Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

Choices

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

I recently Happened upon an experience that really made it clear to me how

connection with the present moment and being mindful can allow you to choose

your behaviour in situations where previously it appeared that there was no

choice. I have an exercise machine and I try to meditate while using it for the

half hour I do everyday. To my mind it is a boring exercise and I generally want

the time to go as soon as possible so I can get off the exercise machine and do

something more interesting and less uncomfortable. These thoughts result it me

compulsively checking the time on the meter on the handlebars. Without

mindfulness practice I will generally find myself checking every minute or two.

If I meditate while exercising I find that if I am really staying connected to

the present moment I will notice the urge or thought that leads me to look at

the meter. As I notice this thought or urge I have a choice- to look or not to

look. If I lose contact with the present moment I am never consciously aware of

the urge- so I have no choice. Of course, this translates well into everyday

life where, particularly when the going gets tough, we lose contact with the

present and lose the ability to make choices.

I am forever telling people about such miraculous findings only for them to

tell me that it¡¯s quite obvious. So sorry if this is one of them.

Posted

Hi ,

I know

what your saying. For me distraction means that I am will miss the thought. As

I am not consciously aware of that thought- I don't seem to have a choice as to

whether or not to follow that thought with the behaviour it asks for-In my

example looking at the clock. For me, this means that, in my everyday life, if

I want to behave in ways that are consistent with my values I must try and

maintain contact with the present moment. As soon as I drift into the world of

thoughts I am distracted and just react to things in the same old ways I have

been doing all my life. In some cases, this may be consistent with living

according to my values but in a lot of cases it is not.

The big

problem for me in maintaining this state- the state in which I have choices to

act in a way consistent with what I really want to be about. I just read

(In reply to 's post)。He talks about acceptance that comes with really being present in the

moment. I have had short periods of time where I feel I have managed to live

like this (Talking minutes or hours)-Where I can relax into what is and not ask

for more or less. In these times I feel like I have finally stopped swimming

against the current of what is- I can choose how I want to behave and use the

energy that would be wasted on resistance to follow my values. The problem is I

just can’t stay there in the present. So how do you ever get to stay? Some

monks spend years in monasteries training their minds to stay in the moment but

never get there- What chance have I got? From my experience it appears that the

more time time I spend in the world of thoughts the more distracted I become. I just

wonder how people like and Jon Kabat-Zin spend so much time in the world

of words and thoughts- writing books, theorizing, researching etc, etc but still seem to

know how to stay with the present moment. My guess in that maybe it’s not to do

with how much time you spend practicing being in contact with the present but

how you train your self in the ability to switch between real contact with the

present moment and being in the world of thoughts.

To: ACT_for_the_Public Sent: Fri, December 24, 2010 7:03:51 PMSubject: Re: Choices

Hi Jim,Reading your email does resonate with me, the way you explain the situation is clear and I have seen myself doing the much the same.And then I start to think, or rather observe myself noticing these very thoughts and urges, and well, I sort of now giggle at myself and thank my mind for noticing.Then I have a thought, do I really have the need to look at the clock or is it possible for me not to to have that urge.When I practice the 'not looking' I find it is hard in the first instance, then it becomes easier as time progresses.Sometimes I notice that I get distracted momentarily, after

which I notice that I was distracted and then I have the thought of, wow that was easy, and so it goes.I wonder if what I have said or the way I have conveyed this is confusing or do you or others relate to these processes of the mind.It is quite easy to find ourselves getting caught up, even quite tangled and engaged in particular thoughts.I know I do all the time, and sometimes I consciously choose to, to see where it goes, sometimes going into quite existential realms of the mind.Then, I realise where I have been and again, consciously connect back to the present moment.Ah, I smile and realise, maybe I have gained some further understanding of my mind and what I can do, what I can choose to do._____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________Jim wrote:I recently Happened upon an experience that really made it clear to me how connection with the present moment and being mindful can allow you to choose your behaviour in situations where previously it appeared that there was no choice. I have an exercise machine and I try to meditate while using

it for the half hour I do everyday. To my mind it is a boring exercise and I generally want the time to go as soon as possible so I can get off the exercise machine and do something more interesting and less uncomfortable. These thoughts result it me compulsively checking the time on the meter on the handlebars. Without mindfulness practice I will generally find myself checking every minute or two. If I meditate while exercising I find that if I am really staying connected to the present moment I will notice the urge or thought that leads me to look at the meter. As I notice this thought or urge I have a choice- to look or not to look. If I lose contact with the present moment I am never consciously aware of the urge- so I have no choice. Of course, this translates well into everyday life where, particularly when the going gets tough, we lose contact with the present and lose the ability to make choices.I am forever telling people about such

miraculous findings only for them to tell me that it¡¯s quite obvious. So sorry if this is one of them.

Posted

Jim, ,Just exercising will facilitate a change in your mental state and usually leads to not frequently checking the time.  I mean without any conscious mental effort to be in present moment, this will often happen spontaneously by just exercising.  Often runners and other exercise enthusiast will often find it hard to stop after exercising a period of time.  They might not feel very eager to start, but once started it's hard to stop.  I certainly have experience this.  So at beginning of exercise I check the time every minute or so until after 15 or 30 minutes actually forget to be checking.  Yoga exercises were developed, as I understand, to help facilitate meditation.  So, what I'm saying here is the actually physical exercise may be much more a facilitator to being in present moment than any kind of conscious mental effort. 

Now, I understand in yoga the mindfulness you have to bring to performing the posses is a large part of what facilitates the mediation and mindfulness, but I think also that the just physical excursion itself facilitates mediation and mindfulness.

+++++Jim, I think you have answered your questions in your last sentence.  I do not think you or I or anyone wants to be in the present moment at all times and not in the " world of thoughts " as you put it.  I believe individuals of most other species are pretty much in present moment.  But our specie's ability to be in the " world of thoughts " is what has led to our species being so successful on this planet.  To simply go to grocery store and buy what you need for meals in the next few days requires you to think ahead and plan what you are going to eat and then what you need to buy.  And thinking about the past and remembering what you like or don't like to eat and recalling how to cook what you want to eat is required.  (Well, that's kind of a funny awkward sentence!  But I hope you all understand what I'm saying).

Anyway my point here is we often need to be in the world of thoughts and not always just in the present.  And in many situations it's harmful not to be thinking of future or past.  E.g. buying something you desire in present without recalling that the money you have is needed to pay rent or mortgage next week.

In ACT, the acceptance of emotions part comes about because the way we solve so many problems effectively is not effective on solving things we struggle with emotionally.  So, if we are cold, we know we can solve that problem by getting rid of that state.  We can put on warmer cloths, or go inside or turn up the thermostat.  Then we are no longer cold.  But for many emotions we feel, to try to do something to eliminate those emotions does not work and leads to our getting more entangled and struggling more.  So hence the acceptance of emotions in ACT.  (In a podcast or i-tunes U interview of I listened to yesterday has given me some valuable clearer insight into " acceptance " but I guess that is for another conversation).

Perhaps, the same kind of thing applies to mindfulness and being in present moment.  Our species' ability to have language and to make all the associations and relationshiips of thoughts and concepts and to think about the past and future is a great ability.  But we can get often get so tied up on our past and stories we tell ourselves and labels we put on ourselves and others and also get tied up on our future and what possible disasters could strike us.  So in the right context, the mindfulness and being present in moment because very important, but not only being in present moment at all times.  But correct me if I'm wrong in some respect on this or you think I'm missing some point or if any of you can eloborate on this much better than I have here, please respond.

 

Hi ,

 

I know

what your saying. For me distraction means that I am will miss the thought. As

I am not consciously aware of that thought- I don't seem to have a choice as to

whether or not to follow that thought with the behaviour it asks for-In my

example looking at the clock. For me, this means that, in my everyday life, if

I want to behave in ways that are consistent with my values I must try and

maintain contact with the present moment. As soon as I drift into the world of

thoughts I am distracted and just react to things in the same old ways I have

been doing all my life. In some cases, this may be consistent with living

according to my values but in a lot of cases it is not.

 

The big

problem for me in maintaining this state- the state in which I have choices to

act in a way consistent with what I really want to be about. I just read

(In reply to 's post)。He talks about acceptance that comes with really being present in the

moment. I have had short periods of time where I feel I have managed to live

like this (Talking minutes or hours)-Where I can relax into what is and not ask

for more or less. In these times I feel like I have finally stopped swimming

against the current of what is- I can choose how I want to behave and use the

energy that would be wasted on resistance to follow my values. The problem is I

just can’t stay there in the present. So how do you ever get to stay? Some

monks spend years in monasteries training their minds to stay in the moment but

never get there- What chance have I got? From my experience it appears that the

more time time I spend in the world of thoughts the more distracted I become. I just

wonder how people like and Jon Kabat-Zin spend so much time in the world

of words and thoughts- writing books, theorizing, researching etc, etc but still seem to

know how to stay with the present moment. My guess in that maybe it’s not to do

with how much time you spend practicing being in contact with the present but

how you train your self in the ability to switch between real contact with the

present moment and being in the world of thoughts.

 

To: ACT_for_the_Public Sent: Fri, December 24, 2010 7:03:51 PM

Subject: Re: Choices

 

Hi Jim,Reading your email does resonate with me, the way you explain the situation is clear and I have seen myself doing the much the same.And then I start to think, or rather observe myself noticing these very thoughts and urges, and well, I sort of now giggle at myself and thank my mind for noticing.

Then I have a thought, do I really have the need to look at the clock or is it possible for me not to to have that urge.When I practice the 'not looking' I find it is hard in the first instance, then it becomes easier as time progresses.

Sometimes I notice that I get distracted momentarily, after

which I notice that I was distracted and then I have the thought of, wow that was easy, and so it goes.I wonder if what I have said or the way I have conveyed this is confusing or do you or others relate to these processes of the mind.

It is quite easy to find ourselves getting caught up, even quite tangled and engaged in particular thoughts.I know I do all the time, and sometimes I consciously choose to, to see where it goes, sometimes going into quite existential realms of the mind.

Then, I realise where I have been and again, consciously connect back to the present moment.Ah, I smile and realise, maybe I have gained some further understanding of my mind and what I can do, what I can choose to do.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Jim wrote:I recently Happened upon an experience that really made it clear to me how connection with the present moment and being mindful can allow you to choose your behaviour in situations where previously it appeared that there was no choice. I have an exercise machine and I try to meditate while using

it for the half hour I do everyday. To my mind it is a boring exercise and I generally want the time to go as soon as possible so I can get off the exercise machine and do something more interesting and less uncomfortable. These thoughts result it me compulsively checking the time on the meter on the handlebars. Without mindfulness practice I will generally find myself checking every minute or two. If I meditate while exercising I find that if I am really staying connected to the present moment I will notice the urge or thought that leads me to look at the meter. As I notice this thought or urge I have a choice- to look or not to look. If I lose contact with the present moment I am never consciously aware of the urge- so I have no choice. Of course, this translates well into everyday life where, particularly when the going gets tough, we lose contact with the present and lose the ability to make choices.

I am forever telling people about such

miraculous findings only for them to tell me that it¡¯s quite obvious. So sorry if this is one of them.

Posted

Hi Russel Regarding exercise- My experience of it is that my mind tends to go into overdrive thinking about all kinds of stuff when I exercise. This is, I guess, a form of avoidance. It doesn't particularly like the experience of exercise as it considers it uncomfortable and boring so the internal world of simulated mind movies, thoughts and stories is a way to get away from it. However, I'm not a big exerciser- I just do 30 minutes on my exercise machine a day and that's it. So perhaps, if I did more I may start to get into and enjoy it more. As it is, it seems to be a valuable exercise in 'leaning in' to pain, (To not avoid it but to experience it as much as possible), and because of this the whole thing has become enjoyable in a different way. For me the more unpleasant the

present moment is, the harder it is to stay stay focused on it. It's much easier to stay connected to the present moment when the experience is pleasant and likeable. With such an experience there is much less reason to try and escape.Of course, thinking is very important. However, I find that a high percentage of my thinking does not help me to plan or to learn- and a lot of it just causes problems. In my experience,if I make a lot of effort to meditate and stay mindful in my everyday life then when a bad situation come along I stand a much better chance of staying connected, accepting what is hapenning and bahaving in way that, deep down inside, I want to. The problem is that stuff I value such as reading leads me to think and thinking means I lose contact with the present which ultimately means that when something bad comes up I am too distracted to choose to bahave the way I'd like to. For me it's hard to put down a book and leave it there.

Reading is just the start of a whole thinking process. That's why I am amazed by people like Steve who have done so much in the world of words but still seem to have the wizdom that can comes from real connection with their lives. For me there seems to be a definite correlation between the amount of time I stay stay connected with the present (Over an extended period of time like weeks and months), and the ability to deal with bad situations (Or 'the funk' as some call it) and stear my life in the direction I choose. So put simply, If I spend a week or two meditating a lot (Doing the hexerflexercise etc), and getting out and doing active stuff while remaining mindful then I notice that I am much more able to be the person I want to be in terms of the way I behave. As soon a start reading and thinking, however then stuff tends to go not as well. Cheers for reading,JimTo: ACT_for_the_Public Sent: Sun, December 26, 2010 2:08:27 AMSubject: Re: Re: Choices

Jim, ,Just exercising will facilitate a change in your mental state and usually leads to not frequently checking the time. I mean without any conscious mental effort to be in present moment, this will often happen spontaneously by just exercising. Often runners and other exercise enthusiast will often find it hard to stop after exercising a period of time. They might not feel very eager to start, but once started it's hard to stop. I certainly have experience this. So at beginning of exercise I check the time every minute or so until after 15 or 30 minutes actually forget to be checking. Yoga exercises were developed, as I understand, to help facilitate meditation. So, what I'm saying here is the actually physical exercise may be much more a facilitator to being in present moment than any kind of conscious mental effort.

Now, I understand in yoga the mindfulness you have to bring to performing the posses is a large part of what facilitates the mediation and mindfulness, but I think also that the just physical excursion itself facilitates mediation and mindfulness.

+++++Jim, I think you have answered your questions in your last sentence. I do not think you or I or anyone wants to be in the present moment at all times and not in the "world of thoughts" as you put it. I believe individuals of most other species are pretty much in present moment. But our specie's ability to be in the "world of thoughts" is what has led to our species being so successful on this planet. To simply go to grocery store and buy what you need for meals in the next few days requires you to think ahead and plan what you are going to eat and then what you need to buy. And thinking about the past and remembering what you like or don't like to eat and recalling how to cook what you want to eat is required. (Well, that's kind of a funny awkward sentence! But I hope you all understand what I'm saying).

Anyway my point here is we often need to be in the world of thoughts and not always just in the present. And in many situations it's harmful not to be thinking of future or past. E.g. buying something you desire in present without recalling that the money you have is needed to pay rent or mortgage next week.

In ACT, the acceptance of emotions part comes about because the way we solve so many problems effectively is not effective on solving things we struggle with emotionally. So, if we are cold, we know we can solve that problem by getting rid of that state. We can put on warmer cloths, or go inside or turn up the thermostat. Then we are no longer cold. But for many emotions we feel, to try to do something to eliminate those emotions does not work and leads to our getting more entangled and struggling more. So hence the acceptance of emotions in ACT. (In a podcast or i-tunes U interview of I listened to yesterday has given me some valuable clearer insight into "acceptance" but I guess that is for another conversation).

Perhaps, the same kind of thing applies to mindfulness and being in present moment. Our species' ability to have language and to make all the associations and relationshiips of thoughts and concepts and to think about the past and future is a great ability. But we can get often get so tied up on our past and stories we tell ourselves and labels we put on ourselves and others and also get tied up on our future and what possible disasters could strike us. So in the right context, the mindfulness and being present in moment because very important, but not only being in present moment at all times. But correct me if I'm wrong in some respect on this or you think I'm missing some point or if any of you can eloborate on this much better than I have here, please respond.

Hi ,

I know

what your saying. For me distraction means that I am will miss the thought. As

I am not consciously aware of that thought- I don't seem to have a choice as to

whether or not to follow that thought with the behaviour it asks for-In my

example looking at the clock. For me, this means that, in my everyday life, if

I want to behave in ways that are consistent with my values I must try and

maintain contact with the present moment. As soon as I drift into the world of

thoughts I am distracted and just react to things in the same old ways I have

been doing all my life. In some cases, this may be consistent with living

according to my values but in a lot of cases it is not.

The big

problem for me in maintaining this state- the state in which I have choices to

act in a way consistent with what I really want to be about. I just read

(In reply to 's post)。He talks about acceptance that comes with really being present in the

moment. I have had short periods of time where I feel I have managed to live

like this (Talking minutes or hours)-Where I can relax into what is and not ask

for more or less. In these times I feel like I have finally stopped swimming

against the current of what is- I can choose how I want to behave and use the

energy that would be wasted on resistance to follow my values. The problem is I

just can’t stay there in the present. So how do you ever get to stay? Some

monks spend years in monasteries training their minds to stay in the moment but

never get there- What chance have I got? From my experience it appears that the

more time time I spend in the world of thoughts the more distracted I become. I just

wonder how people like and Jon Kabat-Zin spend so much time in the world

of words and thoughts- writing books, theorizing, researching etc, etc but still seem to

know how to stay with the present moment. My guess in that maybe it’s not to do

with how much time you spend practicing being in contact with the present but

how you train your self in the ability to switch between real contact with the

present moment and being in the world of thoughts.

To: ACT_for_the_Public Sent: Fri, December 24, 2010 7:03:51 PM

Subject: Re: Choices

Hi Jim,Reading your email does resonate with me, the way you explain the situation is clear and I have seen myself doing the much the same.And then I start to think, or rather observe myself noticing these very thoughts and urges, and well, I sort of now giggle at myself and thank my mind for noticing.

Then I have a thought, do I really have the need to look at the clock or is it possible for me not to to have that urge.When I practice the 'not looking' I find it is hard in the first instance, then it becomes easier as time progresses.

Sometimes I notice that I get distracted momentarily, after

which I notice that I was distracted and then I have the thought of, wow that was easy, and so it goes.I wonder if what I have said or the way I have conveyed this is confusing or do you or others relate to these processes of the mind.

It is quite easy to find ourselves getting caught up, even quite tangled and engaged in particular thoughts.I know I do all the time, and sometimes I consciously choose to, to see where it goes, sometimes going into quite existential realms of the mind.

Then, I realise where I have been and again, consciously connect back to the present moment.Ah, I smile and realise, maybe I have gained some further understanding of my mind and what I can do, what I can choose to do.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Jim wrote:I recently Happened upon an experience that really made it clear to me how connection with the present moment and being mindful can allow you to choose your behaviour in situations where previously it appeared that there was no choice. I have an exercise machine and I try to meditate while using

it for the half hour I do everyday. To my mind it is a boring exercise and I generally want the time to go as soon as possible so I can get off the exercise machine and do something more interesting and less uncomfortable. These thoughts result it me compulsively checking the time on the meter on the handlebars. Without mindfulness practice I will generally find myself checking every minute or two. If I meditate while exercising I find that if I am really staying connected to the present moment I will notice the urge or thought that leads me to look at the meter. As I notice this thought or urge I have a choice- to look or not to look. If I lose contact with the present moment I am never consciously aware of the urge- so I have no choice. Of course, this translates well into everyday life where, particularly when the going gets tough, we lose contact with the present and lose the ability to make choices.

I am forever telling people about such

miraculous findings only for them to tell me that it¡¯s quite obvious. So sorry if this is one of them.

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...