it for a yr several yrs ago and we ended up in the ER several times that yr with impaction. I went nose to nose with a physician over it one time, he told me he had a miracle drug that would make my son go, I laughed when he told me it was Miralax because I told him he was already getting it twice a day. Thank God I quit listening to them and decided to fix the problem myself.TI’m curious, since you’ve had success with miralax and no adverse effects, have you also tried the oxypowder (? I think that’s what it’s called) that’s been mentioned on here? I was wondering how well it works compared to the miralax? From: miralax [mailto:miralax ] On Behalf Of Jack GershonSent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 12:06 PMTo: miralax Subject: RE: pharmacist take I have to say, I don't see anything odd or wrong about relieving my son's chronic constipation. We understand the source of the constipation. Spina Bifida. congenital nerve damage.We have an effective method to keep him regular. Miralax and enemeezWe have observed no apparent adverse effects. He has a twin sister not on Miralax. They are developmentally and behaviorally similar. Diet isn't going to stimulate nerves that don't work.My son needs the water to stay in the bowels and not be taken out of the stool before it has a chance to move of of his bowels. In my son's case, the catastrophic results would be allowing his constipation to snowball into impaction and distended pockets. The Miralax is a blessing for him. Jack From: miralax [mailto:miralax ] On Behalf Of LilluSent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 12:13 PMTo: miralax Subject: Re: pharmacist take Hmmmm...that's really interesting. Then how did they know that giving it to children would not cause some kind of catastrophic result? Who was the first child guinea pig, I wonder? Who was the first PCP to Rx this to a child? Did they simply cross their fingers and hope for the best? No body even knows what the long-term effects will be. I mean, the manufacturers specifically state Not for use for longer than 7 days?? 14 days?? I forget. But no one is recommending long-term use of this product except the docs and for children. Seems odd. And wrong.From: Jack Gershon <jackgershon (DOT) cc>To: miralax Sent: Tue, May 11, 2010 9:34:11 AMSubject: RE: pharmacist take We had a discussion with our bowel and bladder specialist about "not being approved for children". Her take was that many medications that are prescribed are not approved for children. Testing on children is not a popular idea. Parents aren't going to submit their children to trials unless they have a specific need. It is difficult to get the approval for use on children. Jack From: miralax@yahoogroups .com [mailto:miralax@ yahoogroups. com] On Behalf Of Tracie HappelSent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 7:54 AMTo: miralax@yahoogroups .comSubject: pharmacist take This morning I learned a guy I swim with every Tues and Thurs morning is a pharmacist. So, between sets, I asked him why doctors and pharmacists continue to rx Miralax for children when it's not approved. I feel pharmacists are to blame, too. They're the ones that hand the physical product to us with no words of warning. He said while it's true it's not approved, there are no studies to show it's damaging and really, when docs rx meds, it's always risk vs. benefit. More kids are helped with it than harmed by it. I asked him since there ARE some kids who are harmed, why do they not warn parents. He gave 2 reasons: 1) it helps more than it hurts (so I guess for those of us whose kids have been hurt, it doesn't matter...) and 2) it's the parents job to check out all medicines before giving it to their child. I argued that if a doc is rx'ing it to us, we trust them. He just shrugged. Argh!!! The level of frustration made the rest of my swim pretty good as I pounded it out on the water. I was so sad, too, at the level of brainwashing this guy had - he never once considered getting to the root of constipation, he only talked about making kids go - band aid! When I asked him about getting to the root of the problem, he said most parents don't want or understand that, therefore just make them happy and off they go.Anyway, thought I'd share. I didn't dig too deep with him - need to stay friends, ya know.- TracieNo virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/10/10 02:26:00 No virus found in this incoming message.Checked by AVG - www.avg.comVersion: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/11/10 02:26:00 Quote
Guest guest Posted May 16, 2010 Report Posted May 16, 2010 Oxypowder is magnesium oxide and germanium. The same ingredients can be obtained for much less than this brand name product. That being said -- it works. Magnesium is used as an osmotic laxative -- and should be the second intervention tried --- after prescribing dietary interventions first. The last resort would be PEG. > > No, we haven't tried OxyPowder. The key to Miralax's success (for us) is > that it is an osmotic. It holds water in the bowels, allowing the stool to > stay soft longer. > > From what I have read of oxypowder, it is more of a cleanser/de-toxifier. > My son doesn't suffer from anything like this. His problem is poor bowel > motility due to nerve damge of the spinal cord. > > > > _____ > > From: miralax [mailto:miralax ] On Behalf Of > Renae Schley > Sent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 2:49 PM > To: miralax > Subject: RE: pharmacist take > > > > > > I'm curious, since you've had success with miralax and no adverse effects, > have you also tried the oxypowder (? I think that's what it's called) that's > been mentioned on here? I was wondering how well it works compared to the > miralax? > > From: miralax [mailto:miralax ] On Behalf Of > Jack Gershon > Sent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 12:06 PM > To: miralax > Subject: RE: pharmacist take > > > > I have to say, I don't see anything odd or wrong about relieving my son's > chronic constipation. > > We understand the source of the constipation. Spina Bifida. congenital > nerve damage. > > We have an effective method to keep him regular. Miralax and enemeez > > We have observed no apparent adverse effects. He has a twin sister not on > Miralax. They are developmentally and behaviorally similar. > > Diet isn't going to stimulate nerves that don't work. > > My son needs the water to stay in the bowels and not be taken out of the > stool before it has a chance to move of of his bowels. > > In my son's case, the catastrophic results would be allowing his > constipation to snowball into impaction and distended pockets. The Miralax > is a blessing for him. > > Jack > > _____ > > From: miralax [mailto:miralax ] On Behalf Of > Lillu > Sent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 12:13 PM > To: miralax > Subject: Re: pharmacist take > > > > Hmmmm...that's really interesting. Then how did they know that giving it to > children would not cause some kind of catastrophic result? Who was the > first child guinea pig, I wonder? Who was the first PCP to Rx this to a > child? Did they simply cross their fingers and hope for the best? No body > even knows what the long-term effects will be. I mean, the manufacturers > specifically state Not for use for longer than 7 days?? 14 days?? I > forget. But no one is recommending long-term use of this product except the > docs and for children. Seems odd. And wrong. > > > > > > _____ > > > To: miralax > Sent: Tue, May 11, 2010 9:34:11 AM > Subject: RE: pharmacist take > > > > We had a discussion with our bowel and bladder specialist about " not being > approved for children " . Her take was that many medications that are > prescribed are not approved for children. Testing on children is not a > popular idea. Parents aren't going to submit their children to trials > unless they have a specific need. It is difficult to get the approval for > use on children. > > Jack > > _____ > > From: miralax@yahoogroups .com [mailto:miralax@ yahoogroups. com] On Behalf > Of Tracie Happel > Sent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 7:54 AM > To: miralax@yahoogroups .com > Subject: pharmacist take > > > > This morning I learned a guy I swim with every Tues and Thurs morning > is a pharmacist. So, between sets, I asked him why doctors and > pharmacists continue to rx Miralax for children when it's not > approved. I feel pharmacists are to blame, too. They're the ones that > hand the physical product to us with no words of warning. He said > while it's true it's not approved, there are no studies to show it's > damaging and really, when docs rx meds, it's always risk vs. benefit. > More kids are helped with it than harmed by it. I asked him since > there ARE some kids who are harmed, why do they not warn parents. He > gave 2 reasons: 1) it helps more than it hurts (so I guess for those > of us whose kids have been hurt, it doesn't matter...) and 2) it's the > parents job to check out all medicines before giving it to their > child. I argued that if a doc is rx'ing it to us, we trust them. He > just shrugged. Argh!!! The level of frustration made the rest of my > swim pretty good as I pounded it out on the water. I was so sad, too, > at the level of brainwashing this guy had - he never once considered > getting to the root of constipation, he only talked about making kids > go - band aid! When I asked him about getting to the root of the > problem, he said most parents don't want or understand that, therefore > just make them happy and off they go. > > Anyway, thought I'd share. I didn't dig too deep with him - need to > stay friends, ya know. > > - Tracie > > No virus found in this incoming message. > Checked by AVG - www.avg.com > Version: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/10/10 > 02:26:00 > > No virus found in this incoming message. > Checked by AVG - www.avg.com > Version: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2865 - Release Date: 05/11/10 > 02:26:00 > > > > No virus found in this incoming message. > Checked by AVG - www.avg.com > Version: 9.0.819 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/2867 - Release Date: 05/11/10 > 02:26:00 > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.