Guest guest Posted November 2, 2010 Report Posted November 2, 2010 Randy, for once, I think I have to disagree with you. It is not uncommon for patients to have feelings of attachment, even romantic feelings, toward their therapists. A trained therapist should know how to receive and defuse this information from their clients. I once told my therapist I thought I was falling in love with him, and he assured me that that was not uncommon; he calmly pointed out that we were talking about intimate things and establishing a close relationship, we were both young and attractive, etc. The fact that he discussed it so reasonably and did not make me feel weird about it put me at ease, and I realized that I was just infatuated and it was OK, and we were able to move on with the therapy very productively, evenlaughing about it from time to time. That doesn't mean all therapists will be able to react like mine did. But I believe it is incumbent on the therapist to handle this as a professional and not as a layperson might. It was right for him to bring it up -- progress cannot be made in therapy unless one is completely honest, and having personal feelings toward ones therapist must be discussed in the context of the professional relationship. Her duty was to remain present in the room as a professional human being, not in a personal sense, even when he told her something very personal--that he was attracted to her. Your last paragraph in which you set up a hypothetical situation makes no sense to me because she IS his therapist and I don't see how imagining her to be a co-worker in such a scenario is applicable, except perhaps to give him a little insight into her feelings, which is not his job in this relationship. It is her responsibility to react and interact with him from a professional point of view, no matter what he brings to the table. Especially, since he was being honest and his intentions were to explore his feelings toward her and examine if their work could go on with that in the picture. If she was uncomfortable with what he shared with her, the right thing might have been to keep her personal feelings to herself and terminate the relationship. Certainly, snapping at him about not being a robot was not helpful. She is a human being, after all, and can be forgiven for that, but she clearly should have just kindly ended the relationship if she could not handle this news more appropriately as a professional. I really think she messed this up and he may just need to move to another therapist. Helena Re: not sure if I should find a new therapist >> She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I> thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I> said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more> deeply with me and say something like, let's work through> this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a> robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I> hoped she might help me work through it.It seems to me you are putting your therapist in a double bind. You want her to participate in a discussion that involves herin a personal and not a professional sense, and you want her todo this strictly as a professional. In other words to not bepresent in the room as a human being while you talk about howattractive she is as a human being. If she weren't your therapist, but some other person (say, aco-worker) and a similar situation occurred - i.e. you expressedfeelings of attraction for her that she did not share, and thatmade her uncomfortable - would you similarly demand that shedisregard her own discomfort and spend a lot of time discussingyour feelings toward her?- Randy Quote
Guest guest Posted November 2, 2010 Report Posted November 2, 2010 I don't know what the therapist should or shouldn't have done and am not very interested in that. I am more interested in, what can I do to treat others with respect? And in this case in particular, I should not wish to treat a therapist as if she or he were responsible for everything that happened in therapy and I were responsible for nothing. -R. > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I > > thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I > > said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more > > deeply with me and say something like, let's work through > > this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a > > robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I > > hoped she might help me work through it. > > It seems to me you are putting your therapist in a double bind. > You want her to participate in a discussion that involves her > in a personal and not a professional sense, and you want her to > do this strictly as a professional. In other words to not be > present in the room as a human being while you talk about how > attractive she is as a human being. > > If she weren't your therapist, but some other person (say, a > co-worker) and a similar situation occurred - i.e. you expressed > feelings of attraction for her that she did not share, and that > made her uncomfortable - would you similarly demand that she > disregard her own discomfort and spend a lot of time discussing > your feelings toward her? > > - Randy > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 2, 2010 Report Posted November 2, 2010 Helena, Now I am sorry for having come across so harsh so quick. Not sure why I'm so rigid on this topic. I've done a quick spot of reading on this topic & yes, it does seem that a skilled therapist can handle this sort of thing in a way that validates the client & helps teach them how to have a desire or feeling and not having it fulfilled, without this lack of fulfillment becoming an obstacle to engaged living. On the other hand I do think we are talking about a student therapist learning their craft here ... and about our own responsibility in relationships, even with therapists. I can easily imagine the therapist's discomfort here with a situation she has not been trained to handle. If the only way out is " find a new therapist because my current therapist has blown it, " what has been learned? To abandon relationships when others don't do as you wish? -R. > > > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I > > > thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I > > > said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more > > > deeply with me and say something like, let's work through > > > this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a > > > robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I > > > hoped she might help me work through it. > > > > It seems to me you are putting your therapist in a double bind. > > You want her to participate in a discussion that involves her > > in a personal and not a professional sense, and you want her to > > do this strictly as a professional. In other words to not be > > present in the room as a human being while you talk about how > > attractive she is as a human being. > > > > If she weren't your therapist, but some other person (say, a > > co-worker) and a similar situation occurred - i.e. you expressed > > feelings of attraction for her that she did not share, and that > > made her uncomfortable - would you similarly demand that she > > disregard her own discomfort and spend a lot of time discussing > > your feelings toward her? > > > > - Randy > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 2, 2010 Report Posted November 2, 2010 Hi Randy, Thanks for your response and for the 2nd one especially. How did he, as the client, act irresponsibly? He is responsible in this relationship to bring honesty, sincerity and respect to the interaction. He did that. I think both may have contributed to the discomfort, but the therapist could have handled it more appropriately. Surely any therapist knows that their clients may develop romantic feelings toward them and be prepared for that. A student therapist is not in therapy to learn how to be a therapist, although the experience may be educational. He is in therapy to get therapy. I do think it is sometimes OK to abandon the therapist/client relationship if things happen to steer the work off course and trust has been compromised. That is not true in most relationships, of course, where one must learn to accept that others may blow it from time to time and stay the course (unless there is a deal breaker, like abuse). And it may be that this relationship will not have to end--that's up to them. Thanks for your point of view. I do see it, but don't agree with it wholeheartedly. Helena Re: not sure if I should find a new therapist Helena,Now I am sorry for having come across so harsh so quick. Notsure why I'm so rigid on this topic. I've done a quick spot of reading on this topic & yes, it doesseem that a skilled therapist can handle this sort of thing in a way that validates the client & helps teach them how to have a desire or feeling and not having it fulfilled, withoutthis lack of fulfillment becoming an obstacle to engaged living.On the other hand I do think we are talking about a studenttherapist learning their craft here ... and about our ownresponsibility in relationships, even with therapists. I caneasily imagine the therapist's discomfort here with a situationshe has not been trained to handle. If the only way out is"find a new therapist because my current therapist has blownit," what has been learned? To abandon relationships whenothers don't do as you wish? -R. > > > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I > > > thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I > > > said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more > > > deeply with me and say something like, let's work through > > > this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a > > > robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I > > > hoped she might help me work through it. > > > > It seems to me you are putting your therapist in a double bind. > > You want her to participate in a discussion that involves her > > in a personal and not a professional sense, and you want her to > > do this strictly as a professional. In other words to not be > > present in the room as a human being while you talk about how > > attractive she is as a human being. > > > > If she weren't your therapist, but some other person (say, a > > co-worker) and a similar situation occurred - i.e. you expressed > > feelings of attraction for her that she did not share, and that > > made her uncomfortable - would you similarly demand that she > > disregard her own discomfort and spend a lot of time discussing > > your feelings toward her? > > > > - Randy> >> Quote
Guest guest Posted November 2, 2010 Report Posted November 2, 2010 Just like to say -Randy- that the 'Observer exercise' you recorded is absolute quality. Such a perfect recording- your voice, the timing and the exercise itself.ThanksJimTo: ACT_for_the_Public Sent: Tue, November 2, 2010 6:12:32 PMSubject: Re: not sure if I should find a new therapist Helena, Now I am sorry for having come across so harsh so quick. Not sure why I'm so rigid on this topic. I've done a quick spot of reading on this topic & yes, it does seem that a skilled therapist can handle this sort of thing in a way that validates the client & helps teach them how to have a desire or feeling and not having it fulfilled, without this lack of fulfillment becoming an obstacle to engaged living. On the other hand I do think we are talking about a student therapist learning their craft here ... and about our own responsibility in relationships, even with therapists. I can easily imagine the therapist's discomfort here with a situation she has not been trained to handle. If the only way out is "find a new therapist because my current therapist has blown it," what has been learned? To abandon relationships when others don't do as you wish? -R. > > > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I > > > thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I > > > said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more > > > deeply with me and say something like, let's work through > > > this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a > > > robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I > > > hoped she might help me work through it. > > > > It seems to me you are putting your therapist in a double bind. > > You want her to participate in a discussion that involves her > > in a personal and not a professional sense, and you want her to > > do this strictly as a professional. In other words to not be > > present in the room as a human being while you talk about how > > attractive she is as a human being. > > > > If she weren't your therapist, but some other person (say, a > > co-worker) and a similar situation occurred - i.e. you expressed > > feelings of attraction for her that she did not share, and that > > made her uncomfortable - would you similarly demand that she > > disregard her own discomfort and spend a lot of time discussing > > your feelings toward her? > > > > - Randy > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 2, 2010 Report Posted November 2, 2010 I missed that exercise. Will you send it to me? BillTo: ACT_for_the_Public From: hensbyjim@...Date: Tue, 2 Nov 2010 07:05:48 -0700Subject: Re: Re: not sure if I should find a new therapist Just like to say -Randy- that the 'Observer exercise' you recorded is absolute quality. Such a perfect recording- your voice, the timing and the exercise itself.ThanksJimTo: ACT_for_the_Public Sent: Tue, November 2, 2010 6:12:32 PMSubject: Re: not sure if I should find a new therapist Helena, Now I am sorry for having come across so harsh so quick. Not sure why I'm so rigid on this topic. I've done a quick spot of reading on this topic & yes, it does seem that a skilled therapist can handle this sort of thing in a way that validates the client & helps teach them how to have a desire or feeling and not having it fulfilled, without this lack of fulfillment becoming an obstacle to engaged living. On the other hand I do think we are talking about a student therapist learning their craft here ... and about our own responsibility in relationships, even with therapists. I can easily imagine the therapist's discomfort here with a situation she has not been trained to handle. If the only way out is "find a new therapist because my current therapist has blown it," what has been learned? To abandon relationships when others don't do as you wish? -R. > > > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I > > > thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I > > > said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more > > > deeply with me and say something like, let's work through > > > this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a > > > robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I > > > hoped she might help me work through it. > > > > It seems to me you are putting your therapist in a double bind. > > You want her to participate in a discussion that involves her > > in a personal and not a professional sense, and you want her to > > do this strictly as a professional. In other words to not be > > present in the room as a human being while you talk about how > > attractive she is as a human being. > > > > If she weren't your therapist, but some other person (say, a > > co-worker) and a similar situation occurred - i.e. you expressed > > feelings of attraction for her that she did not share, and that > > made her uncomfortable - would you similarly demand that she > > disregard her own discomfort and spend a lot of time discussing > > your feelings toward her? > > > > - Randy > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 2, 2010 Report Posted November 2, 2010 Thank you for your thoughts, and for hearing me experiential, I feel you understand things pretty well. > > > > > > > > So, I've been seeing a therapist for several months at a local clinic. The clinic is run by a local university and is staffed with graduate students who are under supervision. This is all I could afford at the time and the other option I had was to see a psychologist who was booked for 2 months and I didn't want to wait. > > > > > > > > For the greater part of my therapy, things have been very focused and productive. I brought in my ACT book and discussed ACT and how I've been using it, and she was not only open-minded about using ACT, she got the book herself and said that her supervisor was very interested in ACT. We worked through some of the book together. > > > > > > > > Throughout the process I have learned so much about myself, have really grown and begun to accept myself and explore myself for all that I am. I've learned to not judge myself or what I feel in the ways that I used to. This has been a very painful process, but a good one. For every period of pain and growth I've come out stronger and with less of a burden. > > > > > > > > I've had a lot of different, positive feelings towards my therapist. I've found that these feelings were at time confusing. I've come to understand that these feelings are that of openness, connectedness, trust etc. the kinds of feelings I've felt in my very close relationships. Yet there was also a part of me that felt attracted to her at times and the fact that we have so much in common also deepend my connection and closeness to her. It seems that over time I became more aware of these positive feelings, and I was judging some of them as 'inappropriate' etc. For example, I could tell that part of me was longing for a deeper relationship with her, something outside of therapy. I kept fighting this feeling, pushing it down within myself, telling myself that it was crazy etc. What's interesting to me now is that by suppressing it, it manifested itself much more than it would have if I had just explored it straight-away. > > > > > > > > I brought this up with my therapist a few times, saying that I was confused about feelings that I was having in session, my feelings of closeness and openness with her etc. Eventually, I realized that I needed to tell her matter of factly, not in the round about way that I had been. More importantly, I realized that I shouldn't judge myself for having feelings. I can see there being inappropriate actions or words, but to feel a thing is perfectly natural. Over the course of a few weeks I noticed that she seemed uncomfortable at times and even was frustrated with me. When I asked her if she had been frustrated with me in the last session, she admitted that she was. I was glad she was honest and that I could trust my instincts. She brought up termination somewhere around this time, which seemed to come out of nowhere. > > > > > > > > Let me be clear, I never felt in love with my therapist, or obsessed or any such thing. I only would have wanted any kind of contact or relationship outside of the office if it was something that we both wanted, and the one thing I was sure of was that my therapy was going well and that I wanted to continue it. But I needed to get this out of the way. I needed to take a leap, to be totally honest and non-judgemental towards myself and also completely open with her. This was difficult and took a lot of effort. > > > > > > > > When I told her all of how I felt, I explained that I had had many different feelings in session, some of them towards her, that of connection, etc. I even said that if I was forced to lablel them (which I'm loathe to do) I would label some of them as perhaps romantic, others as platonic and that I always felt respectful of her. I also told her that I was attracted to her in many ways, that even though I didn't know her very well that I felt I had a sense of the kind of person she was. She's always been very genuine and open with me and it's fostered a sense of trust between us and I told her how important that was and how it's helped me. > > > > > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more deeply with me and say something like, let's work through this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I hoped she might help me work through it. All that I've learned about therapy (disclosure here, I'm a psychology student myself) is that opening up to one's therapist, even about how you feel towards them, can be very positive and can help deepen one's self-acceptance and self-understanding. Being able to tell someone honestly how you feel about them is definitely a good thing, though sometimes painful. She told me that she hadn't had anything like this happen before and that she would need to talk to her supervisor. > > > > > > > > At the next session she basically said that she felt that my telling her about my feelings were 'inappropriate' in the way that falling for a co-worker would be, that it crossed some kind of boundary. She seemed genuinely concerned about the course of therapy, but she didn't seem to budge on this point. We discussed it for a while and I told her that I felt that telling her those things was a major step forward for me, that I had assumed we would discuss the feelings and explore them the way we have my other feelings. I also told her that through telling her about those feelings, the one's that seemed 'romantic' diminished, or to put it a different way, I began to see them differently. Sometimes actually admitting something to oneself and being honest with yourself and another can make you see things differently and more clearly. I told her that I didn't have feelings for her in the way that she took what I had said. To be honest, I'm not entirely clear what it is she 'heard' me say, she wouldn't tell me that directly when I asked her. She just kept saying that she thought we'd discussed it. > > > > > > > > So at this point she started talking about what was best for me, and for her. I asked what her supervisor said, and she hesitated and said that she'd had a conversation with him and that he supported her and how she felt. For the first time since I started therapy with her, I doubted whether or not she was being honest with me. I told her that I would respect her feelings and if she wanted to start termination, we would do that. Yet, I also told her that I felt it a shame that my therapy might be derailed after such a big step forward for me and that I disagreed with her about the boundary thing. I felt I had crossed no such line and that I in fact SHOULD have told her especially, since she's my therapist and she could help me work through things. > > > > > > > > Anyhow, the session ended with us discussing some recent progress I'd made and I agreed to meet every two weeks as opposed to every week. Yet after I got home, I began to think over the session and I can't help feel, as I felt last week, that she has made this about her somehow. After all, I'm the client. I can only assume that what I told her has triggered something in her. Her reaction was immediate and visceral. It's not as though I threatened her, but it almost feels like she felt threatened somehow. Things being what they are, I am not sure that I should continue seeing her because it seems like she's filtering everything I bring up now through the context of this event. It's as if she's hearing what she expects me to say, not what I'm saying, and that can't really work. For example, when I told her about a recent breakthrough I'd had as regards relationships generally, she told me she was hearing that I still 'had feelings' for her. I had to explain again, highlighting the fact that I was talking about something I'd realized GENERALLY speaking and that it wasn't about her or the feelings I'd described. > > > > > > > > So, at this point, I'm not sure what to do. I have two weeks before our next scheduled appointment, but I'm feeling like this therapy has in some ways already been derailed. And I am not sure if she's going to be able to really treat me if she can't focus on me and what I'm going through. On the other hand, maybe I should continue on through the termination process (which is open-ended at this point). I think a feeling I'm confronting now is a lack of trust in the process moving forward with her. With such a fundamental difference in how we view the boundaries, I'm not sure if we can move forward at all. > > > > > > > > Any advice, thoughts, insights on this would be greatly appreciated. Anyone have a similar experience? > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 2, 2010 Report Posted November 2, 2010 Helena, thank you very much for your response. You've summarized pretty clearly how I feel about the situation and it is nice to know that I'm not completely alone in how I feel about this situation. It's also nice to have confirmation that it can indeed be handled differently. In session with my therapist yesterday I was feeling as though I was being somehow 'inappropriate' even though my inner feelings feels that this isn't so. You also hit the nail on the head, I did feel sort of 'weird' when I was in session yesterday. And some of the looks she's given me, consternation is the word I'd use, it arises a feeling of being judged by her. It also has felt to me, even though I trust her when she says this isn't true, that I've opened up to someone in a very intimate way, and now she's leaving (by bringing up termination.) We've discussed this, and it's true she hasn't 'left' per se, but the termination feels sort of like that. It just sort of feels like it's negatively reinforcing things I've dealt with all my life. Namely, that if you show people your true self, they will reject you and leave. I've made lots of progress with this in therapy, ironically, and now it feels somehow reinforced. I'm working on that. Randy, I want to thank you for your thoughts as well, they are not lost on me. I definitely want my therapist to be present and genuine with me, however, I do agree with Helena about how it should be handled. I also want to clarify something that may not have been clear from my post. My therapist brought up termination a few weeks ago, however she didn't tell me she was uncomfortable etc. but rather was saying that she thought I was making enough progress to end treatment. All this at the same time that she expressed frustration towards me and the first signs of discomfort for her, though I didn't know that's what she felt at the time. Anyhow, I agreed in our session last night to begin meeting every two weeks instead of weekly as a beginning to termination. At this point I am thinking that she brought up termination initially because she was uncomfortable, but I'm not sure of that and I'm not sure that it matters at this point. Maybe she was trying to end it because of that but wasn't sure how to go about it. I also want to make clear that in all of this, I have to hold her supervisor responsible to some degree, because she is in training and I wonder how closely this situation was observed by him. My sense is that, very little. Last week she said she was going to need to talk to her supervisor about the situation, that she hadn't before. I think she should have but maybe she felt she was failing somehow or something. At any rate, none of that is my responsibility, as Helena eloquently pointed out. I think the main thing I'm struggling with is whether or not the remainder of my therapy with her can be productive or if it will somehow do damage. I almost feel that the last three sessions have been damaging to me. And yet at the same time, it feels like I've made progress...almost despite the situation. I also should mention that she gave me an ultimatum in yesterday's session. She said she wanted to get a clearer picture of my feelings before making a decision about what to do (whether and how to terminate.) We discussed my feelings some but I have to be honest, it wasn't a true exploration of them and what they mean to me or to her. It was more of " do you have feelings for me or not " kind of thing, which really misses the whole point of what I was trying to explain to her, and misses the point of how such feelings can (and I feel should) be addressed in therapy, if possible. She told me that if we continued but that I at some point later told her that I had feelings for her that would be the end of therapy. She did acknowledge that some of my positive feelings for her were not problematic. But leads right back to the idea that some of my feelings (romantic-ish, attraction) are not okay. Please understand that my therapist is in a position of power and I went along with this at the time. However, after having a little time to go through my feelings on this, I'm realizing that it's absurd for me to NOT have feelings toward her. I think she's caught up on any kind of attraction/feelings meaning X when I think it means Y to me. I told her this but I don't think she gets it. So basically, my main concern now is that it seems that therapy has become more about what she's comfortable with and less about my therapy. I even found myself giving in to an old pattern of mine to try and make sure she feels comfortable. So I am at an impasse. Do I call her, set up a meeting for next week and terminate, or stay with it, try and explore this further and wrap up my therapy with her in a more positive light. I must say, on the whole, my therapy with her has been VERY positive, and I hold her in high regard. I of course, would rather end things on a positive note, to get some positive closure. I'm just not sure if that can happen if every time I say something about feeling something (whether towards her or in general) she will tense up and begin worrying about whatever it is she's concerned about. Will she continue to be uncomfortable? So maybe if I have no clear decision on this I need to talk to her about it. I really do appreciate all that you all have said and I welcome any thoughts and perspectives. > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I > > thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I > > said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more > > deeply with me and say something like, let's work through > > this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a > > robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I > > hoped she might help me work through it. > > It seems to me you are putting your therapist in a double bind. > You want her to participate in a discussion that involves her > in a personal and not a professional sense, and you want her to > do this strictly as a professional. In other words to not be > present in the room as a human being while you talk about how > attractive she is as a human being. > > If she weren't your therapist, but some other person (say, a > co-worker) and a similar situation occurred - i.e. you expressed > feelings of attraction for her that she did not share, and that > made her uncomfortable - would you similarly demand that she > disregard her own discomfort and spend a lot of time discussing > your feelings toward her? > > - Randy > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 2, 2010 Report Posted November 2, 2010 I agree with Helena's points. A relationship with a therapist is not a relationship of equals (unlike coworkers, except for supervisor-subordinate of course). The therapist is in a power position and should act accordingly. It is not your responsibility as the client to put your therapist at ease! I've had feelings towards some of my therapists but never explored them in therapy. For that reason, I held back and was not completely honest about my feelings in general. It may have been a valuable lesson for me to learn how to deal with those feelings (heck, to admit I even had such feelings!), since I avoid uncomfortable emotions and since relationship difficulties are a major, ongoing issue for me. I think your therapist was being unprofessional and laying it all on you, the client, to resolve. Personally, I could not continue therapy in that kind of closed-off environment.~ lisa  Helena, thank you very much for your response. You've summarized pretty clearly how I feel about the situation and it is nice to know that I'm not completely alone in how I feel about this situation. It's also nice to have confirmation that it can indeed be handled differently. In session with my therapist yesterday I was feeling as though I was being somehow 'inappropriate' even though my inner feelings feels that this isn't so. You also hit the nail on the head, I did feel sort of 'weird' when I was in session yesterday. And some of the looks she's given me, consternation is the word I'd use, it arises a feeling of being judged by her. It also has felt to me, even though I trust her when she says this isn't true, that I've opened up to someone in a very intimate way, and now she's leaving (by bringing up termination.) We've discussed this, and it's true she hasn't 'left' per se, but the termination feels sort of like that. It just sort of feels like it's negatively reinforcing things I've dealt with all my life. Namely, that if you show people your true self, they will reject you and leave. I've made lots of progress with this in therapy, ironically, and now it feels somehow reinforced. I'm working on that. Randy, I want to thank you for your thoughts as well, they are not lost on me. I definitely want my therapist to be present and genuine with me, however, I do agree with Helena about how it should be handled. I also want to clarify something that may not have been clear from my post. My therapist brought up termination a few weeks ago, however she didn't tell me she was uncomfortable etc. but rather was saying that she thought I was making enough progress to end treatment. All this at the same time that she expressed frustration towards me and the first signs of discomfort for her, though I didn't know that's what she felt at the time. Anyhow, I agreed in our session last night to begin meeting every two weeks instead of weekly as a beginning to termination. At this point I am thinking that she brought up termination initially because she was uncomfortable, but I'm not sure of that and I'm not sure that it matters at this point. Maybe she was trying to end it because of that but wasn't sure how to go about it. I also want to make clear that in all of this, I have to hold her supervisor responsible to some degree, because she is in training and I wonder how closely this situation was observed by him. My sense is that, very little. Last week she said she was going to need to talk to her supervisor about the situation, that she hadn't before. I think she should have but maybe she felt she was failing somehow or something. At any rate, none of that is my responsibility, as Helena eloquently pointed out. I think the main thing I'm struggling with is whether or not the remainder of my therapy with her can be productive or if it will somehow do damage. I almost feel that the last three sessions have been damaging to me. And yet at the same time, it feels like I've made progress...almost despite the situation. I also should mention that she gave me an ultimatum in yesterday's session. She said she wanted to get a clearer picture of my feelings before making a decision about what to do (whether and how to terminate.) We discussed my feelings some but I have to be honest, it wasn't a true exploration of them and what they mean to me or to her. It was more of " do you have feelings for me or not " kind of thing, which really misses the whole point of what I was trying to explain to her, and misses the point of how such feelings can (and I feel should) be addressed in therapy, if possible. She told me that if we continued but that I at some point later told her that I had feelings for her that would be the end of therapy. She did acknowledge that some of my positive feelings for her were not problematic. But leads right back to the idea that some of my feelings (romantic-ish, attraction) are not okay. Please understand that my therapist is in a position of power and I went along with this at the time. However, after having a little time to go through my feelings on this, I'm realizing that it's absurd for me to NOT have feelings toward her. I think she's caught up on any kind of attraction/feelings meaning X when I think it means Y to me. I told her this but I don't think she gets it. So basically, my main concern now is that it seems that therapy has become more about what she's comfortable with and less about my therapy. I even found myself giving in to an old pattern of mine to try and make sure she feels comfortable. So I am at an impasse. Do I call her, set up a meeting for next week and terminate, or stay with it, try and explore this further and wrap up my therapy with her in a more positive light. I must say, on the whole, my therapy with her has been VERY positive, and I hold her in high regard. I of course, would rather end things on a positive note, to get some positive closure. I'm just not sure if that can happen if every time I say something about feeling something (whether towards her or in general) she will tense up and begin worrying about whatever it is she's concerned about. Will she continue to be uncomfortable? So maybe if I have no clear decision on this I need to talk to her about it. I really do appreciate all that you all have said and I welcome any thoughts and perspectives. > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I > > thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I > > said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more > > deeply with me and say something like, let's work through > > this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a > > robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I > > hoped she might help me work through it. > > It seems to me you are putting your therapist in a double bind. > You want her to participate in a discussion that involves her > in a personal and not a professional sense, and you want her to > do this strictly as a professional. In other words to not be > present in the room as a human being while you talk about how > attractive she is as a human being. > > If she weren't your therapist, but some other person (say, a > co-worker) and a similar situation occurred - i.e. you expressed > feelings of attraction for her that she did not share, and that > made her uncomfortable - would you similarly demand that she > disregard her own discomfort and spend a lot of time discussing > your feelings toward her? > > - Randy > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 2, 2010 Report Posted November 2, 2010 Helena - I agree with your response to act_ed, but I think that you may have missed that while he is a student, his therapist is also a student. I've see student therapists before and have had similar challenges. Because they are so new and are still " practicing " like student teachers they can both be open to new things (like ACT) and thrown for a loop by things they didn't expect and don't have suffecient experience to deal with. Things may have gone smoother if she was experienced at dealing with this type of situation or if her supervisor was more hands on. ly I think that if her supervisor would have better helped her respond more appropriatly the theraputic relationship wouldn't had to have been busted up. It's sad that act_ed is losing a therapist he's " clicked with " over something that is very common. I wonder if finding a therapist that " get's you " and listens actually increases the likehood of these type of feelings. The first hit that comes up on a Google search of " feelings for therapist " says, " Who wouldn't " fall in love " with someone who listens patiently, has compassion and concern, focuses totally on our problems and helps us solve them? It's a very natural and normal response, especially for patients whose emotional injuries " Anyway, I think act_ed's post doesn't show him being unprofessional and I wouldn't even describe his therapists response as unprofessional, mearly unexperienced! Barbara S. > A student therapist is not in therapy to learn how to be a therapist, although the experience may be educational. He is in therapy to get therapy. I do think it is sometimes OK to abandon the therapist/client relationship if things happen to steer the work off course and trust has been compromised. That is not true in most relationships, of course, where one must learn to accept that others may blow it from time to time and stay the course (unless there is a deal breaker, like abuse). And it may be that this relationship will not have to end--that's up to them. > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 2, 2010 Report Posted November 2, 2010 Barbara, thanks for your thoughts and insights. I've been wrestling with whether or not to contact her supervisor. I have to wonder if he knows anything about this. I think he definitely should. It's also giving me a sickening feeling that she might be abusing her power in the situation, to cover for herself for example, by pushing things on me. Maybe part of her is doing that unconsciously, or maybe that's not it at all. I do know that her doing that would make me feel very betrayed, and I so hope that's not what is going on here. Like you say Barbara, she is inexperienced, and there's a very large part of me that hopes very much that that's all there is to it, that she's just inexperienced and not being supervised well. The alternative is too unsettling. So thank you for reminding me of these points. Now that I've typed all of this out I'm settling down a bit and remembering all of the positives that have taken place in our therapy. This makes me feel very sad, but that's much better than feeling betrayed. And I think I'd feel sad when therapy was over regardless. I hope you're right about this situation. Again, thanks for the input, it's helpful. And thanks to everyone, this is all helping me a great deal. > > A student therapist is not in therapy to learn how to be a therapist, although the experience may be educational. He is in therapy to get therapy. I do think it is sometimes OK to abandon the therapist/client relationship if things happen to steer the work off course and trust has been compromised. That is not true in most relationships, of course, where one must learn to accept that others may blow it from time to time and stay the course (unless there is a deal breaker, like abuse). And it may be that this relationship will not have to end--that's up to them. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 2, 2010 Report Posted November 2, 2010 Here it is attached. Starting to get confused as to whether it was the same Randy I wrote that last mail to as the Randy who recorded this exercise. But it's very good whatever.JimTo: ACT_for_the_Public <act_for_the_public >Sent: Tue, November 2, 2010 9:19:11 PMSubject: RE: Re: not sure if I should find a new therapist I missed that exercise. Will you send it to me? BillTo: ACT_for_the_Public From: hensbyjim@...Date: Tue, 2 Nov 2010 07:05:48 -0700Subject: Re: Re: not sure if I should find a new therapist Just like to say -Randy- that the 'Observer exercise' you recorded is absolute quality. Such a perfect recording- your voice, the timing and the exercise itself.ThanksJimTo: ACT_for_the_Public Sent: Tue, November 2, 2010 6:12:32 PMSubject: Re: not sure if I should find a new therapist Helena, Now I am sorry for having come across so harsh so quick. Not sure why I'm so rigid on this topic. I've done a quick spot of reading on this topic & yes, it does seem that a skilled therapist can handle this sort of thing in a way that validates the client & helps teach them how to have a desire or feeling and not having it fulfilled, without this lack of fulfillment becoming an obstacle to engaged living. On the other hand I do think we are talking about a student therapist learning their craft here ... and about our own responsibility in relationships, even with therapists. I can easily imagine the therapist's discomfort here with a situation she has not been trained to handle. If the only way out is "find a new therapist because my current therapist has blown it," what has been learned? To abandon relationships when others don't do as you wish? -R. > > > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I > > > thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I > > > said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more > > > deeply with me and say something like, let's work through > > > this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a > > > robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I > > > hoped she might help me work through it. > > > > It seems to me you are putting your therapist in a double bind. > > You want her to participate in a discussion that involves her > > in a personal and not a professional sense, and you want her to > > do this strictly as a professional. In other words to not be > > present in the room as a human being while you talk about how > > attractive she is as a human being. > > > > If she weren't your therapist, but some other person (say, a > > co-worker) and a similar situation occurred - i.e. you expressed > > feelings of attraction for her that she did not share, and that > > made her uncomfortable - would you similarly demand that she > > disregard her own discomfort and spend a lot of time discussing > > your feelings toward her? > > > > - Randy > > > 1 of 1 File(s) act_observer_exercise.mp3 Quote
Guest guest Posted November 3, 2010 Report Posted November 3, 2010 Yes, the same. Glad it's been helpful. FYI there are a bunch of other audio exercises by various folks, also freely available & listed on the ACBS web site - the URL is: http://contextualpsychology.org/free_audio -R. > > > > > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I > > > > thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I > > > > said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more > > > > deeply with me and say something like, let's work through > > > > this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a > > > > robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I > > > > hoped she might help me work through it. > > > > > > It seems to me you are putting your therapist in a double bind. > > > You want her to participate in a discussion that involves her > > > in a personal and not a professional sense, and you want her to > > > do this strictly as a professional. In other words to not be > > > present in the room as a human being while you talk about how > > > attractive she is as a human being. > > > > > > If she weren't your therapist, but some other person (say, a > > > co-worker) and a similar situation occurred - i.e. you expressed > > > feelings of attraction for her that she did not share, and that > > > made her uncomfortable - would you similarly demand that she > > > disregard her own discomfort and spend a lot of time discussing > > > your feelings toward her? > > > > > > - Randy > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 3, 2010 Report Posted November 3, 2010 I've really been run through the mill with this experience. I've come back to this forum several times and have read through what everyone has said. It's been very helpful. I keep coming back to this post though, and the question you asked, " Is she? " and I realized that she isn't steering things to a therapeutic direction. I also realized that she may just not be able to right now. Perhaps she doesn't have the tools, perhaps it's triggered something too overwhelming in her. I can accept that she may be unable to take things in a therapeutic direction. I can't accept her telling me that my expressing those things in therapy is inappropriate. And I can't accept an ultimatum from her to not tell her I feel certain feelings again or therapy is over. That kind of conditional situation just isn't going to be good for me and my therapy. I'm realizing that in my last session I wasn't entirely congruent with myself. I don't think she realizes the power position she is in with me. I almost think she sees us as peers in some way, since she brought up the co-workers analogy. I found myself deferring to her, even when inside I knew what she was saying wasn't quite right. I'm saddened because I've realized that therapy simply can't continue if I am not 'allowed' to discuss feelings in therapy, even if they are one's toward her. I can accept that therapy may end, but it is painful, particularly because I've made so much progress, and up until this point it's been a very good fit. Perhaps that's why I've had so many positive and confusing feelings towards her. I even feel if I met her in different circumstances we might have become good friends. I even have some part of me that hopes we could be friends after therapy. To be honest, the thought of never talking to her again after therapy ends has made me sad several times before, like losing a good friend. So I think I need to just tell her that I am uncomfortable continuing therapy with her if I feel I have to censor myself. I can't promise her I won't need to tell her at some point in the future that I am having feelings towards her. I'm not even so sure that I'm not still having them in some way, though it feels to me now that I was having feelings for the situation, so to speak, that all of the positive emotions, the trust, the openness, it all reminded me of how I've felt and have longed to feel towards someone I would have a deep relationship with. But that is probably over-intellectualizing things. I think I did that in the last session to some degree because I didn't want her to feel uncomfortable. Even though I know the feelings are towards her, as a fellow human being who has helped me to learn, to grow, to be more completely who I am, through kindness, openness, through hearing me, through being genuine. Perhaps the labels I used to describe the experience in some way alarmed her, but it doesn't change the fact that the underlying experience/emotions were positive. I'm still not sure if I should contact her supervisor though. I don't want to 'go behind her back', but at the same time, I'm not sure that the supervisor is involved. Would the supervisor really be okay with her telling me that it's not okay for me to bring up these kinds of things with her? I can scarcely imagine that that's true. I am concerned for myself and others who may be subjected to this kind of thing because it's been somewhat traumatic for me. > > > > > > > > So, I've been seeing a therapist for several months at a local clinic. The clinic is run by a local university and is staffed with graduate students who are under supervision. This is all I could afford at the time and the other option I had was to see a psychologist who was booked for 2 months and I didn't want to wait. > > > > > > > > For the greater part of my therapy, things have been very focused and productive. I brought in my ACT book and discussed ACT and how I've been using it, and she was not only open-minded about using ACT, she got the book herself and said that her supervisor was very interested in ACT. We worked through some of the book together. > > > > > > > > Throughout the process I have learned so much about myself, have really grown and begun to accept myself and explore myself for all that I am. I've learned to not judge myself or what I feel in the ways that I used to. This has been a very painful process, but a good one. For every period of pain and growth I've come out stronger and with less of a burden. > > > > > > > > I've had a lot of different, positive feelings towards my therapist. I've found that these feelings were at time confusing. I've come to understand that these feelings are that of openness, connectedness, trust etc. the kinds of feelings I've felt in my very close relationships. Yet there was also a part of me that felt attracted to her at times and the fact that we have so much in common also deepend my connection and closeness to her. It seems that over time I became more aware of these positive feelings, and I was judging some of them as 'inappropriate' etc. For example, I could tell that part of me was longing for a deeper relationship with her, something outside of therapy. I kept fighting this feeling, pushing it down within myself, telling myself that it was crazy etc. What's interesting to me now is that by suppressing it, it manifested itself much more than it would have if I had just explored it straight-away. > > > > > > > > I brought this up with my therapist a few times, saying that I was confused about feelings that I was having in session, my feelings of closeness and openness with her etc. Eventually, I realized that I needed to tell her matter of factly, not in the round about way that I had been. More importantly, I realized that I shouldn't judge myself for having feelings. I can see there being inappropriate actions or words, but to feel a thing is perfectly natural. Over the course of a few weeks I noticed that she seemed uncomfortable at times and even was frustrated with me. When I asked her if she had been frustrated with me in the last session, she admitted that she was. I was glad she was honest and that I could trust my instincts. She brought up termination somewhere around this time, which seemed to come out of nowhere. > > > > > > > > Let me be clear, I never felt in love with my therapist, or obsessed or any such thing. I only would have wanted any kind of contact or relationship outside of the office if it was something that we both wanted, and the one thing I was sure of was that my therapy was going well and that I wanted to continue it. But I needed to get this out of the way. I needed to take a leap, to be totally honest and non-judgemental towards myself and also completely open with her. This was difficult and took a lot of effort. > > > > > > > > When I told her all of how I felt, I explained that I had had many different feelings in session, some of them towards her, that of connection, etc. I even said that if I was forced to lablel them (which I'm loathe to do) I would label some of them as perhaps romantic, others as platonic and that I always felt respectful of her. I also told her that I was attracted to her in many ways, that even though I didn't know her very well that I felt I had a sense of the kind of person she was. She's always been very genuine and open with me and it's fostered a sense of trust between us and I told her how important that was and how it's helped me. > > > > > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more deeply with me and say something like, let's work through this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I hoped she might help me work through it. All that I've learned about therapy (disclosure here, I'm a psychology student myself) is that opening up to one's therapist, even about how you feel towards them, can be very positive and can help deepen one's self-acceptance and self-understanding. Being able to tell someone honestly how you feel about them is definitely a good thing, though sometimes painful. She told me that she hadn't had anything like this happen before and that she would need to talk to her supervisor. > > > > > > > > At the next session she basically said that she felt that my telling her about my feelings were 'inappropriate' in the way that falling for a co-worker would be, that it crossed some kind of boundary. She seemed genuinely concerned about the course of therapy, but she didn't seem to budge on this point. We discussed it for a while and I told her that I felt that telling her those things was a major step forward for me, that I had assumed we would discuss the feelings and explore them the way we have my other feelings. I also told her that through telling her about those feelings, the one's that seemed 'romantic' diminished, or to put it a different way, I began to see them differently. Sometimes actually admitting something to oneself and being honest with yourself and another can make you see things differently and more clearly. I told her that I didn't have feelings for her in the way that she took what I had said. To be honest, I'm not entirely clear what it is she 'heard' me say, she wouldn't tell me that directly when I asked her. She just kept saying that she thought we'd discussed it. > > > > > > > > So at this point she started talking about what was best for me, and for her. I asked what her supervisor said, and she hesitated and said that she'd had a conversation with him and that he supported her and how she felt. For the first time since I started therapy with her, I doubted whether or not she was being honest with me. I told her that I would respect her feelings and if she wanted to start termination, we would do that. Yet, I also told her that I felt it a shame that my therapy might be derailed after such a big step forward for me and that I disagreed with her about the boundary thing. I felt I had crossed no such line and that I in fact SHOULD have told her especially, since she's my therapist and she could help me work through things. > > > > > > > > Anyhow, the session ended with us discussing some recent progress I'd made and I agreed to meet every two weeks as opposed to every week. Yet after I got home, I began to think over the session and I can't help feel, as I felt last week, that she has made this about her somehow. After all, I'm the client. I can only assume that what I told her has triggered something in her. Her reaction was immediate and visceral. It's not as though I threatened her, but it almost feels like she felt threatened somehow. Things being what they are, I am not sure that I should continue seeing her because it seems like she's filtering everything I bring up now through the context of this event. It's as if she's hearing what she expects me to say, not what I'm saying, and that can't really work. For example, when I told her about a recent breakthrough I'd had as regards relationships generally, she told me she was hearing that I still 'had feelings' for her. I had to explain again, highlighting the fact that I was talking about something I'd realized GENERALLY speaking and that it wasn't about her or the feelings I'd described. > > > > > > > > So, at this point, I'm not sure what to do. I have two weeks before our next scheduled appointment, but I'm feeling like this therapy has in some ways already been derailed. And I am not sure if she's going to be able to really treat me if she can't focus on me and what I'm going through. On the other hand, maybe I should continue on through the termination process (which is open-ended at this point). I think a feeling I'm confronting now is a lack of trust in the process moving forward with her. With such a fundamental difference in how we view the boundaries, I'm not sure if we can move forward at all. > > > > > > > > Any advice, thoughts, insights on this would be greatly appreciated. Anyone have a similar experience? > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 4, 2010 Report Posted November 4, 2010 I spoke with my therapist a little while ago and she agreed to meet with me next week. We were going to meet in two weeks but I feel I'd rather address things sooner than later. I told her briefly that I wanted to continue some of the conversation from last time and about what's best for me. It's amazing how I observed myself earlier in the day hesitating to call her, some part of me afraid to lose the relationship because it's been so positive and because of the openness I feel and trust. And I know that by calling I'm taking a step towards either coming back to the table or having therapy with her end. It was very important for me to focus in on what's best for me and to call her and be more assertive about what I want and need. I can see pretty clearly now how I wasn't being entirely congruent with myself in the last session about what's best for me. This forum has helped me to realize that and what's best for me. This is the first step. Hopefully we can come back to the table. And if not, hopefully we can end things on some kind of positive note. I really appreciate everyone's advice on this. I am always open to more and I'll update as things happen. I am impressed and touched by the candor, genuineness and care expressed in these posts. I'm also impressed by how many aspects of ACT are represented, without being explicitly so. It seems many of you really are incorporating ACT into your lives and it is so nice to have you share that with me. I know that it's been helpful to me and I feel that this is yet one more situation to apply it to. > > So, I've been seeing a therapist for several months at a local clinic. The clinic is run by a local university and is staffed with graduate students who are under supervision. This is all I could afford at the time and the other option I had was to see a psychologist who was booked for 2 months and I didn't want to wait. ...... Quote
Guest guest Posted November 5, 2010 Report Posted November 5, 2010 Thanks for sharing and for the encouragement Maarten, very much appreciated. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So, I've been seeing a therapist for several months at a local clinic. The clinic is run by a local university and is staffed with graduate students who are under supervision. This is all I could afford at the time and the other option I had was to see a psychologist who was booked for 2 months and I didn't want to wait. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > For the greater part of my therapy, things have been very focused and productive. I brought in my ACT book and discussed ACT and how I've been using it, and she was not only open-minded about using ACT, she got the book herself and said that her supervisor was very interested in ACT. We worked through some of the book together. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Throughout the process I have learned so much about myself, have really grown and begun to accept myself and explore myself for all that I am. I've learned to not judge myself or what I feel in the ways that I used to. This has been a very painful process, but a good one. For every period of pain and growth I've come out stronger and with less of a burden. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I've had a lot of different, positive feelings towards my therapist. I've found that these feelings were at time confusing. I've come to understand that these feelings are that of openness, connectedness, trust etc. the kinds of feelings I've felt in my very close relationships. Yet there was also a part of me that felt attracted to her at times and the fact that we have so much in common also deepend my connection and closeness to her. It seems that over time I became more aware of these positive feelings, and I was judging some of them as 'inappropriate' etc. For example, I could tell that part of me was longing for a deeper relationship with her, something outside of therapy. I kept fighting this feeling, pushing it down within myself, telling myself that it was crazy etc. What's interesting to me now is that by suppressing it, it manifested itself much more than it would have if I had just explored it straight-away. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I brought this up with my therapist a few times, saying that I was confused about feelings that I was having in session, my feelings of closeness and openness with her etc. Eventually, I realized that I needed to tell her matter of factly, not in the round about way that I had been. More importantly, I realized that I shouldn't judge myself for having feelings. I can see there being inappropriate actions or words, but to feel a thing is perfectly natural. Over the course of a few weeks I noticed that she seemed uncomfortable at times and even was frustrated with me. When I asked her if she had been frustrated with me in the last session, she admitted that she was. I was glad she was honest and that I could trust my instincts. She brought up termination somewhere around this time, which seemed to come out of nowhere. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Let me be clear, I never felt in love with my therapist, or obsessed or any such thing. I only would have wanted any kind of contact or relationship outside of the office if it was something that we both wanted, and the one thing I was sure of was that my therapy was going well and that I wanted to continue it. But I needed to get this out of the way. I needed to take a leap, to be totally honest and non-judgemental towards myself and also completely open with her. This was difficult and took a lot of effort. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > When I told her all of how I felt, I explained that I had had many different feelings in session, some of them towards her, that of connection, etc. I even said that if I was forced to lablel them (which I'm loathe to do) I would label some of them as perhaps romantic, others as platonic and that I always felt respectful of her. I also told her that I was attracted to her in many ways, that even though I didn't know her very well that I felt I had a sense of the kind of person she was. She's always been very genuine and open with me and it's fostered a sense of trust between us and I told her how important that was and how it's helped me. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more deeply with me and say something like, let's work through this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I hoped she might help me work through it. All that I've learned about therapy (disclosure here, I'm a psychology student myself) is that opening up to one's therapist, even about how you feel towards them, can be very positive and can help deepen one's self-acceptance and self-understanding. Being able to tell someone honestly how you feel about them is definitely a good thing, though sometimes painful. She told me that she hadn't had anything like this happen before and that she would need to talk to her supervisor. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > At the next session she basically said that she felt that my telling her about my feelings were 'inappropriate' in the way that falling for a co-worker would be, that it crossed some kind of boundary. She seemed genuinely concerned about the course of therapy, but she didn't seem to budge on this point. We discussed it for a while and I told her that I felt that telling her those things was a major step forward for me, that I had assumed we would discuss the feelings and explore them the way we have my other feelings. I also told her that through telling her about those feelings, the one's that seemed 'romantic' diminished, or to put it a different way, I began to see them differently. Sometimes actually admitting something to oneself and being honest with yourself and another can make you see things differently and more clearly. I told her that I didn't have feelings for her in the way that she took what I had said. To be honest, I'm not en tirely cle ar what it is she 'heard' me say, she wouldn't tell me that directly when I asked her. She just kept saying that she thought we'd discussed it. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So at this point she started talking about what was best for me, and for her. I asked what her supervisor said, and she hesitated and said that she'd had a conversation with him and that he supported her and how she felt. For the first time since I started therapy with her, I doubted whether or not she was being honest with me. I told her that I would respect her feelings and if she wanted to start termination, we would do that. Yet, I also told her that I felt it a shame that my therapy might be derailed after such a big step forward for me and that I disagreed with her about the boundary thing. I felt I had crossed no such line and that I in fact SHOULD have told her especially, since she's my therapist and she could help me work through things. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Anyhow, the session ended with us discussing some recent progress I'd made and I agreed to meet every two weeks as opposed to every week. Yet after I got home, I began to think over the session and I can't help feel, as I felt last week, that she has made this about her somehow. After all, I'm the client. I can only assume that what I told her has triggered something in her. Her reaction was immediate and visceral. It's not as though I threatened her, but it almost feels like she felt threatened somehow. Things being what they are, I am not sure that I should continue seeing her because it seems like she's filtering everything I bring up now through the context of this event. It's as if she's hearing what she expects me to say, not what I'm saying, and that can't really work. For example, when I told her about a recent breakthrough I'd had as regards relationships generally, she told me she was hearing that I still 'had feelings' for her. I had to exp lain again, highlighting the fact that I was talking about something I'd realized GENERALLY speaking and that it wasn't about her or the feelings I'd described. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So, at this point, I'm not sure what to do. I have two weeks before our next scheduled appointment, but I'm feeling like this therapy has in some ways already been derailed. And I am not sure if she's going to be able to really treat me if she can't focus on me and what I'm going through. On the other hand, maybe I should continue on through the termination process (which is open-ended at this point). I think a feeling I'm confronting now is a lack of trust in the process moving forward with her. With such a fundamental difference in how we view the boundaries, I'm not sure if we can move forward at all. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Any advice, thoughts, insights on this would be greatly appreciated. Anyone have a similar experience? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 I met with my therapist last night, for the last time. I had to cancel our session last week as my grandmother passed away. I told her that I had realized that I hadn't been entirely congruent with her in my last meeting, that I had been afraid of losing the relationship and that I therefore had gone along with some of the things she was saying, and in some ways told her what I thought she wanted to hear because I didn't want to upset her further. My realizing that I did this was a big breakthrough for me. I began to see this as a pattern I've had with other people. Therapy can shed so much light on things, even in the midst of (and perhaps because of) this kind of impasse. I told her that I needed to be able to express myself. I explained to her again why I told her about my feelings, how confusing and complicated they are and that I didn't feel comfortable continuing with her ultimatum that I not tell her in the future about such feelings. I told her I had no idea what I would feel in the future and that the next step in my therapy would be for me to work through this stuff. She said again that she had issue with my telling her about those feelings, that my telling her was inappropriate, and that she felt that I should work through those things on my own and something about compartmentalizing them. I told her that I disagreed and that that seemed to just be something that we disagree about. I have come to realize that some things just ARE, and one of those things is that she's just not in a place, for whatever reason, to be able to handle/deal with what I was bringing to the table in the way that I was expecting/needing her to. I no longer feel upset at her for this. I came to realize it just is what it is. She said she felt I was blaming her and I told her that I wasn't angry with her, wasn't blaming her but that I was trying to describe things as they seem to be to me, that we were at an impasse. She seemed to understand this. We discussed this for a bit. I reiterated to her that I didn't want to make her uncomfortable but that I had to do what was best for me and that I understood if she was uncomfortable. I told her that there were many different ways that either of us could deal with the situation. I was trying to illustrate that there was no need to have 'blame', that things just are as they are. In one sense I wish things were different, but I think I've also basically made my peace with it. It was actually a positive discussion overall, I'm not sure how it sounds as I'm describing it. I guess what I mean is it wasn't argumentative or destructive. It was constructive in that we were at least trying to understand one another and respectfully disagreeing. She told me that she was feeling uncomfortable continuing, for herself and for me and that she had been feeling for a while that I had progressed to the point of meeting my goals. It is true that I have progressed quite a bit in our therapy that's taken place since April. I told her that I was uncomfortable continuing if I didn't feel I could express myself and follow therapy where it led me, which in this case was to discuss those feelings and work through them, examine them etc. We agreed that it would be our last session together. I actually had anticipated this and wasn't surprised or anxious about it for some reason. I had even brought a little card with me to give to her in case it was our last session. I knew that if it was to be the end that I wanted to end on as positive a note as possible. I think I just could feel that we had reached an end. We acknowledged our feelings together about the process and exchanged memories and talked about how things had gone from beginning to end. It felt good to discuss things, though I got really emotional. There were tears. It was the sort of sad I've felt at graduations, if that makes sense. I'm glad that we were able to discuss positives and the ups and downs and not focus on the impasse that we had reached only. She said some things that were very important for me to hear and I got the feeling that the things I said to her were important to her also. She told me that she had learned a lot and that she was glad that I had brought ACT into the picture as she hadn't worked with it before. It was kind of cool because when I first brought ACT up (months ago) she said in the following session that she had discussed it with her supervisor and that he was very much in favor of ACT and using it himself. I tried to come back to the table with her, and I am glad that I did. I don't regret anything. I'm glad I asked for and received so much perspective on this board. I think it allowed me to take a step back and see things a little more clearly, and I'm thankful to all of you for that. I can easily see how off the rails I could have gone with this. Now I have to decide if I want to resume therapy with someone else. I'm not clear on what the next step is for me, but I do feel that I have grown tremendously through this process. Thanks again to everyone for helping with this. -E > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So, I've been seeing a therapist for several months at a local clinic. The clinic is run by a local university and is staffed with graduate students who are under supervision. This is all I could afford at the time and the other option I had was to see a psychologist who was booked for 2 months and I didn't want to wait. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > For the greater part of my therapy, things have been very focused and productive. I brought in my ACT book and discussed ACT and how I've been using it, and she was not only open-minded about using ACT, she got the book herself and said that her supervisor was very interested in ACT. We worked through some of the book together. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Throughout the process I have learned so much about myself, have really grown and begun to accept myself and explore myself for all that I am. I've learned to not judge myself or what I feel in the ways that I used to. This has been a very painful process, but a good one. For every period of pain and growth I've come out stronger and with less of a burden. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I've had a lot of different, positive feelings towards my therapist. I've found that these feelings were at time confusing. I've come to understand that these feelings are that of openness, connectedness, trust etc. the kinds of feelings I've felt in my very close relationships. Yet there was also a part of me that felt attracted to her at times and the fact that we have so much in common also deepend my connection and closeness to her. It seems that over time I became more aware of these positive feelings, and I was judging some of them as 'inappropriate' etc. For example, I could tell that part of me was longing for a deeper relationship with her, something outside of therapy. I kept fighting this feeling, pushing it down within myself, telling myself that it was crazy etc. What's interesting to me now is that by suppressing it, it manifested itself much more than it would have if I had just explored it straight-away. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I brought this up with my therapist a few times, saying that I was confused about feelings that I was having in session, my feelings of closeness and openness with her etc. Eventually, I realized that I needed to tell her matter of factly, not in the round about way that I had been. More importantly, I realized that I shouldn't judge myself for having feelings. I can see there being inappropriate actions or words, but to feel a thing is perfectly natural. Over the course of a few weeks I noticed that she seemed uncomfortable at times and even was frustrated with me. When I asked her if she had been frustrated with me in the last session, she admitted that she was. I was glad she was honest and that I could trust my instincts. She brought up termination somewhere around this time, which seemed to come out of nowhere. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Let me be clear, I never felt in love with my therapist, or obsessed or any such thing. I only would have wanted any kind of contact or relationship outside of the office if it was something that we both wanted, and the one thing I was sure of was that my therapy was going well and that I wanted to continue it. But I needed to get this out of the way. I needed to take a leap, to be totally honest and non-judgemental towards myself and also completely open with her. This was difficult and took a lot of effort. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > When I told her all of how I felt, I explained that I had had many different feelings in session, some of them towards her, that of connection, etc. I even said that if I was forced to lablel them (which I'm loathe to do) I would label some of them as perhaps romantic, others as platonic and that I always felt respectful of her. I also told her that I was attracted to her in many ways, that even though I didn't know her very well that I felt I had a sense of the kind of person she was. She's always been very genuine and open with me and it's fostered a sense of trust between us and I told her how important that was and how it's helped me. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more deeply with me and say something like, let's work through this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I hoped she might help me work through it. All that I've learned about therapy (disclosure here, I'm a psychology student myself) is that opening up to one's therapist, even about how you feel towards them, can be very positive and can help deepen one's self-acceptance and self-understanding. Being able to tell someone honestly how you feel about them is definitely a good thing, though sometimes painful. She told me that she hadn't had anything like this happen before and that she would need to talk to her supervisor. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > At the next session she basically said that she felt that my telling her about my feelings were 'inappropriate' in the way that falling for a co-worker would be, that it crossed some kind of boundary. She seemed genuinely concerned about the course of therapy, but she didn't seem to budge on this point. We discussed it for a while and I told her that I felt that telling her those things was a major step forward for me, that I had assumed we would discuss the feelings and explore them the way we have my other feelings. I also told her that through telling her about those feelings, the one's that seemed 'romantic' diminished, or to put it a different way, I began to see them differently. Sometimes actually admitting something to oneself and being honest with yourself and another can make you see things differently and more clearly. I told her that I didn't have feelings for her in the way that she took what I had said. To be honest, I'm not en tirely cle ar what it is she 'heard' me say, she wouldn't tell me that directly when I asked her. She just kept saying that she thought we'd discussed it. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So at this point she started talking about what was best for me, and for her. I asked what her supervisor said, and she hesitated and said that she'd had a conversation with him and that he supported her and how she felt. For the first time since I started therapy with her, I doubted whether or not she was being honest with me. I told her that I would respect her feelings and if she wanted to start termination, we would do that. Yet, I also told her that I felt it a shame that my therapy might be derailed after such a big step forward for me and that I disagreed with her about the boundary thing. I felt I had crossed no such line and that I in fact SHOULD have told her especially, since she's my therapist and she could help me work through things. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Anyhow, the session ended with us discussing some recent progress I'd made and I agreed to meet every two weeks as opposed to every week. Yet after I got home, I began to think over the session and I can't help feel, as I felt last week, that she has made this about her somehow. After all, I'm the client. I can only assume that what I told her has triggered something in her. Her reaction was immediate and visceral. It's not as though I threatened her, but it almost feels like she felt threatened somehow. Things being what they are, I am not sure that I should continue seeing her because it seems like she's filtering everything I bring up now through the context of this event. It's as if she's hearing what she expects me to say, not what I'm saying, and that can't really work. For example, when I told her about a recent breakthrough I'd had as regards relationships generally, she told me she was hearing that I still 'had feelings' for her. I had to exp lain again, highlighting the fact that I was talking about something I'd realized GENERALLY speaking and that it wasn't about her or the feelings I'd described. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So, at this point, I'm not sure what to do. I have two weeks before our next scheduled appointment, but I'm feeling like this therapy has in some ways already been derailed. And I am not sure if she's going to be able to really treat me if she can't focus on me and what I'm going through. On the other hand, maybe I should continue on through the termination process (which is open-ended at this point). I think a feeling I'm confronting now is a lack of trust in the process moving forward with her. With such a fundamental difference in how we view the boundaries, I'm not sure if we can move forward at all. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Any advice, thoughts, insights on this would be greatly appreciated. Anyone have a similar experience? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 2, 2010 Report Posted December 2, 2010 So I'm facing a challenge post-therapy. I ran into my therapist the other day and she wouldn't look at me from across a room in a coffee shop. More specifically she looked at me and then looked away. And a second time when I saw her she looked away quickly and then actually turned her back to me. I'd had her not look at me before and she explained that she wasn't allowed to talk to me or anything for confidentiality reasons, which I understood. She also said that I was welcome to say anything to her if I saw her in public. I did speak to her another time in public and it was fine. But now that therapy is over, I'm confused. We didn't talk about what would happen if I saw her in public post-therapy. Adding to my confusion is the fact that I told her that I would like to get to know her more as a person if possible. I expressed that I didn't have any expectations but that I was open to that possibility. She told me a while ago that we couldn't be friends while she was my therapist. I didn't get a direct response from her on this because it was something I wrote to her on a thank you card I gave to her in our last session. So, I'm conflicted. Should I approach her and clarify things? Or should I not because I want to respect the fact that she might not be comfortable talking to me? I'm very confused. I am really not sure what to do. I guess the biggest problem is feeling like I can't be on any kind of normal, or even civil basis with someone that I've opened up to so much. I know that the therapist/client relationship is different, some might even say unnatural. But we're both humans first, and I guess the human part of me isn't sure how to live the " client " role now that therapy is over. Coming at this from an ACT perspective, I realize that running into, even approaching her isn't really a problem. I guess the problem is I don't want to intrude on her world, if that makes sense. Maybe I need to just clarify things with her and let the pieces fall where they may? And maybe I can explain to her if I approach her how I feel I need some clarity and am not sure what else to do? Or maybe I just let it all drop, confront the pain of being shut out, so to speak? I may just have to accept the fact that she isn't comfortable interacting with me now. Any thoughts? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So, I've been seeing a therapist for several months at a local clinic. The clinic is run by a local university and is staffed with graduate students who are under supervision. This is all I could afford at the time and the other option I had was to see a psychologist who was booked for 2 months and I didn't want to wait. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > For the greater part of my therapy, things have been very focused and productive. I brought in my ACT book and discussed ACT and how I've been using it, and she was not only open-minded about using ACT, she got the book herself and said that her supervisor was very interested in ACT. We worked through some of the book together. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Throughout the process I have learned so much about myself, have really grown and begun to accept myself and explore myself for all that I am. I've learned to not judge myself or what I feel in the ways that I used to. This has been a very painful process, but a good one. For every period of pain and growth I've come out stronger and with less of a burden. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I've had a lot of different, positive feelings towards my therapist. I've found that these feelings were at time confusing. I've come to understand that these feelings are that of openness, connectedness, trust etc. the kinds of feelings I've felt in my very close relationships. Yet there was also a part of me that felt attracted to her at times and the fact that we have so much in common also deepend my connection and closeness to her. It seems that over time I became more aware of these positive feelings, and I was judging some of them as 'inappropriate' etc. For example, I could tell that part of me was longing for a deeper relationship with her, something outside of therapy. I kept fighting this feeling, pushing it down within myself, telling myself that it was crazy etc. What's interesting to me now is that by suppressing it, it manifested itself much more than it would have if I had just explored it straight-away. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I brought this up with my therapist a few times, saying that I was confused about feelings that I was having in session, my feelings of closeness and openness with her etc. Eventually, I realized that I needed to tell her matter of factly, not in the round about way that I had been. More importantly, I realized that I shouldn't judge myself for having feelings. I can see there being inappropriate actions or words, but to feel a thing is perfectly natural. Over the course of a few weeks I noticed that she seemed uncomfortable at times and even was frustrated with me. When I asked her if she had been frustrated with me in the last session, she admitted that she was. I was glad she was honest and that I could trust my instincts. She brought up termination somewhere around this time, which seemed to come out of nowhere. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Let me be clear, I never felt in love with my therapist, or obsessed or any such thing. I only would have wanted any kind of contact or relationship outside of the office if it was something that we both wanted, and the one thing I was sure of was that my therapy was going well and that I wanted to continue it. But I needed to get this out of the way. I needed to take a leap, to be totally honest and non-judgemental towards myself and also completely open with her. This was difficult and took a lot of effort. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > When I told her all of how I felt, I explained that I had had many different feelings in session, some of them towards her, that of connection, etc. I even said that if I was forced to lablel them (which I'm loathe to do) I would label some of them as perhaps romantic, others as platonic and that I always felt respectful of her. I also told her that I was attracted to her in many ways, that even though I didn't know her very well that I felt I had a sense of the kind of person she was. She's always been very genuine and open with me and it's fostered a sense of trust between us and I told her how important that was and how it's helped me. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more deeply with me and say something like, let's work through this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I hoped she might help me work through it. All that I've learned about therapy (disclosure here, I'm a psychology student myself) is that opening up to one's therapist, even about how you feel towards them, can be very positive and can help deepen one's self-acceptance and self-understanding. Being able to tell someone honestly how you feel about them is definitely a good thing, though sometimes painful. She told me that she hadn't had anything like this happen before and that she would need to talk to her supervisor. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > At the next session she basically said that she felt that my telling her about my feelings were 'inappropriate' in the way that falling for a co-worker would be, that it crossed some kind of boundary. She seemed genuinely concerned about the course of therapy, but she didn't seem to budge on this point. We discussed it for a while and I told her that I felt that telling her those things was a major step forward for me, that I had assumed we would discuss the feelings and explore them the way we have my other feelings. I also told her that through telling her about those feelings, the one's that seemed 'romantic' diminished, or to put it a different way, I began to see them differently. Sometimes actually admitting something to oneself and being honest with yourself and another can make you see things differently and more clearly. I told her that I didn't have feelings for her in the way that she took what I had said. To be honest, I'm not en tirely cle ar what it is she 'heard' me say, she wouldn't tell me that directly when I asked her. She just kept saying that she thought we'd discussed it. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So at this point she started talking about what was best for me, and for her. I asked what her supervisor said, and she hesitated and said that she'd had a conversation with him and that he supported her and how she felt. For the first time since I started therapy with her, I doubted whether or not she was being honest with me. I told her that I would respect her feelings and if she wanted to start termination, we would do that. Yet, I also told her that I felt it a shame that my therapy might be derailed after such a big step forward for me and that I disagreed with her about the boundary thing. I felt I had crossed no such line and that I in fact SHOULD have told her especially, since she's my therapist and she could help me work through things. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Anyhow, the session ended with us discussing some recent progress I'd made and I agreed to meet every two weeks as opposed to every week. Yet after I got home, I began to think over the session and I can't help feel, as I felt last week, that she has made this about her somehow. After all, I'm the client. I can only assume that what I told her has triggered something in her. Her reaction was immediate and visceral. It's not as though I threatened her, but it almost feels like she felt threatened somehow. Things being what they are, I am not sure that I should continue seeing her because it seems like she's filtering everything I bring up now through the context of this event. It's as if she's hearing what she expects me to say, not what I'm saying, and that can't really work. For example, when I told her about a recent breakthrough I'd had as regards relationships generally, she told me she was hearing that I still 'had feelings' for her. I had to exp lain again, highlighting the fact that I was talking about something I'd realized GENERALLY speaking and that it wasn't about her or the feelings I'd described. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So, at this point, I'm not sure what to do. I have two weeks before our next scheduled appointment, but I'm feeling like this therapy has in some ways already been derailed. And I am not sure if she's going to be able to really treat me if she can't focus on me and what I'm going through. On the other hand, maybe I should continue on through the termination process (which is open-ended at this point). I think a feeling I'm confronting now is a lack of trust in the process moving forward with her. With such a fundamental difference in how we view the boundaries, I'm not sure if we can move forward at all. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Any advice, thoughts, insights on this would be greatly appreciated. Anyone have a similar experience? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 2, 2010 Report Posted December 2, 2010 Except if you are a homosexual, you'd want a opposite sex therapist.But generally I don't know. I had an opposite sex counselor this past year and particularly during one session felt so strongly connected to her and told her that. I told her that my emotions are very much similar to the emotions I have when I connect well with a dance partner. She didn't have any problem with this and in fact she seemed pleased and said something that is part of the reason she's in this business - to connect with her clients and help them. She is definitely one of the best therapist or counselors I've ever had. Another one that was very good was a guy, but I do think in general there are more good women therapist and counselors. Women, in general, are better at connecting with others than men - I think.  This sounds like a good resolution.Reading through your original post and the replies, I'm wondering if a case could be made for choosing same-sex therapists? Given that clients are often vulnerable when seeking therapeutic help, choosing a same-sex therapist would sidestep some of the complications that can arise when the therapist is of the opposite sex. What thoughts to others have regarding this issue?Regards,Detlef > > > > > > > > > >> > > > > > > > > > So, I've been seeing a therapist for several months at a local clinic. The clinic is run by a local university and is staffed with graduate students who are under supervision. This is all I could afford at the time and the other option I had was to see a psychologist who was booked for 2 months and I didn't want to wait. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > For the greater part of my therapy, things have been very focused and productive. I brought in my ACT book and discussed ACT and how I've been using it, and she was not only open-minded about using ACT, she got the book herself and said that her supervisor was very interested in ACT. We worked through some of the book together. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Throughout the process I have learned so much about myself, have really grown and begun to accept myself and explore myself for all that I am. I've learned to not judge myself or what I feel in the ways that I used to. This has been a very painful process, but a good one. For every period of pain and growth I've come out stronger and with less of a burden. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I've had a lot of different, positive feelings towards my therapist. I've found that these feelings were at time confusing. I've come to understand that these feelings are that of openness, connectedness, trust etc. the kinds of feelings I've felt in my very close relationships. Yet there was also a part of me that felt attracted to her at times and the fact that we have so much in common also deepend my connection and closeness to her. It seems that over time I became more aware of these positive feelings, and I was judging some of them as 'inappropriate' etc. For example, I could tell that part of me was longing for a deeper relationship with her, something outside of therapy. I kept fighting this feeling, pushing it down within myself, telling myself that it was crazy etc. What's interesting to me now is that by suppressing it, it manifested itself much more than it would have if I had just explored it straight-away. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I brought this up with my therapist a few times, saying that I was confused about feelings that I was having in session, my feelings of closeness and openness with her etc. Eventually, I realized that I needed to tell her matter of factly, not in the round about way that I had been. More importantly, I realized that I shouldn't judge myself for having feelings. I can see there being inappropriate actions or words, but to feel a thing is perfectly natural. Over the course of a few weeks I noticed that she seemed uncomfortable at times and even was frustrated with me. When I asked her if she had been frustrated with me in the last session, she admitted that she was. I was glad she was honest and that I could trust my instincts. She brought up termination somewhere around this time, which seemed to come out of nowhere. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Let me be clear, I never felt in love with my therapist, or obsessed or any such thing. I only would have wanted any kind of contact or relationship outside of the office if it was something that we both wanted, and the one thing I was sure of was that my therapy was going well and that I wanted to continue it. But I needed to get this out of the way. I needed to take a leap, to be totally honest and non-judgemental towards myself and also completely open with her. This was difficult and took a lot of effort. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > When I told her all of how I felt, I explained that I had had many different feelings in session, some of them towards her, that of connection, etc. I even said that if I was forced to lablel them (which I'm loathe to do) I would label some of them as perhaps romantic, others as platonic and that I always felt respectful of her. I also told her that I was attracted to her in many ways, that even though I didn't know her very well that I felt I had a sense of the kind of person she was. She's always been very genuine and open with me and it's fostered a sense of trust between us and I told her how important that was and how it's helped me. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more deeply with me and say something like, let's work through this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I hoped she might help me work through it. All that I've learned about therapy (disclosure here, I'm a psychology student myself) is that opening up to one's therapist, even about how you feel towards them, can be very positive and can help deepen one's self-acceptance and self-understanding. Being able to tell someone honestly how you feel about them is definitely a good thing, though sometimes painful. She told me that she hadn't had anything like this happen before and that she would need to talk to her supervisor. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > At the next session she basically said that she felt that my telling her about my feelings were 'inappropriate' in the way that falling for a co-worker would be, that it crossed some kind of boundary. She seemed genuinely concerned about the course of therapy, but she didn't seem to budge on this point. We discussed it for a while and I told her that I felt that telling her those things was a major step forward for me, that I had assumed we would discuss the feelings and explore them the way we have my other feelings. I also told her that through telling her about those feelings, the one's that seemed 'romantic' diminished, or to put it a different way, I began to see them differently. Sometimes actually admitting something to oneself and being honest with yourself and another can make you see things differently and more clearly. I told her that I didn't have feelings for her in the way that she took what I had said. To be honest, I'm not en tirely cle ar what it is she 'heard' me say, she wouldn't tell me that directly when I asked her. She just kept saying that she thought we'd discussed it. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So at this point she started talking about what was best for me, and for her. I asked what her supervisor said, and she hesitated and said that she'd had a conversation with him and that he supported her and how she felt. For the first time since I started therapy with her, I doubted whether or not she was being honest with me. I told her that I would respect her feelings and if she wanted to start termination, we would do that. Yet, I also told her that I felt it a shame that my therapy might be derailed after such a big step forward for me and that I disagreed with her about the boundary thing. I felt I had crossed no such line and that I in fact SHOULD have told her especially, since she's my therapist and she could help me work through things. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Anyhow, the session ended with us discussing some recent progress I'd made and I agreed to meet every two weeks as opposed to every week. Yet after I got home, I began to think over the session and I can't help feel, as I felt last week, that she has made this about her somehow. After all, I'm the client. I can only assume that what I told her has triggered something in her. Her reaction was immediate and visceral. It's not as though I threatened her, but it almost feels like she felt threatened somehow. Things being what they are, I am not sure that I should continue seeing her because it seems like she's filtering everything I bring up now through the context of this event. It's as if she's hearing what she expects me to say, not what I'm saying, and that can't really work. For example, when I told her about a recent breakthrough I'd had as regards relationships generally, she told me she was hearing that I still 'had feelings' for her. I had to exp lain again, highlighting the fact that I was talking about something I'd realized GENERALLY speaking and that it wasn't about her or the feelings I'd described. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So, at this point, I'm not sure what to do. I have two weeks before our next scheduled appointment, but I'm feeling like this therapy has in some ways already been derailed. And I am not sure if she's going to be able to really treat me if she can't focus on me and what I'm going through. On the other hand, maybe I should continue on through the termination process (which is open-ended at this point). I think a feeling I'm confronting now is a lack of trust in the process moving forward with her. With such a fundamental difference in how we view the boundaries, I'm not sure if we can move forward at all. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Any advice, thoughts, insights on this would be greatly appreciated. Anyone have a similar experience?> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >> > > > > > > >> > > > > > >> > > > > >> > > > > > > > > >> > > > > > > > > >> >> Quote
Guest guest Posted December 2, 2010 Report Posted December 2, 2010 If it were me, I'd sit with the confusion in a compassionate way and see what you might find there. It could be a good stretch to just do that. And be careful not to beat yourself up over this. Take care of yourself as you also notice what it all feels like and what your mind is saying and trying to figure out. There is no right or wrong answer, but sitting with it some can only help in my view. Go gentle, Terry > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So, I've been seeing a therapist for several months at a local clinic. The clinic is run by a local university and is staffed with graduate students who are under supervision. This is all I could afford at the time and the other option I had was to see a psychologist who was booked for 2 months and I didn't want to wait. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > For the greater part of my therapy, things have been very focused and productive. I brought in my ACT book and discussed ACT and how I've been using it, and she was not only open-minded about using ACT, she got the book herself and said that her supervisor was very interested in ACT. We worked through some of the book together. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Throughout the process I have learned so much about myself, have really grown and begun to accept myself and explore myself for all that I am. I've learned to not judge myself or what I feel in the ways that I used to. This has been a very painful process, but a good one. For every period of pain and growth I've come out stronger and with less of a burden. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I've had a lot of different, positive feelings towards my therapist. I've found that these feelings were at time confusing. I've come to understand that these feelings are that of openness, connectedness, trust etc. the kinds of feelings I've felt in my very close relationships. Yet there was also a part of me that felt attracted to her at times and the fact that we have so much in common also deepend my connection and closeness to her. It seems that over time I became more aware of these positive feelings, and I was judging some of them as 'inappropriate' etc. For example, I could tell that part of me was longing for a deeper relationship with her, something outside of therapy. I kept fighting this feeling, pushing it down within myself, telling myself that it was crazy etc. What's interesting to me now is that by suppressing it, it manifested itself much more than it would have if I had just explored it straight-away. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I brought this up with my therapist a few times, saying that I was confused about feelings that I was having in session, my feelings of closeness and openness with her etc. Eventually, I realized that I needed to tell her matter of factly, not in the round about way that I had been. More importantly, I realized that I shouldn't judge myself for having feelings. I can see there being inappropriate actions or words, but to feel a thing is perfectly natural. Over the course of a few weeks I noticed that she seemed uncomfortable at times and even was frustrated with me. When I asked her if she had been frustrated with me in the last session, she admitted that she was. I was glad she was honest and that I could trust my instincts. She brought up termination somewhere around this time, which seemed to come out of nowhere. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Let me be clear, I never felt in love with my therapist, or obsessed or any such thing. I only would have wanted any kind of contact or relationship outside of the office if it was something that we both wanted, and the one thing I was sure of was that my therapy was going well and that I wanted to continue it. But I needed to get this out of the way. I needed to take a leap, to be totally honest and non-judgemental towards myself and also completely open with her. This was difficult and took a lot of effort. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > When I told her all of how I felt, I explained that I had had many different feelings in session, some of them towards her, that of connection, etc. I even said that if I was forced to lablel them (which I'm loathe to do) I would label some of them as perhaps romantic, others as platonic and that I always felt respectful of her. I also told her that I was attracted to her in many ways, that even though I didn't know her very well that I felt I had a sense of the kind of person she was. She's always been very genuine and open with me and it's fostered a sense of trust between us and I told her how important that was and how it's helped me. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more deeply with me and say something like, let's work through this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I hoped she might help me work through it. All that I've learned about therapy (disclosure here, I'm a psychology student myself) is that opening up to one's therapist, even about how you feel towards them, can be very positive and can help deepen one's self-acceptance and self-understanding. Being able to tell someone honestly how you feel about them is definitely a good thing, though sometimes painful. She told me that she hadn't had anything like this happen before and that she would need to talk to her supervisor. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > At the next session she basically said that she felt that my telling her about my feelings were 'inappropriate' in the way that falling for a co-worker would be, that it crossed some kind of boundary. She seemed genuinely concerned about the course of therapy, but she didn't seem to budge on this point. We discussed it for a while and I told her that I felt that telling her those things was a major step forward for me, that I had assumed we would discuss the feelings and explore them the way we have my other feelings. I also told her that through telling her about those feelings, the one's that seemed 'romantic' diminished, or to put it a different way, I began to see them differently. Sometimes actually admitting something to oneself and being honest with yourself and another can make you see things differently and more clearly. I told her that I didn't have feelings for her in the way that she took what I had said. To be honest, I'm not en tirely cle ar what it is she 'heard' me say, she wouldn't tell me that directly when I asked her. She just kept saying that she thought we'd discussed it. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So at this point she started talking about what was best for me, and for her. I asked what her supervisor said, and she hesitated and said that she'd had a conversation with him and that he supported her and how she felt. For the first time since I started therapy with her, I doubted whether or not she was being honest with me. I told her that I would respect her feelings and if she wanted to start termination, we would do that. Yet, I also told her that I felt it a shame that my therapy might be derailed after such a big step forward for me and that I disagreed with her about the boundary thing. I felt I had crossed no such line and that I in fact SHOULD have told her especially, since she's my therapist and she could help me work through things. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Anyhow, the session ended with us discussing some recent progress I'd made and I agreed to meet every two weeks as opposed to every week. Yet after I got home, I began to think over the session and I can't help feel, as I felt last week, that she has made this about her somehow. After all, I'm the client. I can only assume that what I told her has triggered something in her. Her reaction was immediate and visceral. It's not as though I threatened her, but it almost feels like she felt threatened somehow. Things being what they are, I am not sure that I should continue seeing her because it seems like she's filtering everything I bring up now through the context of this event. It's as if she's hearing what she expects me to say, not what I'm saying, and that can't really work. For example, when I told her about a recent breakthrough I'd had as regards relationships generally, she told me she was hearing that I still 'had feelings' for her. I had to exp lain again, highlighting the fact that I was talking about something I'd realized GENERALLY speaking and that it wasn't about her or the feelings I'd described. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So, at this point, I'm not sure what to do. I have two weeks before our next scheduled appointment, but I'm feeling like this therapy has in some ways already been derailed. And I am not sure if she's going to be able to really treat me if she can't focus on me and what I'm going through. On the other hand, maybe I should continue on through the termination process (which is open-ended at this point). I think a feeling I'm confronting now is a lack of trust in the process moving forward with her. With such a fundamental difference in how we view the boundaries, I'm not sure if we can move forward at all. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Any advice, thoughts, insights on this would be greatly appreciated. Anyone have a similar experience? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 2, 2010 Report Posted December 2, 2010 Â Except if you are a homosexual, you'd want a opposite sex therapist. Russel, that is a very bizarre and unscientific statement. Are you a homophobe?Maybe what you mean to say is, " Because I am uncertain and uncomfortable about my own sexuality, I will only work with an opposite sex therapist. " I am a man and I have requested male therapists and psychiatrists for past forty years. And I am not gay--not that that actually has anything to do with anything. Now I am moving half a continent away to Colorado and I just arranged for an ACT therapist through email. I picked a woman this time because I liked her answers to my questions. Bud Polk Quote
Guest guest Posted December 3, 2010 Report Posted December 3, 2010 I'm sorry Helena, I thought I had. I appreciate your take, and I definitely think there's a kernel of truth in it. I'd like to think that she at least would like to be friendly with me even if she's not sure how or not allowed, or both. I think I am going to take a step back from it all and focus on doing what's best for me right now. I'm actually feeling much better after getting everyone's thoughts and support. It's almost like this board is therapeutic or something I really do appreciate everyone's thoughts and perspective, it's really helping me loads. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So, I've been seeing a therapist for several months at a local clinic. The clinic is run by a local university and is staffed with graduate students who are under supervision. This is all I could afford at the time and the other option I had was to see a psychologist who was booked for 2 months and I didn't want to wait. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > For the greater part of my therapy, things have been very focused and productive. I brought in my ACT book and discussed ACT and how I've been using it, and she was not only open-minded about using ACT, she got the book herself and said that her supervisor was very interested in ACT. We worked through some of the book together. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Throughout the process I have learned so much about myself, have really grown and begun to accept myself and explore myself for all that I am. I've learned to not judge myself or what I feel in the ways that I used to. This has been a very painful process, but a good one. For every period of pain and growth I've come out stronger and with less of a burden. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I've had a lot of different, positive feelings towards my therapist. I've found that these feelings were at time confusing. I've come to understand that these feelings are that of openness, connectedness, trust etc. the kinds of feelings I've felt in my very close relationships. Yet there was also a part of me that felt attracted to her at times and the fact that we have so much in common also deepend my connection and closeness to her. It seems that over time I became more aware of these positive feelings, and I was judging some of them as 'inappropriate' etc. For example, I could tell that part of me was longing for a deeper relationship with her, something outside of therapy. I kept fighting this feeling, pushing it down within myself, telling myself that it was crazy etc. What's interesting to me now is that by suppressing it, it manifested itself much more than it would have if I had just explored it straight-away. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I brought this up with my therapist a few times, saying that I was confused about feelings that I was having in session, my feelings of closeness and openness with her etc. Eventually, I realized that I needed to tell her matter of factly, not in the round about way that I had been. More importantly, I realized that I shouldn't judge myself for having feelings. I can see there being inappropriate actions or words, but to feel a thing is perfectly natural. Over the course of a few weeks I noticed that she seemed uncomfortable at times and even was frustrated with me. When I asked her if she had been frustrated with me in the last session, she admitted that she was. I was glad she was honest and that I could trust my instincts. She brought up termination somewhere around this time, which seemed to come out of nowhere. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Let me be clear, I never felt in love with my therapist, or obsessed or any such thing. I only would have wanted any kind of contact or relationship outside of the office if it was something that we both wanted, and the one thing I was sure of was that my therapy was going well and that I wanted to continue it. But I needed to get this out of the way. I needed to take a leap, to be totally honest and non-judgemental towards myself and also completely open with her. This was difficult and took a lot of effort. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > When I told her all of how I felt, I explained that I had had many different feelings in session, some of them towards her, that of connection, etc. I even said that if I was forced to lablel them (which I'm loathe to do) I would label some of them as perhaps romantic, others as platonic and that I always felt respectful of her. I also told her that I was attracted to her in many ways, that even though I didn't know her very well that I felt I had a sense of the kind of person she was. She's always been very genuine and open with me and it's fostered a sense of trust between us and I told her how important that was and how it's helped me. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked how I thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I said that I had hoped she might explore the feelings more deeply with me and say something like, let's work through this. When I said that, she snapped at me that she wasn't a robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that I hoped she might help me work through it. All that I've learned about therapy (disclosure here, I'm a psychology student myself) is that opening up to one's therapist, even about how you feel towards them, can be very positive and can help deepen one's self-acceptance and self-understanding. Being able to tell someone honestly how you feel about them is definitely a good thing, though sometimes painful. She told me that she hadn't had anything like this happen before and that she would need to talk to her supervisor. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > At the next session she basically said that she felt that my telling her about my feelings were 'inappropriate' in the way that falling for a co-worker would be, that it crossed some kind of boundary. She seemed genuinely concerned about the course of therapy, but she didn't seem to budge on this point. We discussed it for a while and I told her that I felt that telling her those things was a major step forward for me, that I had assumed we would discuss the feelings and explore them the way we have my other feelings. I also told her that through telling her about those feelings, the one's that seemed 'romantic' diminished, or to put it a different way, I began to see them differently. Sometimes actually admitting something to oneself and being honest with yourself and another can make you see things differently and more clearly. I told her that I didn't have feelings for her in the way that she took what I had said. To be honest, I'm not en tirely cle ar what it is she 'heard' me say, she wouldn't tell me that directly when I asked her. She just kept saying that she thought we'd discussed it. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So at this point she started talking about what was best for me, and for her. I asked what her supervisor said, and she hesitated and said that she'd had a conversation with him and that he supported her and how she felt. For the first time since I started therapy with her, I doubted whether or not she was being honest with me. I told her that I would respect her feelings and if she wanted to start termination, we would do that. Yet, I also told her that I felt it a shame that my therapy might be derailed after such a big step forward for me and that I disagreed with her about the boundary thing. I felt I had crossed no such line and that I in fact SHOULD have told her especially, since she's my therapist and she could help me work through things. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Anyhow, the session ended with us discussing some recent progress I'd made and I agreed to meet every two weeks as opposed to every week. Yet after I got home, I began to think over the session and I can't help feel, as I felt last week, that she has made this about her somehow. After all, I'm the client. I can only assume that what I told her has triggered something in her. Her reaction was immediate and visceral. It's not as though I threatened her, but it almost feels like she felt threatened somehow. Things being what they are, I am not sure that I should continue seeing her because it seems like she's filtering everything I bring up now through the context of this event. It's as if she's hearing what she expects me to say, not what I'm saying, and that can't really work. For example, when I told her about a recent breakthrough I'd had as regards relationships generally, she told me she was hearing that I still 'had feelings' for her. I had to exp lain again, highlighting the fact that I was talking about something I'd realized GENERALLY speaking and that it wasn't about her or the feelings I'd described. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So, at this point, I'm not sure what to do. I have two weeks before our next scheduled appointment, but I'm feeling like this therapy has in some ways already been derailed. And I am not sure if she's going to be able to really treat me if she can't focus on me and what I'm going through. On the other hand, maybe I should continue on through the termination process (which is open-ended at this point). I think a feeling I'm confronting now is a lack of trust in the process moving forward with her. With such a fundamental difference in how we view the boundaries, I'm not sure if we can move forward at all. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Any advice, thoughts, insights on this would be greatly appreciated. Anyone have a similar experience? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 3, 2010 Report Posted December 3, 2010 Glad I could make you smile GG > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So, I've been seeing a therapist for several months at > > > a local clinic. The clinic is run by a local university and is staffed with > > > graduate students who are under supervision. This is all I could afford at > > > the time and the other option I had was to see a psychologist who was booked > > > for 2 months and I didn't want to wait. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > For the greater part of my therapy, things have been > > > very focused and productive. I brought in my ACT book and discussed ACT and > > > how I've been using it, and she was not only open-minded about using ACT, > > > she got the book herself and said that her supervisor was very interested in > > > ACT. We worked through some of the book together. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Throughout the process I have learned so much about > > > myself, have really grown and begun to accept myself and explore myself for > > > all that I am. I've learned to not judge myself or what I feel in the ways > > > that I used to. This has been a very painful process, but a good one. For > > > every period of pain and growth I've come out stronger and with less of a > > > burden. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I've had a lot of different, positive feelings towards > > > my therapist. I've found that these feelings were at time confusing. I've > > > come to understand that these feelings are that of openness, connectedness, > > > trust etc. the kinds of feelings I've felt in my very close relationships. > > > Yet there was also a part of me that felt attracted to her at times and the > > > fact that we have so much in common also deepend my connection and closeness > > > to her. It seems that over time I became more aware of these positive > > > feelings, and I was judging some of them as 'inappropriate' etc. For > > > example, I could tell that part of me was longing for a deeper relationship > > > with her, something outside of therapy. I kept fighting this feeling, > > > pushing it down within myself, telling myself that it was crazy etc. What's > > > interesting to me now is that by suppressing it, it manifested itself much > > > more than it would have if I had just explored it straight-away. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I brought this up with my therapist a few times, saying > > > that I was confused about feelings that I was having in session, my feelings > > > of closeness and openness with her etc. Eventually, I realized that I needed > > > to tell her matter of factly, not in the round about way that I had been. > > > More importantly, I realized that I shouldn't judge myself for having > > > feelings. I can see there being inappropriate actions or words, but to feel > > > a thing is perfectly natural. Over the course of a few weeks I noticed that > > > she seemed uncomfortable at times and even was frustrated with me. When I > > > asked her if she had been frustrated with me in the last session, she > > > admitted that she was. I was glad she was honest and that I could trust my > > > instincts. She brought up termination somewhere around this time, which > > > seemed to come out of nowhere. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Let me be clear, I never felt in love with my > > > therapist, or obsessed or any such thing. I only would have wanted any kind > > > of contact or relationship outside of the office if it was something that we > > > both wanted, and the one thing I was sure of was that my therapy was going > > > well and that I wanted to continue it. But I needed to get this out of the > > > way. I needed to take a leap, to be totally honest and non-judgemental > > > towards myself and also completely open with her. This was difficult and > > > took a lot of effort. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > When I told her all of how I felt, I explained that I > > > had had many different feelings in session, some of them towards her, that > > > of connection, etc. I even said that if I was forced to lablel them (which > > > I'm loathe to do) I would label some of them as perhaps romantic, others as > > > platonic and that I always felt respectful of her. I also told her that I > > > was attracted to her in many ways, that even though I didn't know her very > > > well that I felt I had a sense of the kind of person she was. She's always > > > been very genuine and open with me and it's fostered a sense of trust > > > between us and I told her how important that was and how it's helped me. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > She told me that she was uncomfortable. When she asked > > > how I thought she might react when I thought about telling her, I said that > > > I had hoped she might explore the feelings more deeply with me and say > > > something like, let's work through this. When I said that, she snapped at me > > > that she wasn't a robot. I told her that I knew she wasn't a robot but that > > > I hoped she might help me work through it. All that I've learned about > > > therapy (disclosure here, I'm a psychology student myself) is that opening > > > up to one's therapist, even about how you feel towards them, can be very > > > positive and can help deepen one's self-acceptance and self-understanding. > > > Being able to tell someone honestly how you feel about them is definitely a > > > good thing, though sometimes painful. She told me that she hadn't had > > > anything like this happen before and that she would need to talk to her > > > supervisor. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > At the next session she basically said that she felt > > > that my telling her about my feelings were 'inappropriate' in the way that > > > falling for a co-worker would be, that it crossed some kind of boundary. She > > > seemed genuinely concerned about the course of therapy, but she didn't seem > > > to budge on this point. We discussed it for a while and I told her that I > > > felt that telling her those things was a major step forward for me, that I > > > had assumed we would discuss the feelings and explore them the way we have > > > my other feelings. I also told her that through telling her about those > > > feelings, the one's that seemed 'romantic' diminished, or to put it a > > > different way, I began to see them differently. Sometimes actually admitting > > > something to oneself and being honest with yourself and another can make you > > > see things differently and more clearly. I told her that I didn't have > > > feelings for her in the way that she took what I had said. To be honest, I'm > > > not en tirely cle ar what it is she 'heard' me say, she wouldn't tell me > > > that directly when I asked her. She just kept saying that she thought we'd > > > discussed it. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So at this point she started talking about what was > > > best for me, and for her. I asked what her supervisor said, and she > > > hesitated and said that she'd had a conversation with him and that he > > > supported her and how she felt. For the first time since I started therapy > > > with her, I doubted whether or not she was being honest with me. I told her > > > that I would respect her feelings and if she wanted to start termination, we > > > would do that. Yet, I also told her that I felt it a shame that my therapy > > > might be derailed after such a big step forward for me and that I disagreed > > > with her about the boundary thing. I felt I had crossed no such line and > > > that I in fact SHOULD have told her especially, since she's my therapist and > > > she could help me work through things. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Anyhow, the session ended with us discussing some > > > recent progress I'd made and I agreed to meet every two weeks as opposed to > > > every week. Yet after I got home, I began to think over the session and I > > > can't help feel, as I felt last week, that she has made this about her > > > somehow. After all, I'm the client. I can only assume that what I told her > > > has triggered something in her. Her reaction was immediate and visceral. > > > It's not as though I threatened her, but it almost feels like she felt > > > threatened somehow. Things being what they are, I am not sure that I should > > > continue seeing her because it seems like she's filtering everything I bring > > > up now through the context of this event. It's as if she's hearing what she > > > expects me to say, not what I'm saying, and that can't really work. For > > > example, when I told her about a recent breakthrough I'd had as regards > > > relationships generally, she told me she was hearing that I still 'had > > > feelings' for her. I had to exp lain again, highlighting the fact that I was > > > talking about something I'd realized GENERALLY speaking and that it wasn't > > > about her or the feelings I'd described. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So, at this point, I'm not sure what to do. I have two > > > weeks before our next scheduled appointment, but I'm feeling like this > > > therapy has in some ways already been derailed. And I am not sure if she's > > > going to be able to really treat me if she can't focus on me and what I'm > > > going through. On the other hand, maybe I should continue on through the > > > termination process (which is open-ended at this point). I think a feeling > > > I'm confronting now is a lack of trust in the process moving forward with > > > her. With such a fundamental difference in how we view the boundaries, I'm > > > not sure if we can move forward at all. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Any advice, thoughts, insights on this would be greatly > > > appreciated. Anyone have a similar experience? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > Barbara White, MFT > > Marriage and Family Therapist > > > > barbarawhitetherapy.com > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 3, 2010 Report Posted December 3, 2010 Hi act_ed,I may be way off so take my advice with grain of salt. Others may put in their input. I agree with what you say pretty much here.But, I think wanting to run into her and wanting her to acknowledge you or nod to you I think may be experiential avoidance. I mean what you want to avoid is the pain of this whole thing - the therapist you connected with very well and then express your warm feelings to and then she felt uncomfortable and the therapy relationship ended. And more than that the friendship or any other kind of relationship ended. Now, she doesn't even acknowledge you. It's a big lost for you. So, what I think I'm saying is to face that and face the pain with that. I know that if I were in your shoes, I would be in quite a bit of pain. I have felt this pain a few times in my life.So, anyway, my advice in last post may be really accepting this lost and facing and experiencing the pain. And you may not know what is going on with her. And you don't know her past and what may influence things now. Or what other interactions with people she is experiencing. Perhaps she knows she didn't handle this well and may have gotten some trouble from her supervisor and so she wants to avoid you to avoid bad feelings of not handling this well. I'm not suggesting this is likely - I'm just saying you don't really know what is going on inside her and it may be very different than you think. ++++I want to say that this conversation has been really helpful for me. I don't have time to say right now how, but I will later.  Thanks , I see what you're saying. I don't know about avoiding her, so to speak, as I don't want to feel like I can't go places I normally would go, especially since I might meet friends out and such. I would hate to enter into some kind of experiential avoidance as it were. But I do think you're right about my needing time, and I'm sure she probably does too. Perhaps it was just too soon and the emotions too raw. I definitely think I should not look for opportunities to run into her or anything like that, and if I see that she's at a place and I have the option to go elsewhere, perhaps I should for a time. But again, I don't want to end up being a hermit or avoid places and people I love because of this, and I definitely wouldn't want her to either, that would make me very sad. > > > > > > > > > From: Barbara White <bwhite2000@> > > > > > Subject: Re: Re: not sure if I should find a new > > therapist > > > To: ACT_for_the_Public <ACT_for_the_Public%40yahoogroups.com> > > > Date: Friday, 3 December, 2010, 12:22 > > > > > > > > >  > > > > > > > > > > > > Hi -- > > > > > > I'd like to mention a couple things. > > > > > > First of all, ethically, the same rules of confidentiality apply whether > > someone is a current or past client (ie.the therapist must not disclose any > > information about the therapy, or indeed that there even is/was a > > therapeutic relationship). And the reason a therapist leaves it up to a > > client (or or past client) to come over to them in public is maintain the > > client's confidentiality. For example, suppose a client was out in public > > with other people and the therapist/ex-therapist came over. If their friends > > ask " how do you know each other? " it puts the client in a position of of > > either disclosing the fact of the therapy (which they may not want to do) or > > lying or being evasive. > > > > > > The second thing thing is, ethically, a therapist is not supposed to be > > friends with a client after therapy is finished (the same thing goes for > > romantic relationships with clients). This is for the good of the > > client. This isn't to say that this never happens, but it could result in > > the licensing board taking action against the therapist. There are a few > > reasons for this 'rule' but the most important one in my opinion is because > > it is up to the therapist to hold healthy boundaries. The therapeutic > > relationship is not an equal relationship in many ways. It is about the > > therapist taking care of the client (or it should be.) The therapist tends > > to be in a position of power (they know a lot about the client, the client > > knows little about them.) This is not in itself a bad thing -- it is > > appropriate for a therapist to focus on the client and not make sessions > > about themselves. But were the therapist to try to have a relationship out > > of/post > > > therapy, this inequality would be an abuse of the power in the > > relationship. Now this may not be a particular issue to you, but many > > people have been hurt in their lives because people who should have > > maintained boundaries, (ie. people in a power position) haven't. This can > > range from a parent making a child the caretaker in the relationship to > > sexual abuse. Both are abuses of power, both of them have to do with a > > lack of appropriate boundaries. > > > > > > Okay, this may be more than you are interested, and is just my take on > > the situation. I hope it clarifies some things for you. Ending a > > therapeutic relationship can be very challenging and upsetting. From my > > perspective, the very real issues and feelings of the termination of > > therapy, as well as your feelings about your ex-therapist would best be > > served by talking it through with another therapist (or using ACT principles > > to just sit with the feelings, notice them, etc.). You could contact your > > ex-therapist for a session to discuss your experience, but from what you > > disclosed about her, she doesn't seem all that comfortable dealing with the > > complex feelings that come up in therapy. Of course, I view this as a > > shortcoming in a therapist, but we're talking about the best way to get YOUR > > needs met, and so I personally wouldn't want to go to an empty well. > > > > > > I hope this has been helpful -- take it for what it's worth. > > > > > > Best, > > > Barbara W. > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted December 3, 2010 Report Posted December 3, 2010 Bud, No problem. I replied to message after others had posted and so that may be confusing. I gotta run to catch a bus!   Bud,Huh!? I don't think you understand what I said or to what I was responding. Really mundane thing I was saying but don't worry about it. , My most humble apologies. I have only been on the ACT listserv for a week, so I think I missed the beginning of the thread. And I have only been skimming longer posts because of the volume of email. I had no context for your statement I replied to. Without context, it struck me as wrong. Again, I apologize to you. Now I understand the thread a little better and have a context for your remark. Bud Polk Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.