Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Re: Re: PREJUDICES and response-ability

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

Thanks, Randy. That was very helpful. If only to have someone seemingly understand though it wasn't only that .

I have oCD and one of the "charges" held against people with OCD (I am sort of laughing as I write the word charges!) is that we suffer from hyperresponsibility. So it is very easy for those who know to come back with the accusation that if you speak up about something that is worrying you that you are being hyperresponsible rather than responsible.

In the particular case I am thinking of, and there have been many many for me recently, someone else with OCD was ehgaging in very risky compulsions that made her a very dangerous driver and when I gently expressed concern for her children who were passengers I was seen as the problem.

I guess in this case I was response-able at least initially but then the question arises where do i go from there. Report her? That would really not be like me! Funnily enough though I just yesterday received an OCD newsletter in which there was information about a new regulation that people driving in the UK have to report OCD to the driving licence authority DVLA - sounds extreme when OCD could involve totally driving-unrelated compulsions.

It did strike me though that in this particular case there was a need for the person concerned to think very carefully about whether she was fit to drive.

However, this new legal information brought the moral dilemma up again for me. Where do I sit on the irresponsibility-hyperresponsibility spectrum?

As you say you can't be sure of knowing in advance that your response will be right and again I struggle with two conflicting values I think.

I often wish I didn't care so much!

S.

Subject: Re: PREJUDICES and response-abilityTo: ACT_for_the_Public Date: Tuesday, 21 December, 2010, 12:18

>> Speaking up and rocking the boat (reminded of Russ 's> somewhat different boat metaphor now)and failing to get a> discussion going can end up with you being the one excluded> ... > I guess knowing when you are response-able is a key> question?One small thing I've learned in the past six months orso is that for me there is no right answer to the question, "When am I response-able?" Except maybe the answer of "always." And there is no right answer at all and never will be if Iask myself, "Well, if I *am* response-able, what should I do?"and then look to the heavens or the universe or someone elseto tell me. No answers,

only choices. I have a family member who I love very much. Our relationship isonly occasional - his choice. We have a truce of sorts in the areaof prejudice. We both know where each other stands and that westrongly disagree. So on those few occasions we meet for familybusiness, we don't get into any of that although we know it'sthere. In his own way he cares for me, as best he can, andhe is not someone I want to push away. I'd rather gently lure himin, if I can - knowing that very likely I will never be able to. So that's one decision. I don't rock the boat. Some might say I am condoning prejudice.In a different area, I just turned down a fairly lucrative piece ofadvertising writing last month because I feel the product beingpromoted is unsafe. I think I've mentioned this on the list before.My position is a minority position in this country, and I have lostwhat for me is a big chunk

of income. I met with understanding butnot 100 percent approval from people who know me. Some said theywould have taken the job. Others worried about the loss of income.I wouldn't say it was a hard choice compared to what a lot of people have to deal with in their lives. My point is, therewas nothing telling me what to do or even that I "had" to doanything. "Searching my heart" would not have produced a 100 percent right answer. Nor did the universe or God give me a sign. And if I had asked others to tell me what to do, I wouldhave gotten different answers. Some in agreement with what Iultimately chose, but others not.So when I ask myself "What is the right thing to do here - rock or not rock this particular boat?" the answer seems to bethat there is "right" thing - only the act of choosing. - R.

Posted

Hi S,

First, only you can decide if your concern about this person's unsafe driving is real or a product of your hyper responsibility. Is she smoking while driving (maybe a little risk) or is she texting while driving (high risk). You say it is very dangerous, so I assume the risk is real. If so, could you bring the issue up to someone who is close to her and her children, instead of or prior to reporting it to the authorities? If she is really endangering her children, and no one around her wants to address it, then I would report it. Think about how you would feel if she caused an accident that harmed or killed her or any of her children, and you might have helped to prevent that. That sounds harsh, but it's quite possible, from what you are describing.

I think we all, as a society, need to stand up for our children, and if the parents won't or can't do it, intervention is the responsible thing to do. I once had lunch with a social worker friend who drove children to medical appointments. One day when we met for lunch, he was drunk (swaying), and he meant to go to his driving job after that. I took his keys and called his boss. I lost his friendship, which really hurt, but my actions may have saved lives. Two months later, he was killed in a accident that he caused driving drunk; fortunately, he was the only one in the car.

Helena

Re: PREJUDICES and response-abilityTo: ACT_for_the_Public Date: Tuesday, 21 December, 2010, 12:18

>> Speaking up and rocking the boat (reminded of Russ 's> somewhat different boat metaphor now)and failing to get a> discussion going can end up with you being the one excluded> ... > I guess knowing when you are response-able is a key> question?One small thing I've learned in the past six months orso is that for me there is no right answer to the question, "When am I response-able?" Except maybe the answer of "always." And there is no right answer at all and never will be if Iask myself, "Well, if I *am* response-able, what should I do?"and then look to the heavens or the universe or someone elseto tell me. No answers, only choices. I have a family member who I love very much. Our relationship isonly occasional - his choice. We have a truce of sorts in the areaof prejudice. We both know where each other stands and that westrongly disagree. So on those few occasions we meet for familybusiness, we don't get into any of that although we know it'sthere. In his own way he cares for me, as best he can, andhe is not someone I want to push away. I'd rather gently lure himin, if I can - knowing that very likely I will never be able to. So that's one decision. I don't rock the boat. Some might say I am condoning prejudice.In a different area, I just turned down a fairly lucrative piece ofadvertising writing last month because I feel the product beingpromoted is unsafe. I think I've mentioned this on the list before.My position is a minority position in this country, and I have lostwhat for me is a big chunk of income. I met with understanding butnot 100 percent approval from people who know me. Some said theywould have taken the job. Others worried about the loss of income.I wouldn't say it was a hard choice compared to what a lot of people have to deal with in their lives. My point is, therewas nothing telling me what to do or even that I "had" to doanything. "Searching my heart" would not have produced a 100 percent right answer. Nor did the universe or God give me a sign. And if I had asked others to tell me what to do, I wouldhave gotten different answers. Some in agreement with what Iultimately chose, but others not.So when I ask myself "What is the right thing to do here - rock or not rock this particular boat?" the answer seems to bethat there is "right" thing - only the act of choosing. - R.

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...