Guest guest Posted September 23, 2010 Report Posted September 23, 2010 I got them in 2nd or 3rd grade. Both my kids had them, my son when he was in 3rd grade and at age 3. She got them from her brother and I had TJ clearing up and broke out.To: asthma Sent: Thu, September 23, 2010 6:12:11 AMSubject: chicken pox I was really young when I got them. Alana > at age 28 I came down with chicken pox. > > > Ann > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 23, 2010 Report Posted September 23, 2010 I was really young when I got them and then they tried to make me get the vaccine when it came out and joined the state requirements. I was the 16 year old who was very nonconsensual especial once I understood that it was a live vaccine. Thankfully they could titer me and shockingly I was immune. I understand shingles stinks but wouldn't you still have the risk of shingles if you get the live vaccine since you can theoretically get chicken pox from it since they aren't dead? -Kat > > > > at age 28 I came down with chicken pox. > > > > > > Ann > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 If you've had chicken pox, you have a much higher level of immunity to shingles. I really can't imagine that a vaccine would make much of a difference apart from in people who a suppressed immune system. Exposure when your own kids have it tops up your immunity. The reason they rarely vaccinate against chicken pox here is because it could really increase the rate of shingles - sounds like the vaccination doesn't provide the same level of protection against it as actually getting chicken pox.Some vaccinations are essential, others unnecessary. I should have had a vaccination against European tick borne encephalitis when I went to Belarus - at the time it was not licenced for use in the UK, and my doctor told me I'd be at more risk if I actually had the vaccination than if I covered up and used insect repellent. Similarly, I should have had rabies when I went to Romania (big problem there with stray dogs). I didn't bother, as I was staying in Romania's second biggest city - I knew healthcare there wouldn't be too far behind that of Western EuropeJennTha can tek t'lass outta Yorkshire...! Don't brand me, don't classify me, don't tell me what to wear. I'll be who I want to be, and I'm proud to be me.Subject: Re: chicken poxTo: asthma Date: Friday, 24 September, 2010, 1:23I was really young when I got them and then they tried to make me get the vaccine when it came out and joined the state requirements. I was the 16 year old who was very nonconsensual especial once I understood that it was a live vaccine. Thankfully they could titer me and shockingly I was immune. I understand shingles stinks but wouldn't you still have the risk of shingles if you get the live vaccine since you can theoretically get chicken pox from it since they aren't dead? -Kat> > >> at age 28 I came down with chicken pox. > > > > > > Ann > >>------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 Jenn, you can only get shingles if youve had the chicken pox. The chicken pox virus stays dormant in your body and exposure to chicken pox later can "awaken" the dormant virus which then shows up as shingles. The vaccine may actually decrease your risk of getting shingles because the vaccine version of chicken pox is weak and it is also somewhat altered so it is not able to survive like the actual chicken pox virus. Chickenpox vaccine Immunization with the varicella vaccine (or chickenpox vaccine) - now recommended in the United States for all children between 18 months and adolescence - can protect children from getting chickenpox. People who have been vaccinated against chickenpox are less likely to get shingles because the weak, “attenuated†strain of virus used in the chickenpox vaccine is less likely to survive in the body over decades. But a definitive answer to the question of whether shingles can occur later in life in a person vaccinated against chickenpox will only be provided when enough data have been gathered over the next several decades. Some scientists believe that immunizing children against chickenpox increases the risk of shingles in adults who were not themselves immunized during childhood. This is because when adults care for children sick with chickenpox, it reboosts their own immunity that keeps the virus in their nerve cells from reactivating as shingles. With fewer children coming down with chickenpox, there are fewer opportunities for this "reboosting" of adult immunity, and so there may be more shingles cases for the next 40-50 years. http://www.ninds.nih.gov/disorders/shingles/detail_shingles.htm Re: chicken pox To: asthma Date: Friday, 24 September, 2010, 1:23 I was really young when I got them and then they tried to make me get the vaccine when it came out and joined the state requirements. I was the 16 year old who was very nonconsensual especial once I understood that it was a live vaccine. Thankfully they could titer me and shockingly I was immune. I understand shingles stinks but wouldn't you still have the risk of shingles if you get the live vaccine since you can theoretically get chicken pox from it since they aren't dead? -Kat > > > > at age 28 I came down with chicken pox. > > > > > > Ann > > > ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 You are - but when you get older or become stressed, if your immunity drops, you get shingles. Which might or might not be a catastrophe; I don't know. Not sure if you can get chickenpox from someone with shingles; maybe. Some of these childhood diseases can cause serious illness in people who got vaccines instead of the disease and then the immunity wore off. Me, I'm glad I caught them all in childhood. My sister has left me inclined to snort at shingles by panicking and thinking she had cancer, and then lighting into me about what a face rash was. Now I refuse to get the vaccine. If I get shingles the sky won't fall. As for my sister, if she didn't work 18 hours a day as an international project manager with IBM, and if she calmed down, she'd not have shingles. Yours,Villandra chicken pox I thought once you have chicken pox you are immune for life.Alana Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 Usually a person only gets chicken pox once in their life...unless they had a really mild case and immunity waned but that is fairly rare. Shingles is a dormant version of chicken pox. The varicella virus (chicken pox) stays in your body for life, and if something triggers it, it re-emerges as shingles. Shingles attacks the nerves, usually in the face or trunk of the body. A person cannot get shingles if they have not had the chicken pox, however, a person who has not had chicken pox, can catch chicken pox from contact with the rash of a person with shingles. Chicken pox is spread via direct contact or airborne transmission whereas shingles is only spread via direct contact with the person. In the US, about 25% of all adults come down with Shingles at some point in their lives. Both of them are caused by the Herpes viruses (not the same herpes as the STD though) that also cause mono, epstein barre, cold sores and now they are also thinking bells palsy might be related to shingles outbreaks without the rash! Ann chicken pox I thought once you have chicken pox you are immune for life. Alana Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 That's interesting, as it's very different to a lot of the info we have here. The NHS doesn't routinely vaccinate because of evidence it'll cause an increase in the rate of shinglesI really don't think the vaccine is necessaryJennTha can tek t'lass outta Yorkshire...! Don't brand me, don't classify me, don't tell me what to wear. I'll be who I want to be, and I'm proud to be me. Subject: Re: chicken pox To: asthma Date: Friday, 24 September, 2010, 1:23 I was really young when I got them and then they tried to make me get the vaccine when it came out and joined the state requirements. I was the 16 year old who was very nonconsensual especial once I understood that it was a live vaccine. Thankfully they could titer me and shockingly I was immune. I understand shingles stinks but wouldn't you still have the risk of shingles if you get the live vaccine since you can theoretically get chicken pox from it since they aren't dead? -Kat > > > > at age 28 I came down with chicken pox. > > > > > > Ann > > > ------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 You are immune to chicken pox but you can still get shingles when you're older. The virus, herpes zostrex, or something like that, stays in your body and can sometimes reactivate, causing shingles. That's what my dr told me.To: asthma Sent: Fri, September 24, 2010 5:56:46 AMSubject: chicken pox I thought once you have chicken pox you are immune for life. Alana Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 A friend of mine got shingles and she said her dr told her not to be around anyone who has not had chicken pox and that they could get the chicken pox from her.To: asthma Sent: Fri, September 24, 2010 8:26:33 AMSubject: Re: chicken pox You are - but when you get older or become stressed, if your immunity drops, you get shingles. Which might or might not be a catastrophe; I don't know. Not sure if you can get chickenpox from someone with shingles; maybe. Some of these childhood diseases can cause serious illness in people who got vaccines instead of the disease and then the immunity wore off. Me, I'm glad I caught them all in childhood. My sister has left me inclined to snort at shingles by panicking and thinking she had cancer, and then lighting into me about what a face rash was. Now I refuse to get the vaccine. If I get shingles the sky won't fall. As for my sister, if she didn't work 18 hours a day as an international project manager with IBM, and if she calmed down, she'd not have shingles. Yours,Villandra chicken pox I thought once you have chicken pox you are immune for life.Alana Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010  Sounds impractical to me. They need to go back to letting everyone get chickenpox in childhood, and it won't be a problem. Diseases happen. I can't imagine staying home from work from shingles. In fact, if I stay home more than once or twice for any reason, I can lose my job. But only a baby stays home with shingles. No, I'm not getting immunized against shingles. Arrrrgh! Yours,Villandra chicken pox I thought once you have chicken pox you are immune for life.Alana Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 Villandra - Everybody's case of anything is different from others. I have mild asthma - but most here do not. I wouldn't stay out of work with asthma but many here could not go to work at all. The same is true of shingles. I had a mild case of shingles. It was on the back of my head. If I were to lie on that side the pain would be unbearable - but I was able to avoid that. Some cases of shingles are in a place where sitting on a chair would be unbearable. Some rashes are extremely unsightly, etc. You cannot judge for others. Also - while most of us have a case of shingles and it passes (there is also a treatment if caught early limits the disease to a week or two) but others suffer permanent damage. It is not to be taken lightly just because most of us get off easy. Most of us survive the flu - but some die of it. I would just appreciate it if the fact that everyone is different was taken into account. I'm sure all of us have suffered from the lack of understanding about our illness that others have shown us. We all extrapolate from our own experience - but it is best not to assume that what is easy for us is easy for someone else. - a > > Sounds impractical to me. They need to go back to letting everyone get chickenpox in childhood, and it won't be a problem. Diseases happen. I can't imagine staying home from work from shingles. In fact, if I stay home more than once or twice for any reason, I can lose my job. But only a baby stays home with shingles. > > No, I'm not getting immunized against shingles. Arrrrgh! > > Yours, > Villandra > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 Shingles is a reason to stay home. Most babies dont get shingles since they havent had chicken pox yet. Shingles is extremely painful and can become serious if its not treated properly. Even though the risk of transmission of shingles is limited to direct contact, people who have compromised immune systems need not have much contact to become infected. When my aunt got shingles she couldnt go out in public for almost 3 weeks because the rash was still there and that is contagious. She wasnt supposed to be around large crowds or people with compromised immune systems. Anyone can lose their job by getting sick, but thats sometimes how it is, and if your job is going to fire you for having shingles and staying home, then quite frankly they arent worth working for. Some things you just need to stay home. Ann Re: chicken pox  Sounds impractical to me. They need to go back to letting everyone get chickenpox in childhood, and it won't be a problem. Diseases happen. I can't imagine staying home from work from shingles. In fact, if I stay home more than once or twice for any reason, I can lose my job. But only a baby stays home with shingles. No, I'm not getting immunized against shingles. Arrrrgh! Yours, Villandra chicken pox I thought once you have chicken pox you are immune for life. Alana Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 Hi Villandra, My wife had a very small case of shingles on one of her shoulder blades about 3 years ago. She was able to function but not without pain. The blisters and marks went away after about 6 weeks. She still has a constant itch/pain where the outbreak occured. There are some who have not had a slight case like this. My mother had it break out almost like a belt all the way around her waist. She did miss quite a bit of work and went back even though she was in great pain. Both of these women had chicken pox as kids and were not immune to shingles as they are different (but closely related) diseases. I have not yet heard of any illness where blanket statements apply. No disease is a 'one size fits all' type of event nor do any 2 people react the exactly the same. As a human resource manager (not too long ago anyway) I know that it is very dangerous to fire someone for illness. The employer is opened up to possible litigation and penalties. No doubt, there are unscruppoulus employers who have no compassion. I'd suggest looking for another job if yours is such as they probably will use any excuse to rid themselves of someone they don't want/need. To me, statements like "only a baby stays home with shingles" are hurtful and judgmental. Mike McBride O God do not leave me. I have done nothing good in your sight, but according to your goodness, let me now make a beginning of good. - Abba Arsenius >> Sounds impractical to me. They need to go back to letting everyone get chickenpox in childhood, and it won't be a problem. Diseases happen. I can't imagine staying home from work from shingles. In fact, if I stay home more than once or twice for any reason, I can lose my job. But only a baby stays home with shingles. > > No, I'm not getting immunized against shingles. Arrrrgh!> > Yours,> Villandra> Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 I did some research. There seems to be massive confusion about shingles, but most sources say that if you can keep the sores covered, they are virtually not contagious, and also that they last three or four weeks. Have you ever seen anyone go on disability for having shingles, because that's what you'd have to do to stay home in isolation for three to four weeks. The sores are contagious until they scab over, and that takes three or four weeks. I think shingles is a fact of life. People just get it. Everytime I give blood, I have to swear that I don't have it and haven't had it recently, and noone I know has either - as if I'd know if they did. Chickenpox is more highly contagious, but also most contagious for two days before you come down with it, so not everyone recommends keeping a child with chickenpox home only because he has chickenpox. Isolating children with chickenpox does not stop the spread of chickenpox. Human resources personnel and workplace managers often lack heads, and I learned from someone else's hard experience on a HR board, that if your doctor tells you you can work but to stay away from certain people, to put in writing that you ARE cleared to go to work, and also specify what people you must avoid and how important that is. It's alot harder for an employer to take issue with what you were told in writing than what you were told verbally. As to avoiding people, does he mean that your employer must provide an isolated cubicle where noone who has not had chickenpox and no pregnant women will go, and your own private bathroom, or (much more likely) does he mean something more practical? Do your darndest to get him to specify that any restrictions about who you should be around apply " where possible " . That means that your employer only has to do what he can easily to do keep you away from pregnant women and those who haven't had chickenpox; most likely, tell people in the office who need to stay away from you to stay away from you. That is teh approach doctors at my low income health clinic take to keeping our health issues from costing us our jobs. For instance, my asthma means I can't go around acetone, zerox toner or construction fumes and dust, ever, but the note says, " where possible " . My balance disorder means I can't climb tall ladders, ever, but the note specifies " where possible " . My bladder issue means if I need to go, you'd better let me, but the note specifies, " where possible " . Does avoid people who have not had chicken pox and pregnant women intend to mean, don't take the public bus system? Of course not. I don't really see not telling people around you that you have shingles; how else do they have an opportunity to protect themselves? If you're sent home from work despite being medically cleared for work, you may have all sorts of grounds for action, from appealing up the chain of command to union or legal action, and, even in Texas, as long as you're cleared to work without undue restrictions, you can claim unemployment. Then you have money to live on, and the employer has a chargeback. Employers with heads, and some employers without heads, don't like that. AND, you're required to look for work, and conceivably you might find another job. In Texas, you can even have lost your job for a bona fide health restriction, as long as you can work. When I broke my leg, I had to give up my daytime temporary job that involved running around all day, lifting boxes, and filing. But I kept my part time evening job that required me to sit in a chair and make phone calls, and talk to people. Obviously I was " able to work " . I applied for jobs similar to the one I'd lost - office clerk. They aren't all as physical as the one I lost. I also collected unemployment when I lost a job because the acetone and zerox toner seriously exacerbated my asthma. The employer tried to deny it, and by the time the appeal (which I won) came up, I'd been at another job for several weeks. I did lose a week of unemployment when I had my appendix removed. I was in the hospital, and clearly not able to work. Remember, this society's issues with chickenpox aren't the fault of people who have shingles, they're the fault of a society that insists on protecting children from mild childhood illnesses that become serious if the children didn't have the actual disease before reaching adulthood. Those vaccines don't work, and they're a very bad idea. This is the CDC's problem, not yours or mine. I saw one woman whining about not feeling up to work on account of pain from a past incident of shingles. " Noone at work understands my pain " . I'm picturing this and rolling my eyes. Well, I understand pain. I've gone to work crying, but pain alone has never kept me home. My parents raised me better than that. Besides, if one is in pain that severe, who wants to sit home thinking about it? Not me. I want to be around people and doing something more fun. And, if the issue isn't actually pain, but the need to elevate and/or ice a broken leg, it's very important to remember to smile. For real. Sticking hte leg under the desk if possible. Yes, I once broke my leg, and like was expected when I was in school, I matter of factly went to work. Kids came to school in great big wheelchairs with the leg up, but they did not stay home in bed; I was in graduate school the first time I saw that, and the young professor of medical sociology was getting off way too much demonstrating how to do the sick role. She lost most of the respect I'd ever had for her. I didn't have a cast, because it was a broken fibula and I couldn't have gotten to work if I did have a cast. Broken legs swell dramatically, cutting off the circulation, which is why they're commonly kept elevated, and the fracture site adn muscles over it had to be iced when it got aggravated. Yours, Villandra Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 Amen to that! A dear friend of mine in her 90s had a case of shingles on her torso that spread to one eye. Shingles in an eye is extremely dangerous and can result in permanent loss of vision. Fortunately her doctor treated her aggressively for it, and though she was pretty much laid up for a few months, she was able to save her vision in the affected eye. Despite having suffered a stroke years earlier that had left this lady with a withered leg, she made it to the gym three times a week to exercise on recumbent bicycle, rotary arm machine, and EFX, both before and after her bout of shingles. She was certainly no coward nor a person who babied herself, but during her shingles bout she was truly laid up and kept herself at home. Slats > > > > Sounds impractical to me. They need to go back to letting everyone get chickenpox in childhood, and it won't be a problem. Diseases happen. I can't imagine staying home from work from shingles. In fact, if I stay home more than once or twice for any reason, I can lose my job. But only a baby stays home with shingles. > > > > No, I'm not getting immunized against shingles. Arrrrgh! > > > > Yours, > > Villandra > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 Yeah mine always come when I get stressed too much. Used to have them regularly when I was working as it was very stressful at times. Re: chicken pox You are - but when you get older or become stressed, if your immunity drops, you get shingles. Which might or might not be a catastrophe; I don't know. Not sure if you can get chickenpox from someone with shingles; maybe. Some of these childhood diseases can cause serious illness in people who got vaccines instead of the disease and then the immunity wore off. Me, I'm glad I caught them all in childhood. My sister has left me inclined to snort at shingles by panicking and thinking she had cancer, and then lighting into me about what a face rash was. Now I refuse to get the vaccine. If I get shingles the sky won't fall. As for my sister, if she didn't work 18 hours a day as an international project manager with IBM, and if she calmed down, she'd not have shingles. Yours,Villandra Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010  Yes they can! I am always careful around children when I have them. And pregnant women too! They can infect the baby. Re: chicken pox A friend of mine got shingles and she said her dr told her not to be around anyone who has not had chicken pox and that they could get the chicken pox from her. Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 Villandra, your judgmental and hurtful statements are causing me to lose respect for YOU. I am probably not the only one who is inclined to start simply ignoring your posts entirely. If that is what you want, by all means, continue to post such nasty comments as " but pain alone has never kept me home. My parents raised me better than that. " . But if you want people to read what you post, please tone down the snark. In case you're wondering... my pain management doctor advised me to stay home when the pain is too bad. It's NOT SAFE TO DRIVE if it hurts too much, pain is exceedingly distracting. And when it hurts so badly that you can't stop the tears from running down your face, it's awfully distracting to your co-workers, whose feelings and productivity should also be considered in your decisions. I did some research. There seems to be massive confusion about shingles,but most sources say that if you can keep the sores covered, they are virtually not contagious, and also that they last three or four weeks.Have you ever seen anyone go on disability for having shingles, becausethat's what you'd have to do to stay home in isolation for three to four weeks. The sores are contagious until they scab over, and that takes threeor four weeks. I think shingles is a fact of life. People just get it.Everytime I give blood, I have to swear that I don't have it and haven't had it recently, and noone I know has either - as if I'd know if they did.Chickenpox is more highly contagious, but also most contagious for two daysbefore you come down with it, so not everyone recommends keeping a child with chickenpox home only because he has chickenpox. Isolating childrenwith chickenpox does not stop the spread of chickenpox.Human resources personnel and workplace managers often lack heads, and Ilearned from someone else's hard experience on a HR board, that if your doctor tells you you can work but to stay away from certain people, to putin writing that you ARE cleared to go to work, and also specify what peopleyou must avoid and how important that is. It's alot harder for an employer to take issue with what you were told in writing than what you were toldverbally. As to avoiding people, does he mean that your employer mustprovide an isolated cubicle where noone who has not had chickenpox and no pregnant women will go, and your own private bathroom, or (much more likely)does he mean something more practical?Do your darndest to get him to specify that any restrictions about who youshould be around apply " where possible " . That means that your employer only has to do what he can easily to do keep you away from pregnant womenand those who haven't had chickenpox; most likely, tell people in the officewho need to stay away from you to stay away from you. That is teh approach doctors at my low income health clinic take to keeping our health issuesfrom costing us our jobs. For instance, my asthma means I can't go aroundacetone, zerox toner or construction fumes and dust, ever, but the note says, " where possible " . My balance disorder means I can't climb tallladders, ever, but the note specifies " where possible " . My bladder issuemeans if I need to go, you'd better let me, but the note specifies, " where possible " . Does avoid people who have not had chicken pox and pregnantwomen intend to mean, don't take the public bus system? Of course not.I don't really see not telling people around you that you have shingles; how else do they have an opportunity to protect themselves?If you're sent home from work despite being medically cleared for work, youmay have all sorts of grounds for action, from appealing up the chain of command to union or legal action, and, even in Texas, as long as you'recleared to work without undue restrictions, you can claim unemployment.Then you have money to live on, and the employer has a chargeback. Employers with heads, and some employers without heads, don't like that.AND, you're required to look for work, and conceivably you might findanother job.In Texas, you can even have lost your job for a bona fide health restriction, as long as you can work. When I broke my leg, I had to giveup my daytime temporary job that involved running around all day, liftingboxes, and filing. But I kept my part time evening job that required me to sit in a chair and make phone calls, and talk to people. Obviously I was " able to work " . I applied for jobs similar to the one I'd lost - officeclerk. They aren't all as physical as the one I lost. I also collected unemployment when I lost a job because the acetone and zerox toner seriouslyexacerbated my asthma. The employer tried to deny it, and by the time theappeal (which I won) came up, I'd been at another job for several weeks. I did lose a week of unemployment when I had my appendix removed. I was inthe hospital, and clearly not able to work.Remember, this society's issues with chickenpox aren't the fault of peoplewho have shingles, they're the fault of a society that insists on protecting children from mild childhood illnesses that become serious if the childrendidn't have the actual disease before reaching adulthood. Those vaccinesdon't work, and they're a very bad idea. This is the CDC's problem, not yours or mine.I saw one woman whining about not feeling up to work on account of pain froma past incident of shingles. " Noone at work understands my pain " . I'mpicturing this and rolling my eyes. Well, I understand pain. I've gone to work crying, but pain alone has never kept me home. My parents raisedme better than that. Besides, if one is in pain that severe, who wants tosit home thinking about it? Not me. I want to be around people and doing something more fun. And, if the issue isn't actually pain, but theneed to elevate and/or ice a broken leg, it's very important to remember tosmile. For real. Sticking hte leg under the desk if possible. Yes, I once broke my leg, and like was expected when I was in school, I matter offactly went to work. Kids came to school in great big wheelchairs with theleg up, but they did not stay home in bed; I was in graduate school the first time I saw that, and the young professor of medical sociology wasgetting off way too much demonstrating how to do the sick role. She lostmost of the respect I'd ever had for her. I didn't have a cast, because it was a broken fibula and I couldn't have gotten to work if I did have a cast.Broken legs swell dramatically, cutting off the circulation, which is whythey're commonly kept elevated, and the fracture site adn muscles over it had to be iced when it got aggravated. Yours,Villandra------------------------------------ Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 I have seen people with their faces covered with the rash and you can lose your eyesight if it gets into your eyes. So it is nothing to play with. I always went to work with my shingles but they were in a place that was covered anyhow and I was not around children. If there were any women in the building who were pregnant I avoided contact with them. Re: chicken pox Villandra - Everybody's case of anything is different from others. I have mild asthma - but most here do not. I wouldn't stay out of work with asthma but many here could not go to work at all. The same is true of shingles. I had a mild case of shingles. It was on the back of my head. If I were to lie on that side the pain would be unbearable - but I was able to avoid that. Some cases of shingles are in a place where sitting on a chair would be unbearable. Some rashes are extremely unsightly, etc. You cannot judge for others. Also - while most of us have a case of shingles and it passes (there is also a treatment if caught early limits the disease to a week or two) but others suffer permanent damage. It is not to be taken lightly just because most of us get off easy. Most of us survive the flu - but some die of it. I would just appreciate it if the fact that everyone is different was taken into account. I'm sure all of us have suffered from the lack of understanding about our illness that others have shown us. We all extrapolate from our own experience - but it is best not to assume that what is easy for us is easy for someone else. - a Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 Villandra, My friend's doctor told her to STAY HOME away from everyone and to make sure that anyone who came to their house was immune to chicken pox. Her husband asked me and my daughter at the door if we'd had them because she was CONTAGIOUS to ANYONE who had not had chicken pox. This was from a DOCTOR. I've researched shingles too and it can cause someone who has not had chicken pox to get them. Shingles is extremely painful and can cause a person to miss work because the person gets quite sick for a bit then the pain is rough. I saw my late mother in law go through h* & L over the nerve pain from shingles. Sorry, you don't necessarily go on disability but you could possibly get unemployment or you do without some things and make do. If that virus reactivates and you get shingles you will stay home under doctor's orders because no employer is going to take the chance on you giving non immune people an illness like that. Give kids the vaccine and prevent problems later. Chicken pox is contagious from a day or so before the breakout to the time the pox all dry up. Period. My son was beginning to clear when my daughter got it. There is a week to two week incubation. Do some more research and get off your dang high horse. No doctor in his right mind will clear a person to go to work with full blown shingles or chicken pox. From: "tiggernut24@..." To: asthma Sent: Fri, September 24, 2010 2:41:56 PMSubject: Re: chicken pox I did some research. There seems to be massive confusion about shingles, but most sources say that if you can keep the sores covered, they are virtually not contagious, and also that they last three or four weeks. Have you ever seen anyone go on disability for having shingles, because that's what you'd have to do to stay home in isolation for three to four weeks. The sores are contagious until they scab over, and that takes three or four weeks. I think shingles is a fact of life. People just get it. Everytime I give blood, I have to swear that I don't have it and haven't had it recently, and noone I know has either - as if I'd know if they did. Chickenpox is more highly contagious, but also most contagious for two days before you come down with it, so not everyone recommends keeping a child with chickenpox home only because he has chickenpox. Isolating children with chickenpox does not stop the spread of chickenpox. Human resources personnel and workplace managers often lack heads, and I learned from someone else's hard experience on a HR board, that if your doctor tells you you can work but to stay away from certain people, to put in writing that you ARE cleared to go to work, and also specify what people you must avoid and how important that is. It's alot harder for an employer to take issue with what you were told in writing than what you were told verbally. As to avoiding people, does he mean that your employer must provide an isolated cubicle where noone who has not had chickenpox and no pregnant women will go, and your own private bathroom, or (much more likely) does he mean something more practical? Do your darndest to get him to specify that any restrictions about who you should be around apply "where possible". That means that your employer only has to do what he can easily to do keep you away from pregnant women and those who haven't had chickenpox; most likely, tell people in the office who need to stay away from you to stay away from you. That is teh approach doctors at my low income health clinic take to keeping our health issues from costing us our jobs. For instance, my asthma means I can't go around acetone, zerox toner or construction fumes and dust, ever, but the note says, "where possible". My balance disorder means I can't climb tall ladders, ever, but the note specifies "where possible". My bladder issue means if I need to go, you'd better let me, but the note specifies, "where possible". Does avoid people who have not had chicken pox and pregnant women intend to mean, don't take the public bus system? Of course not. I don't really see not telling people around you that you have shingles; how else do they have an opportunity to protect themselves? If you're sent home from work despite being medically cleared for work, you may have all sorts of grounds for action, from appealing up the chain of command to union or legal action, and, even in Texas, as long as you're cleared to work without undue restrictions, you can claim unemployment. Then you have money to live on, and the employer has a chargeback. Employers with heads, and some employers without heads, don't like that. AND, you're required to look for work, and conceivably you might find another job. In Texas, you can even have lost your job for a bona fide health restriction, as long as you can work. When I broke my leg, I had to give up my daytime temporary job that involved running around all day, lifting boxes, and filing. But I kept my part time evening job that required me to sit in a chair and make phone calls, and talk to people. Obviously I was "able to work". I applied for jobs similar to the one I'd lost - office clerk. They aren't all as physical as the one I lost. I also collected unemployment when I lost a job because the acetone and zerox toner seriously exacerbated my asthma. The employer tried to deny it, and by the time the appeal (which I won) came up, I'd been at another job for several weeks. I did lose a week of unemployment when I had my appendix removed. I was in the hospital, and clearly not able to work. Remember, this society's issues with chickenpox aren't the fault of people who have shingles, they're the fault of a society that insists on protecting children from mild childhood illnesses that become serious if the children didn't have the actual disease before reaching adulthood. Those vaccines don't work, and they're a very bad idea. This is the CDC's problem, not yours or mine. I saw one woman whining about not feeling up to work on account of pain from a past incident of shingles. "Noone at work understands my pain". I'm picturing this and rolling my eyes. Well, I understand pain. I've gone to work crying, but pain alone has never kept me home. My parents raised me better than that. Besides, if one is in pain that severe, who wants to sit home thinking about it? Not me. I want to be around people and doing something more fun. And, if the issue isn't actually pain, but the need to elevate and/or ice a broken leg, it's very important to remember to smile. For real. Sticking hte leg under the desk if possible. Yes, I once broke my leg, and like was expected when I was in school, I matter of factly went to work. Kids came to school in great big wheelchairs with the leg up, but they did not stay home in bed; I was in graduate school the first time I saw that, and the young professor of medical sociology was getting off way too much demonstrating how to do the sick role. She lost most of the respect I'd ever had for her. I didn't have a cast, because it was a broken fibula and I couldn't have gotten to work if I did have a cast. Broken legs swell dramatically, cutting off the circulation, which is why they're commonly kept elevated, and the fracture site adn muscles over it had to be iced when it got aggravated. Yours, Villandra Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 Why do they ask you if you have had shingles lately when you give blood? I hope you answered truthfully. Ora >Everytime I give blood, I have to swear that I don't have it and haven't had >it recently, and noone I know has either - as if I'd know if they did. > > >Yours, >Villandra > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 I was thinking about giving blood and found out I couldn't because I'm on insulin. It does depend on the type of insulin though. Anyway, the virus that causes shingles and chicken pox, if it's active, can cause someone who gets that blood to get sick. That's why they ask. I was asked too and that's what I was told.To: asthma Sent: Fri, September 24, 2010 7:30:35 PMSubject: Re: chicken pox Why do they ask you if you have had shingles lately when you give blood? I hope you answered truthfully. Ora >Everytime I give blood, I have to swear that I don't have it and haven't had >it recently, and noone I know has either - as if I'd know if they did. > > >Yours, >Villandra > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 I just gave blood last month and that wasnt one of the things they asked me about. Interesting. Ann Re: chicken pox Why do they ask you if you have had shingles lately when you give blood? I hope you answered truthfully. Ora >Everytime I give blood, I have to swear that I don't have it and haven't had >it recently, and noone I know has either - as if I'd know if they did. > > >Yours, >Villandra > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 24, 2010 Report Posted September 24, 2010 Villandra - I have one thing to say - may you never get shingles. I have never had pain like I had with shingles - and depending on where you get it - well - I am VERY sure you have no idea what you are talking about. - a > > I did some research. There seems to be massive confusion about shingles, > but most sources say that if you can keep the sores covered, they are > virtually not contagious, and also that they last three or four weeks. > > Have you ever seen anyone go on disability for having shingles, because > that's what you'd have to do to stay home in isolation for three to four > weeks. The sores are contagious until they scab over, and that takes three > or four weeks. I think shingles is a fact of life. People just get it. > Everytime I give blood, I have to swear that I don't have it and haven't had > it recently, and noone I know has either - as if I'd know if they did. > > Chickenpox is more highly contagious, but also most contagious for two days > before you come down with it, so not everyone recommends keeping a child > with chickenpox home only because he has chickenpox. Isolating children > with chickenpox does not stop the spread of chickenpox. > > Human resources personnel and workplace managers often lack heads, and I > learned from someone else's hard experience on a HR board, that if your > doctor tells you you can work but to stay away from certain people, to put > in writing that you ARE cleared to go to work, and also specify what people > you must avoid and how important that is. It's alot harder for an employer > to take issue with what you were told in writing than what you were told > verbally. As to avoiding people, does he mean that your employer must > provide an isolated cubicle where noone who has not had chickenpox and no > pregnant women will go, and your own private bathroom, or (much more likely) > does he mean something more practical? > > Do your darndest to get him to specify that any restrictions about who you > should be around apply " where possible " . That means that your employer > only has to do what he can easily to do keep you away from pregnant women > and those who haven't had chickenpox; most likely, tell people in the office > who need to stay away from you to stay away from you. That is teh approach > doctors at my low income health clinic take to keeping our health issues > from costing us our jobs. For instance, my asthma means I can't go around > acetone, zerox toner or construction fumes and dust, ever, but the note > says, " where possible " . My balance disorder means I can't climb tall > ladders, ever, but the note specifies " where possible " . My bladder issue > means if I need to go, you'd better let me, but the note specifies, " where > possible " . Does avoid people who have not had chicken pox and pregnant > women intend to mean, don't take the public bus system? Of course not. > > I don't really see not telling people around you that you have shingles; how > else do they have an opportunity to protect themselves? > > If you're sent home from work despite being medically cleared for work, you > may have all sorts of grounds for action, from appealing up the chain of > command to union or legal action, and, even in Texas, as long as you're > cleared to work without undue restrictions, you can claim unemployment. > Then you have money to live on, and the employer has a chargeback. > Employers with heads, and some employers without heads, don't like that. > AND, you're required to look for work, and conceivably you might find > another job. > > In Texas, you can even have lost your job for a bona fide health > restriction, as long as you can work. When I broke my leg, I had to give > up my daytime temporary job that involved running around all day, lifting > boxes, and filing. But I kept my part time evening job that required me to > sit in a chair and make phone calls, and talk to people. Obviously I was > " able to work " . I applied for jobs similar to the one I'd lost - office > clerk. They aren't all as physical as the one I lost. I also collected > unemployment when I lost a job because the acetone and zerox toner seriously > exacerbated my asthma. The employer tried to deny it, and by the time the > appeal (which I won) came up, I'd been at another job for several weeks. > > I did lose a week of unemployment when I had my appendix removed. I was in > the hospital, and clearly not able to work. > > Remember, this society's issues with chickenpox aren't the fault of people > who have shingles, they're the fault of a society that insists on protecting > children from mild childhood illnesses that become serious if the children > didn't have the actual disease before reaching adulthood. Those vaccines > don't work, and they're a very bad idea. This is the CDC's problem, not > yours or mine. > > I saw one woman whining about not feeling up to work on account of pain from > a past incident of shingles. " Noone at work understands my pain " . I'm > picturing this and rolling my eyes. Well, I understand pain. I've gone > to work crying, but pain alone has never kept me home. My parents raised > me better than that. Besides, if one is in pain that severe, who wants to > sit home thinking about it? Not me. I want to be around people and > doing something more fun. And, if the issue isn't actually pain, but the > need to elevate and/or ice a broken leg, it's very important to remember to > smile. For real. Sticking hte leg under the desk if possible. Yes, I > once broke my leg, and like was expected when I was in school, I matter of > factly went to work. Kids came to school in great big wheelchairs with the > leg up, but they did not stay home in bed; I was in graduate school the > first time I saw that, and the young professor of medical sociology was > getting off way too much demonstrating how to do the sick role. She lost > most of the respect I'd ever had for her. I didn't have a cast, because it > was a broken fibula and I couldn't have gotten to work if I did have a cast. > Broken legs swell dramatically, cutting off the circulation, which is why > they're commonly kept elevated, and the fracture site adn muscles over it > had to be iced when it got aggravated. > > Yours, > Villandra > Quote
Guest guest Posted September 26, 2010 Report Posted September 26, 2010 I'd wondered if that was an American thing - I've certainly never been asked that, and thet are very strict here. I'm also wondering now if shingles is another medical condition which is far less common here. It does exist, but it's not overly common.JennTha can tek t'lass outta Yorkshire...! Don't brand me, don't classify me, don't tell me what to wear. I'll be who I want to be, and I'm proud to be me.>Everytime I give blood, I have to swear that I don't have it and haven't had >it recently, and noone I know has either - as if I'd know if they did.>>>Yours,>Villandra>>>------------------------------------ Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.