Guest guest Posted January 28, 2010 Report Posted January 28, 2010 Am in total agreement here and it is one of the herbs i now use in standardised extract in my practice.Never got any satisfactory results using the regular tincture for the purposes outlined in pauls mail, or the fresh sp tr i made myself ( time of year could explain this too....) > > By Bergener from Henriettes list. > > > Zoe > > Medical Herbalist > MNIMH RGN Dip Phyt. > > www.herbaljournal.co.uk > www.zoehawes.co.uk > Bath > 01761 439 920 > > > Begin forwarded message: > > > > > Date: 27 January 2010 22:55:10 GMT > > To: Herb > > Subject: Re: [herb] Ginkgo--no good. NOT > > Reply-To: Herb > > > > My experience with gingko is this: > > > > First of all, ginkgo as a vasodilator/brain tonic is not a traditional > > Chinese use of either the leaf or the seed, and was discovered > > exclusively with the contencrated phrmaceutical extracts. > > > > Second, these extracts also have toxic materials removed, these are > > collectively called " ginkgotoxin " in pharmacology, they are well-known > > in Chinese medicine, and ginkgo is considered borderline toxic in > > Chinese herbalism in all its forms. > > > > Third, ginkgo was never used as a medicine in Western herbalism until > > after a special issue on the pharmaceutical extract appeared in Presse > > Medicale in France in 1986. Immediately thereafter the US companies > > started harvesting and marketing all manner of ginkgo products, > > powers, tinctures, sloppily standardized extracts etc. with complete > > disragard for the fact that the products discussed in the French > > journal all had the ginkgotoxin removed, and were anywhere from 50 > > times to infinitely stronger, depending on season of harbvest (at some > > times of year there is no active constituent). > > > > Ginkgotoxin causes headache and gi upset. This is a universal side > > effect of the tincture of its is taken in high enough dose or for long > > enough. Because I've been in school communities full of experimentally > > minded students for the last 15 years, I've now seen at least 30 such > > cases, with the onset of the headache beginning within a range of 1 > > day to 2 weeks. In addition, in the late 80s, some comapnies made > > concentrated extracts without the toxins removed, and the headache > > rate was at least 50% with those products within a few days. I saw or > > heard of at least 50 cases in the late 80s. > > > > I don't like the idea of standardized extracts personally, but why be > > dogmatic? Ginkgo is one of 3 herbs that are demonstrably superior in > > this form, the other two I believe being milk thistle seed and > > bilberry concentrate. In the case of ginkgo, the non-concetrated forms > > have nasty side effects. > > > > The non-standardized form are highly unlikely to cause any blood > > thinning, because they have negligible amounts of active contsitutents > > anyway. > > > > After 15 years since its introduction, i have yet to find a single > > individual or case where a simple of non-standardized ginkgo provided > > any benefit on a sustained basis, other than an initial placebo type > > thing that happens with any herbs. here I mean taken for 2-3 months > > regularly, have a benefit, and have no side effect. I be open to > > hearing such a report, any takers? > > > > -- > > Bergner > > North American Institute of Medical Herbalism http://naimh.com > > Medical Herbalism Journal http://medherb.com > > _______________________________________________ > > Herb mailing list > > Herb@... > > http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/listinfo/herb > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted January 28, 2010 Report Posted January 28, 2010 Hi everyone, Just a quick update to this topical thread. I saw a news article today on the possible toxic effects of Ginkgo and its products which can been seen here: http://www.physorg.com/news183816819.html It reports on a review article that has just been published. There is a link to the article which is available to read for free (for now). In this review the authors give some interesting information on Ginkgo including its toxic constituent Ginkgotoxin and its possible mode of action that could explain reports of epileptic seizures in clinical trials of Ginkgo products. Although the article is a review and therefore is not a primary source of research it does raise some interesting points that should be considered from a safety perspective and also seem to reflect what Bergner was saying. One thing that did strike me as odd though was that they reported that measurable amounts of Ginkgo compounds including Ginkgotoxin were found in a homeopathic product. As it has an extensive set of references some further reading might shed some light on this and allow interested readers to check out the authors' source materials which they have drawn their conclusions from. Cheers, Drew McNaughton > > > Am in total agreement here and it is one of the herbs i now use in standardised extract in my practice.Never got any satisfactory results using the regular tincture for the purposes outlined in pauls mail, or the fresh sp tr i made myself ( time of year could explain this too....) > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.