Guest guest Posted December 20, 2010 Report Posted December 20, 2010 I've been involved with Press-Ganey before. So has my wife. (I'm a family doc dreaming of IMP but not IMPlementing d/t waiting for my wife to figure out her career; she's a neurologist.) They are a parasitic corporation that siphons off money better spent on real healthcare while purporting to help healthcare-providing organizations improve their "customer satisfaction." Since the patient who wrote the negative comment did not know who s/he was writing about, you can hardly expect the survey to have any accuracy. You can't appeal it,either. All any of us can do is try to get into a situation where that can't happen, and derive professional satisfaction from the knowledge that we are actually practicing good medicine and doing things that are useful for our patients. I guess that's one reason docs IMP out! (Sort of like opting out, but more specific...) Felix Albuquerque The Wonder of Press-Ganey Alas I'm not REALLY an IMP, as I still work for a man--a nicer "MAN" than most, but still part of a large hospital corporation/group. As part of my annual review last week, I had to look over my Press Ganey report. I did make improvements in some areas, other areas could be better. But what really got me annoyed was apparently a negative comment was listed from a patient , that more or less said that I was two hours behind in clinic and made them wait, then it happened again and they would never return to see me. The problem, of course, is that I've never been 2 hours behind in my 3+ years on the job. They were apparently referring to ANOTHER doctor in my group. But when I asked about getting this removed apparently its NOT a simple process but would eventually fall off given enough time. Given that I am sure hospitals and suits are using Press Ganey to get rid of, and or justify salary cuts or payment changes based on PATIENT SATISFACTION, I'm not happy with that answer. Is there any recourse? Talk to a press ganey person if they have a procedure to actually fix it? Is it really as hard as my employer claims or perhaps press ganey is just not scientific and is just another tool the non-medical types use to torture the medical providers? Unlike some of my partners, I am not trying to become best friends with my patients nor do I refill their pain meds and antibiotics whenever they want--so I imagine that would effect how satisfied the patients are with me and or my care =-- I imagine that ain't gonna help my press ganey score. I did have the highest percentage of diabetics with HGA1c Below 8 and ldl below 100, so my metrics were better than my peers... Quote
Guest guest Posted December 21, 2010 Report Posted December 21, 2010 All the questions from Press-Ganey are the same from hospital to hospital 'so they can compare apples to apples'. Our hospital also uses them, and I see no value other than to the Press Ganey Corporation and its CEO. Read 'If Disney Ran Your Hospital', although keep in mind that the guy who wrote it specifically spent time with Disney so he could write a (hopefully bestselling) book about applying Disney's customer service approach to healthcare. Some is unworkable, some is common sense, some will never happen as long as narcissistic CEO's are in charge, but the general jist of the book is this: Unless your 'customers' rate you 5 on a scale of 1-5, they will not show customer loyalty (what you really want to measure, not satisfaction!). It also talks about empowering workers, treating staff as if they are worth something, etc. All the stuff that just makes sense. Anyway, no advice on Press Ganey, other than it is a useless behemoth that sucks cash (offers no value for the cost) from the healthcare industry IMHO. I've been involved with Press-Ganey before. So has my wife. (I'm a family doc dreaming of IMP but not IMPlementing d/t waiting for my wife to figure out her career; she's a neurologist.) They are a parasitic corporation that siphons off money better spent on real healthcare while purporting to help healthcare-providing organizations improve their " customer satisfaction. " Since the patient who wrote the negative comment did not know who s/he was writing about, you can hardly expect the survey to have any accuracy. You can't appeal it,either. All any of us can do is try to get into a situation where that can't happen, and derive professional satisfaction from the knowledge that we are actually practicing good medicine and doing things that are useful for our patients. I guess that's one reason docs IMP out! (Sort of like opting out, but more specific...) Felix Albuquerque The Wonder of Press-Ganey Alas I'm not REALLY an IMP, as I still work for a man--a nicer " MAN " than most, but still part of a large hospital corporation/group. As part of my annual review last week, I had to look over my Press Ganey report. I did make improvements in some areas, other areas could be better. But what really got me annoyed was apparently a negative comment was listed from a patient , that more or less said that I was two hours behind in clinic and made them wait, then it happened again and they would never return to see me. The problem, of course, is that I've never been 2 hours behind in my 3+ years on the job. They were apparently referring to ANOTHER doctor in my group. But when I asked about getting this removed apparently its NOT a simple process but would eventually fall off given enough time. Given that I am sure hospitals and suits are using Press Ganey to get rid of, and or justify salary cuts or payment changes based on PATIENT SATISFACTION, I'm not happy with that answer. Is there any recourse? Talk to a press ganey person if they have a procedure to actually fix it? Is it really as hard as my employer claims or perhaps press ganey is just not scientific and is just another tool the non-medical types use to torture the medical providers? Unlike some of my partners, I am not trying to become best friends with my patients nor do I refill their pain meds and antibiotics whenever they want--so I imagine that would effect how satisfied the patients are with me and or my care =-- I imagine that ain't gonna help my press ganey score. I did have the highest percentage of diabetics with HGA1c Below 8 and ldl below 100, so my metrics were better than my peers... -- Lynette I Iles MD 301 South Iowa Ste 2Washington IA 52353 Flexible Family Care 'Modern medicine the old-fashioned way' This e-mail and attachments may contain information which is confidential and is only for the named addressee. If you have received this email in error, please notify the sender immediately and delete it from your computer. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.