Guest guest Posted March 22, 2010 Report Posted March 22, 2010 For better or worse. I hope for the better.I'm not happy with many things in this bill, but it's a start. Hey. I'm a glass half full kind of girl.If I have this right, the doughnut hole will go away or become smaller, insurance companies will not be able to excise people from plans when they become ill, people will not become bankrupt by serious illness. These are huge. I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. Now the real work starts, as in, how to make this work. Now can the doctors and nurses please sit at the table to figure that part out? Pharma and Big Insurance had their chance to sit at the table. They got what they wanted, so to speak.With trepidation and hope,KathleenMy feeling is that it will be about us…soon. We know we are heading down an economically unsustainable path. Initially, there was a moral (and economic) reason to cover the uninsured. There is no way health care reform would have gotten even this far with any discussion of changing doctor payment. HOWEVER, now that most people will be covered, the discussion will begin as to how we can pay for the system we have. My guess is that there will be lots of pilot studies and other things trying to determine the most cost effective and highest quality form of medicine. Data from the US and other countries shows this starts with a strong primary care system. The definition of a strong primary care system is still debatable, but it is imperative for us to clean our house and prove our worth or we will be told by others what that means. At IMP we are working to do this. Stayed tuned… From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of pricklyfinger2007Sent: Sunday, March 21, 2010 10:42 AMTo: Subject: Re: health reform vote why couldnt this be about us too? first step, ok fair. levelling reimbursement with subspecialty, ok fair. bring them down some, bring us up some. but when will reform and push for primary care happen? support for prevention happen? when i die?the reason for lack of access is unaffordable insurance. unreasonable qualifiers, the mere fact you have to be well and not taking thyroid pills in order to be insured.hospitals, hospital systems, insurance companies are the problem. if i, as a primary care physician can make THE pockets swell i am sure i will be heard. nothing like feeding a prize fighter.good grief.> > >> > >> > >> > > Sangeetha,> > > I'm with you.> > > We have to start somewhere.> > > Sharon> > >> > >> > >> > > --> > > PATIENTS,please remember email may not be entirely secure and that Email> > is part of the medical record and is placed into the chart ( be careful what> > you say!)> > > Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions> > > Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter> > is more urgent .> > >> > >> > > MD> > > > > > > > > ph fax > > > impcenter.org> > >> >> > > >> > > > -- > PATIENTS,please remember email may not be entirely secure and that Email is> part of the medical record and is placed into the chart ( be careful what> you say!)> Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions> Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is> more urgent .> > > MD> > > ph fax > impcenter.org> Quote
Guest guest Posted March 22, 2010 Report Posted March 22, 2010 I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? -- Graham Chiuhttp://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/ Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 22, 2010 Report Posted March 22, 2010 Graham,It's not clear how this could affect direct cash practices. In theory it should not change the modus operandi of direct practices. However, it depends on the structure of the new contracts. The people who sign up for or are put into an HMO type indemnity plan, will not be able to see a non-par physician. To do so, they would pay out of pocket, but would not be reimbursed. If all 32 million are in such HMOs, could be a big problem for physicians who are non-par. People would still be required to pay the premiums. There has been talk in some states to make obtaining a medical license contingent upon participating in medicare. This looks like conscription to me. Now would be the time for all doctors and nurses to come together to help shape the nature of the new health insurance so that both patients and those provide the care have some choices. Nurses do extremely well at organizing and negotiating. Doctors are notorious for inability to organize. If doctors squabble to remain individuals, we will become fractious sheep herded into the big pen. But would it be so bad to become sheep if we don't feel like sheep? We could lose what influence we once had to effect better patient care. Trapped is trapped even if the rat doesn't know it. Bring on cookbook medicine and more ridiculous metrics to quantify how well we turn pages rather than how well we take care of our patients. Please anyone jump in here...Gordon?KathleenOn Mon, Mar 22, 2010 at 6:00 PM, Kathleen Patton <krpattoncomcast (DOT) net> wrote:I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? -- Graham Chiuhttp://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 22, 2010 Report Posted March 22, 2010 Was there a provision for 85% of every health care dollar has to go to actual health care...less to administration/profit/CEOs For better or worse. I hope for the better. I'm not happy with many things in this bill, but it's a start. Hey. I'm a glass half full kind of girl. If I have this right, the doughnut hole will go away or become smaller, insurance companies will not be able to excise people from plans when they become ill, people will not become bankrupt by serious illness. These are huge. I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. Now the real work starts, as in, how to make this work. Now can the doctors and nurses please sit at the table to figure that part out? Pharma and Big Insurance had their chance to sit at the table. They got what they wanted, so to speak. With trepidation and hope, Kathleen My feeling is that it will be about us…soon. We know we are heading down an economically unsustainable path. Initially, there was a moral (and economic) reason to cover the uninsured. There is no way health care reform would have gotten even this far with any discussion of changing doctor payment. HOWEVER, now that most people will be covered, the discussion will begin as to how we can pay for the system we have. My guess is that there will be lots of pilot studies and other things trying to determine the most cost effective and highest quality form of medicine. Data from the US and other countries shows this starts with a strong primary care system. The definition of a strong primary care system is still debatable, but it is imperative for us to clean our house and prove our worth or we will be told by others what that means. At IMP we are working to do this. Stayed tuned… From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of pricklyfinger2007 Sent: Sunday, March 21, 2010 10:42 AMTo: Subject: Re: health reform vote why couldnt this be about us too? first step, ok fair. levelling reimbursement with subspecialty, ok fair. bring them down some, bring us up some. but when will reform and push for primary care happen? support for prevention happen? when i die? the reason for lack of access is unaffordable insurance. unreasonable qualifiers, the mere fact you have to be well and not taking thyroid pills in order to be insured.hospitals, hospital systems, insurance companies are the problem. if i, as a primary care physician can make THE pockets swell i am sure i will be heard. nothing like feeding a prize fighter. good grief.> > >> > > > > >> > > Sangeetha,> > > I'm with you.> > > We have to start somewhere.> > > Sharon> > >> > >> > >> > > -- > > > PATIENTS,please remember email may not be entirely secure and that Email> > is part of the medical record and is placed into the chart ( be careful what> > you say!)> > > Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions > > > Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter> > is more urgent .> > >> > >> > > MD> > > > > > > > > ph fax > > > impcenter.org> > >> >> > > >> > > > -- > PATIENTS,please remember email may not be entirely secure and that Email is> part of the medical record and is placed into the chart ( be careful what > you say!)> Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions> Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is> more urgent .> > > MD> > > ph fax > impcenter.org> -- M.D.www.elainemd.comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined. This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 22, 2010 Report Posted March 22, 2010 I totally agree that we are stronger when we stand together. The evidence is overwhelming. Independent doctors receive lower payments from insurance companies than networked practices. My approach is to create a clinically integrated network.The way I plan to do this is by inviting others to use www.HowsYourHeatlh.org with their patients with the expectation that a minimum of 50 per quarter take the on line checkup so that we each have enough data, that we each post key metrics on access, relationship, communication etc.G Graham,It's not clear how this could affect direct cash practices. In theory it should not change the modus operandi of direct practices. However, it depends on the structure of the new contracts. The people who sign up for or are put into an HMO type indemnity plan, will not be able to see a non-par physician. To do so, they would pay out of pocket, but would not be reimbursed. If all 32 million are in such HMOs, could be a big problem for physicians who are non-par. People would still be required to pay the premiums. There has been talk in some states to make obtaining a medical license contingent upon participating in medicare. This looks like conscription to me. Now would be the time for all doctors and nurses to come together to help shape the nature of the new health insurance so that both patients and those provide the care have some choices. Nurses do extremely well at organizing and negotiating. Doctors are notorious for inability to organize. If doctors squabble to remain individuals, we will become fractious sheep herded into the big pen. But would it be so bad to become sheep if we don't feel like sheep? We could lose what influence we once had to effect better patient care. Trapped is trapped even if the rat doesn't know it. Bring on cookbook medicine and more ridiculous metrics to quantify how well we turn pages rather than how well we take care of our patients. Please anyone jump in here...Gordon?KathleenOn Mon, Mar 22, 2010 at 6:00 PM, Kathleen Patton <krpattoncomcast (DOT) net> wrote:I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? -- Graham Chiuhttp://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 22, 2010 Report Posted March 22, 2010 An answer might be not to take any insurance. Let the patients deal with the payer, get the middleman out of it. The dentists here do OK this way, and the dentists in Canada, when they saw this coming with national health care, bailed out and left the physicians accepting it. The deal is with the government and the patient, it does not have to be between me and my patient. My 2cents. We'd better get wise to this fast!! J MD Quote
Guest guest Posted March 22, 2010 Report Posted March 22, 2010 Gordon, Not to question your almost always laser like insight and solutions; but something tells me that this still would not allow us under present anti-trust laws to join together (no single tax ID number BS as always) in a meaningful way to then use our collective clout to get consessions from these ologopolies. Thoughts, ideas??? To: Sent: Mon, March 22, 2010 10:35:33 AMSubject: Re: health reform bill passed I totally agree that we are stronger when we stand together. The evidence is overwhelming. Independent doctors receive lower payments from insurance companies than networked practices. My approach is to create a clinically integrated network. The way I plan to do this is by inviting others to use www.HowsYourHeatlh. org with their patients with the expectation that a minimum of 50 per quarter take the on line checkup so that we each have enough data, that we each post key metrics on access, relationship, communication etc. G Graham, It's not clear how this could affect direct cash practices. In theory it should not change the modus operandi of direct practices. However, it depends on the structure of the new contracts. The people who sign up for or are put into an HMO type indemnity plan, will not be able to see a non-par physician. To do so, they would pay out of pocket, but would not be reimbursed. If all 32 million are in such HMOs, could be a big problem for physicians who are non-par. People would still be required to pay the premiums. There has been talk in some states to make obtaining a medical license contingent upon participating in medicare. This looks like conscription to me. Now would be the time for all doctors and nurses to come together to help shape the nature of the new health insurance so that both patients and those provide the care have some choices. Nurses do extremely well at organizing and negotiating. Doctors are notorious for inability to organize. If doctors squabble to remain individuals, we will become fractious sheep herded into the big pen. But would it be so bad to become sheep if we don't feel like sheep? We could lose what influence we once had to effect better patient care. Trapped is trapped even if the rat doesn't know it. Bring on cookbook medicine and more ridiculous metrics to quantify how well we turn pages rather than how well we take care of our patients. Please anyone jump in here...Gordon? Kathleen On Mon, Mar 22, 2010 at 6:00 PM, Kathleen Patton <krpattoncomcast (DOT) net> wrote: I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? -- Graham Chiuhttp://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 22, 2010 Report Posted March 22, 2010 Hey Questions: 1) Did this include the repeal of the Insurance industries anti-trust waiver as Leahy and Schummer were threatening and attempting to do??? 2) From other comments posted here and because I have not heard anything else on the subject, so the concept from the Clinton era reforms of totally free and open access to any doctor of your choice never made it in there either? FYI for everyone: As you may know our NYS AG Cuomo took on and won a large battle with the evil empire of UHC and their claimed to be separate and independent when in actuality they owned and controlled Ingenix. As most of you probably also know Ingenix was the company UHC created to artificially hold down out of network payment and rates, by controlling the supposed data behind Ingenix setting the Usual and Customary rates for UHC, which then sold that data to all their buddies in the other insurance carriers so as to make sure that all carriers held to the same exact rediculous low rates so nobody rocked that boat and raised the rates and ruined the party for them all. This effectively trapped way too many docs with few options but to stay in-network even though they knew better and didn't really want to or left doctors and patients at odds over charges verses insurance payment. Granted I feel that many practices have insanely high fee schedules that have no basis in reality being way over 200% of present day Medicare, effectively only screwing the cash paying patient and doing nothing to help the practice recover an extra dime from any of the carriers, especially since Ingenix was proven to be using data for setting U & C that was at least 10 years old or worse as many docs had been claiming for years.... I am proud to say that the new system put in place by AG Cuomo will be housed and run right here in CNY on the campus of Syracuse University and funded with monies agreed to with all the carriers he went after for using this clearly bogus data. So now the question is, for those of us who do not have insanely out of this world fee schedules and charges who are still trapped in the insurance system, might it be advantagous to review and bump all of our fee schedules as much as most of us are attempting to hold the line on pounding those who pay us cash on the barrel. I have barely bumped any codes in almost 4 or 5 years and now our Level 3 est 99213 is slightly less than $5 difference from what our highest paying local plan will pay verses what we charge. If us nice docs continue to hold the line in the face of an honest system that is supposed to do a formula of averaging out what the average doc charges verses what the average plan pays, then might we be screwing ourselves on this one if we don't as some point, like annually all giving our fee schedules a modest bump to keep the U & C slowly moving upward to keep pace with inflation and our ever increasing costs. It hurts to talk like this because clearly as we slowly start dropping carriers to free ourselves from their strangle hold grip, one will we be shooting ourselves in the foot charging high prices that scare patients off, and two clearly we want to make a good and decent living but don't want to cream people either while doing business with them. I gather now that there will be so many people who have access to some sort of coverage that such concerns for the uninsured will decrease one would hope, and then we can charge what we deem appropriate for our services based on what the market will bare. And if there is still and growing lack of PCP's getting into the game, more and more practices will continue the toxic speed it up assembly line, that hopefully some patients with out of network benefits or just don't care and want to be treated like a person and not someone holding a number on the deli line, we will be able to find enough reasonable patients to fill our smaller panel practices to provide ourselves with a decent living... Still sucks to be the average American in the system but perhaps us IMP's can find a means to survive and hack out a living..... Just some thoughts on all of this.... To: Sent: Mon, March 22, 2010 10:16:56 AMSubject: Re: health reform bill passed Was there a provision for 85% of every health care dollar has to go to actual health care...less to administration/ profit/CEOs On Sun, Mar 21, 2010 at 10:00 PM, Kathleen Patton <krpattoncomcast (DOT) net> wrote: For better or worse. I hope for the better. I'm not happy with many things in this bill, but it's a start. Hey. I'm a glass half full kind of girl. If I have this right, the doughnut hole will go away or become smaller, insurance companies will not be able to excise people from plans when they become ill, people will not become bankrupt by serious illness. These are huge. I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. Now the real work starts, as in, how to make this work. Now can the doctors and nurses please sit at the table to figure that part out? Pharma and Big Insurance had their chance to sit at the table. They got what they wanted, so to speak. With trepidation and hope, Kathleen My feeling is that it will be about us…soon. We know we are heading down an economically unsustainable path. Initially, there was a moral (and economic) reason to cover the uninsured. There is no way health care reform would have gotten even this far with any discussion of changing doctor payment. HOWEVER, now that most people will be covered, the discussion will begin as to how we can pay for the system we have. My guess is that there will be lots of pilot studies and other things trying to determine the most cost effective and highest quality form of medicine. Data from the US and other countries shows this starts with a strong primary care system. The definition of a strong primary care system is still debatable, but it is imperative for us to clean our house and prove our worth or we will be told by others what that means. At IMP we are working to do this. Stayed tuned… From: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com [mailto:@yahoogrou ps.com] On Behalf Of pricklyfinger2007Sent: Sunday, March 21, 2010 10:42 AMTo: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) comSubject: [Practiceimprovemen t1] Re: health reform vote why couldnt this be about us too? first step, ok fair. levelling reimbursement with subspecialty, ok fair. bring them down some, bring us up some. but when will reform and push for primary care happen? support for prevention happen? when i die?the reason for lack of access is unaffordable insurance. unreasonable qualifiers, the mere fact you have to be well and not taking thyroid pills in order to be insured.hospitals, hospital systems, insurance companies are the problem. if i, as a primary care physician can make THE pockets swell i am sure i will be heard. nothing like feeding a prize fighter.good grief.> > >> > >> > >> > > Sangeetha,> > > I'm with you.> > > We have to start somewhere.> > > Sharon> > >> > >> > >> > > --> > > PATIENTS,please remember email may not be entirely secure and that Email> > is part of the medical record and is placed into the chart ( be careful what> > you say!)> > > Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions> > > Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter> > is more urgent .> > >> > >> > > MD> > > 115 Mt Blue Circle> > > > > > ph fax > > > impcenter.org> > >> >> > > >> > > > -- > PATIENTS,please remember email may not be entirely secure and that Email is> part of the medical record and is placed into the chart ( be careful what> you say!)> Email is best used for appointment making and brief questions> Email replies can be expected within 24 hours-Please CALL if the matter is> more urgent .> > > MD> > > ph fax > impcenter.org> -- M.D.www.elainemd. comOffice: Go in the directions of your dreams and live the life you've imagined.This email transmission may contain protected and privileged, highly confidential medical, Personal and Health Information (PHI) and/or legal information. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this material, you may not use, publish, discuss, disseminate or otherwise distribute it. If you are not the intended recipient, or if you have received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and confidentially destroy the information that email in error. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 22, 2010 Report Posted March 22, 2010 IPA. From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Bleiweiss Sent: Monday, March 22, 2010 4:16 PM To: Subject: Re: health reform bill passed Gordon, Not to question your almost always laser like insight and solutions; but something tells me that this still would not allow us under present anti-trust laws to join together (no single tax ID number BS as always) in a meaningful way to then use our collective clout to get consessions from these ologopolies. Thoughts, ideas??? From: L. Gordon To: Sent: Mon, March 22, 2010 10:35:33 AM Subject: Re: health reform bill passed I totally agree that we are stronger when we stand together. The evidence is overwhelming. Independent doctors receive lower payments from insurance companies than networked practices. My approach is to create a clinically integrated network. The way I plan to do this is by inviting others to use www.HowsYourHeatlh. org with their patients with the expectation that a minimum of 50 per quarter take the on line checkup so that we each have enough data, that we each post key metrics on access, relationship, communication etc. G Graham, It's not clear how this could affect direct cash practices. In theory it should not change the modus operandi of direct practices. However, it depends on the structure of the new contracts. The people who sign up for or are put into an HMO type indemnity plan, will not be able to see a non-par physician. To do so, they would pay out of pocket, but would not be reimbursed. If all 32 million are in such HMOs, could be a big problem for physicians who are non-par. People would still be required to pay the premiums. There has been talk in some states to make obtaining a medical license contingent upon participating in medicare. This looks like conscription to me. Now would be the time for all doctors and nurses to come together to help shape the nature of the new health insurance so that both patients and those provide the care have some choices. Nurses do extremely well at organizing and negotiating. Doctors are notorious for inability to organize. If doctors squabble to remain individuals, we will become fractious sheep herded into the big pen. But would it be so bad to become sheep if we don't feel like sheep? We could lose what influence we once had to effect better patient care. Trapped is trapped even if the rat doesn't know it. Bring on cookbook medicine and more ridiculous metrics to quantify how well we turn pages rather than how well we take care of our patients. Please anyone jump in here...Gordon? Kathleen On Mar 22, 2010, at 1:32 AM, Graham Chiu wrote: On Mon, Mar 22, 2010 at 6:00 PM, Kathleen Patton <krpattoncomcast (DOT) net> wrote: I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? -- Graham Chiu http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/ Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 Gordon is correct about the issues that many IMPers are facing nationwide. My decision to begin dropping insurance lies predominantly on the fact that I am in NJ-the KING of the deadzones. Right now the strategy is go cash or go employee. The mandates and taxes on small business are worsening. In June alone a rise in the payroll tax that was voted on last year will kick in. $1000k per employee. I only have myself and one FT-that's $2000k right there. Imagine a group of 2-3 docs that have 4-6 employees! I have more than enough work to justify more employees, or at least another PT, but I can't afford it. I am already splitting overhead costs with another IMPer(nephrology). Despite that, I am spending about $15k per month in overhead and sometimes making the bottom line and sometimes, not so much. In order to make ends meet, I moonlight at a medispa doing the cosmetic stuff. I'm pulling 60-80hr weeks and can't run on the treadmill anymore...been doing it for over 2 yrs now. Having given my soliloquy, please understand that those of us deciding to drop insurance don't do so lightly. I don't wish ill on any of my patients, but if I can't make the bottom line, I can't keep my doors open and we are back at square one. In an ideal world, the compensation would be enough and the micropractice would be fabulous. This is very difficult to accomplish in this state where the average visit brings you $65-85 for a level 4. I am planning to keep my micro dream alive by trying an alternate route as others in neighboring communities have tried. I really would like to hold off having to join the " monstrosity " of the multispecialty/hospital employed model for as long as I can. Toast to better times and thanks for listening. > > > > I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. > > > > So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? > > > -- > Graham Chiu > http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/ > Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 You are NOT an employee, you are an OWNER -- don't tax yourself. Re: health reform bill passed Gordon is correct about the issues that many IMPers are facing nationwide. My decision to begin dropping insurance lies predominantly on the fact that I am in NJ-the KING of the deadzones. Right now the strategy is go cash or go employee. The mandates and taxes on small business are worsening. In June alone a rise in the payroll tax that was voted on last year will kick in. $1000k per employee. I only have myself and one FT-that's $2000k right there. Imagine a group of 2-3 docs that have 4-6 employees! I have more than enough work to justify more employees, or at least another PT, but I can't afford it. I am already splitting overhead costs with another IMPer(nephrology). Despite that, I am spending about $15k per month in overhead and sometimes making the bottom line and sometimes, not so much. In order to make ends meet, I moonlight at a medispa doing the cosmetic stuff. I'm pulling 60-80hr weeks and can't run on the treadmill anymore...been doing it for over 2 yrs now. Having given my soliloquy, please understand that those of us deciding to drop insurance don't do so lightly. I don't wish ill on any of my patients, but if I can't make the bottom line, I can't keep my doors open and we are back at square one. In an ideal world, the compensation would be enough and the micropractice would be fabulous. This is very difficult to accomplish in this state where the average visit brings you $65-85 for a level 4. I am planning to keep my micro dream alive by trying an alternate route as others in neighboring communities have tried. I really would like to hold off having to join the "monstrosity" of the multispecialty/hospital employed model for as long as I can. Toast to better times and thanks for listening.> > > > I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. > > > > So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? > > > -- > Graham Chiu> http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/> Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR.> Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 1) Going cash only works if there is enough demand but not enough service. Is this true? 2) What kind of payor breakdown do you have? I am aware that Medicare is the best payor for you in NJ (I'm in PA), but do you take worst payor like Medicaid? 3) How many pts a week do you see? I was having the same trouble that you had, until another doc left practice (died), then my volumes shot up to $50/and I'm fine. Matt in Western PA (My overhead is similar to yours... I moonlight too, 2 AMs a week for salary) Re: health reform bill passed Gordon is correct about the issues that many IMPers are facing nationwide. My decision to begin dropping insurance lies predominantly on the fact that I am in NJ-the KING of the deadzones. Right now the strategy is go cash or go employee. The mandates and taxes on small business are worsening. In June alone a rise in the payroll tax that was voted on last year will kick in. $1000k per employee. I only have myself and one FT-that's $2000k right there. Imagine a group of 2-3 docs that have 4-6 employees! I have more than enough work to justify more employees, or at least another PT, but I can't afford it. I am already splitting overhead costs with another IMPer(nephrology). Despite that, I am spending about $15k per month in overhead and sometimes making the bottom line and sometimes, not so much. In order to make ends meet, I moonlight at a medispa doing the cosmetic stuff. I'm pulling 60-80hr weeks and can't run on the treadmill anymore...been doing it for over 2 yrs now. Having given my soliloquy, please understand that those of us deciding to drop insurance don't do so lightly. I don't wish ill on any of my patients, but if I can't make the bottom line, I can't keep my doors open and we are back at square one. In an ideal world, the compensation would be enough and the micropractice would be fabulous. This is very difficult to accomplish in this state where the average visit brings you $65-85 for a level 4. I am planning to keep my micro dream alive by trying an alternate route as others in neighboring communities have tried. I really would like to hold off having to join the "monstrosity" of the multispecialty/hospital employed model for as long as I can. Toast to better times and thanks for listening.> > > > I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. > > > > So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? > > > -- > Graham Chiu> http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/> Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR.> Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 Could you list your overhead expenses. $15000/mpnth seems steep unless that includes your salary. To: Sent: Tue, March 23, 2010 12:02:11 AMSubject: Re: health reform bill passed Gordon is correct about the issues that many IMPers are facing nationwide. My decision to begin dropping insurance lies predominantly on the fact that I am in NJ-the KING of the deadzones. Right now the strategy is go cash or go employee. The mandates and taxes on small business are worsening. In June alone a rise in the payroll tax that was voted on last year will kick in. $1000k per employee. I only have myself and one FT-that's $2000k right there. Imagine a group of 2-3 docs that have 4-6 employees! I have more than enough work to justify more employees, or at least another PT, but I can't afford it. I am already splitting overhead costs with another IMPer(nephrology) . Despite that, I am spending about $15k per month in overhead and sometimes making the bottom line and sometimes, not so much. In order to make ends meet, I moonlight at a medispa doing the cosmetic stuff. I'm pulling 60-80hr weeks and can't run on the treadmill anymore...been doing it for over 2 yrs now. Having given my soliloquy, please understand that those of us deciding to drop insurance don't do so lightly. I don't wish ill on any of my patients, but if I can't make the bottom line, I can't keep my doors open and we are back at square one. In an ideal world, the compensation would be enough and the micropractice would be fabulous. This is very difficult to accomplish in this state where the average visit brings you $65-85 for a level 4. I am planning to keep my micro dream alive by trying an alternate route as others in neighboring communities have tried. I really would like to hold off having to join the "monstrosity" of the multispecialty/ hospital employed model for as long as I can. Toast to better times and thanks for listening.> > > > I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. > > > > So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? > > > -- > Graham Chiu> http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/> Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR.> Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 Probably depends on the business format. If you are a LLC you are the owner, if a SubS you are probably an employee. From: [ ] On Behalf Of Dr Levin [dr_levin@...] Sent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 4:34 AM To: Subject: Re: Re: health reform bill passed You are NOT an employee, you are an OWNER -- don't tax yourself. Re: health reform bill passed Gordon is correct about the issues that many IMPers are facing nationwide. My decision to begin dropping insurance lies predominantly on the fact that I am in NJ-the KING of the deadzones. Right now the strategy is go cash or go employee. The mandates and taxes on small business are worsening. In June alone a rise in the payroll tax that was voted on last year will kick in. $1000k per employee. I only have myself and one FT-that's $2000k right there. Imagine a group of 2-3 docs that have 4-6 employees! I have more than enough work to justify more employees, or at least another PT, but I can't afford it. I am already splitting overhead costs with another IMPer(nephrology). Despite that, I am spending about $15k per month in overhead and sometimes making the bottom line and sometimes, not so much. In order to make ends meet, I moonlight at a medispa doing the cosmetic stuff. I'm pulling 60-80hr weeks and can't run on the treadmill anymore...been doing it for over 2 yrs now. Having given my soliloquy, please understand that those of us deciding to drop insurance don't do so lightly. I don't wish ill on any of my patients, but if I can't make the bottom line, I can't keep my doors open and we are back at square one. In an ideal world, the compensation would be enough and the micropractice would be fabulous. This is very difficult to accomplish in this state where the average visit brings you $65-85 for a level 4. I am planning to keep my micro dream alive by trying an alternate route as others in neighboring communities have tried. I really would like to hold off having to join the " monstrosity " of the multispecialty/hospital employed model for as long as I can. Toast to better times and thanks for listening. > > > > I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. > > > > So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? > > > -- > Graham Chiu > http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/ > Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 MATT,Not sure everybody can count on that as part of the business plan 3) How many pts a week do you see? I was having the same trouble that you had, until another doc left practice (died), then my volumes shot up to $50/and I'm fine. Re: health reform bill passed Gordon is correct about the issues that many IMPers are facing nationwide. My decision to begin dropping insurance lies predominantly on the fact that I am in NJ-the KING of the deadzones. Right now the strategy is go cash or go employee. The mandates and taxes on small business are worsening. In June alone a rise in the payroll tax that was voted on last year will kick in. $1000k per employee. I only have myself and one FT-that's $2000k right there. Imagine a group of 2-3 docs that have 4-6 employees! I have more than enough work to justify more employees, or at least another PT, but I can't afford it. I am already splitting overhead costs with another IMPer(nephrology). Despite that, I am spending about $15k per month in overhead and sometimes making the bottom line and sometimes, not so much. In order to make ends meet, I moonlight at a medispa doing the cosmetic stuff. I'm pulling 60-80hr weeks and can't run on the treadmill anymore...been doing it for over 2 yrs now. Having given my soliloquy, please understand that those of us deciding to drop insurance don't do so lightly. I don't wish ill on any of my patients, but if I can't make the bottom line, I can't keep my doors open and we are back at square one. In an ideal world, the compensation would be enough and the micropractice would be fabulous. This is very difficult to accomplish in this state where the average visit brings you $65-85 for a level 4. I am planning to keep my micro dream alive by trying an alternate route as others in neighboring communities have tried. I really would like to hold off having to join the " monstrosity " of the multispecialty/hospital employed model for as long as I can. Toast to better times and thanks for listening.> > > > I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. > > > > So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? > > > -- > Graham Chiu> http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/> Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR.> -- Sangeetha Murthy M.D Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 Wow-so many questions. Let's see: 1)Talking off the top of my head(since I don't have the numbers in front of me)Rent utilities supplies/stamps etc run about $2000-$2500k depending on the utilites/need to buy vaccines that month etc. 2)Payroll is the biggest(and the taxes that come with it). talking a bi weekly payroll of about $2600k with additional taxes of $1700 or so. Right now that includes my salary of $70k(which is the bear minimum in order for me to afford my utilities/ motgage and good 'ol Sallie Mae)and my MA who is working 35-37hrs/wk at $13/hr. I do my own billing, use elctronic records etc. 3) $900/mo to payoff loan for equiptment(have less than 2yrs left) 4) I write off the car through the business-400k/mo(2yrs left) 5) Insurance: this is another biggie. Malpractice $12K/yr, business insurance $1500/yr, health insurance $400/month(no rx plan/high deductible, disabilty $1000/yr 6)You then have to factor in " emergency " or things that are unanticipated. Remember the accountants need to get paid once a year, etc. 7)My lowest payer will pay me about $57 for a 99214, highest is Medicare at $83 and if they have a secondary will get the $20...many have medicaid as the secondary and I don't participate in medicaid. 8) Currently seeing anywhere from 8-14/d-average of about 40-45 visits a week(only working 4 days in the office since I have that moonlighting job). Some weeks are gangbusters, others not so much. Last month there was a substantial drop off in the number of visits(everyone in the community noticed it), this month is better. 9) RAC insurance is for the RAC auditors. Everyone is worried regarding medicare audits-they have already audited 3 FP/IMs in the area, many brokers are now offering this as coverage to fight Medicare/settle in the event of an oversight. The quotes I have recieved so far have been anywhere from $900-1500/yr. Any other questions? > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 > > million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. > > I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. > > > > > > > > > > > > So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? > > > > > > > > > -- > > > Graham Chiu > > > http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/ > > > Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > Sangeetha Murthy M.D > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 This is always the stubbling block. I am not sure that you can do a cross state lines IPA From: [ ] On Behalf Of Batlle [jbatlle@...] Sent: Monday, March 22, 2010 3:11 PM To: Subject: RE: health reform bill passed IPA. From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Bleiweiss Sent: Monday, March 22, 2010 4:16 PM To: Subject: Re: health reform bill passed Gordon, Not to question your almost always laser like insight and solutions; but something tells me that this still would not allow us under present anti-trust laws to join together (no single tax ID number BS as always) in a meaningful way to then use our collective clout to get consessions from these ologopolies. Thoughts, ideas??? From: L. Gordon <gmooreidealhealthnetwork> To: Sent: Mon, March 22, 2010 10:35:33 AM Subject: Re: health reform bill passed I totally agree that we are stronger when we stand together. The evidence is overwhelming. Independent doctors receive lower payments from insurance companies than networked practices. My approach is to create a clinically integrated network. The way I plan to do this is by inviting others to use www.HowsYourHeatlh. org with their patients with the expectation that a minimum of 50 per quarter take the on line checkup so that we each have enough data, that we each post key metrics on access, relationship, communication etc. G Graham, It's not clear how this could affect direct cash practices. In theory it should not change the modus operandi of direct practices. However, it depends on the structure of the new contracts. The people who sign up for or are put into an HMO type indemnity plan, will not be able to see a non-par physician. To do so, they would pay out of pocket, but would not be reimbursed. If all 32 million are in such HMOs, could be a big problem for physicians who are non-par. People would still be required to pay the premiums. There has been talk in some states to make obtaining a medical license contingent upon participating in medicare. This looks like conscription to me. Now would be the time for all doctors and nurses to come together to help shape the nature of the new health insurance so that both patients and those provide the care have some choices. Nurses do extremely well at organizing and negotiating. Doctors are notorious for inability to organize. If doctors squabble to remain individuals, we will become fractious sheep herded into the big pen. But would it be so bad to become sheep if we don't feel like sheep? We could lose what influence we once had to effect better patient care. Trapped is trapped even if the rat doesn't know it. Bring on cookbook medicine and more ridiculous metrics to quantify how well we turn pages rather than how well we take care of our patients. Please anyone jump in here...Gordon? Kathleen On Mon, Mar 22, 2010 at 6:00 PM, Kathleen Patton <krpattoncomcast (DOT) net> wrote: I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? -- Graham Chiu http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/ Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 Traditionally, we don't count our own salary in cost, so you could say your expenses are 9800/month, that does not sound too high. I assume you did not mean that you pay 400,000/month for your car, but 400/mo. You could try to get the bank to extend your loan out a few years and decrease your cash flow output, might gain you 300-400/month. We are doing competitive shopping for supplies and buying drugs, like synvisc and depo from Canada. Can you get the county to provide the immunizations to the kids, or do you get paid enough for them? In our county, they will provide any vaccine to any kid, so we are not doing menactra or gardisel, since they are too expensive and we don't seem to get full reimbursement. Does your malpractice carrier give discounts for " parttime work? " Ours charges less for working less than 25 hours a week IN DIRECT PATIENT CARE. If the place you are moonlighting provides the coverage while you are there, you might be able to fit your patients into those hours. If they don't pay, you should be sure what they pay you includes enought to have the insurance. The big problem is your income, not your expenses. there is no way you can do this if the payers are paying less than MDC. From: [ ] On Behalf Of drsof99 [drsof@...] Sent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 9:18 AM To: Subject: Re: health reform bill passed Wow-so many questions. Let's see: 1)Talking off the top of my head(since I don't have the numbers in front of me)Rent utilities supplies/stamps etc run about $2000-$2500k depending on the utilites/need to buy vaccines that month etc. 2)Payroll is the biggest(and the taxes that come with it). talking a bi weekly payroll of about $2600k with additional taxes of $1700 or so. Right now that includes my salary of $70k(which is the bear minimum in order for me to afford my utilities/ motgage and good 'ol Sallie Mae)and my MA who is working 35-37hrs/wk at $13/hr. I do my own billing, use elctronic records etc. 3) $900/mo to payoff loan for equiptment(have less than 2yrs left) 4) I write off the car through the business-400k/mo(2yrs left) 5) Insurance: this is another biggie. Malpractice $12K/yr, business insurance $1500/yr, health insurance $400/month(no rx plan/high deductible, disabilty $1000/yr 6)You then have to factor in " emergency " or things that are unanticipated. Remember the accountants need to get paid once a year, etc. 7)My lowest payer will pay me about $57 for a 99214, highest is Medicare at $83 and if they have a secondary will get the $20...many have medicaid as the secondary and I don't participate in medicaid. 8) Currently seeing anywhere from 8-14/d-average of about 40-45 visits a week(only working 4 days in the office since I have that moonlighting job). Some weeks are gangbusters, others not so much. Last month there was a substantial drop off in the number of visits(everyone in the community noticed it), this month is better. 9) RAC insurance is for the RAC auditors. Everyone is worried regarding medicare audits-they have already audited 3 FP/IMs in the area, many brokers are now offering this as coverage to fight Medicare/settle in the event of an oversight. The quotes I have recieved so far have been anywhere from $900-1500/yr. Any other questions? > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 > > million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. > > I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. > > > > > > > > > > > > So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? > > > > > > > > > -- > > > Graham Chiu > > > http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/ > > > Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > Sangeetha Murthy M.D > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 We are S-Corp. Must be considered an employee. Can pay minimal salary (we pay Steve $60,000/ year on the advice of our accountant). Remaining profit can be paid to the “shareholder” (Steve is the sole shareholder) as dividends (avoiding payroll tax liability that way). Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd.info From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Kennedy, Jim Sent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 7:34 AM To: Subject: RE: Re: health reform bill passed Probably depends on the business format. If you are a LLC you are the owner, if a SubS you are probably an employee. From: [ ] On Behalf Of Dr Levin [dr_levincomcast (DOT) net] Sent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 4:34 AM To: Subject: Re: Re: health reform bill passed You are NOT an employee, you are an OWNER -- don't tax yourself. Re: health reform bill passed Gordon is correct about the issues that many IMPers are facing nationwide. My decision to begin dropping insurance lies predominantly on the fact that I am in NJ-the KING of the deadzones. Right now the strategy is go cash or go employee. The mandates and taxes on small business are worsening. In June alone a rise in the payroll tax that was voted on last year will kick in. $1000k per employee. I only have myself and one FT-that's $2000k right there. Imagine a group of 2-3 docs that have 4-6 employees! I have more than enough work to justify more employees, or at least another PT, but I can't afford it. I am already splitting overhead costs with another IMPer(nephrology). Despite that, I am spending about $15k per month in overhead and sometimes making the bottom line and sometimes, not so much. In order to make ends meet, I moonlight at a medispa doing the cosmetic stuff. I'm pulling 60-80hr weeks and can't run on the treadmill anymore...been doing it for over 2 yrs now. Having given my soliloquy, please understand that those of us deciding to drop insurance don't do so lightly. I don't wish ill on any of my patients, but if I can't make the bottom line, I can't keep my doors open and we are back at square one. In an ideal world, the compensation would be enough and the micropractice would be fabulous. This is very difficult to accomplish in this state where the average visit brings you $65-85 for a level 4. I am planning to keep my micro dream alive by trying an alternate route as others in neighboring communities have tried. I really would like to hold off having to join the " monstrosity " of the multispecialty/hospital employed model for as long as I can. Toast to better times and thanks for listening. > > > > I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. > > > > So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? > > > -- > Graham Chiu > http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/ > Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 , We are Sub-S as well and I draw the entire salary while and the President draws nothing saving us Compensation and extra payroll hastles as well. I thought Sub's like us were taxed that the owner's rate on their personal income taxes no matter what. What you seem to be saying is, that you guys pay yourselves a semi-reasonable salary and then directly take the rest paid directly to as the one and only shareholder just as is ours. So the company pays him dividends which I guess would get taxed at the lower capital gains rate of about 15% or regular corp taxes rate with none of the extra payroll ones? Please detail because I'm all ears... As an aside, I have been thinking for quite some time now that we need to get back on the payroll to some extent because she is not properly vested in SS, SSDI, and Medicare I believe because she has been considered not employed or contributing for quite some time now. At some point in the future should the need arise that she was to get very sick it would be nice to have such basic support available for her and possibly the kids too as the children of someone on disability. Hopefully will never need such but you never know and I have seen such happen way too many times before to others. Anyway, I would love to keep us both some what employed for just such reasons but at the same time, it seems that you have found a means of using the Sub-S a much better personal advantage in terms of exposure to tax liabilities. So please speak up and share..... Thanks much. To: Sent: Tue, March 23, 2010 12:37:00 PMSubject: RE: Re: health reform bill passed We are S-Corp. Must be considered an employee. Can pay minimal salary (we pay Steve $60,000/ year on the advice of our accountant). Remaining profit can be paid to the “shareholder†(Steve is the sole shareholder) as dividends (avoiding payroll tax liability that way). Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd. info From: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com [mailto: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com ] On Behalf Of Kennedy, JimSent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 7:34 AMTo: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) comSubject: RE: [Practiceimprovemen t1] Re: health reform bill passed Probably depends on the business format. If you are a LLC you are the owner, if a SubS you are probably an employee. From: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com [ Practiceimprovemen t1yahoogroups (DOT) com ] On Behalf Of Dr Levin [dr_levincomcast (DOT) net]Sent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 4:34 AMTo: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) comSubject: Re: [Practiceimprovemen t1] Re: health reform bill passed You are NOT an employee, you are an OWNER -- don't tax yourself. [Practiceimprovemen t1] Re: health reform bill passed Gordon is correct about the issues that many IMPers are facing nationwide. My decision to begin dropping insurance lies predominantly on the fact that I am in NJ-the KING of the deadzones. Right now the strategy is go cash or go employee. The mandates and taxes on small business are worsening. In June alone a rise in the payroll tax that was voted on last year will kick in. $1000k per employee. I only have myself and one FT-that's $2000k right there. Imagine a group of 2-3 docs that have 4-6 employees! I have more than enough work to justify more employees, or at least another PT, but I can't afford it. I am already splitting overhead costs with another IMPer(nephrology) . Despite that, I am spending about $15k per month in overhead and sometimes making the bottom line and sometimes, not so much. In order to make ends meet, I moonlight at a medispa doing the cosmetic stuff. I'm pulling 60-80hr weeks and can't run on the treadmill anymore...been doing it for over 2 yrs now. Having given my soliloquy, please understand that those of us deciding to drop insurance don't do so lightly. I don't wish ill on any of my patients, but if I can't make the bottom line, I can't keep my doors open and we are back at square one. In an ideal world, the compensation would be enough and the micropractice would be fabulous. This is very difficult to accomplish in this state where the average visit brings you $65-85 for a level 4. I am planning to keep my micro dream alive by trying an alternate route as others in neighboring communities have tried. I really would like to hold off having to join the "monstrosity" of the multispecialty/ hospital employed model for as long as I can. Toast to better times and thanks for listening.> > > > I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. > > > > So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? > > > -- > Graham Chiu> http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/> Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR.> Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 But wait a minutes. What is the actual Medicare allowable there in your part of the Garden State??? I ask because it seems that although you are saying that Medicare pays you $83 dollars which seems to be the Medicare payment of their 80% share of the allowable, but that is not the full allowable because you can collect the other 20%, $20+ from either the patient or their secondary. If you do not PAR with Medicaid and the patient knows that, then they are responsible for the last 20% balance of the Medicare Allowable. So in reality the allowable and what you are entitled to collect is really $103 and change which is about $17 higher than up here in CNY. Now according to where you are in NJ, your cost of doing business may be much higher, but all in all, $103 Medicare for a 99214 is not that bad as compared to many other parts of the country. You problem is really the fact that none of of your commercials are paying much more than Medicare. But even up here, our better commercial payers are only paying between $100 and $110 total allowable. And again on the low side of your statement is that again with or without patient responsibility included on the $57 dollars because when one adds in $15-$30 worth of copays, then that is almost but not quite a reasonable payment although I too would say it is still too low, especially if you are in the higher priced end of the state where things are expensive because of your proximity to NYC and other higher priced parts of your own state. We were from downstate NY and so we know a bit about NJ as NY'ers and my brother in law has lived there on and off for many years too. Now please speak up about this RAC audit insurance... I have never heard of such a thing before and it sure sounds like something that in itself could be abused by these head hunters and the gov't. Now they will check the insurance rolls to see who does or does not have RAC insurance in the cheaper practices that normally wouldn't be worth their time and money going after, but now that there is a deep pocketed insurance company to stand behind, watch out because here they come!!! Catch my drift here. Many times when someone has no insurance then there is no case in all sorts of different torts... The defendant has not enough money or assets to make it worth the lawyers time... But add insurance with a million dollar's worth of coverage and watch out because now it is certainly worth their time and effort and now instead of not being bothered you have lived thru the stress and the entire experience and no to make them go away you have a possible blemish on your record even though normally you would have been the small fry that was ignored. And yet at the same time, I know that this audits have us all scared half to death because they are so expensive and time consuming and emotionally draining to defend against... No less now we basically have freelance bounty hunters out there going after anyone they think they can get their hands on... Very upsetting and concerning... Not sure which way to go on this one... can you tell us more about this new insurance please... Thanks much... To: " " < >Sent: Tue, March 23, 2010 12:08:01 PMSubject: RE: Re: health reform bill passed Traditionally, we don't count our own salary in cost, so you could say your expenses are 9800/month, that does not sound too high. I assume you did not mean that you pay 400,000/month for your car, but 400/mo. You could try to get the bank to extend your loan out a few years and decrease your cash flow output, might gain you 300-400/month. We are doing competitive shopping for supplies and buying drugs, like synvisc and depo from Canada. Can you get the county to provide the immunizations to the kids, or do you get paid enough for them? In our county, they will provide any vaccine to any kid, so we are not doing menactra or gardisel, since they are too expensive and we don't seem to get full reimbursement. Does your malpractice carrier give discounts for "parttime work?" Ours charges less for working less than 25 hours a week IN DIRECT PATIENT CARE. If the place you are moonlighting provides the coverage while you are there, you might be able to fit your patients into those hours. If they don't pay, you should be sure what they pay you includes enought to have the insurance. The big problem is your income, not your expenses. there is no way you can do this if the payers are paying less than MDC. From: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com [Practiceimprovemen t1yahoogroups (DOT) com] On Behalf Of drsof99 [drsofhotmail (DOT) com]Sent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 9:18 AMTo: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) comSubject: [Practiceimprovemen t1] Re: health reform bill passed Wow-so many questions. Let's see:1)Talking off the top of my head(since I don't have the numbers in front of me)Rent utilities supplies/stamps etc run about $2000-$2500k depending on the utilites/need to buy vaccines that month etc.2)Payroll is the biggest(and the taxes that come with it). talking a bi weekly payroll of about $2600k with additional taxes of $1700 or so. Right now that includes my salary of $70k(which is the bear minimum in order for me to afford my utilities/ motgage and good 'ol Sallie Mae)and my MA who is working 35-37hrs/wk at $13/hr. I do my own billing, use elctronic records etc.3) $900/mo to payoff loan for equiptment(have less than 2yrs left)4) I write off the car through the business-400k/ mo(2yrs left)5) Insurance: this is another biggie. Malpractice $12K/yr, business insurance $1500/yr, health insurance $400/month(no rx plan/high deductible, disabilty $1000/yr6)You then have to factor in "emergency" or things that are unanticipated. Remember the accountants need to get paid once a year, etc. 7)My lowest payer will pay me about $57 for a 99214, highest is Medicare at $83 and if they have a secondary will get the $20...many have medicaid as the secondary and I don't participate in medicaid.8) Currently seeing anywhere from 8-14/d-average of about 40-45 visits a week(only working 4 days in the office since I have that moonlighting job). Some weeks are gangbusters, others not so much. Last month there was a substantial drop off in the number of visits(everyone in the community noticed it), this month is better.9) RAC insurance is for the RAC auditors. Everyone is worried regarding medicare audits-they have already audited 3 FP/IMs in the area, many brokers are now offering this as coverage to fight Medicare/settle in the event of an oversight. The quotes I have recieved so far have been anywhere from $900-1500/yr.Any other questions?> > >> > >> > >> > > I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32> > million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included.> > I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus.> > >> > >> > >> > > So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance?> > >> > >> > > --> > > Graham Chiu> > > http://www.compkaro ri.co.nz: 8090/> > > Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR.> > >> >> > > >> > > > -- > Sangeetha Murthy M.D> Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 SO you pay yourself $70,000 and your MA $24,000. Hopefully you are related, but if not dose your MA really do 1/3 of your work? With eMDs it does most of the work for you especially billing collections and electronic payment. Investment in right tenchnology may improve your practice. Perhaps cutting your MA to 20 hours. Plan/Do/Study/Act Need more information to help. Your medicare reimbursement seems adequate. To: Sent: Tue, March 23, 2010 10:18:28 AMSubject: Re: health reform bill passed Wow-so many questions. Let's see:1)Talking off the top of my head(since I don't have the numbers in front of me)Rent utilities supplies/stamps etc run about $2000-$2500k depending on the utilites/need to buy vaccines that month etc.2)Payroll is the biggest(and the taxes that come with it). talking a bi weekly payroll of about $2600k with additional taxes of $1700 or so. Right now that includes my salary of $70k(which is the bear minimum in order for me to afford my utilities/ motgage and good 'ol Sallie Mae)and my MA who is working 35-37hrs/wk at $13/hr. I do my own billing, use elctronic records etc.3) $900/mo to payoff loan for equiptment(have less than 2yrs left)4) I write off the car through the business-400k/ mo(2yrs left)5) Insurance: this is another biggie. Malpractice $12K/yr, business insurance $1500/yr, health insurance $400/month(no rx plan/high deductible, disabilty $1000/yr6)You then have to factor in "emergency" or things that are unanticipated. Remember the accountants need to get paid once a year, etc. 7)My lowest payer will pay me about $57 for a 99214, highest is Medicare at $83 and if they have a secondary will get the $20...many have medicaid as the secondary and I don't participate in medicaid.8) Currently seeing anywhere from 8-14/d-average of about 40-45 visits a week(only working 4 days in the office since I have that moonlighting job). Some weeks are gangbusters, others not so much. Last month there was a substantial drop off in the number of visits(everyone in the community noticed it), this month is better.9) RAC insurance is for the RAC auditors. Everyone is worried regarding medicare audits-they have already audited 3 FP/IMs in the area, many brokers are now offering this as coverage to fight Medicare/settle in the event of an oversight. The quotes I have recieved so far have been anywhere from $900-1500/yr.Any other questions?> > >> > >> > >> > > I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32> > million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included.> > I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus.> > >> > >> > >> > > So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance?> > >> > >> > > --> > > Graham Chiu> > > http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/> > > Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR.> > >> >> > > >> > > > -- > Sangeetha Murthy M.D> Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 You are paying yourself handsomely. Do you expect to do as well if you drop insurance? What do you think you will charge? Drop your lowest payer. That is obscene. RAC insurance is a rip-off. Otherwise no one would sell it. I did not think that NJ was one of the states doing RAC auditing in the private office yet. Could be wrong but by wasting money on insurance you are saying that you can’t justify your charges. I doubt that is true. Sofia, how will your overhead decrease without insurance? You haven’t mentioned any “billing costs” in your overhead. PS: 400k/mo on car, must be one hell of a car. J Kathy Saradarian, MD Branchville, NJ www.qualityfamilypractice.com Solo 4/03, Practicing since 9/90 Practice Partner 5/03 Low staffing From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of drsof99 Sent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 11:18 AM To: Subject: Re: health reform bill passed Wow-so many questions. Let's see: 1)Talking off the top of my head(since I don't have the numbers in front of me)Rent utilities supplies/stamps etc run about $2000-$2500k depending on the utilites/need to buy vaccines that month etc. 2)Payroll is the biggest(and the taxes that come with it). talking a bi weekly payroll of about $2600k with additional taxes of $1700 or so. Right now that includes my salary of $70k(which is the bear minimum in order for me to afford my utilities/ motgage and good 'ol Sallie Mae)and my MA who is working 35-37hrs/wk at $13/hr. I do my own billing, use elctronic records etc. 3) $900/mo to payoff loan for equiptment(have less than 2yrs left) 4) I write off the car through the business-400k/mo(2yrs left) 5) Insurance: this is another biggie. Malpractice $12K/yr, business insurance $1500/yr, health insurance $400/month(no rx plan/high deductible, disabilty $1000/yr 6)You then have to factor in " emergency " or things that are unanticipated. Remember the accountants need to get paid once a year, etc. 7)My lowest payer will pay me about $57 for a 99214, highest is Medicare at $83 and if they have a secondary will get the $20...many have medicaid as the secondary and I don't participate in medicaid. 8) Currently seeing anywhere from 8-14/d-average of about 40-45 visits a week(only working 4 days in the office since I have that moonlighting job). Some weeks are gangbusters, others not so much. Last month there was a substantial drop off in the number of visits(everyone in the community noticed it), this month is better. 9) RAC insurance is for the RAC auditors. Everyone is worried regarding medicare audits-they have already audited 3 FP/IMs in the area, many brokers are now offering this as coverage to fight Medicare/settle in the event of an oversight. The quotes I have recieved so far have been anywhere from $900-1500/yr. Any other questions? > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 > > million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. > > I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. > > > > > > > > > > > > So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? > > > > > > > > > -- > > > Graham Chiu > > > http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/ > > > Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > Sangeetha Murthy M.D > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 23, 2010 Report Posted March 23, 2010 , I don’t totally understand all of the tax implications. My dad is our CPA and last year I paid Steve “bonuses” that then had taxes (payroll included) withheld. Dad wasn’t happy about that….said we would’ve been better off tax-wise to pay him dividends (paying estimated quarterly taxes on that amount and NO payroll taxes). All of the profit from the business is taxed on our personal income tax….thus putting us subject to AMT for the first time this year because we also had a large loan write-off in 2009, making us look much better on paper than we are in real life. I draw no salary because we don’t want to pay unemployment insurance (required for me to pay in CA even though I am the spouse of the sole shareholder and things would have to go drastically bad with our marriage for me to claim unemployment against ourselves!) or payroll taxes for me. Even though I’m the office manager and Corporate Secretary, I’m currently drawing no salary. It makes it easier to justify the days that I don’t go in to the office to do yard work when I don’t get paid J If you are paying self-employment tax for , I believe that is supposed to be accruing to SS, SSDI, and MDC? Of course we aren’t counting on getting any of that by the time we retire, if we ever can. Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd.info From: [mailto: ] On Behalf Of Bleiweiss Sent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 10:35 AM To: Subject: Re: Re: health reform bill passed , We are Sub-S as well and I draw the entire salary while and the President draws nothing saving us Compensation and extra payroll hastles as well. I thought Sub's like us were taxed that the owner's rate on their personal income taxes no matter what. What you seem to be saying is, that you guys pay yourselves a semi-reasonable salary and then directly take the rest paid directly to as the one and only shareholder just as is ours. So the company pays him dividends which I guess would get taxed at the lower capital gains rate of about 15% or regular corp taxes rate with none of the extra payroll ones? Please detail because I'm all ears... As an aside, I have been thinking for quite some time now that we need to get back on the payroll to some extent because she is not properly vested in SS, SSDI, and Medicare I believe because she has been considered not employed or contributing for quite some time now. At some point in the future should the need arise that she was to get very sick it would be nice to have such basic support available for her and possibly the kids too as the children of someone on disability. Hopefully will never need such but you never know and I have seen such happen way too many times before to others. Anyway, I would love to keep us both some what employed for just such reasons but at the same time, it seems that you have found a means of using the Sub-S a much better personal advantage in terms of exposure to tax liabilities. So please speak up and share..... Thanks much. From: Pratt <karen.oaktreecomcast (DOT) net> To: Sent: Tue, March 23, 2010 12:37:00 PM Subject: RE: Re: health reform bill passed We are S-Corp. Must be considered an employee. Can pay minimal salary (we pay Steve $60,000/ year on the advice of our accountant). Remaining profit can be paid to the “shareholder” (Steve is the sole shareholder) as dividends (avoiding payroll tax liability that way). Pratt Office Manager Oak Tree Internal Medicine P.C www.prattmd. info From: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com [mailto: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com ] On Behalf Of Kennedy, Jim Sent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 7:34 AM To: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com Subject: RE: [Practiceimprovemen t1] Re: health reform bill passed Probably depends on the business format. If you are a LLC you are the owner, if a SubS you are probably an employee. From: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com [ Practiceimprovemen t1yahoogroups (DOT) com ] On Behalf Of Dr Levin [dr_levincomcast (DOT) net] Sent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 4:34 AM To: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com Subject: Re: [Practiceimprovemen t1] Re: health reform bill passed You are NOT an employee, you are an OWNER -- don't tax yourself. ----- Original Message ----- From: drsof99 To: Practiceimprovement 1yahoogroups (DOT) com Sent: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 1:02 AM Subject: [Practiceimprovemen t1] Re: health reform bill passed Gordon is correct about the issues that many IMPers are facing nationwide. My decision to begin dropping insurance lies predominantly on the fact that I am in NJ-the KING of the deadzones. Right now the strategy is go cash or go employee. The mandates and taxes on small business are worsening. In June alone a rise in the payroll tax that was voted on last year will kick in. $1000k per employee. I only have myself and one FT-that's $2000k right there. Imagine a group of 2-3 docs that have 4-6 employees! I have more than enough work to justify more employees, or at least another PT, but I can't afford it. I am already splitting overhead costs with another IMPer(nephrology) . Despite that, I am spending about $15k per month in overhead and sometimes making the bottom line and sometimes, not so much. In order to make ends meet, I moonlight at a medispa doing the cosmetic stuff. I'm pulling 60-80hr weeks and can't run on the treadmill anymore...been doing it for over 2 yrs now. Having given my soliloquy, please understand that those of us deciding to drop insurance don't do so lightly. I don't wish ill on any of my patients, but if I can't make the bottom line, I can't keep my doors open and we are back at square one. In an ideal world, the compensation would be enough and the micropractice would be fabulous. This is very difficult to accomplish in this state where the average visit brings you $65-85 for a level 4. I am planning to keep my micro dream alive by trying an alternate route as others in neighboring communities have tried. I really would like to hold off having to join the " monstrosity " of the multispecialty/ hospital employed model for as long as I can. Toast to better times and thanks for listening. > > > > I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. > > > > So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? > > > -- > Graham Chiu > http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/ > Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. > Quote
Guest guest Posted March 24, 2010 Report Posted March 24, 2010 Your numbers are actually not that bad. I'm assuming your medicare falls under region " other new jersey " and for this they pay $106 for 214. You should be getting that extra 20% all the time, not just in those with secondaries, except for the care/caid patients; and you should probably strictly limit the number of care/caid patients in your practice. Your main problem is that in a dead zone such as our lovely Garden State you can't operate as a pure IMP. Your volume of visits is just too low to support the overhead in this state. If you're taking home 70k based on your low volume, this is good. While you probably don't want to stick it to your ma; your next ma needs to work for $10/hour. In this economy there are plenty of quality people who will work for that. Getting back to your main issue, you need to up your volume to @275/month. THis is still a light schedule of under 14 per day...meaning 1/2 hour visits, which is pretty easy. (actually, 14/day x 22 days/mo=308 visits) This is what we call (or at least i now officially do) a " JIMP " , or JOISEY IMP...a la exit 4. Finally, don't go and work for the man....I speak of what i know. You'll be judged solely by your " rvu's " and be expected by a mid level manager (or mba if your really lucky) to see patients every 15 minutes (28 per day) or less and they'll dispose of you as soon as a they can hire someone else cheaper. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I'm not happy that for profit insurance companies will be handed 32 > > > million new customers. I'm not happy that a public option isn't included. > > > I'm not happy that poor women may have been thrown under the bus. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > So how does this affect the model where you don't take insurance? > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > > Graham Chiu > > > > http://www.compkarori.co.nz:8090/ > > > > Synapse - the use from anywhere EMR. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > Sangeetha Murthy M.D > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.