Guest guest Posted November 16, 2010 Report Posted November 16, 2010 I hope someone has an answer. My 13 yr old daughter (I think she is High functioning Autistic, but the one psychologist I took her to said not) has lost a grandmother and a cousin in the last few months and she doesn't cry. She doesn't talk about them. She acts as if nothing has happened. We are Christians and she has been raised in the Faith but I am afraid her practical mind has a hard time dealing with the hereafter and things she cannot see. I think she must think about these people sometimes and miss them but since she never verbalizes or shows any interest when I bring up the topic I can't be sure. I would be interested in hearing some responses regarding this too. Thanks. wrote: > > I am new to this site and found it as I was trying to get info on how my husband, who I have dx as Aspie, deals with grief. >>>>> Quote
Guest guest Posted November 16, 2010 Report Posted November 16, 2010 Hello. I hope I can help. I am a adult AS female and I can assure you that your daughter is processing her grief within her self. I have lost people very close to me..brother..grandmother..and to those around I seemed cold, quiet,and continued as though nothing had changed but on the inside.....I needed time to process all the changes both with logical and Spiritual reasoning. My advice is to just reassure your daughther that you are there if she needs to talk out loud but give her time to go through this grief in her AS way.She certainly misses her cousin and grandmother and may not be ready or able to verbalize . I know my processing can take a long time to those who do not understand but my processing and being connected with "feeling"work together. I am sorry that your family is grieving . It is so good to know that there are parents like you willing to try and understand what does not look like "normal" in your child may be just be a different "normal" you have yet to understand. Please keep asking questions and looking for answers from those who get it from the inside out. Marjory AS Re: How do AS handle grief? I hope someone has an answer. My 13 yr old daughter (I think she is High functioning Autistic, but the one psychologist I took her to said not) has lost a grandmother and a cousin in the last few months and she doesn't cry. She doesn't talk about them. She acts as if nothing has happened. We are Christians and she has been raised in the Faith but I am afraid her practical mind has a hard time dealing with the hereafter and things she cannot see. I think she must think about these people sometimes and miss them but since she never verbalizes or shows any interest when I bring up the topic I can't be sure. I would be interested in hearing some responses regarding this too.Thanks. wrote:>> I am new to this site and found it as I was trying to get info on how my husband, who I have dx as Aspie, deals with grief. >>>>> Quote
Guest guest Posted November 16, 2010 Report Posted November 16, 2010 Marjory Maley wrote: << Hello. I hope I can help. I am a adult AS female and I can assure you that your daughter is processing her grief within her self. I have lost people very close to me..brother..grandmother..and to those around I seemed cold, quiet, and continued as though nothing had changed but on the inside.....I needed time to process all the changes both with logical and Spiritual reasoning. My advice is to just reassure your daughther that you are there if she needs to talk out loud but give her time to go through this grief in her AS way. >> I'm a lot like you in this respect, Marjory. When my husband of 20 years died by suicide in 2008, I too was considered cold and quiet as I began the long journey of processing this tragedy. I cried once on the day that he died, yet never again. There was also a practical side to my emotional disengagement. This was my first experience with the death of someone close to me, and I had no family or script to help guide me through the process. I had to figure it out on my own, with the help of Professor Google. For me, it was important to maintain the illusion of control over the situation so that I could continue to function and take care of the many practical tasks that needed to be accomplished in the months following my husband's death. While at the same time holding at bay the meddling of various individuals in my husband's life, who continued to drain my energy yet offered no support or condolences to me whatsoever. But wait! There's more. I had just discovered my husband's 10 year affair, the consequences of his bipolar spending compulsions in the form of liquidated retirement accounts, along with 4 years of completed tax returns that he had not bothered to mail. Then there was the mortgage that I was now solely responsible for. Not to mention the denial of a payout on his life insurance due to his suicide. I also had been unemployed for a long time and really needed to focus on starting a job search. Money was already tight and the prospect of losing my house was ever-present. In short, I was excruciatingly aware of suddenly being without a safety net. My support network was very limited. Thus, I really didn't have the luxury of breaking down, at least for the foreseeable future. Everyone grieves in their own way, for their own reasons. Let's not make their journey any more painful by measuring their recovery process against some hypothetical standard of what proper grieving 'should' look like. Best, ~CJ Quote
Guest guest Posted November 16, 2010 Report Posted November 16, 2010 > > I hope someone has an answer. My 13 yr old daughter (I think she is High functioning Autistic, but the one psychologist I took her to said not) has lost a grandmother and a cousin in the last few months and she doesn't cry. She doesn't talk about them. She acts as if nothing has happened. We are Christians and she has been raised in the Faith but I am afraid her practical mind has a hard time dealing with the hereafter and things she cannot see. I think she must think about these people sometimes and miss them but since she never verbalizes or shows any interest when I bring up the topic I can't be sure. I would be interested in hearing some responses regarding this too. My perspective is from a non-Christian view, but there may be some useful information in what I am saying. I'm also very high functioning Aspie, as is my husband, and our 15 year old has been diagnosed PDD-NOS (on the Spectrum, but not Aspie). I assure you, your daughter does feel a sense of loss over her departed relatives. Many Spectrum people have problems handling emotions -- we have them, but don't know how to express them, or fear that we will express our emotions in ways that aren't socially acceptable. So we look cold and unfeeling. Your daughter may not know how to grieve in the same way everyone else does, so chooses not to display any emotion. Then again, her feelings about the loss may be different. If she believes in an afterlife, she may not feel the need to grieve at all -- her relatives have just stepped out of her ability to be with them for a while, she'll be back in touch with them eventually. We don't grieve when someone takes a job in another city, how is going to Heaven any different? [You and I know it is, but your daughter may not.] Or, she may not believe death is anything to be sad about in the first place. Everyone dies, it's part of the natural flow of things, and though we may miss our loved ones, we should not grieve as if their deaths were preventable. I know this is a non-Christian perspective, so it may not be how your daughter is processing things, but if she's questioning her religious beliefs (and 13 is a common age to do so), she may be thinking along these lines. This last perspective is mine. When my parents died, I did nothing that looked like traditional grieving -- I often cry easily, but did not cry then. My parents had lived full lives, and it was time for them to go. I do miss them, but there is very little sadness involved. On the other hand, my (almost certainly) Aspie father-in-law was so stricken with grief when his wife died that he had a minor stroke. --Liz Quote
Guest guest Posted November 16, 2010 Report Posted November 16, 2010 From my experiences only.... I am AS. Like the others people often consider me 'cold' or think that I have not 'dealt with it' when there has been death in my family. There are several aspects that make people think this way. I don't cry. It's not that I don't have crying feelings internally. It is just physically painful to cry and sometimes impossible. It's like the 'cry system' doesn't work consistently or correctly. Also often emotions do not show very well on my face. That also seems to be random. Sometimes works, sometimes doesn't. The third aspect I thought of is that growing up I always felt judged by my mother because she was always telling me what I should feel or do in situations like this. That made me more focused on rebelling against her rather than dealing with and feeling my very real grief. I felt like she thought I was stupid and like she thought I was a bad kid because I wasn't showing the correct emotion. She made assumptions about me that weren't true based on what she saw on the surface and never bothered to observe long term behaviors, indeed did not give me opportunity to choose correct behavior. She always told me what to do before I had a chance to do it on my own. My response to that was to do nothing at all. I was willing to do as I was told when it came to chores or other but when it came to how I felt or relational things I instinctively objected to that. So I can imagine I came off even more as if I had no feeling and/or no relationship sense when it came to grief. So I'd say the biggest thing would be let them deal with it in their own time and in their own way. We process differently. Different timing coming from a different direction. We might do something that appears unrelated but is meaningful to us. Don't underestimate... Hope that helps, Jennie AS Quote
Guest guest Posted November 16, 2010 Report Posted November 16, 2010 There are times I have wanted to cry, and cannot get the tears to flow...and then there are times that I tear up (despite not wanting to) from the frustration of not being able to express myself properly (and am then accused of crying to get my own way). Either I'd love to cry and can't, or I'm trying not to and can't stop! Very frustrating! And I'm an only child, but it sounds like and I grew up with the same mother... ~ "Nobody realizes that some people expend tremendous energy merely to be normal."--Albert Camus Sent from my VZW BlackBerrySender: aspires-relationships Date: Tue, 16 Nov 2010 14:35:19 -0800To: <aspires-relationships >ReplyTo: aspires-relationships Subject: Re: How do AS handle grief? From my experiences only.... I am AS. Like the others people often consider me 'cold' or think that I have not 'dealt with it' when there has been death in my family. There are several aspects that make people think this way. I don't cry. It's not that I don't have crying feelings internally. It is just physically painful to cry and sometimes impossible. It's like the 'cry system' doesn't work consistently or correctly. Also often emotions do not show very well on my face. That also seems to be random. Sometimes works, sometimes doesn't. The third aspect I thought of is that growing up I always felt judged by my mother because she was always telling me what I should feel or do in situations like this. That made me more focused on rebelling against her rather than dealing with and feeling my very real grief. I felt like she thought I was stupid and like she thought I was a bad kid because I wasn't showing the correct emotion. She made assumptions about me that weren't true based on what she saw on the surface and never bothered to observe long term behaviors, indeed did not give me opportunity to choose correct behavior. She always told me what to do before I had a chance to do it on my own. My response to that was to do nothing at all. I was willing to do as I was told when it came to chores or other but when it came to how I felt or relational things I instinctively objected to that. So I can imagine I came off even more as if I had no feeling and/or no relationship sense when it came to grief. So I'd say the biggest thing would be let them deal with it in their own time and in their own way. We process differently. Different timing coming from a different direction. We might do something that appears unrelated but is meaningful to us. Don't underestimate... Hope that helps, Jennie AS Quote
Guest guest Posted November 17, 2010 Report Posted November 17, 2010 What you share here , reminds me of another aspect of this whole issue of grief. While I understand doing certain things because they are the culturally acceptable thing to do in order to show respect I do not understand showing respect to someone just because they died or are going to die. What I mean is... some people are not respectable and one thing I have always struggled with is the tendancy of people to observe all the the cultural respect stuff and behave as if the person had been an honorable decent person when in reality everyone knows they weren't. I'm fine with helping the people who are left behind and showing them concern and care, but have a real hard time going along with the cultural acceptable things to do like talking about the dead person as if they were the best person ever when clearly they weren't. Anyway, I'm not saying this is applies to anyone's situation here. Just something related to the issues surrounding grief I thought of that I have struggled with a lot. Jennie How do AS handle grief? Greetings: I am NS/NT and was married to a AS partner for years. I experienced the same thing when his father and mother died. It was almost like he did not care and in retrospect it was like others with AS have stated. It was not that he did not care, but he internalized and expressed it differently. Everyone expresses their AS genes differently. If you have seen the movie TEMPLE, I love the scene when a close person to her dies and she did not understand the traditions of our culture and her mother tried to explain, it is what WE DO to show our respect. I don't have any pearls of wisdom to add to this thread other than there are certain social norms we all go through and maybe don't ascribe to, to show our RESPECT for others in this situation. Like another writer pointed out, if you are spiritual, one might think, Sayonara, old friend, we will meet again in another dimension. You almost have to ask the person, WHY? You just might be surprised by their answer. I was. Just me. Quote
Guest guest Posted November 17, 2010 Report Posted November 17, 2010 Jennie Unknown wrote: << While I understand doing certain things because they are the culturally acceptable thing to do in order to show respect I do not understand showing respect to someone just because they died or are going to die. What I mean is... some people are not respectable and one thing I have always struggled with is the tendancy of people to observe all the the cultural respect stuff and behave as if the person had been an honorable decent person when in reality everyone knows they weren't. I'm fine with helping the people who are left behind and showing them concern and care, but have a real hard time going along with the cultural acceptable things to do like talking about the dead person as if they were the best person ever when clearly they weren't. >> Okay, so you value showing concern and care for those who are left behind. Like any good gift, the nature of the gift should really be something that the recipient values, not the giver. Perhaps showing your concern and care would be most appreciated if you honored what is important to them. That of doing the culturally acceptable thing that would make them happy, even if you must hold your nose. Best, ~CJ Quote
Guest guest Posted November 18, 2010 Report Posted November 18, 2010 CJ I understand what you are saying but how do you think that applies when dealing with people who are/have been truly evil? I mean pedophiles, abusers....really mean nasty people. To me it was/is a conflict internally of compromising my own view of what is right. What I have ended up with is I will attend such funerals but I refuse to lie and talk about an evil person as if they were a wonderful saint. It's just not ok with me, so I either scrape the bottom of the barrel and find one, however miniscule, good thing to say OR I say things directed only at the person who is grieving, like if the person is a Christian or God believer I would say 'God knows your pain'. Though once I made the mistake of saying 'God is with you' and got a mini sermon right then and there from the grieving person about God only being in heaven not here and, and, and... So even that can get dicey. Jennie Re: How do AS handle grief? > Okay, so you value showing concern and care for those who are left > behind. Like any good gift, the nature of the gift should really be > something that the recipient values, not the giver. > > Perhaps showing your concern and care would be most appreciated if you > honored what is important to them. That of doing the culturally > acceptable thing that would make them happy, even if you must hold your > nose. > > Best, > ~CJ Quote
Guest guest Posted November 18, 2010 Report Posted November 18, 2010 Jennie, I understand what you are saying. Sometimes death saves a person and they ‘appear’ wonderful and saintly even though they were not. Someone in our community just died, and in reading what was written about her you had to wonder who they were talking about – someone that certainly I had never seen or experienced! The hypocrisy is hard. Cheryl From: aspires-relationships [mailto:aspires-relationships ] On Behalf Of Jennie Unknown Sent: Thursday, November 18, 2010 2:09 PM To: aspires-relationships Subject: Re: How do AS handle grief? CJ I understand what you are saying but how do you think that applies when dealing with people who are/have been truly evil? I mean pedophiles, abusers....really mean nasty people. To me it was/is a conflict internally of compromising my own view of what is right. What I have ended up with is I will attend such funerals but I refuse to lie and talk about an evil person as if they were a wonderful saint. It's just not ok with me, so I either scrape the bottom of the barrel and find one, however miniscule, good thing to say OR I say things directed only at the person who is grieving, like if the person is a Christian or God believer I would say 'God knows your pain'. Though once I made the mistake of saying 'God is with you' and got a mini sermon right then and there from the grieving person about God only being in heaven not here and, and, and... So even that can get dicey. Jennie Re: How do AS handle grief? > Okay, so you value showing concern and care for those who are left > behind. Like any good gift, the nature of the gift should really be > something that the recipient values, not the giver. > > Perhaps showing your concern and care would be most appreciated if you > honored what is important to them. That of doing the culturally > acceptable thing that would make them happy, even if you must hold your > nose. > > Best, > ~CJ ------------------------------------ " We each have our own way of living in the world, together we are like a symphony. Some are the melody, some are the rhythm, some are the harmony It all blends together, we are like a symphony, and each part is crucial. We all contribute to the song of life. " ....Sondra We might not always agree; but TOGETHER we will make a difference. ASPIRES is a closed, confidential, moderated list. Responsibility for posts to ASPIRES lies entirely with the original author. Do NOT post mail off-list without the author's permission. When in doubt, please refer to our list rules at: http://www.aspires-relationships.com/info_rules.htm ASPIRES ~ Climbing the mountain TOGETHER http://www.aspires-relationships.com Quote
Guest guest Posted November 18, 2010 Report Posted November 18, 2010 A safe phrase is " My thoughts and care are with you during this difficult time. " And you can say " I know so-and so will be missed by all who knew and loved him/her " while thinking to yourself, so-and-so was so a terrible human that he/she wasn't loved at all. I prefer the first but if you care for the grieving party then the second is at least truthful because it doesn't identify you as someone who gives a rat's behind. All you are trying to do is express some kindness to someone who is alive, for whom you have positive feelings, and is feeling badly, due to the loss of another human being. Cheers, Hadassah Lynn Editor/Writer Re: How do AS handle grief? CJ I understand what you are saying but how do you think that applies when dealing with people who are/have been truly evil? I mean pedophiles, abusers....really mean nasty people. To me it was/is a conflict internally of compromising my own view of what is right. What I have ended up with is I will attend such funerals but I refuse to lie and talk about an evil person as if they were a wonderful saint. It's just not ok with me, so I either scrape the bottom of the barrel and find one, however miniscule, good thing to say OR I say things directed only at the person who is grieving, like if the person is a Christian or God believer I would say 'God knows your pain'. Though once I made the mistake of saying 'God is with you' and got a mini sermon right then and there from the grieving person about God only being in heaven not here and, and, and... So even that can get dicey. Jennie Re: How do AS handle grief? > Okay, so you value showing concern and care for those who are left > behind. Like any good gift, the nature of the gift should really be > something that the recipient values, not the giver. > > Perhaps showing your concern and care would be most appreciated if you > honored what is important to them. That of doing the culturally > acceptable thing that would make them happy, even if you must hold your > nose. > > Best, > ~CJ ------------------------------------ " We each have our own way of living in the world, together we are like a symphony. Some are the melody, some are the rhythm, some are the harmony It all blends together, we are like a symphony, and each part is crucial. We all contribute to the song of life. " ...Sondra We might not always agree; but TOGETHER we will make a difference. ASPIRES is a closed, confidential, moderated list. Responsibility for posts to ASPIRES lies entirely with the original author. Do NOT post mail off-list without the author's permission. When in doubt, please refer to our list rules at: http://www.aspires-relationships.com/info_rules.htm ASPIRES ~ Climbing the mountain TOGETHER http://www.aspires-relationships.com Quote
Guest guest Posted November 18, 2010 Report Posted November 18, 2010 > All you are trying to do is express some kindness to someone who is alive, > for whom you have positive feelings, and is feeling badly, due to the loss > of another human being. I usually sidestep the issue and don't talk about the deceased at all. Instead, I focus my words on the grieving. " I'm sorry for your loss " is trite, but does express my feelings. Other good phrases, depending on specifics, are " What a shock you had " , " I hope <the deceased> had an easy passing " (because I don't wish a horrible death on anyone), " S/he lived a full life " (full of something, I don't say what), and " How are you holding up? " If the griever is someone I might hug, a hug can be enough communication with no words. --Liz ------------ The Aspie Parent blog: http://aspergersparent.wordpress.com/ SF, science, and Gifted Ed t-shirts, mugs, and other items at http://www.zazzle.com/CartesianBear* Follow my shop activity at http://twitter.com/cartesianbear Quote
Guest guest Posted November 18, 2010 Report Posted November 18, 2010 Just an observation on this discussion.Grief is a personal issue that everyoneexperiences differently. Different individuals have different experiencesand relationships with those that have died and that relationship defineshow they feel about that person.So generalising and judging individualsis done from our own perspective which may be shared by others but notnecessarily all. We are complex beings with light and dark shades. Some are darker than others. Some of us are exposed to thedarker sides while others experience the lighter sides.Perhaps we can all agree that deathis the final arbiter for all of us and we will all end up being judgedby the one person we fear most - ourselves.Interesting discussion and one thatI have been following.From an AS perspective death is justanother life event. I am very pragmatic about death myself and donot suffer overwhelming grief when loved ones pass on. There isa sense that something is gone and life goes on. We go on and therest of humanity goes on so it is all a process. There is also thesense that their mortality emphasises my own which lasts for a while andthen recedes into the background. I also speculate on how I would approachmy own death and the process that surrounds it. There is an intellectualinterest in this that I find rather fascinating. I do think however that living witha loved one and watching them experience the final period leading up todeath would be upsetting and hard to take. I have not experiencedthis myself but I know that I would find that hard.Greg DX AS at 53To: aspires-relationships Date: 19/11/2010 08:40 AMSubject: RE: How do AS handle grief?Sent by: aspires-relationships A safe phrase is " My thoughts and care are with youduring this difficulttime. " And you can say " I know so-and so will be missed by allwho knew andloved him/her " while thinking to yourself, so-and-so was so a terriblehumanthat he/she wasn't loved at all. I prefer the first but if you care forthegrieving party then the second is at least truthful because it doesn'tidentify you as someone who gives a rat's behind.All you are trying to do is express some kindness to someone who is alive,for whom you have positive feelings, and is feeling badly, due to the lossof another human being.Cheers,Hadassah Lynn Editor/Writer-----Original Message-----From: aspires-relationships [mailto:aspires-relationships ]On Behalf Of Jennie UnknownSent: Thursday, November 18, 2010 1:09 PMTo: aspires-relationships Subject: Re: How do AS handle grief?CJI understand what you are saying but how do you think that applies whendealing with people who are/have been truly evil? I mean pedophiles, abusers....really mean nasty people. To me it was/is a conflict internallyof compromising my own view of what is right. What I have ended up withis Iwill attend such funerals but I refuse to lie and talk about an evil personas if they were a wonderful saint. It's just not ok with me, so I eitherscrape the bottom of the barrel and find one, however miniscule, good thingto say OR I say things directed only at the person who is grieving, likeif the person is a Christian or God believer I would say 'God knows your pain'.Though once I made the mistake of saying 'God is with you' and got a minisermon right then and there from the grieving person about God only beinginheaven not here and, and, and... So even that can get dicey.Jennie Re: How do AS handle grief?> Okay, so you value showing concern and care for those who are left> behind. Like any good gift, the nature of the gift should really be> something that the recipient values, not the giver.>> Perhaps showing your concern and care would be most appreciated ifyou> honored what is important to them. That of doing the culturally> acceptable thing that would make them happy, even if you must holdyour> nose. >> Best,> ~CJ------------------------------------ " We each have our own way of living in the world, together weare like a symphony.Some are the melody, some are the rhythm, some are the harmony It all blends together, we are like a symphony, and each part is crucial.We all contribute to the song of life. " ...Sondra We might not always agree; but TOGETHER we will make a difference.ASPIRES is a closed, confidential, moderated list.Responsibility for posts to ASPIRES lies entirely with the original author.Do NOT post mail off-list without the author's permission.When in doubt, please refer to our list rules at:http://www.aspires-relationships.com/info_rules.htmASPIRES ~ Climbing the mountain TOGETHERhttp://www.aspires-relationships.com Quote
Guest guest Posted November 18, 2010 Report Posted November 18, 2010 Thanks, those are good safe statements of caring. And are not specific to a belief system which would avoid the problem I had at the one funeral where I got a sermon...! J RE: How do AS handle grief? A safe phrase is "My thoughts and care are with you during this difficulttime." And you can say "I know so-and so will be missed by all who knew andloved him/her" while thinking to yourself, so-and-so was so a terrible humanthat he/she wasn't loved at all. I prefer the first but if you care for thegrieving party then the second is at least truthful because it doesn'tidentify you as someone who gives a rat's behind.All you are trying to do is express some kindness to someone who is alive,for whom you have positive feelings, and is feeling badly, due to the lossof another human being.Cheers,Hadassah Lynn Editor/Writer Quote
Guest guest Posted November 18, 2010 Report Posted November 18, 2010 Thanks Liz. These are also helpful to me. I have tended in life to avoid saying what I felt were empty platitudes but I have realized recently that most people do not look past the surface words and are totally fine with it. In fact seem to get some comfort from the.... I guess it's a social ritual...? It's like what is said is not relevent just the fact that you participate (or not) in the ritual... It has taken years for me to even begin to see this. I may still be off base.... lol Jennie Re: How do AS handle grief? I usually sidestep the issue and don't talk about the deceased at all.Instead, I focus my words on the grieving. "I'm sorry for your loss" is trite, but does express my feelings. Other good phrases, depending on specifics, are "What a shock you had", "I hope <the deceased> had an easy passing" (because I don't wish a horrible death on anyone), "S/he lived a full life" (full of something, I don't say what), and "How are you holding up?" If the griever is someone I might hug, a hug can be enough communication with no words.--Liz Quote
Guest guest Posted November 18, 2010 Report Posted November 18, 2010 > > Thanks Liz. These are also helpful to me. I have tended in life to avoid saying what I felt were empty platitudes but I have realized recently that most people do not look past the surface words and are totally fine with it. In fact seem to get some comfort from the.... I guess it's a social ritual...? It's like what is said is not relevent just the fact that you participate (or not) in the ritual... It has taken years for me to even begin to see this. I may still be off base.... lol I think you're right. In this circumstance, our job is to comfort the grieving -- by saying or doing things that make *them* feel comforted. These are not necessarily the things that would make *us* feel better, but as long as we don't violate our own ethical/moral systems, we should do/say what they want. [i wouldn't try to comfort someone by talking about Christian concepts of afterlife, for example.] If we don't know someone well enough to know what they would want us to say, best is to follow the cultural norms -- if we do, we won't be accused of saying improper things. I have to admit, it took me years before I understood that saying " I'm sorry " to the grieving was not an admission of guilt on my part. I grew up thinking I'm sorry meant I was responsible for the death, but now I know it's shorthand for " I wish your sadness hadn't taken place. " --Liz ------------ The Aspie Parent blog: http://aspergersparent.wordpress.com/ SF, science, and Gifted Ed t-shirts, mugs, and other items at http://www.zazzle.com/CartesianBear* Follow my shop activity at http://twitter.com/cartesianbear Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 I hear you... you have to know someone REALLY good because when I had someone preach me a sermon it was someone who is a Christian and who I therefore assumed would like to hear that God cares... I had no clue there were Christian denominations who object to the idea that God is with us in the here and now.... Valuable lesson that! I knew not to make those statements to someone who I know does not have that belief system or might be an atheist or some other religion but even within a certain religion you still can't be sure that people believe the same thing and you just never know what might trigger an objection which is certainly not the goal in a grief situation! So I totally get that, I don't say anything that could be at all construed as a belief statement even to people who I think have the same beliefs. Only if I have known them personally for many years and they have clearly expressed their beliefs!! Fortunately in my particular case I probably actually helped the man feel better with my blunder because he probably viewed it as having received an opportunity to speak truth to the 'heathen and therefore it was not objectionable to him, just me. LOL Jennie Re: How do AS handle grief? [i wouldn't try to comfort someone by talking about Christian concepts of afterlife, for example.]If we don't know someone well enough to know what they would want us to say, best is to follow the cultural norms -- if we do, we won't be accused of saying improper things. Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 Hadassah wrote: << A safe phrase is " My thoughts and care are with you during this difficult time. " And you can say " I know so-and so will be missed by all who knew and loved him/her " while thinking to yourself, so-and-so was so a terrible human that he/she wasn't loved at all. I prefer the first but if you care for the grieving party then the second is at least truthful because it doesn't identify you as someone who gives a rat's behind. >> I agree with you, Hadassah. << All you are trying to do is express some kindness to someone who is alive, for whom you have positive feelings, and is feeling badly, due to the loss of another human being. >> That's exactly the intent of my earlier post. You just said it better than I did. This social ritual is for the benefit of the living, not the deceased. If people can focus on extending a gift of kindness to the mourner, the character of the deceased is irrelevant. Best, ~CJ Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 Liz Cademy wrote: << Instead, I focus my words on the grieving. " I'm sorry for your loss " is trite, but does express my feelings. Other good phrases, depending on specifics, are " What a shock you had " , " I hope <the deceased> had an easy passing " (because I don't wish a horrible death on anyone), " S/he lived a full life " (full of something, I don't say what), and " How are you holding up? " If the griever is someone I might hug, a hug can be enough communication with no words. >> More good suggestions. Never worry about being trite. Mourners don't seem to be that picky. They just want to know that others care. Best, ~CJ Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 Liz Cademy wrote: << In this circumstance, our job is to comfort the grieving -- by saying or doing things that make *them* feel comforted. These are not necessarily the things that would make *us* feel better, but as long as we don't violate our own ethical/moral systems, we should do/say what they want. >> Very nicely expressed, Liz. That's why I like to compare the gesture to a gift chosen with the recipient (not the giver) in mind. << I have to admit, it took me years before I understood that saying " I'm sorry " to the grieving was not an admission of guilt on my part. I grew up thinking I'm sorry meant I was responsible for the death, but now I know it's shorthand for " I wish your sadness hadn't taken place. " >> For a long time I was similarly confused about the purpose of forgiveness. I didn't realize that it was for *my* benefit, not the transgressor's. Once I realized that, forgiveness became a helluva lot easier. Best, ~CJ Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 I know we have certain different ways to perform a job task with a different understanding from others and they get upset for not obeying things or how they told us to perform certain job their way, not our way to make it simple. I just find out this week I have AS and I can not stay so long on a job because I can't work on a team and I have trouble in been social with people, does anyone know how to deal with this situation in how to interact with them socially? Francisco Quiroga. Sent from my iPhone Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 No need to acknowledge the deceased at all if you don't want to, Jennie. It's not like they will get all offended if you ignore 'em. Condolences are for the benefit of the living mourners. Focus on them and their feelings of loss instead. Best, ~CJ Jennie Unknown wrote: > CJ > > I understand what you are saying but how do you think that applies when > dealing with people who are/have been truly evil? I mean pedophiles, > abusers....really mean nasty people. To me it was/is a conflict internally > of compromising my own view of what is right. What I have ended up with is I > will attend such funerals but I refuse to lie and talk about an evil person > as if they were a wonderful saint. It's just not ok with me, so I either > scrape the bottom of the barrel and find one, however miniscule, good thing > to say OR I say things directed only at the person who is grieving, like if > the person is a Christian or God believer I would say 'God knows your pain'. > Though once I made the mistake of saying 'God is with you' and got a mini > sermon right then and there from the grieving person about God only being in > heaven not here and, and, and... So even that can get dicey. > > Jennie Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 Thanks for everyone who replied and provided some insight on this subject. My daughter (age 13) probably seems uncaring to other members of the family who are always talking about how much they " miss " her grandmother and cousin. I was just worried that she is keeping it all inside, but I really do not think that is it. By the way, she gets angry at me whenever I suggest she might be AS. She is determined to be seen as normal and I am letting her live that way because it is her choice and she is able to do so. Maybe some day she will want friends. But maybe not having any is easier while she figures out things. I know she used to watch Hannah Montana on TV every day a couple years ago just to try to figure out how and why people in school talked to each other the way they did. Maybe it helped her build a facade that works at school. Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 Liz, Thanks for the thought about what "I'm sorry" could mean to an AS. I will have to explain to my aspie that when he says "I'm sorry" it is not that he is responsible, nor even that it is bad the person has died, only that he is sorry that the survivor is sad. That was really insightful for me!! Thanks! Pat To: aspires-relationships Sent: Thu, November 18, 2010 3:37:01 PMSubject: Re: How do AS handle grief? > > Thanks Liz. These are also helpful to me. I have tended in life to avoid saying what I felt were empty platitudes but I have realized recently that most people do not look past the surface words and are totally fine with it. In fact seem to get some comfort from the.... I guess it's a social ritual...? It's like what is said is not relevent just the fact that you participate (or not) in the ritual... It has taken years for me to even begin to see this. I may still be off base.... lolI think you're right.In this circumstance, our job is to comfort the grieving -- by saying or doing things that make *them* feel comforted. These are not necessarily the things that would make *us* feel better, but as long as we don't violate our own ethical/moral systems, we should do/say what they want. [i wouldn't try to comfort someone by talking about Christian concepts of afterlife, for example.]If we don't know someone well enough to know what they would want us to say, best is to follow the cultural norms -- if we do, we won't be accused of saying improper things.I have to admit, it took me years before I understood that saying "I'm sorry" to the grieving was not an admission of guilt on my part. I grew up thinking I'm sorry meant I was responsible for the death, but now I know it's shorthand for "I wish your sadness hadn't taken place."--Liz------------The Aspie Parent blog: http://aspergersparent.wordpress.com/SF, science, and Gifted Ed t-shirts, mugs, and other items at http://www.zazzle.com/CartesianBear*Follow my shop activity at http://twitter.com/cartesianbear Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2010 Report Posted November 19, 2010 So Greg, how do you think about your own mortality? My aspie will at times talk about death, and doesn't seem to get the concept that when he dies, I will be alone. That has huge emotional impact for me that he "doesn't get". When I talk about my death, and his being alone, he will say he will miss me, and then makes half a joke about how he will get rid of all the "girl things" I have around the house. (china, flowers,etc) Is death to an AS just another interesting experience? As far as being around someone who is in the process of dying, when my AS came to visit with my mom a month or so before she died. He really had no interest in being with her to say the kind of things that NS people say to each other at the end of life. He was good at helping DO the things I needed done, but not emotional at all during the very last. Later, he looked at her during the funeral and couldn't give the platitudes "Oh she looks so nice!". He responded to one of my mother's elderly friends, "I don't think she looks nice, I think she looks kind of dead!" They were very taken back and we can laught about it now, but I think he still doesn't totally understand the need to just not say much, for most of what he says as an AS would be socially inappropriate and offensive to the NS people. Thanks for your insight since you are obviously male and over 50. My AS is 58, and just diagnosed in the last year. It has been great after 21 years of marriage to finally begin to understand his "quirks". I thought he was just and engineer!! Pat To: aspires-relationships Sent: Thu, November 18, 2010 2:23:40 PMSubject: RE: How do AS handle grief? Just an observation on this discussion. Grief is a personal issue that everyone experiences differently. Different individuals have different experiences and relationships with those that have died and that relationship defines how they feel about that person. So generalising and judging individuals is done from our own perspective which may be shared by others but not necessarily all. We are complex beings with light and dark shades. Some are darker than others. Some of us are exposed to the darker sides while others experience the lighter sides. Perhaps we can all agree that death is the final arbiter for all of us and we will all end up being judged by the one person we fear most - ourselves. Interesting discussion and one that I have been following. From an AS perspective death is just another life event. I am very pragmatic about death myself and do not suffer overwhelming grief when loved ones pass on. There is a sense that something is gone and life goes on. We go on and the rest of humanity goes on so it is all a process. There is also the sense that their mortality emphasises my own which lasts for a while and then recedes into the background. I also speculate on how I would approach my own death and the process that surrounds it. There is an intellectual interest in this that I find rather fascinating. I do think however that living with a loved one and watching them experience the final period leading up to death would be upsetting and hard to take. I have not experienced this myself but I know that I would find that hard. Greg DX AS at 53 To: aspires-relationships Date: 19/11/2010 08:40 AM Subject: RE: How do AS handle grief? Sent by: aspires-relationships A safe phrase is "My thoughts and care are with you during this difficulttime." And you can say "I know so-and so will be missed by all who knew andloved him/her" while thinking to yourself, so-and-so was so a terrible humanthat he/she wasn't loved at all. I prefer the first but if you care for thegrieving party then the second is at least truthful because it doesn'tidentify you as someone who gives a rat's behind.All you are trying to do is express some kindness to someone who is alive,for whom you have positive feelings, and is feeling badly, due to the lossof another human being.Cheers,Hadassah Lynn Editor/Writer-----Original Message-----From: aspires-relationships [mailto:aspires-relationships ] On Behalf Of Jennie UnknownSent: Thursday, November 18, 2010 1:09 PMTo: aspires-relationships Subject: Re: How do AS handle grief?CJI understand what you are saying but how do you think that applies when dealing with people who are/have been truly evil? I mean pedophiles, abusers....really mean nasty people. To me it was/is a conflict internally of compromising my own view of what is right. What I have ended up with is Iwill attend such funerals but I refuse to lie and talk about an evil person as if they were a wonderful saint. It's just not ok with me, so I either scrape the bottom of the barrel and find one, however miniscule, good thing to say OR I say things directed only at the person who is grieving, like if the person is a Christian or God believer I would say 'God knows your pain'.Though once I made the mistake of saying 'God is with you' and got a mini sermon right then and there from the grieving person about God only being inheaven not here and, and, and... So even that can get dicey.Jennie Re: How do AS handle grief?> Okay, so you value showing concern and care for those who are left> behind. Like any good gift, the nature of the gift should really be> something that the recipient values, not the giver.>> Perhaps showing your concern and care would be most appreciated if you> honored what is important to them. That of doing the culturally> acceptable thing that would make them happy, even if you must hold your> nose. >> Best,> ~CJ------------------------------------"We each have our own way of living in the world, together weare like a symphony.Some are the melody, some are the rhythm, some are the harmony It all blends together, we are like a symphony, and each part is crucial.We all contribute to the song of life."...Sondra We might not always agree; but TOGETHER we will make a difference.ASPIRES is a closed, confidential, moderated list.Responsibility for posts to ASPIRES lies entirely with the original author.Do NOT post mail off-list without the author's permission.When in doubt, please refer to our list rules at:http://www.aspires-relationships.com/info_rules.htmASPIRES ~ Climbing the mountain TOGETHERhttp://www.aspires-relationships.com Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.