Jump to content
RemedySpot.com

RE: Question re Hernia Exam

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted

1. with an email address like ldlc should we talk lipids??2 What you ran up against I think is that  people do not  need bimanuals  or even t heir heart listened to but they  expect it Actual real people  do not  understand evidence based medicine. And  so  becasue this is a new patient who had an expectation  it gets awkward- no relationship with him/he had an expectation. You did  you r job with the  hx and ros but people  say " That was not a physical all she did was talk tome "   so I yes will do stupid unnecessary exam  stuff depending on my relationship with them       My own doctor look s in my ears -I mean what for??Maybe I should  go see her more often and establish a relationship:)

 alternatively Liza  can we  make the  joke- that what you do for a living is get men to take their pants off.:) At the VA 1990 of my 2000 patients were men   and that is what I told my mother:)

from the uspstf below: Screening for Testicular Cancer

Note: An update to this recommendation is in

progress. Please visit the USPSTF Web site at http://www.uspreventiveservicestaskforce.org/uspstf/uspstest.htm or the USPSTF's Electronic Preventive Services Selector (ePSS) at http://epss.ahrq.gov for the most recent recommendation.

Summary of Recommendation The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommends against routine screening for testicular cancer in asymptomatic adolescent and adult males. Grade: D Recommendation. Clinical Considerations

The low incidence of testicular cancer and favorable outcomes in the

absence of screening make it unlikely that clinical testicular examinations would provide important health benefits. Clinical examination by a physician and self-examination are the potential screening options for testicular cancer. However, little evidence is available to assess the accuracy, yield, or benefits of screening for testicular cancer. Although currently most testicular cancers are discovered by patients themselves or their partners, either unintentionally or by self-examination, there is no evidence that teaching young men how to examine themselves for testicular cancer would improve health outcomes, even among men at high risk, including men with a history of undescended

testes or testicular atrophy. Clinicians should be aware of testicular cancer as a possible diagnosis when young men present to them with suggestive signs and symptoms. There is some evidence that patients who present initially with symptoms of testicular cancer are frequently diagnosed as having epididymitis, testicular trauma, hydrocele, or other benign disorders. Efforts to promote prompt assessment and better evaluation of testicular

problems may be more effective than widespread screening as a means of promoting early detection.

This USPSTF recommendation was first published by: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, Rockville, MD. February 2004. To read the recommendation, go to: http://www.uspreventiveservicestaskforce.org/uspstf/uspstest.htm.

 

Did a routine physical on a 31 yo new pt. Per hx no problems with GU ROS. I did not do a hernia check. I did talk about testicular self checks. I would do testicular checks with a return visit or if any concerns expressed. At the end of the visit did tell me he had this testicular check done when he had his exam years ago (he was tested for STD then). I then offered to do the exam to be thorough; pt prefers to come in at a later date for this exam or come in if any symptoms.

Question: Do you include this exam all the time with your routine physicals? I did not do it with the neg ROS; pt new to me and also partly bec IMP solo without chaperone. How would you have handle this. Would not want to do a less than thorough exam and not serve pt with best care. Any opinions. (If female cpe, pap and pelvic almost always expected as soon as scheduled.)

-- PATIENTS-please remember  that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical  record and is placed into your  chart ( be careful what you say!)

Email is best used for appointment making and  brief  questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL  if the  matter is more urgent .     MD    

     ph    fax impcenter.org

Posted

I have stopped doing hernia exams also because recent evidence

says that treating them is not necessary if not causing symptoms and early

treatment does not prevent later complications, probably just leads to more

surgeries. It think explanations are generally well received. But,

you have to go through the motions of listening to the heart and lungs and poke

the stomach. People just expect it.

Kathy Saradarian, MD

Branchville, NJ

www.qualityfamilypractice.com

Solo 4/03, Practicing since 9/90

Practice Partner 5/03

Low staffing

From:

[mailto: ] On Behalf Of Jean

Antonucci

Sent: Wednesday, November 10, 2010 2:44 PM

To:

Subject: Re: Question re Hernia Exam

1. with an email address like ldlc should we talk lipids??

2 What you ran up against I think is that people do not need

bimanuals or even t heir heart listened to but they expect it

Actual real people do not understand evidence based medicine.

And so becasue this is a new patient who had an expectation

it gets awkward- no relationship with him/he had an expectation. You did

you r job with the hx and ros but people say " That was not a

physical all she did was talk tome " so I yes will do stupid

unnecessary exam stuff depending on my relationship with them

My own doctor look s in my ears -I mean what

for??Maybe I should go see her more often and establish a relationship:)

alternatively Liza can we make the joke- that what

you do for a living is get men to take their pants off.:) At the VA 1990 of my

2000 patients were men and that is what I told my mother:)

from the uspstf below:

Screening for Testicular Cancer

Note: An update to this recommendation is in progress.

Please visit the USPSTF Web site at http://www.uspreventiveservicestaskforce.org/uspstf/uspstest.htm

or

the USPSTF's Electronic Preventive Services Selector (ePSS) at http://epss.ahrq.gov for the most recent

recommendation.

Summary of Recommendation

The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommends against

routine screening for testicular cancer in asymptomatic adolescent and adult

males.

Grade: D Recommendation.

Clinical Considerations

The low incidence of testicular cancer and

favorable outcomes in the absence of screening make it unlikely that

clinical testicular examinations would provide important health benefits.

Clinical examination by a physician and self-examination are the potential

screening options for testicular cancer. However, little evidence is

available to assess the accuracy, yield, or benefits of screening for

testicular cancer.

Although currently most testicular cancers are

discovered by patients themselves or their partners, either unintentionally

or by self-examination, there is no evidence that teaching young men how

to examine themselves for testicular cancer would improve health outcomes,

even among men at high risk, including men with a history of undescended

testes or testicular atrophy.

Clinicians should be aware of testicular cancer

as a possible diagnosis when young men present to them with suggestive

signs and symptoms. There is some evidence that patients who present

initially with symptoms of testicular cancer are frequently diagnosed as

having epididymitis, testicular trauma, hydrocele, or other benign

disorders. Efforts to promote prompt assessment and better evaluation of

testicular problems may be more effective than widespread screening as a

means of promoting early detection.

This USPSTF recommendation was first published by: Agency for Healthcare

Research and Quality, Rockville, MD. February 2004. To read the recommendation,

go to: http://www.uspreventiveservicestaskforce.org/uspstf/uspstest.htm.

Did a routine physical on a 31

yo new pt. Per hx no problems with GU ROS. I did not do a hernia check. I did

talk about testicular self checks. I would do testicular checks with a return

visit or if any concerns expressed. At the end of the visit did tell me he had

this testicular check done when he had his exam years ago (he was tested for

STD then). I then offered to do the exam to be thorough; pt prefers to come in

at a later date for this exam or come in if any symptoms.

Question: Do you include this exam all the time with your routine physicals? I

did not do it with the neg ROS; pt new to me and also partly bec IMP solo

without chaperone. How would you have handle this. Would not want to do a less

than thorough exam and not serve pt with best care. Any opinions. (If female

cpe, pap and pelvic almost always expected as soon as scheduled.)

--

PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that

Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart (

be careful what you say!)

Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions

Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the

matter is more urgent .

MD

ph fax

impcenter.org

CyberDefender has scanned this email for potential threats.

Version 2.0 / Build 4.03.29.01

Get free PC security at http://www.cyberdefender.com

Posted

I agree with Jean….

On point #2, we have now started giving

patients info about “what to expect” at their preventive exam. If anyone wants

to plagiarize it, you can find it here: https://prattmd.info/uploads/Preventive_Exam_Info_Sheet.pdf

Since we started giving this to our patients (it is also on our website), we

have not had any complaints about what wasn’t done at a physical.

Pratt

Office Manager

Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C

www.prattmd.info

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of

Sent: Wednesday, November 10, 2010

11:44 AM

To:

Subject: Re:

Question re Hernia Exam

1.

with an email address like ldlc should we talk lipids??

2

What you ran up against I think is that people do not need

bimanuals or even t heir heart listened to but they expect it

Actual real people do not understand evidence based medicine.

And so becasue this is a new patient who had an expectation

it gets awkward- no relationship with him/he had an expectation. You did

you r job with the hx and ros but people say " That was not a

physical all she did was talk tome " so I yes will do stupid

unnecessary exam stuff depending on my relationship with them

My own doctor look s in my ears -I mean what

for??Maybe I should go see her more often and establish a relationship:)

alternatively

Liza can we make the joke- that what you do for a living is

get men to take their pants off.:) At the VA 1990 of my 2000 patients were

men and that is what I told my mother:)

from

the uspstf below:

Screening

for Testicular Cancer

Note:

An update to this recommendation is in progress. Please visit the USPSTF Web

site at http://www.uspreventiveservicestaskforce.org/uspstf/uspstest.htm

or the USPSTF's Electronic

Preventive Services Selector (ePSS) at http://epss.ahrq.gov

for the most recent recommendation.

Summary of Recommendation

The

U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommends against routine

screening for testicular cancer in asymptomatic adolescent and adult males.

Grade: D Recommendation.

Clinical

Considerations

The low incidence of testicular cancer and

favorable outcomes in the absence of screening make it unlikely that

clinical testicular examinations would provide important health benefits.

Clinical examination by a physician and self-examination are the potential

screening options for testicular cancer. However, little evidence is

available to assess the accuracy, yield, or benefits of screening for

testicular cancer.

Although currently most testicular cancers are

discovered by patients themselves or their partners, either

unintentionally or by self-examination, there is no evidence that teaching

young men how to examine themselves for testicular cancer would improve

health outcomes, even among men at high risk, including men with a history

of undescended testes or testicular atrophy.

Clinicians should be aware of testicular cancer

as a possible diagnosis when young men present to them with suggestive

signs and symptoms. There is some evidence that patients who present

initially with symptoms of testicular cancer are frequently diagnosed as

having epididymitis, testicular trauma, hydrocele, or other benign

disorders. Efforts to promote prompt assessment and better evaluation of

testicular problems may be more effective than widespread screening as a

means of promoting early detection.

This

USPSTF recommendation was first published by: Agency for Healthcare Research

and Quality, Rockville, MD. February 2004. To read the

recommendation, go to: http://www.uspreventiveservicestaskforce.org/uspstf/uspstest.htm.

Did a routine physical on

a 31 yo new pt. Per hx no problems with GU ROS. I did not do a hernia check. I

did talk about testicular self checks. I would do testicular checks with a

return visit or if any concerns expressed. At the end of the visit did tell me

he had this testicular check done when he had his exam years ago (he was tested

for STD then). I then offered to do the exam to be thorough; pt prefers to come

in at a later date for this exam or come in if any symptoms.

Question: Do you include this exam all the time with your routine physicals? I

did not do it with the neg ROS; pt new to me and also partly bec IMP solo

without chaperone. How would you have handle this. Would not want to do a less

than thorough exam and not serve pt with best care. Any opinions. (If female

cpe, pap and pelvic almost always expected as soon as scheduled.)

--

PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that

Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart (

be careful what you say!)

Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions

Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the

matter is more urgent .

MD

115 Mt Blue

Circle

Farmington

ME 04938

ph fax

impcenter.org

Posted

Back in the late 70's someone did a study of about 10,000 screening PE's in

normally health young men, roughly ages 20-50. The results showed that if the

patient said they felt fine, and their BP was normal, any further exam or

testing was not necessary, and the number of " unexpected abnormals " was to small

to make it worthwhile. The value, seems to me, having a trusting relationship,

lipids q 5?, and the rest is just expectation. Agree spending more time talking

about health has way more value, but still get questions about EKG's, etc.

________________________________________

From:

[ ] On Behalf Of ldlcsamson

[lzsmsn@...]

Sent: Wednesday, November 10, 2010 12:05 PM

To:

Subject: Question re Hernia Exam

Did a routine physical on a 31 yo new pt. Per hx no problems with GU ROS. I did

not do a hernia check. I did talk about testicular self checks. I would do

testicular checks with a return visit or if any concerns expressed. At the end

of the visit did tell me he had this testicular check done when he had his exam

years ago (he was tested for STD then). I then offered to do the exam to be

thorough; pt prefers to come in at a later date for this exam or come in if any

symptoms.

Question: Do you include this exam all the time with your routine physicals? I

did not do it with the neg ROS; pt new to me and also partly bec IMP solo

without chaperone. How would you have handle this. Would not want to do a less

than thorough exam and not serve pt with best care. Any opinions. (If female

cpe, pap and pelvic almost always expected as soon as scheduled.)

Posted

Thanks for the input re the hernia exam.  was right on in terms of addressing patient expectations.  , making those explicit in a preventive visit " what to expect " sheet is a great idea.  So according to Kathy and Jim, no evidence that doing a hernia exam is helpful for the patient. 

It would have been helpful if I was able to explain that to the pt.  I will be ready for the next patient. Thank you.

Back in the late 70's someone did a study of about 10,000 screening PE's in normally health young men, roughly ages 20-50. The results showed that if the patient said they felt fine, and their BP was normal, any further exam or testing was not necessary, and the number of " unexpected abnormals " was to small to make it worthwhile. The value, seems to me, having a trusting relationship, lipids q 5?, and the rest is just expectation. Agree spending more time talking about health has way more value, but still get questions about EKG's, etc.

________________________________________From: [ ] On Behalf Of ldlcsamson [lzsmsn@...]

Sent: Wednesday, November 10, 2010 12:05 PMTo: Subject: Question re Hernia Exam

Did a routine physical on a 31 yo new pt. Per hx no problems with GU ROS. I did not do a hernia check. I did talk about testicular self checks. I would do testicular checks with a return visit or if any concerns expressed. At the end of the visit did tell me he had this testicular check done when he had his exam years ago (he was tested for STD then). I then offered to do the exam to be thorough; pt prefers to come in at a later date for this exam or come in if any symptoms.

Question: Do you include this exam all the time with your routine physicals? I did not do it with the neg ROS; pt new to me and also partly bec IMP solo without chaperone. How would you have handle this. Would not want to do a less than thorough exam and not serve pt with best care. Any opinions. (If female cpe, pap and pelvic almost always expected as soon as scheduled.)

------------------------------------

Posted

i do it all no matter ros for a new pt pe

Question re Hernia Exam

Did a routine physical on a 31 yo new pt. Per hx no problems with GU ROS. I did

not do a hernia check. I did talk about testicular self checks. I would do

testicular checks with a return visit or if any concerns expressed. At the end

of the visit did tell me he had this testicular check done when he had his exam

years ago (he was tested for STD then). I then offered to do the exam to be

thorough; pt prefers to come in at a later date for this exam or come in if any

symptoms.

Question: Do you include this exam all the time with your routine physicals? I

did not do it with the neg ROS; pt new to me and also partly bec IMP solo

without chaperone. How would you have handle this. Would not want to do a less

than thorough exam and not serve pt with best care. Any opinions. (If female

cpe, pap and pelvic almost always expected as soon as scheduled.)

Posted

ditto

To: Cc: Sent: Wed, November 10, 2010 9:46:39 PMSubject: Re: Question re Hernia Exam

i do it all no matter ros for a new pt pe Question re Hernia ExamDid a routine physical on a 31 yo new pt. Per hx no problems with GU ROS. I did not do a hernia check. I did talk about testicular self checks. I would do testicular checks with a return visit or if any concerns expressed. At the end of the visit did tell me he had this testicular check done when he had his exam years ago (he was tested for STD then). I then offered to do the exam to be thorough; pt

prefers to come in at a later date for this exam or come in if any symptoms. Question: Do you include this exam all the time with your routine physicals? I did not do it with the neg ROS; pt new to me and also partly bec IMP solo without chaperone. How would you have handle this. Would not want to do a less than thorough exam and not serve pt with best care. Any opinions. (If female cpe, pap and pelvic almost always expected as soon as scheduled.)

Posted

I offer my male patients an option. I can do the exam in my office, or if they would feel more comfortable, I can refer to a local urologist who will provide a prostate and testicular check to my male patients and not charge them an additional co-pay for the exam. I set this up and got it sanctioned by BCBS & Aetna since the question of waving co-pays came into play. In return I provide the same type service to his female patients. If he sees a female patient who needs a PAP/Breast exam done they are referred to me and we perform just the breast exam and PAP collection. Has worked out well for the last 5 years. Beth Sullivan, DORidgeway Family PracticeCommerce, GA 30529 From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of ldlcsamsonSent: Wednesday, November 10, 2010 2:05 PMTo: Subject: Question re Hernia Exam Did a routine physical on a 31 yo new pt. Per hx no problems with GU ROS. I did not do a hernia check. I did talk about testicular self checks. I would do testicular checks with a return visit or if any concerns expressed. At the end of the visit did tell me he had this testicular check done when he had his exam years ago (he was tested for STD then). I then offered to do the exam to be thorough; pt prefers to come in at a later date for this exam or come in if any symptoms.Question: Do you include this exam all the time with your routine physicals? I did not do it with the neg ROS; pt new to me and also partly bec IMP solo without chaperone. How would you have handle this. Would not want to do a less than thorough exam and not serve pt with best care. Any opinions. (If female cpe, pap and pelvic almost always expected as soon as scheduled.)

Posted

now that's beautiful. Actual cooperation  among all the players..!

 

I offer my male patients an option.  I can do the exam in my office, or if they would feel more comfortable, I can refer to a local urologist who will provide a prostate and testicular check to my male patients and not charge them an additional co-pay for the exam.  I set this up and got it sanctioned by BCBS & Aetna since the question of waving co-pays came into play.  In return I provide the same type service to his female patients.  If he sees a female patient who needs a PAP/Breast exam done they are referred to me and we perform just the breast exam and PAP collection.  Has worked out well for the last 5 years.

 Beth Sullivan, DO

Ridgeway Family PracticeCommerce, GA  30529

 From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of ldlcsamson

Sent: Wednesday, November 10, 2010 2:05 PMTo: Subject: Question re Hernia Exam

   Did a routine physical on a 31 yo new pt. Per hx no problems with GU ROS. I did not do a hernia check. I did talk about testicular self checks. I would do testicular checks with a return visit or if any concerns expressed. At the end of the visit did tell me he had this testicular check done when he had his exam years ago (he was tested for STD then). I then offered to do the exam to be thorough; pt prefers to come in at a later date for this exam or come in if any symptoms.

Question: Do you include this exam all the time with your routine physicals? I did not do it with the neg ROS; pt new to me and also partly bec IMP solo without chaperone. How would you have handle this. Would not want to do a less than thorough exam and not serve pt with best care. Any opinions. (If female cpe, pap and pelvic almost always expected as soon as scheduled.)

-- PATIENTS-please remember  that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical  record and is placed into your  chart ( be careful what you say!)

Email is best used for appointment making and  brief  questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL  if the  matter is more urgent .     MD    

     ph    fax impcenter.org

Posted

Took 11 letters and 8 months to get it all setup but it works great now Beth Sullivan, DORidgeway Family PracticeCommerce, GA 30529 From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sent: Thursday, November 11, 2010 7:55 AMTo: Subject: Re: Question re Hernia Exam now that's beautiful. Actual cooperation among all the players..! I offer my male patients an option. I can do the exam in my office, or if they would feel more comfortable, I can refer to a local urologist who will provide a prostate and testicular check to my male patients and not charge them an additional co-pay for the exam. I set this up and got it sanctioned by BCBS & Aetna since the question of waving co-pays came into play. In return I provide the same type service to his female patients. If he sees a female patient who needs a PAP/Breast exam done they are referred to me and we perform just the breast exam and PAP collection. Has worked out well for the last 5 years. Beth Sullivan, DORidgeway Family PracticeCommerce, GA 30529 From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of ldlcsamsonSent: Wednesday, November 10, 2010 2:05 PMTo: Subject: Question re Hernia Exam Did a routine physical on a 31 yo new pt. Per hx no problems with GU ROS. I did not do a hernia check. I did talk about testicular self checks. I would do testicular checks with a return visit or if any concerns expressed. At the end of the visit did tell me he had this testicular check done when he had his exam years ago (he was tested for STD then). I then offered to do the exam to be thorough; pt prefers to come in at a later date for this exam or come in if any symptoms.Question: Do you include this exam all the time with your routine physicals? I did not do it with the neg ROS; pt new to me and also partly bec IMP solo without chaperone. How would you have handle this. Would not want to do a less than thorough exam and not serve pt with best care. Any opinions. (If female cpe, pap and pelvic almost always expected as soon as scheduled.)-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

Nice Work!

To: Sent: Thu, November 11, 2010 8:35:32 AMSubject: RE: Question re Hernia Exam

Took 11 letters and 8 months to get it all setup but it works great now

Beth Sullivan, DO

Ridgeway Family Practice

Commerce, GA 30529

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sent: Thursday, November 11, 2010 7:55 AMTo: Subject: Re: Question re Hernia Exam

now that's beautiful. Actual cooperation among all the players..!

I offer my male patients an option. I can do the exam in my office, or if they would feel more comfortable, I can refer to a local urologist who will provide a prostate and testicular check to my male patients and not charge them an additional co-pay for the exam. I set this up and got it sanctioned by BCBS & Aetna since the question of waving co-pays came into play. In return I provide the same type service to his female patients. If he sees a female patient who needs a PAP/Breast exam done they are referred to me and we perform just the breast exam and PAP collection. Has worked out well for the last 5 years.

Beth Sullivan, DO

Ridgeway Family Practice

Commerce, GA 30529

From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of ldlcsamsonSent: Wednesday, November 10, 2010 2:05 PMTo:

Subject: Question re Hernia Exam

Did a routine physical on a 31 yo new pt. Per hx no problems with GU ROS. I did not do a hernia check. I did talk about testicular self checks. I would do testicular checks with a return visit or if any concerns expressed. At the end of the visit did tell me he had this testicular check done when he had his exam years ago (he was tested for STD then). I then offered to do the exam to be thorough; pt prefers to come in at a later date for this exam or come in if any symptoms.Question: Do you include this exam all the time with your routine physicals? I did not do it with the neg ROS; pt new to me and also partly bec IMP solo without chaperone. How would you have handle this. Would not want to do a less than thorough exam and not serve pt with best care. Any opinions. (If female cpe, pap and pelvic almost always expected as soon as scheduled.)

-- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org

Posted

Liza,

I think it is helpful to look at evidence.

The US Preventive Services Task Force is an amazing resource for this.  For example:

 

In 2004, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommended against screening for testicular cancer because of its relative rarity, the lack of evidence showing the accuracy of clinical or self-examination, and highly favorable outcomes from treatment. Instead, the USPSTF encouraged clinicians to consider testicular cancer in their differential diagnosis for patients with testicular symptoms (4). In 2009, the USPSTF decided to update the evidence to reaffirm its previous recommendation. The goal of this reaffirmation update was to search for new, high-quality studies with the potential to change the previous recommendation.

Although we did not identify any studies that directly discussed either the benefits or harms of testicular cancer screening, Carmignani and colleagues (7) needed to perform ultrasonography on 1320 symptomatic men to find 27 tumors. Because symptomatic men have a higher pretest probability of cancer than asymptomatic men, one would expect the number needed to screen to detect 1 case of testicular cancer to be considerably greater, and the false-positive rate substantially higher, than those in the study by Carmignani and colleagues.

There are some established risk factors for testicular cancer, such as cryptorchidism and family history of testicular cancer, but researchers continue to look for new ones. A prospective study of 1,504 healthy volunteers (8) found that 84, or approximately 5%, had testicular microlithiasis. After 5 years of follow-up, only 1 participant received a diagnosis of a testicular germ-cell tumor after discovering a palpable mass on self-examination (9).

Although these studies do not directly address the benefits of screening, they serve as a reminder for primary care clinicians to consider testicular cancer as part of their differential diagnosis in patients with testicular or scrotal symptoms. As the USPSTF stated in a previous recommendation statement (10), although the average primary care physician may see only 1 patient with testicular cancer over 20 to 25 years, 26% to 56% of patients with testicular cancer had an initially incorrect diagnosis of another testicular disorder.

In summary, we found no new studies since the 2004 USPSTF recommendation on the benefits or harms of screening for testicular cancer by testicular self-examination, physician examination, or other screening tests.

 

At the bottom I'll include the recommendations for a 31 y male nonsmoker who is sexually active. 

 

There are web and smartphone tools for these.  I like to use these check lists for my annual wellness exams.

 

To me, this is an incredibly useful tool, free courtesy of our federal govt. 

 

http://epss.ahrq.gov/PDA/index.jsp

 

 

On a side note, my doc did a rectal exam at my physical (was 47y) at the time; she said, I know there is no evidence to do this, but I still always do.  Actually frustrated me quite a bit....here is the summary of colorectal screening recommendations:

The USPSTF recommends screening for colorectal cancer using fecal occult blood testing, sigmoidoscopy, or colonoscopy, in adults, beginning at age 50 years and continuing until age 75 years. The risks and benefits of these screening methods vary. Go to the Rationale and Clinical Considerations sections for comparisons of the risks and benefits of different screening regimens, as well as the specific intervals for different recommended tests.

 

On the website, you can always click to more details. 

 

I love the Pratts' letter about harms and benefits.  We as IMPs (and often primary care providers) should, of all people, understand that concept.  Now, I'll step off the soapbox.

 

Sharon

 

Here is the summary for the inital patient in question: 

 

10 - Recommended (A, B)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

A

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents at Increased Risk

A*

High Blood Pressure: Screening -- Adults 18 and Over

A

Syphilis: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased Risk

B

Alcohol Misuse: Screening and Behavioral Counseling -- Men, Women, and Pregnant Women

B*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over -- When staff-assisted depression care supports are in place

B

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Adults with Hyperlipidemia and Other Risk Factors for CVD

B

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34, Increased risk for CHD

B

Obesity: Screening and Intensive Counseling -- Obese Men and Women

B*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral Counseling -- Sexually Active Adolescents and Adults at Increased Risk

B*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women -- Sustained BP 135/80+

17 - Not Recommended (D)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

D*

Aspirin to Prevent CVD: Men younger than 45 years of age, to prevent myocardial infarction

D*

Asymptomatic Bacteriuria: Screening -- Men and Non-Pregnant Women

D

Bladder Cancer: Screening -- Adults

D

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Low Risk

D*

Carotid Artery Stenosis: Screening -- General Adult Population

D*

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: Screening -- Adults, Using Spirometry

D

Genital Herpes: Screening -- Adolescents and Adults, Asymptomatic

D

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men and Women at Low Risk

D

Hemochromatosis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Hepatitis B: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Pancreatic Cancer: Screening -- Adults, Asymptomatic

D

Peripheral Arterial Disease: Screening -- Adults

D

Routine Aspirin or NSAIDs for the Primary Prevention of Colorectal Cancer: Preventive Medication -- All Adults, Average Risk

D

Syphilis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Testicular Cancer: Screening -- Adolescent and Adult Men

D

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD: Preventive Medication -- Beta Carotene

28 - Uncertain (C, I)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

C*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over -- When staff-assisted depression care supports are not in place

C

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents, Not at Increased Risk

C

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34, Not at increased risk for CHD

I*

CHD: Risk assessment using non-traditional risk factors -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

I

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Increased Risk

I

Chlamydia: Screening -- Men

I*

Drug Use - Illicit : Screening -- Adolescent, Adults, and Pregnant Women

I

Family and Intimate Partner Violence: Screening

I

Glaucoma: Screening -- Adults

I

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men at Increased Risk

I

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Unselected Patients, Primary Care Setting

I

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased Risk

I

Low Back Pain: Counseling -- Adults

I

Lung Cancer: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

I

Obesity: Screening and Counseling at Any Intensity -- Overweight Men and Women

I

Obesity: Screening and Moderate/Low Intensity Counseling -- Obese Men and Women

I

Oral Cancer: Screening -- Adults

I

Physical Activity: Behavioral Counseling -- Primary Care Setting

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries: Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Driving under influence of alcohol or riding with alcohol-impaired drivers

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries: Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Proper use of motor vehicle occupant restraints

I*

Prostate Cancer: Screening -- Men younger than 75

I*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral Counseling -- Non-sexually-active Adolescents and Adults Not at Increased Risk

I

Skin Cancer: Counseling by Primary Care Physician -- Men and Women

I*

Skin Cancer: Screening - - Men and Women

I

Suicide Risk: Screening -- Men and Women

I

Thyroid Disease: Screening -- Men and Women

I*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women -- BP 135/80 or lower

I

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD: Preventive Medication -- A, C, E, Multi

 

 

Sharon McCoy MD

Renaissance Family Medicine

10 McClintock Court; Irvine, CA  92617

PH: (949)387-5504   Fax: (949)281-2197  Toll free phone/fax: 

www.SharonMD.com

 

 

Posted

The USPSTF not withstanding, it takes about 60-120 seconds to a reasonably thorough genital exam on an average male, especially if they are partially disrobed with underpants under gown. The cost and risks are negligible and as in most cancers, it's probably better to make an earlier than later diagnosis. In 15 years of practice, I've diagnosed at least 2 or 3 men with testicular cancer that I can recall off the top of my head, so I guess I'm above average. It's also pertinent that testicular cancer has a bimodal distribution with peaks in adolescence and later in life. Teenage boys are particularly apt to ignore and be embarrassed by genital sxs, write them off as being normal development or nothing serious, and not seek care for them.Although I did plenty of gyn and ob in residency, I find myself referring many women patients to ob/gyn for routine care because I don't feel all that comfortable with it anymore.Just my 2 cents.Straz

Liza,

I think it is helpful to look at evidence.

The US Preventive Services Task Force is an amazing resource for this. For example:

In 2004, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommended against screening for testicular cancer because of its relative rarity, the lack of evidence showing the accuracy of clinical or self-examination, and highly favorable outcomes from treatment. Instead, the USPSTF encouraged clinicians to consider testicular cancer in their differential diagnosis for patients with testicular symptoms (4). In 2009, the USPSTF decided to update the evidence to reaffirm its previous recommendation. The goal of this reaffirmation update was to search for new, high-quality studies with the potential to change the previous recommendation.Although we did not identify any studies that directly discussed either the benefits or harms of testicular cancer screening, Carmignani and colleagues (7) needed to perform ultrasonography on 1320 symptomatic men to find 27 tumors. Because symptomatic men have a higher pretest probability of cancer than asymptomatic men, one would expect the number needed to screen to detect 1 case of testicular cancer to be considerably greater, and the false-positive rate substantially higher, than those in the study by Carmignani and colleagues.There are some established risk factors for testicular cancer, such as cryptorchidism and family history of testicular cancer, but researchers continue to look for new ones. A prospective study of 1,504 healthy volunteers (8) found that 84, or approximately 5%, had testicular microlithiasis. After 5 years of follow-up, only 1 participant received a diagnosis of a testicular germ-cell tumor after discovering a palpable mass on self-examination (9).Although these studies do not directly address the benefits of screening, they serve as a reminder for primary care clinicians to consider testicular cancer as part of their differential diagnosis in patients with testicular or scrotal symptoms. As the USPSTF stated in a previous recommendation statement (10), although the average primary care physician may see only 1 patient with testicular cancer over 20 to 25 years, 26% to 56% of patients with testicular cancer had an initially incorrect diagnosis of another testicular disorder.In summary, we found no new studies since the 2004 USPSTF recommendation on the benefits or harms of screening for testicular cancer by testicular self-examination, physician examination, or other screening tests.

At the bottom I'll include the recommendations for a 31 y male nonsmoker who is sexually active.

There are web and smartphone tools for these. I like to use these check lists for my annual wellness exams.

To me, this is an incredibly useful tool, free courtesy of our federal govt.

http://epss.ahrq.gov/PDA/index.jsp

On a side note, my doc did a rectal exam at my physical (was 47y) at the time; she said, I know there is no evidence to do this, but I still always do. Actually frustrated me quite a bit....here is the summary of colorectal screening recommendations:

The USPSTF recommends screening for colorectal cancer using fecal occult blood testing, sigmoidoscopy, or colonoscopy, in adults, beginning at age 50 years and continuing until age 75 years. The risks and benefits of these screening methods vary. Go to the Rationale and Clinical Considerations sections for comparisons of the risks and benefits of different screening regimens, as well as the specific intervals for different recommended tests.

On the website, you can always click to more details.

I love the Pratts' letter about harms and benefits. We as IMPs (and often primary care providers) should, of all people, understand that concept. Now, I'll step off the soapbox.

Sharon

Here is the summary for the inital patient in question:

10 - Recommended (A, B)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

A

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents at Increased Risk

A*

High Blood Pressure: Screening -- Adults 18 and Over

A

Syphilis: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased Risk

B

Alcohol Misuse: Screening and Behavioral Counseling -- Men, Women, and Pregnant Women

B*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over -- When staff-assisted depression care supports are in place

B

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Adults with Hyperlipidemia and Other Risk Factors for CVD

B

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34, Increased risk for CHD

B

Obesity: Screening and Intensive Counseling -- Obese Men and Women

B*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral Counseling -- Sexually Active Adolescents and Adults at Increased Risk

B*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women -- Sustained BP 135/80+

17 - Not Recommended (D)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

D*

Aspirin to Prevent CVD: Men younger than 45 years of age, to prevent myocardial infarction

D*

Asymptomatic Bacteriuria: Screening -- Men and Non-Pregnant Women

D

Bladder Cancer: Screening -- Adults

D

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Low Risk

D*

Carotid Artery Stenosis: Screening -- General Adult Population

D*

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: Screening -- Adults, Using Spirometry

D

Genital Herpes: Screening -- Adolescents and Adults, Asymptomatic

D

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men and Women at Low Risk

D

Hemochromatosis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Hepatitis B: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Pancreatic Cancer: Screening -- Adults, Asymptomatic

D

Peripheral Arterial Disease: Screening -- Adults

D

Routine Aspirin or NSAIDs for the Primary Prevention of Colorectal Cancer: Preventive Medication -- All Adults, Average Risk

D

Syphilis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Testicular Cancer: Screening -- Adolescent and Adult Men

D

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD: Preventive Medication -- Beta Carotene

28 - Uncertain (C, I)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

C*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over -- When staff-assisted depression care supports are not in place

C

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents, Not at Increased Risk

C

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34, Not at increased risk for CHD

I*

CHD: Risk assessment using non-traditional risk factors -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

I

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Increased Risk

I

Chlamydia: Screening -- Men

I*

Drug Use - Illicit : Screening -- Adolescent, Adults, and Pregnant Women

I

Family and Intimate Partner Violence: Screening

I

Glaucoma: Screening -- Adults

I

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men at Increased Risk

I

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Unselected Patients, Primary Care Setting

I

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased Risk

I

Low Back Pain: Counseling -- Adults

I

Lung Cancer: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

I

Obesity: Screening and Counseling at Any Intensity -- Overweight Men and Women

I

Obesity: Screening and Moderate/Low Intensity Counseling -- Obese Men and Women

I

Oral Cancer: Screening -- Adults

I

Physical Activity: Behavioral Counseling -- Primary Care Setting

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries: Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Driving under influence of alcohol or riding with alcohol-impaired drivers

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries: Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Proper use of motor vehicle occupant restraints

I*

Prostate Cancer: Screening -- Men younger than 75

I*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral Counseling -- Non-sexually-active Adolescents and Adults Not at Increased Risk

I

Skin Cancer: Counseling by Primary Care Physician -- Men and Women

I*

Skin Cancer: Screening - - Men and Women

I

Suicide Risk: Screening -- Men and Women

I

Thyroid Disease: Screening -- Men and Women

I*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women -- BP 135/80 or lower

I

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD: Preventive Medication -- A, C, E, Multi

Sharon McCoy MD

Renaissance Family Medicine

10 McClintock Court; Irvine, CA 92617

PH: (949)387-5504 Fax: (949)281-2197 Toll free phone/fax:

www.SharonMD.com

Posted

However, what do you do if you detect a hernia? Because

that can cause more harm than good. I am assuming the men with testicular

cancer had no symptoms and it was an accidental finding?

Kathy Saradarian, MD

Branchville, NJ

www.qualityfamilypractice.com

Solo 4/03, Practicing since 9/90

Practice Partner 5/03

Low staffing

From:

[mailto: ] On Behalf Of

Strazzullo

Sent: Friday, November 12, 2010 11:23 AM

To:

Subject: Re: Question re Hernia Exam

The USPSTF not withstanding, it takes about 60-120 seconds to a reasonably

thorough genital exam on an average male, especially if they are partially

disrobed with underpants under gown. The cost and risks are negligible

and as in most cancers, it's probably better to make an earlier than later

diagnosis. In 15 years of practice, I've diagnosed at least 2 or 3 men with

testicular cancer that I can recall off the top of my head, so I guess I'm

above average. It's also pertinent that testicular cancer has a bimodal

distribution with peaks in adolescence and later in life. Teenage boys

are particularly apt to ignore and be embarrassed by genital sxs, write them

off as being normal development or nothing serious, and not seek care for them.

Although I did plenty of gyn and ob in residency, I find

myself referring many women patients to ob/gyn for routine care because I don't

feel all that comfortable with it anymore.

Just my 2 cents.

Straz

Liza,

I think it is helpful to look at

evidence.

The US Preventive Services Task

Force is an amazing resource for this. For example:

In 2004, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force

(USPSTF) recommended against screening for testicular cancer because of its

relative rarity, the lack of evidence showing the accuracy of clinical or self-examination,

and highly favorable outcomes from treatment. Instead, the USPSTF encouraged clinicians to consider testicular cancer in their

differential diagnosis for patients with testicular symptoms (4).

In 2009, the USPSTF decided to update the evidence to reaffirm its previous

recommendation. The goal of this reaffirmation update was to search for new, high-quality

studies with the potential to change the previous recommendation.

Although we did not identify any studies that

directly discussed either the benefits or harms of testicular cancer screening,

Carmignani and colleagues (7)

needed to perform ultrasonography on 1320 symptomatic men to find 27 tumors.

Because symptomatic men have a higher pretest probability of cancer than

asymptomatic men, one would expect the number needed to screen to detect 1 case

of testicular cancer to be considerably greater, and the false-positive rate

substantially higher, than those in the study by Carmignani and colleagues.

There are some established risk factors for testicular

cancer, such as cryptorchidism and family history of testicular cancer, but

researchers continue to look for new ones. A prospective study of 1,504 healthy

volunteers (8)

found that 84, or approximately 5%, had testicular microlithiasis. After 5

years of follow-up, only 1 participant received a diagnosis of a testicular

germ-cell tumor after discovering a palpable mass on self-examination (9).

Although these studies do not directly address the

benefits of screening, they serve as a reminder for primary care clinicians to

consider testicular cancer as part of their differential diagnosis in patients

with testicular or scrotal symptoms. As the USPSTF stated in a previous

recommendation statement (10),

although the average primary care physician may see only 1 patient with

testicular cancer over 20 to 25 years, 26% to 56% of patients with testicular

cancer had an initially incorrect diagnosis of another testicular disorder.

In summary, we found no new studies since the 2004

USPSTF recommendation on the benefits or harms of screening for testicular

cancer by testicular self-examination, physician examination, or other

screening tests.

At the bottom I'll include the

recommendations for a 31 y male nonsmoker who is sexually active.

There are web and smartphone tools

for these. I like to use these check lists for my annual wellness exams.

To me, this is an incredibly useful

tool, free courtesy of our federal govt.

http://epss.ahrq.gov/PDA/index.jsp

On a side note, my doc did a rectal

exam at my physical (was 47y) at the time; she said, I know there is no

evidence to do this, but I still always do. Actually frustrated me quite

a bit....here is the summary of colorectal screening recommendations:

The USPSTF recommends screening for

colorectal cancer using fecal occult blood testing, sigmoidoscopy, or

colonoscopy, in adults, beginning at age 50 years and continuing until age 75

years. The risks and benefits of these screening methods vary. Go to the

Rationale and Clinical Considerations sections for comparisons of the risks and

benefits of different screening regimens, as well as the specific intervals for

different recommended tests.

On the website, you can always

click to more details.

I love the Pratts' letter

about harms and benefits. We as IMPs (and often primary care providers)

should, of all people, understand that concept. Now, I'll step off the

soapbox.

Sharon

Here is the summary for the inital

patient in question:

10 - Recommended (A, B)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

A

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents at

Increased Risk

A*

High Blood Pressure: Screening -- Adults 18 and

Over

A

Syphilis: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased

Risk

B

Alcohol Misuse: Screening and Behavioral Counseling

-- Men, Women, and Pregnant Women

B*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over --

When staff-assisted depression care supports are in place

B

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Adults with

Hyperlipidemia and Other Risk Factors for CVD

B

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34,

Increased risk for CHD

B

Obesity: Screening and Intensive Counseling --

Obese Men and Women

B*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral

Counseling -- Sexually Active Adolescents and Adults at Increased Risk

B*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women

-- Sustained BP 135/80+

17 - Not Recommended (D)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

D*

Aspirin to Prevent CVD: Men younger than 45 years

of age, to prevent myocardial infarction

D*

Asymptomatic Bacteriuria: Screening -- Men and

Non-Pregnant Women

D

Bladder Cancer: Screening -- Adults

D

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Low

Risk

D*

Carotid Artery Stenosis: Screening -- General Adult

Population

D*

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: Screening --

Adults, Using Spirometry

D

Genital Herpes: Screening -- Adolescents and

Adults, Asymptomatic

D

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men and Women at Low Risk

D

Hemochromatosis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

D

Hepatitis B: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

D

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

D

Pancreatic Cancer: Screening -- Adults,

Asymptomatic

D

Peripheral Arterial Disease: Screening -- Adults

D

Routine Aspirin or NSAIDs for the Primary Prevention of

Colorectal Cancer: Preventive Medication -- All Adults, Average Risk

D

Syphilis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Testicular Cancer: Screening -- Adolescent and

Adult Men

D

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD:

Preventive Medication -- Beta Carotene

28 - Uncertain (C, I)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

C*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over --

When staff-assisted depression care supports are not in place

C

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents, Not at

Increased Risk

C

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34,

Not at increased risk for CHD

I*

CHD: Risk assessment using non-traditional risk

factors -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

I

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults,

Increased Risk

I

Chlamydia: Screening -- Men

I*

Drug Use - Illicit : Screening -- Adolescent,

Adults, and Pregnant Women

I

Family and Intimate Partner Violence: Screening

I

Glaucoma: Screening -- Adults

I

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men at Increased Risk

I

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Unselected Patients,

Primary Care Setting

I

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Men and Women at

Increased Risk

I

Low Back Pain: Counseling -- Adults

I

Lung Cancer: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

I

Obesity: Screening and Counseling at Any Intensity

-- Overweight Men and Women

I

Obesity: Screening and Moderate/Low Intensity

Counseling -- Obese Men and Women

I

Oral Cancer: Screening -- Adults

I

Physical Activity: Behavioral Counseling -- Primary

Care Setting

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries:

Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Driving under influence of alcohol or

riding with alcohol-impaired drivers

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries:

Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Proper use of motor vehicle occupant

restraints

I*

Prostate Cancer: Screening -- Men younger than 75

I*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral

Counseling -- Non-sexually-active Adolescents and Adults Not at Increased

Risk

I

Skin Cancer: Counseling by Primary Care Physician

-- Men and Women

I*

Skin Cancer: Screening - - Men and Women

I

Suicide Risk: Screening -- Men and Women

I

Thyroid Disease: Screening -- Men and Women

I*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women

-- BP 135/80 or lower

I

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD:

Preventive Medication -- A, C, E, Multi

Sharon McCoy MD

Renaissance Family Medicine

10 McClintock Court; Irvine,

CA 92617

PH: (949)387-5504 Fax:

(949)281-2197 Toll free phone/fax:

www.SharonMD.com

CyberDefender has scanned this email for potential threats.

Version 2.0 / Build 4.03.29.01

Get free PC security at http://www.cyberdefender.com

Posted

I have a friend who is alive and well because he or his doc caught his cancer at just around 18 years of age... now he got the prostetic testi to fill his sack and allow him to look normal... But we were all musician and one day a mutual friend of ours, actually the guy who introduced us to one another came up with a little of a tease of a joke....

"Suddenly.... I'm not half the man I used to be..... There's one Gonad hanging off of me, Oh how I long for yesterday.... Why it had to go, I don't know they wouldn't say..... I felt something wrong, now I long for yesterdaaaaaaaaaay...."

Just thought I'd share a cute if not a bit crude joke... :)

To: Sent: Fri, November 12, 2010 11:22:33 AMSubject: Re: Question re Hernia Exam

The USPSTF not withstanding, it takes about 60-120 seconds to a reasonably thorough genital exam on an average male, especially if they are partially disrobed with underpants under gown. The cost and risks are negligible and as in most cancers, it's probably better to make an earlier than later diagnosis. In 15 years of practice, I've diagnosed at least 2 or 3 men with testicular cancer that I can recall off the top of my head, so I guess I'm above average. It's also pertinent that testicular cancer has a bimodal distribution with peaks in adolescence and later in life. Teenage boys are particularly apt to ignore and be embarrassed by genital sxs, write them off as being normal development or nothing serious, and not seek care for them.

Although I did plenty of gyn and ob in residency, I find myself referring many women patients to ob/gyn for routine care because I don't feel all that comfortable with it anymore.

Just my 2 cents.

Straz

Liza,

I think it is helpful to look at evidence.

The US Preventive Services Task Force is an amazing resource for this. For example:

In 2004, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommended against screening for testicular cancer because of its relative rarity, the lack of evidence showing the accuracy of clinical or self-examination, and highly favorable outcomes from treatment. Instead, the USPSTF encouraged clinicians to consider testicular cancer in their differential diagnosis for patients with testicular symptoms (4). In 2009, the USPSTF decided to update the evidence to reaffirm its previous recommendation. The goal of this reaffirmation update was to search for new, high-quality studies with the potential to change the previous recommendation.

Although we did not identify any studies that directly discussed either the benefits or harms of testicular cancer screening, Carmignani and colleagues (7) needed to perform ultrasonography on 1320 symptomatic men to find 27 tumors. Because symptomatic men have a higher pretest probability of cancer than asymptomatic men, one would expect the number needed to screen to detect 1 case of testicular cancer to be considerably greater, and the false-positive rate substantially higher, than those in the study by Carmignani and colleagues.

There are some established risk factors for testicular cancer, such as cryptorchidism and family history of testicular cancer, but researchers continue to look for new ones. A prospective study of 1,504 healthy volunteers (8) found that 84, or approximately 5%, had testicular microlithiasis. After 5 years of follow-up, only 1 participant received a diagnosis of a testicular germ-cell tumor after discovering a palpable mass on self-examination (9).

Although these studies do not directly address the benefits of screening, they serve as a reminder for primary care clinicians to consider testicular cancer as part of their differential diagnosis in patients with testicular or scrotal symptoms. As the USPSTF stated in a previous recommendation statement (10), although the average primary care physician may see only 1 patient with testicular cancer over 20 to 25 years, 26% to 56% of patients with testicular cancer had an initially incorrect diagnosis of another testicular disorder.

In summary, we found no new studies since the 2004 USPSTF recommendation on the benefits or harms of screening for testicular cancer by testicular self-examination, physician examination, or other screening tests.

At the bottom I'll include the recommendations for a 31 y male nonsmoker who is sexually active.

There are web and smartphone tools for these. I like to use these check lists for my annual wellness exams.

To me, this is an incredibly useful tool, free courtesy of our federal govt.

http://epss.ahrq.gov/PDA/index.jsp

On a side note, my doc did a rectal exam at my physical (was 47y) at the time; she said, I know there is no evidence to do this, but I still always do. Actually frustrated me quite a bit....here is the summary of colorectal screening recommendations:

The USPSTF recommends screening for colorectal cancer using fecal occult blood testing, sigmoidoscopy, or colonoscopy, in adults, beginning at age 50 years and continuing until age 75 years. The risks and benefits of these screening methods vary. Go to the Rationale and Clinical Considerations sections for comparisons of the risks and benefits of different screening regimens, as well as the specific intervals for different recommended tests.

On the website, you can always click to more details.

I love the Pratts' letter about harms and benefits. We as IMPs (and often primary care providers) should, of all people, understand that concept. Now, I'll step off the soapbox.

Sharon

Here is the summary for the inital patient in question:

10 - Recommended (A, B)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

A

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents at Increased Risk

A*

High Blood Pressure: Screening -- Adults 18 and Over

A

Syphilis: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased Risk

B

Alcohol Misuse: Screening and Behavioral Counseling -- Men, Women, and Pregnant Women

B*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over -- When staff-assisted depression care supports are in place

B

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Adults with Hyperlipidemia and Other Risk Factors for CVD

B

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34, Increased risk for CHD

B

Obesity: Screening and Intensive Counseling -- Obese Men and Women

B*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral Counseling -- Sexually Active Adolescents and Adults at Increased Risk

B*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women -- Sustained BP 135/80+

17 - Not Recommended (D)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

D*

Aspirin to Prevent CVD: Men younger than 45 years of age, to prevent myocardial infarction

D*

Asymptomatic Bacteriuria: Screening -- Men and Non-Pregnant Women

D

Bladder Cancer: Screening -- Adults

D

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Low Risk

D*

Carotid Artery Stenosis: Screening -- General Adult Population

D*

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: Screening -- Adults, Using Spirometry

D

Genital Herpes: Screening -- Adolescents and Adults, Asymptomatic

D

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men and Women at Low Risk

D

Hemochromatosis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Hepatitis B: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Pancreatic Cancer: Screening -- Adults, Asymptomatic

D

Peripheral Arterial Disease: Screening -- Adults

D

Routine Aspirin or NSAIDs for the Primary Prevention of Colorectal Cancer: Preventive Medication -- All Adults, Average Risk

D

Syphilis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Testicular Cancer: Screening -- Adolescent and Adult Men

D

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD: Preventive Medication -- Beta Carotene

28 - Uncertain (C, I)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

C*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over -- When staff-assisted depression care supports are not in place

C

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents, Not at Increased Risk

C

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34, Not at increased risk for CHD

I*

CHD: Risk assessment using non-traditional risk factors -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

I

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Increased Risk

I

Chlamydia: Screening -- Men

I*

Drug Use - Illicit : Screening -- Adolescent, Adults, and Pregnant Women

I

Family and Intimate Partner Violence: Screening

I

Glaucoma: Screening -- Adults

I

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men at Increased Risk

I

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Unselected Patients, Primary Care Setting

I

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased Risk

I

Low Back Pain: Counseling -- Adults

I

Lung Cancer: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

I

Obesity: Screening and Counseling at Any Intensity -- Overweight Men and Women

I

Obesity: Screening and Moderate/Low Intensity Counseling -- Obese Men and Women

I

Oral Cancer: Screening -- Adults

I

Physical Activity: Behavioral Counseling -- Primary Care Setting

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries: Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Driving under influence of alcohol or riding with alcohol-impaired drivers

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries: Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Proper use of motor vehicle occupant restraints

I*

Prostate Cancer: Screening -- Men younger than 75

I*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral Counseling -- Non-sexually-active Adolescents and Adults Not at Increased Risk

I

Skin Cancer: Counseling by Primary Care Physician -- Men and Women

I*

Skin Cancer: Screening - - Men and Women

I

Suicide Risk: Screening -- Men and Women

I

Thyroid Disease: Screening -- Men and Women

I*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women -- BP 135/80 or lower

I

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD: Preventive Medication -- A, C, E, Multi

Sharon McCoy MD

Renaissance Family Medicine

10 McClintock Court; Irvine, CA 92617

PH: (949)387-5504 Fax: (949)281-2197 Toll free phone/fax:

www.SharonMD.com

Posted

Merle Haggard's said it before: If I only had one arm to hold you well better yet if I had none at allThen I wouldn`t have two arms that ache for youAnd I`d have one less mem`ry to recallIf I only had one ear to listen to the lies that you told to meThen I would more closely resemble the half a man that you`ve made of me[ guitar - sax ]And if I only had one leg to stand onThen how much how much truer picture you`d seeAnd then I would more closely resamble the half of man that you`ve made of meYeah then I would more closely resamble the half of man that you`ve made of me

I have a friend who is alive and well because he or his doc caught his cancer at just around 18 years of age... now he got the prostetic testi to fill his sack and allow him to look normal... But we were all musician and one day a mutual friend of ours, actually the guy who introduced us to one another came up with a little of a tease of a joke....

"Suddenly.... I'm not half the man I used to be..... There's one Gonad hanging off of me, Oh how I long for yesterday.... Why it had to go, I don't know they wouldn't say..... I felt something wrong, now I long for yesterdaaaaaaaaaay...."

Just thought I'd share a cute if not a bit crude joke... :)

To: Sent: Fri, November 12, 2010 11:22:33 AMSubject: Re: Question re Hernia Exam The USPSTF not withstanding, it takes about 60-120 seconds to a reasonably thorough genital exam on an average male, especially if they are partially disrobed with underpants under gown. The cost and risks are negligible and as in most cancers, it's probably better to make an earlier than later diagnosis. In 15 years of practice, I've diagnosed at least 2 or 3 men with testicular cancer that I can recall off the top of my head, so I guess I'm above average. It's also pertinent that testicular cancer has a bimodal distribution with peaks in adolescence and later in life. Teenage boys are particularly apt to ignore and be embarrassed by genital sxs, write them off as being normal development or nothing serious, and not seek care for them.

Although I did plenty of gyn and ob in residency, I find myself referring many women patients to ob/gyn for routine care because I don't feel all that comfortable with it anymore.

Just my 2 cents.

Straz

Liza,

I think it is helpful to look at evidence.

The US Preventive Services Task Force is an amazing resource for this. For example:

In 2004, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommended against screening for testicular cancer because of its relative rarity, the lack of evidence showing the accuracy of clinical or self-examination, and highly favorable outcomes from treatment. Instead, the USPSTF encouraged clinicians to consider testicular cancer in their differential diagnosis for patients with testicular symptoms (4). In 2009, the USPSTF decided to update the evidence to reaffirm its previous recommendation. The goal of this reaffirmation update was to search for new, high-quality studies with the potential to change the previous recommendation.Although we did not identify any studies that directly discussed either the benefits or harms of testicular cancer screening, Carmignani and colleagues (7) needed to perform ultrasonography on 1320 symptomatic men to find 27 tumors. Because symptomatic men have a higher pretest probability of cancer than asymptomatic men, one would expect the number needed to screen to detect 1 case of testicular cancer to be considerably greater, and the false-positive rate substantially higher, than those in the study by Carmignani and colleagues.There are some established risk factors for testicular cancer, such as cryptorchidism and family history of testicular cancer, but researchers continue to look for new ones. A prospective study of 1,504 healthy volunteers (8) found that 84, or approximately 5%, had testicular microlithiasis. After 5 years of follow-up, only 1 participant received a diagnosis of a testicular germ-cell tumor after discovering a palpable mass on self-examination (9).Although these studies do not directly address the benefits of screening, they serve as a reminder for primary care clinicians to consider testicular cancer as part of their differential diagnosis in patients with testicular or scrotal symptoms. As the USPSTF stated in a previous recommendation statement (10), although the average primary care physician may see only 1 patient with testicular cancer over 20 to 25 years, 26% to 56% of patients with testicular cancer had an initially incorrect diagnosis of another testicular disorder.In summary, we found no new studies since the 2004 USPSTF recommendation on the benefits or harms of screening for testicular cancer by testicular self-examination, physician examination, or other screening tests.

At the bottom I'll include the recommendations for a 31 y male nonsmoker who is sexually active.

There are web and smartphone tools for these. I like to use these check lists for my annual wellness exams.

To me, this is an incredibly useful tool, free courtesy of our federal govt.

http://epss.ahrq.gov/PDA/index.jsp

On a side note, my doc did a rectal exam at my physical (was 47y) at the time; she said, I know there is no evidence to do this, but I still always do. Actually frustrated me quite a bit....here is the summary of colorectal screening recommendations:

The USPSTF recommends screening for colorectal cancer using fecal occult blood testing, sigmoidoscopy, or colonoscopy, in adults, beginning at age 50 years and continuing until age 75 years. The risks and benefits of these screening methods vary. Go to the Rationale and Clinical Considerations sections for comparisons of the risks and benefits of different screening regimens, as well as the specific intervals for different recommended tests.

On the website, you can always click to more details.

I love the Pratts' letter about harms and benefits. We as IMPs (and often primary care providers) should, of all people, understand that concept. Now, I'll step off the soapbox.

Sharon

Here is the summary for the inital patient in question:

10 - Recommended (A, B)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

A

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents at Increased Risk

A*

High Blood Pressure: Screening -- Adults 18 and Over

A

Syphilis: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased Risk

B

Alcohol Misuse: Screening and Behavioral Counseling -- Men, Women, and Pregnant Women

B*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over -- When staff-assisted depression care supports are in place

B

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Adults with Hyperlipidemia and Other Risk Factors for CVD

B

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34, Increased risk for CHD

B

Obesity: Screening and Intensive Counseling -- Obese Men and Women

B*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral Counseling -- Sexually Active Adolescents and Adults at Increased Risk

B*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women -- Sustained BP 135/80+

17 - Not Recommended (D)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

D*

Aspirin to Prevent CVD: Men younger than 45 years of age, to prevent myocardial infarction

D*

Asymptomatic Bacteriuria: Screening -- Men and Non-Pregnant Women

D

Bladder Cancer: Screening -- Adults

D

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Low Risk

D*

Carotid Artery Stenosis: Screening -- General Adult Population

D*

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: Screening -- Adults, Using Spirometry

D

Genital Herpes: Screening -- Adolescents and Adults, Asymptomatic

D

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men and Women at Low Risk

D

Hemochromatosis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Hepatitis B: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Pancreatic Cancer: Screening -- Adults, Asymptomatic

D

Peripheral Arterial Disease: Screening -- Adults

D

Routine Aspirin or NSAIDs for the Primary Prevention of Colorectal Cancer: Preventive Medication -- All Adults, Average Risk

D

Syphilis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

D

Testicular Cancer: Screening -- Adolescent and Adult Men

D

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD: Preventive Medication -- Beta Carotene

28 - Uncertain (C, I)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

C*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over -- When staff-assisted depression care supports are not in place

C

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents, Not at Increased Risk

C

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34, Not at increased risk for CHD

I*

CHD: Risk assessment using non-traditional risk factors -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

I

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Increased Risk

I

Chlamydia: Screening -- Men

I*

Drug Use - Illicit : Screening -- Adolescent, Adults, and Pregnant Women

I

Family and Intimate Partner Violence: Screening

I

Glaucoma: Screening -- Adults

I

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men at Increased Risk

I

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Unselected Patients, Primary Care Setting

I

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased Risk

I

Low Back Pain: Counseling -- Adults

I

Lung Cancer: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

I

Obesity: Screening and Counseling at Any Intensity -- Overweight Men and Women

I

Obesity: Screening and Moderate/Low Intensity Counseling -- Obese Men and Women

I

Oral Cancer: Screening -- Adults

I

Physical Activity: Behavioral Counseling -- Primary Care Setting

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries: Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Driving under influence of alcohol or riding with alcohol-impaired drivers

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries: Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Proper use of motor vehicle occupant restraints

I*

Prostate Cancer: Screening -- Men younger than 75

I*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral Counseling -- Non-sexually-active Adolescents and Adults Not at Increased Risk

I

Skin Cancer: Counseling by Primary Care Physician -- Men and Women

I*

Skin Cancer: Screening - - Men and Women

I

Suicide Risk: Screening -- Men and Women

I

Thyroid Disease: Screening -- Men and Women

I*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women -- BP 135/80 or lower

I

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD: Preventive Medication -- A, C, E, Multi

Sharon McCoy MD

Renaissance Family Medicine

10 McClintock Court; Irvine, CA 92617

PH: (949)387-5504 Fax: (949)281-2197 Toll free phone/fax:

www.SharonMD.com

Posted

I don't see how detecting a hernia can cause more harm than good. Operating unnecessarily on a hernia may cause more harm than good, but diagnosing it is only making a patient aware of a condition they have. Also, I do preemployment physicals. I'm sure employers want to know if they person they've hired to lift patients has a preexisting hernia.One man was sent to me by his wife, he had scheduled an appointment for a different chief complaint and she called me a head of time to make sure I addressed the issue of a bigger testicle. One presented with pain and looked like a torsion but the UTZ showed a mass; this patient had presented a year or two earlier with testiclular complaints and either was not referred or was referred and did not follow-up with urology. One was an elderly gentleman who was totally unaware of the mass.BTW, a few years pack I did a DRE on a 42 yo asymptomatic man, who had an irregular prostate. Referred to Urology, had cancer, underwent radical prostatectomy, tolerated well w/ no incontinence or impotence and is still disease free. He came by a year or two later and thanked me for saving his life. Don't get that too much in FP/urgent care. The USPSTF doesn't recommend DRE routinely, so he'd probably be dead by 50 or 60 if I hadn't ignored their guidelines.Straz

However, what do you do if you detect a hernia? Because

that can cause more harm than good. I am assuming the men with testicular

cancer had no symptoms and it was an accidental finding? Kathy Saradarian, MDBranchville, NJwww.qualityfamilypractice.comSolo 4/03, Practicing since 9/90Practice Partner 5/03Low staffing

From:

[mailto: ] On Behalf Of

Strazzullo

Sent: Friday, November 12, 2010 11:23 AM

To:

Subject: Re: Question re Hernia Exam

The USPSTF not withstanding, it takes about 60-120 seconds to a reasonably

thorough genital exam on an average male, especially if they are partially

disrobed with underpants under gown. The cost and risks are negligible

and as in most cancers, it's probably better to make an earlier than later

diagnosis. In 15 years of practice, I've diagnosed at least 2 or 3 men with

testicular cancer that I can recall off the top of my head, so I guess I'm

above average. It's also pertinent that testicular cancer has a bimodal

distribution with peaks in adolescence and later in life. Teenage boys

are particularly apt to ignore and be embarrassed by genital sxs, write them

off as being normal development or nothing serious, and not seek care for them.

Although I did plenty of gyn and ob in residency, I find

myself referring many women patients to ob/gyn for routine care because I don't

feel all that comfortable with it anymore.

Just my 2 cents.

Straz

Liza,

I think it is helpful to look at

evidence.

The US Preventive Services Task

Force is an amazing resource for this. For example:

In 2004, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force

(USPSTF) recommended against screening for testicular cancer because of its

relative rarity, the lack of evidence showing the accuracy of clinical or self-examination,

and highly favorable outcomes from treatment. Instead, the USPSTF encouraged clinicians to consider testicular cancer in their

differential diagnosis for patients with testicular symptoms (4).

In 2009, the USPSTF decided to update the evidence to reaffirm its previous

recommendation. The goal of this reaffirmation update was to search for new, high-quality

studies with the potential to change the previous recommendation.Although we did not identify any studies that

directly discussed either the benefits or harms of testicular cancer screening,

Carmignani and colleagues (7)

needed to perform ultrasonography on 1320 symptomatic men to find 27 tumors.

Because symptomatic men have a higher pretest probability of cancer than

asymptomatic men, one would expect the number needed to screen to detect 1 case

of testicular cancer to be considerably greater, and the false-positive rate

substantially higher, than those in the study by Carmignani and colleagues.There are some established risk factors for testicular

cancer, such as cryptorchidism and family history of testicular cancer, but

researchers continue to look for new ones. A prospective study of 1,504 healthy

volunteers (8)

found that 84, or approximately 5%, had testicular microlithiasis. After 5

years of follow-up, only 1 participant received a diagnosis of a testicular

germ-cell tumor after discovering a palpable mass on self-examination (9).Although these studies do not directly address the

benefits of screening, they serve as a reminder for primary care clinicians to

consider testicular cancer as part of their differential diagnosis in patients

with testicular or scrotal symptoms. As the USPSTF stated in a previous

recommendation statement (10),

although the average primary care physician may see only 1 patient with

testicular cancer over 20 to 25 years, 26% to 56% of patients with testicular

cancer had an initially incorrect diagnosis of another testicular disorder.In summary, we found no new studies since the 2004

USPSTF recommendation on the benefits or harms of screening for testicular

cancer by testicular self-examination, physician examination, or other

screening tests.

At the bottom I'll include the

recommendations for a 31 y male nonsmoker who is sexually active.

There are web and smartphone tools

for these. I like to use these check lists for my annual wellness exams.

To me, this is an incredibly useful

tool, free courtesy of our federal govt.

http://epss.ahrq.gov/PDA/index.jsp

On a side note, my doc did a rectal

exam at my physical (was 47y) at the time; she said, I know there is no

evidence to do this, but I still always do. Actually frustrated me quite

a bit....here is the summary of colorectal screening recommendations:

The USPSTF recommends screening for

colorectal cancer using fecal occult blood testing, sigmoidoscopy, or

colonoscopy, in adults, beginning at age 50 years and continuing until age 75

years. The risks and benefits of these screening methods vary. Go to the

Rationale and Clinical Considerations sections for comparisons of the risks and

benefits of different screening regimens, as well as the specific intervals for

different recommended tests.

On the website, you can always

click to more details.

I love the Pratts' letter

about harms and benefits. We as IMPs (and often primary care providers)

should, of all people, understand that concept. Now, I'll step off the

soapbox.

Sharon

Here is the summary for the inital

patient in question:

10 - Recommended (A, B)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

A

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents at

Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

A*

High Blood Pressure: Screening -- Adults 18 and

Over

<image002.jpg>

A

Syphilis: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased

Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

B

Alcohol Misuse: Screening and Behavioral Counseling

-- Men, Women, and Pregnant Women

<image002.jpg>

B*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over --

When staff-assisted depression care supports are in place

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

B

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Adults with

Hyperlipidemia and Other Risk Factors for CVD

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

B

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34,

Increased risk for CHD

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

B

Obesity: Screening and Intensive Counseling --

Obese Men and Women

<image002.jpg>

B*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral

Counseling -- Sexually Active Adolescents and Adults at Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

B*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women

-- Sustained BP 135/80+

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

17 - Not Recommended (D)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

D*

Aspirin to Prevent CVD: Men younger than 45 years

of age, to prevent myocardial infarction

<image002.jpg>

D*

Asymptomatic Bacteriuria: Screening -- Men and

Non-Pregnant Women

<image002.jpg>

D

Bladder Cancer: Screening -- Adults

<image002.jpg>

D

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Low

Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

D*

Carotid Artery Stenosis: Screening -- General Adult

Population

<image002.jpg>

D*

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: Screening --

Adults, Using Spirometry

<image002.jpg>

D

Genital Herpes: Screening -- Adolescents and

Adults, Asymptomatic

<image002.jpg>

D

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men and Women at Low Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

D

Hemochromatosis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

<image002.jpg>

D

Hepatitis B: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

<image002.jpg>

D

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

<image002.jpg>

D

Pancreatic Cancer: Screening -- Adults,

Asymptomatic

<image002.jpg>

D

Peripheral Arterial Disease: Screening -- Adults

<image002.jpg>

D

Routine Aspirin or NSAIDs for the Primary Prevention of

Colorectal Cancer: Preventive Medication -- All Adults, Average Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

D

Syphilis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

D

Testicular Cancer: Screening -- Adolescent and

Adult Men

<image002.jpg>

D

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD:

Preventive Medication -- Beta Carotene

<image002.jpg>

28 - Uncertain (C, I)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

C*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over --

When staff-assisted depression care supports are not in place

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

C

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents, Not at

Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

C

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34,

Not at increased risk for CHD

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I*

CHD: Risk assessment using non-traditional risk

factors -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

<image002.jpg>

I

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults,

Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Chlamydia: Screening -- Men

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I*

Drug Use - Illicit : Screening -- Adolescent,

Adults, and Pregnant Women

<image002.jpg>

I

Family and Intimate Partner Violence: Screening

<image002.jpg>

I

Glaucoma: Screening -- Adults

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men at Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Unselected Patients,

Primary Care Setting

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Men and Women at

Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Low Back Pain: Counseling -- Adults

<image002.jpg>

I

Lung Cancer: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

<image002.jpg>

I

Obesity: Screening and Counseling at Any Intensity

-- Overweight Men and Women

<image002.jpg>

I

Obesity: Screening and Moderate/Low Intensity

Counseling -- Obese Men and Women

<image002.jpg>

I

Oral Cancer: Screening -- Adults

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Physical Activity: Behavioral Counseling -- Primary

Care Setting

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries:

Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Driving under influence of alcohol or

riding with alcohol-impaired drivers

<image002.jpg>

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries:

Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Proper use of motor vehicle occupant

restraints

<image002.jpg>

I*

Prostate Cancer: Screening -- Men younger than 75

<image002.jpg>

I*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral

Counseling -- Non-sexually-active Adolescents and Adults Not at Increased

Risk

<image002.jpg>

I

Skin Cancer: Counseling by Primary Care Physician

-- Men and Women

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I*

Skin Cancer: Screening - - Men and Women

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Suicide Risk: Screening -- Men and Women

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Thyroid Disease: Screening -- Men and Women

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women

-- BP 135/80 or lower

<image002.jpg>

I

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD:

Preventive Medication -- A, C, E, Multi

<image002.jpg>

Sharon McCoy MD

Renaissance Family Medicine

10 McClintock Court; Irvine,

CA 92617

PH: (949)387-5504 Fax:

(949)281-2197 Toll free phone/fax:

www.SharonMD.com

CyberDefender has scanned this email for potential threats.

Version 2.0 / Build 4.03.29.01

Get free PC security at http://www.cyberdefender.com

Posted

Because we are sharing, here's my attachment to the wonderful Beatles song previously quoted.

 

My best friend in jr and senior high school had a rough year when he was 16. That summer, he wanted to tell me something and was very serious about it, certainly out of character. He told me he was gay (circa 1978). I was a little confused since he had been my first boyfriend several years before. As I sat contemplating this new information, out of the radio came,' I'm not half the man I used to be.' I can remember looking at him, then both of us burst out laughing so hard, we couldn't stop for 10-15 minutes. 30 years later, it is still a running joke between the two of us when something is serendipitous.

Merle Haggard's said it before:  If I only had one arm to hold you well better yet if I had none at allThen I wouldn`t have two arms that ache for you

And I`d have one less mem`ry to recallIf I only had one ear to listen to the lies that you told to meThen I would more closely resemble the half a man that you`ve made of me[ guitar - sax ]And if I only had one leg to stand on

Then how much how much truer picture you`d seeAnd then I would more closely resamble the half of man that you`ve made of meYeah then I would more closely resamble the half of man that you`ve made of me

 

I have a friend who is alive and well because he or his doc caught his cancer at just around 18 years of age... now he got the prostetic testi to fill his sack and allow him to look normal... But we were all musician and one day a mutual friend of ours, actually the guy who introduced us to one another came up with a little of a tease of a joke....

 

" Suddenly.... I'm not half the man I used to be..... There's one Gonad hanging off of me, Oh how I long for yesterday.... Why it had to go, I don't know they wouldn't say..... I felt something wrong, now I long for yesterdaaaaaaaaaay.... "  

 

Just thought I'd share a cute if not a bit crude joke... :)

 

 

Posted

Thanks for the songs.  Sharon thanks for the USPS Task Force data.  I obtained records on the pt and he had circumcision as an adult and also had lesions checked by his pcp 4 years ago.  I asked him to come back for me to do a thorough hernia check and also recheck if any recurrence of prior lesions.  So pt will come back for the check.

 

Because we are sharing, here's my attachment to the wonderful Beatles song previously quoted.

 

My best friend in jr and senior high school had a rough year when he was 16. That summer, he wanted to tell me something and was very serious about it, certainly out of character. He told me he was gay (circa 1978). I was a little confused since he had been my first boyfriend several years before. As I sat contemplating this new information, out of the radio came,' I'm not half the man I used to be.' I can remember looking at him, then both of us burst out laughing so hard, we couldn't stop for 10-15 minutes. 30 years later, it is still a running joke between the two of us when something is serendipitous.

Merle Haggard's said it before:  If I only had one arm to hold you well better yet if I had none at allThen I wouldn`t have two arms that ache for you

And I`d have one less mem`ry to recallIf I only had one ear to listen to the lies that you told to meThen I would more closely resemble the half a man that you`ve made of me[ guitar - sax ]And if I only had one leg to stand on

Then how much how much truer picture you`d seeAnd then I would more closely resamble the half of man that you`ve made of meYeah then I would more closely resamble the half of man that you`ve made of me

 

I have a friend who is alive and well because he or his doc caught his cancer at just around 18 years of age... now he got the prostetic testi to fill his sack and allow him to look normal... But we were all musician and one day a mutual friend of ours, actually the guy who introduced us to one another came up with a little of a tease of a joke....

 

" Suddenly.... I'm not half the man I used to be..... There's one Gonad hanging off of me, Oh how I long for yesterday.... Why it had to go, I don't know they wouldn't say..... I felt something wrong, now I long for yesterdaaaaaaaaaay.... "  

 

Just thought I'd share a cute if not a bit crude joke... :)

 

 

Posted

So, curious, why did you do the DRE?

BTW, a few years pack I did a DRE on a 42 yo asymptomatic man, who had an irregular prostate.  Referred to Urology, had cancer, underwent radical prostatectomy, tolerated well w/ no incontinence or impotence and is still disease free.  He came by a year or two later and thanked me for saving his life.  Don't get that too much in FP/urgent care.  The USPSTF doesn't recommend DRE routinely, so he'd probably be dead by 50 or 60 if I hadn't ignored their guidelines.

Straz

 

However, what do you do if you detect a hernia?  Because

that can cause more harm than good.  I am assuming the men with testicular

cancer had no symptoms and it was an accidental finding?  

Kathy Saradarian, MDBranchville, NJ

www.qualityfamilypractice.com

Solo 4/03, Practicing since 9/90Practice Partner 5/03

Low staffing 

  

From:

[mailto: ] On Behalf Of

Strazzullo

Sent: Friday, November 12, 2010 11:23 AM

To:

Subject: Re: Question re Hernia Exam

  

The USPSTF not withstanding, it takes about 60-120 seconds to a reasonably

thorough genital exam on an average male, especially if they are partially

disrobed with underpants under gown.  The cost and risks are negligible

and as in most cancers, it's probably better to make an earlier than later

diagnosis.  In 15 years of practice, I've diagnosed at least 2 or 3 men with

testicular cancer that I can recall off the top of my head, so I guess I'm

above average.  It's also pertinent that testicular cancer has a bimodal

distribution with peaks in adolescence and later in life.  Teenage boys

are particularly apt to ignore and be embarrassed by genital sxs, write them

off as being normal development or nothing serious, and not seek care for them.

 

Although I did plenty of gyn and ob in residency, I find

myself referring many women patients to ob/gyn for routine care because I don't

feel all that comfortable with it anymore.

 

Just my 2 cents.

 

Straz

 

 

 

 

Liza,

I think it is helpful to look at

evidence.

The US Preventive Services Task

Force is an amazing resource for this.  For example:

 

In 2004, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force

(USPSTF) recommended against screening for testicular cancer because of its

relative rarity, the lack of evidence showing the accuracy of clinical or self-examination,

and highly favorable outcomes from treatment. Instead, the USPSTF encouraged clinicians to consider testicular cancer in their

differential diagnosis for patients with testicular symptoms (4).

In 2009, the USPSTF decided to update the evidence to reaffirm its previous

recommendation. The goal of this reaffirmation update was to search for new, high-quality

studies with the potential to change the previous recommendation.Although we did not identify any studies that

directly discussed either the benefits or harms of testicular cancer screening,

Carmignani and colleagues (7)

needed to perform ultrasonography on 1320 symptomatic men to find 27 tumors.

Because symptomatic men have a higher pretest probability of cancer than

asymptomatic men, one would expect the number needed to screen to detect 1 case

of testicular cancer to be considerably greater, and the false-positive rate

substantially higher, than those in the study by Carmignani and colleagues.There are some established risk factors for testicular

cancer, such as cryptorchidism and family history of testicular cancer, but

researchers continue to look for new ones. A prospective study of 1,504 healthy

volunteers (8)

found that 84, or approximately 5%, had testicular microlithiasis. After 5

years of follow-up, only 1 participant received a diagnosis of a testicular

germ-cell tumor after discovering a palpable mass on self-examination (9).Although these studies do not directly address the

benefits of screening, they serve as a reminder for primary care clinicians to

consider testicular cancer as part of their differential diagnosis in patients

with testicular or scrotal symptoms. As the USPSTF stated in a previous

recommendation statement (10),

although the average primary care physician may see only 1 patient with

testicular cancer over 20 to 25 years, 26% to 56% of patients with testicular

cancer had an initially incorrect diagnosis of another testicular disorder.In summary, we found no new studies since the 2004

USPSTF recommendation on the benefits or harms of screening for testicular

cancer by testicular self-examination, physician examination, or other

screening tests.

 

At the bottom I'll include the

recommendations for a 31 y male nonsmoker who is sexually active. 

 

There are web and smartphone tools

for these.  I like to use these check lists for my annual wellness exams.

 

To me, this is an incredibly useful

tool, free courtesy of our federal govt. 

 

http://epss.ahrq.gov/PDA/index.jsp

 

 

On a side note, my doc did a rectal

exam at my physical (was 47y) at the time; she said, I know there is no

evidence to do this, but I still always do.  Actually frustrated me quite

a bit....here is the summary of colorectal screening recommendations:

The USPSTF recommends screening for

colorectal cancer using fecal occult blood testing, sigmoidoscopy, or

colonoscopy, in adults, beginning at age 50 years and continuing until age 75

years. The risks and benefits of these screening methods vary. Go to the

Rationale and Clinical Considerations sections for comparisons of the risks and

benefits of different screening regimens, as well as the specific intervals for

different recommended tests.

 

On the website, you can always

click to more details. 

 

I love the Pratts' letter

about harms and benefits.  We as IMPs (and often primary care providers)

should, of all people, understand that concept.  Now, I'll step off the

soapbox.

 

Sharon

 

Here is the summary for the inital

patient in question: 

 

10 - Recommended (A, B)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

A

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents at

Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

A*

High Blood Pressure: Screening -- Adults 18 and

Over

<image002.jpg>

A

Syphilis: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased

Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

B

Alcohol Misuse: Screening and Behavioral Counseling

-- Men, Women, and Pregnant Women

<image002.jpg>

B*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over --

When staff-assisted depression care supports are in place

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

B

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Adults with

Hyperlipidemia and Other Risk Factors for CVD

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

B

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34,

Increased risk for CHD

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

B

Obesity: Screening and Intensive Counseling --

Obese Men and Women

<image002.jpg>

B*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral

Counseling -- Sexually Active Adolescents and Adults at Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

B*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women

-- Sustained BP 135/80+

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

17 - Not Recommended (D)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

D*

Aspirin to Prevent CVD: Men younger than 45 years

of age, to prevent myocardial infarction

<image002.jpg>

D*

Asymptomatic Bacteriuria: Screening -- Men and

Non-Pregnant Women

<image002.jpg>

D

Bladder Cancer: Screening -- Adults

<image002.jpg>

D

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Low

Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

D*

Carotid Artery Stenosis: Screening -- General Adult

Population

<image002.jpg>

D*

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: Screening --

Adults, Using Spirometry

<image002.jpg>

D

Genital Herpes: Screening -- Adolescents and

Adults, Asymptomatic

<image002.jpg>

D

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men and Women at Low Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

D

Hemochromatosis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

<image002.jpg>

D

Hepatitis B: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

<image002.jpg>

D

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

<image002.jpg>

D

Pancreatic Cancer: Screening -- Adults,

Asymptomatic

<image002.jpg>

D

Peripheral Arterial Disease: Screening -- Adults

<image002.jpg>

D

Routine Aspirin or NSAIDs for the Primary Prevention of

Colorectal Cancer: Preventive Medication -- All Adults, Average Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

D

Syphilis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

D

Testicular Cancer: Screening -- Adolescent and

Adult Men

<image002.jpg>

D

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD:

Preventive Medication -- Beta Carotene

<image002.jpg>

 

28 - Uncertain (C, I)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

C*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over --

When staff-assisted depression care supports are not in place

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

C

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents, Not at

Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

C

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34,

Not at increased risk for CHD

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I*

CHD: Risk assessment using non-traditional risk

factors -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

<image002.jpg>

I

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults,

Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Chlamydia: Screening -- Men

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I*

Drug Use - Illicit : Screening -- Adolescent,

Adults, and Pregnant Women

<image002.jpg>

I

Family and Intimate Partner Violence: Screening

<image002.jpg>

I

Glaucoma: Screening -- Adults

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men at Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Unselected Patients,

Primary Care Setting

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Men and Women at

Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Low Back Pain: Counseling -- Adults

<image002.jpg>

I

Lung Cancer: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

<image002.jpg>

I

Obesity: Screening and Counseling at Any Intensity

-- Overweight Men and Women

<image002.jpg>

I

Obesity: Screening and Moderate/Low Intensity

Counseling -- Obese Men and Women

<image002.jpg>

I

Oral Cancer: Screening -- Adults

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Physical Activity: Behavioral Counseling -- Primary

Care Setting

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries:

Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Driving under influence of alcohol or

riding with alcohol-impaired drivers

<image002.jpg>

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries:

Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Proper use of motor vehicle occupant

restraints

<image002.jpg>

I*

Prostate Cancer: Screening -- Men younger than 75

<image002.jpg>

I*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral

Counseling -- Non-sexually-active Adolescents and Adults Not at Increased

Risk

<image002.jpg>

I

Skin Cancer: Counseling by Primary Care Physician

-- Men and Women

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I*

Skin Cancer: Screening - - Men and Women

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Suicide Risk: Screening -- Men and Women

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Thyroid Disease: Screening -- Men and Women

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women

-- BP 135/80 or lower

<image002.jpg>

I

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD:

Preventive Medication -- A, C, E, Multi

<image002.jpg>

 

 

Sharon McCoy MD

Renaissance Family Medicine

10 McClintock Court; Irvine,

CA  92617

PH: (949)387-5504   Fax:

(949)281-2197  Toll free phone/fax: 

www.SharonMD.com

 

 

 

 

CyberDefender has scanned this email for potential threats.

Version 2.0 / Build 4.03.29.01

Get free PC security at http://www.cyberdefender.com

-- Graham Chiuhttp://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR.

Posted

Don't be surprised if the USPSTF comes out with a negative recommendation on

prostate cancer screening soon. I think it's up for review in 2011 or 2012.

The problems is that for every patient " saved " by early diagnosis, there are

many more harmed by over diagnosis. For every 10 patients with prostate cancer,

only one benefits from treatment. So may have saved this patient's life

but he may not have. The patient may have a recurrance and die 8 years from now

which may have been the same life expectancy without treatment. In addition, if

the rectal exam wasn't done, the patient may have developed symptoms soon after

the non-exam and investigation would have resulted in the same diagnosis with

potentially the same outcome.

The other problem with cancer screening is that not all cancers are " bad "

cancers. Some cancers grow way too slowly to cause problems in the patient's

life time. Some cancers grow faster but the person dies from a car accident.

Some cancers actually regress without treatment!! Moreover, we know treatment

is harmful. That's why we have to look at life expectancy outcome studies, not

just disease specifc outcomes.

This is a good read if you can get your hands on the article:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20498425

Counter-intuitively, finding disease is not always good.

Craig

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > Liza,

> >

> > I think it is helpful to look at evidence.

> >

> > The US Preventive Services Task Force is an amazing resource for this. For

example:

> >

> >

> >

> > In 2004, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommended

against screening for testicular cancer because of its relative rarity, the lack

of evidence showing the accuracy of clinical or self-examination, and highly

favorable outcomes from treatment. Instead, the USPSTF encouraged clinicians to

consider testicular cancer in their differential diagnosis for patients with

testicular symptoms (4). In 2009, the USPSTF decided to update the evidence to

reaffirm its previous recommendation. The goal of this reaffirmation update was

to search for new, high-quality studies with the potential to change the

previous recommendation.

> >

> > Although we did not identify any studies that directly discussed either the

benefits or harms of testicular cancer screening, Carmignani and colleagues (7)

needed to perform ultrasonography on 1320 symptomatic men to find 27 tumors.

Because symptomatic men have a higher pretest probability of cancer than

asymptomatic men, one would expect the number needed to screen to detect 1 case

of testicular cancer to be considerably greater, and the false-positive rate

substantially higher, than those in the study by Carmignani and colleagues.

> >

> > There are some established risk factors for testicular cancer, such as

cryptorchidism and family history of testicular cancer, but researchers continue

to look for new ones. A prospective study of 1,504 healthy volunteers (8) found

that 84, or approximately 5%, had testicular microlithiasis. After 5 years of

follow-up, only 1 participant received a diagnosis of a testicular germ-cell

tumor after discovering a palpable mass on self-examination (9).

> >

> > Although these studies do not directly address the benefits of screening,

they serve as a reminder for primary care clinicians to consider testicular

cancer as part of their differential diagnosis in patients with testicular or

scrotal symptoms. As the USPSTF stated in a previous recommendation statement

(10), although the average primary care physician may see only 1 patient with

testicular cancer over 20 to 25 years, 26% to 56% of patients with testicular

cancer had an initially incorrect diagnosis of another testicular disorder.

> >

> > In summary, we found no new studies since the 2004 USPSTF recommendation on

the benefits or harms of screening for testicular cancer by testicular

self-examination, physician examination, or other screening tests.

> >

> >

> >

> > At the bottom I'll include the recommendations for a 31 y male nonsmoker who

is sexually active.

> >

> >

> >

> > There are web and smartphone tools for these. I like to use these check

lists for my annual wellness exams.

> >

> >

> >

> > To me, this is an incredibly useful tool, free courtesy of our federal govt.

> >

> >

> >

> > http://epss.ahrq.gov/PDA/index.jsp

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > On a side note, my doc did a rectal exam at my physical (was 47y) at the

time; she said, I know there is no evidence to do this, but I still always do.

Actually frustrated me quite a bit....here is the summary of colorectal

screening recommendations:

> >

> > The USPSTF recommends screening for colorectal cancer using fecal occult

blood testing, sigmoidoscopy, or colonoscopy, in adults, beginning at age 50

years and continuing until age 75 years. The risks and benefits of these

screening methods vary. Go to the Rationale and Clinical Considerations sections

for comparisons of the risks and benefits of different screening regimens, as

well as the specific intervals for different recommended tests.

> >

> >

> >

> > On the website, you can always click to more details.

> >

> >

> >

> > I love the Pratts' letter about harms and benefits. We as IMPs (and often

primary care providers) should, of all people, understand that concept. Now,

I'll step off the soapbox.

> >

> >

> >

> > Sharon

> >

> >

> >

> > Here is the summary for the inital patient in question:

> >

> >

> >

> > 10 - Recommended (A, B)

> >

> > Grade

> >

> > Title

> >

> > Risk Info.

> >

> > Details

> >

> > A

> >

> > HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents at Increased Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > A*

> >

> > High Blood Pressure: Screening -- Adults 18 and Over

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > A

> >

> > Syphilis: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > B

> >

> > Alcohol Misuse: Screening and Behavioral Counseling -- Men, Women, and

Pregnant Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > B*

> >

> > Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over -- When staff-assisted

depression care supports are in place

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > B

> >

> > Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Adults with Hyperlipidemia and Other Risk

Factors for CVD

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > B

> >

> > Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34, Increased risk for CHD

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > B

> >

> > Obesity: Screening and Intensive Counseling -- Obese Men and Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > B*

> >

> > Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral Counseling -- Sexually Active

Adolescents and Adults at Increased Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > B*

> >

> > Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women -- Sustained BP 135/80+

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > 17 - Not Recommended (D)

> >

> > Grade

> >

> > Title

> >

> > Risk Info.

> >

> > Details

> >

> > D*

> >

> > Aspirin to Prevent CVD: Men younger than 45 years of age, to prevent

myocardial infarction

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D*

> >

> > Asymptomatic Bacteriuria: Screening -- Men and Non-Pregnant Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Bladder Cancer: Screening -- Adults

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Low Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D*

> >

> > Carotid Artery Stenosis: Screening -- General Adult Population

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D*

> >

> > Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: Screening -- Adults, Using Spirometry

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Genital Herpes: Screening -- Adolescents and Adults, Asymptomatic

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men and Women at Low Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Hemochromatosis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Hepatitis B: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Hepatitis C: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Pancreatic Cancer: Screening -- Adults, Asymptomatic

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Peripheral Arterial Disease: Screening -- Adults

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Routine Aspirin or NSAIDs for the Primary Prevention of Colorectal Cancer:

Preventive Medication -- All Adults, Average Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Syphilis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Testicular Cancer: Screening -- Adolescent and Adult Men

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD: Preventive Medication --

Beta Carotene

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> >

> >

> > 28 - Uncertain (C, I)

> >

> > Grade

> >

> > Title

> >

> > Risk Info.

> >

> > Details

> >

> > C*

> >

> > Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over -- When staff-assisted

depression care supports are not in place

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > C

> >

> > HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents, Not at Increased Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > C

> >

> > Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34, Not at increased risk for

CHD

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > CHD: Risk assessment using non-traditional risk factors -- Asymptomatic Men

and Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Increased Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Chlamydia: Screening -- Men

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > Drug Use - Illicit : Screening -- Adolescent, Adults, and Pregnant Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Family and Intimate Partner Violence: Screening

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Glaucoma: Screening -- Adults

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men at Increased Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Unselected Patients, Primary Care Setting

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Hepatitis C: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Low Back Pain: Counseling -- Adults

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Lung Cancer: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Obesity: Screening and Counseling at Any Intensity -- Overweight Men and

Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Obesity: Screening and Moderate/Low Intensity Counseling -- Obese Men and

Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Oral Cancer: Screening -- Adults

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Physical Activity: Behavioral Counseling -- Primary Care Setting

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries: Counseling in Primary Care

Setting -- Driving under influence of alcohol or riding with alcohol-impaired

drivers

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries: Counseling in Primary Care

Setting -- Proper use of motor vehicle occupant restraints

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > Prostate Cancer: Screening -- Men younger than 75

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral Counseling --

Non-sexually-active Adolescents and Adults Not at Increased Risk

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Skin Cancer: Counseling by Primary Care Physician -- Men and Women

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > Skin Cancer: Screening - - Men and Women

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Suicide Risk: Screening -- Men and Women

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Thyroid Disease: Screening -- Men and Women

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women -- BP 135/80 or lower

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD: Preventive Medication --

A, C, E, Multi

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > Sharon McCoy MD

> >

> > Renaissance Family Medicine

> >

> > 10 McClintock Court; Irvine, CA 92617

> >

> > PH: (949)387-5504 Fax: (949)281-2197 Toll free phone/fax:

> >

> > www.SharonMD.com

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > CyberDefender has scanned this email for potential threats.

> > Version 2.0 / Build 4.03.29.01

> > Get free PC security at http://www.cyberdefender.com

> >

> >

> >

>

Posted

Nowhere else but  from IMPs would I get the Beatles and gay guys  coming out  in the 70s , DREs  and USPSTF , and  testicular cancer screening and .chaperoning and Merle Haggard in the context of fabuous medical care

 I mean really you  guys, you warm my heart.Go IMPS!:)

 

Thanks for the songs.  Sharon thanks for the USPS Task Force data.  I obtained records on the pt and he had circumcision as an adult and also had lesions checked by his pcp 4 years ago.  I asked him to come back for me to do a thorough hernia check and also recheck if any recurrence of prior lesions.  So pt will come back for the check.

 

Because we are sharing, here's my attachment to the wonderful Beatles song previously quoted.

 

My best friend in jr and senior high school had a rough year when he was 16. That summer, he wanted to tell me something and was very serious about it, certainly out of character. He told me he was gay (circa 1978). I was a little confused since he had been my first boyfriend several years before. As I sat contemplating this new information, out of the radio came,' I'm not half the man I used to be.' I can remember looking at him, then both of us burst out laughing so hard, we couldn't stop for 10-15 minutes. 30 years later, it is still a running joke between the two of us when something is serendipitous.

Merle Haggard's said it before:  If I only had one arm to hold you well better yet if I had none at allThen I wouldn`t have two arms that ache for you

And I`d have one less mem`ry to recallIf I only had one ear to listen to the lies that you told to meThen I would more closely resemble the half a man that you`ve made of me[ guitar - sax ]And if I only had one leg to stand on

Then how much how much truer picture you`d seeAnd then I would more closely resamble the half of man that you`ve made of meYeah then I would more closely resamble the half of man that you`ve made of me

 

I have a friend who is alive and well because he or his doc caught his cancer at just around 18 years of age... now he got the prostetic testi to fill his sack and allow him to look normal... But we were all musician and one day a mutual friend of ours, actually the guy who introduced us to one another came up with a little of a tease of a joke....

 

" Suddenly.... I'm not half the man I used to be..... There's one Gonad hanging off of me, Oh how I long for yesterday.... Why it had to go, I don't know they wouldn't say..... I felt something wrong, now I long for yesterdaaaaaaaaaay.... "  

 

Just thought I'd share a cute if not a bit crude joke... :)

 

 

-- PATIENTS-please remember  that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical  record and is placed into your  chart ( be careful what you say!)

Email is best used for appointment making and  brief  questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL  if the  matter is more urgent .     MD    

     ph    fax impcenter.org

Posted

I won't be surprised.The USPSTF and I are looking at 2 different things. They are looking at what benefits/harms the average patient and what are the costs to society of attempting to make and treat that diagnosis; and I am looking at what benefits/harms the individual in front of me. You may argue that using average outcomes allows you to generalize to the specific patient, but it really doesn't. It's like Dennis Hopper in Apocolypse Now (that's for you Jean) ranting on about how you can't land on a fraction; either the individual patient you're examining has cancer/hernia/whatever or they haven't, you may look at an 40 yo man and think that only 1 in 50 men his age has even microscopic prostate CA, but if the patient has it the actual odds are 100% and if he doesn't they're 0%. If the patient understands the risks and benefits, the choice of a procedure is up to them, to not allow them to have this choice because the USPSTF, the AMA, or the ACS recommend against looking for a disease that they may have and could shorten their life is ostrich-like. In this specific case, the man was 40, on no medications, nl BMI, in good health basically; sure he may be hit by a bus stepping off a curb leaving his urologist's office, but it's not likely. Would I recommend a 75 yo man with HTN and DM undergo a DRE to screen for prostate CA; probably not, but it's his choice and I'd offer it to him. By the way, I get yearly fu letters from his urologist; it's been 4 or 5 years and he is still cancer free (knock on wood).I believe that as a thorough physician finding disease is always good, because if you know about it you have the choice of treating it or at least preparing for it.I tried to find the article in the abstract and couldn't. But there are an awful lot of "may"s and "most likely"s in the abstract with no hard numbers. I also thought that EBM preferred double-blind, ITT, studies with adequete statistical power, which according to abstract would be impossible to do. Population based data may be totally off as well unless they can point to specific trends of people who were treated for breast and prostate ca dying earlier than people who had the same disease and decided not to be treated for it versus a group of people who never had the disease but are of apparantly the same state of health (and how do you determine that). Maybe the population-based data are skewed because we've turned our world into such a cess pool that we're all slowly dying of toxin exposure or maybe the toxic life style of the average person who develops DM, HTN, etc. and dies ( I think it's about 40 or 50% of the population now) statistically over whelm the small percentage of CA survivors who take care of their health and live far beyond the expected time for untreated cancer. Personally, I don't think we'll ever know.By the way, are you willing to make the logical leap for DM/HTN/heart disease. The only studies on treating these conditions I have seen (I'll admit, I may have missed them) compare treatment to non-treatment of diseased individuals and don't use population based data to see if we are really extending the lives of patients with TZDs, metformin, sulfonylureas. How many of these patients die from CA despite treatment of the DM? And we certainly create increased morbidity and mortality with the drugs such as Troglitazone or Avandia.Straz

Don't be surprised if the USPSTF comes out with a negative recommendation on prostate cancer screening soon. I think it's up for review in 2011 or 2012. The problems is that for every patient "saved" by early diagnosis, there are many more harmed by over diagnosis. For every 10 patients with prostate cancer, only one benefits from treatment. So may have saved this patient's life but he may not have. The patient may have a recurrance and die 8 years from now which may have been the same life expectancy without treatment. In addition, if the rectal exam wasn't done, the patient may have developed symptoms soon after the non-exam and investigation would have resulted in the same diagnosis with potentially the same outcome.

The other problem with cancer screening is that not all cancers are "bad" cancers. Some cancers grow way too slowly to cause problems in the patient's life time. Some cancers grow faster but the person dies from a car accident. Some cancers actually regress without treatment!! Moreover, we know treatment is harmful. That's why we have to look at life expectancy outcome studies, not just disease specifc outcomes.

This is a good read if you can get your hands on the article:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20498425

Counter-intuitively, finding disease is not always good.

Craig

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > Liza,

> >

> > I think it is helpful to look at evidence.

> >

> > The US Preventive Services Task Force is an amazing resource for this. For example:

> >

> >

> >

> > In 2004, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommended against screening for testicular cancer because of its relative rarity, the lack of evidence showing the accuracy of clinical or self-examination, and highly favorable outcomes from treatment. Instead, the USPSTF encouraged clinicians to consider testicular cancer in their differential diagnosis for patients with testicular symptoms (4). In 2009, the USPSTF decided to update the evidence to reaffirm its previous recommendation. The goal of this reaffirmation update was to search for new, high-quality studies with the potential to change the previous recommendation.

> >

> > Although we did not identify any studies that directly discussed either the benefits or harms of testicular cancer screening, Carmignani and colleagues (7) needed to perform ultrasonography on 1320 symptomatic men to find 27 tumors. Because symptomatic men have a higher pretest probability of cancer than asymptomatic men, one would expect the number needed to screen to detect 1 case of testicular cancer to be considerably greater, and the false-positive rate substantially higher, than those in the study by Carmignani and colleagues.

> >

> > There are some established risk factors for testicular cancer, such as cryptorchidism and family history of testicular cancer, but researchers continue to look for new ones. A prospective study of 1,504 healthy volunteers (8) found that 84, or approximately 5%, had testicular microlithiasis. After 5 years of follow-up, only 1 participant received a diagnosis of a testicular germ-cell tumor after discovering a palpable mass on self-examination (9).

> >

> > Although these studies do not directly address the benefits of screening, they serve as a reminder for primary care clinicians to consider testicular cancer as part of their differential diagnosis in patients with testicular or scrotal symptoms. As the USPSTF stated in a previous recommendation statement (10), although the average primary care physician may see only 1 patient with testicular cancer over 20 to 25 years, 26% to 56% of patients with testicular cancer had an initially incorrect diagnosis of another testicular disorder.

> >

> > In summary, we found no new studies since the 2004 USPSTF recommendation on the benefits or harms of screening for testicular cancer by testicular self-examination, physician examination, or other screening tests.

> >

> >

> >

> > At the bottom I'll include the recommendations for a 31 y male nonsmoker who is sexually active.

> >

> >

> >

> > There are web and smartphone tools for these. I like to use these check lists for my annual wellness exams.

> >

> >

> >

> > To me, this is an incredibly useful tool, free courtesy of our federal govt.

> >

> >

> >

> > http://epss.ahrq.gov/PDA/index.jsp

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > On a side note, my doc did a rectal exam at my physical (was 47y) at the time; she said, I know there is no evidence to do this, but I still always do. Actually frustrated me quite a bit....here is the summary of colorectal screening recommendations:

> >

> > The USPSTF recommends screening for colorectal cancer using fecal occult blood testing, sigmoidoscopy, or colonoscopy, in adults, beginning at age 50 years and continuing until age 75 years. The risks and benefits of these screening methods vary. Go to the Rationale and Clinical Considerations sections for comparisons of the risks and benefits of different screening regimens, as well as the specific intervals for different recommended tests.

> >

> >

> >

> > On the website, you can always click to more details.

> >

> >

> >

> > I love the Pratts' letter about harms and benefits. We as IMPs (and often primary care providers) should, of all people, understand that concept. Now, I'll step off the soapbox.

> >

> >

> >

> > Sharon

> >

> >

> >

> > Here is the summary for the inital patient in question:

> >

> >

> >

> > 10 - Recommended (A, B)

> >

> > Grade

> >

> > Title

> >

> > Risk Info.

> >

> > Details

> >

> > A

> >

> > HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents at Increased Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > A*

> >

> > High Blood Pressure: Screening -- Adults 18 and Over

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > A

> >

> > Syphilis: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > B

> >

> > Alcohol Misuse: Screening and Behavioral Counseling -- Men, Women, and Pregnant Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > B*

> >

> > Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over -- When staff-assisted depression care supports are in place

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > B

> >

> > Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Adults with Hyperlipidemia and Other Risk Factors for CVD

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > B

> >

> > Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34, Increased risk for CHD

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > B

> >

> > Obesity: Screening and Intensive Counseling -- Obese Men and Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > B*

> >

> > Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral Counseling -- Sexually Active Adolescents and Adults at Increased Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > B*

> >

> > Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women -- Sustained BP 135/80+

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > 17 - Not Recommended (D)

> >

> > Grade

> >

> > Title

> >

> > Risk Info.

> >

> > Details

> >

> > D*

> >

> > Aspirin to Prevent CVD: Men younger than 45 years of age, to prevent myocardial infarction

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D*

> >

> > Asymptomatic Bacteriuria: Screening -- Men and Non-Pregnant Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Bladder Cancer: Screening -- Adults

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Low Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D*

> >

> > Carotid Artery Stenosis: Screening -- General Adult Population

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D*

> >

> > Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: Screening -- Adults, Using Spirometry

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Genital Herpes: Screening -- Adolescents and Adults, Asymptomatic

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men and Women at Low Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Hemochromatosis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Hepatitis B: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Hepatitis C: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Pancreatic Cancer: Screening -- Adults, Asymptomatic

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Peripheral Arterial Disease: Screening -- Adults

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Routine Aspirin or NSAIDs for the Primary Prevention of Colorectal Cancer: Preventive Medication -- All Adults, Average Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Syphilis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Testicular Cancer: Screening -- Adolescent and Adult Men

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > D

> >

> > Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD: Preventive Medication -- Beta Carotene

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> >

> >

> > 28 - Uncertain (C, I)

> >

> > Grade

> >

> > Title

> >

> > Risk Info.

> >

> > Details

> >

> > C*

> >

> > Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over -- When staff-assisted depression care supports are not in place

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > C

> >

> > HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents, Not at Increased Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > C

> >

> > Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34, Not at increased risk for CHD

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > CHD: Risk assessment using non-traditional risk factors -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Increased Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Chlamydia: Screening -- Men

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > Drug Use - Illicit : Screening -- Adolescent, Adults, and Pregnant Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Family and Intimate Partner Violence: Screening

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Glaucoma: Screening -- Adults

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men at Increased Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Unselected Patients, Primary Care Setting

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Hepatitis C: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased Risk

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Low Back Pain: Counseling -- Adults

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Lung Cancer: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Obesity: Screening and Counseling at Any Intensity -- Overweight Men and Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Obesity: Screening and Moderate/Low Intensity Counseling -- Obese Men and Women

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Oral Cancer: Screening -- Adults

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Physical Activity: Behavioral Counseling -- Primary Care Setting

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries: Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Driving under influence of alcohol or riding with alcohol-impaired drivers

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries: Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Proper use of motor vehicle occupant restraints

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > Prostate Cancer: Screening -- Men younger than 75

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral Counseling -- Non-sexually-active Adolescents and Adults Not at Increased Risk

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Skin Cancer: Counseling by Primary Care Physician -- Men and Women

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > Skin Cancer: Screening - - Men and Women

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Suicide Risk: Screening -- Men and Women

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Thyroid Disease: Screening -- Men and Women

> >

> > <image001.jpg>

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I*

> >

> > Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women -- BP 135/80 or lower

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> > I

> >

> > Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD: Preventive Medication -- A, C, E, Multi

> >

> > <image002.jpg>

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > Sharon McCoy MD

> >

> > Renaissance Family Medicine

> >

> > 10 McClintock Court; Irvine, CA 92617

> >

> > PH: (949)387-5504 Fax: (949)281-2197 Toll free phone/fax:

> >

> > www.SharonMD.com

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > CyberDefender has scanned this email for potential threats.

> > Version 2.0 / Build 4.03.29.01

> > Get free PC security at http://www.cyberdefender.com

> >

> >

> >

>

Posted

Doing a complete physical and because I disagree with USPSTF on this topic.Straz

So, curious, why did you do the DRE?

BTW, a few years pack I did a DRE on a 42 yo asymptomatic man, who had an irregular prostate. Referred to Urology, had cancer, underwent radical prostatectomy, tolerated well w/ no incontinence or impotence and is still disease free. He came by a year or two later and thanked me for saving his life. Don't get that too much in FP/urgent care. The USPSTF doesn't recommend DRE routinely, so he'd probably be dead by 50 or 60 if I hadn't ignored their guidelines.

Straz

However, what do you do if you detect a hernia? Because

that can cause more harm than good. I am assuming the men with testicular

cancer had no symptoms and it was an accidental finding? Kathy Saradarian, MDBranchville, NJwww.qualityfamilypractice.com

Solo 4/03, Practicing since 9/90Practice Partner 5/03Low staffing

From:

[mailto: ] On Behalf Of

Strazzullo

Sent: Friday, November 12, 2010 11:23 AM

To:

Subject: Re: Question re Hernia Exam

The USPSTF not withstanding, it takes about 60-120 seconds to a reasonably

thorough genital exam on an average male, especially if they are partially

disrobed with underpants under gown. The cost and risks are negligible

and as in most cancers, it's probably better to make an earlier than later

diagnosis. In 15 years of practice, I've diagnosed at least 2 or 3 men with

testicular cancer that I can recall off the top of my head, so I guess I'm

above average. It's also pertinent that testicular cancer has a bimodal

distribution with peaks in adolescence and later in life. Teenage boys

are particularly apt to ignore and be embarrassed by genital sxs, write them

off as being normal development or nothing serious, and not seek care for them.

Although I did plenty of gyn and ob in residency, I find

myself referring many women patients to ob/gyn for routine care because I don't

feel all that comfortable with it anymore.

Just my 2 cents.

Straz

Liza,

I think it is helpful to look at

evidence.

The US Preventive Services Task

Force is an amazing resource for this. For example:

In 2004, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force

(USPSTF) recommended against screening for testicular cancer because of its

relative rarity, the lack of evidence showing the accuracy of clinical or self-examination,

and highly favorable outcomes from treatment. Instead, the USPSTF encouraged clinicians to consider testicular cancer in their

differential diagnosis for patients with testicular symptoms (4).

In 2009, the USPSTF decided to update the evidence to reaffirm its previous

recommendation. The goal of this reaffirmation update was to search for new, high-quality

studies with the potential to change the previous recommendation.Although we did not identify any studies that

directly discussed either the benefits or harms of testicular cancer screening,

Carmignani and colleagues (7)

needed to perform ultrasonography on 1320 symptomatic men to find 27 tumors.

Because symptomatic men have a higher pretest probability of cancer than

asymptomatic men, one would expect the number needed to screen to detect 1 case

of testicular cancer to be considerably greater, and the false-positive rate

substantially higher, than those in the study by Carmignani and colleagues.There are some established risk factors for testicular

cancer, such as cryptorchidism and family history of testicular cancer, but

researchers continue to look for new ones. A prospective study of 1,504 healthy

volunteers (8)

found that 84, or approximately 5%, had testicular microlithiasis. After 5

years of follow-up, only 1 participant received a diagnosis of a testicular

germ-cell tumor after discovering a palpable mass on self-examination (9).Although these studies do not directly address the

benefits of screening, they serve as a reminder for primary care clinicians to

consider testicular cancer as part of their differential diagnosis in patients

with testicular or scrotal symptoms. As the USPSTF stated in a previous

recommendation statement (10),

although the average primary care physician may see only 1 patient with

testicular cancer over 20 to 25 years, 26% to 56% of patients with testicular

cancer had an initially incorrect diagnosis of another testicular disorder.In summary, we found no new studies since the 2004

USPSTF recommendation on the benefits or harms of screening for testicular

cancer by testicular self-examination, physician examination, or other

screening tests.

At the bottom I'll include the

recommendations for a 31 y male nonsmoker who is sexually active.

There are web and smartphone tools

for these. I like to use these check lists for my annual wellness exams.

To me, this is an incredibly useful

tool, free courtesy of our federal govt.

http://epss.ahrq.gov/PDA/index.jsp

On a side note, my doc did a rectal

exam at my physical (was 47y) at the time; she said, I know there is no

evidence to do this, but I still always do. Actually frustrated me quite

a bit....here is the summary of colorectal screening recommendations:

The USPSTF recommends screening for

colorectal cancer using fecal occult blood testing, sigmoidoscopy, or

colonoscopy, in adults, beginning at age 50 years and continuing until age 75

years. The risks and benefits of these screening methods vary. Go to the

Rationale and Clinical Considerations sections for comparisons of the risks and

benefits of different screening regimens, as well as the specific intervals for

different recommended tests.

On the website, you can always

click to more details.

I love the Pratts' letter

about harms and benefits. We as IMPs (and often primary care providers)

should, of all people, understand that concept. Now, I'll step off the

soapbox.

Sharon

Here is the summary for the inital

patient in question:

10 - Recommended (A, B)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

A

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents at

Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

A*

High Blood Pressure: Screening -- Adults 18 and

Over

<image002.jpg>

A

Syphilis: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased

Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

B

Alcohol Misuse: Screening and Behavioral Counseling

-- Men, Women, and Pregnant Women

<image002.jpg>

B*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over --

When staff-assisted depression care supports are in place

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

B

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Adults with

Hyperlipidemia and Other Risk Factors for CVD

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

B

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34,

Increased risk for CHD

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

B

Obesity: Screening and Intensive Counseling --

Obese Men and Women

<image002.jpg>

B*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral

Counseling -- Sexually Active Adolescents and Adults at Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

B*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women

-- Sustained BP 135/80+

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

17 - Not Recommended (D)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

D*

Aspirin to Prevent CVD: Men younger than 45 years

of age, to prevent myocardial infarction

<image002.jpg>

D*

Asymptomatic Bacteriuria: Screening -- Men and

Non-Pregnant Women

<image002.jpg>

D

Bladder Cancer: Screening -- Adults

<image002.jpg>

D

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Low

Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

D*

Carotid Artery Stenosis: Screening -- General Adult

Population

<image002.jpg>

D*

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: Screening --

Adults, Using Spirometry

<image002.jpg>

D

Genital Herpes: Screening -- Adolescents and

Adults, Asymptomatic

<image002.jpg>

D

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men and Women at Low Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

D

Hemochromatosis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

<image002.jpg>

D

Hepatitis B: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

<image002.jpg>

D

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

<image002.jpg>

D

Pancreatic Cancer: Screening -- Adults,

Asymptomatic

<image002.jpg>

D

Peripheral Arterial Disease: Screening -- Adults

<image002.jpg>

D

Routine Aspirin or NSAIDs for the Primary Prevention of

Colorectal Cancer: Preventive Medication -- All Adults, Average Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

D

Syphilis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

D

Testicular Cancer: Screening -- Adolescent and

Adult Men

<image002.jpg>

D

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD:

Preventive Medication -- Beta Carotene

<image002.jpg>

28 - Uncertain (C, I)

Grade

Title

Risk Info.

Details

C*

Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over --

When staff-assisted depression care supports are not in place

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

C

HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents, Not at

Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

C

Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34,

Not at increased risk for CHD

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I*

CHD: Risk assessment using non-traditional risk

factors -- Asymptomatic Men and Women

<image002.jpg>

I

CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults,

Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Chlamydia: Screening -- Men

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I*

Drug Use - Illicit : Screening -- Adolescent,

Adults, and Pregnant Women

<image002.jpg>

I

Family and Intimate Partner Violence: Screening

<image002.jpg>

I

Glaucoma: Screening -- Adults

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men at Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Unselected Patients,

Primary Care Setting

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Hepatitis C: Screening -- Men and Women at

Increased Risk

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Low Back Pain: Counseling -- Adults

<image002.jpg>

I

Lung Cancer: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and

Women

<image002.jpg>

I

Obesity: Screening and Counseling at Any Intensity

-- Overweight Men and Women

<image002.jpg>

I

Obesity: Screening and Moderate/Low Intensity

Counseling -- Obese Men and Women

<image002.jpg>

I

Oral Cancer: Screening -- Adults

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Physical Activity: Behavioral Counseling -- Primary

Care Setting

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries:

Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Driving under influence of alcohol or

riding with alcohol-impaired drivers

<image002.jpg>

I*

Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries:

Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Proper use of motor vehicle occupant

restraints

<image002.jpg>

I*

Prostate Cancer: Screening -- Men younger than 75

<image002.jpg>

I*

Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral

Counseling -- Non-sexually-active Adolescents and Adults Not at Increased

Risk

<image002.jpg>

I

Skin Cancer: Counseling by Primary Care Physician

-- Men and Women

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I*

Skin Cancer: Screening - - Men and Women

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Suicide Risk: Screening -- Men and Women

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I

Thyroid Disease: Screening -- Men and Women

<image001.jpg>

<image002.jpg>

I*

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women

-- BP 135/80 or lower

<image002.jpg>

I

Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD:

Preventive Medication -- A, C, E, Multi

<image002.jpg>

Sharon McCoy MD

Renaissance Family Medicine

10 McClintock Court; Irvine,

CA 92617

PH: (949)387-5504 Fax:

(949)281-2197 Toll free phone/fax:

www.SharonMD.com

CyberDefender has scanned this email for potential threats.

Version 2.0 / Build 4.03.29.01

Get free PC security at http://www.cyberdefender.com

-- Graham Chiuhttp://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR.

Posted

I strongly agree with you. Using statistical data to understand the risk is very helpful, but it is the patient, with sufficient "informed" consent, that should decide the issue. It isn't my health care -- it's the patient's health care.

In my first nurse practitioner job 10 years ago, I was working in a GI group seeing patients for a variety of the milder GI illnesses and for pre-colonoscopy physicals. It was early in the movement away from flex-sig to colonoscopy. I had an 80-year-old man come in and ask for a colonoscopy. He was very well-educated, in terrific shape, no chronic illness, still running every day and playing golf, and he'd been reading about the differences between the various screening procedures and had decided on a colonoscopy. At that time, the doctors in the group required me to go to one of them (assigned daily) and get approval for the plan. I presented this man to the managing partner, who refused to do the colonoscopy, saying an 80-year-old didn't need it because he wasn't going to live long enough to benefit from it. I disagreed, and despite my description of the man's robust health, he was adamant. Feeling very unhappy about this, I went to one of the other partners, who readily agreed to the test. The managing partner discovered this, was very angry, and threatened to fire me. We closed the door and had a good talk, and I explained that statistics are one thing, but the person sitting in front of you is another. I asked, "If you were 80, and looked and felt like you do now at 55, and I told you that you couldn't have a screening test you felt was necessary, wouldn't you feel betrayed, discriminated against?" He finally agreed -- and agreed to trust my judgment -- and could see that I was advocating for the patient.

The other side is also true -- having worked in the ICU for years, I've helped many families see that the continued use of expensive, elaborate, and painful medical technology to maintain a life that is miserable and unlikely to progress back to health is futile and a form of torture. Well-informed patients almost always make the correct decision.

Deanna Tolman, FNP

I won't be surprised.

The USPSTF and I are looking at 2 different things. They are looking at what benefits/harms the average patient and what are the costs to society of attempting to make and treat that diagnosis; and I am looking at what benefits/harms the individual in front of me. You may argue that using average outcomes allows you to generalize to the specific patient, but it really doesn't. It's like Dennis Hopper in Apocolypse Now (that's for you Jean) ranting on about how you can't land on a fraction; either the individual patient you're examining has cancer/hernia/whatever or they haven't, you may look at an 40 yo man and think that only 1 in 50 men his age has even microscopic prostate CA, but if the patient has it the actual odds are 100% and if he doesn't they're 0%. If the patient understands the risks and benefits, the choice of a procedure is up to them, to not allow them to have t his choice because the USPSTF, the AMA, or the ACS recommend against looking for a disease that they may have and could shorten their life is ostrich-like. In this specific case, the man was 40, on no medications, nl BMI, in good health basically; sure he may be hit by a bus stepping off a curb leaving his urologist's office, but it's not likely. Would I recommend a 75 yo man with HTN and DM undergo a DRE to screen for prostate CA; probably not, but it's his choice and I'd offer it to him. By the way, I get yearly fu letters from his urologist; it's been 4 or 5 years and he is still cancer free (knock on wood).

I believe that as a thorough physician finding disease is always good, because if you know about it you have the choice of treating it or at least preparing for it.

I tried to find the article in the abstract and couldn't. But there are an awful lot of "may"s and "most likely"s in the abstr act with no hard numbers. I also thought that EBM preferred double-blind, ITT, studies with adequete statistical power, which according to abstract would be impossible to do. Population based data may be totally off as well unless they can point to specific trends of people who were treated for breast and prostate ca dying earlier than people who had the same disease and decided not to be treated for it versus a group of people who never had the disease but are of apparantly the same state of health (and how do you determine that). Maybe the population-based data are skewed because we've turned our world into such a cess pool that we're all slowly dying of toxin exposure or maybe the toxic life style of the average person who develops DM, HTN, etc. and dies ( I think it's about 40 or 50% of the population now) statistically over whelm the small percentage of CA survivors who take care of their health and live far beyond the expected time for untreated cancer. Personally, I don't think we'll ever know.

By the way, are you willing to make the logical leap for DM/HTN/heart disease. The only studies on treating these conditions I have seen (I'll admit, I may have missed them) compare treatment to non-treatment of diseased individuals and don't use population based data to see if we are really extending the lives of patients with TZDs, metformin, sulfonylureas. How many of these patients die from CA despite treatment of the DM? And we certainly create increased morbidity and mortality with the drugs such as Troglitazone or Avandia.

Straz

Don't be surprised if the USPSTF comes out with a negative recommendation on prostate cancer screening soon. I think it's up for review in 2011 or 2012. The problems is that for every patient "saved" by early diagnosis, there are many more harmed by over diagnosis. For every 10 patients with prostate cancer, only one benefits from treatment. So may have saved this patient's life but he may not have. The patient may have a recurrance and die 8 years from now which may have been the same life expectancy without treatment. In addition, if the rectal exam wasn't done, the patient may have developed symptoms soon after the non-exam and investigation would have resulted in the same diagnosis with potentially the same outcome.The other problem with cancer screening is that not all cancers are "bad" cancers. Some cancers grow way too slowly to cause problems in the patient's life time. Some cancers grow faster but the person dies from a car accident. Some cancers actually regress without treatment!! Moreover, we know treatment is harmful. That's why we have to look at life expectancy outcome studies, not just disease specifc outcomes. This is a good read if you can get your hands on the article:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20498425Counter-intuitively, finding disease is not always good.Craig> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Liza,> > > > I think it is helpful to look at evidence.> > > > The US Preventive Services Task Force is an amazing resource for this. For example:> > > > > > > > In 2004, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommended against screening for testicular cancer because of its relative rarity, the lack of evidence showing the accuracy of clinical or self-examination, and highly favorable outcomes from treatment. Instead, the USPSTF encouraged clinicians to consider testicular cancer in their differential diagnosis for patients with testicular symptoms (4). In 2009, the USPSTF decided to update the evidence to reaffirm its previous recommendation. The goal of this reaffirmation update was to search for new, high-quality studies with the potential to change the previous recommendation.> > > > Although we did not identify any studies that directly discussed either the benefits or harms of testicular cancer screening, Carmignani and colleagues (7) needed to perform ultrasonography on 1320 symptomatic men to find 27 tumors. Because symptomatic men have a higher pretest probability of cancer than asymptomatic men, one would expect the number needed to screen to detect 1 case of testicular cancer to be considerably greater, and the false-positive rate substantially higher, than those in the study by Carmignani and colleagues.> > > > There are some established risk factors for testicular cancer, such as cryptorchidism and family history of testicular cancer, but researchers continue to look for new ones. A prospective study of 1,504 healthy volunteers (8) found that 84, or approximately 5%, had testicular microlithiasis. After 5 years of follow-up, only 1 participant received a diagnosis of a testicular germ-cell tumor after discovering a palpable mass on self-examination (9).> > > > Although these studies do not directly address the benefits of screening, they serve as a reminder for primary care clinicians to consider testicular cancer as part of their differential diagnosis in patients with testicular or scrotal symptoms. As the USPSTF stated in a previous recommendation statement (10), although the average primary care physician may see only 1 patient with testicular cancer over 20 to 25 years, 26% to 56% of patients with testicular cancer had an initially incorrect diagnosis of another testicular disorder.> > > > In summary, we found no new studies since the 2004 USPSTF recommendation on the benefits or harms of screening for testicular cancer by testicular self-examination, physician examination, or other screening tests.> > > > > > > > At the bottom I'll include the recommendations for a 31 y male nonsmoker who is sexually active. > > > > > > > > There are web and smartphone tools for these. I like to use these check lists for my annual wellness exams.> > > > > > > > To me, this is an incredibly useful tool, free courtesy of our federal govt. > > > > > > > > http://epss.ahrq.gov/PDA/index.jsp> > > > > > > > > > > > On a side note, my doc did a rectal exam at my physical (was 47y) at the time; she said, I know there is no evidence to do this, but I still always do. Actually frustrated me quite a bit....here is the summary of colorectal screening recommendations:> > > > The USPSTF recommends screening for colorectal cancer using fecal occult blood testing, sigmoidoscopy, or colonoscopy, in adults, beginning at age 50 years and continuing until age 75 years. The risks and benefits of these screening methods vary. Go to the Rationale and Clinical Considerations sections for comparisons of the risks and benefits of different screening regimens, as well as the specific intervals for different recommended tests.> > > > > > > > On the website, you can always click to more details. > > > > > > > > I love the Pratts' letter about harms and benefits. We as IMPs (and often primary care providers) should, of all people, understand that concept. Now, I'll step off the soapbox.> > > > > > > > Sharon> > > > > > > > Here is the summary for the inital patient in question: > > > > > > > > 10 - Recommended (A, B)> > > > Grade> > > > Title> > > > Risk Info.> > > > Details> > > > A> > > > HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents at Increased Risk> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > A*> > > > High Blood Pressure: Screening -- Adults 18 and Over> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > A> > > > Syphilis: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased Risk> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > B> > > > Alcohol Misuse: Screening and Behavioral Counseling -- Men, Women, and Pregnant Women> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > B*> > > > Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over -- When staff-assisted depression care supports are in place> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > B> > > > Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Adults with Hyperlipidemia and Other Risk Factors for CVD> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > B> > > > Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34, Increased risk for CHD> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > B> > > > Obesity: Screening and Intensive Counseling -- Obese Men and Women> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > B*> > > > Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral Counseling -- Sexually Active Adolescents and Adults at Increased Risk> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > B*> > > > Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women -- Sustained BP 135/80+> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > 17 - Not Recommended (D)> > > > Grade> > > > Title> > > > Risk Info.> > > > Details> > > > D*> > > > Aspirin to Prevent CVD: Men younger than 45 years of age, to prevent myocardial infarction> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D*> > > > Asymptomatic Bacteriuria: Screening -- Men and Non-Pregnant Women> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D> > > > Bladder Cancer: Screening -- Adults> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D> > > > CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Low Risk> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D*> > > > Carotid Artery Stenosis: Screening -- General Adult Population> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D*> > > > Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: Screening -- Adults, Using Spirometry> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D> > > > Genital Herpes: Screening -- Adolescents and Adults, Asymptomatic> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D> > > > Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men and Women at Low Risk> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D> > > > Hemochromatosis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D> > > > Hepatitis B: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D> > > > Hepatitis C: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D> > > > Pancreatic Cancer: Screening -- Adults, Asymptomatic> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D> > > > Peripheral Arterial Disease: Screening -- Adults> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D> > > > Routine Aspirin or NSAIDs for the Primary Prevention of Colorectal Cancer: Preventive Medication -- All Adults, Average Risk> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D> > > > Syphilis: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D> > > > Testicular Cancer: Screening -- Adolescent and Adult Men> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > D> > > > Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD: Preventive Medication -- Beta Carotene> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > > > > > 28 - Uncertain (C, I)> > > > Grade> > > > Title> > > > Risk Info.> > > > Details> > > > C*> > > > Depression: Screening -- Adults age 18 and over -- When staff-assisted depression care supports are not in place> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > C> > > > HIV: Screening -- Adults and Adolescents, Not at Increased Risk> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > C> > > > Lipid Disorders in Adults: Screening -- Men 20-34, Not at increased risk for CHD> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I*> > > > CHD: Risk assessment using non-traditional risk factors -- Asymptomatic Men and Women> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > CHD: Screening Using ECG, ETT, EBCT -- Adults, Increased Risk> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Chlamydia: Screening -- Men> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I*> > > > Drug Use - Illicit : Screening -- Adolescent, Adults, and Pregnant Women> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Family and Intimate Partner Violence: Screening> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Glaucoma: Screening -- Adults> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Gonorrhea: Screening -- Men at Increased Risk> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Healthy Diet: Counseling -- Unselected Patients, Primary Care Setting> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Hepatitis C: Screening -- Men and Women at Increased Risk> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Low Back Pain: Counseling -- Adults> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Lung Cancer: Screening -- Asymptomatic Men and Women> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Obesity: Screening and Counseling at Any Intensity -- Overweight Men and Women> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Obesity: Screening and Moderate/Low Intensity Counseling -- Obese Men and Women> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Oral Cancer: Screening -- Adults> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Physical Activity: Behavioral Counseling -- Primary Care Setting> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I*> > > > Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries: Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Driving under influence of alcohol or riding with alcohol-impaired drivers> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I*> > > > Prevention of Motor Vehicle Occupant Injuries: Counseling in Primary Care Setting -- Proper use of motor vehicle occupant restraints> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I*> > > > Prostate Cancer: Screening -- Men younger than 75> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I*> > > > Sexually Transmitted Infections: Behavioral Counseling -- Non-sexually-active Adolescents and Adults Not at Increased Risk> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Skin Cancer: Counseling by Primary Care Physician -- Men and Women> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I*> > > > Skin Cancer: Screening - - Men and Women> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Suicide Risk: Screening -- Men and Women> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Thyroid Disease: Screening -- Men and Women> > > > <image001.jpg>> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I*> > > > Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Screening Men and Women -- BP 135/80 or lower> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > I> > > > Vitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and CVD: Preventive Medication -- A, C, E, Multi> > > > <image002.jpg>> > > > > > > > > > > > Sharon McCoy MD> > > > Renaissance Family Medicine> > > > 10 McClintock Court; Irvine, CA 92617> > > > PH: (949)387-5504 Fax: (949)281-2197 Toll free phone/fax: > > > > www.SharonMD.com> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > CyberDefender has scanned this email for potential threats.> > Version 2.0 / Build 4.03.29.01> > Get free PC security at http://www.cyberdefender.com> > > > > >>

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...