Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: good trends and bad for solo, noncorporate docs

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

Can someone help me with some verifiable information? It's been said that hospital owned practices receive higher fees for the same care that could be rendered by non-hospital owned practices. I've assumed this but is this really true? Where is the cold hard information? Impossible to get other docs, even friends, to talk. everyone is terrified of colluding. The third party players aren't forthcoming of course. i continue to casually talk with my state senator neighbor about 'healthcare' in Massachusetts. I'd like to pull some hard stuff together and have a real sit down conversation with him. The municipalities here are going broke. The cost of healthcare 'coverage' is cited a big problem. If ever there was a perfect target project for a local network of IMPS to show its stuff, this is it. We know that superb primary care not only saves money, but oh by the way, superb primary care improves quality in verifiable measurements. Two problems: 1. The mandated health insurance coverage, everyone is a captive. 2. The powerful hospital networks. Both of these problem institutions have the incentive, money and power to fight and kill such a project. But...I'd like to have some facts about the fee differential between hospital practices and non-hospital practices. Kathleen -- did you get coal in your stocking? :-( All the junk that is coming our way and will not stop -- hospitals once again here buying primaries and then they'll staff their clinics... many of the 50+ yo docs have not been renewed as they "cost too much"... shades of HMOs that the hospital will "buy out" and doc and "run them more efficiently" ie, downstaffing and make you fill out registries to show how "well you're doing" but ignore the pt. Other trend, though, that gives me hope is that "regular" pts with well paying insurance now "can't get into the docs" because the hospital run offices have staff that feel overwhelmed so push off new pts... that I can live with! Matt in Western PAHappy that IMP in Washington DC in 2011 -- I'm really going to try to go this year!, even if it's only to watch touch type! Hahah Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market, and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in as i am not in a network, though I have some patients with it who get covered go figure , anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago and rejected their offer told them about HYH and how I work and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonableI still did not take them and their hassle factor is very bad and I knew it would put me over the edge:) LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that Aetna would get between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than whining and saying I hate you:) Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call for Aetna for me so was not crucial New patietn-- I had call them up and say "what do you pay for a 99213 out of network" and they said about 6.00 less than what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her ,she uses her insurance ,pays only a littel and so far she is willing to do it.Its all stoppid though very stoopid I am sittin g here solving a narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run out days ago but I had done up the script and for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is fraught with garbage.You think diagnosis an treatment is hard BUt itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupidI agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers. We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-) You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts. M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

Can someone help me with some verifiable information? It's been said that hospital owned practices receive higher fees for the same care that could be rendered by non-hospital owned practices. I've assumed this but is this really true? Where is the cold hard information? Impossible to get other docs, even friends, to talk. everyone is terrified of colluding. The third party players aren't forthcoming of course. i continue to casually talk with my state senator neighbor about 'healthcare' in Massachusetts. I'd like to pull some hard stuff together and have a real sit down conversation with him. The municipalities here are going broke. The cost of healthcare 'coverage' is cited a big problem. If ever there was a perfect target project for a local network of IMPS to show its stuff, this is it. We know that superb primary care not only saves money, but oh by the way, superb primary care improves quality in verifiable measurements. Two problems: 1. The mandated health insurance coverage, everyone is a captive. 2. The powerful hospital networks. Both of these problem institutions have the incentive, money and power to fight and kill such a project. But...I'd like to have some facts about the fee differential between hospital practices and non-hospital practices. Kathleen -- did you get coal in your stocking? :-( All the junk that is coming our way and will not stop -- hospitals once again here buying primaries and then they'll staff their clinics... many of the 50+ yo docs have not been renewed as they "cost too much"... shades of HMOs that the hospital will "buy out" and doc and "run them more efficiently" ie, downstaffing and make you fill out registries to show how "well you're doing" but ignore the pt. Other trend, though, that gives me hope is that "regular" pts with well paying insurance now "can't get into the docs" because the hospital run offices have staff that feel overwhelmed so push off new pts... that I can live with! Matt in Western PAHappy that IMP in Washington DC in 2011 -- I'm really going to try to go this year!, even if it's only to watch touch type! Hahah Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market, and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in as i am not in a network, though I have some patients with it who get covered go figure , anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago and rejected their offer told them about HYH and how I work and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonableI still did not take them and their hassle factor is very bad and I knew it would put me over the edge:) LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that Aetna would get between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than whining and saying I hate you:) Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call for Aetna for me so was not crucial New patietn-- I had call them up and say "what do you pay for a 99213 out of network" and they said about 6.00 less than what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her ,she uses her insurance ,pays only a littel and so far she is willing to do it.Its all stoppid though very stoopid I am sittin g here solving a narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run out days ago but I had done up the script and for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is fraught with garbage.You think diagnosis an treatment is hard BUt itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupidI agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers. We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-) You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts. M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

Can someone help me with some verifiable information? It's been said that hospital owned practices receive higher fees for the same care that could be rendered by non-hospital owned practices. I've assumed this but is this really true? Where is the cold hard information? Impossible to get other docs, even friends, to talk. everyone is terrified of colluding. The third party players aren't forthcoming of course. i continue to casually talk with my state senator neighbor about 'healthcare' in Massachusetts. I'd like to pull some hard stuff together and have a real sit down conversation with him. The municipalities here are going broke. The cost of healthcare 'coverage' is cited a big problem. If ever there was a perfect target project for a local network of IMPS to show its stuff, this is it. We know that superb primary care not only saves money, but oh by the way, superb primary care improves quality in verifiable measurements. Two problems: 1. The mandated health insurance coverage, everyone is a captive. 2. The powerful hospital networks. Both of these problem institutions have the incentive, money and power to fight and kill such a project. But...I'd like to have some facts about the fee differential between hospital practices and non-hospital practices. Kathleen -- did you get coal in your stocking? :-( All the junk that is coming our way and will not stop -- hospitals once again here buying primaries and then they'll staff their clinics... many of the 50+ yo docs have not been renewed as they "cost too much"... shades of HMOs that the hospital will "buy out" and doc and "run them more efficiently" ie, downstaffing and make you fill out registries to show how "well you're doing" but ignore the pt. Other trend, though, that gives me hope is that "regular" pts with well paying insurance now "can't get into the docs" because the hospital run offices have staff that feel overwhelmed so push off new pts... that I can live with! Matt in Western PAHappy that IMP in Washington DC in 2011 -- I'm really going to try to go this year!, even if it's only to watch touch type! Hahah Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market, and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in as i am not in a network, though I have some patients with it who get covered go figure , anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago and rejected their offer told them about HYH and how I work and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonableI still did not take them and their hassle factor is very bad and I knew it would put me over the edge:) LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that Aetna would get between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than whining and saying I hate you:) Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call for Aetna for me so was not crucial New patietn-- I had call them up and say "what do you pay for a 99213 out of network" and they said about 6.00 less than what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her ,she uses her insurance ,pays only a littel and so far she is willing to do it.Its all stoppid though very stoopid I am sittin g here solving a narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run out days ago but I had done up the script and for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is fraught with garbage.You think diagnosis an treatment is hard BUt itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupidI agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers. We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-) You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts. M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

 

Can someone help me with some verifiable information?  It's been said that hospital owned practices receive higher fees for the same care that could be rendered by non-hospital owned practices.  I've assumed this but is this really true?  Where is the cold hard information? Impossible to get other docs, even friends, to talk.  everyone is terrified of colluding.  The third party players aren't forthcoming of course.  

they get a facilty fee on top op of the  fee they are paid  I think is how it goes..and  I don;t know much but  here for a while MaInecare --medicaid --was paying hospital  docs a higher fee I think that was to encourage them t o s ee those folks. Cough cough If you paid me more I would see them too  This has changed I believe in t he last year

But everything is different everywhere. It would seem to  me that you state medical association  would  be able to talk to you about this

i continue to casually talk with my state senator neighbor about 'healthcare' in Massachusetts.  I'd like to pull some hard stuff together and have a real sit down conversation with him.  

The municipalities  here are going broke.  The cost of healthcare 'coverage' is cited a big problem.  If ever there was a perfect target project for a local network of IMPS to show its stuff, this is it.  We know that superb primary care not only saves money, but oh by the way, superb primary care improves quality in verifiable measurements. Two problems:  1. The mandated health insurance coverage, everyone is a captive. 2. The powerful hospital networks.  

Both of these problem institutions have the incentive, money and power to fight and kill such a project. But...

I'd like to have some facts about the fee differential between hospital practices and non-hospital practices.  

Kathleen   

-- did you get coal in your stocking? :-(

 All the junk that is coming our way and will not stop -- hospitals once again here buying primaries and then they'll staff their clinics... many of the 50+ yo docs have not been renewed as they " cost too much " ... shades of HMOs that the hospital will " buy out " and doc and " run them more efficiently " ie, downstaffing and make you fill out registries to show how " well you're doing " but ignore the pt.

 Other trend, though, that gives me hope is that " regular " pts with well paying insurance now " can't get into the docs " because the hospital run offices have staff that feel overwhelmed so push off new pts... that I can live with!

 Matt in Western PAHappy that IMP in Washington DC in 2011 -- I'm really going to try to go this year!, even if it's only to watch touch type!  Hahah

 Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter 

I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market,  and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in  as i am not in a network, though I have some patients  with it  who  get covered go figure ,  anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago  and  rejected their offer  told them about HYH and  how I work  and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonable

I still did not take them and their hassle factor is   very bad and I knew it would  put me over the edge:)    LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s    later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that  Aetna would get  between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than  whining and saying I hate you:)

 Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call  for Aetna for me so  was not crucial  New patietn--   I had call them up and say " what do you pay for a 99213 out of network " and they said about 6.00 less than  what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her  ,she uses her insurance ,pays  only a littel and so far she is willing to do  it.

Its all stoppid though  very stoopid I am sittin g  here solving a  narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run   out days ago but I had done up the script and  for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med  but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is  fraught with garbage.

You think diagnosis an treatment  is hard  BUt  itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago  system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupid

JeanOn Sun, Dec 26, 2010 at 11:04 AM, Larry Lindeman  wrote:

 I agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!

Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

 You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers. 

We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-)

 You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine

On Sat, Dec 25, 2010 at 1:06 PM, Larry Lindeman  wrote:

 By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.

Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

 Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with  patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts.

  M.D.www.elainemd.com

Office: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. 

 If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. 

-- 

M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice:

Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. 

 If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. 

-- 

PATIENTS-please remember  that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical  record and is placed into your  chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and  brief  questions

Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL  if the  matter is more urgent .     MD           ph    fax

impcenter.org

-- PATIENTS-please remember  that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical  record and is placed into your  chart ( be careful what you say!)

Email is best used for appointment making and  brief  questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL  if the  matter is more urgent .     MD    

     ph    fax impcenter.org

Posted

RE going broke... municipalities, vs hospital owned practices.

Yes, hospital owned does NOT mean less cost to the insurer; the insurer is often FORCED to pay MORE to these folks, so this whole idea of lower cost but do better has some built in hypocrisies.

More consolidation in health care OFTEN means HIGHER ADMIN COSTS and therefore the larger hospital owned and corporate groups INSIST on MORE PAYMENT!!

I believe this trend has already shown up in Massachusetts.

As long as WE as individual practices can satisfy our pts' needs, then WE can survive and not feel taken advantage of.

Once the corporatization of medicine goes further.... the costs and reimbursements for these larger groups of hospital and institutional owned practices will inevitably go down, and the promised efficiencies will not materialize.... The only way that costs are reduced (and pay to docs continues at a sustainable level) is when the hospital system OWNS the insurance, and makes it pay... they end up with their OWN headaches, however, as nonprofits MUST TAKE Medicaid and absorb the cost...no thanks.

IMP forever.

I will NEVER NEVER NEVER work for a hospital or HMO EVER AGAIN....

Matt in Western PA

21 degrees, light snow flurries

Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter

I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market, and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in as i am not in a network, though I have some patients with it who get covered go figure , anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago and rejected their offer told them about HYH and how I work and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonableI still did not take them and their hassle factor is very bad and I knew it would put me over the edge:) LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that Aetna would get between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than whining and saying I hate you:) Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call for Aetna for me so was not crucial New patietn-- I had call them up and say "what do you pay for a 99213 out of network" and they said about 6.00 less than what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her ,she uses her insurance ,pays only a littel and so far she is willing to do it.Its all stoppid though very stoopid I am sittin g here solving a narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run out days ago but I had done up the script and for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is fraught with garbage.You think diagnosis an treatment is hard BUt itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupidJean

I agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!

Larry Lindeman MD

Roscoe Village Family Medicine

2255 W. Roscoe

Chicago, Illinois 60618

www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers.

We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-)

You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine

By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.

Larry Lindeman MD

Roscoe Village Family Medicine

2255 W. Roscoe

Chicago, Illinois 60618

www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts.

M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

Larger groups can negotiate higher fees. I can get up to 40% more from some insurers by being a member of a large PPO. On other plans there is no difference. Solo docs get the least of anybody.

Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

RE going broke... municipalities, vs hospital owned practices.

Yes, hospital owned does NOT mean less cost to the insurer; the insurer is often FORCED to pay MORE to these folks, so this whole idea of lower cost but do better has some built in hypocrisies.

More consolidation in health care OFTEN means HIGHER ADMIN COSTS and therefore the larger hospital owned and corporate groups INSIST on MORE PAYMENT!!

I believe this trend has already shown up in Massachusetts.

As long as WE as individual practices can satisfy our pts' needs, then WE can survive and not feel taken advantage of.

Once the corporatization of medicine goes further.... the costs and reimbursements for these larger groups of hospital and institutional owned practices will inevitably go down, and the promised efficiencies will not materialize.... The only way that costs are reduced (and pay to docs continues at a sustainable level) is when the hospital system OWNS the insurance, and makes it pay... they end up with their OWN headaches, however, as nonprofits MUST TAKE Medicaid and absorb the cost...no thanks.

IMP forever.

I will NEVER NEVER NEVER work for a hospital or HMO EVER AGAIN....

Matt in Western PA

21 degrees, light snow flurries

Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter

I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market, and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in as i am not in a network, though I have some patients with it who get covered go figure , anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago and rejected their offer told them about HYH and how I work and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonableI still did not take them and their hassle factor is very bad and I knew it would put me over the edge:) LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that Aetna would get between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than whining and saying I hate you:) Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call for Aetna for me so was not crucial New patietn-- I had call them up and say "what do you pay for a 99213 out of network" and they said about 6.00 less than what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her ,she uses her insurance ,pays only a littel and so far she is willing to do it.Its all stoppid though very stoopid I am sittin g here solving a narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run out days ago but I had done up the script and for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is fraught with garbage.You think diagnosis an treatment is hard BUt itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupidJean

I agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!

Larry Lindeman MD

Roscoe Village Family Medicine

2255 W. Roscoe

Chicago, Illinois 60618

www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers.

We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-)

You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine

By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.

Larry Lindeman MD

Roscoe Village Family Medicine

2255 W. Roscoe

Chicago, Illinois 60618

www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts.

M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

Larger groups can negotiate higher fees. I can get up to 40% more from some insurers by being a member of a large PPO. On other plans there is no difference. Solo docs get the least of anybody.

Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

RE going broke... municipalities, vs hospital owned practices.

Yes, hospital owned does NOT mean less cost to the insurer; the insurer is often FORCED to pay MORE to these folks, so this whole idea of lower cost but do better has some built in hypocrisies.

More consolidation in health care OFTEN means HIGHER ADMIN COSTS and therefore the larger hospital owned and corporate groups INSIST on MORE PAYMENT!!

I believe this trend has already shown up in Massachusetts.

As long as WE as individual practices can satisfy our pts' needs, then WE can survive and not feel taken advantage of.

Once the corporatization of medicine goes further.... the costs and reimbursements for these larger groups of hospital and institutional owned practices will inevitably go down, and the promised efficiencies will not materialize.... The only way that costs are reduced (and pay to docs continues at a sustainable level) is when the hospital system OWNS the insurance, and makes it pay... they end up with their OWN headaches, however, as nonprofits MUST TAKE Medicaid and absorb the cost...no thanks.

IMP forever.

I will NEVER NEVER NEVER work for a hospital or HMO EVER AGAIN....

Matt in Western PA

21 degrees, light snow flurries

Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter

I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market, and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in as i am not in a network, though I have some patients with it who get covered go figure , anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago and rejected their offer told them about HYH and how I work and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonableI still did not take them and their hassle factor is very bad and I knew it would put me over the edge:) LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that Aetna would get between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than whining and saying I hate you:) Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call for Aetna for me so was not crucial New patietn-- I had call them up and say "what do you pay for a 99213 out of network" and they said about 6.00 less than what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her ,she uses her insurance ,pays only a littel and so far she is willing to do it.Its all stoppid though very stoopid I am sittin g here solving a narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run out days ago but I had done up the script and for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is fraught with garbage.You think diagnosis an treatment is hard BUt itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupidJean

I agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!

Larry Lindeman MD

Roscoe Village Family Medicine

2255 W. Roscoe

Chicago, Illinois 60618

www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers.

We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-)

You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine

By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.

Larry Lindeman MD

Roscoe Village Family Medicine

2255 W. Roscoe

Chicago, Illinois 60618

www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts.

M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

Larger groups can negotiate higher fees. I can get up to 40% more from some insurers by being a member of a large PPO. On other plans there is no difference. Solo docs get the least of anybody.

Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

RE going broke... municipalities, vs hospital owned practices.

Yes, hospital owned does NOT mean less cost to the insurer; the insurer is often FORCED to pay MORE to these folks, so this whole idea of lower cost but do better has some built in hypocrisies.

More consolidation in health care OFTEN means HIGHER ADMIN COSTS and therefore the larger hospital owned and corporate groups INSIST on MORE PAYMENT!!

I believe this trend has already shown up in Massachusetts.

As long as WE as individual practices can satisfy our pts' needs, then WE can survive and not feel taken advantage of.

Once the corporatization of medicine goes further.... the costs and reimbursements for these larger groups of hospital and institutional owned practices will inevitably go down, and the promised efficiencies will not materialize.... The only way that costs are reduced (and pay to docs continues at a sustainable level) is when the hospital system OWNS the insurance, and makes it pay... they end up with their OWN headaches, however, as nonprofits MUST TAKE Medicaid and absorb the cost...no thanks.

IMP forever.

I will NEVER NEVER NEVER work for a hospital or HMO EVER AGAIN....

Matt in Western PA

21 degrees, light snow flurries

Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter

I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market, and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in as i am not in a network, though I have some patients with it who get covered go figure , anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago and rejected their offer told them about HYH and how I work and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonableI still did not take them and their hassle factor is very bad and I knew it would put me over the edge:) LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that Aetna would get between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than whining and saying I hate you:) Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call for Aetna for me so was not crucial New patietn-- I had call them up and say "what do you pay for a 99213 out of network" and they said about 6.00 less than what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her ,she uses her insurance ,pays only a littel and so far she is willing to do it.Its all stoppid though very stoopid I am sittin g here solving a narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run out days ago but I had done up the script and for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is fraught with garbage.You think diagnosis an treatment is hard BUt itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupidJean

I agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!

Larry Lindeman MD

Roscoe Village Family Medicine

2255 W. Roscoe

Chicago, Illinois 60618

www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers.

We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-)

You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine

By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.

Larry Lindeman MD

Roscoe Village Family Medicine

2255 W. Roscoe

Chicago, Illinois 60618

www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts.

M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

Kathleen, Having just come off of 6 months of negotiations to join a local mega group that is affiliated with a hospital, I can tell you that they told us that for 2009, steve's income would have been $30,000 higher than what we actually made. We didn't sign with them because they weren't going to allow him to continue working his 2nd job, basically. But there were other factors, too, and I'm glad that he stayed solo ( at least for now).

Can someone help me with some verifiable information? It's been said that hospital owned practices receive higher fees for the same care that could be rendered by non-hospital owned practices. I've assumed this but is this really true? Where is the cold hard information? Impossible to get other docs, even friends, to talk. everyone is terrified of colluding. The third party players aren't forthcoming of course. i continue to casually talk with my state senator neighbor about 'healthcare' in Massachusetts. I'd like to pull some hard stuff together and have a real sit down conversation with him. The municipalities here are going broke. The cost of healthcare 'coverage' is cited a big problem. If ever there was a perfect target project for a local network of IMPS to show its stuff, this is it. We know that superb primary care not only saves money, but oh by the way, superb primary care improves quality in verifiable measurements. Two problems: 1. The mandated health insurance coverage, everyone is a captive. 2. The powerful hospital networks. Both of these problem institutions have the incentive, money and power to fight and kill such a project. But...I'd like to have some facts about the fee differential between hospital practices and non-hospital practices. Kathleen -- did you get coal in your stocking? :-( All the junk that is coming our way and will not stop -- hospitals once again here buying primaries and then they'll staff their clinics... many of the 50+ yo docs have not been renewed as they "cost too much"... shades of HMOs that the hospital will "buy out" and doc and "run them more efficiently" ie, downstaffing and make you fill out registries to show how "well you're doing" but ignore the pt. Other trend, though, that gives me hope is that "regular" pts with well paying insurance now "can't get into the docs" because the hospital run offices have staff that feel overwhelmed so push off new pts... that I can live with! Matt in Western PAHappy that IMP in Washington DC in 2011 -- I'm really going to try to go this year!, even if it's only to watch touch type! Hahah Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market, and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in as i am not in a network, though I have some patients with it who get covered go figure , anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago and rejected their offer told them about HYH and how I work and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonableI still did not take them and their hassle factor is very bad and I knew it would put me over the edge:) LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that Aetna would get between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than whining and saying I hate you:) Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call for Aetna for me so was not crucial New patietn-- I had call them up and say "what do you pay for a 99213 out of network" and they said about 6.00 less than what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her ,she uses her insurance ,pays only a littel and so far she is willing to do it.Its all stoppid though very stoopid I am sittin g here solving a narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run out days ago but I had done up the script and for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is fraught with garbage.You think diagnosis an treatment is hard BUt itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupidI agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers. We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-) You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts. M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

Kathleen, Having just come off of 6 months of negotiations to join a local mega group that is affiliated with a hospital, I can tell you that they told us that for 2009, steve's income would have been $30,000 higher than what we actually made. We didn't sign with them because they weren't going to allow him to continue working his 2nd job, basically. But there were other factors, too, and I'm glad that he stayed solo ( at least for now).

Can someone help me with some verifiable information? It's been said that hospital owned practices receive higher fees for the same care that could be rendered by non-hospital owned practices. I've assumed this but is this really true? Where is the cold hard information? Impossible to get other docs, even friends, to talk. everyone is terrified of colluding. The third party players aren't forthcoming of course. i continue to casually talk with my state senator neighbor about 'healthcare' in Massachusetts. I'd like to pull some hard stuff together and have a real sit down conversation with him. The municipalities here are going broke. The cost of healthcare 'coverage' is cited a big problem. If ever there was a perfect target project for a local network of IMPS to show its stuff, this is it. We know that superb primary care not only saves money, but oh by the way, superb primary care improves quality in verifiable measurements. Two problems: 1. The mandated health insurance coverage, everyone is a captive. 2. The powerful hospital networks. Both of these problem institutions have the incentive, money and power to fight and kill such a project. But...I'd like to have some facts about the fee differential between hospital practices and non-hospital practices. Kathleen -- did you get coal in your stocking? :-( All the junk that is coming our way and will not stop -- hospitals once again here buying primaries and then they'll staff their clinics... many of the 50+ yo docs have not been renewed as they "cost too much"... shades of HMOs that the hospital will "buy out" and doc and "run them more efficiently" ie, downstaffing and make you fill out registries to show how "well you're doing" but ignore the pt. Other trend, though, that gives me hope is that "regular" pts with well paying insurance now "can't get into the docs" because the hospital run offices have staff that feel overwhelmed so push off new pts... that I can live with! Matt in Western PAHappy that IMP in Washington DC in 2011 -- I'm really going to try to go this year!, even if it's only to watch touch type! Hahah Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market, and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in as i am not in a network, though I have some patients with it who get covered go figure , anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago and rejected their offer told them about HYH and how I work and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonableI still did not take them and their hassle factor is very bad and I knew it would put me over the edge:) LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that Aetna would get between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than whining and saying I hate you:) Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call for Aetna for me so was not crucial New patietn-- I had call them up and say "what do you pay for a 99213 out of network" and they said about 6.00 less than what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her ,she uses her insurance ,pays only a littel and so far she is willing to do it.Its all stoppid though very stoopid I am sittin g here solving a narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run out days ago but I had done up the script and for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is fraught with garbage.You think diagnosis an treatment is hard BUt itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupidI agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers. We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-) You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts. M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

Thanks, Jean. Good point about the Mass med society. They should have some information. I'll see what I can dig up and report in. Might this be an issue worthy of our advocacy efforts? Last year the state atty general released some information regarding larger hospitals having the power to negotiate for more money, but it wasn't clear to what the money was attached. No real news here, just as we all thought. Money = Power, Power = Money.To : So glad you had the smarts and guts to pull out of the deal. BravoTo Marty: Exactly. Rock on.To Larry: What does the PPO admin charge individual practices for its negotiating services? Put another way, is there a reliable percentage of the ?revenue,?fee negotiated? For anyone: Another question, How is it that a PPO can do the negotiating but if the practices gather together to negotiate, it becomes an issued of restricting fair trade? Call me babe in the big woods, however, friends in large and small practices, owned and non-owned, are not clear on much of this either.Kathleen Can someone help me with some verifiable information? It's been said that hospital owned practices receive higher fees for the same care that could be rendered by non-hospital owned practices. I've assumed this but is this really true? Where is the cold hard information? Impossible to get other docs, even friends, to talk. everyone is terrified of colluding. The third party players aren't forthcoming of course. they get a facilty fee on top op of the fee they are paid I think is how it goes..and I don;t know much but here for a while MaInecare --medicaid --was paying hospital docs a higher fee I think that was to encourage them t o s ee those folks. Cough cough If you paid me more I would see them too This has changed I believe in t he last yearBut everything is different everywhere. It would seem to me that you state medical association would be able to talk to you about thisi continue to casually talk with my state senator neighbor about 'healthcare' in Massachusetts. I'd like to pull some hard stuff together and have a real sit down conversation with him. The municipalities here are going broke. The cost of healthcare 'coverage' is cited a big problem. If ever there was a perfect target project for a local network of IMPS to show its stuff, this is it. We know that superb primary care not only saves money, but oh by the way, superb primary care improves quality in verifiable measurements. Two problems: 1. The mandated health insurance coverage, everyone is a captive. 2. The powerful hospital networks. Both of these problem institutions have the incentive, money and power to fight and kill such a project. But...I'd like to have some facts about the fee differential between hospital practices and non-hospital practices. Kathleen -- did you get coal in your stocking? :-( All the junk that is coming our way and will not stop -- hospitals once again here buying primaries and then they'll staff their clinics... many of the 50+ yo docs have not been renewed as they "cost too much"... shades of HMOs that the hospital will "buy out" and doc and "run them more efficiently" ie, downstaffing and make you fill out registries to show how "well you're doing" but ignore the pt. Other trend, though, that gives me hope is that "regular" pts with well paying insurance now "can't get into the docs" because the hospital run offices have staff that feel overwhelmed so push off new pts... that I can live with! Matt in Western PAHappy that IMP in Washington DC in 2011 -- I'm really going to try to go this year!, even if it's only to watch touch type! Hahah Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market, and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in as i am not in a network, though I have some patients with it who get covered go figure , anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago and rejected their offer told them about HYH and how I work and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonableI still did not take them and their hassle factor is very bad and I knew it would put me over the edge:) LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that Aetna would get between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than whining and saying I hate you:) Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call for Aetna for me so was not crucial New patietn-- I had call them up and say "what do you pay for a 99213 out of network" and they said about 6.00 less than what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her ,she uses her insurance ,pays only a littel and so far she is willing to do it.Its all stoppid though very stoopid I am sittin g here solving a narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run out days ago but I had done up the script and for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is fraught with garbage.You think diagnosis an treatment is hard BUt itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupidI agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers. We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-) You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts. M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

Thanks, Jean. Good point about the Mass med society. They should have some information. I'll see what I can dig up and report in. Might this be an issue worthy of our advocacy efforts? Last year the state atty general released some information regarding larger hospitals having the power to negotiate for more money, but it wasn't clear to what the money was attached. No real news here, just as we all thought. Money = Power, Power = Money.To : So glad you had the smarts and guts to pull out of the deal. BravoTo Marty: Exactly. Rock on.To Larry: What does the PPO admin charge individual practices for its negotiating services? Put another way, is there a reliable percentage of the ?revenue,?fee negotiated? For anyone: Another question, How is it that a PPO can do the negotiating but if the practices gather together to negotiate, it becomes an issued of restricting fair trade? Call me babe in the big woods, however, friends in large and small practices, owned and non-owned, are not clear on much of this either.Kathleen Can someone help me with some verifiable information? It's been said that hospital owned practices receive higher fees for the same care that could be rendered by non-hospital owned practices. I've assumed this but is this really true? Where is the cold hard information? Impossible to get other docs, even friends, to talk. everyone is terrified of colluding. The third party players aren't forthcoming of course. they get a facilty fee on top op of the fee they are paid I think is how it goes..and I don;t know much but here for a while MaInecare --medicaid --was paying hospital docs a higher fee I think that was to encourage them t o s ee those folks. Cough cough If you paid me more I would see them too This has changed I believe in t he last yearBut everything is different everywhere. It would seem to me that you state medical association would be able to talk to you about thisi continue to casually talk with my state senator neighbor about 'healthcare' in Massachusetts. I'd like to pull some hard stuff together and have a real sit down conversation with him. The municipalities here are going broke. The cost of healthcare 'coverage' is cited a big problem. If ever there was a perfect target project for a local network of IMPS to show its stuff, this is it. We know that superb primary care not only saves money, but oh by the way, superb primary care improves quality in verifiable measurements. Two problems: 1. The mandated health insurance coverage, everyone is a captive. 2. The powerful hospital networks. Both of these problem institutions have the incentive, money and power to fight and kill such a project. But...I'd like to have some facts about the fee differential between hospital practices and non-hospital practices. Kathleen -- did you get coal in your stocking? :-( All the junk that is coming our way and will not stop -- hospitals once again here buying primaries and then they'll staff their clinics... many of the 50+ yo docs have not been renewed as they "cost too much"... shades of HMOs that the hospital will "buy out" and doc and "run them more efficiently" ie, downstaffing and make you fill out registries to show how "well you're doing" but ignore the pt. Other trend, though, that gives me hope is that "regular" pts with well paying insurance now "can't get into the docs" because the hospital run offices have staff that feel overwhelmed so push off new pts... that I can live with! Matt in Western PAHappy that IMP in Washington DC in 2011 -- I'm really going to try to go this year!, even if it's only to watch touch type! Hahah Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market, and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in as i am not in a network, though I have some patients with it who get covered go figure , anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago and rejected their offer told them about HYH and how I work and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonableI still did not take them and their hassle factor is very bad and I knew it would put me over the edge:) LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that Aetna would get between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than whining and saying I hate you:) Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call for Aetna for me so was not crucial New patietn-- I had call them up and say "what do you pay for a 99213 out of network" and they said about 6.00 less than what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her ,she uses her insurance ,pays only a littel and so far she is willing to do it.Its all stoppid though very stoopid I am sittin g here solving a narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run out days ago but I had done up the script and for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is fraught with garbage.You think diagnosis an treatment is hard BUt itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupidI agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers. We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-) You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts. M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

I get up to 50% more directly from my patients by being solo and not

participating with insurers.

No billing fees.

No waiting for a check.

AR almost nil.

I have 1 fte in my office who also works for my wife, a psychiatrist.

I don't waste time looking over third party contracts.

As most of you who are official IMP's, I work directly with patients.

Big corporations always promise their workers better pay and benefits, but they

are rarely realized in the end, as the need for ever increasing corporate

profits invariably looks to cost cutting, and thereby quality cutting, usually

at the hands of it's employees, in this case, physicians.

My suggestion.

Ride out the storm as an independent physician, away from corporate buyouts.

Stay true to your patients and yourself.

Horvitz, D.O.

stown, N.J.

Www.drhorvitz.com

Sent from my iPad

Posted

I get up to 50% more directly from my patients by being solo and not

participating with insurers.

No billing fees.

No waiting for a check.

AR almost nil.

I have 1 fte in my office who also works for my wife, a psychiatrist.

I don't waste time looking over third party contracts.

As most of you who are official IMP's, I work directly with patients.

Big corporations always promise their workers better pay and benefits, but they

are rarely realized in the end, as the need for ever increasing corporate

profits invariably looks to cost cutting, and thereby quality cutting, usually

at the hands of it's employees, in this case, physicians.

My suggestion.

Ride out the storm as an independent physician, away from corporate buyouts.

Stay true to your patients and yourself.

Horvitz, D.O.

stown, N.J.

Www.drhorvitz.com

Sent from my iPad

Posted

The situation in Massachusetts is more distorted than in other

states due to the enormous market power of Partner's Healthcare,

even in outpatient medicine.   The Boston

Globe did a Spotlight series on this a couple of years ago

and Levy frequently discusses the issue on his blog. 

Basically, Mass General, Brigham and Women's and the other big names

have enormous marketing clout in Mass.   Since most patients are not

paying directly for their own care, many prefer to go to these

facilities.  Partner's Healthcare uses this leverage to get much

higher fees from the third party payers.

On the PPO negotiating question, from what I've read lately that is

as complex and legally risky as the noncovered benefits fee issue we

discussed here recently.

Mass. sounds like a tough state for primary care, more so for

starting a peds practice.  Have you considered southern New

Hampshire?

(Mass. exile  in Maine)

 

Thanks, Jean.  Good point about the Mass med society.

 They should have some information.  I'll see what I can

dig up and report in.  Might this be an issue worthy of

our advocacy efforts?  

Last year the state atty general released some

information regarding larger hospitals having the power to

negotiate for more money, but it wasn't clear to what the

money was attached.   No real news here, just as we all

thought.  Money = Power, Power = Money.

To :  So glad you had the smarts and guts to

pull out of the deal.  Bravo

To Marty:  Exactly.  Rock on.

To Larry:  What does the PPO admin charge individual

practices for its negotiating services?  Put another

way, is there a reliable percentage of the ?revenue,?fee

negotiated?   

For anyone:  Another question, How is it that a PPO

can do the negotiating but if the practices gather

together to negotiate, it becomes an issued of

restricting fair trade?  

Call me babe in the big woods, however, friends in

large and small practices, owned and non-owned, are not

clear on much of this either.

Kathleen

Posted

The situation in Massachusetts is more distorted than in other

states due to the enormous market power of Partner's Healthcare,

even in outpatient medicine.   The Boston

Globe did a Spotlight series on this a couple of years ago

and Levy frequently discusses the issue on his blog. 

Basically, Mass General, Brigham and Women's and the other big names

have enormous marketing clout in Mass.   Since most patients are not

paying directly for their own care, many prefer to go to these

facilities.  Partner's Healthcare uses this leverage to get much

higher fees from the third party payers.

On the PPO negotiating question, from what I've read lately that is

as complex and legally risky as the noncovered benefits fee issue we

discussed here recently.

Mass. sounds like a tough state for primary care, more so for

starting a peds practice.  Have you considered southern New

Hampshire?

(Mass. exile  in Maine)

 

Thanks, Jean.  Good point about the Mass med society.

 They should have some information.  I'll see what I can

dig up and report in.  Might this be an issue worthy of

our advocacy efforts?  

Last year the state atty general released some

information regarding larger hospitals having the power to

negotiate for more money, but it wasn't clear to what the

money was attached.   No real news here, just as we all

thought.  Money = Power, Power = Money.

To :  So glad you had the smarts and guts to

pull out of the deal.  Bravo

To Marty:  Exactly.  Rock on.

To Larry:  What does the PPO admin charge individual

practices for its negotiating services?  Put another

way, is there a reliable percentage of the ?revenue,?fee

negotiated?   

For anyone:  Another question, How is it that a PPO

can do the negotiating but if the practices gather

together to negotiate, it becomes an issued of

restricting fair trade?  

Call me babe in the big woods, however, friends in

large and small practices, owned and non-owned, are not

clear on much of this either.

Kathleen

Posted

PPO's can only negotiate prices if they are "clinically integrated". That is how they get around antitrust. The group has to act as group to improve quality.I had a membership fee of $250 to join. There is no ongoing fee. I belong to an unusually good PHO but they have had enough publicity that many are trying to copy their business model. Because of the improvements in quality and cost with coordination of care the feds I hear are encouraging this kind of quality integration.

Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

Thanks, Jean. Good point about the Mass med society. They should have some information. I'll see what I can dig up and report in. Might this be an issue worthy of our advocacy efforts? Last year the state atty general released some information regarding larger hospitals having the power to negotiate for more money, but it wasn't clear to what the money was attached. No real news here, just as we all thought. Money = Power, Power = Money.To : So glad you had the smarts and guts to pull out of the deal. BravoTo Marty: Exactly. Rock on.To Larry: What does the PPO admin charge individual practices for its negotiating services? Put another way, is there a reliable percentage of the ?revenue,?fee negotiated? For anyone: Another question, How is it that a PPO can do the negotiating but if the practices gather together to

negotiate, it becomes an issued of restricting fair trade? Call me babe in the big woods, however, friends in large and small practices, owned and non-owned, are not clear on much of this either.Kathleen Can someone help me with some verifiable information? It's been said that hospital owned practices receive higher fees for the same care that could be rendered by non-hospital owned practices. I've assumed this but is this really true? Where is the cold hard information? Impossible to get other docs, even friends, to talk. everyone is terrified of colluding. The third party players aren't forthcoming of course. they get a facilty fee on top op of the fee they are paid I think is how it goes..and I don;t know much but here for a while MaInecare --medicaid --was paying hospital docs a higher fee I think that was to encourage them t o s ee those folks. Cough cough If you paid me more I would see them too This has changed I believe in t he last yearBut everything is different everywhere. It would seem to me that you state medical association would be able to talk to you about thisi continue to casually talk with my state senator neighbor about 'healthcare' in Massachusetts. I'd like to pull some hard stuff together and have a real sit down conversation with him. The municipalities here are going broke. The cost of healthcare 'coverage' is cited a big problem. If ever there was a perfect target project for a local network of IMPS to show its stuff, this is it. We know that superb primary care not only saves money, but oh by the way, superb primary care improves quality in verifiable measurements. Two problems: 1. The mandated health insurance coverage, everyone is a captive. 2. The powerful hospital networks. Both of these problem institutions have the incentive, money and

power to fight and kill such a project. But...I'd like to have some facts about the fee differential between hospital practices and non-hospital practices. Kathleen -- did you get coal in your stocking? :-( All the junk that is coming our way and will not stop -- hospitals once again here buying primaries and then they'll staff their clinics... many of the 50+ yo docs have not been renewed as they "cost too much"... shades of HMOs that the hospital will "buy out" and doc and "run them more efficiently" ie, downstaffing and make you fill out registries to show how "well you're doing" but ignore the pt. Other trend, though, that gives me hope is that "regular" pts with well paying insurance now "can't get into the docs" because the hospital run offices have staff that feel overwhelmed so push

off new pts... that I can live with! Matt in Western PAHappy that IMP in Washington DC in 2011 -- I'm really going to try to go this year!, even if it's only to watch touch type! Hahah Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market, and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in as i am not in a network, though I have some patients with it who get covered go figure , anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago and rejected their offer told them about HYH and how I work and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonableI still did not take them and their hassle factor is very bad and I knew it would put me over the edge:) LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that Aetna

would get between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than whining and saying I hate you:) Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call for Aetna for me so was not crucial New patietn-- I had call them up and say "what do you pay for a 99213 out of network" and they said about 6.00 less than what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her ,she uses her insurance ,pays only a littel and so far she is willing to do it.Its all stoppid though very stoopid I am sittin g here solving a narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run out days ago but I had done up the script and for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is fraught with garbage.You think

diagnosis an treatment is hard BUt itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupidI agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an

increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers. We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-)On Dec 25, 2010, at 7:06 PM,

wrote: You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.comOn Dec 23, 2010, at 11:00 PM,

wrote: Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts. M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- Elaine

Chu M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in

error. -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

PPO's can only negotiate prices if they are "clinically integrated". That is how they get around antitrust. The group has to act as group to improve quality.I had a membership fee of $250 to join. There is no ongoing fee. I belong to an unusually good PHO but they have had enough publicity that many are trying to copy their business model. Because of the improvements in quality and cost with coordination of care the feds I hear are encouraging this kind of quality integration.

Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

Thanks, Jean. Good point about the Mass med society. They should have some information. I'll see what I can dig up and report in. Might this be an issue worthy of our advocacy efforts? Last year the state atty general released some information regarding larger hospitals having the power to negotiate for more money, but it wasn't clear to what the money was attached. No real news here, just as we all thought. Money = Power, Power = Money.To : So glad you had the smarts and guts to pull out of the deal. BravoTo Marty: Exactly. Rock on.To Larry: What does the PPO admin charge individual practices for its negotiating services? Put another way, is there a reliable percentage of the ?revenue,?fee negotiated? For anyone: Another question, How is it that a PPO can do the negotiating but if the practices gather together to

negotiate, it becomes an issued of restricting fair trade? Call me babe in the big woods, however, friends in large and small practices, owned and non-owned, are not clear on much of this either.Kathleen Can someone help me with some verifiable information? It's been said that hospital owned practices receive higher fees for the same care that could be rendered by non-hospital owned practices. I've assumed this but is this really true? Where is the cold hard information? Impossible to get other docs, even friends, to talk. everyone is terrified of colluding. The third party players aren't forthcoming of course. they get a facilty fee on top op of the fee they are paid I think is how it goes..and I don;t know much but here for a while MaInecare --medicaid --was paying hospital docs a higher fee I think that was to encourage them t o s ee those folks. Cough cough If you paid me more I would see them too This has changed I believe in t he last yearBut everything is different everywhere. It would seem to me that you state medical association would be able to talk to you about thisi continue to casually talk with my state senator neighbor about 'healthcare' in Massachusetts. I'd like to pull some hard stuff together and have a real sit down conversation with him. The municipalities here are going broke. The cost of healthcare 'coverage' is cited a big problem. If ever there was a perfect target project for a local network of IMPS to show its stuff, this is it. We know that superb primary care not only saves money, but oh by the way, superb primary care improves quality in verifiable measurements. Two problems: 1. The mandated health insurance coverage, everyone is a captive. 2. The powerful hospital networks. Both of these problem institutions have the incentive, money and

power to fight and kill such a project. But...I'd like to have some facts about the fee differential between hospital practices and non-hospital practices. Kathleen -- did you get coal in your stocking? :-( All the junk that is coming our way and will not stop -- hospitals once again here buying primaries and then they'll staff their clinics... many of the 50+ yo docs have not been renewed as they "cost too much"... shades of HMOs that the hospital will "buy out" and doc and "run them more efficiently" ie, downstaffing and make you fill out registries to show how "well you're doing" but ignore the pt. Other trend, though, that gives me hope is that "regular" pts with well paying insurance now "can't get into the docs" because the hospital run offices have staff that feel overwhelmed so push

off new pts... that I can live with! Matt in Western PAHappy that IMP in Washington DC in 2011 -- I'm really going to try to go this year!, even if it's only to watch touch type! Hahah Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market, and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in as i am not in a network, though I have some patients with it who get covered go figure , anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago and rejected their offer told them about HYH and how I work and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonableI still did not take them and their hassle factor is very bad and I knew it would put me over the edge:) LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that Aetna

would get between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than whining and saying I hate you:) Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call for Aetna for me so was not crucial New patietn-- I had call them up and say "what do you pay for a 99213 out of network" and they said about 6.00 less than what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her ,she uses her insurance ,pays only a littel and so far she is willing to do it.Its all stoppid though very stoopid I am sittin g here solving a narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run out days ago but I had done up the script and for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is fraught with garbage.You think

diagnosis an treatment is hard BUt itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupidI agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an

increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers. We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-)On Dec 25, 2010, at 7:06 PM,

wrote: You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.Larry Lindeman MDRoscoe Village Family Medicine2255 W. RoscoeChicago, Illinois 60618www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.comOn Dec 23, 2010, at 11:00 PM,

wrote: Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts. M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. -- Elaine

Chu M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in

error. -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

They can negotiate higher rates, but this is not isolated to larger groups.

Some great independent docs who know the right people and have great

business skills can get better rates too. Very subjective - all I can say. . .

.. . .and interesting. . .

some people 'round here getting mid 70s or higher conversion factors

and others in the 50s. Go figure . .

Pamela

> >>>

> >>>>

> >>>>

> >>>> Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection

> >>>> letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the

> >>>> Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff

> >>>> like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with

> >>>> patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these

> >>>> services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get

> >>>> one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my

> >>>> lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is

> >>>> full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my

> >>>> BX pts are some of my favorite pts.

> >>>>

> >>>>

> >>>> M.D.

> >>>> www.elainemd.com

> >>>> Office:

> >>>> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

> >>>> imagined.

> >>>> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,

> >>>> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information

> >>>> (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only

> >>>> for the use of the individual or entity named above.

> >>>>

> >>>>

> >>>>

> >>>> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

> >>>> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute

> >>>> it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have

> >>>> received this transmission in error, please notify the sender

> >>>> immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email

> >>>> in error.

> >>>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>> --

> >>> M.D.

> >>> www.elainemd.com

> >>> Office:

> >>> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

> >>> imagined.

> >>> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,

> >>> highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI)

> >>> and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the

> >>> use of the individual or entity named above.

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

> >>> not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it.

> >>> If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received

> >>> this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately

> >>> and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

> >>>

> >>

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > --

> > PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and

> > that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your

> > chart ( be careful what you say!)

> > Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions

> > Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the

> > matter is more urgent .

> >

> >

> > MD

> >

> >

> > ph fax

> > impcenter.org

> >

> >

> >

>

Posted

Amen Matt.

Populist movement afoot. . .

Yes, people are getting out of their La-Z-Boys,

putting down their remotes and actually designing

ideal hospitals and clinics.

Seriously. It's happening:

http://www.idealmedicalcare.org/ideal-clinic.php

http://www.idealmedicalcare.org/ideal-hospital.php

Onward,

~ Pamela

Pamela Wible, MD

3575 St. #220

Eugene, OR 97405

roxywible@...

www.idealmedicalcare.org

>

>

>

>

>

> Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this

rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the

Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky

I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to

have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so

how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my

lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not

taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my

favorite pts.

>

>

> M.D.

> www.elainemd.com

> Office:

> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

imagined.

> This email transmission may contain protected and

privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI)

and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the

individual or entity named above.

>

>

>

> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you

may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you

are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in

error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the

information that email in error.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> --

> M.D.

> www.elainemd.com

> Office:

> Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've

imagined.

> This email transmission may contain protected and privileged,

highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal

information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or

entity named above.

>

>

>

> If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may

not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are

not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error,

please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information

that email in error.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> --

> PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and

that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be

careful what you say!)

> Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions

> Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the

matter is more urgent .

>

>

> MD

>

>

> ph fax

> impcenter.org

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> --

> PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that

Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful

what you say!)

> Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions

> Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is

more urgent .

>

>

> MD

>

>

> ph fax

> impcenter.org

>

Posted

I once was tempted to join the hospital group. I had a proforma done by the hospital and they specifically showed me the higher rates of reimbursements. My pay is 60-80% below the hospital's negotiated rates. The insurance companies laugh at me when I want "equal pay for equal work."

Will Conner, M.D.

Family Medicine Physician

211 W. s St Ste. 102

s, N.C. 28105

--- Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter

I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market, and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in as i am not in a network, though I have some patients with it who get covered go figure , anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago and rejected their offer told them about HYH and how I work and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonableI still did not take them and their hassle factor is very bad and I knew it would put me over the edge:) LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that Aetna would get between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than whining and saying I hate you:) Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call for Aetna for me so was not crucial New patietn-- I had call them up and say "what do you pay for a 99213 out of network" and they said about 6.00 less than what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her ,she uses her insurance ,pays only a littel and so far she is willing to do it.Its all stoppid though very stoopid I am sittin g here solving a narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run out days ago but I had done up the script and for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is fraught with garbage.You think diagnosis an treatment is hard BUt itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupidJean

I agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!

Larry Lindeman MD

Roscoe Village Family Medicine

2255 W. Roscoe

Chicago, Illinois 60618

www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers.

We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-)

You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine

By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.

Larry Lindeman MD

Roscoe Village Family Medicine

2255 W. Roscoe

Chicago, Illinois 60618

www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts.

M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

Hey , hows the snow up there? We got ~18 inches last night :)Thank you for your knowledge and acknowledgement of the situation here in Massachusetts. I know it's difficult for most, even those of us who are living with it, to wrap our minds around it. Trying to explain it only sounds like hyperbolic Sermo doom talk to those outside of our fair state. You really have to see it / live it to believe it. But it is real. Not a friendly environment for medical practice of any stripe. I've heard it said that we're lucky as physicians, because we can just hang out our shingle and we'll always have a job. Not so here. New Hampshire, Rhode Island and Maine all look better than Massachusetts but they are a long commute from my part time gig at BU and husband's job in Boston. As you pointed out there are multiple mega hospital systems here. They have more power than God. Then there are the giant third party 'payers' with more money than God. They've just been granted more power to get more money as a result of the Massachusetts mandated insurance coverage law • The hospital players: In the T-rex goliath category we have Partners (Mass Gen, B & W et al) and Caregroup ( Levy and BIDMC) In the smaller but still huge, hissing cousin category, we have UMass med, TuftsNEMC, BUMC, Lahey and the now for-profit Caritas system purchased recently by capital investment group, Cerberus.• The third party payer players: Blue Cross Harvard Pilgrim The half dozen of also-ran carnivores, Fallon, Aetna, Cigna, Coventry, Health New England (a quasi HMO)• The practice players: Atrius Harvard Vanguard is the largest non-hospital owned, physician- led practice with ~800 physicians and ~4k NPs, PAs, nurses and MAs in 28 locations. Rules of engagement:The hospitals gobble up the practices. The practices feed patients to the hospitals. The third party payers try to eat the hospitals.But hospitals have worked a deal that gives them extra rations from the third party payers. I'm still not clear as to why it should be that hospital affiliated practices get better pay even though they may not be within earshot of the hospitals themselves. Cannibalism and incest are acceptable among the players.Hospitals and third party payers both try to take bites out of Atrius Harvard Vanguard's hide. All other practices become assimilated or run for their lives. The patients wait 6 months to a year to get an appointment with a PCP, if they can find a PCP. Any practice other than AHV, that resists the pull of the hospital black holes finds itself without hospital privileges. The patients of the yet to be assimilated practices encounter obstacles and hassles when they need the access to hospitals. This continues until the practice succumbs or the patient moves on to a hospital practice. I'm watching this process unfold as a friend's well established, medium sized (5 doc, 3NP) practice is trying to resist. Not pretty. The half-time score:It looks like it should be even up between the hospitals and the third party payers, however the TPPs control the money. Atrius Harvard Vanguard should have some traction because it has lots and lots of patients and because its size might make it difficult to swallow. Sadly AHV is so large that it can't move quickly because it has to carry an over grown, non-revenue producing administration. Further, AHV does not have the revenues from procedure profit centers as the hospitals do. Patients lose.Potential game change: There needs to be a small disturbance on this playing field. I have some ideas involving a network of IMPs rescuing a couple of desperate municipalities. This would require a small miracle; said municipalities would need special dispensation from the mandated insurance coverage law. A long shot. With forlorn hope in Beantown,Kathleen The situation in Massachusetts is more distorted than in other states due to the enormous market power of Partner's Healthcare, even in outpatient medicine. The Boston Globe did a Spotlight series on this a couple of years ago and Levy frequently discusses the issue on his blog. Basically, Mass General, Brigham and Women's and the other big names have enormous marketing clout in Mass. Since most patients are not paying directly for their own care, many prefer to go to these facilities. Partner's Healthcare uses this leverage to get much higher fees from the third party payers.On the PPO negotiating question, from what I've read lately that is as complex and legally risky as the noncovered benefits fee issue we discussed here recently. Mass. sounds like a tough state for primary care, more so for starting a peds practice. Have you considered southern New Hampshire? (Mass. exile in Maine) Thanks, Jean. Good point about the Mass med society. They should have some information. I'll see what I can dig up and report in. Might this be an issue worthy of our advocacy efforts? Last year the state atty general released some information regarding larger hospitals having the power to negotiate for more money, but it wasn't clear to what the money was attached. No real news here, just as we all thought. Money = Power, Power = Money.To : So glad you had the smarts and guts to pull out of the deal. BravoTo Marty: Exactly. Rock on.To Larry: What does the PPO admin charge individual practices for its negotiating services? Put another way, is there a reliable percentage of the ?revenue,?fee negotiated? For anyone: Another question, How is it that a PPO can do the negotiating but if the practices gather together to negotiate, it becomes an issued of restricting fair trade? Call me babe in the big woods, however, friends in large and small practices, owned and non-owned, are not clear on much of this either.Kathleen

Posted

And the reason this is not seen as anti-competitive and anti-trust when the Super sized purchaser is in bed with the largest providers of the services to be paying them higher prices is???? As opposed to going after the insurance carriers who have an anti-trust waiver at a federal level, has anyone every attempted to sue or prosecute the super large providers and hospitals for anti-free trade practices colluding with the carriers??? These guys are not covered by the same laws.. The carriers are allowed to share info and collude so they have access to the information they need to "set the community rates"...

But working with the purchaser of the services to pay them higher than the smaller guys in town is a perfect collusion against us small guys to squeeze us out of the market by literately starving us out while expecting us to provide the same level of care and services... They are certain doing this and are guilty of it, it is only a matter of getting a right minded, anti-private carrier, pro-market based states AG to finally go after some of these guys... Just because the carriers have the right to collude among themselves doesn't give them and the hospitals and super groups the right to low ball, high ball us right out of the market...

The law was specific in the concept that they have limited amount of freedom to collude to do this setting of the community rates... It never stated or was intended to allow them keep the prices paid higher, artificially higher than if left alone to their own free market fluctuations.... honestly I really think a few folks should start looking into this and read the actual original law... Also our Senator here in NYS, Chuck Shummer and Senator Lehey of Vermont were both half serious about taking away this waiver from the insurance carriers as they were making life miserable for the President and the Dem's as they kept insisting in taking an unfair amount of ground in the Insurance Reform laws... They even started holding hearings on the subject. And I believe Harry Reid was on board in repealing this as well... I believe the law was written by a Senator from his state back during WWII when it was originally proposed and passed. He was even

quoted as saying, he had a decent amount for this past Senator but he too could not understand just what the heck the man was thinking when he originally put the bill together....

Anybody feel like attempt to work and pick away at this one??? It seems clear to me that almost certainly this law was never intended to be used for anything other than the sharing of knowledge for the best and most accurate setting of premium rates... To use it to allow for the collusion between the carriers who are at least covered by the law in some way with the providers of the services that the carriers are to be paying for, to keep the prices artificially out of balance for some providers verses others so as to pervert the entire market and the prices for the end consumers, and that these providers were never intended to be captured and covered by the law in terms of going beyond free giving up their metrics and prices for measurement by the waived carriers seems to be an extreme violation of any form of anti-trust and collusion laws.....

Question what was the name of this law again... Like the Maclareen Fergerson act or something like that??? Oh it would be so glorious to finally find a way to take a chunk out of these bastards... Happy New Year...

To: Sent: Mon, December 27, 2010 8:28:36 PMSubject: RE: good trends and bad for solo, noncorporate docs

I once was tempted to join the hospital group. I had a proforma done by the hospital and they specifically showed me the higher rates of reimbursements. My pay is 60-80% below the hospital's negotiated rates. The insurance companies laugh at me when I want "equal pay for equal work."

Will Conner, M.D.

Family Medicine Physician

211 W. s St Ste. 102

s, N.C. 28105

--- Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter

I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market, and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in as i am not in a network, though I have some patients with it who get covered go figure , anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago and rejected their offer told them about HYH and how I work and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonableI still did not take them and their hassle factor is very bad and I knew it would put me over the edge:) LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that Aetna would get between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than whining and saying I hate you:) Just got anew aetna patietn

anyway and there is not much call for Aetna for me so was not crucial New patietn-- I had call them up and say "what do you pay for a 99213 out of network" and they said about 6.00 less than what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her ,she uses her insurance ,pays only a littel and so far she is willing to do it.Its all stoppid though very stoopid I am sittin g here solving a narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run out days ago but I had done up the script and for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is fraught with garbage.You think diagnosis an treatment is hard BUt itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and

there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupidJean

I agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!

Larry Lindeman MD

Roscoe Village Family Medicine

2255 W. Roscoe

Chicago, Illinois 60618

www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers.

We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-)

You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine

By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.

Larry Lindeman MD

Roscoe Village Family Medicine

2255 W. Roscoe

Chicago, Illinois 60618

www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts.

M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in

error.

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please

notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

I know it. That sort of thing should be illegal

 

I once was tempted to join the hospital group.  I had a proforma done by the hospital and they specifically showed me the higher rates of reimbursements.  My pay is 60-80% below the hospital's negotiated rates.  The insurance companies laugh at me when I want " equal pay for equal work. "  

Will Conner, M.D.

Family Medicine Physician

211 W. s St Ste. 102

s, N.C. 28105

 

 

 

--- Re: Blue Cross Rejection letter

 

I have fewer insurances in Maine than most- tough market,  and I now take all but 2 insurances and one of those will not let me in  as i am not in a network, though I have some patients  with it  who  get covered go figure ,  anyway I looked into Aetna a couple yrs ago  and  rejected their offer  told them about HYH and  how I work  and they increased the rate to perfectly reasonable

I still did not take them and their hassle factor is   very bad and I knew it would  put me over the edge:)    LIke I am not over the edge now Actually the Aetna rep emailed me many month s    later asking, and I told her flat out what other recptionsists tell me about trying to work with them and that  Aetna would get  between me and my patients. Which sounds so much more mature than  whining and saying I hate you:)

 Just got anew aetna patietn anyway and there is not much call  for Aetna for me so  was not crucial  New patietn--   I had call them up and say " what do you pay for a 99213 out of network " and they said about 6.00 less than  what I could charge her with a cash pay discount so she does it. I get paid by her  ,she uses her insurance ,pays  only a littel and so far she is willing to do  it.

Its all stoppid though  very stoopid I am sittin g  here solving a  narcotic script problem for the NH who saw that they would run   out days ago but I had done up the script and  for some reason of cours e it is a holiday weekend now there is no med  but oh yes docs have to be able to fax hard copies to nursing homes on Sundays Yeesh. This job is  fraught with garbage.

You think diagnosis an treatment  is hard  BUt  itis the other stuff that is killing me.. The hard drive a ll in one fax here and there and do it form where and whenever rules for NH rules for regular folks but call this insurance co first at this number which is changed as of two days ago  system-- cripes This job is stoopid.Just stupid

Jean

On Sun, Dec 26, 2010 at 11:04 AM, Larry Lindeman  wrote:

 

I agree with . Sometimes they will negotiate, sometimes not. 2 years ago we told united that we were going to drop them unless they gave us an increase,They said there was nothing that they could do. We started the discussions 5 months prior to the end of our contract. We then gave them official notice of canceling the contract and notified our patients. We had a lot of patients who were upset so we told them to contact United and also the benefits people at the job. Less than 1 week before the contract was over United came back to us saying that they had received many calls and were wondering why we were unhappy with them. We negotiated a 15% increase which was good enough for me. We were listed as a double star provider which meant that we were among the best doctors for both cost and quality which helped. But you have to be willing to walk away or they will not negotiate!

Larry Lindeman MD

Roscoe Village Family Medicine

2255 W. Roscoe

Chicago, Illinois 60618

www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

 

You have to be willing to walk away from your contract or any threats will not have any bite. Also, I would read your contract before you do that. Some contracts you cannot get out of until 90 days before your renewal date. So any threat you make that violates your contract would pit you against their lawyers. 

We got that survey, too, and it was very satisfying to rate them at the bottom of the scale. ;-)

 

You think if I go to BX and say i plan to stop seeing any more of new BX pt since they pay so low, that that would help me negotiate w them, or is it a hopeless situation? Coincidentally, I just received a survey to rate BX...as you can imagine, I burned them. made me feel better but who knows how effective any of these are. Wonder what it will take to become like Switzerland- they have a triple mandate for health care- 1. Everyone has to carry health insurance 2. When people apply, they can't be denied 3. All health insurers are non profit except when when it comes to alternative medicine

On Sat, Dec 25, 2010 at 1:06 PM, Larry Lindeman  wrote:

 

By dropping your lower paying and more difficult payors your life will be much easier. Many patients will be able to switch to the plans you do take and other swill be willing to see you out of network. Over the years we have dropped over 1/3 of our payors.

Larry Lindeman MD

Roscoe Village Family Medicine

2255 W. Roscoe

Chicago, Illinois 60618

www.roscoevillagefamilymedicine.com

 

Do you thin it would be illegal for me to publish this rejection letter from BX. I had asked for an increase in my pay rate to the Medicare rate ( they are the highest payer in CA). It said stuff like how lucky I am to be able to have them provide me with  patients, how fortunate I am to have available to me all these services, etc. Should I respond to them and if so how? Anyone get one of these letter and had a successful rebuttal? BX is my lowest payer, and the most hassle. Considering my practice is full, ie not taking new pts, may be I should drop them...but my BX pts are some of my favorite pts.

 

M.D.www.elainemd.com

Office: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. 

 If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. 

--  M.D.www.elainemd.com

Office: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. 

 If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. 

-- PATIENTS-please remember  that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical  record and is placed into your  chart ( be careful what you say!)

Email is best used for appointment making and  brief  questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL  if the  matter is more urgent .     MD    

      ph    fax impcenter.org

-- PATIENTS-please remember  that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical  record and is placed into your  chart ( be careful what you say!)

Email is best used for appointment making and  brief  questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL  if the  matter is more urgent .     MD    

     ph    fax impcenter.org

-- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.

This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above.

 If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error.

Posted

Kathleen, so nicely put. As desperate as municipalities are/will be, it would probably be a big miracle for them to consider a network of IMPs. At least I would think such network not only would have to be willing and able, but actually up and “operating” at the time of any proposal. A great idea however worthy of someone taking it up. > The patients of the yet to be assimilated practices encounter obstacles and hassles when they need the access to hospitals. What are some of the worst ways that this actually manifests in the field, any examples? Sincerely, Ari Shohat from CA From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Kathleen PattonSent: Monday, December 27, 2010 7:39 PMTo: Subject: Re: good trends and bad for solo, noncorporate docs Hey , hows the snow up there? We got ~18 inches last night :)Thank you for your knowledge and acknowledgement of the situation here in Massachusetts. I know it's difficult for most, even those of us who are living with it, to wrap our minds around it. Trying to explain it only sounds like hyperbolic Sermo doom talk to those outside of our fair state. You really have to see it / live it to believe it. But it is real. Not a friendly environment for medical practice of any stripe. I've heard it said that we're lucky as physicians, because we can just hang out our shingle and we'll always have a job. Not so here. New Hampshire, Rhode Island and Maine all look better than Massachusetts but they are a long commute from my part time gig at BU and husband's job in Boston. As you pointed out there are multiple mega hospital systems here. They have more power than God. Then there are the giant third party 'payers' with more money than God. They've just been granted more power to get more money as a result of the Massachusetts mandated insurance coverage law • The hospital players: In the T-rex goliath category we have Partners (Mass Gen, B & W et al) and Caregroup ( Levy and BIDMC) In the smaller but still huge, hissing cousin category, we have UMass med, TuftsNEMC, BUMC, Lahey and the now for-profit Caritas system purchased recently by capital investment group, Cerberus. • The third party payer players: Blue Cross Harvard Pilgrim The half dozen of also-ran carnivores, Fallon, Aetna, Cigna, Coventry, Health New England (a quasi HMO) • The practice players: Atrius Harvard Vanguard is the largest non-hospital owned, physician- led practice with ~800 physicians and ~4k NPs, PAs, nurses and MAs in 28 locations. Rules of engagement:The hospitals gobble up the practices. The practices feed patients to the hospitals. The third party payers try to eat the hospitals.But hospitals have worked a deal that gives them extra rations from the third party payers. I'm still not clear as to why it should be that hospital affiliated practices get better pay even though they may not be within earshot of the hospitals themselves. Cannibalism and incest are acceptable among the players.Hospitals and third party payers both try to take bites out of Atrius Harvard Vanguard's hide. All other practices become assimilated or run for their lives. The patients wait 6 months to a year to get an appointment with a PCP, if they can find a PCP. Any practice other than AHV, that resists the pull of the hospital black holes finds itself without hospital privileges. The patients of the yet to be assimilated practices encounter obstacles and hassles when they need the access to hospitals. This continues until the practice succumbs or the patient moves on to a hospital practice. I'm watching this process unfold as a friend's well established, medium sized (5 doc, 3NP) practice is trying to resist. Not pretty. The half-time score:It looks like it should be even up between the hospitals and the third party payers, however the TPPs control the money. Atrius Harvard Vanguard should have some traction because it has lots and lots of patients and because its size might make it difficult to swallow. Sadly AHV is so large that it can't move quickly because it has to carry an over grown, non-revenue producing administration. Further, AHV does not have the revenues from procedure profit centers as the hospitals do. Patients lose. Potential game change: There needs to be a small disturbance on this playing field. I have some ideas involving a network of IMPs rescuing a couple of desperate municipalities. This would require a small miracle; said municipalities would need special dispensation from the mandated insurance coverage law. A long shot. With forlorn hope in Beantown,Kathleen The situation in Massachusetts is more distorted than in other states due to the enormous market power of Partner's Healthcare, even in outpatient medicine. The Boston Globe did a Spotlight series on this a couple of years ago and Levy frequently discusses the issue on his blog. Basically, Mass General, Brigham and Women's and the other big names have enormous marketing clout in Mass. Since most patients are not paying directly for their own care, many prefer to go to these facilities. Partner's Healthcare uses this leverage to get much higher fees from the third party payers.On the PPO negotiating question, from what I've read lately that is as complex and legally risky as the noncovered benefits fee issue we discussed here recently. Mass. sounds like a tough state for primary care, more so for starting a peds practice. Have you considered southern New Hampshire? (Mass. exile in Maine) Thanks, Jean. Good point about the Mass med society. They should have some information. I'll see what I can dig up and report in. Might this be an issue worthy of our advocacy efforts? Last year the state atty general released some information regarding larger hospitals having the power to negotiate for more money, but it wasn't clear to what the money was attached. No real news here, just as we all thought. Money = Power, Power = Money. To : So glad you had the smarts and guts to pull out of the deal. BravoTo Marty: Exactly. Rock on.To Larry: What does the PPO admin charge individual practices for its negotiating services? Put another way, is there a reliable percentage of the ?revenue,?fee negotiated? For anyone: Another question, How is it that a PPO can do the negotiating but if the practices gather together to negotiate, it becomes an issued of restricting fair trade? Call me babe in the big woods, however, friends in large and small practices, owned and non-owned, are not clear on much of this either.Kathleen

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...