Guest guest Posted March 1, 2010 Report Posted March 1, 2010 Hi Thane, I agree with you to a point, if Big Pharma had their way, they wouldn't even allow us to take supplements or use Rife machines. They have kept Laetrille illegal in this country for years. I have to go to Mexico to get treatments that I can't get here in the US, because of the medical politics and greed. However, I would want my Naturopath to be able to order lab and blood tests to determine heavy metal loads or hormone levels or even a lyme test. An ND from Trinity can not do this, therefore what they can do is limited to muscle testing and the accuracy of this is dependent on the skill of the practitioner which can vary greatly from one practitioner to another. It is just nice that when I go to Klinghardt and he or one of the NDs in his office muscle tests me that they can follow up with lab work. I do think that claiming to be a doctor with a two year degree can lead people to assume that one is more highly qualified then they actually are. Thane, I know that you do your research, but not everyone who sees the initials ND or the word Doctor know that there is even an ND degree that is only a two year course or worse yet someone who just decided to hang out there shingle with no training. I guess that is legal in some states. I had no clue that there was a two year degree for an ND until Sue Massey and Finette had a little dispute a few years back on one of the boards and I then did my research to actually check on the Trinity education. Being on the west coast, I guess I had always assumed that my NDs had as much training as an MD. This taught me never to assume anything. > > I think most of this licensing stuff is only there to limit competition in the health field and not to protect patients. We should be able to choose to see whom we want regardless of their training. I've met plenty of highly educated idiots on this journey and some good insightful uneducated folks. I'm interested in the person who can help regardless of their certification. I'm a responsible adult. > > Thane > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 1, 2010 Report Posted March 1, 2010 Hi Marsha, That was a wonderful tutorial, thank you... I too feel feel to call one a doctor, far more education than a few years or a few years online is needed to earn the title of Doctor..... Many see Dr. and just assume there is a lot of education that earned that title, where in reality that may not be the truth and I personally feel this is misleading and as you say they may be calling themselves a doctor with just two years of online training, no other education.... When I see Dr. in front of my physicians name, I want to know that a lot of study went into his/her's education. At a minimum, I want to know they've had many years of education and training and are licensed to practice medicine and have earned the title of Doctor.... Even at that, there are good ones and not so good ones, like you say a continuing education from the cute little pharma rep...:-) I don't feel you are offending anyone with what your wrote, but rather you have enlightened many to ask good questions of anyone with Dr. in front of their name... It is important when we are entrusting our health care to others to know exactly who they are and what education they have... At least when we see CNHP, we know exactly what that means... But when we see Dr. unfortunately, this can mean different things and far too many really don't understand and may not realize the person they call doctor may not have much education at all.... Again, nicely done, Jim PS: May I pass your post on to others? > > > > > > > > > > > I've been gone a long time because I suddenly got busy caring for a cancer > > > patient who was not diagnosed until he was in the ICU about to die. We have > > > been treating him with alternative cancer therapies and he has made a > > > miraculous recovery so far. Since then, people have been approaching me with > > > all sorts if illnesses, and I have actually been able to give helpful advice > > > to a number of them. I think now I want to get some type of health > > > consultant license. I have not been working and earning money because I am > > > too busy caring for this person. Hence, I have not been treating myself > > > either...I want to start consulting and earning some money on my own time, > > > without the boss...The job I have now pushes pharma drugs and I am not happy > > > with it. > > > > > > Anyone know of a short online program where I can get some type of health > > > consultant license or anything like that? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > L. Richey, MD, ND, BCIM > > > > The Healthy Path, LLC > > http://www.the- healthy-path. org > > http://www.autism- in-the-christian -home.com > > > > Sweet Creations Alpaca Farm, LLC > > http://www.sweet- creations- alpaca-farm. org (NEW WEBSITE IN PROGRESS!) > > > > > > > > > -- > L. Richey, MD, ND, BCIM > > The Healthy Path, LLC > http://www.the- healthy-path. org > http://www.autism- in-the-christian -home.com > > Sweet Creations Alpaca Farm, LLC > http://www.sweet- creations- alpaca-farm. org  (NEW WEBSITE IN PROGRESS!) > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 2, 2010 Report Posted March 2, 2010 Since my name was mentioned... I would like to comment as well. I agree wholeheartedly with Thane that when I was critically ill, was given 3 years to live back in 1999, I would have seen ANYONE that had any information that would have helped me recover and as a matter of fact, it was a woman that lived about 10 houses away. She did NOT have "MD" or "ND" or any other such initials after her name. She managed a health food store and was on IV for 10 years; lost a rib, had 5 angioplasties, 3 back surgeries. We did go to the medical drs,even Yale,. for 5yrs only to be out over $100,000 and had my husband, my 6 kids and myself all critically ill. My husband ended up with heart surgery. You all can keep searching for the person with the most degrees but that is NOT going to heal you. If that impresses you, than so be it. I attended Trinity because it was a Christian education and I truly believe that God is in control of all our lives. I am not going to have a 'religious' debate here but we all think that we are in control and that if we just do this or that, we will be healed by some great dr.or the latest trendy modality. I am doing awesome, feel great like I am 29 (although I am 52) whereas I felt like I was 90 and going to die in 1999. I work approx. 60hrs/wk, head up our Youth Group at church and volunteer as well. I could not get out of bed for 1999. No amount of education, $$, could replace what I have. God has truly blessed me and I am grateful. I am not a medical dr., don't want to be... my purpose is to be available for those whom God calls to me. Not everyone can afford Dr. K or travel to Washington state or see the top LLMDs to the tune of $750/hr. So what is everybody else supposed to do? I am a broken vessel doing God's work; he equips me with what I need. My training is not just a 2yr. course either, which is an ignorant statement. In the field of holistic health, it is an ongoing, continuing education and I am continuously taking courses, attending conferences to increase my personal knowledge. I am also Board Certified. Please consider the words that you put out because they can either bless people or hurt. The tongue is our most dangerous weapon and it is not beneficial to be negative. We are to speak words of love, joy, hope. blessings-Dr. Sue Massie Quote
Guest guest Posted March 2, 2010 Report Posted March 2, 2010 Sue, I don't believe in any way this conversation was about you or your credentials. If there was any negativity on anyones part I did not see it. As far as I can see you are the only person using your tongue as a weapon. Tamara > > Since my name was mentioned... I would like to comment as well. I agree > wholeheartedly with Thane that when I was critically ill, was given 3 years to > live back in 1999, I would have seen ANYONE that had any information that > would have helped me recover and as a matter of fact, it was a woman that > lived about 10 houses away. She did NOT have " MD " or " ND " or any other such > initials after her name. She managed a health food store and was on IV for > 10 years; lost a rib, had 5 angioplasties, 3 back surgeries. We did go to > the medical drs,even Yale,. for 5yrs only to be out over $100,000 and had my > husband, my 6 kids and myself all critically ill. My husband ended up with > heart surgery. You all can keep searching for the person with the most > degrees but that is NOT going to heal you. If that impresses you, than so be > it. I attended Trinity because it was a Christian education and I truly > believe that God is in control of all our lives. I am not going to have a > 'religious' debate here but we all think that we are in control and that if we > just do this or that, we will be healed by some great dr.or the latest > trendy modality. I am doing awesome, feel great like I am 29 (although I am 52) > whereas I felt like I was 90 and going to die in 1999. I work approx. > 60hrs/wk, head up our Youth Group at church and volunteer as well. I could not > get out of bed for 1999. No amount of education, $$, could replace what I > have. God has truly blessed me and I am grateful. I am not a medical dr., > don't want to be... my purpose is to be available for those whom God calls to > me. Not everyone can afford Dr. K or travel to Washington state or see the > top LLMDs to the tune of $750/hr. So what is everybody else supposed to > do? I am a broken vessel doing God's work; he equips me with what I need. My > training is not just a 2yr. course either, which is an ignorant statement. > In the field of holistic health, it is an ongoing, continuing education and > I am continuously taking courses, attending conferences to increase my > personal knowledge. I am also Board Certified. > Please consider the words that you put out because they can either bless > people or hurt. The tongue is our most dangerous weapon and it is not > beneficial to be negative. We are to speak words of love, joy, hope. > > blessings- > > Dr. Sue Massie > > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 2, 2010 Report Posted March 2, 2010 Hi Sue, No one was attacking you or being negative we are merely expressing our opinions and having a discussion about differences in institutional requirements. I don't think anyone in this group takes issue with the fact that there are many helpful people out there who are not doctors but are educated in various healing modalities. Many in this group are examples of people who have been helping others navigate this Lyme journey. The discussion is not about whether or not it is okay to provide help to others who are ill. I am sure that we are all here partly for that reason, to share what has helped and what hasn't helped. I am all for us helping each other. The problem as I see it is if someone sees ND or doctor next to a persons name the natural assumption is that person is nearly as highly trained as an MD and has at least 6 years of college education invested in that degree. I earned a Masters degree and I continued to take coursework and earned 90 credits beyond my Masters. Things constantly evolve and change and I would expect that any doctor would be required to pursue continuing education coursework just like I am required to do as a teacher. I am not ignorant of the fact that education is ongoing for life and that you are continuing to take courses. I am required to have a certain amount of graduate hours every time I re-certify which is every 4 years. Any profession is going to require that you keep up with changes and since medicine is ever evolving I would expect that you would take additional coursework. However, taking a class here and there is never as difficult as entering into a Maters program and completing it. The two do not even compare. As far as board certification goes, I am unfamiliar with what your state (is it New Jersey)? requires with regard to board certification, but my state requires at least a four year degree with a fifth year of internship. I have also researched this and many other state requirements. There is no testing out of the education requirement to get board certified, as may be the case in your state. My point is if I were new in town and was desperate to find a good Naturopath and went through the phone book and found one, I would want to know if that person had a two year degree before I plopped down a fee for an office call, there is a big difference in the education of someone with a two year degree and one with a four year degree or beyond. A person with a two year degree cannot order lab tests or cannot legally give IVs, they also can't write prescriptions for bioidentical hormones or thyroid etc. My personal feeling is that one should not use the doctor title with the equivalent of a two year degree regardless of what their college allows. You can do a lot of continuing education after earning your certification, but the bottom line is, the weekend workshops that you attend will never compare to the rigorousness of an actual 6 year college education where you are admitted to a Masters and Doctoral program. I admire that you have a close walk with God; but I guess when choosing an Education for myself, I would be more concerned about the value and depth of knowledge that I wouldl receive and the outcome of my education in terms of it's ability to land me a job, then whether the professors hold my same religious values, but that is just me. I am not bashing Trinity's education nor God in the least, for someone like me who wants to learn things about natural health it is probably a wonderful program, provided I don't plan to practice as a doctor. If I were to pursue an education that would allow me to legitimately practice as a doctor, I would choose at least a school that offers the equivalent of a Bachelor's degree. I would never call myself a doctor with a two year degree. A two year degree barely begins to scratch the surface of an education, but then again, you'll notice that I don't use M.Ed after my name when I post either. Blessings back, > > Since my name was mentioned... I would like to comment as well. I agree > wholeheartedly with Thane that when I was critically ill, was given 3 years to > live back in 1999, I would have seen ANYONE that had any information that > would have helped me recover and as a matter of fact, it was a woman that > lived about 10 houses away. She did NOT have " MD " or " ND " or any other such > initials after her name. She managed a health food store and was on IV for > 10 years; lost a rib, had 5 angioplasties, 3 back surgeries. We did go to > the medical drs,even Yale,. for 5yrs only to be out over $100,000 and had my > husband, my 6 kids and myself all critically ill. My husband ended up with > heart surgery. You all can keep searching for the person with the most > degrees but that is NOT going to heal you. If that impresses you, than so be > it. I attended Trinity because it was a Christian education and I truly > believe that God is in control of all our lives. I am not going to have a > 'religious' debate here but we all think that we are in control and that if we > just do this or that, we will be healed by some great dr.or the latest > trendy modality. I am doing awesome, feel great like I am 29 (although I am 52) > whereas I felt like I was 90 and going to die in 1999. I work approx. > 60hrs/wk, head up our Youth Group at church and volunteer as well. I could not > get out of bed for 1999. No amount of education, $$, could replace what I > have. God has truly blessed me and I am grateful. I am not a medical dr., > don't want to be... my purpose is to be available for those whom God calls to > me. Not everyone can afford Dr. K or travel to Washington state or see the > top LLMDs to the tune of $750/hr. So what is everybody else supposed to > do? I am a broken vessel doing God's work; he equips me with what I need. My > training is not just a 2yr. course either, which is an ignorant statement. > In the field of holistic health, it is an ongoing, continuing education and > I am continuously taking courses, attending conferences to increase my > personal knowledge. I am also Board Certified. > Please consider the words that you put out because they can either bless > people or hurt. The tongue is our most dangerous weapon and it is not > beneficial to be negative. We are to speak words of love, joy, hope. > > blessings- > > Dr. Sue Massie > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.