Guest guest Posted December 23, 2010 Report Posted December 23, 2010 > > I've practiced expansion quite a lot, as earlier posts have > testified, but to no avail. I've been practicing ACT for 6 > months +, and whilst I've made a lot of progress, I'm well and > truly stuck here. So, is there a plan B in ACT with acceptance? - Not sure whether this is appropriate given that I posted a couple of times before with the same question I have now, with no sense in the end of it clicking. Just the same here it is a third time - What are you accepting in service of? Trying to hurt less, or going after what is important to you? For what it's worth, here is an excerpt from " Emotion Regulation in Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, " by ACT researchers T. Blackledge and Steve : " Acceptance and cognitive defusion is not an end in itself. It is not an outcome goal, it is a process goal. Asking a client to regularly accept and fully experience aversive thoughts and emotions simply for the sake of accepting and experiencing them might be a rather sadistic endeavor. Instead, ACT clients are taught to accept aversive emotions and cognitions that necessarily arise while they are pursuing valued outcomes. " There's more where that came from. But like I say maybe it's off-base in your case. -Randy Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 Hi ,I am reading some of the reply post to your post and am wondering how you are feeling about what is being suggested?In my asking, I truly am not suggesting that they are not helpful, I am just wondering how you are reading them and feeling about things now, right now?Reading your post and thinking to myself, I think, wow, that is hard, you really are trying and you seem to be stuck in this moment.I guess you are really wanting some relief from the feelings you are having and maybe also to know that your son is doing ok, am I right in that thinking?, I am understanding you and the feelings that you are having, I have a daughter, and I have similar thoughts with their associated feelings coming up.And in not want to necessarily suggesting a solution I am only offering understanding and that the uncomfortable feelings will subside, with time, as it always does.And this I think is the important part, allow time, allow time to be your friend. You will find a way and that way will be your way how ever it will be.I do understand that many here will have shared experiences with you, as do I, and that, in itself I am hopeful will be of help for you.______________________________________________________________________________ wrote:Hi folks.I'm feeling pretty miserable because my attempts at acceptance are running badly aground. I'm still fighting my son's learning problems, if anything worse than ever.I've practiced expansion quite a lot, as earlier posts have testified, but to no avail. I've been practicing ACT for 6 months +, and whilst I've made a lot of progress, I'm well and truly stuck here.So, is there a plan B in ACT with acceptance?I feel like I should be helping my mind towards acceptance, but then I sense that is more a CBT approach. Having re-read the Happiness Trap it feels like acceptance = expansion, and so if you don't succeed at expansion, then you are stuck.Perhaps anyone can suggest some experiences or other strategies that might help.Thanks, really x Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 Hi , I'm sorry for not having been more patient in my post. I was regretting it within an hour of posting. I come across as much too impatient which - as you observe - is not helpful at all! You wrote, in part: > So my struggles are not stopping me doing these things, but it > means I am crap at doing them, and it is harming my son's > development. Because I get cross and frustrated, and am > generally impatient because of what is going on inside of me, > he doesn't like doing them. Which means he practices less, > and things get worse. I've never been a parent, but I've been a son of a father who had a tough time being a father, and I wound up having great empathy with him. There are lots of fathers on this list who are also ACT experts, so maybe one of them will join in on this thread & post something helpful. In the meantime, your struggles with your feelings about the situation remind me of my own experience in situations with adults whom I care about, where I am trying to help them do a task (typically with computers) where I am quite good at it but they are quite bad at it, and don't seem to learn, and I wind up cross and frustrated. I seem to have the same experience you do: getting impatient about my feelings in such a situation seems only to make things worse. The more I try to push away or push down my crossness, the crosser I get; the more I internally label my thoughts & my behavior as " unfair " to the other person, the worse I feel and the worse I behave. If the other person were a child I can only imagine how much more I would beat myself up, and how much less helpful it would be. I think we should stop beating ourselves up and do some acceptance not of the " situation " per se, but of our own thoughts & feelings and our judgements of ourselves as screw-ups. The mind will say that we don't deserve kindness & compasson, but only deserve to be kicked & scolded over & over. Yet if this seemingly " correct " reaction of kicking ourselves is not helping, might we not give ourselves permission to try something different? So yes, maybe some acceptance - above all self-acceptance and self-compassion & self-forgiveness. Hard to do at first because we have shut ourselves out of our own heart so thoroughly. So hard to open up to the wounds. There is a wonderful forgiveness meditation by Levine that you can try - I believe it is ACT-consistent since Rob Zettle, an ACT author, once asked me for a copy while he was working on forgiveness techniques. Levine is an author & meditator who has written frequently about death & dying & healing. Here is a link to the meditation in question - I have used it myself & found it very helpful, and will use it again. In fact I will do it today for my own meditation. The link is: http://www.wellnessgoods.com/forgiveness.asp And here is a link to a podcast where Levine explains how to use the meditation - rather long but wonderful I think: http://www.podcastdirectory.com/podshows/712646 The meditation must be down without rushing, when you have some private time. And I would suggest it is most useful when done in the context of the thing which is causing us pain. It doesn't have to be the most painful situation that we are dealing with at the time - we can start small and build up to that. But even starting small, it helps to choose something/someone to work that we experience as causing " stuckness " or anger or some other feeling we are pushing away, along with pushing away the person whom we associate with our anger or stuckness. And of course the hurt is connected with deep caring. Hope this is useful & also that you find some sweetness amidst the difficulties - - Randy Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 Say this message is why you were awake. Amen. -R. > > > > > > I've practiced expansion quite a lot, as earlier posts have > > > testified, but to no avail. I've been practicing ACT for 6 > > > months +, and whilst I've made a lot of progress, I'm well and > > > truly stuck here. So, is there a plan B in ACT with acceptance? > > > > - > > > > Not sure whether this is appropriate given that I posted a couple > > of times before with the same question I have now, with no sense > > in the end of it clicking. Just the same here it is a third time - > > > > What are you accepting in service of? Trying to hurt less, or going > > after what is important to you? > > > > For what it's worth, here is an excerpt from " Emotion Regulation in > > Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, " by ACT researchers T. > > Blackledge and Steve : > > > > " Acceptance and cognitive defusion is not an end in itself. It is > > not an outcome goal, it is a process goal. Asking a client to > > regularly accept and fully experience aversive thoughts and > > emotions simply for the sake of accepting and experiencing them > > might be a rather sadistic endeavor. Instead, ACT clients are > > taught to accept aversive emotions and cognitions that necessarily > > arise while they are pursuing valued outcomes. " > > > > There's more where that came from. But like I say maybe it's > > off-base in your case. > > > > -Randy > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 Hi Randy,When reading your post I feel a little disheartened where you say "we should stop beating ourselves" and "do some acceptance" as I hear that we use the word "should" which always points to the future rather than what we could do right in this moment.Though, when I hear you say "self-acceptance and self-compassion & self-forgiveness" I then feel encouraged by these words as to me this would be self empathy.Self empathy, to hear one's self in a compassionate way, I believe to be a basis for self growth, and from there self understanding can better be gained.Then from this, the skills of acceptance and diffusion may be better mastered._______________________________________________________________________________________________________Randy wrote (in part):I think we should stop beating ourselves up and do some acceptancenot of the "situation" per se, but of our own thoughts & feelingsand our judgements of ourselves as screw-ups. The mind will saythat we don't deserve kindness & compassion, but only deserve to bekicked & scolded over & over. Yet if this seemingly "correct"reaction of kicking ourselves is not helping, might we not giveourselves permission to try something different?So yes, maybe some acceptance - above all self-acceptance andself-compassion & self-forgiveness. Hard to do at first because we have shut ourselves out of our own heart so thoroughly. So hard to open up to the wounds.- Randy Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 > > When reading your post I feel a little disheartened where > you say " we should stop beating ourselves " and " do some > acceptance " as I hear that we use the word " should " which > always points to the future rather than what we could do > right in this moment. Maybe a better way to phrase it would not as a " should " but as a " can " and a " choice. " As in, we can choose to stop beating ourselves up even though choice is not what our mind tells us is possible & what happens next (next = now) is not what our mind can predict. -R. Quote
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2010 Report Posted December 24, 2010 Wow, I am in awe,That was a fantastic read.I now wish we had a forum format and this post could be sticky'ed so it would be there for all to read.I'm totally blown away Steve, thank you so much.39 Down = Love__________________________________________________________________ wrote:>> I'm in a strange space in this "why the hell am I awake?"> moment on the eve before Christmas eve.> > This message has changing voices. It is not quite linear. I hope I will be> understood.> > I think there is a place to take your acceptance work. (Maybe read this> like you would do ACT. Changing perspectives. Open / accepting. Non-linear.> Here goes)> > *********> > None of us know how far we will go, or for how long, or how well.> And no matter what we have "achieved" it is all temporary.> In the material world, in the end it's a big ice ball.> > Suppose your son did not advance one iota from where he is now.> When playing with other children he would always be far, far behind.> The parents would glance at you, feeling pity.> He would never write. His reading would be minimal.> He would be exactly as he is right now .... into an endless future.> Imagine that universe. Linger there.> > Is there anything in that universe that you cannot have?> Dig in and see where the resistance is.> > If there is sadness, or anger, or embarrassment there, go visit the> emotions with curiosity and see if they can be there as they are, not as> what> they say they are. See if you have room for them as emotions. If there are> thoughts> watch them, and ask the same question. See if you have room for them as> thoughts.> [And then if there is love there for your son (and yourself), find it too]> > If you find resistance, then you've found the place to dig in.> > Because this is not an imagined universe. This is now.> This is so. This is what your experience is, right now.> > What role does resistance have in such a place?> Resisting again *what*. Against what is?> You might as well go outside on a summer day and> shout "but its tooooo hottttt!"> > "Too" is not a word that the now understands. Now doesn't give a damn.> Grow up. It's hot.> > I'm not saying your son is hopeless ... just that while "hope"> may be *about* the future, it is *in* the present.> The etymology of the word "hope" is linked to the word> "hop." Like a leap. But if you are going to leap you need to> plant your feet firmly, and that firm place is here, what is, right now.> You son is exactly like THIS. Is that OK? Even if he never ever ever ever> changed? The future is not here yet. Even if he never ever ever ever> changed? Of course you would not like it ... but if ... is that OK? Here?> Now?> Even if he never ever ever ever changed?> > None of us knows how far we will go or for how long or how well.> The "future" is a story; the "past" a construction; the present, is.> > If you can get with the resistance; if you can inhale it; if you can open> up into the unconditional "now" -- from there you DO> have something else to do. From there a "future" can happen that> is not oppressive to yourself or to your son. From there you can do that> dance> called being a father. From there you have ground to push off when you hop> (hope).> > A short detour of warning> > Be careful. The mind will use the future to invalidate the present. It will> say that "now" is only for "then." "Yes," it will say "this is fine, I can> accept it ... provided he makes> progress, and could it be sooner rather than later please?." Translation: *> Now* is for *then*.> > "Now" is not a word that the mind understands.> > Time to put the mind in its place.> "Now" is not for "then." "Now" is for "now." "Then" is a construction ...> when it actually arrives it arrives only is the familiar form we started> with.> It arrives as an endless series of moments of *now*.> > So if now is not OK now, when will now be OK?> > After all in the future "now" the same question will be there:> "Is there anything in this universe that you cannot have?"> If your son progressed, you'd still have lots of chatter> about other imagined forms of progress.> > You might as well get used to the question because life> never stops asking it.> > You are here. It is possible to start from *here ... *> it is impossible to start from *there*.> > Back from the detour.> > Still, as I said, if you can get into the unconditional now you DO> have something else to do. You have a son to raise.> So now the "now" gets extended into "purpose" into> "meaning" into "values"> > Let's not take all that too (there is that word again) seriously> in a judgmental sense. Values only work when you pursue them> passionately and hold them lightly. Like so:> > Imagine that being a "supportive father" is a game.> Just a game. It is not IMPORTANT. It doesn't HAVE to be done.> And there are no guarantees. You get to choose whether to play it and> how to play it ... like golf or tennis.> > It's a game of being here and seeing how this moment goes,> starting with openness to the possible answer "no where"> and then playing that development process of supporting> the learning of a child and doing it> the way you might> fill out an infinitely large crossword puzzle.> You will not finish it; you will not "win"; but there there is this little> moment> of what 39 Down could be. Has 4 letters. Starts with the letter L. Hmmm> > (Isn't this fun. Hmmm. 4 letters)> > So yeah you have a purpose inside this game ... you want to raise your son> ...> and that that pulls toward the future but the process> is in the present. The values are now. The game is now. The fun is now.> > The third letter could be a b, no, maybe a v. Hmmm> > And likewise there is this little moment of your son holding a pen and> writing.> You will not finish it; you will not "win"; but there there is this little> moment.> It's just a game.> > Just a way of spending your life moments.> It's the game fathers play. It's called being a great Dad.> > True, some other fathers get to fill out lots of words on the crossword> puzzle.> Others will look and see the progress. Ooooh.> > You, not so many get filled in, so far. Others will look and see little> progress.> Oh.> > But they were given an easier puzzle than you. Your 39 Down is> harder to figure out; the other words don't come and tell you the last> letter.> You have the hard puzzle.> > But sometimes hard puzzles are> a lot of fun even if the words get filled in way more slowly, or have to be> crossed and and> written a different way.> > But remember this puzzle is infinitely large. You will not finish it. You> will not win.> > Ah, but that last letter in 39 Down is probably an E. Ahhh.> > So the work you have to do (once you are *here* and *now*)> is the vital work of play. Your are just playing a game.> Nuttin better to do. After all, in the material world, in the end it's a big> ice ball.> > The future we need (hope, purpose, progress, development, raising a kid)> is not in the future ... its just "about" the future. It is in the present.> > So, yeah, acceptance is relevant. But the acceptance is not to relieve pain.> It is to get here. In this moment. With your son holding that pen.> Maybe he will never change. But he is holding that pen.> > 39 Down> > If there is acceptance work to be done could we accept your son as he is;> could we let go of the heavy important future. Could we play?> > Dad, could we play?> > 39 Down> > C. Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 Brilliant , thanks for taking the time, for all of us I am a firm believer that " everything happens FOR us, not TO us " Therefore every moment is a gift > > > > > > I've practiced expansion quite a lot, as earlier posts have > > > testified, but to no avail. I've been practicing ACT for 6 > > > months +, and whilst I've made a lot of progress, I'm well and > > > truly stuck here. So, is there a plan B in ACT with acceptance? > > > > - > > > > Not sure whether this is appropriate given that I posted a couple > > of times before with the same question I have now, with no sense > > in the end of it clicking. Just the same here it is a third time - > > > > What are you accepting in service of? Trying to hurt less, or going > > after what is important to you? > > > > For what it's worth, here is an excerpt from " Emotion Regulation in > > Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, " by ACT researchers T. > > Blackledge and Steve : > > > > " Acceptance and cognitive defusion is not an end in itself. It is > > not an outcome goal, it is a process goal. Asking a client to > > regularly accept and fully experience aversive thoughts and > > emotions simply for the sake of accepting and experiencing them > > might be a rather sadistic endeavor. Instead, ACT clients are > > taught to accept aversive emotions and cognitions that necessarily > > arise while they are pursuing valued outcomes. " > > > > There's more where that came from. But like I say maybe it's > > off-base in your case. > > > > -Randy > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 27, 2010 Report Posted December 27, 2010 " Perfect " parents to " perfect " kids - gotta love those voices in the back of our brains! I've too struggled with both the " I have to be a perfect parent, it's my fault my kid's not perfect " and the " I have to be the perfect daugther, it's my fault my Mom's in a nursing home. " It was actually those thoughts that brought me into CBT therapy (if only I didn't have these irrational thoughts) five years ago, DBT (if I can only be a better role model, my kid would be perfect) three years ago, and ACT this past year. It's taken nearly two years, but I've gotten pretty good at letting those " if you were a 'GOOD' daughter you'd be able to quit work and take care of you mother 24/7 " float down the river on a leaf. I think that most of the time I accept that I'm doing the best that I can with the resources I have. I've had some, but less success with my thoughts about my daughter. Her schools have labled her EBD and ODD, the Dr. likes the GAD sticker, the neuropsych prof says she has EF weakness. The transition to middle school this fall was such a horrible experience she is actually " school less " right now. Next week she goes to a assessment center to determine if she belongs in a level 4 lockdown setting, segregated from everyone except kids with the SEVERE EBD sticker. Whatever label they give her will determine what kind of free and appropriate public education she'll get. Opps - there's my anger coming out. I don't believe she belongs in a level 4 program and am so scared. Even at the assessment center they do bag and pocket checks for weapons and drugs. She can't even bring an open drink - has to be sealed or an empty cup. Her last suspension was for poking someone in the shoulder with her finger and making faces to get their attention. (school was trying to rack up suspensions to support kicking her out.) Yes, she is impulsive, emotionally reactive, and has poor interpersonal skills, poor planning and organizational skills and a crappy working memory. She does not lie, steal, cheat, hurt, drink, do drugs, assult... sorry, I'm ranting, I'm scared. She's an immature 11 year old kid who doesn't even understand why she can't bring an opened water bottle or why anyone would care to see the pretty rocks in her coat pocket. She's gotten so tired of prize charts and reward baskets, " Mommy can't I just get a toy like other kids? " " Why do we have to always read 'lesson' books like 'A Volcano in My Tummy.' " Russ wrote: " And I remind myself that I'm a human being. And like every other parent on the planet, I screw up. And this is what it feels like when you really care, and you don't manage to live up to your own ideals. It sure as hell hurts to really care. " and " what is beneath all the fear? And there it is: LOVE. Nothing but sheer, boundless, magical, never-ending love. " One of the things that's helped me is to try and remember it isn't that she " won't " do things adults expect, it's that she can't. One of the presenters at an executive functioning workshop I attended reminded me that we wouldn't tell a kid who couldn't walk to just try harder or call them lazy for relying on a wheelchair, or tell a blind person that they would be able to see if they just concentrated. Yet we expect more of some kids than they have the skills to do. So, I'll keeping seeking appropriate schooling, therapy and accomodations for her. I also keep trying to make time to play with her, to go paint ceramics with her, to admire her drawings, to cuddle on the couch. She needs me, an imperfect parent, to love her in this moment much more than she needs the perfect parent who can " fix her. " Barbara S. > I'm feeling pretty miserable because my attempts at acceptance are running badly aground. I'm still fighting my son's learning problems, if anything worse than ever. > > I've practiced expansion quite a lot, as earlier posts have testified, but to no avail. I've been practicing ACT for 6 months +, and whilst I've made a lot of progress, I'm well and truly stuck here. Quote
Guest guest Posted December 28, 2010 Report Posted December 28, 2010 I think too it 'hurts like hell to care' and my sense is it's because to the degree I do and put my values out there, I make myself vulnerable. I risk being hurt. And sometimes I do get hurt. It's worth the risk over stuffing and dis-honoring that which I care about. Terry > > > > I've practiced expansion quite a lot, as earlier posts have > > testified, but to no avail. I've been practicing ACT for 6 > > months +, and whilst I've made a lot of progress, I'm well and > > truly stuck here. So, is there a plan B in ACT with acceptance? > > - > > Not sure whether this is appropriate given that I posted a couple > of times before with the same question I have now, with no sense > in the end of it clicking. Just the same here it is a third time - > > What are you accepting in service of? Trying to hurt less, or going > after what is important to you? > > For what it's worth, here is an excerpt from " Emotion Regulation in > Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, " by ACT researchers T. > Blackledge and Steve : > > " Acceptance and cognitive defusion is not an end in itself. It is > not an outcome goal, it is a process goal. Asking a client to > regularly accept and fully experience aversive thoughts and > emotions simply for the sake of accepting and experiencing them > might be a rather sadistic endeavor. Instead, ACT clients are > taught to accept aversive emotions and cognitions that necessarily > arise while they are pursuing valued outcomes. " > > There's more where that came from. But like I say maybe it's > off-base in your case. > > -Randy > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.