Guest guest Posted July 18, 2010 Report Posted July 18, 2010 Our practice is 5 years old. So we still are paying on start-up loans, which makes the % higher. Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd.info From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Dr. Nwaizuzu Sent: Saturday, July 17, 2010 9:52 AM To: Subject: Re: What's your percent overhead? At the early stages of a practice over heads may be 100% of total receipts. And the figures might get better as the practice ages.So I will suggest it will make more sense if we could also factor in the age of the practice. Like total receipt/overhead/age of practice From: Pratt <karen.oaktreecomcast (DOT) net> To: Sent: Sat, July 17, 2010 12:22:16 PM Subject: RE: What's your percent overhead? To make the math simple, I took what we paid Steve plus what the business net income is to calculate total income. Divide that by the total receipts and that is our taxable income for the year. 43% for Q1 & Q2 2010, which calculates our overhead at 57%. If I add health insurance and vehicle expense, total income (including benefits) is 47%, putting overhead at 53%. For 2009, our income + benefits was 54%, overhead was 46%. But these numbers all include income that comes from research, which also offsets some of our high rent, so I felt that we should include it. Without research, we would require a tenant so that our rent would be offset somewhat. Otherwise, our rent is our biggest expense at 24% of receipts. With the offset of a tenant (currently research, which also brings in income), it cuts the rent expense in half. Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd. info Quote
Guest guest Posted July 19, 2010 Report Posted July 19, 2010 Matt, No use your revenue the income line off of you profit and loss statement, that ill bring your accounts into line. Also you need to leave out the outside income that is not supported by these expenses. You can run them both ways to see where you are, but if you include this it will comtaminate IMP data. ________________________________________ From: [ ] On Behalf Of Pratt [karen.oaktree@...] Sent: Saturday, July 17, 2010 9:10 AM To: Subject: RE: What's your percent overhead? Matt, I’m going to try to run these numbers this weekend when I’ve had enough coffee. I am not going to include Steve’s moonlighting income. That does not flow through the practice at all. I’m considering whether or not to include the research income. I think it makes the best comparison if we are all only comparing direct patient care. Perhaps I’ll run it both ways. Might be interesting information to learn anyways. Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd.info<http://www.prattmd.info> ________________________________ From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Dr Levin Sent: Friday, July 16, 2010 6:18 PM To: Subject: Re: What's your percent overhead?  OK so if I include all of these categories as my numerator, you're telling me the " denominator " should be my charges? I collect 85% of my charges. During the day, I also take an hourly rate 2 mornings a week, and also have a retainer fee for some outside work. Would these also be income? Sounds like they're not part of the charges so don't count. I'd like to see what others think. Matt in Western PA IMP employee / provider question > > > > > > Hello all -- > > I am working 4 days a week right now, and have the opportunity to employ a > like-minded ARNP and mommy who only wants to work the other 2 days a week. I > rent my clinic space 7 days a week and would love to be open on Saturdays, > so this seems to make sense. I want to be fair about giving her a percentage > of her collections but the only formula I have is the one from when I was a > partner (Monthly clinic revenue - expenses X percentage of charges). Since > my sweaty equity is in the clinic and she really just wants to show up and > work, this will leave many admin duties to me (billing done by husband). Any > ideas? Is Don out there with a formula for me? > > a Garrido, ARNP > <http://www.villagefamilyclinic.com> www.villagefamilyclinic.com<http://www.villagefamilyclinic.com><http://www.villa\ gefamilyclinic.com> > -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!) Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org<http://impcenter.org> Quote
Guest guest Posted July 19, 2010 Report Posted July 19, 2010 , Use the total income figure as your demoninator as long as it does not include outside revenue. No need to do all the math. Use the income line from your software. Health insurance is a benefit to you, and is not an expense, dont't include it. I know the other income supports your rent, but we would really like to know what % of the IMP practice is the rent costing. It is important for you to know what research or a tenant does to your expenses, but if we were to publish the data, this would be more appropriate for a footnote, otherwise the data is contaminated Jim ________________________________________ From: [ ] On Behalf Of Pratt [karen.oaktree@...] Sent: Saturday, July 17, 2010 10:22 AM To: Subject: RE: What's your percent overhead? To make the math simple, I took what we paid Steve plus what the business net income is to calculate total income. Divide that by the total receipts and that is our taxable income for the year. 43% for Q1 & Q2 2010, which calculates our overhead at 57%. If I add health insurance and vehicle expense, total income (including benefits) is 47%, putting overhead at 53%. For 2009, our income + benefits was 54%, overhead was 46%. But these numbers all include income that comes from research, which also offsets some of our high rent, so I felt that we should include it. Without research, we would require a tenant so that our rent would be offset somewhat. Otherwise, our rent is our biggest expense at 24% of receipts. With the offset of a tenant (currently research, which also brings in income), it cuts the rent expense in half. Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd.info<http://www.prattmd.info> Quote
Guest guest Posted July 19, 2010 Report Posted July 19, 2010 This is true in all industries and businesses. Do the numbers the same way, we can pick a time frame for a grid that would show building practices from mature> I would think somewhere in the 3-5 year range. Then we can show that a building IMP practice should have expenses of X% while a mature practice should be looking at Y%. This gives us a industry benchmark. If we manipulate the data, it is useless. ________________________________________ From: [ ] On Behalf Of Dr. Nwaizuzu [familydocta@...] Sent: Saturday, July 17, 2010 10:52 AM To: Subject: Re: What's your percent overhead? At the early stages of a practice over heads may be 100% of total receipts. And the figures might get better as the practice ages.So I will suggest it will make more sense if we could also factor in the age of the practice. Like total receipt/overhead/age of practice ________________________________ To: Sent: Sat, July 17, 2010 12:22:16 PM Subject: RE: What's your percent overhead? To make the math simple, I took what we paid Steve plus what the business net income is to calculate total income. Divide that by the total receipts and that is our taxable income for the year. 43% for Q1 & Q2 2010, which calculates our overhead at 57%. If I add health insurance and vehicle expense, total income (including benefits) is 47%, putting overhead at 53%. For 2009, our income + benefits was 54%, overhead was 46%. But these numbers all include income that comes from research, which also offsets some of our high rent, so I felt that we should include it. Without research, we would require a tenant so that our rent would be offset somewhat. Otherwise, our rent is our biggest expense at 24% of receipts. With the offset of a tenant (currently research, which also brings in income), it cuts the rent expense in half. Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd. info<http://www.prattmd.info/> Quote
Guest guest Posted July 20, 2010 Report Posted July 20, 2010 From Fam Pract Manag. 2002 Nov-Dec;9(10):78. http://www.aafp.org/fpm/2002/1100/p78.html#fpm20021100p78-sa2 Acceptable overhead Q In terms of practice overhead, what is considered acceptable and unacceptable? I'm about to start looking for a practice to join and would like to know how much of a practice's revenue should go toward overhead. A Knowing a practice's overhead can help you monitor trends in expenses, but there is no litmus test for deciding whether the number is reasonable. Before you sign a contract, it may be more useful to ask what the other physicians earn rather than what their overhead is. Would you prefer to work in a practice with 40 percent overhead and earn $100,000 or a practice with 60 percent overhead and earn $200,000? Obviously, the bottom line is more important. That said, you may still be interested in some ballpark overhead figures. Practice overhead (which usually includes nonphysician employment costs, occupancy costs, supplies, professional liability insurance and phone and answering-service expenses) generally runs from 40 percent to 60 percent of the practice's total revenue. In terms of dollars, $80,000 of overhead per physician is pretty typical, but this number can vary greatly. For example, having a midlevel provider in the practice would increase the overhead, but the income generated by this provider would also increase the bottom line. F. Arnow, CPA, CFP*ADB & Associates Glendale, Wis.There is also some information in this article,http://www.aafp.org/fpm/990700fm/42.html#overheadThanks, Andy  I have thinking about this. Traditionally and by the data published by the AAFP on % of overhead, it has been done by charges. However, for this group with such diverse payments and fee schedules, it would make more sense to use % of receipts. I have no issue with that, and if we could report %'s not totals if that is " safer. " The definition of overhead is basically all costs that you need to keep your business running. All costs found on the income statement except for direct labor, direct materials, and costs attributable to outside subcontractors that can be billed directly to a customer’s account. " Overhead expenses are absorbed by the business and factored into the selling price as a percentage of the direct labor cost. They include indirect costs such as accounting, advertising, depreciation, indirect labor, insurance, interest, legal fees, rent, repairs, supplies, taxes, telephone, travel, and utilities. " These include fixed and variable expenses, but do not include salary or benefits directly paid to principals. Most of the medical expense literature that I have seen, do include malpractice insurance, but not health or disability, since these are benefits, and of course do not include salary or bonus payments. If you use quickbooks, it will calculate these for you.If you leave anything out, you will give a bogus view of your practice, but we could break it into fewer categories; Rent (+CAMS) Supplies (office, postage and Medical) Malpractice and business insurance Loan interest Taxes Computer expenses Telephone Cleaning Fees and Dues (including Journals and books) Contributions Travel and CME Contract labor (employees) Other (lump all others in here)  I am not locked into the categories, just took my material ones. I guess I am a splitter not a lumper. This would compare apples to apples. I can go either way on including outside revenue, but if we are truly trying to compare our practices, it would seem leaving out all income that is earned elsewhere makes more sense. If we are trying to compare our total livlihood, then we should include it. Since many of us, do not have outside income, I would leave it out, but anyone could report it both ways..I think if we did this, we would create an " industry standard " which would be helpful to all of us.     From: [ ] On Behalf Of Pratt [karen.oaktree@...] Sent: Tuesday, July 13, 2010 6:57 PM To: Subject: RE: What's your percent overhead?  This is why it’s comparing apples to oranges. Health insurance, cell phones, and Steve’s car expenses are all part of “a†in my calculations because they are paid by the business. “B†in my book is only our salary and the profit from the business. At least we’re calculating “c†the same J  Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd.info From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sent: Tuesday, July 13, 2010 5:37 PM To: Subject: Re: What's your percent overhead?   My overhead is everything I bring in that must be paid A a real number say $30,000. I get to take home ( and pay health isnuracne etcetcetc from what is left over.) B another real number  say 70.000. C is everything I brought in-- (A +B =C)   c= 100,000 and A as a percent of C is the percetn overhead number. A= 30% here.  My overhead is calculated as a % of receipts.  Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd.info From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Dr Levin Sent: Tuesday, July 13, 2010 4:42 PM To: Subject: Re: What's your percent overhead?     So overhead is % of " charges'? But my collections on most charges are 85%, and my moonlighting is paid hourly without charges-- how does that work? IMP employee / provider question > > > > > > Hello all -- > > I am working 4 days a week right now, and have the opportunity to employ a > like-minded ARNP and mommy who only wants to work the other 2 days a week. I > rent my clinic space 7 days a week and would love to be open on Saturdays, > so this seems to make sense. I want to be fair about giving her a percentage > of her collections but the only formula I have is the one from when I was a > partner (Monthly clinic revenue - expenses X percentage of charges). Since > my sweaty equity is in the clinic and she really just wants to show up and > work, this will leave many admin duties to me (billing done by husband). Any > ideas? Is Don out there with a formula for me? > > a Garrido, ARNP > <http://www.villagefamilyclinic.com> www.villagefamilyclinic.com<http://www.villagefamilyclinic.com> > -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!) Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent .    MD       ph   fax impcenter.org Quote
Guest guest Posted July 20, 2010 Report Posted July 20, 2010 I have been following along on this discussion of what constitutes overhead. Then, I remembered I have a spreadsheet we could use (or adapt) from my participation with the National Demonstration Project.  I know many of you think “TransforMed†is a dirty word, but regardless, I am attaching a blank spreadsheet that we used as participating practices.  This did help (though I hear some practices were not so willing to provide their data) the researchers compare “apples to applesâ€. It looks complex, but seems to capture most of the elements we have been discussing.  Perhaps, someone more financially savvy than I can re-work the headings to be more IMP-friendly. It is attached. Ramona Ramona G. Seidel, MD www.baycrossingfamilymedicine.com Your Bridge to Health 269 Peninsula Farm Road Suite F Arnold, MD 21012 410 518-9808 From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Andy Barr Sent: Tuesday, July 20, 2010 6:43 AM To: Subject: Re: What's your percent overhead? From Fam Pract Manag. 2002 Nov-Dec;9(10):78. http://www.aafp.org/fpm/2002/1100/p78.html#fpm20021100p78-sa2 Acceptable overhead Q In terms of practice overhead, what is considered acceptable and unacceptable? I'm about to start looking for a practice to join and would like to know how much of a practice's revenue should go toward overhead. A Knowing a practice's overhead can help you monitor trends in expenses, but there is no litmus test for deciding whether the number is reasonable. Before you sign a contract, it may be more useful to ask what the other physicians earn rather than what their overhead is. Would you prefer to work in a practice with 40 percent overhead and earn $100,000 or a practice with 60 percent overhead and earn $200,000? Obviously, the bottom line is more important. That said, you may still be interested in some ballpark overhead figures. Practice overhead (which usually includes nonphysician employment costs, occupancy costs, supplies, professional liability insurance and phone and answering-service expenses) generally runs from 40 percent to 60 percent of the practice's total revenue. In terms of dollars, $80,000 of overhead per physician is pretty typical, but this number can vary greatly. For example, having a midlevel provider in the practice would increase the overhead, but the income generated by this provider would also increase the bottom line. F. Arnow, CPA, CFP* ADB & Associates Glendale, Wis. There is also some information in this article, http://www.aafp.org/fpm/990700fm/42.html#overhead Thanks, Andy On Fri, Jul 16, 2010 at 7:04 PM, Kennedy, Jim <jim.kennedyucdenver (DOT) edu> wrote: I have thinking about this. Traditionally and by the data published by the AAFP on % of overhead, it has been done by charges. However, for this group with such diverse payments and fee schedules, it would make more sense to use % of receipts. I have no issue with that, and if we could report %'s not totals if that is " safer. " The definition of overhead is basically all costs that you need to keep your business running. All costs found on the income statement except for direct labor, direct materials, and costs attributable to outside subcontractors that can be billed directly to a customer’s account. " Overhead expenses are absorbed by the business and factored into the selling price as a percentage of the direct labor cost. They include indirect costs such as accounting, advertising, depreciation, indirect labor, insurance, interest, legal fees, rent, repairs, supplies, taxes, telephone, travel, and utilities. " These include fixed and variable expenses, but do not include salary or benefits directly paid to principals. Most of the medical expense literature that I have seen, do include malpractice insurance, but not health or disability, since these are benefits, and of course do not include salary or bonus payments. If you use quickbooks, it will calculate these for you.If you leave anything out, you will give a bogus view of your practice, but we could break it into fewer categories; Rent (+CAMS) Supplies (office, postage and Medical) Malpractice and business insurance Loan interest Taxes Computer expenses Telephone Cleaning Fees and Dues (including Journals and books) Contributions Travel and CME Contract labor (employees) Other (lump all others in here) I am not locked into the categories, just took my material ones. I guess I am a splitter not a lumper. This would compare apples to apples. I can go either way on including outside revenue, but if we are truly trying to compare our practices, it would seem leaving out all income that is earned elsewhere makes more sense. If we are trying to compare our total livlihood, then we should include it. Since many of us, do not have outside income, I would leave it out, but anyone could report it both ways..I think if we did this, we would create an " industry standard " which would be helpful to all of us. From: [ ] On Behalf Of Pratt [karen.oaktreecomcast (DOT) net] Sent: Tuesday, July 13, 2010 6:57 PM To: Subject: RE: What's your percent overhead? This is why it’s comparing apples to oranges. Health insurance, cell phones, and Steve’s car expenses are all part of “a†in my calculations because they are paid by the business. “B†in my book is only our salary and the profit from the business. At least we’re calculating “c†the same J Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd.info From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Sent: Tuesday, July 13, 2010 5:37 PM To: Subject: Re: What's your percent overhead? My overhead is everything I bring in that must be paid A a real number say $30,000. I get to take home ( and pay health isnuracne etcetcetc from what is left over.) B another real number say 70.000. C is everything I brought in-- (A +B =C) c= 100,000 and A as a percent of C is the percetn overhead number. A= 30% here. On Tue, Jul 13, 2010 at 8:22 PM, Pratt <karen.oaktreecomcast (DOT) net> wrote: My overhead is calculated as a % of receipts. Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd.info From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Dr Levin Sent: Tuesday, July 13, 2010 4:42 PM To: Subject: Re: What's your percent overhead?  So overhead is % of " charges'? But my collections on most charges are 85%, and my moonlighting is paid hourly without charges-- how does that work? IMP employee / provider question > > > > > > Hello all -- > > I am working 4 days a week right now, and have the opportunity to employ a > like-minded ARNP and mommy who only wants to work the other 2 days a week. I > rent my clinic space 7 days a week and would love to be open on Saturdays, > so this seems to make sense. I want to be fair about giving her a percentage > of her collections but the only formula I have is the one from when I was a > partner (Monthly clinic revenue - expenses X percentage of charges). Since > my sweaty equity is in the clinic and she really just wants to show up and > work, this will leave many admin duties to me (billing done by husband). Any > ideas? Is Don out there with a formula for me? > > a Garrido, ARNP > <http://www.villagefamilyclinic.com> www.villagefamilyclinic.com<http://www.villagefamilyclinic.com> > -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!) Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD 115 Mt Blue Circle Farmington ME 04938 ph fax impcenter.org 1 of 1 File(s) Blank Finance Form.xls Quote
Guest guest Posted July 20, 2010 Report Posted July 20, 2010 Thanks for doing this. I am in an SBA business class for Native American's right now, and I am the only doctor. Everyone else is in some kind of contracting or construction work. So the sheet's they provided me to do my stuff on, totally didn't relate, but this will. LIkely won't get it back to list for at least a wk, as I have to be out of town this weekend, and deposition next wk. Goody, NOT. Cote' MD Cote' Medical, Laser, and Spa [Practiceimprovemen t1] IMP employee / provider question > > > > > > Hello all -- > > I am working 4 days a week right now, and have the opportunity to employ a > like-minded ARNP and mommy who only wants to work the other 2 days a week. I > rent my clinic space 7 days a week and would love to be open on Saturdays, > so this seems to make sense. I want to be fair about giving her a percentage > of her collections but the only formula I have is the one from when I was a > partner (Monthly clinic revenue - expenses X percentage of charges). Since > my sweaty equity is in the clinic and she really just wants to show up and > work, this will leave many admin duties to me (billing done by husband). Any > ideas? Is Don out there with a formula for me? > > a Garrido, ARNP > <http://www.villagef amilyclinic. com> www.villagefamilycl inic.com<http://www.villagef amilyclinic. com> > -- PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what you say!)Email is best used for appointment making and brief questionsEmail replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is more urgent . MD ph fax impcenter.org Quote
Guest guest Posted July 20, 2010 Report Posted July 20, 2010 Craig, I agree with your points, and have no issue showing numbers. I believe this is not universal, however. I can add those data points also From: [ ] On Behalf Of Craig Ross [rossmd@...] Sent: Tuesday, July 20, 2010 2:06 PM To: Subject: Re: What's your percent overhead? Jim, This is a great little tool. The precentages are interesting. However, percentages alone can be misleading similar to the difference between relative and absolute benefits in studies. As mentioned on Andy Barr's post below, 40% overhead is hard to compare to 60% without knowing the revenue. Without showing absolute numbers (which I'm not sure is a bad thing especially if it was on the member-only side of idealhealthnetwork.org), it might be helpful to add the data points of " # of employees " and " # of providers " . Craig > > > >> > >> a, > >> > >> > >> > >> You need to be clear on a number of things: > >> > >> > >> > >> What do you want to get out of the relationship? > >> > >> More time off? > >> > >> Better coverage for your patients? > >> > >> Growth of the practice? > >> > >> Reduction in overhead by better use of your facility? > >> > >> More income from charging for the additional administrative activities you > >> will be doing? > >> > >> The " companionship " value of having an associate? > >> > >> > >> > >> What is this going to cost you? > >> > >> Increase in B & O tax due to more gross revenue to the > >> practice? > >> > >> Additional administrative time for you and your husband? (do > >> not forget the many hours necessary to get the new provider credentialed for > >> ins) > >> > >> How will you keep track of what she brings in? > >> > >> Cost of hiring additional staff? > >> > >> If she will be an employee, what will you have to pay in L & I, > >> benefits, SSI, etc? > >> > >> What will this do to your malpractice insurance costs? > >> > >> What will it cost you (in your time and money) if she takes > >> a vacation or time off? > >> > >> > >> > >> Is she going to be an employee, a partner, an independent contractor, or is > >> she just going to rent space from you? > >> > >> Each one of these has different implications. The " cleanest " > >> solution is for her to rent space from you and to pay you for administrative > >> services at a rate you are comfortable with. > >> > >> If she will be any of the other choices, you really need to > >> get legal advice to set up the relationship in a way where you have a > >> minimal chance of getting burned. Actually, you should consider the legal > >> advice, even if you are going to have her rent space and pay you for > >> administrative services. > >> > >> > >> > >> Then the issue is whether she gets paid based on her charges or on her > >> receipts? Charges is easiest to administer, but you have to have a clear > >> understanding of what you actually get paid, and how long it takes to get > >> the money. For a new employee, it may take quite a bit longer for the cash > >> to come in. Paid by receipts is more fair and accurate, but is a much > >> bigger administrative hassle, and many systems have trouble calculating this > >> accurately. Of course, if she is going to be paid by receipts, there will > >> be quite a delay in her getting her money. > >> > >> > >> > >> For many years, I hired doctors, NPs, and PAs for a percentage of their > >> gross charges. In my case (back then), our receipts were about 60% of our > >> gross charges, and our overhead was about 65% of our receipts, so I would > >> expect to " net " about 21% of gross charges. I kept a few percent for the > >> administrative hassle and for the time value of money, and paid them the > >> rest. Of course, you have to be able to adjust the formula as the > >> situation changes. In a more " IMP " like practice, the overhead should be > >> much lower, but adding an employed physician really pushes the overhead up, > >> and potentially makes one less " IMPish. " > >> > >> > >> > >> The most important thing is to decide why you want to add an associate, and > >> whether it really makes any financial sense to do it? > >> > >> > >> > >> I would be happy to meet you sometime for a cup of coffee to discuss this > >> more, as you progress in your plans. > >> > >> > >> > >> dts > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> From: <mailto:Practiceimprovement 1%40yahoogroups. com> Practiceimprovement > >>1yahoogroups (DOT) com<mailto:Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com> > >> > >> [mailto:<mailto:Practiceimprovement 1%40yahoogroups. com>Practiceimprovement > >>1yahoogroups (DOT) com<mailto:Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com>] On Behalf Of > >>kristina_arnp > >> > >> Sent: Saturday, July 10, 2010 8:03 AM > >> To: <mailto:Practiceimprovement 1%40yahoogroups. com> Practiceimprovement > >>1yahoogroups (DOT) com<mailto:Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com> > >> > >> Subject: [Practiceimprovemen t1] IMP employee / provider question > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> Hello all -- > >> > >> I am working 4 days a week right now, and have the opportunity to employ a > >> like-minded ARNP and mommy who only wants to work the other 2 days a week. I > >> rent my clinic space 7 days a week and would love to be open on Saturdays, > >> so this seems to make sense. I want to be fair about giving her a percentage > >> of her collections but the only formula I have is the one from when I was a > >> partner (Monthly clinic revenue - expenses X percentage of charges). Since > >> my sweaty equity is in the clinic and she really just wants to show up and > >> work, this will leave many admin duties to me (billing done by husband). Any > >> ideas? Is Don out there with a formula for me? > >> > >> a Garrido, ARNP > >> <http://www.villagef amilyclinic. com> www.villagefamilycl > >>inic.com<http://www.villagef amilyclinic. com> > >> > >> > > > > > > > > -- > PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email > is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what > you say!) > Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions > Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is > more urgent . > > >    MD >    >    > ph   fax > impcenter.org >  > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 20, 2010 Report Posted July 20, 2010 Maybe there's a way that overhead numbers could be posted anonymously or in aggregate at the new forum. I could see why some might not want to post their books in public. Craig, I agree with your points, and have no issue showing numbers. I believe this is not universal, however. I can add those data points also From: [ ] On Behalf Of Craig Ross [rossmd] Sent: Tuesday, July 20, 2010 2:06 PM To: Subject: Re: What's your percent overhead? Jim, This is a great little tool. The precentages are interesting. However, percentages alone can be misleading similar to the difference between relative and absolute benefits in studies. As mentioned on Andy Barr's post below, 40% overhead is hard to compare to 60% without knowing the revenue. Without showing absolute numbers (which I'm not sure is a bad thing especially if it was on the member-only side of idealhealthnetwork.org), it might be helpful to add the data points of "# of employees" and "# of providers". Craig > > > >> > >> a, > >> > >> > >> > >> You need to be clear on a number of things: > >> > >> > >> > >> What do you want to get out of the relationship? > >> > >> More time off? > >> > >> Better coverage for your patients? > >> > >> Growth of the practice? > >> > >> Reduction in overhead by better use of your facility? > >> > >> More income from charging for the additional administrative activities you > >> will be doing? > >> > >> The "companionship" value of having an associate? > >> > >> > >> > >> What is this going to cost you? > >> > >> Increase in B & O tax due to more gross revenue to the > >> practice? > >> > >> Additional administrative time for you and your husband? (do > >> not forget the many hours necessary to get the new provider credentialed for > >> ins) > >> > >> How will you keep track of what she brings in? > >> > >> Cost of hiring additional staff? > >> > >> If she will be an employee, what will you have to pay in L & I, > >> benefits, SSI, etc? > >> > >> What will this do to your malpractice insurance costs? > >> > >> What will it cost you (in your time and money) if she takes > >> a vacation or time off? > >> > >> > >> > >> Is she going to be an employee, a partner, an independent contractor, or is > >> she just going to rent space from you? > >> > >> Each one of these has different implications. The "cleanest" > >> solution is for her to rent space from you and to pay you for administrative > >> services at a rate you are comfortable with. > >> > >> If she will be any of the other choices, you really need to > >> get legal advice to set up the relationship in a way where you have a > >> minimal chance of getting burned. Actually, you should consider the legal > >> advice, even if you are going to have her rent space and pay you for > >> administrative services. > >> > >> > >> > >> Then the issue is whether she gets paid based on her charges or on her > >> receipts? Charges is easiest to administer, but you have to have a clear > >> understanding of what you actually get paid, and how long it takes to get > >> the money. For a new employee, it may take quite a bit longer for the cash > >> to come in. Paid by receipts is more fair and accurate, but is a much > >> bigger administrative hassle, and many systems have trouble calculating this > >> accurately. Of course, if she is going to be paid by receipts, there will > >> be quite a delay in her getting her money. > >> > >> > >> > >> For many years, I hired doctors, NPs, and PAs for a percentage of their > >> gross charges. In my case (back then), our receipts were about 60% of our > >> gross charges, and our overhead was about 65% of our receipts, so I would > >> expect to "net" about 21% of gross charges. I kept a few percent for the > >> administrative hassle and for the time value of money, and paid them the > >> rest. Of course, you have to be able to adjust the formula as the > >> situation changes. In a more "IMP" like practice, the overhead should be > >> much lower, but adding an employed physician really pushes the overhead up, > >> and potentially makes one less "IMPish." > >> > >> > >> > >> The most important thing is to decide why you want to add an associate, and > >> whether it really makes any financial sense to do it? > >> > >> > >> > >> I would be happy to meet you sometime for a cup of coffee to discuss this > >> more, as you progress in your plans. > >> > >> > >> > >> dts > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> From: <mailto:Practiceimprovement 1%40yahoogroups. com> Practiceimprovement > >>1yahoogroups (DOT) com<mailto:Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com> > >> > >> [mailto:<mailto:Practiceimprovement 1%40yahoogroups. com>Practiceimprovement > >>1yahoogroups (DOT) com<mailto:Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com>] On Behalf Of > >>kristina_arnp > >> > >> Sent: Saturday, July 10, 2010 8:03 AM > >> To: <mailto:Practiceimprovement 1%40yahoogroups. com> Practiceimprovement > >>1yahoogroups (DOT) com<mailto:Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com> > >> > >> Subject: [Practiceimprovemen t1] IMP employee / provider question > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> Hello all -- > >> > >> I am working 4 days a week right now, and have the opportunity to employ a > >> like-minded ARNP and mommy who only wants to work the other 2 days a week. I > >> rent my clinic space 7 days a week and would love to be open on Saturdays, > >> so this seems to make sense. I want to be fair about giving her a percentage > >> of her collections but the only formula I have is the one from when I was a > >> partner (Monthly clinic revenue - expenses X percentage of charges). Since > >> my sweaty equity is in the clinic and she really just wants to show up and > >> work, this will leave many admin duties to me (billing done by husband). Any > >> ideas? Is Don out there with a formula for me? > >> > >> a Garrido, ARNP > >> <http://www.villagef amilyclinic. com> www.villagefamilycl > >>inic.com<http://www.villagef amilyclinic. com> > >> > >> > > > > > > > > -- > PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email > is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what > you say!) > Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions > Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is > more urgent . > > >    MD >    >    > ph   fax > impcenter.org >  > Quote
Guest guest Posted July 20, 2010 Report Posted July 20, 2010 Here are the revisions you requested. I would be happy to recieve the data in unmarked envelopes, or via offline email and mask the data once I get it. I believe there value here and as a study wecould all participate in publishing this. From: [ ] On Behalf Of Pierce [bpierce@...]Sent: Tuesday, July 20, 2010 3:25 PMTo: Subject: Re: Re: What's your percent overhead? Maybe there's a way that overhead numbers could be posted anonymously or in aggregate at the new forum. I could see why some might not want to post their books in public. Craig,I agree with your points, and have no issue showing numbers. I believe this is not universal, however. I can add those data points alsoFrom: [ ] On Behalf Of Craig Ross [rossmd]Sent: Tuesday, July 20, 2010 2:06 PMTo: Subject: Re: What's your percent overhead? Jim,This is a great little tool. The precentages are interesting. However, percentages alone can be misleading similar to the difference between relative and absolute benefits in studies. As mentioned on Andy Barr's post below, 40% overhead is hard to compare to60% without knowing the revenue.Without showing absolute numbers (which I'm not sure is a bad thing especially if it was on the member-only side of idealhealthnetwork.org), it might be helpful to add the data points of " # of employees " and " # of providers " .Craig > >> >> > >> a, > >> > >> > >> > >> You need to be clear on a number of things: > >> > >> > >> > >> What do you want to get out of the relationship? > >> > >> More time off? > >> > >> Better coverage for your patients? > >> > >> Growth of the practice? > >> > >> Reduction in overhead by better use of your facility? > >> > >> More income from charging for the additional administrative activities you > >> will be doing? > >> > >> The " companionship " value of having an associate? > >> > >> > >> > >> What is this going to cost you? > >> > >> Increase in B & O tax due to more gross revenue to the > >> practice? > >> > >> Additional administrative time for you and your husband? (do > >> not forget the many hours necessary to get the new provider credentialed for> >> ins) > >> > >> How will you keep track of what she brings in? > >> > >> Cost of hiring additional staff? > >> > >> If she will be an employee, what will you have to pay in L & I, > >> benefits, SSI, etc? > >> > >> What will this do to your malpractice insurance costs? > >> > >> What will it cost you (in your time and money) if she takes > >> a vacation or time off? > >> > >> > >> > >> Is she going to be an employee, a partner, an independent contractor, or is > >> she just going to rent space from you? > >> > >> Each one of these has different implications. The " cleanest " > >> solution is for her to rent space from you and to pay you for administrative> >> services at a rate you are comfortable with. > >> > >> If she will be any of the other choices, you really need to > >> get legal advice to set up the relationship in a way where you have a > >> minimal chance of getting burned. Actually, you should consider the legal > >> advice, even if you are going to have her rent space and pay you for > >> administrative services. > >> > >> > >> > >> Then the issue is whether she gets paid based on her charges or on her > >> receipts? Charges is easiest to administer, but you have to have a clear > >> understanding of what you actually get paid, and how long it takes to get > >> the money. For a new employee, it may take quite a bit longer for the cash > >> to come in. Paid by receipts is more fair and accurate, but is a much > >> bigger administrative hassle, and many systems have trouble calculating this> >> accurately. Of course, if she is going to be paid by receipts, there will > >> be quite a delay in her getting her money. > >> > >> > >> > >> For many years, I hired doctors, NPs, and PAs for a percentage of their > >> gross charges. In my case (back then), our receipts were about 60% of our > >> gross charges, and our overhead was about 65% of our receipts, so I would > >> expect to " net " about 21% of gross charges. I kept a few percent for the > >> administrative hassle and for the time value of money, and paid them the > >> rest. Of course, you have to be able to adjust the formula as the > >> situation changes. In a more " IMP " like practice, the overhead should be > >> much lower, but adding an employed physician really pushes the overhead up, > >> and potentially makes one less " IMPish. " > >> > >> > >> > >> The most important thing is to decide why you want to add an associate, and > >> whether it really makes any financial sense to do it? > >> > >> > >> > >> I would be happy to meet you sometime for a cup of coffee to discuss this > >> more, as you progress in your plans. > >> > >> > >> > >> dts > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> From: <mailto:Practiceimprovement 1%40yahoogroups. com> Practiceimprovement> >>1yahoogroups (DOT) com<mailto:Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com>> >>> >> [mailto:<mailto:Practiceimprovement 1%40yahoogroups. com>Practiceimprovement> >>1yahoogroups (DOT) com<mailto:Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com>] On Behalf Of> >>kristina_arnp > >>> >> Sent: Saturday, July 10, 2010 8:03 AM > >> To: <mailto:Practiceimprovement 1%40yahoogroups. com> Practiceimprovement> >>1yahoogroups (DOT) com<mailto:Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com>> >>> >> Subject: [Practiceimprovemen t1] IMP employee / provider question > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> Hello all -- > >> > >> I am working 4 days a week right now, and have the opportunity to employ a > >> like-minded ARNP and mommy who only wants to work the other 2 days a week. I> >> rent my clinic space 7 days a week and would love to be open on Saturdays, > >> so this seems to make sense. I want to be fair about giving her a percentage> >> of her collections but the only formula I have is the one from when I was a > >> partner (Monthly clinic revenue - expenses X percentage of charges). Since > >> my sweaty equity is in the clinic and she really just wants to show up and > >> work, this will leave many admin duties to me (billing done by husband). Any> >> ideas? Is Don out there with a formula for me? > >> > >> a Garrido, ARNP > >> <http://www.villagef amilyclinic. com>www.villagefamilycl > >>inic.com<http://www.villagef amilyclinic. com>> >>> >> > >> >> > > > -- > PATIENTS-please remember that email may not be entirely secure, and that Email> is part of the medical record and is placed into your chart ( be careful what> you say!)> Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions> Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is > more urgent .> > >    MD>    >    > ph   fax > impcenter.org>  > 1 of 1 File(s) IMP overhead.xls Quote
Guest guest Posted July 21, 2010 Report Posted July 21, 2010 Here's a copy of an FPM article about IMPs published in 2007. It lists the average monthly revenue and expenses for a group of 15 IMPs at that time. Guinn 1 of 1 File(s) FPM Wasson 9 07.pdf Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.